Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 29 Tape 59 Side 1 Bodhicitta

39 min · 4,230 words · 29 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 29 Tape 59 Side 1 Bodhicitta
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches on the non-virtuous actions of speech and mind, including idle speech, covetousness, ill will and wrong views, and the rebirths and environmental results each is said to bring. It then answers questions on responding to harm by understanding karma and on how to create positive imprints in the mind. The session closes with the dedication of merit.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-29

Duration: 40 min

UUID: cb5e2289-55bc-48c4-9b96-f507935d8547

Words: 4,230

So much more noisy than in the past. In the past, if you wanted to go off into retreat and find a quiet place to retreat, They were everywhere, these quiet places. Now it is unbelievably difficult to find really quiet if one wants to do very serious, intense, long retreats where it really is important to have silence, such as doing a Samādhi retreat or developing concentration where you have to have a place which is silent, it’s very difficult to find such places. And of course now, developing samadhi, it mentions that it’s good to not just Samādhi but any retreat, it’s always good to do retreats in places where holy beings have meditated because there’s some blessing, some energy there. But then you go to these places and there are riots!

There’s a riot taking place all day long. If you go to Bodh Gaya, or if you go in the boiling weather, it’s quiet. When it’s fifty degrees Celsius, it’s very quiet. Hardly anyone is breathing during that time. But you go like now, many people are planning to go later this year, early next year, it will be just it’s a wonderful place, I’m not saying not to go but it’s just a circus, it’s just unbelievable.

And all the holy places, because they attract many people, but they don’t attract them to do serious practice, everyone goes there just to visit and carry on and so on. It’s unbelievable, noisy. So most of the holy places where it would be really good to meditate, it’s difficult because they’re tourist places. And then in our own countries, it’s so difficult to find places that are really quiet where we can meditate. I mean, there may be places like in the middle of Australia, but then it’s difficult to meditate there because one doesn’t have support and things.

But a place where everything is there, it’s hard to find, hard to find. Because there’s always noise going on, our worldly mind expressing itself, aeroplanes going overhead, everything. So we’ve created that environment, this noisy environment. Music is blasting everywhere. In cities, if you live in an apartment building, you move into one place because it’s nice and quiet and then three months later new neighbours come and the rock and roll music blasts all night or the television is blasting all night or there’s opera or something going on, very difficult not to disturb the mind.

So also another result, similar to the cause, is being harshly treated by others. We harshly treat others with speech, it comes back to us. And then we have the habit of speaking roughly, coarsely, in an unpleasant way. And one is born in environments which are very dusty, thorny, deserts, with sharp rocks, broken glass, dry, with little water, where there are snakes, scorpions and large salt wastes. Which is, I always make my hilarious joke, this is a description of Australia.

But the Australian accent is very beautiful, very pleasing to the ear. Then there is gossip, idle gossip, idle speech, or meaningless speech. Someone defined it as discussing the joys of saṃsāra. So, this idle speech or gossip includes this could even include talking about the dharma to wrong people, people who are not interested, who have no wish to listen, are not interested, do not have a positive attitude to the dharma but then you just talk about it, blah blah blah blah blah, with not a particularly virtuous motivation, you try to impress people with this knowledge of stuff, this becomes negative speech. The basis of idle speech, Lama Tsongkhapa says, is speech about a topic that is not meaningful, such as talking about fighting, fault finding, disputes.

Speaking like a drunkard or a lunatic, and the speech of someone who has a wrong livelihood. The speech of someone who has a wrong livelihood. Idle speech is disjointed, irreligious and senseless, jumbled reveals the afflictions. And I won’t quote some of the rest, but you can read it. So, has to be done with one of the non virtuous minds of ignorance, anger or attachment.

Also, we check up when we engage in this kind of speech, talking about anything that comes into our head, all kinds of worldly things, more and more, with no real purpose, then sooner or later it comes around to criticising other people to some extent. idle gossip is talking about other people usually. First we start off with politicians, famous people, people in the news, then we get to people we know, and then we get to criticising them, and this and that. And then in the process of doing that, we kind of try to promote ourselves in the process. So, the result similar to the cause when we are in a human realm is that our speech has no virtue or discipline.

Are unable to keep the confidences of others, people don’t take us seriously, And we have the habit to talk a lot, just uncontrollably talking, and also have the habit of interrupting others. We don’t listen, people are saying something and we have to interrupt all the time. The environmental result is being born in a place with reversed seasons, a place where the wells go dry, where fruit trees don’t yield, and the forests and lakes become spoiled, polluted and so on, which is what is happening to many parts of this earth, in fact practically every place. Then there are the three negative actions of mind. So the first of these is covetousness.

Covetousness is a very particular state of mind, it is a type of desire attachment, but it’s a very strong form of that. Lama Tsongkhapa says it has to have five qualities or aspects: of having a mind that is exceedingly attached to our own things, our own resources having a mind of attachment that wants to accumulate more things, having a mind of longing or craving for things, having experienced the good things of others, their wealth and so on. Having an envious mind, thinking that whatever belongs to another person should be mine. So we really envy the things of others. And having a mind that is overcome due to covetousness by shamelessness, In other words, it’s a mind that doesn’t see any fault in following those thoughts of craving and grasping at the possessions of others.

So this becomes a cause to be born in the lower realms, especially in the preta realms. When we take rebirth as a human being again, the result similar to the cause is to be one has a very discontented mind. We find it very difficult to be content with anything that we have. Whatever we have is never quite right someone else has got something better what we have is not good enough. We’re unable to complete the projects that we engage in, and what we do engage in often fails, the ventures that we engage in often fail.

And we have the habit of craving for meaningless things. We get caught up in craving for things more and more till the point where we simply crave for anything, it doesn’t matter what it is, we have that habit. So anything can become desirable to us and we want it. So you get people accumulating all sorts of ridiculous things. And then you have people who like every culture this happens of people who accumulate stuff and can’t let go of it, live in places just piled with stuff.

Complete, filthy garbage that they can’t let go of it. And the environmental result is we’re born in a place where our property quickly deteriorates and we’re born in isolated places. This could also mean that even if we’re not born in an actual isolated place, we may be born in a city that we feel very isolated from others. Then there is ill will or malice, which is an extremely strong form of anger, which tends to become the cause to be reborn in the hell realms. So this is an attitude of it has five characteristics.

It’s an attitude of hostility driven by a mind that is perceiving the causes of harm and everything connected with those causes of harm as being truly existing, it becomes incredibly solid in the mind that this is really bad, is really the cause of my suffering, it’s really like that, they’re really evil and so on. So that’s one factor. It has the quality there’s no patience in that mind, a total inability to bear that suffering for a moment. It has a quality of great resentfulness, resenting the object of anger. And our mind dwells on that thing or person again and again, repeatedly, with anger.

It has a quality of envy which thinks it would be good if the person, the enemy, was harmed in some way, was suffering. And again it has this quality of shamelessness that it doesn’t see that there’s anything wrong in indulging in this mind whatsoever. So this is one of the most extreme negative states that we can get into, this one. When our anger has become extremely strong, hatred has become extremely strong, and we dwell on it again and again without any thought to modify it, without any thought that there’s anything wrong with having that attitude. So this becomes the cause of the lowest realms.

When that karma runs out and due to some good karma ripening at some future time, when we are a human being again, then the result similar to the cause of malice is that we often experience feelings of guilt, have lots of guilty feelings, we have a very incredibly suspicious mind, or always suspicious of many things, and also experience various degrees of paranoia. Paranoia? Yeah. So maybe all of us experience a little paranoia at some times. You know, you walk down the street and you look at someone and you think someone’s looking at you in an unpleasant way, and you know, why are they looking like that?

They don’t even know me!’ So we get paranoid about that. It’s very minor, but if we’ve indulged in this malice, ill will very strongly, that paranoia can become completely full blown. It can end up including everyone we see, which generates this mind that feels everyone is firstly we think a group of people are plotting against us, and then there are signs. Our paranoid mind sees that there are certain signs that these people are plotting. Then we start to see that more and more people have these signs until practically everyone is part of the plot.

I once met someone like that, When I first met her, the people plotting against her was just a very specific group of people, but it got more and more. There just had to be one little sign, and then she knew that they were part of the plot. Eventually it got to practically everyone. Another result similar to the cause of this state of mind is that one experiences often being not believed, one says things but one is not believed, so one generates incredible hatred because one isn’t believed. So incredible frustration and hatred because people just don’t believe me.

The habit that comes from malice and ill will is enjoying harming and causing discomfort and mischief to others. The environmental result is to be born in a place where there is war, disasters, epidemics, places infested with poisonous insects and snakes, dangerous animals, ghosts and bad tasting food. Then finally, the last of the three negativities of mind is having wrong views. So, then, this is a particular like all of us at some point have wrong views, but this particular negative karma of mind is a very strong form of wrong views which someone once translated, which I think is a very helpful translation, antagonistic thinking. So, to have this completely so means not simply disbelieving in something which is true, but having this mind that consciously and actively denies that.

It doesn’t want to even consider the possibility that something is true one has invested you know, a lot in denying that and is happy to deny that, and puts a lot of energy into doing that. So it’s a very distorted, stubborn denial of things. And it has to have these five qualities or five characteristics or attitudes: an attitude of confusion due to not knowing objects of knowledge exactly It is a violent attitude that delights in negativity. It’s an attitude that continuously operates in the wrong way because of thinking about wrong views. It’s an attitude that is a mistaken denial that such things as virtuous behaviour do exist.

And again, it has this quality of having no sense, well, it’s not a quality, an attitude of shamelessness, that doesn’t consider that this state of mind is harmful in any way whatsoever. So, in particular, of course, from a Buddhist point of view, one of the wrong views is denying the law of cause and effect. So if you totally deny it with all these qualities, this becomes this wrong view. You have no openness at all to considering the fact that one’s actions have effects and that these effects can go on for a long time. So then, when one is reborn as a human in the future, the result similar to the cause is that one has a great deal of ignorance, one is very dissatisfied, angry, one doesn’t meet the dharma.

If one does, one finds it very difficult to believe it, and even if one believes it, then one finds it difficult to understand it. Also another result similar to the cause of this is that even for those who believe in the Dharma and understand it, the mind becomes very dull when trying to practice Dharma but very clear when doing worldly things. So many of us can identify that moment. And it’s very interesting, not only do we tend to get sleepy in teachings or when we meditate, but particularly in teachings, especially when there’s something that is particularly beneficial for our state of mind, we fall asleep then, our mind goes completely dull at that point. The habit, which is the other aspect of the result similar to the cause, is always criticizing others, finding faults with everything and misunderstanding the Dharma.

Always misinterpreting it, putting this negative view on it. Then one is born in an environment with poor crops where there’s no opportunity to meet or practice the Dharma of any kind, the natural resources become exhausted, springs go dry, the environment becomes polluted, law and order collapses, there is no protection and nothing is held sacred. This is what is happening in our world now. All of these things are happening more and more. The environment is becoming polluted, nothing is held sacred, less and less protection and so on, because wrong views of many kinds are dominant in our minds, in the minds of sentient beings now.

So our environment is reflecting that. I don’t know if there’s time but no, I think I have to leave it. Sorry if there’s some questions. Yes? Right.

Right. No, I don’t think so. Intoxicants can lead to some of these things, but intoxicants itself is not as heavy as these things as such. Just the mere taking of intoxicants, but then the mind becoming intoxicated can lead to creating some of these negative karmas. So in a sense it is included in a way.

Both. The first part, chewing up the good karma, yes, if one is listening with the right attitude and using it to motivate for more karma, the second one applies. But every time we experience some good thing, we’re using up the karma that enables us to experience that good thing. This is why it’s explained that in trying to develop single pointed concentration, one needs a great deal of merit to be able to achieve that state of mind because every time we meditate we use up our good karma. So, if we don’t meditate properly, we just use up the good karma and we don’t create more good karma, we may just create some confusion.

So when one is doing a Samādhi retreat, one is doing a lot of meditation and a lot of intensive meditation, so this is burning up one’s good karma. So you need a lot to keep going to succeed. And this is why also here I’ve got a little propaganda in here this is why in the Gelugpa tradition it’s very important to say this, I think, because I think the Gelugpa tradition is wonderful. It is unique, has its very unique aspects. I mean, all the traditions are wonderful, but the Gelugpa tradition emphasizes probably more than any other Buddhist tradition in the world that I know of, and I don’t really know much about the other Buddhist traditions, from what little I know of the other Buddhist traditions, it seems to emphasise more than any of the others the importance of studying the Dharma first, of having an intellectual understanding of the teachings.

Lama Tsongkhapa emphasised, and his disciples ever since have emphasised, how important it is. And it seems logical that if one meditates, and you sit down and you concentrate on something, that whether it’s good or bad, whether it’s real meditation or not, whether you call it meditation or not, but when your mind is concentrating on something strongly, you’re making a strong imprint in the mind which is also affecting your understanding, your wisdom. So if you concentrate on something that is correct, that is a correct understanding of something, and you concentrate on it, you’re making a very strong positive imprint that is helping to develop one’s insight, one’s wisdom, one’s understanding. If, on the other hand, even with good motivation, one sits down and spends many days, years, meditating on something that is a wrong understanding, All you’re putting in your mind is deeper wrong understanding. One is obscuring the mind.

Meditation is meant to open up the mind, clear the mind, develop wisdom that sees the truth. If we meditate on wrong views, wrong understanding, like a potluck version of the Dharma, potluck, no, no, patchwork, right? What am I trying to say? Potluck? Anyway, just a mishmash understanding of the Dharma, it can be a disaster.

We’re just imprinting this misunderstanding in our mind. This is why our teachers in this tradition emphasize so much, get a right understanding of the teachings. Intelligence is so precious. That’s why you see the Gelugpalamas, they just study all the time, they’re in their room reading texts. It’s their greatest joy to attain knowledge, wisdom knowledge.

That’s why the monks debate so much, to get this correct understanding. Firstly, a correct conceptual understanding. And that is the basis to experience this direct non conceptual insight. That’s why His Holiness often says that, let alone studying the dharma, it’s also good to use your intelligence to gain any kind of knowledge, good knowledge. If one doesn’t have the energy to study the dharma very much, use your intelligence to study other meaningful things, just to keep the mind, you know, the intelligence active and use it.

Otherwise, create the cause to be a dog, an animal, where we’ve got this intelligence but we don’t use it, we just want to kind of float along. We don’t want to think about things, we just don’t want to think. We want to find someone to think for us. Much easier. Yes.

Just in reading Diamond Cutter by Geshe Michael Roach, he talks about the empty nature of phenomenon. Yes. And how based upon how you interpret things, we can either create positive or negative imprints in the mind. Mhmm. Can you give any practical advice as to how, or have a stab at hand, how to to take things which we might interpret as being negative, perhaps actions towards ourselves, and yet interpret those by creating a positive imprint in the mind?

As opposed to interpreting an action done towards us as they’re meant due to accepting that due to accepting By others? Yes. So for example, he doesn’t he doesn’t give any practical examples in the book that somebody for example shouts at us for an action that we’ve done and our immediate response is to to correct negative or that correct negative imprint in our mind, we want to respond in exactly the same way. Yes. Whereas he seems to be suggesting that it’s responding the same way, creating a negative imprint.

Right. And therefore the response should be one that creates a positive imprint. Yes, yes. How do you do that? The question is when people respond in negative I think it comes down to when people respond and react to us in negative ways.

When we react back in a negative way, that creates more negative karma. How can we respond in positive ways to what we perceive as negative negativity directed towards us? In general, part of the way to do that is based on understanding karma, the law of cause and effect. This is happening Why we get angry is because we don’t feel there’s a fault in us, that we have got nothing to do with why this person is doing that. But if we understand, really understand and accept the law of cause and effect, then we can accept that in some way, even though I may not have done anything in this life, there is a cause lying within my mind so that I experience this unpleasant effect.

So the more we’ve meditated on that, therefore we expect these things to happen, and then we’re ready for them. So that’s the basic preparation. To answer your question well, it takes a really long time and much of the later part of the course is about how to do this, particularly like with which we did in Perth with the mind training teachings, yeah, the bodhicitta mind training teachings. Yes, that was what it was about, yeah. Practicing patience and seeing the good qualities of problems and harm and so on.

Because the mind that sees as, I think, was it saying, Lama Tsongkhapa, when he was talking about when we in relation to our teachers, the mind, the ordinary mind, the negative mind that sees faults, that wants to see faults, if we follow that mind, can see endless faults in anything, even the purest object, we can find faults from our negative mind. But if we follow the mind that sees qualities, we can see qualities. And it’s the same so this mind, that can be used in practicing, transforming what we normally perceive as bad things and suffering and problems. If we dwell on only the negative aspects of these things, we will see whatever harm coming to us, we exaggerate it more and more, it becomes so threatening, so frightening, so terrible, so evil, so bad that, you know, like in one moment all our negative thoughts are directed at that, just by concentrating on the negative side, but we can train to see the positive qualities of something. Yeah, we can actually and this is part of the mystic traditions of all the great religions within Christianity, that one can see there are the worldly mind sees suffering as totally bad, the mystic mind sees suffering as good.

One sees good aspects of suffering and problems. And by dwelling or training the mind to dwell on those, rather than becoming the cause of suffering, our problems become the cause of happiness and a motivation to follow the spiritual life even more. Saint Francis was in the Christian tradition an amazing example of that. I think we finished five o’clock. Thank you very much.

We can dedicate the merit. So, in listening to the teachings, four aspects. There is the motivation. If we try to have the motivation, this is the very best motivation for creating good karma. From a Buddhist point of view, we have the Dharma teachings, even though, sorry, it’s not presented very well, but at least we’re directing our mind to the Dharma so that the Dharma is an incredibly potent, virtuous, karmic object the best, most powerful object.

Then if we listen with an open mind, with concentration and finding joy in the dharma, then this is the very best way to listen, and then we dedicate the merit to enlightenment. This creates the most unbelievably powerful virtuous karma. So we’ve done that for almost an hour and a half, and you had to practice patience with me, which makes the karma even greater. So, then one dedicates to enlightenment and rejoices. One rejoices alongside that all these people alongside me here, sitting here, have done the same thing, how wonderful this is.

So we dedicate this merit to enlightenment. May the precious Bodhicitta not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Okay, thank you very much. You could bring don’t forget to bring this sheet of the ten non virtues to the meditation session because we’ll meditate on this.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
preta
Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How can we respond positively, and create a positive imprint in the mind, when others act negatively toward us?

Reacting negatively creates more negative karma. Part of the way to respond positively is to understand and accept the law of cause and effect. We get angry because we feel no fault in ourselves, but if we accept karma, we can see that even if we did nothing in this life, a cause lies within our mind for the unpleasant effect. Meditating on this means we expect such things and are ready for them. This is the basic preparation. Beyond that, we can train the mind to see the good qualities of problems and harm, rather than dwelling on the negative and exaggerating it. Then problems become a cause of happiness and a motivation to follow the spiritual life even more.

Scroll to Top