45 min · 5,061 words · 16 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches that the eight worldly concerns trap us in this life and that the antidotes are understanding emptiness and impermanence and death. It explains karma, distinguishing throwing from ripening karma and the karma of eating meat. It also covers the precious human rebirth and the first noble truth, and it opens with questions and answers.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-16
Duration: 46 min
UUID: 9ec8b060-c57e-45f4-904d-244b823d2188
Words: 5,061
All the objects of the worldly concerns are something very limited. They’re not what we really want if we check with wisdom. They are limited and they are limiting. They limit us constantly again and again, they keep us trapped in just this life, and they trap us into believing there is only this life and only the pleasures and problems of this life, when there is something far greater than this. So, all of the path to enlightenment, actually the meditation teachings of the path to enlightenment, show us how to overcome the eight worldly concerns.
For example, the main antidote, the most powerful direct antidote to overcome all of the eight worldly concerns is an understanding of emptiness, the true way all phenomena exist, the empty nature of all phenomena, that everything actually arises depending on many factors. When we really understand that, even that understanding helps to cut the eight worldly concerns. If we have any kind of inner experience of it, that really cuts the worldly concerns. But that comes at the end of the path. At least in the presentation of the path, teachings are on emptiness, the wisdom teachings come at the very end.
The next mode for us as ordinary people, the understanding, the experience that is most powerful in cutting the eight worldly concerns is the understanding of impermanence and death. So this is what I’ll talk about next. So I have to warn you that this can be, especially for people who have never thought about impermanence and death, can be quite a shocking thing. But it’s meant to be, it’s meant to be. It’s meant to wake us up, but it’s also the truth.
Impermanence and death is not something created by Buddhists, it’s just simply the way things are. It’s characteristic of the way things are at the moment. But I will leave that for this afternoon. If you have some questions Yes? Yeah.
But it has to be. Right, it isn’t. Generosity is easier to practice. But if you just practice generosity question, okay. It explains this in the teachings.
If one practices very good morality sorry, very good generosity in a life but it’s not based on morality, the karmic result is, for example, you get born as a dog to very rich people who feed you filet mignon every day, they take you to these restaurants, you know these dog restaurants in New York City, these dog things where you you know? Where you get your hair cut and permed and colored and then your owners die and they leave you five million dollars. That is the karmic result of practicing generosity. Also Nagas, know, they talk about, you know, people who know about Nagas, or if you’ve read The Hobbit, you know, you get born as these kind of Naga beings with great wealth, but you can’t do anything with it, and you’re incredibly attached to that wealth. There are two things.
There is the throwing karma and the ripening karma. There is the pure morality we create. By practicing pure morality we create these karmic imprints in our mind which act as the throwing karma. We use all those up to get us into a human life but we haven’t created enough morality to then have the strong imprint to behave morally when we are human. Yes.
Yeah. Maybe. I I think this is the way I understand it. I mean, I mean, is not maybe the total right understanding, but I think something like that. So yeah, so there’s the throwing karma that throws us into a life and then there’s the ripening karma that ripens in that life.
So that can be like so as a human being this is very we all have a human life so our throwing karma was very good but because we have some suffering and some happiness in this life our ripening karma is a mixture of negative karma, negative ripening karma and some positive ripening karma. And for us, for beings who have a precious human rebirth, is a lot of good ripening karma. Some human beings have a vast amount, a lot of negative ripening karma in their life and very little good ripening karma. So there can be all sorts of gradations. The vegetables we get are sprayed with pesticides?
Mhmm. And if we know that that was, you know, bugs were killed in order to cultivate at least this food, how do we, you know, karmic we deal with that? When you eat meat, eating meat is not a the person eating a piece of meat has not directly caused that animal to die, right? But of course, by creating the market for it, there is perhaps an indirect cause. With vegetables, of course with all vegetables insects die, even if you don’t use chemical pesticides somehow in the cultivation of food, every kind of food insects are killed in the ground and so on.
So this is a part of the suffering of saṃsāra, unavoidable, because we have to eat. Eating meat? Oh no, there’s quite a bit of difference, sure. No, there’s definitely difference. What’s the difference between eating meat and not eating meat?
Some places if you eat meat, it’s almost sure that you’ve created the cause for that animal to die. They run out the back and kill the animal almost in some cases. So definitely there, by eating that meat, you are accumulating the karma of killing. You haven’t killed but someone else is killing for you. So the karma of eating that meat, the Buddha said, if someone kills an animal for you, you can’t eat that food.
That is heavy, that is definitely heavy karma. But if you buy meat from a butcher shop or a supermarket, that karma is nowhere near as heavy. There’s so many debates now because the modern world has changed, it’s become karmically very complex to really understand because in the past meat was killed fairly quickly because it couldn’t be preserved. So in that case if you went like this is what happens here, these little meat stalls where there’s the goat tied at the back. So you ask for a bit of goat meat and you know, maybe there’s one goat hanging there, the dead one, but then you ask for some more and they go chop and chop it up, you know.
So that’s what it was like most of the world, most of the time, but now we have refrigeration so it becomes very indirect, it’s really difficult to say that by eating meat one is creating the market. And of course in growing animals for meat, only purpose, the reason a farmer grows animals, raises animals for meat is to kill them. By creating the market for that, there is some I I think what one has to say, it’s unavoidable, you know, there’s some karma. In the case of vegetables, even though the farmer kills the insects, the farmer is growing vegetables. He has no motivation to grow vegetables in order to kill insects.
He kills insects in order to grow the vegetables. And he would actually all commercial farmers would prefer not to kill the insects because they would prefer not to have insects because it’s expensive. So the karma is quite, quite different. Yeah, the motivation is the main thing. The Tibetan lamas do say that even if when eating meat one is not directly creating the cause of killing, so one is not accumulating that karma.
The lamas do say that in eating meat is creating some obstacle to developing compassion. Yes? Sure, the question is about in indigenous communities or closed communities where killing animals is part of the traditional culture and so on. But again this is an example of one has to check, that culture says it’s okay, but is it? What I try to point out in talking about positive and negative karma is it’s got nothing to do with culture and time and ordinary people’s perceptions, it’s determined by what it’s doing to the mind.
Yeah, there are many cultures and this has been where there’s not like enjoyment of killing and they also accept that the killing is not so good, that they have to kill to eat, there’s not much choice, and so there’s ceremonies and things where they what’s the word? They kind of apologise to the animal and say I’m sorry, but So think this would definitely modify the karma for sure. But still there is some karma of killing. The motivation may not be so heavy and so on, and of course it’s modified by some regret of having to kill, so that modifies the karma a great deal, but still there is some karma of killing. And from a Buddhist perspective, the fact that beings are born into an environment where it’s necessary to kill, this is some negative karma itself.
Like animals are born in the in the situation where there’s they have to kill there’s this heavy instinct to kill. Yes, it’s still negative karma, yes, yes. But again, it may not be totally the strongest negative karma because you may not wish to do it but one is forced to. But then again, what is forcing you to is one’s attachment to one’s own life and saying my life is more important than the life of this animal or this person. So this is it’s difficult to say that this is true.
Yeah? Yes? Yes. Well the two strongest senses are your eye sense and the ear sense. These are of five senses.
How we are dominated by the eye consciousness and the ear consciousness, especially the eye consciousness. Yes. Have this wish for happiness, it gets distorted into because most of the time we don’t know how to generate this pure, lasting happiness, and so we get obsessed with just the appearance of happiness, the pleasures of this life which we really think are happiness and going to last. So, we get really well, the imprint is not just from this life, we’ve been following this thought, life after life. So the craving for the pleasures of this life is incredibly strong.
So that’s one thing. But we do have the ability not to follow that craving, we have some choice. But the more we allow ourselves to follow that craving, that craving gets stronger and stronger, we have this incredible grasping for the pleasures of this life, we exaggerate more and more how important they are and therefore we get more and more attached to them. And the more attached to those things we are, the more there is fear that that pleasure, that happiness will go away. Immediately there is this strong craving attachment, the more underneath subtly within our subconscious there is this fear that it’s going to stop.
One part of our mind, because our mind is very confused, believes or wants to believe that this happiness is permanent, it’s changing moment by moment, it’s going to last, but somehow at the same time almost we fear that it won’t. We’re afraid of that. And so we have a lot of aversion to anything that might interrupt our pleasure. So then this also creates the fact that the situation that the more we’re attached to things, the more we’re afraid we’ll lose them or we won’t get them. So the more we follow so we have those thoughts in our mind, we don’t have to follow them, but sometimes we follow these fears and aversions a lot, they dominate our mind.
So the more we allow our mind to be dominated by this fear of not having happiness or the fear of losing whatever I’ve got, the more our mind gets dominated by that. In that state, when a little bit of pleasure comes along that can distracts us from this fear of suffering, we exaggerate it. It’s so wonderful, our mind hooks onto it. Such as like a piece of chocolate, you know? Is suffering?
Yes, all of it is suffering. Which which kind of suffering? The suffering of feeling? Yeah. Well, the fear and the aversion, that is gross suffering.
The pleasure is suffering of change, which we’ll explain later on. I don’t know if this happens in Thailand, I have no idea, but if it’s true, this is definitely very negative karma. And I think it’s true, you can argue says this in the teachings, you can create negative karma by doing it yourself, getting someone else to do it, or rejoicing that someone has done something negative or positive. If you rejoice in someone doing something positive, you get some good karma. If you rejoice in someone doing something negative, you get some negative karma from it.
And for example, a general who sits in their office and sends a thousand people off to war and each of those men or women kills people, that general gets the karma. So if you ask someone to kill someone for you, you get the karma of killing and you also get some of the karma of making of the that person has killed. In a sense worse. Maybe one more and Absolutely. Definitely.
Yes. Yes. Yes. Sure. Very important.
So you just put the last one. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. In the case of making a choice between shirts, I think you necessarily have if you need a shirt then buying a shirt is not I mean maybe it’s a little bit of a worldly concern but what this is really talking about is investing so much importance in these things.
For example, you buy a shirt, you need a shirt, you have no shirts whatsoever, so we need some clothing to keep warm. So wanting to have a shirt is not negative karma, right? But then on top of that, we want a shirt that will make us look super fantastic and sexy and desirable and this and that, and like rich and important. So that, that kind of mind is definitely a worldly concern. And thinking buying, you know, by having this kind of shirt makes me a really significant, important, valuable person.
And Someone who has that attachment is nowhere, is nothing. These are the worldly concerns. But just deciding to buy a good quality shirt, kind of being intelligent. If you’ve got the money, you buy good quality. That’s okay.
But buying it as a way to be generates pride and so on. Look at me, I’ve got this very expensive shirt and I look so fantastic. And so that’s a worldly concern. Or you buy a shirt to look so humble and poor, that’s a worldly concern too. Okay, we’ll take a short, short break, a leg stretching break.
So, hello, hello. To make this time meaningful for ourselves and others, it depends very much from our own side generating the right attitude for listening. So as much as possible, we try and generate the correct motivation, particularly at least having the most basic religious or spiritual aspiration, motivation, which is seeking to develop oneself, one’s mind, one’s heart, not just for the benefit of this life, but at least for the benefit of our next life. Beyond that we can think of achieving we can motivate to achieve liberation, but especially we can try to motivate to fully overcome all the gross and subtle obscurations that cover that obscure our Buddha nature and achieve the enlightened state for the benefit of all the countless different kinds of sentient beings who have so many different kinds of suffering and need our help so much. So as we try and generate this motivation, we can visualize the Buddha in front of us as our object of refuge, and think of all the different kinds of sentient beings surrounding us.
I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly by the merits I create through listening to the So, we spend a little bit of time now focusing our mind on the breath in order to generate, or enable some more concentration, and clarity, and calmness to arise in the mind, which we can then apply to focusing concentrating on the teachings, so that we can understand them better and so that there’s a chance that they make a deeper imprint in our mind. So I think I tried to say in the opening talk, the introductory talk, first night, that any true religious system, and especially applies to the Buddhadharma, is very revolutionary. It is the opposite. If you remember, I mentioned hello, can’t hear? Sorry.
The Buddhadharma, like any genuine religious system, is very revolutionary. I did say, and you may remember, that one rough way of discovering whether something is the Dharma or not is if it’s opposite to the ordinary worldly mind. If it opposes the ordinary worldly mind, it is the dharma. If it’s the same, it’s not the dharma. So when you hear, especially for the first time or you start to hear things more clearly and realize the implications, it can be quite shocking.
We may not have really thought about these things much before, certainly when I met the Buddhadharma, it was very shocking, very shocking. And somehow the mind, especially the western mind, I don’t know about the minds of non western people here, the way the western mind tends to go, one way it tends to go, is then to wallow in guilt, you know, that now you hear this, and oh, I’m not doing this, and I don’t have this motivation, and we just seem to make out rather than use these teachings as an inspiration and to use the method contained to do something positive, we somehow use the teachings to beat ourselves on the head and wallow in guilt that, Oh, I’m not doing this. I didn’t do it. I haven’t done it. I’ve never thought about it.
This is not the point, that all that is past, and the idea is to try to approach the dharma with it can inspire us to do something that we haven’t done before, and we have the chance. We don’t have to wallow in guilt and so on, and I’m not trying in talking about the dharma to make guilt arise in the mind and make people feel inferior or something. Please, the whole idea of all of it, it is meant to be inspiring. That’s what I’m trying to do, believe it or not. It may not look like it at all but I’m trying to be inspiring.
So even the very heaviest things are meant to wake us up, not to make us feel bad but to wake up, to have a little bit of to achieve the ultimate awakening, we have to awaken to many small things first, many little awakenings. So even the heavy things that are said in the Buddhadharma, that are taught in the Buddhadharma, that we have to there are many ways of presenting the Buddhadharma and some teachers present it in a very very soft way. My teacher is Lama Zopa Rinpoche, he does not do that, so have been influenced by him and I could do it a lot harder than I’m doing, you know? So I yeah. So even hearing the heavy bits, the heavy bits, is to hear it, it itself can if we listen to it and approach it in the right way, kind of all of it is joyful and inspiring.
To know the first noble truth, that life is suffering, actually to know that and to understand that that actually is true, that itself is very liberating in the moment to understand and to stop fighting and trying to make something that is by its nature suffering, to make it something else, is just bashing our heads against walls and is also making us feel there’s something wrong with us because we won’t make with ordinary methods, with ordinary methods we can’t make life wonderful all the time for ourselves and others. It’s just bashing ourselves on the head. And when we wake up to the fact that existence controlled by delusion and karma is frustrating, is imperfect, it’s got its nice side, its enjoyable side, its beauties and pleasures, but it’s limited and imperfect. And as soon as we have a little bit of awakening to the truth of that, this itself is liberating, it’s incredibly liberating. It’s not yeah.
It doesn’t if one understands it correctly, it doesn’t make you miserable, it does the opposite. That’s how one can understand the Buddha Dharma, what the buddha presented. So I’m going to say a few heavy things as not to make you guilty, us guilty. Because all of this, excuse me, I’m sitting on this glorious throne, but all of what I’m saying applies to me, I’m not, you know, please don’t think I’m so definitely I try to apply everything, basically I try to teach myself in these courses, you know, why I go on and on and on is to put it in my mind. So and some of it is meant to freak us out a little bit for a while, to wake up in order to wake up.
Because there is this remember, please try we can try to remember, we all need to try to remember in listening to the Buddhadharma, is that the first noble truth if we just think about the first noble truths that there is suffering and there’s all these ever present causes of suffering, this is really depressing. If you only think about that, if we only dwell on that. But why did the Buddha talk about those things? Because there are the third and fourth noble truths that these ever present causes of suffering can be totally eliminated. That’s total cessation can occur and there is a method, an unbetrayable method we can apply to bring that about.
So that is very joyful. Yeah? So we should always hear the first noble truths in the context of the third and fourth. First you have to present the heavy bad news in order to get to the good news, But it’s always presented in that context that we have Buddha nature that is indestructible and all the suffering is destructible. But if we don’t know we’re jail, if we don’t know how bad the situation is, we won’t do anything about it.
Sorry. So, we may not have recognized it but all of us here probably have, do have in some way, amazingly wonderful human rebirth, the perfect human rebirth, the precious human we have a precious human rebirth. It may not be utterly perfect human rebirth but even if we’ve got seventeen out of the eighteen things, we’re really in a good situation. If we have sixteen of the eighteen factors, we’re really incredibly lucky. If we’ve got fifteen of the eighteen of these eight freedoms, ten endowments, we’re unbelievably fortunate.
If we’ve got all eighteen, there’s nothing to complain about. Really, we’re really set. It’s just everything is right to change, to develop our mind. So we can rejoice in that. So we may not have recognized this yet, but if we recognize it then we can do so much with our life.
And then it becomes a little bit shocking to realize the things that we could be doing with this life, we could have done, the missed opportunities, that is a little bit shocking, it may make us sad, may make ourselves guilty but the Buddha is not trying to make us feel guilty about that. But if we recognize this human rebirth, we can start doing these wonderful things of purifying our mind, avoiding negative karma, doing all sorts of enjoyable things that create merit, of cultivating our mind. This amazing thing, to cultivate the mind, to cultivate loving kindness, and patience, and compassion, and wisdom, and concentration, and all these things, and to cultivate generosity in our life, a generous attitude in every way to other living beings, to cultivate just a simple acceptance of all the different kinds of human beings that exist in the world. We can do that. We can just to do that, to cultivate just this kind of acceptance that other people are different from us, have other cultures, religions, traditions, ideas and so on.
And to be able to cultivate a genuine acceptance of the difference is a wonderful thing to do, and we can do this with the precious human rebirth. Maybe we haven’t ever really done that or tried hard enough in the past. But now if we recognize this precious human rebirth we can start. We don’t have to worry and moan and groan and feel guilty about the time that’s lost. It’s lost, it’s gone, it’s past.
Now there is the present, this amazing new present that can open up for us. There are people who pass their entire life without having without doing one really genuinely virtuous deed in their life. This is really sad, we don’t want to die like that at the moment of death realizing, you know, we’ve wasted our life on these eight worldly concerns and we haven’t really done one single virtuous thing. And why people don’t do a single virtuous thing in their life is because of following the eight worldly concerns. Being only concerned with worldly happiness, having this very tiny mind that is limited, there’s just this life we think.
We try to open our mind to the possibility of future lives, of the continuity of the mind. And we just get trapped in thinking, you know, we wake up and it’s just all we think of is today. How many of us who are Buddhists or follow Christianity or Judaism or here or something, all of whom talk about future existence and to be aware of it. How often do we wake up in the morning with the awareness of our future lives? There’s just this day is so, you know, on top of us, you know, this little mind that just is aware of today, and not even the totality of today but just right now.
Getting a cup of tea, coffee, a piece of toast or something, just the present moment. And that, being aware of the present moment, is not living in the present moment. Living in the present moment is much more than just being kind of obsessed with what’s in front of the nose. Living in the moment has the awareness that the moment changes, and there’s another moment and another moment and another moment. But we tend to be kind of just reality is right in front of us, and we’re obsessed with it, it’s so real, it seems so real, and we are so speedy, and if we check our life, modern life is getting speedier, it is really getting speedier.
In the twenty four years I’ve been a monk, things get faster and faster. When I first met the Dharma, there was so much time to practice and to come to meditation courses, people could drop their jobs and go off and do retreats or come to the east for a hangout for a while and go back and get another job, but that time has passed, everyone can’t give up their job because there’s thousands of other people who take it. We have to work people have to work more and more hours because if you don’t someone is willing to do the job. In dharma centers it’s so difficult to have weekend retreats because no one has time to take a whole two days off. It’s harder and harder in the centers.
It used to be very easy to have weekend retreats, week long retreats and so on. Life is getting speedier and speedier and with no time, the amazing thing, no time. With all the labor saving devices we have that can do things in an instant. Somehow we have all these things but we have no time, we just simply have no time. It’s that one up there that you can’t do anything about.
Thank you very much. I always give these same examples, but when I lived in South India in the evenings, when I lived in Sera Monastery near Mysore, in the evening times the Indian workers would come home from the fields in their ox carts, sitting in the back of the ox cart, and maybe their son or uncle or brother would be lying in the hay in the back of the cart, and the wheel kind of goes around, creak, you know, goes around, and the cart, you know, the ox cart plods along. Everything is so slow, so slow. But these people have time. They don’t have to rush home.
Somehow they don’t have any of these labor saving devices, but there’s so much time. And yet we scream home from work in our sort of triple, I don’t know what, turbo prop something or other and get stuck in a traffic jam anyway. And there’s no time. There’s just no time. If you stay around the Tibetan lamas themselves, like Lama Zopa Rinpoche, he does so many things but he has so much time.
He has so much time to do each thing. Rinpoche does everything very carefully and slowly and precisely, but it gets accomplished and something else gets accomplished and so many things get done. There’s so much space in the mind. But somehow for us, we are just so speedy, so speedy. We create this reality and there’s so much speed, we don’t have time to check that reality and the value of it, if it has any essence.
So there’s this appearance, you know, that our cultures, modern cultures are creating all this tantalizing stuff for us to consume, all the time. And we’re all chasing after it for this worldly happiness but we never check its nature. We experience this dissatisfaction again and again and again, but somehow we never learn from it because it all
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- nagas lu (Tib)
- A snake-like being of the animal realm that lives in or near bodies of water; commonly associated with fertility of the land, but can also function as a protector of religion. LYWA
- obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
- One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
- perfect human rebirth
- The rare human state, qualified by eight freedoms and ten richnesses, which provide the ideal conditions for practicing Dharma and attaining enlightenment. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.