44 min · 4,242 words · 13 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains refuge as developing faith in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, which creates a virtuous mind that protects against falling to the lower realms. It argues for committing wholeheartedly to one path rather than mixing religions, and presents refuge as the basis for taking vows and becoming an inner being. Audience questions cover topics such as whether the Buddha sees the future and why suffering exists.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-13
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 3d06067e-d29b-49a9-8ec4-eb6e53071d6e
Words: 4,242
Us from the suffering of the lower realms. So how does that work? It’s difficult to explain exactly, but refuge is this when we go for refuge, take refuge, or do refuge, we’re generating this state of faith in our mind in the Buddhadharma and Sangha. We’re developing this virtuous mind. So it is that virtuous mind, if it is in our mind, this confidence, this trust, this faith in these pure qualities, while that exists in our mind and our mind is in that state, we can’t fall, the mind can’t fall to the lower realms because the mind is in a virtuous state.
It is said even if you think of the word Buddha with faith at the time of death, your mind can’t fall into the lower realms. Because one’s mind is in a virtuous state, a very positive virtuous state, the mind is in refuge, that is, trusting in these virtuous qualities, having admiration for these virtuous qualities. One’s mind is admiring these virtuous qualities, and what always goes with those, the stronger that admiration is, there’s a longing for those qualities, a sincere longing for those qualities. So that is a state of mind that prevents us, prevents any kind of negative karma because that state of mind acts as a condition that prevents any negative karma that would throw us into the lower realm from ripening. Because the negative karmas need various conditions to come about, to rise and ripen, so when the mind is in this state of refuge, these negative karmas can’t ripen.
Lama Zopa Rinpoche said a few years ago, which I found really inspiring, just something very simple, because I always thought that to stop falling from the lower realms you had to have this complete refuge in Buddhadharma and Sangha and have this total understanding in your mind, and that would help you not fall to the lower realms. Rinpoche once said here during one of the Kopan courses that even if you have some admiration, respect, faith in an ordinary monk or nun at the time of death, and you think of that person, they’re totally ordinary human beings but they’re ordained, and you have some admiration for them as ordained people, and you think of that person at the time of death, you can’t go to the lower realms. Yes. It’s the dharmakaya. The dharmakaya, which is the omniscient mind of the Buddha.
Yes. Yes. This is a good question and very difficult to answer. If the Buddha can see the future, what does this mean about? Does this mean that our future is fixed and therefore it’s just an illusion that we are changing things?
Don’t think it means this because one way I try to understand this, which may not be correct, so this is just my understanding, or one way I try to understand this, is that things are changing moment by moment. The world, everything is changing moment by moment, depending on causes and conditions. So at any one moment, for example, if we take ourselves, at any one moment we’re in a particular state of mind depending on causes and conditions, and the Buddha can see that, right? And there are all sorts of implications from being in that state of mind and following it, So if one is in a particular state of mind and follows that, then the future is this. So the Buddha can see that.
But in the very next moment, our mind causes and conditions change, our mind changes, and the Buddha can see that, and the Buddha can see that the future of that is this. And in the next moment, our mind changes, and the Buddha can see that, can see the future implications will be this. So when it says the Buddha can see the future, it doesn’t mean a permanent future. The Buddha can see the future which is changing moment by moment. Hope that makes some sense.
And the point is, let alone Buddhas, there are people who can see ordinary, deluded people who can see the future, have the ability, some limited ability to see the future. And yet things are changing all the time. Can a Buddhist celebrate Christmas? A Buddhist can do anything they like. Sorry?
Are you saying Buddhists or Buddhists? Buddhists. Buddhists. I mean, of course, we can do anything we like, there’s karma. But as a Buddhist, one I mean, no one is telling us, you must do this, you must not do that.
Even as a monk, there are vows to keep and it’s very interesting that, especially in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, although there is some kind of monastic encouragement to keep one’s vows, one isn’t being chased around to be a good person and whatever. I mean, to some extent there is, but there’s no one really kind of like, you have to do this and you must do that, you mustn’t do that. Sometimes we would like that, but actually it’s often missing. The lamas can stand there and just watch one monk do something really terrible and say nothing. That’s not considered same refuge in the other world as God?
Celebrating Christmas? Well, depends how you celebrate it. Of course, when you take refuge I mean, we’ll get to this was going to explain about actually deciding to follow take refuge or not later on in the course, But of course, one of the meanings of actually taking refuge, deciding to take refuge, of course, is you decide to follow the Buddhist teaching. You make this decision to follow the Buddhist path, which is that path can exist only in reliance on the Buddhist teachings and to take that as one’s the thing you place your trust in. So if you place your trust in that, you can’t place your trust in other things, or not to the same extent.
One can admire other religions and systems of teachings and whatever, and admire them and gain inspiration from them, but if in taking refuge, really taking refuge in one’s heart, if one system says this and the Buddhadharma says that, if we take refuge, even if we don’t understand it, the idea is we follow what the Buddha said, the Buddha’s teachings because we have decided these teachings come from Buddha mind, and therefore that’s true, even if we can’t understand That’s the nitty gritty of taking refuge. We decide that there is Buddha mind and these teachings come from that mind and this is what we trust. But if we start to mix everything up, it gets very confusing. It’s so important, and this is one thing, whether one becomes a Buddhist or not, that these teachings are giving some guidance to, is that we need to develop conviction, refuge in one path, one foundation, one source. Develop a conviction in saṃsāra, we may decide it’s Buddha, we may decide it’s the Christian God, or the Muslim God, or the Jewish God, or the Taoist God, I don’t know, God or whatever, whatever, or that there is no God or there is no Buddha but there is something else, but we need to decide that we can really rely on that and to really rely on the teachings coming from that which we believe is totally trustworthy.
And if we start mixing, we’re not going to get anywhere. There’s this view that is very common now that everything is the same and we just put it all together and mix it up, and then we have this universal thing. But it doesn’t work like that. All religions have their good qualities and meet the needs of particular people in particular times. And from my point of view, although the Buddhadharma is something really wonderful and perfect and if people could believe in it, it would benefit them, it’s also one can see that many people do not feel comfortable with the Buddhadharma, so there’s no point trying to put force on them, there’s no benefit whatsoever.
People have to accept it from their own side. And even within the Buddhadharma, there’s many versions of it, different aspects, different practices, suitable for different people at different times. But what the teaching of refuge is telling us is that we have to choose a path and follow that path wholeheartedly and consistently, otherwise we won’t get anywhere. Even within the Buddhism there are many ways of practicing it, but if you keep chopping and changing, we’ll never get anywhere. Because why do we chop and change?
Because we doubt, Oh, I’m on this path, oh, look, there’s that. Oh, oh, this one, and then there’s that one, and there’s this teacher, and that teacher, and this one, and this place, and that place. So we doubt and change and never get anywhere. And also what is often behind those doubts is our sneaky little self-cherishing mind. Oh, this looks easier.
This bit is too difficult. This whole idea of making this one religion out of all the other religions is the self-cherishing mind takes the easy bit from this one, and the easy bit from that one. You leave out the hells from that one, forget that, that’s not true, and enlightenment is possible in one week, take that one. Know, don’t have to like your enemies, take that one, kill your enemies, this is good, then you have this nice mush, which is nothing, it’s just totally suitable for the worldly mind. If there’s suffering everywhere?
Good question. This is often asked, I often ask this question myself. I’m happy for an explanation from someone. We can’t get rid of Buddha nature. What would you call it?
Buddha. Buddha nature transforms into Buddha. I don’t think I said that. I don’t think I said, you just need Buddha. Sorry?
Sorry? By liberating our Buddha nature, When that’s liberated, we stop suffering, we stop the suffering of others. Just ongoing bliss. But I think in answer it’s not really an answer to your question but think one thing is that we, at our level now, when we think of suffering and compassion as a response to suffering, we somehow our compassion shakes our mind and upsets us because it’s a very undeveloped kind of compassion, but great compassion is a very stable, courageous mind. And when one’s mind is really shaken and unhappy, one can’t take on the suffering or overcome the suffering of others.
Somehow Buddhas are perfectly undisturbed and also when we say they’re happy, I mean, this is really an unfortunate word, we don’t have of we think of happy as, you know, happy happy happy. So a Buddha isn’t like happy happy happy as people are, you know, are dying and being tortured and so on. It’s not like they have that kind of mind. Yes, but he also does manifest crying when he talks about suffering. Not like us anyway, certainly not like us.
By accepting suffering, you are saying suffering is transcended. Accepting the suffering, transcend it. You act and transcend. If you Fight. Fight.
Yes. Yes. That’s true. I think. Yeah.
Something like that hopefully. But this is one of these inconceivable things, it’s difficult for our mind to quite conceive how this works. This is also perhaps one aspect of it because when we ourselves get upset by the suffering of others and the suffering of this world, One of the reasons is because we feel it’s hopeless, it’s always going to go on and there’s nothing much we can do about it, but Buddha mind is not sort of oppressed like that at all. Okay, maybe we take just a very short break, a leg stretching break, and then we’ll do a little contemplation. So, as we sit in a comfortable position, we generate good motivation for just going over, reflecting on what we’ve heard so far this morning, just so we can try to think about its implications a little bit, make a stronger imprint in our mind, so we can consider that if we keep entrusting ourselves to things which are very relative and limited, then this will always breed insecurity, constant insecurity.
But if we entrust our mind to that which is completely pure, eternal and absolute, then there is a real chance for freedom. It’s so important in working with our mind in profoundest way, not just to solve temporarily some problems of this life, but to solve all the problems of existence now and in the future, that we have to rely on something, a completely pure mind, which we call Buddha mind. It’s not simply pure, but possesses all good qualities and possesses not just these compassionate good qualities, but perfect wisdom as well. We should really develop some conviction of the absolute necessity of relying on such a mind. So the teaching needs to be something wise and compassionate, but also very flexible, not rigid and dogmatic.
Study a particular teaching and see that it has all these many good qualities these wise, compassionate, flexible qualities, then we can perhaps consider this reflects that they come from a wise, fully compassionate, flexible mind. And by generating faith in such a mind, that faith, admiring those qualities, acts as a condition that can lead us to develop such a mind. That the mind developing the admiration for enlightenment itself places us in a very positive state, a very protective state of mind itself. When we listen to the rest of the presentation of the Buddhadharma, we can investigate it for these qualities of wisdom, compassion, flexibility, openness, and so on. And look within the teachings whether they show the signs of the indications of being a reflection of a very pure mind that we can rely on and place our trust in and develop refuge, something that enables us to follow a very safe direction in life away from suffering towards greater and greater peace, contentment.
Merit of this time, this morning, that may become a cause to achieve the most perfect state of enlightenment, not just for our own sake, but so we have the qualities that do not cause harm in any way to any living being at any time, but rather continuously benefit every living being in every possible way, all the time. Precious bodhicitta born arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then on page sixty there’s the third offering practice that you may like to join in, sixty, sixty one. As we recite Om Ah hum, we imagine this ordinary food transforming into nectar, this very blissful nectar that can totally energize and satisfy our whole being, our body and mind.
And particularly, we can imagine the Buddha that we really are at the very center of our heart chakra, surrounded by all different kinds of sentient beings, and so we offer this nectar as we eat, we offer this nectar to the Buddha and all sentient beings. Particularly, as we eat, we try to eat with motivation to take care of the body, so that we can use the body to practice the Dharma. Having a healthy body is a condition for a healthy energetic mind that we can direct to the practice of Dharma. Okay. Thank you.
So as much as possible to make this time a Dharma practice, something far reaching in its benefit for ourselves and others, reaching beyond this life into future existences, it’s helpful to generate a really strong, clear motivation, and especially we can try to generate the aspiration to awaken our Buddha nature, our Buddha potential, for the benefit of all living beings, working to counteract all the obstructions in our mind, so that we can achieve the enlightened state. And we can base this thought on a refuge, complete trust conviction in the existence of Buddhas, and therefore, the pure teachings, the pure method that shows us how to achieve this enlightened state, and a trust in the that there are the Ārya Sangha who can guide us on this path. So if one wishes, one can do the traditional as one says, if one wishes, one can join in the traditional Buddhist prayer. If not, of course no one has to say it any time during this course at all, it’s just something that one may want to try. So as we say the prayer, also there is the tradition of visualizing the field of refuge which can be embodied in the single figure of Śākyamūni Buddha, and ourselves surrounded by all the different sentient beings.
I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the supreme assembly, which I create by listening, to teaching the Dharma, and become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings. So again, we can spend just a little time focusing our mind on the breath, in order to develop a concentration that we can try to maintain as we take as our object the explanation of the path to enlightenment. Okay. Thank you. So so the more we discover the existence of our mind, its potential for harm to ourself and others, but especially its potential to bring incredible joy and benefit to ourself and others, not just in a short term way but in continuously lasting way, the more we need to discover a method that can overcome those disturbing thoughts and actually perhaps discover a method that shows us how to eliminate them, We need to discover a method, totally reliable method, that shows us how to develop the full potential of our mind that comes about without causing harm to any living being, including ourselves, at any time.
So having discovered the potential of our mind, we need to discover a true path that comes from a pure source and to develop a deep understanding of it that causes us to aspire to follow that path more and more, not just as some kind of little bit of entertainment in our life, but the very core of our life, and life after life. So this is the sense of developing a refuge in the Triple Gem that leads us to generate this refuge in our own Buddha nature, or the fundamental goodness and wisdom of our mind, and to become an inner being, train our mind to become an inner being, so that day by day, as our life progresses, we become less obsessed with the superficial and meaningless things of life and become more and more concerned and involved in a wise and compassionate way with those things which are really meaningful and beneficial. So this is what refuge is about. So it is the door to the path to liberation and enlightenment. Without that refuge, that strong conviction that there is a path, there is a final goal, and that there is a way to achieve it, and a conviction that myself, even though I am deluded, there is a way I can go beyond delusion and achieve this path, unless we have this refuge, we don’t even start the path.
So it’s essential to think about whole idea of what refuge is. Because as I’ve been saying all the lamas make this point, this is why I’m just copying them none of these ideas are original unfortunately we’ve been following the wrong refuges life after life, in worldly things and physical things, in completely deluded people, and even refuges in false teachings, and there are beings who, of course, have psychic powers and this and that, and we take refuge in them because they look impressive, they are superior to us, but are they really totally, fully developed? So it’s an important thing to think about in the spiritual life at the very beginning. This is why I’ve tried to mention it at the very beginning. Just as Lama Tsongkhapa did in his teaching on the path of enlightenment called the songs of experience.
So there are many, many things to talk about, the idea of Buddhist refuge, but maybe we’ll leave them now. And maybe I’ll just talk yeah, it’s a nice topic, but anyway, maybe we’ll leave it. I’ve always wanted to talk about this in lots of detail, but somehow the causes and conditions don’t arise, so therefore one can’t do it. So I just maybe, at the expense of maybe appearing like I’m trying to indoctrinate the new people here, to talk about the benefits of taking refuge, why we should take refuge in the Triple Gem, having thought about their qualities. So the first benefit is that one becomes an inner being, one enters the Buddhist path, in a sense, one becomes an inner being.
It is the way to as I said, there’s this tradition, once one takes refuge, one of the basic commitments when one formally takes refuge is to recite the prayer of taking refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha three times in the morning, three times at night. But the purpose of that is to remind ourselves, as Lama Yeshe used to say, to do refuge, to wake up as much as we can, to remind ourselves moment by moment that the external world is just an illusion, the happiness of the external world is an illusion, it’s impermanent, it’s unsatisfying. So when we take refuge or doing refuge, we’re reminding ourselves of that fact and reminding ourselves that there is this amazing garden of the mind to cultivate, and we can spend some time today cultivating that mind. So this is being an inner being, and every possible good result comes from that. But if we don’t take refuge, if we don’t do refuge, this process of becoming an inner being doesn’t take place.
So this is one of the great benefits. Another great benefit is that within the Buddhist system itself, is the basis, it’s an essential basis for taking vows. So, having taken refuge, there are many levels of vows that one can take. The first level are the pratimoksha vows, and these are the vows that act as the basis for achieving liberation, individual liberation liberating oneself from saṃsāra, achieving the state of nirvana, becoming an arhat. So there are different aspects of the pratimoksha vows.
The most basic ones are the five lay vows of not killing, stealing, lying, avoiding sexual misconduct, and avoiding taking any kind of intoxicants, including tobacco. So, by taking these vows, they act as a basis of purifying our mind, having a clear mind, and avoiding the worst kinds of negative karma. Other major so these are the five lay vows. Other major category of vows of individual liberation are the vows of monks and nuns. So there are the within that, the main category are the novice vows and the vows of a fully ordained monk or nun.
And in the Mahāyāna tradition, these vows are taken for life. In the Theravada tradition, lineage, one can take these monks’ vows for however long one likes, one can give them up at any time without any trouble. In the Mahāyāna tradition, or especially in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, these vows are taken for life. So one can only take these vows on the basis of refuge. And there’s a particular ceremony where one takes these vows, and if anyone has gone through this ceremony of sincerely taking these vows on the basis of refuge, and as I tried to say before, the essential refuge is, at our level, the Buddhadharma, and within the Buddhadharma the essential refuge is some understanding in the law of cause and effect, and the desire to follow it in our daily life.
So when one takes the vows on that basis, something does happen, it’s not just some empty thing. I always give the example, I can’t think of anything better, I’m happy to hear any later on, some better I’m sure there are better explanations, but at least in the West there’s the tradition of taking New Year resolutions, I am never ever again going to do this or that, and three days later, one’s completely forgotten. And maybe the explanation of why these vows don’t work so well, even though we call them vows in a sense, is because even though we sincerely want to avoid something, there isn’t some solid basis on which to place that vow. But when one has refuge, there is a solid, genuine basis. Taking these vows through a lineage that goes back in an unbroken succession to the Buddha.
So something happens, some blessing from the Buddha happens that enables us to do things that, as ordinary deluded people, we can’t do. It’s not totally magical because if we’re not careful, we can break them, it’s not like that, but there’s some little bit of magic in that, I think Buddha magic. So these are the basic vows of avoiding causing harm with body and speech. So these are the lay and the ordained pratimoksha vows of avoiding causing harm with body and speech. Then there are the bodhisattva vows that one can take, finally, within the Mahāyāna, there are the very special tantric teachings, the vajrayana, which is the teachings about how to practice the fast way to achieve enlightenment.
So this is something that the tantric
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- five lay vows panchashila (Skt); ge nyen gi dompa nga (Tib)
- The precepts taken by lay Buddhist practitioners for life: to abstain from killing, stealing, lying, sexual misconduct and taking intoxicants. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- inner being nangpa (Tib)
- Another term for a Buddhist, so called because the person has entered "inside" the teachings of the Buddha by taking heartfelt refuge in the Three Jewels... LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
- The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.