17 min · 1,777 words · 7 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Answers questions on whether plants and bacteria are sentient, explaining that plants themselves are not, though sentient beings may live with them or resemble them. Teaches that Dharma must be contemplated and practised right after hearing it, using the analogy of leather softened by butter, and closes with dedication of merit.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-07
Duration: 17 min
UUID: 2dd5785f-2271-40d8-abea-46abee16f0d7
Words: 1,777
Know that plants don’t have consciousness, that is, that they aren’t sentient beings. This question is asked at every Dharma course. Well, of course, I don’t know if plants are sentient beings, but it says in the teachings they are not, so I have refuge in the teachings. So, that is one way of knowing. And, of course, there are some indications that plants have consciousness, but it’s not actual proof.
When we get talking about other kinds of sentient beings, there are sentient beings that live with plants, especially trees and so on. So what actually might look like the plant having consciousness is because there is a sentient being living with that plant or group of plants and also thinks that that is their home. So if you take care of their home, they respond well, and if you don’t, they don’t like it because there are sentient beings there. But the plants themselves are not sentient. Plant vegetation is not sentient, fortunately.
If it was, we’re in more trouble than we think. I understand why so many people want to think plants are sentient because it really means we’re much worse off. We’re creating more harm than if they’re not. Right? On the other hand, like for example, Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, there are sentient beings that look like plants.
This is particularly in the ocean, especially deep down, there are sentient beings that look like plants but which are in fact sentient. But that which is actually vegetation is not sentient. Where the level starts is also something very tricky of what defines a sentient being. But very tiny insects, maybe certain kinds of bacteria, maybe all bacteria are sentient. It’s hard to say.
Lama Yeshe once said that the bacteria that transforms milk into yogurt is not sentient. How come? I don’t know, it’s just not. I don’t know, possibly they are, possibly they are, yes. Certainly in our stomach we have all sorts of little sentient beings living, definitely.
Something like four hundred different kinds of sentient beings live in our body. Yes. Yes. It has Buddha nature. Yes, but as a chicken, very difficult to do.
It’s hard enough as a human being, as a chicken it’s really a struggle. Which is not really funny actually, but Sorry, I didn’t really get onto the topic this afternoon. Maybe there’s only five minutes, if we have a few more questions, there’s no point trying to start now on something new. Yes? You were talking about right way of listening, so by the mistakes of the fabric.
And then the second one was, you showed the bowl and you said, It gets dirty, and I put something in it, and it gets dirty. Is it possible the other way around that you can be so eager to listen to the Dharma as a comparison you have something sweet in the bowl and then something comes in the bowl and it gets sweet as well? Oh, yes, sure. I think so. Yeah, you could say that.
Yes. So that would not be too eager is not the right attitude. Oh, sorry. Maybe I missed your point. Being too eager, you transform something some nonsense into something good.
Is that what you’re saying? Would it be possible to listen to a diamond too eager as if you have something sweet in your bowl already before you know that, and then you have something in it and it turns sweet as well? Is that possible with the Dharma or not? I don’t know if it’s ever possible to be too eager about the Dharma. The trouble is we’re not, most of us, eager enough, maybe, to hear it and practice it.
The wise ones have spoken. Yes. Yes. Yes. Sure, that’s possible.
One is eager to learn so you hear some concept but you don’t fully understand it, one is eager to learn the next thing and the next thing. So, is that possible to somehow miss the understanding that way? So that’s definitely possible. Actually, this is a very good point because in this course, it’s one month and many, many things are introduced to people, so many new concepts. That is why it’s important as much as for each individual here to try to use this time to think about concepts that are new to us and to really because there’s some time while you’re listening to the teachings to think about them, then there’s some time in meditation.
But this is also what I meant by in the free time, much of that free time can just be wasted. So, I think it’s really helpful to Of course, it’s nice to meet new people and talk and enjoy the environment here and whatever, but it’s important to have a little bit of time to oneself in the break time to just digest all the information that is coming to allow it to sink in. And this is really what the practice is about, that we hear the teachings and it is crucial to contemplate them, to think about them, and think about them and meditate on them as soon as we hear them. There’s a whole story about this because In the Tibetan tradition, the lamas make this point, that they give this analogy that I’ve never been able I hope somebody here can think of a modern analogy that fits our experience. But in Tibet, I suppose it still happens in Tibetan, but in Tibetan culture and cuisine, butter is very important yak butter, and traditionally the Tibetans keep it in leather pouches.
This lovely rancid butter is kept in these leather pouches. Apparently, the butter because in Tibetan style, a little bit rancid butter is good, so the butter is kept in these leather pouches for long periods of time. And then the butter is used and then more butter is put in the leather pouch. So, apparently these leather pouches, after some time, go really stiff. They’ve had the butter in them for a long time, over years and years, and they go completely rigid and stiff.
So the Tibetan lamas give the analogy that what is really important when we hear the Dharma, when we hear it and whatever we understand of it and we feel is meaningful and beneficial to ourselves, we should immediately put it into practice, meditate on it and put it into practice. And this becomes like if you have a piece of leather, a new piece of leather, and you take just a little bit of butter, what a Tibetan would do, take a little bit of butter and you rub it in the leather and the leather becomes with just a little bit of butter, you rub it in for a short time straight away and the leather becomes soft. But, if you hear the Dharma again and again and again over a long period of time and you never do anything with it, really, you never contemplate it, never put it into practice, but the mind is always hearing it, it’s like one of these leather pouches that is full of the butter, the butter is always there, and the leather goes stiff, rigid. And then, what is the most beneficial thing in the entire universe, our mind becomes impervious to because we didn’t put it into practice.
So then, there’s nothing that can help us because the mind has gone totally rigid. And there is the Dharma and it’s always there, we’ve always heard it, but all it’s done is make the mind rigid. So what else is there to change our mind? There’s nothing left. So this is the greatest disaster that can possibly happen, is to hear the truth and what is really beneficial and to ignore it.
But if you hear just a little bit and you understand just a little bit of it, it doesn’t matter. Just a teeny little bit of the dharma and you take that as precious and you rub it into the mind continuously, the mind becomes completely flexible. Not weak and soft, but like leather, but completely open and flexible and transformed. Well that’s the second one of contemplating it, contemplating it and practicing it. The first one is hearing, the second one is contemplating it.
Yeah? Which also what that contemplation means includes actually studying it, like you hear something, so then you go off, you take notes, you read the notes, you read texts about that topic, and you contemplate it, you meditate on it. And why do we meditate? What is the purpose of meditation? Is putting an imprint in the mind and an impression, various levels, types of impressions in the mind that and the purpose of them is to transform our perception of the world and to try to maintain that perception in our daily life.
So the more we meditate about various things, the more we can be mindful of those things in our daily life. And the more we’re mindful of them, the more that affects our behavior and perception in a meaningful, beneficial way. For example, meditating on impermanence. We think about it, contemplate it, study what it really means, and then by meditating on it a lot, then in our daily life, whatever we’re doing, those imprints, those thoughts that we put into our mind deeply arise up in our daily consciousness and we remember, Oh, things are actually impermanent. I thought they were permanent, but they’re impermanent.
If they’re impermanent, then I should react this way, not that way. I think we have to finish. It’s time. Sorry. Okay, so, having tried to generate a good motivation for listening to teachings and then having tried to listen in the best way, then we should understand that we have generated these very positive imprints in our mind, so we can dedicate this positive energy for it to become a cause for our complete liberation from all suffering and for us to be able to awaken to our true nature, our Buddha nature, achieve complete enlightenment, a state that brings about our own perfect lasting happiness and a state that enables us to continuously, effortlessly, joyfully, spontaneously, perfectly benefit every living being without exception.
So the dedication is on page It’s also really nice to do the Bodhicitta dedication, which is at the bottom of page twenty one, twenty-two, twenty-one, so we can do that. And then the dedication of merit or the positive energy on top of page twenty-two, twenty-three. Bottom of page twenty is the Tibetan. Okay. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.