Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 11 Tape 16 Side 2 Taking Refuge

43 min · 4,995 words · 11 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 11 Tape 16 Side 2 Taking Refuge
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk opens with a bodhicitta motivation and a refuge visualization of the Buddha and all sentient beings. It then explains the two causes of taking refuge: wise fear of suffering and confidence in the qualities of the Triple Gem. The speaker distinguishes the spiritual path from modern psychology, advises checking a teacher before trusting them, and presents the Buddha’s compassion for beings in happiness, since all worldly happiness is suffering.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-11

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 180e5061-c6ce-4b49-b709-9adfef6e06ce

Words: 4,995

Possible, try to generate good motivation for listening to the teachings right now. Especially if we can try and generate this bodhicitta thought that in order to perfectly benefit myself, to bring about that state without harm to others, and to bring about a state that can actually benefit all living beings, I need to train my mind away from suffering, confusion, towards greater and greater clarity, awareness, renunciation, wisdom and compassion. To follow this path successfully, I need to know this path. In order to know the path, I need to hear some explanation of it. And for this reason, for the benefit of myself and all others, I’m listening to these teachings, trying to generate some respect for the origin of these teachings, some trust, reliance in the qualities of the founding teacher of this tradition.

And the more I have this, or the more this gradually evolves, the more I can generate faith in the path. We can think of the source of these origins manifesting before us right now in the aspect of the Śākyamūni Buddha with a body of glorious, transparent, golden light. And at the same time, we think of all sentient beings who have so much suffering and who need our help in so many different ways surrounding us right now. Particularly our mother on our left, father on our right, family, friends behind us, and the people we dislike or who dislike us directly in front. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly By the merits I create, I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings.

So, to try to listen with a more concentrated mind, spend just a short time now focusing on the breath as much as we can, sitting in a comfortable, correct posture. Really directing the mind with strong interest and understanding towards the breath, and realizing that by keeping the mind on that breath, one develops the beginning of mastery of the mind that enables us to subdue, eventually eliminate the disturbing thoughts, and enables us to cultivate the positive potentials of our mind. Okay, thank you very much. Just before going on to the topic, again going back to the details of the meditation on refuge. The visualization that we traditionally do, when we generate the motivation of trying to think of all sentient beings, we try and visualize all sentient beings because from the very beginning to help generate even, in a sense non conceptually, the thought of working for others because just by thinking that there are other beings around us all the time, that they are suffering, this helps to motivate us to follow the spiritual life of whatever tradition we wish to follow, not just for our own sake, but for the benefit of others.

Try to listen to the teachings, not just for our own sake, but for the sake of others. We try to meditate, not just for our own sake, but for the sake of others as well. The point is, in reality, we are constantly surrounded by all sentient beings. They are around us all the time, especially in this room, there’s quite a few. Our self obsessed mind, even when sentient beings are physically present, hardly notice them.

We are surrounded by human beings all the time, we are surrounded by beings of the animal realm all the time, but our self obsession blocks our even that basic awareness of them, and certainly even if we are aware of them as physical entities, our self obsession so much, or depending on how strong it is, blocks our awareness of the state of mind of these beings, particularly the suffering state of mind they are experiencing. So it’s really helpful to try to generate this visualization as much as one can. One can just think of human beings, but if one likes, one can include all the beings of the animal realm. If one thinks they have mind and therefore need help, then one can try to conceive the fact that there are beings, these spirit beings, ghost beings, maybe hell beings exist, maybe different kinds of God beings exist who need my help, who are suffering. And especially there is the tradition of visualizing our mother and father of this life because our parents we have this incredibly strong karma with our parents.

So it’s really important that we repay the kindness of our parents of this life. This is one of the strongest karmas to benefit our parents is one of the greatest karmas we can create. When we go into the details of karma, the strength of karma depends particularly on the object that we direct our actions, good or bad, to. There are what are called heavy how can you express it? Charged.

Charged, heavy karmic objects and one of these heavily charged karmic objects are our mother and father. Benefiting them creates if you give a chocolate to your mother, you create more karma than giving a chocolate to someone else. If you hit your mother on the head, you create more negative karma than hitting someone else on the head. It’s like that. Because we have this our mother and father have been so kind, they have given us our body, especially our mother.

So, we think of our mother on our left because our left side is the wisdom side, the feminine side which is the wisdom side oh sorry, right side, right side is the male side which is the Bodhicitta side, the compassion side. Which doesn’t mean that females aren’t compassionate, males aren’t wise, don’t. It’s not to get too concrete straight away. The reason for visualising family and friends behind us is because of our attachment, these are the people we want to think of in front of us, you know, so we put them at the back to reduce this kind of attachment. The people we don’t want to think about, our enemies, the people we dislike or wish to harm us, we put them in front and try and think, especially for these beings, I need to change my mind, develop my mind.

So it’s a very skillful psychological method that we can practice even if we’re not Buddhists. It’s kind of helpful. So that’s one thing. So then, just a couple of things I would like to try and clarify because someone has just very thoughtfully pointed out that when I was explaining, talking, saying things this morning, some things could have been very greatly misinterpreted. So, one thing is that I said about Western psychology or modern psychology.

So, I personally am a great fan of modern psychology. Certain aspects of it, and certain types of it I really admire and think are extremely helpful and make a very great contribution to the understanding of the mind and are very helpful at a certain level. But what I was trying to say is that I was talking about the spiritual part. Modern psychology is dealing about and its assumptions are basically all the solid modern psychologies I know basically are assuming that there’s just this life. Maybe the individual persons may have a different view, but the psychology is working about the problems of this life and dealing with the mind of this life for the benefit of this life.

So in that context, modern psychology is very good. Some of it, not all of it. Some of it is very, even from an ordinary point of view, think, harmful and misleading, but some of it is excellent and very helpful. But I was talking about the spiritual life, and as I tried to indicate a number of times, the spiritual life begins with thinking not about this life, but about future existence. Of using this life, not just for something in this life, but for future existence.

This is what distinguishes every kind of religious view. All the different kinds of religions have this in common, of working for future existence, taking into account that. So when we take into that account, we have a much broader perspective and modern psychology does not, at the moment, to my knowledge, have that perspective or even purpose. It’s not working, doesn’t claim, I don’t think, to bring about perfect lasting happiness. In fact, I think, from my understanding, most modern psychologists don’t believe this is possible.

They simply don’t accept that this is possible. So I’m trying to introduce the idea of following a spiritual path. If we’re trying to follow a spiritual path to something that brings about more than just the happiness, the limited happiness of this life, then we need to follow and not just modify the suffering of the mind, which modern psychology can do to some extent, some of the good forms of it. But if we’re trying to follow a path where we hope that we can eliminate all suffering and develop a state of continuous contentment that benefits others, we have to go beyond these kind of limited ideas and philosophies. We have to have something that’s not just a guess.

I mean, I think many psychologists, if they’re honest, psychological theories would have to admit that they don’t know that what they’re propounding is totally accurate. It’s an idea and it’s experimental. We try this and we try that, and some things work and some things don’t work, and some things work quite well. But what I was trying to point out, which is what the Buddhadharma points out, if want to really purify our mind and not damage our mind in the long term, then we need to rely on a perfect method that can only come from a perfectly realised being. These two things can be combined and I think it’s quite helpful.

What often blocks our ability to practice the Dharma are out the gross problems, mental problems we have in this life. And sometimes we use sometimes we can use a spiritual a religion, a spiritual practice to hide our problems, not look at them. It gets very complicated because our mind is very complicated. So, I wasn’t trying to deny the value of modern psychology. Sorry if I gave that impression and suggesting that people stop it, if people have been into it.

People who are psychologists are evil and should stop being psychologists, or people who are attending psych studying psychology or receiving psychological or psychiatric help, I wasn’t suggesting to stop that in any way at all. I was not saying that. I was just sort of talking about following the spiritual life, the complete spiritual life. Please, sorry if I gave confusion, having a confused mind, I’m not a Buddha. When the Buddha speaks, as Karen pointed out, talking about the thirty no, no, she didn’t mention her.

There are sixty four qualities of the Buddha’s speech. When the Buddha speaks, everything he says is absolutely, precisely clear without mistake. When a Buddha, manifesting as the Buddha, speaks, you know exactly, you understand exactly what he means. And there’s never the tiniest confusion in the mind. It only brings clarity and joy and bliss in the mind, so you can tell immediately that I am not a Buddha.

Sorry. That’s why ultimately we need to hear the Dharma from very highly, if not Buddha’s, very highly realized beings who have very pure minds and therefore extremely pure speech. What was the second point? Oh, yes. So I also said about that many religions, and I specified the Christian religion, mainly this is because the one probably most of us are familiar with, but I was not criticising the Christian tradition.

I was just simply pointing out that many religions these days are getting and because Christianity aspires this incredible state, That’s how it originated. It was talking about future existence and working for a future existence. But some there is a tendency in the Christian religion and also in the Buddhist religion to just to generate that into working just doing things in this life, good deeds in this life. And I was not denying in any way that the doing of good deeds in this life is incredibly important. It is an essential part of the spiritual life to benefit other sentient beings.

Bodhisattvas a bodhisattva does absolutely everything possible to bring every kind of possible happiness to everyone. They will transform themselves into chocolates because they can, to make sentient beings happy. Yeah? They manifest as dogs. If you want a dog, they will manifest as a dog for you so you can say hello little dog and pat them and feel happy.

Is what this may sound ridiculous, but this is what bodhisattvas can do. When you’ve got a bodhisattva mind, you can manifest as anything. One of the greatest, most famous Tibetan bodhisattvas spent his entire life building chain bridges in Tibet. That is all he did. He did write holy Dharma as well, a teacher, but his main occupation was building bridges.

Bodhisattvas are truck drivers, milkmen, also prostitutes, all sorts of things to make people happy. Bodhisattvas definitely manifest as prostitutes, not every prostitute is bodhisattvas. Right. And so we it’s not that in following the spiritual life you only do spiritual things for people. I was not saying that one only does elevated Many many years ago when I was first working at the Chenrezig Institute in Australia, It was certainly the first Tibetan Buddhist centre in Australia, one of the first in the Western world in the non traditional Buddhist countries.

It was just starting, there was almost no one to help. I used to rush around like a plucked chicken doing all sorts of things, was the assistant director. One day we had a what do you call it? A toilet. What do you call it?

The ones that have the thing outside. What do you call them? Compost. Not the compost, but the Outhouse. No, not the outhouse, the thing where all the stuff goes in, you know, septic tank.

So this would regularly get blocked, and I would rush out and stir it to sort of unblock and stuff. One day I was very very busy, so I asked this young man, very spiritual young man, could you please go off and stir this to unblock it for the sake of all sentient beings? I didn’t say that bit but and he said to me very very seriously, he said, I’m sorry, I’m a dharma practitioner, I don’t do these things. I’m a spiritual person, I don’t do these kind of things. So that is a total misunderstanding of what spiritual life is about.

And I wasn’t saying one does it, I was not trying to say that, but I was trying to say that it can be a big mistake that we just get caught up in just modifying the suffering of beings. We have to modify this, we have to because I want my suffering modified. If I have a headache, I want someone to take care of me. So therefore, I should take care of people who have headaches. If I’m hungry and have no food, I would like someone to give me some food.

So therefore, I should be willing to give food to people who don’t have food. But we have to understand that’s not going to solve the problems of the world. We do that, but that’s not going to solve the problems of the world, the suffering of the world. Right? And as I try to say, the greatest gift we can give is the understanding of the mind.

From a Buddhist point of view, maybe there isn’t mind and maybe we don’t have to understand the mind and maybe forget about the mind, but I tend to think there is a mind and that’s the problem. This is what the Buddha taught. So, a Buddhist point of view, to have an incredible, not just an intellectual understanding of the mind, but a deep experience of the mind that one can give to others and show them how, you know, you can do this with your mind, that you have this mind, and your mind has a Buddha nature, and you can do these amazing things with it. This is the greatest gift we can give to others. But there’s many gifts we can give to sentient beings, this is the greatest one.

So we can aspire step by step to work to be able to give this gift. As we’re working aspiring to be able to give this gift of the dharma, and not just dharma words, but deep dharma experience, We do all the other things as well. We clean toilets, wash the floor, drive cars for people, hold their hands, say nice things to them, say stupid jokes to them, crack jokes, anything to make people happy with the right motivation. Anything to make people happy, to benefit, to relieve the suffering. That’s what it’s all about.

But we can’t lose sight of the goal that while people have ignorance, everything that we do is just temporary. And even if you drown people with food and clothing, if they haven’t got the karma, they can’t benefit from it, they can’t even get it. Billions and billions of dollars is sent to countries, from the wealthy countries to the poor countries. Do the poor people get it? No.

Who gets it in those countries? The rich people get it, The people who control the country. Usually, the warlords or the corrupt politicians get it. Most of it. A little bit trickles down.

If you go to India and into the shops, you see in the shops what is it? Not for sale, donated by the United States. It’s in shops for sale. Even in India, let yeah. If one doesn’t have the karma, one can’t get the result.

This is what the Buddha taught, I don’t know if it’s true or not. Third thing that was thoughtfully pointed out is that looks like because I’m talking about refuge so soon, it looks like I’m trying to force people to become it could look like I am kind of all this heavy propaganda to become Buddhist, but three quarters of the people here claim to be Buddhist, but many of them say they haven’t taken refuge, so I’m trying to explain for people the value of refuge. And since this is a Buddhist course, for the new people, is a Buddhist course about the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, then I’m trying to introduce what this means. So please excuse me if anyone thinks I’m trying to dominate their mind. I am a little bit, it’s true.

But I told you I was going to do that. I told you. Usually, refuge comes later, but also someone did advise me to teach it early. I also had that thought so that’s why I’m trying to do it, just to give some idea of what is meant by it. So, causes of taking refuge and the thing is, one can use this understanding, this Buddhist understanding, to apply maybe one doesn’t feel comfortable with the Buddhist tradition, but some of these ideas about taking refuge, of putting your trust in something really, really profound and pure and wise and compassionate, you can apply to other traditions.

And to check, in order to take refuge, one really needs to understand the teaching that you’re taking refuge in. The more one understands the teaching, the more one knows whether it’s really wise to get involved in it or not. And the teaching itself is a reflection of the teacher and the teacher as a reflection of the teaching. If the teacher is confused, if you can see that the teacher isn’t pure, the teaching is not worth following. If the teaching indicates an incredible kind of vast awareness and compassion and wisdom.

It seems to suggest that the being who taught it has those qualities. It’s a very useful way to check up. And we need to check up to protect our mind because maybe I shouldn’t say this, but I think it’s important to say that even in the Buddhist tradition, there are false teachers wandering around, very bad Buddhist teachers, claiming, leading people astray, using the teachings. Maybe some of them don’t even start out wanting to do that, but, you know, myself having sat here and taught these tried to teach these courses before, I’m very aware that it’s very easy to manipulate people’s minds to some extent. Yeah, it’s very easy.

So, don’t try to do that, and I don’t try to do it for my benefit, But it’s so easy, it really is so easy, so please take care. There’s this kind of group mind that can develop, and one can develop a positive there’s positive group minds, but there can be very neurotic, mass negative minds that develop. We all know history. One can get all sorts of excited about different things that happen here, so beware. Take care.

Just do things at your own pace with your own wisdom. Just because everyone else is doing it, it doesn’t mean that you have to do it. Personally, I think taking refuge is a great thing to do, but you should do it when you feel ready. I’m not saying do it, and I’m not saying do it in this course, next week, whenever it happens. If the lama comes along and is giving refuge and everyone is rushing around saying, Let’s take refuge, it’s a very good thing, Think about it.

It’s your mind, it’s your mind, it’s your life. Take care. Don’t let people manipulate you. Lama Yeshe, guess what Lama Yeshe used to say, everyone has a ring in their nose, and I’m the only one who puts a rope around the ring in my nose. No one else leads me around.

He said it much better than that. Just keep remembering everything I say. Lama Yeshe used to say, Check up. Check up. Check up yourself.

Take time to check up yourself. And, of course, I’m, you know, I can’t control this, I’m wanting to present this as true and valued and beneficial, that’s my job. I’m not gonna say Buddhadharma is kind of okay, it’s sort of, Oh, you know, it’s What’s the point of listening to something like that? Of course. But check up, check up.

So, the causes in the text, the traditional explanation of why we should take refuge, the causes of taking refuge are two. Firstly, the wise fear of suffering firstly, the fear of suffering of the lower realms, understanding I have these negative potentials in my mind that could ripen and throw me in the lower realms. So what can protect me from that? How can I protect myself from that? Or how can I protect myself from all the suffering of saṃsāra, of being even a human being again?

Still, as a human forget about the lower realms, as a human being, I have to experience sickness, old age, death, meeting with unpleasant people and situations, not meeting with what I want to meet with, and being separated from what I do want to be with. All this suffering I can experience. So, what can protect me from that? Fearing all that suffering, one generates that wise fear of all that and thinks, What? Is there something that can protect me from it?

So that’s the first cause. And the second cause is having confidence that there is something from the Buddhist point of view, the Triple Gem, the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. One develops this wise confidence that the Buddhadharma and Sangha have qualities, very unique, powerful, pure qualities that can protect us. And as I said, for us, as people new to the Buddhadharma or new to any kind of spirit, you know, thinking about following a spiritual path, a good enough motivation for taking some level of refuge is just the awareness of the suffering of this life. What can protect me in a really total way from the suffering of this life?

And so then we think of the qualities of the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. So the more we are aware of our suffering and the potential for suffering in this life, in future lives, this motivates us. That wise fear of suffering can motivate us to search carefully for a wise refuge. So then we can look at the qualities of the Buddhadharma and Sangha. Just generally speaking, I’ve tried to indicate in a very general way because I don’t have any ability to do anything else, and it also takes a lot of time.

If we begin to see the nature of our mind and that the afflictions are not something permanently within our mind, they change, they depend on causes and conditions, this is an indication that they can be removed. One can then imagine if they’re removed, they can’t come back, and in the positive qualities that we do have we do have wisdom, compassion, generosity then there’s nothing inhibiting the full flourishing of those qualities. Especially as mind is what knows. If we let it know, it can know more and more and more. Simple example: when we were first born, we did not know how to walk.

And through the power of familiarity, walking is not just a robotic effort, it requires knowing, knowing what to do. So, through the power of familiarity, we learned how to walk. Something that was totally unknown to us and something we were totally incapable of, but we had the potential to do through the power of familiarity we learned to do. We started off not knowing how to speak at all, we only made mumbling noises. We had no familiarity with any language whatsoever, but we had the potential to learn, and through the power of familiarity, that potential enabled us to learn how to speak.

Since then, some of us may have learnt to speak many languages through the power of familiarity and not giving up. If think about this, then through the power of familiarity of knowing and knowing, being familiar with compassion and having nothing obstructing the knowing of that, enlightenment. Enlightened mind is possible, it exists. But then, you know, that’s some indication, some indication. And but then so you could say, Okay, enlightened mind exists, okay, let’s call it I prefer to call it God, you guys go around calling it Buddha.

So, okay, let’s call this mind Buddha, mind, keep you happy. But what is to say that these teachings that you call the Buddha Dharma actually comes from the Buddha mind? Well, again, this is difficult to prove, very difficult to prove, but the indication is that and this is what we’re going to look into briefly in this month, the quality of the Buddha’s teachings and the basic the two main aspects of the Buddha’s teachings about developing compassion, the quality of compassion, and the qualities or experience of wisdom. The Buddhadharma talks about compassion not just for gross suffering. All of us know about ordinary suffering, physical and mental gross suffering.

But then the Buddha taught that happiness is suffering. All the happiness that we have ever experienced in our life, the Buddha said, is suffering. This is very interesting. And the Buddha said that one should have compassion for people who are happy because they’re not happy. This is really interesting.

How many teachings say that? This teaching is either really, really stupid or it’s really quite profound, far more profound than we’ve ever thought about. Our happiness is suffering. Our total bliss, every possible happiness that we’ve ever experienced, is an example of the first truth of noble beings. A noble being wouldn’t touch with a ten foot pole any of the happiness that we’ve ever experienced.

Not with a ten foot pole, wouldn’t touch it, wouldn’t come near it. Disgusting. Just disgusting. People who are absolutely blissful in this world are the objects of the Buddha’s compassion. They should be the objects of our compassion.

Just having a body and mind, the Buddha said, is a reason to feel compassion for someone. Anyone who’s got an ordinary body and an ordinary mind, a body produced by delusion and karma, that is a reason to feel compassion for someone. So when yeah, not to feel pity for someone, but to wish they didn’t have that state, and to generate this mind that becomes stronger and stronger, to develop this great compassion that is able to relieve that suffering from others, to stop it. And this compassion, as I said, that is taught in the Buddhadharma is not just for friends, and good people, and beautiful people, and virtuous people, or this compassion is not something directed at neutral people, but is also directed at every kind of being, including what conventionally is believed to be the most evil, terrible, vicious, nasty beings that have ever existed. They are especially objects of compassion.

This is the compassion that the Buddha mind is talking about, because the Buddha mind has that compassion, and the Buddha’s teachings, the Buddhadharma, talks about essentiality, the necessity of developing in our minds that compassion for others. Compassion that is just for the suffering of friends who are experiencing gross pain, it’s no big deal. Everyone naturally has that. Even dogs have that. Dogs have that.

What’s the big deal about developing that? But to develop an incredible wish for someone who has just chopped your mother to pieces, to wish them to have absolute joy right now, that’s another kind of compassion. And that’s what the Buddha

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top