Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 07 Tape 06 Side 1 Motivation

44 min · 5,061 words · 7 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 07 Tape 06 Side 1 Motivation
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains that meditation means becoming familiar with what is true and virtuous, and distinguishes concentration meditation from analytical meditation. It describes three levels of wisdom arising from hearing, contemplating and single-pointed focus on the teachings. It also answers a question on how to purify motivation, saying that starting with an imperfect motivation and persisting is how practice begins.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-07

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 9d354921-9381-4740-92f2-1ba5132f1256

Words: 5,061

Destroying itself and people are starving and killing each other and there’s so much misery in the world and I suppose to look at my breath, what is that going to do? Maybe I should explain this. It doesn’t really matter so much what the object is, but in order to work with our mind, to develop our mind, we need to have an object. Meditation is not just sitting down, closing the eyes and waiting for something to happen. Years and years ago, one of my friends who was a monk, not a monk anymore, he was teaching trying to teach his mother to meditate and so she was closing her eyes and she’s sitting there and she’s afterwards she said, I can’t see anything, nothing I can’t see anything.

So, the point about every kind of meditation, it requires an object, and in Buddhism, the object has to be either something neutral, a neutral object, or a virtuous object. There’s no point meditating on negative, harmful, non virtuous objects. That comes naturally. That comes naturally. To hold the mind on something neutral or virtuous is relatively difficult.

It doesn’t, at the moment, come naturally. The term that we translate as meditation, which the Sanskrit word is bhavana, bhavana, something like that, was translated in Tibetan by the word gom, and this word means familiarity. What we’re trying to do in meditation is become familiar with what is true and virtuous. This is basically what we’re trying to do in Buddhist meditation. Again, meditation is a word that can mean many things these days.

And some of them, the meaning of meditation that is developed in the West bears almost no relationship to what meditation in Buddhism is about. So meditation in a Buddhist context is about becoming familiar with what is true, about the Dharma, the truth, the truth of our self and all phenomena, and what is virtuous. Because, generally speaking, for all of us as ordinary people with untrained minds, what we are familiar with is what is untrue or distorted and what is non virtuous. That is what goes through our mind unobserved most of the time, stuff that is distortion of reality and what is not particularly virtuous. Meditation is the process of moving away from that and becoming familiar with what is more true eventually, so that we can experience the ultimate, final, perfect truth and what is more virtuous, until we experience the utter purity of our own mind that which is pervaded by love, compassion and a total inability to cause harm to any living being.

So, to practice real meditation, one has to take as an object that which is either neutral or virtuous. So, in the case of the breath, the breath is a neutral object. It is neither a virtuous thing nor non virtuous. One of the points about taking the breath as an object of meditation is that by holding the mind, focusing the mind, our awareness on that one object as much as we can, then it prevents anything else arising. The more we can keep the mind on one thing, it can’t go on to other things.

Particularly, it is taught by the great masters who’ve worked with their mind that we cannot have, at the same time, a virtuous thought and a non virtuous thought. It’s impossible for these two things to exist in the mind simultaneously at the very same moment. Of course, because our mind works very quickly, a virtuous mind and a negative one can change very quickly, but at any single moment, one can’t have these two contradictory thoughts in the mind. So, by training the mind to hold the mind on one thing, here, at the beginning, it’s a neutral thought, that also makes it difficult for a non virtuous thought to arise. Of course, as we are doing it, many different thoughts, virtuous, non virtuous arise because we can’t keep our mind on the one object long.

But the more we can do that, the energy goes into that one point and there is less and less energy for anything else to arise. So this is the basic method of beginning to gain mastery of our mind so that we can move our mind to what we want, not what is the tendency of the mind, is to move towards things which are distortions of reality and not particularly virtuous. So even though it’s a very simple practice and a very simple object that looks very boring, the breath, Nothing fascinating or mystical about it. A method, it’s a way to achieve, to begin to achieve some mastery over the mind. And from there, all other aspects of the mind, positive, amazing experiences of the mind, can be developed.

So, also, in this context, I should point out that there are two major kinds of meditation that we do, especially in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. These are concentration meditation and analytical meditation. So most people, when they think about meditation, think of it as being only about concentration, where you hold your mind on one thing. Particularly, it’s often associated with the idea of no thought. Real meditation is trying to get rid of all thoughts.

So when one is practising concentration meditation up to a point, that is true. In concentration meditation, we are trying to eliminate thought, but not all thought. We are trying to eliminate uncontrolled negative thought. But even to develop concentration to hold the mind on one object, one has to employ some thoughts. But they’re virtuous and helpful thoughts.

But certainly the aim of Buddhist meditation, particularly from the Tibetan Buddhist point of view, especially this tradition, the Gelugpa tradition of Lama Tsongkhapa, we are not trying to destroy thought because our intellect, our intelligence, is one of the crucial aspects, one of the most amazing parts of our mind. From our ordinary intelligence, intelligence is basically that aspect of the mind which is able to distinguish what is meaningful from what is meaningless, what is beneficial from what is harmful. This is the basic aspect of intelligence. From that, by developing that quality of intelligence and the thought associated with that, the highest wisdom arises. The highest wisdom that is going to liberate us is an extension of this basic intelligence that is operative in our mind, in our mental consciousness all the time.

So, meditation is not trying to destroy thought. We do need to overcome our negative, meaningless thoughts, but we’re not trying to stop all thought. Because, believe it or not, loving kindness, compassion, these are thoughts. We are not trying to stop thoughts of love and compassion, we’re trying to increase them. So anyway, one type of meditation is concentration meditation.

And the other type, which is not well known in the West and is also not employed very much in some Buddhist traditions, but is so, especially in the Gelugpa tradition, is analytical meditation. And this is what we’ll be doing a lot of during this course, mostly doing analytical meditation. And this is where we analyse particular things, we think about particular things, such as impermanence. What is it? And what are the implications of it for me and existence?

So by thinking about that in a deep way, in a concentrated deep way, deeper and deeper, then one’s perception of the world changes, starts to change, and it affects our daily awareness. Meditation is not about just sitting down and having some interesting mystical experience while one is sitting there. Lama Yeshe defined meditation, one way of defining it, as an active, alert confrontation with reality. Whose reality? Our reality.

An active alert it’s not something mystical, it’s an active alert confrontation with reality. Something that we all need to do to check our reality. Is my reality the same as another person’s reality? Also, one does analytical meditation on loving kindness. We think about it.

By thinking about it, the mind takes on that aspect more and more. Because we don’t think about loving kindness enough in our life, there isn’t enough in our mind. It’s not in our heart because we don’t think about it or we don’t think about it properly. Years and years ago, in the good old days, good old famous good old days. For some young people here, this is the good old it will be the good old days.

You know, the Beatles used to don’t know if any of you have heard of the Beatles, but they used to say, Love is all you need, a wonderful idea, but they never said how to get So many people talk about love, the importance of love, they don’t even define what it is and how to have it. It’s great going around saying, All we need is love, but what is it and how does one generate it in the mind? Basically, it’s generated by thinking about it correctly, intensively, and eliminating those things that oppose the thoughts of love, and being aware that there are thoughts in the mind, our own mind, that oppose our own thoughts of love towards others. We want to love others, but a certain aspect of our mind doesn’t, is afraid of it in all sorts of ways. But because we’re not aware of it, that takes over our mind.

So our love is so tiny that we have this potential to love every sentient being. This is our Buddha nature. So, analytical meditation is incredibly important and especially in developing this is maybe jumping the gun a little bit, but what maybe not a good expression for Buddhists, but sorry. Bad imprint still there. As I did mention when we first talked about the Heart Sūtra, the Buddhist teachings essentially are about developing wisdom, the wisdom that will liberate us from all suffering and enable us to benefit others.

So that wisdom is a non conceptual mind. It is a non conceptual mind that is directly seeing reality as it is, just as like our eye consciousness sees red colour without any concepts associated with it. The mind just the eye consciousness just spontaneously, directly, without any other help, sees red. Right now our mental consciousness is not able to directly perceive what is really existing, free of all the stuff that we impose on it good, bad, mine, not mine, wish it was mine, all these kinds of things. So, it is a non conceptual mind.

But the inconceivable great bodhisattva, Lama Tsongkhapa, the founder of the Gelugpa tradition, argued that the way to develop this non conceptual mind is by thinking conceptually. And concentrating on these conceptual thoughts, and through some interesting process, one eventually arrives at this non conceptual state of direct experience. So our intellect is an incredibly precious aspect of our mind. The Tibetan lamas always make the joke that if the goal of meditation and the Buddhist path was to stop thought, then we might as well pray to be born a chicken because they don’t think, you know. We oh, sorry.

Then, if the whole point of meditation and the Buddhist path is to achieve a state of non-thinking, we might as well get reborn as a chicken. There’s not a lot of thought going on in the mind of a chicken, right? But this is not what Buddhadharma is about. So in analytical meditation, also concentration is required even though one is following these logical processes of thought. Those logical processes of thought become the object of meditation.

So one concentrates on that logical process of thought. For example, thinking about impermanence or thinking about loving kindness, that becomes the object of meditation. So anything that is not a logical, clear thought about that topic is a distraction, so we need to avoid it. So concentration, developing some degree of concentration, is a key aspect of all types of meditation, the two main types of meditation. In concentration meditation, it is goal, it is the whole point.

In analytical meditation, it is a secondary tool to keep the mind on track. Does that make sense? Get the general idea? I assume the silence means yes. Okay, great.

Yes. People heard the question? Was it true that when the Buddha first taught, and when he taught about the Four Noble Truths, did the disciples who heard immediately understand and realise, Yes, this is believed to be the case. Because those beings who the first disciples of the Buddha had the karma, their mind was in that state where just by and in a very pure state, just by hearing the Buddha teach one time, they were able to totally understand, not just intellectually but in a very deep way, what the Buddha taught. This is one of the differences between us and those times, the good old days, that our minds are much more agitated, so we need to hear the teachings again and again.

Also, this is why it’s important Maybe I should have I normally say this at the very beginning of the talks, but as you may have noticed, I was kind of, I don’t know, a little bit distracted the first night and yesterday. I don’t know what happened, but should try to say, justify why I am sitting on this glorious Dharma throne. No, I said why I’m sitting on the throne but why me? Why should you listen to me? So, it’s difficult to find many good reasons, because ideally, someone teaching the Buddhadharma should have a complete intellectual understanding of it and a total realization of it.

So, unfortunately, I do not have either of those qualities. So, I’m not really a teacher, so please don’t make that mistake that I’m in any way what is meant by a real teacher in the Buddhadharma. But it does say in the teachings that the basic, the minimum qualification, the barest minimum qualification for someone to teach the Buddhadharma to someone is that they know a little bit more than the other person. So, maybe I know a little bit more than some of you about the Buddhadharma. And this is because I’ve had the good fortune to have heard the Buddhadharma from some of the greatest Tibetan masters of the Gelugpa tradition that have existed in recent times.

Some of my main teachers, unfortunately, have passed away, but I’ve heard many teachings from Lama Zopa Rinpoche, who is without doubt an incredible being, a true practitioner of the Buddhadharma in the most profound, true way of what a practitioner means, and of Lama Yeshe, who historically will go down as one of the most important Tibetan masters to bring the Buddhadharma to the West. And also I’ve heard many teachings from His Holiness, Dalai Lama, from His Holiness’s main tutor, Kyabje Ling Rinpoche, who unfortunately passed away, from Serkong Rinpoche, who also has passed away, from Tsenzhab Serkong Rinpoche, also another great teacher of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama. So my mind has had some contact with these great beings and something went in, something went in. Didn’t understand much of it, but there is some imprints of the Buddhadharma there. The main reason on top of that why I can do this is because Lama Sopa Rinpoche has given me permission to, has requested that, so I’m doing it because my guru, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, has asked me to do it, and so he presumably has some confidence that what I say will not be totally, totally off the wall.

But this is what I was trying to say, that when listening to the Buddhadharma, something very magical also happens because even by listening to the Buddhadharma from an extremely ordinary person like myself, which is unfortunately I’m not being humble, I’m just speaking the truth. But even by listening to the Dharma from a very ordinary person who at least hopefully knows a little bit of the Dharma and is trying to teach at least I try from my side to teach it with the right motivation, that I hope I don’t get too out of control with my ego sitting here and whatever. Because of the dependent arising, depending on one’s own wish to change the mind, and because all the Buddhas want that to happen, all the Buddhas and bodhisattvas in the entire universe are working non stop for each of us to realize our Buddha nature. So that is there, that is always there, that is the given reality, believe it or not. That is reality.

The Buddha mind is here working all the time, manifesting in countless ways, trying to wake us up to who we really are. That is going on around us all the time. And so, depending on that, and then our self awakening some sincere, strong wish to wake up to who we are, and then you hear something about how to wake up from someone like me and it can work. It can work. Something truly amazing can happen because of this dependent arising.

I don’t know how I got onto that, that wasn’t meant to be the topic. Yes, the idea yes, this is an answer to this question, sorry. So, the point is, when we hear the teachings so when you hear the teachings from someone like me, of course, to the dependent arising, something really amazing can work. But if you hear it from a truly realized master, then the effect on the mind is so much greater, depending on, of course, one’s own motivation. Because as I said, if one doesn’t have the openness and the motivation and so on from one’s own side, you can hear a Buddha teach and it won’t do anything, it won’t do a single thing.

But because of the magical nature of dependent arising, if one has the right motivation, you can hear the Buddha Dharma from a totally ordinary person and it can be completely liberating. It really depends so much from our own side. But, having said that, if one hears the Buddhadharma from a truly realized master, then the effect on the mind is so much more powerful. Because through the speech of that person, their mind, in a sense, is being transferred to us, not in the sense that the devotion we have towards them goes into us, but it has this amazing influence on our mind. So this is only something one can experience by meeting truly realized masters.

So I hope this doesn’t disappoint you too much and you think, Well, I should leave now and find the real thing. Know, Lama Zopa Rinpoche has said that actually, like the ordinary students who have studied with some of the Tibetan masters, because we share the same culture, we come and background and we have the same delusions and everything, then the ordinary practitioners have some ability to transfer something to new people that sometimes gets blocked with the lamas because of the difference in culture, language and so on. So there is some benefit, at least hearing the dharma, you’re getting some dharma information from ordinary practitioners and then having that background, then when you meet the truly realised masters, then you have something to work with already and then it can be really incredibly beneficial. Because it’s really helpful to have many different kinds of teachers to help us on the path. So just in connection with that, it is said that there are three kinds of wisdom that arise in our mind.

The first kind of wisdom this is because what we’re trying to develop is wisdom, and everything that supports that wisdom and enhances that wisdom, and with that wisdom all our love, compassion and etc can blossom in an amazing way. So the first level I mean, there’s many ways you can talk about wisdom it and so on, one way of talking about it is the first type of wisdom that arises in our mind arises in dependence on hearing the teachings. And this is particularly applicable for most of us who have not been born into a Buddhist culture and the teachings are very new and quite a few of the ideas, concepts are quite different than what we have been are familiar with in our culture. And so, the first level of wisdom arises from hearing an explanation of the Buddhadharma. For example, we hear about the law of cause and effect and a wisdom, and hopefully a wisdom arises that understands the truth of that and has faith in it, so that wisdom protects our mind.

Even the wisdom of realizing that we have mind and what its potential for harm and benefit is, arises by hearing the teachings. The second level wisdom arises by contemplating those teachings, doing analytical meditation on them, contemplating them, combined with concentration again and again. So a deeper level of experience, transformative experience arises. Because if we are open to the Buddhadharma, if our mind is open to it, there is the karmic disposition towards it and so on, just by hearing the words of the Dharma, something opens up in our mind. Some of us have had that experience.

Just by hearing things, We may have never heard it before, we’ve never really thought about it exactly like that, but when you hear it, you feel, That’s it. I’ve kind of believed that my whole life, but I haven’t been able to put it in words properly. So a kind of wisdom arises, a kind of awakening, some kind of transformation takes place just by hearing the Buddhadharma. But that’s only a little bit of transformation. It may seem very big at first because that wisdom, that truth, and that the virtuous quality of that wisdom is so, so different from our confused mind.

The difference is so great, it looks like something, you know, something really amazing and powerful has happened, but still, these old negative thoughts are there. So what starts to really change those is not just hearing the Dharma again and again, but contemplating it, meditating on it again and again and again. So then this deeper level of transformation, something much more lasting and pervasive occurs. So this is the second deeper level of wisdom that arises. Then the final, deepest level of wisdom arises when we are able to develop single pointed concentration, like the highest level of concentration, and that single pointed mind is able to focus without any distraction on the teachings about the nature of reality.

Firstly, understanding the false way we are the false views of self and others that we have, seeing how they are false, because firstly we believe our views are true, but then we’re able to concentrate single pointedly and realise that although certain things appear vividly in a particular way that seems it can’t be a mistake, we can, by understanding the teachings and single pointedly concentrating on them, can realise it’s just an illusion, it’s completely false. And then our mind is able to single pointedly focus on what is true, what is actually there, free of all impositions. And when we’re able to do that, we are liberated. That is the highest wisdom. But it begins by hearing the Dharma, getting a correct explanation of it, and also so we have to listen to that as well.

Someone can give a correct explanation of the teachings, but because we don’t listen properly, we don’t hear correct explanation. The first disciples did, and they listened with single pointed minds to a Buddha explaining, so there was this instant, effortless, total understanding. We are unfortunately not in that state, so we have to work a lot harder for a longer period of time. But it’s still possible, it’s still possible. It always will be possible, in fact.

So first there is this wisdom arising from hearing correctly, then by contemplating correctly, and then eventually single pointedly focusing on the deep meaning of those teachings. So this is one way of looking at the path to liberation and enlightenment. We have twenty minutes left, yeah? Haven’t got to the topic of this afternoon yet. Any questions so far?

Yes? Definition of thought? Definition of thought? Thought. I’m sorry, I don’t know the definition of thought.

What is the definition of thought? Okay, old students, what is the definition of thought? Thought. It is a conceptual secondary mind. We’ll escape with that for the time being.

I’ll check the definition of thought. Thought is a concept, right? It is a conceptual. It is the experience of something, it is the knowing of something depending on something else. That is what thought is.

It’s the knowing of something by depending on something else which is not that thing. When we see red, when the eye consciousness sees red, one doesn’t have to depend on anything else to experience it directly. But, with our mental consciousness, everything that we know depends on something else. Even to know, to recognise a pillar, a pillar, to recognise that depends on having a generic image in the mind of what a pillar is by having seen many pillars in the past. So we have a generic idea, a general concept of pillar and then there is a specific pillar and then we know this is a pillar.

Is it maybe a learned concept? A learned concept? Yes, that’s also an aspect of it, sure. Perception is not thought. Yes.

Yes, yes. Yes. Well, that was just a simplification, right? It’s not quite that easy. Yeah.

There is some view in some Buddhist schools perhaps that that is what happens, you just stop the thoughts and everything is okay. This is not the view that Lama Tsongkhapa taught. Yes, but I don’t think I can explain at the moment but I’ll try to make it clearer through the course. Slowly, slowly. Anyway, this won’t make any sense to very new people.

I’ll just mumble a few words but in tantra, there is the example clear light, the mother clear light and so on like that. The mind has the most subtle level of mind is the clear mind of clear light mind, there are various levels of the clear light mind. So, to get to the purest level of the clear light mind, have to get rid of concepts, you have to get rid of them. And they don’t go away by themselves. Someone who hasn’t asked a question before, yes?

Seems to be very much about me, me and me. And I’d like to I like it to be more altruistic. And some of it isn’t, some of it isn’t. And I’m constantly sort of evaluating that. How do you how do you define the correct motivation?

How do you achieve the correct motivation? If if, for instance, you know, regarding dedication to meditation, which should wanna be in in the correct frame of mind, You know, like if you’re feeling really lousy, or if you’re feeling depressed, or even angry? Should you meditate? Yeah. Because I’ve always sort of thought that it’s it’s a good thing to do because it does tend to transform the mind a little bit too fast this point, but is it of less value if you’re angry with yourself?

Generally, for people who may not have heard, the question is of the problem of motivation, of how to have a pure motivation and checking one’s motivation because sometimes we think our motivation is good but it turns out it’s not so great. And then also whether it’s good to meditate when the mind is depressed or in a negative state of mind, because the motivation then is not so good. We try to have this pure motivation of I’m doing this course, I’m meditating, I’m practicing for the sake of all sentient beings. This is the imprint we try to put in our mind. But of course, it’s not true.

We’re not doing it for that reason. But this is the aim. So, as ordinary people, our motivation is ordinary and it’s mixed up. There’s some good aspect of it but there’s a lot of nonsense and ego and self-cherishing there and that is natural, that’s where we start. We can only start where we are and just slowly, through trying with effort and developing more awareness, we can purify that motivation.

And that’s the only way to do it, just keep going. And the point is that if we wait to do something, whether it’s something small or big, with a pure motivation, we will never do anything because there’s no such thing as having a pure motivation from the beginning. Only Buddhas have a pure motivation. We are not Buddhas. Of course we have a totally impure motivation.

This is what the path is about, is purifying every aspect of our mind and the motivation. The actual bodhicitta motivation, this wish, this pure wish to benefit all sentient beings, arises after much, much time and effort. But it will only arise by starting off with a lousy motivation, but being aware it’s a lousy motivation but still keep going and trying to change it. And even the motivation for trying to change the motivation may be a lousy motivation but that’s our mind, that’s how our minds work. We always the self-cherishing always finds an excuse not to do something good.

Oh, it’s not pure, so I won’t do it. And again, trying to meditate when the mind is depressed or angry or so on, this really depends a little bit but actually when our mind is angry, that’s when we should meditate to try to overcome that anger. But of course if the anger is incredibly strong, it may be impossible to do anything. But my view is that any attempt to meditate is good. It doesn’t matter in one sense what goes on in the meditation, whether it’s good or bad, is important is the attempt to try to do it.

Because it’s only by trying again and again that things get better through the power of familiarity. That’s what it’s all about, of training the mind. Yes.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the definition of thought in Buddhist mind science?

Thought is a conceptual, secondary mind. It is the knowing or experiencing of something by depending on something else which is not that thing. Direct perception works differently: when the eye consciousness sees red, it does not depend on anything else to experience it directly. With the mental consciousness, everything we know depends on something else. For example, recognising a pillar depends on having a generic image in the mind of what a pillar is, formed by having seen many pillars in the past. We hold a general concept of pillar, then meet a specific pillar, and then know that this is a pillar.

Scroll to Top