Karma — 2016-04-19

1 h 38 min · 4,410 words · 19 April 2016 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma — 2016-04-19
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 98-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche takes uncontrived definite emergence—the stable, spontaneous turning away from cyclic existence—as the key to understanding how a practitioner genuinely enters the Buddhist path. Using Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles as his template, he explores how recognizing the faults of cyclic existence naturally generates the wish for permanent rather than transitory happiness. He defines the path as sapience upheld by uncontrived definite emergence and explains entry onto the path of accumulation, then addresses the counterintuitive fact that beings on the path still experience suffering—which becomes fuel for liberation. The session includes extensive Q&A where students work through genuine confusions about the relationship between the thought of definite emergence and liberation, what prevents degeneration, and the paradox of a ‘self’ progressing toward selflessness. For practitioners with prior Lamrim study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2016-04-19 – KR.mp3

UUID: b3b39b2b-e96a-4711-a927-4e8b0eddd68a

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Karma

Date: 2016-04-19

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,405

As Je Tsongkhapa says in the preliminary verses of the three principles of the path, the meaning of the essence of the teachings of all the conquerors. This verse refers to the thought of definite emergence which is the very innermost essence of the teachings of all the conquerors. So here the thought of definite emergence does not refer to mere definite emergence but uncontrived definite emergence. And it is very helpful to use the three principles of the path as a template through which one understands the lamrim specifically to use the presentation of definite emergence in these three principles of the path. And the two verses in the three principles of the path turn away from the vanities of future lives to reflecting on the incontrovertibility of karma and suffering.

In a nutshell explain how to generate a definite emergence which strives for liberation. Now here liberation is the exact opposite of cyclic existence. In other words of our contaminated aggregates And it is through understanding the thoughts of these contaminated aggregates that one can generate this striving for liberation. Now once one is able to identify the faults of cyclic existence and this must apply to oneself, in other words, the faults of cyclic existence apply to one’s own contaminated aggregates, Then in turn, one will be able to strive for liberation to understanding clearly that the happiness which we experience in this life is a transitory happiness and that we should aim not for transitory but for durable or permanent happiness. Now a stable happiness is identified as liberation.

And therefore, through understanding the faults of cyclic existence, once we reach the point where even for one instant, as is said in the three principles of the path, we do not desire the marvels of cyclic existence, but instead, we strive continually for a permanent state of happiness which is none other than liberation. As I said in the three principles of the path, striving day and night without cease for liberation at that point, definite emergence would have been well generated. Then such a definite emergence when it becomes an unfabricated definite emergence is uncontrived definite emergence. So this is what is meant by an uncontrived definite emergence or an uncontrived mind striving for liberation. Now Chris, what’s the definition of a path?

Do Do we understand? And the hero? And Maggie? Everyone can give it. That’s the way it should be.

Can you all give the definition? Alright, alright. That’s fine. Thank you. Now in the definition of a path, sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence.

Definite emergence has been explained, a thought of definite emergence has been explained. An uncontrived thought of definite emergence has been explained. And the verb or the past participle upheld here means simply that this sapience arises in dependence upon this uncontrived thought of definite emergence. It is in other words, its object of attainment. It is what it enables one to attain.

So in the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. It is through this repeated familiarization with the thought of definite emergence that eventually it becomes uncontrived. And at this point, it gives rise to a virtuous mind or a virtuous consciousness. Now this is a critical point. And once this has happened, one will have entered the path.

Now where precisely does one enter the path within the five paths? The path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and normal learning. One does not enter in any which place. One enters precisely at the level of the path of accumulation. So one will have entered the path of accumulation.

And here we shall not enter in the distinction between the three paths of accumulation, the path of accumulation of hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas. We shall just consider one has entered the path of accumulation. Now what precisely is meant by the path of accumulation? What is meant by that, it is called a path of accumulation because one will have engaged or one will engage in the accumulations on the basis of a mind which is upheld by definite emergence. Now this is not to say that before entering the path one will not engage in accumulations which train in liberation.

So therefore, once one has generated a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, one will have entered the path. And at this point, one will have entered the path at the level of the path of accumulation. One will be a person of the path of accumulation or one of the path of accumulation. So in Tibet. So at this point one has to give an instance or an example of a path of accumulation.

And one or a consciousness which understands what is to be appropriated and what is to be relinquished within the four noble truths would be a good example. Then whether a mind of generosity or ethics would be a good example or not, that is something which has to be examined very carefully. Likewise, would a mind of refuge be a good instance or not, that has to be examined carefully. So at present, there are some delicate points. Specifically, Once one has generated a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence or once one has generated that uncontrived definite emergence.

In other words, stable definite emergence is degeneration from that state possible. Then if one examines the scriptures, there is no degeneration from that state possible because the mind of definite emergence has been stably generated. Now the situation is somewhat different for the generation of bodhicitta or the generation of the mind of the Mahāyāna. It is possible at the level of the path of accumulation of a bodhisattva to degenerate from that path of accumulation of a bodhisattva. But if one degenerates from the path of accumulation of a bodhisattva, what does one fall down to?

One falls down to the path of a hearer because one does not degenerate from the generation of definite emergence. So this calls for careful analysis. There are some beings who even though they have initially trained in bodhicitta find the concept very heavy and difficult to handle and degenerate to the path of a hearer. So there are numerous debates about this in the great monasteries. These are difficult topics.

One thing is clear, there is no degeneration from the path. Then you might think while having entered the path, one must be in a state of permanent bliss. Not at all. Beings who have entered the path are in cyclic existence like us. The difference is that whatever difficulties they experience become the motor for an ever more powerful wish to attain liberation.

It acts as fuel for the wish to attain liberation. This misunderstanding that somehow once one has entered the path, one is suffused with bliss is quite widespread. Beings who have entered the path experience great suffering, but this suffering acts as a motor for liberation. Now in the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, when we say that the sapience is upheld, what do we mean by upheld? We mean that the sapience has fallen under the power, under the sway of uncontrived definite emergence.

You know what this means, we speak of being under the power or the sway of bodhicitta or under the power or the sway of the afflictions, of desire, of anger. We all have experienced of falling under the sway of anger. So this is a meaning of being upheld. One is upheld by, in this case uncontrived definite emergence because one is under the power of it. Then this term upheld, Zin in Tibetan, the past tense of is one which is sometimes difficult for us to understand.

It simply means that one has fallen under the sway or under the power of definite emergence. Now we can understand what it means if we reflect on what happens to us when we fall under the sway or under the power of great anger. Now, in the definition of a path, sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. When we analyze the terms a sapience which is upheld, as we said, this means a sapience which is under the power or under the sway of uncontrived definite emergence. Now this sapience is a virtuous mind, a virtuous consciousness and we might wonder why it is a virtuous consciousness.

Sapience in general is an actor. An actor engages in action. Here the actions of sapiens are exclusively virtuous. What are they? They exclusively are an understanding of the four noble truths in the forwards and the reverse sequence.

So you can therefore clearly understand that the sapience is a virtuous mind because it engages in virtuous deeds and these virtuous deeds are an understanding of what is to be appropriate, appropriated and what is to be relinquished within the four noble truths. In other words, how to engage. So in our own minds, there are probably virtuous states of mind. Now, activity of these states of mind, that is something we have to investigate. They might be focused on the Triple Gem, they might be focused on causality, they might also be focused on the four noble truths, what is to be appropriated and what is to be relinquished within the four noble truths.

So one might wonder why in the definition of the path which is a sapience upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, the object of the sapience should be the four noble truths and it is simply because the motivation or that which upholds the sapience is none other than a mind striving for liberation. A stable mind striving for liberation. Now you can see how the definition of the path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence becomes an extremely weighty topic. Specifically when we refer to a sapience here, this sapience is engaged in an activity which is none other than focusing on the mode of abiding of the four truths. In other words, what is happening is that a mind striving for liberation ascertains its object.

And for a mind striving for liberation, the object which is ascertained would be none other than the four noble truths. Then if you understand sapience as a virtuous mind or consciousness, your understanding will deepen. Now, we, when we generate definite emergence, this is none other than a mind striving for liberation. And one has to therefore analyze and identify its object of attainment that which is striven for. What is liberation?

Does liberation exist or not? Obviously it does. However, it calls for great effort to attain it, so we must investigate this carefully. And even if we are unable to attain it in one lifetime, then over time we will. So when we speak of liberation, obviously liberation is the abandonment of the afflictions.

But that in and of itself doesn’t give us a real understanding of liberation. What we need is a special feeling about liberation which goes beyond just the verbal statement, liberation is an abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions, liberation is an abandonment which is an abandonment of cyclic existence. So liberation is none other than an abandonment which is an abandonment of cyclic existence. It is none other than an abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions. But what precisely is the root of these afflictions?

Its root is the ignorance apprehending a self. Once we are able to abandon the ignorance apprehending a self, we will have attained liberation and the afflictions will no longer arise. In as much as anger arises, in dependence on the ignorance apprehending self, having abandoned the former anger will no longer arise. Let us now therefore meditate during a couple of minutes on the meaning of the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. And let us investigate during these couple of minutes whether liberation exists or not.

If we generate a strong sense that liberation exists, this is a very great achievement. Thank you, lady, for your work. No. No. That’s okay.

Please open the prayer book, page one. One b, two, three, four, and page five, number six, manner of faith, verse one and three. So I will take your questions at present, one or two questions. Geshe-la, I was, puzzled last week and I’ve gone away and thought about it and I’m still puzzled. You said on Tuesday and Wednesday a few times that renunciation was none other than liberation, and I just can’t see how definite emergent renunciation is the same as liberation.

So the reason for which definite emergence is liberation is to be understood as follows. Within the 14 characteristics of the four noble truths, if we take the third noble truths, the noble truths of cessation, its four characteristics are cessation, peace, sublimity and definite emergence. Now the characteristics of the noble truth of cessation are the noble truth of cessation. Therefore, definite emergence is the noble truth of cessation. And the meaning of the syllables definite emergence, in Tibetan, definite means that one has permanently or durably emerged and means to emerge.

Therefore, when in the three principles of the path, Je Tsongkhapa says, hence initially seek definite emergence. He is not referring to the definite emergence which is liberation but the thought of definite emergence. This is what one should strive to generate. I repeat? Yeah, realise that it’s one of the characteristics of the third noble truth But it seems and even tonight, you said it’s definite emergence is the mind striving for liberation.

And it seems every definition I’ve ever seen and last year we learned that, for example, definite emergence is the gateway to the path of the being, the path shared with the being of middling scope, whereas the object of attainment is liberation. And it always seems that definite emergence is the striving or the wish or the awakening I found. I even looked the word up in Tibetan. But liberation is the actual achieving it. So I’m puzzled that the two terms can be synonymous.

I think I would encourage you to read the Lamrim in depth and then this distinction between the thought of definite emergence and definite emergence which is liberation will become clearer. It was said that an uncontrived thought of definite emergence cannot degenerate, but it is not until the level of forbearance on the path of preparation that a being is free from the possibility of rebirth in lower realms. So this seems to leave open the possibility that we could encounter a dog that is on the path. Is that possible? It’s a good doubt.

But we don’t say So it’s a good question. What is important to be understood is that once one has entered the path, one no longer accumulates that type of non virtuous karma. The karma which can mature before one has attained the level of forbearance of the path of preparation to precipitate a lower rebirth is karma which was accumulated in previous lives. Now whether one could or not in dependence on such karma be reborn as an animal is open to question since animals have limited understanding. Definitely, one could be reborn as a hell being, but hell beings have generally clear intelligence.

Yeah. I just thought it could explain the virtuous behavior of some animals that we see. Yes, your question is once one is reborn in the lower realms, let’s say there’s an animal after having entered the path, would one be an animal which has entered the path? And the answer is yes, one would be an animal which has entered the path, but there would be no benefit because one would be overwhelmed by one’s condition. And just one other question.

This might be a bit off topic, but my question is on the path of definite emergence or renunciation and aim to achieve liberation. I guess in the four noble truths of suffering, it’s because of ignorance of our thoughts of our self. And then once we’ve realized that there’s no self, that we’ve become liberated. I guess the question is from all that, then who is on the journey or what is on the journey from the self to the selfless? So when we speak of selflessness in Buddhism, we do not say that the ordinary I does not exist.

We do not say that the experiencer or the accumulator of karma and the experiencer of the fruition of karma does not exist. What we say is that a certain mistaken apprehension of the self is to be eliminated. So all of us have deep within ourselves this sense of self or of I, it is something we all experience, we have a sensation of this. Now the mode of presentation of the I differs in the various schools of Buddhist tenets. The schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Mādhyamika downwards, because we have this deep sense of self or I within ourselves, identify the I or the self with the mental consciousness.

On the other hand, Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika considers that there is no I or self in this sense, and that the I and the self is a mere conceptual or nominal imputation out there. Now this is something we can only understand through a lot of reflection. And another? Yeah. What does it mean that a sapience is an actor?

So sapience is a knowledge or an understanding. Now as a knowledge or an understanding, it understands something. It therefore is the actor which performs the act of understanding that something. Would the definition of path be damaged if we just said sapience of uncontrived definite emergence rather than upheld. And there is a problem in Tibetan grammar because the, and you have done some Tibetan so you’ll understand.

Is an instrumental. Then it is inappropriate for the instrumental in this case to become the agent of the verb to know. What problem does Zin pa upheld cause for you? The sapience is essentially referring to a wisdom of uncontrived renunciation. So it just seems in English a bit of a You want to change the instrumental to genitive as well.

Give him the finger he takes This term upheld, Zin pa, is a very profound term. If we just limit ourselves to vocabulary and linguistics, we would not plumb the depths. We have to look carefully at its meaning in terms of the four noble truths. Do you at present have a good understanding of what is upheld by an uncontrived sort of definite emergence and a sapience or not? Lily doesn’t understand.

Anyone else? I don’t understand. Okay, another. Is sapience a person, is that what you’re asking? Yes.

Sapiens is a subject. It’s an actor. So naturally, this sapience is a virtuous mind but there are numerous virtuous minds. This specific virtuous mind is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence and what this means is that this specific virtuous mind, the sapience is a subject whose object is the four noble truths. Now, in the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite renunciation.

An uncontrived thought of definite renunciation is in other words, first, a mind which is striving for liberation. And secondly, a mind which is striving for liberation spontaneously in an uncontrived fashion in the same way as we ourselves when we get up in the morning, automatically start thinking about preparing breakfast. When in the definition it is said that the sapience is upheld, upheld here means that the sapience is under the power or under the sway of a mind, an uncontrived mind of definite emergence. Being under the sway or under the power is best understood in terms of ourselves being under the sway or under the power of anger. Okay and another question?

Another, you’re asking second. You are also second. If I explain to my friend what is the path, if I say that it is a being that has uncontrolled renunciation, is this sufficient or not? It’s not appropriate. Because in the same way as in mundane terms when we speak of a path, we speak of the means to get somewhere.

Here when we speak of a path, a path is the means to get to a state, either the state of full enlightenment or the state of liberation. Persons are those who train in this path. They are those who walk if you wish on this path, they are not the path. The path or that which is walked upon and the walker are different. When we use the word stable for having obtained a stable state of definite emergence, then I’m assuming that that’s referring also to having attained calm abiding.

Would that be correct? You’re asking if to attain stable definite emergence, one must attain calm abiding first. It’s a good question. It is not necessary in my opinion to have calm abiding to attain uncontrived or stable renunciation. However, once one has attained calm abiding, it is much easier to obtain stable, uncontrived renunciation.

Hi Marco. To follow from the question that was asked behind me, is it appropriate to think that that which definitely emerges are purified aggregates and that which is definitely emerged from contaminated aggregates? No, we use the term contaminated aggregates for cyclic existence but we do not refer to liberation or the object of attainment of definite emergence as uncontaminated aggregates since it is just the truth of cessation. For easier understanding, can one use the words accompanied or conjoined instead of up held? What is the problem with upheld?

In English. I don’t see a problem, but you see a problem. The term Zin pa in Tibetan normally means grasped or apprehended. Then it doesn’t work at all in this context. So I translated it as upheld.

It is it means that the motivation is in the background. You can mentally translate it by grasped if you prefer. Zinpa, grasped or apprehended by. If there’s a relation, there’s a stanza in the foundation of all qualities in which the term is used. But don’t get hung up on terminology please and try to understand the meaning of a sapience which is upheld or whatever you want to choose translated by by uncontrived, a sort of uncontrived definite emergence.

I didn’t know whether I understand correctly. During the last session, definite emerges is we have to focus on the suffering as a motivation for to give rise to definite emergence. Is that correct? Yes, that is how one generates definite emergence. Through focusing on the suffering of cyclic existence, one generates sadness or depression and in dependence on this, one gives rise to definite emergence.

Lilli? Just a question about the word impelled. In the 12… sorry. In the 12… oh, no. Sorry.

In general, it said we’re impelled by karma and afflictions, karma and afflictions. We’re impelled into cyclic existence. Is that the same word, the Zin pa word? We use the verb impelled in Tibetan when we refer for instance to the afflictions being impelled or having arisen from self grasping, so for negative states of mind. Whereas here, upheld is used for positive, virtuous states of mind.

Maggie? Hold the microphone to your chair. Geshe-la, you’ve said that on the path, beings are in cyclic existence, but the difference is that the difficulties they experience acts as a fuel to obtain liberation. Now if beings are in cyclic existence, it must be necessary for them to have suffering due to cravings. Is it not possible for such beings to when they face difficulties to have this act as both a fuel to, you know, to want to attain liberation, but maybe possibly out of ignorance to have worldly desires or desires for vanities of this life.

To be in two minds, so to speak. Yes, there is desire and so forth in the minds of beings who have entered the path. However, even though there is desire within the minds of beings who have entered the path, it is not the sort of coarse desire which we find within our minds. The desire within our minds is a desire for the five sense objects. The desire which is present within the minds of beings which have entered the path is a more subtle form of desire.

And just one question, maybe you? I think, and there were. I just want clarification, please. Now it says that you said that Bodhisattva can degenerate from the path and then become Hinayanist. And then at one point you also said that there one thing is clear that there is no degeneration in the path.

Can you verify that for me, please? No, is no contradiction. It is not possible to degenerate from the path. However, it is possible to degenerate from having generated bodhicitta. There is a difference of scope or of breadth between the two.

If one degenerates from having generated bodhicitta, one has not degenerated from the past. One still has renunciation within one or definite emergence within one’s mind stream. It is just that one sees the path of the bodhisattvas as too difficult and one focuses on one’s own personal interest. Just to clarify, we’re doing definitions, but I think you said tonight, Geshe-la, that once definite emergence has been generated, it gives rise to a virtuous mind and then one has entered the path of accumulation. So I assume that’s not the thought of definite emergence, that is definite emergence and one enters the path, but one hasn’t achieved liberation at that point.

Is that correct? I’ll need to go home and chew over this. So once one has entered the path, there is no longer any degeneration of the sort of definite emergence which focuses on the faults of cyclic existence and one strives then for attaining definite emergence or liberation. Okay, I’ll stop here tonight. Thank you.

Please open the page nine. We recite eight, nine, ten, eleven, twelve.

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is it sufficient to explain to a friend that the path is a being who has uncontrolled renunciation?

No, it is not appropriate. In ordinary terms, a path is the means of getting somewhere. In the same way, in the Buddhist sense a path is the means to reach a state, either full enlightenment or liberation. Persons are those who train in the path. They are, so to speak, the ones who walk on it, but they are not the path itself. The path, which is what is walked upon, and the walker are different.

Scroll to Top