45 min · 5,309 words · 21 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the law of cause and effect: karmic imprints never fade until purified, ripen in greater measure than their cause, and depend on four factors (motivation, object, manner of action, and completion, with regret or dedication). It then distinguishes throwing karma, which determines rebirth in a lower realm, from ripening karma. It stresses avoiding negative actions before pursuing virtue.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-21
Duration: 46 min
UUID: 2174e265-0a3e-4376-849f-3d11d1c5e316
Words: 5,309
Created the cause. There’s no escape. Can’t blame anyone for anything if we really understand the law of cause and effect. We cannot blame anyone for anything. No external person, God, Buddha, our parents, our husband, wife, children, our teacher.
We can’t blame the government, we cannot blame anyone. If we create the cause, we get the effect. If we get the effect, we created the cause. And also, having created the cause, that imprint in the mind never dissipates, it is always there. That imprint in the mind is always there, going on moment by moment, indestructible, formless, it goes on and it carries the imprint.
So that imprint doesn’t go away. It only goes away if, in the case of the positive imprints, we destroy them, burn them up through the force of anger Or, in the case of the negative imprints, they go away, they are reduced because we apply powerful purification practices to them. But other than that, having created the imprint good or bad, it will never lose its potency, its power, its potential. It’s there all the time. And at some point it may be one trillion billion billion billion eons in the future but then the causes and conditions come together and in one moment the full result comes.
This is what the Buddha taught. This is why we should never be sad that the results don’t come in this life, that we feel, Oh, it’s not working. It is working. If we do virtuous things, we are creating positive imprints and the result has to come sometimes. It may not come when we want it, like immediately next weekend or at the end of this life, but it will come in our future lives for sure if we don’t damage those imprints with anger and so on.
The result has to come. And the fourth aspect of karma, of the basic aspects of karma, the law of cause and effect, is that having created the imprint in the mind, the result that so the imprint is created in a moment, in just one moment. In one moment, as we are generating hatred, the imprints are being generated. As we are generating loving kindness, the imprint, the positive imprint, is being generated. So, it’s just momentarily, the energy is there.
But when the result comes, the result is far, far greater than the energy that went into creating that imprint. Result can last an entire lifetime, the whole lifetime of a human being, or it can the result can last the entire lifetime in a lower realm which is millions of years, millions of years, or it can be the whole lifetime of a God being which is also millions and millions of years. So the Buddha taught that the results of karma, of the karmic imprints, are expandable. Just like a tiny seed produces a great tree, So these imprints in our mind, good and bad, produce, when they ripen, an enormous result. Therefore, we should avoid as much as possible even tiny negative actions with our body, speech and mind, and we should try to accumulate even tiny virtuous actions with our body, speech and mind because even a tiny virtuous action will produce a huge result.
If we offer one grain of sugar to an ant, we can get a huge result. Especially if we offer it with the Bodhicitta thought and we offer it nicely and we dedicate the merit, the Buddha taught, the result is enormous. This is the way the mind works. This is the way the Buddha perceived the mind working with his clear, unmistaken consciousness, this direct perception. This, of course, there’s no way I can prove this.
This completely depends on faith. But the more we understand something about mind, and the more we under as His Holiness says, the more one studies the wisdom teachings of the Buddha, the more one can have faith in the law of cause and effect. But even in this life we can also see from one tiny action the results can go on and on all this life, greater and greater, good or bad. Just, know, worrying example, you drop a little stone in a still lake and the ripples go out and out And can affect many, many people as well, not just oneself. So these are the four basic aspects of karma to think about, develop some faith in, and to be mindful of.
To be mindful of, to hold that in the mind during the day with faith, and therefore if one is mindful of that, not just simply aware but mindful of it, then when there is the tendency to do something negative, there’s the thought, but the result, the negative result will be so great. I shouldn’t do it. If we really contemplate these things, remember that contemplate that one and stick it deep in the mind, then the mindfulness is strong and the faith is if we’ve developed strong faith in the Buddha and the Buddha’s teachings and therefore even if we can’t prove some of these points, we have faith, then we develop this energy, this wisdom energy that will start to cut our habitual creation of negative actions with our body, speech and mind because we think, Oh, it doesn’t matter. There’s no real significant result from these things. So it’s okay.
In the movies, when the bad guy does the bad things, the music gets loud, you know. But when in our daily life we do bad things, the music doesn’t play loud, you know. There’s no warning. We have to develop this mindfulness ourselves that it may look completely innocuous, but the karma may the karmic result may be incredible. Innocuous, insignificant.
We reflect on some very basic ideas that we may have never considered before, and by thinking about them with faith, then these have the power if we generate faith in them and act on them, they the ability to affect our behaviour and this is what we’re trying to do. So, going through the four aspects of karma, that it’s definite, that the result can’t be experienced without creating the cause, that karma is enduring and expandable this is not very exciting material but it’s still something to be meditated on. One analyzes these things, trying to understand them and the implications of them as much as one can. And by imprinting these things in the mind with understanding, then we can be mindful in our daily life and therefore act accordingly. So this protects our mind from negative karma, encourages us to do virtuous things.
So this itself makes our precious human rebirth meaningful. And in the presentation of observing the law of cause and effect, it’s always emphasised that first we need to avoid negative karma. This is the first thing to do, is to avoid negative karma. Of course, as we’re trying to put emphasis on avoiding negative karma, we should try to accumulate and do virtuous things, but at least we need to keep avoiding negative karma because if we do lots of good things, do virtuous actions and we meditate a lot and study the teachings and get into doing all sorts of formal meditation practice Dharma practices such as prostrations and doing mandala offerings and various things like that, but we don’t stop creating negative karma, then no matter how many good things we do, how many tantric practices we do, we’re always, by having not stopped doing negative actions, we continuously create obstacles for the success of all the good practices we’re doing. We do all these good things but they won’t bring a complete result because we continuously are creating negative karma.
So, in his wisdom the Buddha taught that first we stop creating negative karma. So the more we’ve got into that state of mind that doesn’t want to harm oneself in any way or others, then on the basis of that mind, when we do virtuous things, any kind of virtuous thing, in a general way in our ordinary life, or very specific Dharma practices, then the result will be much greater and our Dharma practice itself will go much more smoothly and bring the real result. Because we can fall into this trap, especially those who are Buddhists and practicing tantra and so on, that now I’m doing these very powerful special practices, but we forget the basic one of avoiding negative karma. So that is continuously creating an obscured mind. If we keep putting the Dharma into a the Dharma experiences that arise in our mind depend on the state of our mind.
If our mind is relatively pure, then the dharma we put into our mind will have an incredible effect. If we put the dharma into a very polluted mind, it can’t have much effect. It will have some effect, but not as much as it could have. So these four things: the karma is definite, that we cannot experience the result without having created the cause that having created the cause, the effect will never be lost through time, the potency will never be lost through the passage of time, and that the result is expandable. It’s important to meditate on these things again and again.
So, there are four other aspects of karma that it’s also important to know and meditate on as a way of helping us to protect our mind from getting caught up in negativities and enable the positive tendencies of our mind to manifest. So this is understanding the four factors that determine the extent of the result of our actions. So we can create positive or negative karma and the strength of the result that comes, good or bad, depends on four factors. These, of course, can all vary, so that’s why the results of karma can be so varied, the strengths of the particular results can be so varied, even though it’s all coming from the same basic laws that are operating universally in the same way all the time. So the most important factor of the four factors determining the strength of the karmic result is the motivation, the impulse that drives the action.
So this is usually presented from the point of view of negative karma but it also applies to positive karma. But in the case of creating negative karma that produces a great result, the impulse has to be the act has to be motivated by one of the three poisonous minds. That is, some form of ignorance, or afflicted desire or anger. And so, if those are missing, then the negative won’t be as great. And also, of course, depending on the strength of that delusion, the strength of the ignorance, the strength of the desire or the anger, then of course the result is greater.
And also, as part of that impulse, this negative mind has to be directed to an unmistaken object one knows the object, one is aware of the object and one is consciously directing one’s mind, the negative thought, to that object. So that’s the first factor and that is said to be the most important factor, the motivation. So if we kill an ant but we’re not aware of it and we have no intention to to kill one, then the karmic result is far far there may be some negative result but it will be very small because there was no intention to do so, and was no intention to do so, and one wasn’t directing any negative thought towards that being. Even though one killed an ant, one hadn’t directed one’s awareness to that being, with the purpose of harming in any way. So this is the first factor, the impulse.
The second factor that determines the strength is of potency of the karma and therefore the result that comes is the object itself. So again, one has to have an unmistaken object your mind is consciously directed to a particular thing or person, and then depending on the nature of that object, one creates a certain power. So, in the case of creating negative karma, the worst negative karma is created with, for example, killing, then if we kill a human being, this is worse than killing an animal, any kind of animal, because a human being has much more potential to benefit than an animal does. And then within human beings, there are very karmically potent kinds of human beings. Among human beings, our parents, holy beings, and especially our teachers, and the Sangha, these are the most karmically potent.
So, any negative action directed to our parents, to religious people, like the Sangha, and especially to holy beings, then the karma is far, far worse. Because these beings, like in the case of our parents, they have been so helpful to us, we have such strong connections with them, so harming them has far greater result than harming another ordinary human being. Harming holy beings is worse, and among holy beings harming our own teachers is the worst negative karma. Any negative action of body, speech and mind directed to our teachers, our spiritual masters, who we’ve decided are our guides to enlightenment, then any negativity directed towards them is without a doubt the worst negative karma that one can create. Also, any positive actions of body speech directed towards our teachers is the best positive karma we can create.
Then, this is very difficult to I mean, there’s no way to logically prove this, but also, apart from human beings, there are certain objects that are very karmically potent, such as images of the Buddhas, paintings and statues of Buddhas and bodhisattvas and so on, and also stupas. So, any negativity directed towards those can create a great deal of negative karma. Anything positive towards them creates much more positive karma. This is why there’s the whole idea in Buddhism of creating holy images, because one can create a great deal of merit with them. Is why stupas are built so that people can circumambulate them and create merit.
And because the object itself has so much positive power, even if you circumambulate a stupa with no virtuous thought, no conscious intention to circumambulate a stupa, it creates great merit. And of course the traditional story, the mind blowing story that is given to illustrate this, is the case of there was one old man who wanted to become a monk went to various arhats and said, Please ordain me. And the arhats, who of course had incredible clairvoyance who could see the past lives of beings going back millions of years, looked at this man and said, Oh, you don’t have the karma, you haven’t got the good karma to be ordained. And this poor old man was very depressed and then finally he went to the Buddha. And because the Buddha has complete unobstructed awareness, he could see way, way back in the past this old man, when he was a fly, had there was some leaf and there was some shit on the leaf and this leaf was floating around the stupa, there was some water around the stupa and the leaf was going around the stupa and the fly was sitting on the shit, on the leaf, on the water, going around the stupa and that created the merit to be a monk.
So he became a monk. Proof positive! For us, there’s no way we can understand this but this is taught in the sutras that just even without any conscious intention circumambulating the stupa because it is a karmically potent object symbolising, embodying all the qualities of the omniscient mind, then it creates merit. If you harm a stupa, it creates unbelievable negative karma. If you look at a statue or an image of the Buddha with a negative mind, it creates good karma because of the power of the object.
But if you look at the Buddha’s image with a negative mind and then you decide to rip it to pieces or destroy it, then that creates lots of negative karma. Yes, but if you harm it, if you look at it with a negative mind, it creates some positive imprint. But if you actually damage it, it’s the very opposite. That’s why making holy images, sponsoring them, repairing them, making offerings to them creates so much merit because they’re karmically potent. This cannot be explained at all.
One either has faith that this is true or not. But one can generate this faith because of having some intelligent reasons for believing other aspects of the Buddha’s teachings. But the Buddha taught this, and all the great beings believe it. From the time of the Buddha, Nāgārjuna, all beings have put effort into doing these kinds of practices. For example, if you go to Bodh Gaya, to the stupa where the Buddha was enlightened, the fence, the stone fence around that was offered by Nāgārjuna.
I mean, not all of it is the original, some of it is the original. It was offered because at the time, the stupa had degenerated, and there were all these wild elephants tramping around, damaging things, so Nāgārjuna offered this stupa to offer this fence, this stone carved railing, to protect this holy object from rampages of elephants. So Nāgārjuna had a direct realisation of emptiness. He was the being who had the ability to reintroduce the wisdom teachings of the Buddha back into the earth and explain them perfectly. So he did these prayers, he believed these things and practiced them.
So, if one understands these teachings of emptiness and who taught them and what they did, there’s some basis for having faith in these things. There’s no way, intellectually, one can understand them or see how they work, for sure. So Buddhism definitely requires some faith. If you have no faith that Buddha mind exists, how can you practice Buddhism? If you have no faith that you have a mind, how can you practice the Dharma?
If you have no faith that one’s mind has some basic goodness, how can you practice? There has to be faith. So the third factor that determines the strength of the power of the imprint one creates and therefore the result of it, is the way the action is actually done. So, if one kills someone, if you kill them in a way that takes a very long time, and you do it to induce the greatest suffering while the person is dying, then of course this creates an incredibly strong negative imprint which will produce an enormous suffering result. If one kills but the act causes the person to die very quickly with a minimum of pain, then this causes less suffering.
The imprint is not as powerful and therefore the result won’t be as great. But still, you’ve killed someone, so it’s still a very huge suffering result. But if we do it in a really nasty way, then it causes more suffering in the future. Similarly, we do a virtuous action and we do it in a very kind of perfect, precise way, then it creates the greatest positive virtue. If we do a virtuous action, but we do it in a very sloppy, not very nice way, then it minimizes the positive imprint and therefore the positive result.
And then the final factor of the four factors is the completion of the act. So this has two aspects: the actual completing of the act, such as we may try to kill someone but we don’t complete the action, the person doesn’t die, so that is not a complete negative act of killing. We’ve tried to kill them, we had the motivation, we had the unmistaken object and so on, and we stabbed them or shot them or whatever, but they didn’t die, so it’s not a complete act of killing, so it won’t produce the full karmic result. But if we complete the act and the actual action that we’re doing, we bring to a completion and the full result comes of killing, for example, then this makes a very strong, a totally strong imprint bringing the full result. And the other aspect of the completion is the state of mind that we have when we complete the action.
If, in the case of negative karma, we are happy that we’ve done the action of killing, stealing, engaging sexual misconduct, lying, divisive speech and so on, if we’re happy or, put it another way, there’s no regret it’s not necessarily that one is happy but there’s some satisfaction or there’s no sense of regret whatsoever. One is happy in the sense that there is not the slightest regret for having done the action, then this is a complete negative action. One kills and in the moment of seeing the person die, there isn’t the slightest twinge of regret. So this makes it a complete negative action, bringing the total result, the worst result. On the other hand, even though you start out with a lot of hatred to the person and I’m definitely going to kill this person, and you do it, you complete the action of killing and the person dies, but as that happens, this regret arises in the mind, then this doesn’t become complete and full result doesn’t come.
So similarly, if one does a virtuous action of you save the life of something, a little rat, and you’re so happy that you save his drowning, he fluffs around and comes alive, so you actually save the life and you’re really happy. There’s no regret, Oh, that he’s going to come and steal my cheese or bread, or bring the bubonic plague into my house, so there’s no regret whatsoever, you’re really happy that you’ve done this act of saving the life, then this is complete and makes a very powerful positive imprint. But then you save the life and then you regret and you think, Oh, little baby rat is going to grow up in a huge rat, eat my food, bring all sorts of poison into me, you regret it, then you’ve immediately reduced the virtuous karmic imprint so it won’t bring such a great result. So these are the four factors. These can vary enormously with each action that we do.
The factors can be completely different each time, so therefore the result can vary a great deal. And of course, the case of a negative karma, if all the factors are extremely strong, then it makes it much more difficult to purify. But if the factors have been all very wishy washy, easier to purify. And in the case of doing a virtuous action, if the completion involves not just being happy but we dedicate it, we dedicate it to enlightenment or, anyway, we dedicate it to a virtuous purpose, that protects it from being harmed by anger, our negative minds. So these are the four basic factors to be aware of: our motivation, the object we direct our negative minds towards, the way we do negative actions of body, speech and mind, and whether we complete them totally or not, and especially whether we have no regret whatsoever for what we do, the negative things we do.
So of course, in the case of purifying negative karma, we’ve mentioned, probably Karen’s talked about this quite a lot as well, that the main factor in purifying these negative imprints is the regret. So if we regret it in the moment we do it, it immediately weakens a great deal the negative imprint. But even if we regret it years later, lifetimes later, that regret has the power to weaken that negative imprint in our mind. Okay, so there are other factors that change the intensity of the karmic result but maybe we can leave those for the time being. And they are mentioned on page twenty nine of Karen’s meditation book, the six different factors that change the weight or determine the weight of karma.
But these four are the most important to be aware of. So also, if we do something good by accident, there’s no intention to do some helpful or virtuous deed, again, the positive imprint and therefore the result won’t be very strong. But if we have a conscious reason, motivation for doing something, then the karmic result is greater. And then, on top of that, if our virtuous motivation is, you know, we want to be kind, we want to do some virtuous thing like practising giving to someone, but our motivation may be virtuous, but it’s really very, very limited. Maybe we only do it for the happiness of the person of this life, so the result will be very limited.
But if we give some very simple thing, and even though that simple thing can only produce some pleasure in this life, like we give one chocolate to a person, so that chocolate can only give the pleasure from here to there for one or two seconds, But our motivation is that may this become some cause for this person. By myself being generous and understanding how giving makes sentient beings happy, may this become a cause for me to become totally generous and bring complete happiness to sentient beings, not just to this one sentient being but to all sentient beings. If we do it with that kind of motivation, that Bodhicitta motivation, then giving this one chocolate to one person creates a huge positive potential in the mind. And if we then dedicate that positive potential to enlightenment, then it can bring a huge result. That’s how karma works.
If we don’t dedicate it, we just do some nice thing with no particular reason and with no particular dedicated purpose, it will produce some happiness but it will just be worldly happiness, some happiness in saṃsāra. We get a chocolate back. But if we give a chocolate with this very intense motivation and we dedicate it to enlightenment, we will get a chocolate back but we will also get you know, it will create the cause to have the conditions to practice the Dharma and to understand the Dharma and to meet Dharma teachers and all the conditions to practice Dharma. So it doesn’t become we should understand that our virtuous deeds, done with ignorance, don’t become direct causes of enlightenment, but they do become the conditions whereby we can practice, you know, the Dharma, know, have it like get a precious human rebirth and practice the Dharma. So it becomes an indirect cause of liberation and enlightenment, and we need all these indirect causes and conditions.
If we do a virtuous action with some understanding of emptiness, then it becomes a direct cause of liberation and enlightenment. But if it’s lacking that, even if it has the Bodhicitta motivation, then it becomes a cause for good things in saṃsāra. But there are many good things in saṃsāra. There are very limited things like a piece of chocolate and then other things within saṃsāra are hearing that being able to come to Kopan someone giving you a ticket to come to Kopan. And those kinds of things.
We need those. These are indirect causes of enlightenment. Someone tells you, Oh, His Holiness the Dalai Lama is teaching next week, Would you like a ticket? Or, Have this Dharma book. Something like that.
So there’s a great difference between doing good deeds and doing them with a conscious motivation and a very elevated motivation, and also dedicating it to a specific purpose. So then, it’s important to understand what the Buddha taught are the results of karma, the karmic results, especially of negative actions. So the Buddha taught that there are three major results of any negative action. We’ve already mentioned so far at various points that one way of classifying karma is that there is throwing karma and ripening karma. So throwing karma is a karmic potential, a karmic seed that throws us into another lifetime, is the cause to have a particular rebirth as a human, animal, god, whatever.
And then the ripening karma is the karma that ripens during that life. We have a throwing karma, for example, in our past life when we died, a throwing karma ripened that threw us, in a sense, that pushed our mind to have this experience of this human rebirth. And now that throwing karma has ripened to have this human life and body. And now, day by day, our various ripening karmas ripen. The various experiences of this life come about are the effects of the ripening karma, good and bad.
We have some good ripening karma, such as perhaps being here is due to good ripening karma, and we have some bad ripening karma like getting diarrhoea here or getting a cold or something like that. So throwing karma is good or bad, it is a karma that has all the four factors that I just talked about complete. There is the impulse is complete, the object, the act and the completion are all completed. Either so for a negative throwing karma, we had a negative motivation, the object was a very heavy object, did the act in a very negative way and we completed it and there was no regret. So we completed a total negative potential in the mind which is going to have a totally suffering result.
So that is a negative throwing karma that will throw us into so that cannot throw us into a human rebirth. No way. It can only throw us if it ripens. It can only throw us into a lower realm. So then a virtuous action with all the four factors complete, that cannot throw us into a lower realm, it can only throw us into a human realm or into the lower God realms.
So this is why the Buddha taught about the ten virtuous and non virtuous actions because any one of them, the Buddha taught, any one of them, if done strongly enough and often enough, creates a throwing karma that throws us into the lower realms. These actions, the ten non virtuous actions, none of them, if we they cannot become the cause of human rebirth. They can only act as the cause of lower rebirth. And only the ten virtuous actions can become causes of human rebirth. So, we take one example of killing and we do it with all the factors complete, there’s no regret, we kill a human being, a nice human being, we hate this nice human being, pleasant human being, we hate them for some reason, so we kill them, and we kill them or even if we just shoot them, there’s no regret.
So this is a complete negative karma. If it ripens at the time of death, it becomes a throwing karma, and this throwing that can only throw us into a lower realm, it cannot throw us into a human realm. So, that karma of killing that person has three major results. Right? Three major results.
The first is called the ripening result, that it throws us even though it’s a throwing karma. The ripening result is that it ripens in a lower realm as an animal, a preta being, or in the lowest realms of the hell realms. So the karma ripens that way, it throws us into a lower realm. So if we experience that lower realm for a particular period of time, the karma ripens that particular part of the karma of killing this person, Person X, okay, we’ve killed Person X. Because of that, when that karma
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four aspects of karma
- The four ways karma will ripen, either in this life or a future life. They are: the ripening result, the possessed result, experiencing the result similar to the cause and creating the result similar to the cause. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
- Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.