Emptiness — 2016-04-13

1 h 41 min · 4,288 words · 13 April 2016 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness — 2016-04-13
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 102-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche poses a direct challenge: if you accept the Mahāyāna, where is your bodhicitta? He establishes that bodhicitta—the determination to attain enlightenment for the sake of all beings—is the sole gateway to Mahāyāna practice, more fundamental than visualization, mantra, or tantric initiation. Using the seed analogy, bodhicitta is the uncommon cause of full enlightenment (a barley seed produces only barley), while wisdom realizing emptiness is shared with lower vehicles. He explains bodhicitta as a mental transformation where one’s mind becomes wholly oriented toward others, rooted in great compassion, which arises from renunciation. Rinpoche traces the progression: how renunciation of the small scope differs from fully characterized renunciation of the middling scope, and how the latter naturally unfolds into compassion and bodhicitta. Extended Q&A clarifies these connections and addresses why Hīnayāna practitioners do not develop bodhicitta despite practicing renunciation.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2016-04-13 – KR.mp3

UUID: 8c01c371-611b-48c5-8649-eb0359c52ecb

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Date: 2016-04-13

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,292

So the third path, the path of the being of the great scope has three outlines. The first is that the outline which indicates that the mind of bodhicitta is the only gateway for entry in the Mahāyāna. The second is the mode of generating bodhicitta. And the third is the mode of training in behavior upon having generated bodhicitta. So regarding the first outline, teaching that bodhicitta is the only gateway for entry in the Mahāyāna.

What is meant here by gateway is just that the presence or the absence of bodhicitta within one’s continuum is a criterion of whether that person is a Mahāyāna being or not. In the Buddhist treatises, when one refers to the state of Buddhahood, this is the exclusive goal of the Mahāyāna being and therefore bodhicitta is the uncommon cause of such a result. That bodhicitta is the sole cause of full enlightenment is evident. It is clear that the realization of emptiness alone is not a cause, an exclusive cause of full enlightenment. For that matter, practices such as a practice of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance, of enthusiasm and so forth are shared with the lower vehicle.

This is why our precious teacher, Kirti Tsenshab Rinpoche, in keeping with the lineage which goes back to Śāntideva always said hold bodhicitta as your foremost pleasure. So I would imagine most of you in this room accept the Mahāyāna. Many, if not most of you have received advanced tantric initiations, recite mantras and so forth. But these advanced tantric initiations, they arise from an understanding of bodhicitta. Now ideally, one will have generated an uncontrived experience of bodhicitta.

If one has not generated that, then one should have generated a contrived experience of bodhicitta and if that is not present, at least one should think about bodhicitta. And since we are theoretically people who accept the Mahāyāna, then there is food for thought regarding bodhicitta much more in a sense than regarding the four noble truths. As I explained last time, empathy is present within our mind stream. Then what has to be done is to extend this empathy far beyond its limited scope to as many others as possible. Then eventually we will give rise to bodhicitta.

Then if someone were to ask us what do you mean when you say you practice Mahāyāna Dharma, Then we might unfortunately answer things like I visualize deities and so forth. And at that point really our statements will be devoid of meaning. There is a very great risk of this. And the answer to this is given in the first outline of the subdivision of the path of the being of the great scope. When in the Lamrim the question is asked, what is it which makes Mahāyāna Dharma?

Answer is, it is only bodhicitta which makes Mahāyāna Dharma. bodhicitta is the uncommon cause whose uncommon result is full enlightenment. The wisdom realizing emptiness is shared with hearers and solitary realizers. Then I suspect you probably do have enough time to read through the Lamrims which are translated in English and specifically through the section on the great vehicle and on the advantages of bodhicitta. This is really very beautiful and it is very important.

Then to gain an understanding of emptiness is very difficult. Even if we study the great text over and again, this understanding may elude us and to change our mind in the light of our understanding of emptiness is even more difficult. This is not the case with bodhicitta since as I mentioned, the seeds of bodhicitta are present within our mind stream. Then, what is bodhicitta? bodhicitta, the uncontrived experience of bodhicitta means that one’s mind is under the power of others.

Now what does this mean? We know clearly that most of the mental difficulties we experience, we experience through our interaction with others. Now when our mind is under the power of others, when everything we do is for others, then there is no difficulty which can come from others since we are so close to them. Now for one’s mind to be under the sway, under the power of others, does not mean that one goes around engaging in constant charitable deeds like taking meals or bringing meals to others and so forth, that’s a very coarse understanding of the phenomenon. It’s a mental transformation which is required.

There is no specific discussion in the context of bodhicitta of past and future lives. It is a practice we should engage in continually. And this is why Je Tsongkhapa in his canonical visualization, the concise Lamrim says, hence the heroic sons of the victors take bodhicitta as their perpetual pledge or oath. Now what this means is that the heroic sons of the victors, bodhisattvas are constantly engaged in altruistic action and here oath or pledge to Tibetan refers to none other than one’s core practice. Do you understand?

Do you understand? So please focus on what is said and then understanding will arise easily. Then bodhicitta is not a difficult topic to reflect upon or to understand to the difference let’s say of the 16 characteristics of the four noble truths or let’s say coarse and subtle selflessness of persons which are difficult, arduous topics. So this is why we should reflect on it. Then in this world of us, there are beings who are exclusively focused on the welfare of others.

Whether they are in actuality bodhisattvas or not, we cannot say but beings such as Mahatma Gandhi or such as Nelson Mandela or such as His Holiness the Dalai Lama. Then emptiness is another matter altogether that is the uncommon seal of Buddhism. Now whether these beings who train in altruism are actually training in emptiness and are not, that is another story. Then even though we say that emptiness is very important and it is important to reflect on it, nonetheless it is very difficult to do so. Then people when they stay on retreat, spend retreat, in retreat months or years on Yamāntaka, on Vajrayoginī, on Hayagrīva, on Heruka but I always find it very strange that you never hear of someone doing long retreats on renunciation or on bodhicitta.

Then as is said in the Lamrim, ideally one would generate an uncontrived experience of bodhicitta. Then if that is not possible, which generate a contrived fabricated experience of bodhicitta. And if that is not possible at the very least, one should reflect on bodhicitta. And if one does this, then one will be familiar with the common or the shared path. Now to enter in some sort of strange tantric practice with no foundation in the Mahāyāna, this is very odd.

Then Geshe Kelsang Wangchuk would say to his students, you must do a retreat on definite emergence or renunciation or you must do a retreat on bodhicitta or you must do a retreat on the three principles of the path. That is what is important. So bodhicitta is the uncommon gateway into the Mahāyāna. It is also a state of mind whose uncommon result is full enlightenment and this can best be understood through the example given in the Lamrim of seeds which need as common causes to lead to a sprout, water, manure and warmth. But then we have the uncommon cause which gives rise to a specific seed.

So let us say seeds of barley, of wheat and of rice will only respectively give rise to barley, wheat and rice. They are the uncommon cause of their result. A seed of barley will never give rise to wheat nor will a seed of wheat ever give rise to barley. Then you can apply this example to the following theoretical construct. The wisdom which realizes emptiness can be the cause of the enlightenment of a hearer.

It can be the cause of the enlightenment of a solitary realizer, or it can be the cause of the enlightenment of a bodhisattva, full enlightenment. But bodhicitta can only be the cause of full enlightenment. It cannot be the cause of the enlightenment of a hearer or a solitary realizer. Then there are numerous advantages of bodhicitta. We shall not enter in them in detail.

I would like to encourage you to read the explanation of the 10 advantages of bodhicitta explained in Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand. I know you are busy, but I don’t think you are that busy that it is impossible to read the Lamrim a bit. The presence or the absence of bodhicitta within our own mind stream is the criterion of whether or not the practice we engage in is Mahāyāna. If bodhicitta is present within our mindstream, our practice is Mahāyāna. If bodhicitta is absent in our mindstream, how could our practice be Mahāyāna?

It is not through listening or studying Mahāyāna treatises alone that our practice becomes Mahāyāna. Then we speak frequently of calm abiding or of the paranormal powers. Then obviously if one has the paranormal powers, they are only of benefit if one can use them. But in comparison with this, when we think of the benefits of bodhicitta, they are far superior. bodhicitta presents benefits both ultimately and in the short term both for oneself and for others.

Now the cause of bodhicitta as is asserted in Maitreya’s Uttaratantra is compassion. I say its cause is compassion. And this is therefore what we should train in. And this is why the Lamrim says it is not sufficient for the dharma to be a Mahāyāna dharma. The being must be a Mahayanaist.

And for the being to be a Mahayanaist, bodhicitta must be present in his or her mind stream. So now you understand the criteria for being a Mahāyānist or a Mahāyāna practitioner, but what is important is to understand also the difference between a Mahāyānist and a Hinayanist. What is that difference? Could you answer? So the answer is what is the difference between a Mahāyāna and a Hīnayāna practitioner?

Simply the presence or the absence of bodhicitta as was explained. If bodhicitta is present within the continuum, the being is a Mahāyāna practitioner. This is really important. This is something we should understand. Now what is the difference between a Mahāyāna practitioner and a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets?

You do understand that if someone is a propounder of Mahāyāna tenets, he is not necessarily a Mahāyāna practitioner. What example do you give? Is there a difference and if so, what is it between a Hīnayāna practitioner and a propounder of Hīnayāna tenets? Yes. And moreover, I think before.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. Pratyekabuddha. Yes, such being to exist. So it’s important to be able to make these distinctions otherwise we get confused. So the uncommon cause of bodhicitta is great compassion.

And if we seek for the cause of great compassion, it is definite emergence or renunciation. So this is the connection between the path shared with the being of the middling scope and the path of the being of the great scope. Since definite emergence or renunciation is the topic, the main topic of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Therefore, when we meditate and engage for instance in an overview meditation of the Lamrim, this is how we proceed. We understand that great compassion is the uncommon cause of bodhicitta and when we investigate what the cause of great compassion is, we find that it is definite emergence or renunciation.

And therefore, it is definite emergence or renunciation which leads into great compassion and this is the boundary between the path of the being of the middling and of the great scope. And therefore, a fully characterized definite emergence, in other words, uncontrived definite emergence is not just a mind which is striving for oneself alone for liberation, it is a mind striving for oneself for liberation. And this mind striving for oneself for liberation can be extended to others. When it is extended to others, it leads to great compassion. It’s somewhat easier to proceed backwards from the Mahāyāna to the Hīnayāna.

Now when we investigate the foundation of definite emergence or renunciation, we find that its foundation lies in the four noble truths which are the uncommon component of the Buddhist teachings. We cannot say that for instance, the empathy which down the line may give rise to bodhicitta is an uncommon component of Buddhist teachings which is shared with other religious traditions. So clearly the uncommon component of the path of the being of the great scope is bodhicitta and the uncommon component of the path of the being of the small scope is reflection on death and impermanence. Then if we look at the specific uncommon component of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, it would have to be the presentation of the four noble truths and this is also in a certain sense the foundation of the Buddhist teachings. So I think you do have time to engage in these investigations and if you don’t, perhaps you should make time.

Then what precisely is the uncommon characteristic or the uncommon feature of Buddhist thought. It is the four noble truths. And then if we ask the fundamental question, what is the difference between Buddhist and non-Buddhist tenets? Then I personally feel this is something one should investigate for oneself carefully. Then when we say we should reflect on the four noble truths, really we should focus on the latter two of the four noble truths, the noble truths of cessation and of the path.

The noble truth of cessation is liberation. The noble truth of the path are the means to attain liberation and here one should investigate carefully whether the noble truth of cessation exists or not and if it exists, what it is. One must identify what liberation is, what the noble truth of cessation is. Otherwise, it is nonsensical to strive for something one does not understand. Since all of us are beings who are striving for liberation, who are striving for utter freedom, it is important for us to understand what this liberation we strive for is.

It is an abandonment of the afflictions. Now, what is an abandonment of the afflictions and by what means are the afflictions abandoned? What are the antidotes to the afflictions? This is what we should investigate. So once uncontrived renunciation has been generated within the mind stream, one has gained the realizations of the path shared with the being of the middling scope.

Now generally speaking, the presentation of the downwards or reverse generation from bodhicitta to its cause, great compassion, and from great compassion to its cause, uncontrived definite emergence is more straightforward than the presentation in the forward sequence. Because obviously one must analyze very carefully how after having generated uncontrived definite emergence, the transition to the Mahāyāna occurs. This mode of transition must be examined. So let us now meditate for a couple of minutes on the advantages, the potency of the generation of bodhicitta within our mind stream. [Recitation instructions]

So, listen carefully, I have a question for you. Give me an example or an instance of a path of the being of the middling scope. A person who is a practitioner of the path of the being of the middling scope. So my apologies, I mistranslated. Geshe-la wants a path of the being of the middling scope.

An example of a path of the being of the middling scope. Then probably, the practices of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance, of enthusiasm, of concentration within the continuum of a being who has generated uncontrived, in other words, unfabricated renunciation would all qualify. So then since to generate bodhicitta, one must generate its uncommon cause which is great compassion. And since in turn great compassion is rooted in uncontrived renunciation of which we have no direct experience, it is rather difficult for us to understand this process. Then it would be rather nice if we generated this within our mind stream one day.

Otherwise, this is akin as Tibetan say to trying to eat Momo’s in a mirror. And then, when such a being has generated for the first time uncontrived renunciation, then in dependence on uncontrived renunciation, the realizations of the path of the being of the middling scope arise. At this point, through having received in the past instructions on bodhicitta and through having received advice from the spiritual friend, it is possible to then effect the transition to the Mahāyāna. So once after reflecting on the sufferings of one’s aggregates and within the sufferings, the foremost sufferings are mental. That which causes the greatest hardship to us is mental sufferings.

This is not to deny the existence of physical sufferings, but they are subsidiary. Once one has generated a profound realization of the suffering nature of the aggregates, the wish to be freed from this suffering arises. At this point, when one extends this wish to be freed from the suffering of one’s own aggregates to all beings who are similar to us in experiencing also the suffering of the aggregates, one will have generated great compassion. Since great compassion is none other than the wish, why would it be inappropriate for all sentient beings to be freed from suffering and the causes of suffering? That’s it, right?

So once one has generated within oneself that wish to be freed from the suffering of the aggregates and specifically to eliminate mental suffering, one in turn will be able to help others who experience mental suffering. Now clearly this is not to say that physical suffering is unimportant but one may or may not be in the position to be able to give material goods to another person which would alleviate their physical suffering. Now regarding the mode of generation of great compassion, there are two different modes of generation. The first is in dependence on the sevenfold cause and effect or causal instruction and the second is the instruction of the interchange of self and others. Then we shall stop here and at present, I will take your questions.

One question per person please and please make your questions concise, short. I think there’s a third method of generating bodhicitta. It is reflecting on the four immeasurables. Excuse me, could you repeat the beginning of your question? I think the third method to generate bodhicitta is The third method?

Method. Method, the third method. Yeah. It is reflecting on the four immeasurables. No, it is not possible to generate bodhicitta in dependence on the four immeasurables but the four immeasurables are included within the seven fold causal instruction for the generation of bodhicitta and the interchange of self and others.

Andre? I don’t really know how to phrase this question. It’s meditating on the faults of cyclic existence leads to definite emergence. How long, what do we need to do to develop definite emergence? How long and in what way do we focus in order to develop definite emergence?

So regarding your first question, how long it takes to generate renunciation, there is no definiteness. It depends on the person. It depends on the efforts the person makes. It depends on the prior habituation of the person. It can happen very quickly or it can take a very long time.

Now regarding the mode of generation of definite emergence, as I explained last time, it is reflecting on the faults of cyclic existence that eventually we give rise to this spontaneous, innate sense of revulsion towards cyclic existence and when this arises, this is uncontrived renunciation. I’m trying to understand the transition between somebody with uncontrived renunciation. Geshe-la taught that a being with uncontrived renunciation, having in the past received instructions on bodhicitta advice from a spiritual friend. If that is the case, how did Buddha Śākyamūni himself make that transition not having received any teachings on bodhicitta? So Buddha Śākyamūni relied on a teacher in the life in which Buddha Śākyamūni attained full enlightenment, he manifested the 12 deeds of a fully enlightened being, but he had generated bodhicitta and attained full enlightenment many lives before that.

It is said that to generate bodhicitta one must put great effort and reliance on the spiritual friend. Just need to clarify something because I’m I’m getting a bit confused tonight and I think also last night as well. Renunciation my understanding is that renunciation is the practice of being at the small scope and that definite emergence is the practice of being at the middling scope. But tonight I certainly heard I feel like I have heard that renunciation and definite emergence were interchangeable. For example, I wrote down earlier renunciation or definite emergence is the cause for great compassion.

So could Geshe-la please clarify that? And my second part to that question would be that if one develops uncontrived renunciation as a being of the small scope, could one also develop bodhicitta at that time as well? Definite emergence So renunciation and definite emergence are completely synonymous. There is something called renunciation of definite emergence at the level of the path of the being of the small scope but it is not a true definite emergence or renunciation. It is a mere definite emergence or renunciation.

True definite emergence is a path of the being of the middling scope. What is your second question? Okay, it may be a bit redundant but having had that answer, but if one does develop the mere renunciation of the being of the small scope, could one develop strong bodhicitta at that point. No, how could it be possible? No, it doesn’t exist.

And another? With that question that was raised, is there a difference between renunciation and uncontrived renunciation? Is renunciation part of the small scope and uncontrived? The link between the middling and the great scope. So, mere renunciation at the level of the path of the being of the small scope is turning away from the vanities of this life.

Special or fully characterized renunciation at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope is turning away from the vanities of all lives. In other words, striving for a liberation from all of cyclic existence. Now technically we must make a difference between definite emergence which is liberation and the sort of definite emergence which is wishing for liberation. Another. Amanda?

Why is with the middle scope and the Four Noble Truths, Why are the four noble truths called truths whereas in the great scope, it’s referred to as Mahāyāna mind? What would be the difference between truth and mind? So regarding the four noble truths, it’s strictly the four truths. These are called truths, denpa in Tibetan because it is through realizing the truth that one attains the object of attainment by means of a path of abandonment. Now regarding the mind of bodhicitta, it is called a mind within the context of the opposition between a main mind and mental factors.

That is why one is truth and the other a mind. Geshe-la, you said that renunciation is the cause of great compassion, that seemed clear, but I was thinking of a Śrāvaka and a Pratyekabuddha also need renunciation to attain liberation, but they don’t go on to develop great compassion. Is that a conscious decision on their part? Or is there something else at play? So basically the majority position is that there is no So there is no great compassion within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers because there is not an extension of definite emergence to all sentient beings.

As a result, great compassion does not arise. Sorry, I was wondering why isn’t that there that extension? Is it that the people on the Mahāyāna path work towards it and they consciously don’t want to? Basically because these are beings who from the beginning when they entered the path were focusing on attaining a liberation from their own suffering. Then as a result when they approach such a liberation there is no particular wish or interest in helping others.

Those are good questions. Yes, I can. I was just interested, Geshe said that the state of Buddhahood is the exclusive goal of the Mahāyāna. So with the Hinayanists, do they believe that liberation is Buddhahood, or do they think that there’s only one person that’s ever achieved Buddhahood, which being No, the hearers and solitary realizers accept the existence of the state of full enlightenment otherwise from whom would they have received teachings on liberation, but they themselves do not generate a wish to attain that state. Okay, just for you.

Thank you, Geshe-la. I can accept and I do understand that being of the small scope, practice, of turning away from the vanities of this life, does not lead to bodhicitta. But, I also have a doubt. I do really think that a being of the small scope who wishes for a higher rebirth, and that’s their main practice, is capable of doing that from a bodhicitta motivation that if they can have a higher rebirth the next lifetime, they’ll meet with the teachings, hopefully a perfect teacher, and be able to develop in the Dharma to be of benefit to all beings. So there are paths which are shared with the being of the small and the middling scope within the minds of Mahāyāna practitioners.

But these Mahāyāna practitioners, when they strive for a higher rebirth, do not strive principally for a higher rebirth. Okay. Let’s come here to net. [Recitation instructions — page nine].

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How long does it take to develop definite emergence (renunciation), and what is the way to generate it?

There is no fixed length of time for generating renunciation. It depends on the person, on the efforts the person makes, and on the person's prior habituation. It can happen very quickly or it can take a very long time. As for the way to generate definite emergence, one reflects on the faults of cyclic existence. Eventually this gives rise to a spontaneous, innate sense of revulsion towards cyclic existence. When this arises, it is uncontrived renunciation.

Why are the four noble truths called truths, while in the great scope bodhicitta is referred to as a Mahāyāna mind?

The four noble truths are strictly truths. They are called truths (denpa in Tibetan) because it is through realizing the truth that one attains the object of attainment by means of a path of abandonment. Bodhicitta, on the other hand, is called a mind within the context of the distinction between a main mind and mental factors. That is why one is called a truth and the other a mind.

Do hearers and solitary realizers (Hinayanists) believe liberation is Buddhahood, or that only one person has ever achieved Buddhahood?

No. Hearers and solitary realizers accept that the state of full enlightenment exists. If it did not, there would be no one from whom they could have received teachings on liberation. However, they themselves do not generate a wish to attain that state.

Scroll to Top