Karma – 2015-08-09 – KR

1 h 46 min · 12,941 words · 9 August 2015

Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma - 2015-08-09 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a symposium presentation on the twelve links of dependent arising, explaining each link through the Lamrim Chenmo and related commentaries, and relating them to embryological development. The talk covers the two-life and three-life models of how the links mature across lives, and uses a case of reincarnation to illustrate. Questions follow on animal rebirth, evolution, and when consciousness enters the fetus.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 47m

UUID: 2671de85-799a-47d5-b476-397ef30c7625

Date: 2015-08-09

Words: 12,937

Welcome back everybody. I hope you have enjoyed a nourishing lunch and we will continue to nourish our minds with the final presentation for this symposium with Ilya Djerovich. The topic being The 12 Links of Dependent Arising embryological and perceptual analysis which follows on beautifully from Jampa Inyan this morning. Thank you, Ilya. Thank you very much.

I’m sorry. You’re wired for sound, wired for video, and wired for coffee. So it makes for quite a combination. And I’m glad that so many of you have lasted until this afternoon. This is not an easy topic we are covering.

On the other hand, I think it’s really perhaps what is most useful for us at present. Then, Japanian gave an extremely sophisticated and clear presentation of the 12 limbs this morning and I thought I would continue by treating the topic. I will represent the 12 limbs again and then see if we can find sufficient evidence within Stevenson’s cases of the operation of karma and causality in the light of the 12 limbs. Then as I mentioned yesterday, while the evidence Stevenson uses for the existence of past and future lives is, in my opinion, strong, the evidence for the operativeness of karma is far less clear and we have to actually dig within the material to try to find it. I find it particularly interesting case which I will present to you today.

So generally speaking, dependent arising is divided into outer and inner dependent arising. Outer dependent arising refers to causality as it is understood presently in science and non quantum physics. Inner dependent arising refers to what we are interested in which is dependent arising within the context of the five contaminated aggregates. In other words, the 12 limbs. And I’ll draw for this presentation from a series of different works.

I will basically quote in a function of relevance. First and foremost, I would highly recommend Je Tsongkhapa’s section on the 12 limbs in his Lamrim Chenmo, the path of the being of the middling scope, the second part thereof. It is not his final statement and you will see that there are some points regarding the third limb of consciousness which he qualifies but it is extremely clear. Then I’ll also draw on the two root texts Vasubandu’s Abidhama Khosa and Asaṇga’s Abidhama Samuchaya, mainly the Abidhama Samuchaya end on a late Tibetan reading of the 12 limbs which is if you wish the canonical reading at Serraje monastery that of Jitsu Chikigilti. In addition to this, I have quoted from what is known as the fourfold interwoven commentary on Jetsongkopas Lamrim Cemu.

There are some short passages by one of Jetsongkopas disciples, Baso Chokyi Gyaltsen which qualify what Je Tsongkhapa says and you will find that this is quite relevant for what we do. So the 12 limbs can be presented in two completely different ways. A general presentation of the 12 limbs and the 12 limbs posited for one individual and one series of 12 limbs. So I shall initially give a general presentation which is shared with all the Buddhist traditions and then the difficulties arise when we try to posit it for one individual and one series of 12 limbs. In other words, when we try to posit the unfolding of a first limb ignorance on the basis of which the second limb compositional factors of karma is impacted into consciousness for one given karmic seed.

This is where one has to analyze quite carefully and my goal in this presentation will be to link this to some of the modern data we have from embryology which was not completely available to the Indian and Tibetan scholars. I will not be talking of the sūtra on the development of the embryo, the Garbhavakranti sūtra, which I quoted here in the past and which gives astonishingly accurate depictions of the development of the embryo simply because there isn’t time. So within the 12 links, the first is the link of ignorance traditionally represented by a blind man and this is one of the limbs regarding which there is considerable disagreement, specifically putting the view from Abhidharma aside for the time being, we have two main views those of Dharma Kirti and that of Asaṇga. I’d say the view of Asaṇga as expounded in Abhidharma Samuchaya is probably the most complete. For dharma kirti, in Pramanavarttikam, ignorance is merely ignorance of selflessness, ignorance of the view of the transitory composite.

This is a very restrictive understanding of ignorance. It is unclear whether we would be able to use the 12 links very significantly if we relied only on this view of Dharmakīrti. Asanga’s view is that ignorance is asserted as incompatible with the view. Now if we look a bit into the passage of Kamalavatika which is not terribly clear but you should be able to catch the drift. Dharmakirti says, regarding that here since the antidote, in other words the antidote to ignorance knowledge is knowledge of the authentic Yanda in Tibetan.

This is the object of the selflessness of persons. It’s antithesis, in other words, the antithesis of the antidote is the view of the transitory collections which apprehend a selfless persons. So this is a fairly clear statement that the ignorance referred to in this context is only that ignorance which apprehends a self of persons. Asaṇga’s viewpoint as understood by Je Tsongkhapa is far more sophisticated. From within the mistaken application of the view of the authentic and a mere confusion regarding the view of the authentic, the latter is asserted in brief from within wrong understanding in a mind which does not understand, a mind which does not understand is asserted.

And here specifically what Asaṇga implies is that there are two forms of ignorance or confusion, the first regarding causality and the second regarding suchness. And this is of considerable import since it is through the first that one can accumulate karma, in other words, compositional factors for rebirth in the lower realms and through the second the one accumulates comma for rebirth in the higher realms. So this enables a very complete presentation of the 12 links which is broadly speaking that adopted by the Kadampa Geshe Geshe Puchongwa who presented all three paths, path of the being of the small, middling and great scope in the light of the 12 links. Now, if we move onwards to the second, excuse me, first the definition of ignorance within the 12 limbs in keeping with Jyotunjugi Gjeltsin’s ancillary topics on perfection is a mental factor ignorant regarding suchness, which has become the motivation of projecting karma, which is subsumed within one series of dependent arising with itself. So ignorance like many of the limbs within the 12 limbs is a mental factor, but what is striking in Jitsu Shiggy Gertz’s definition is that he seems to side clearly with Dharma Kirti.

Then my personal sympathies do lie with Asanda on this topic but this is what the present. The projecting karma which is referred to Jitsynchukki Gelsen’s definition of ignorance is the second limb, traditionally symbolized by a potter at work. Karma is what constructs our experiential reality. Broadly speaking, karma can be subdivided into two projecting and completing karma. Projecting or impending karma is karma which impels a life.

Completing karma is karma which fleshes out that life, the events of that life. And projecting karma to make a very simple presentation can be divided into that projecting higher rebirth and that projecting lower rebirth. With that projecting higher rebirth divided between virtuous karma which projects a higher rebirth within the desire realm and immutable karma projecting a higher rebirth in the form or formless realms. Now the application of the 12 limbs to the form and formless realms is more complicated, we shall not enter into it today. We shall just be working within the context of rebirth within the desired realm.

Asaṇga defines composition of factors as what thoroughly subdivides sentient beings in terms of migrations and is the condition for the imprints of consciousness. In other words, it is compositional factors, comma, which defines the transmigration of sentient beings and the second component of Asaṇga’s definition is when we will find in all of the definitions in Abhidhamma Samuchaya, it is the causal link to the next limb, in this case the limb of consciousness. And unsurprisingly, just from Chikigitsa’s definitions which have the advantage of more than one thousand years over Asaṇga’s are somewhat more informative. For Kama is an intention which is a mental factor. Generally speaking intentions are always mental factors projecting later another existence which would have been projected by it and motivated by an ignorance which is subsumed within one series of dependent arising with that.

So here I highlighted the key elements, comma, excuse me, dependent arising, in other words, comma are an intention, they are here a mental factor and they project another existence. Then the second clause here merely indicates that this second limb of composition of factors is included within one cycle of 12 limbs, one specific cycle of 12 limbs. The destiny of a sentient being is composed of an almost infinite group of cycles of 12 limbs interwoven a little bit as the fabric of a tissue, as a piece of cloth on a loom. Then each of the limbs has to be linked to one of these cycles. So in this specific case, the second clause merely indicates that intention, let’s say in cycle k, is linked causally to ignorance in cycle K and also will give rise to the following link which is consciousness in cycle K and not some of the cycle.

So far so good? If I say k and n and n plus k, is everyone going to faint or Didn’t you accept it? Our following limb is consciousness, traditionally symbolized by a little monkey which says everything there is to say about the state of consciousness at present, scattered as monkeys. I don’t know if you’ve ever seen a monkey in a zoo, but they are not the most tranquil of animals. And as pointed out this morning, consciousness within the 12 limbs is understood by Chitamatra as the Alaya Vajnana and by all other schools as the mental consciousness.

Then probably in the context of Anuttara Yoga tantra, this would be what is known as a fundamental mind or nuxin. And it is within the third limb of consciousness that some specific problems of Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation of the 12 limbs arise. Problems which are basically occulted in the later on Schonastic tradition. Presents the limb of consciousness as subdivided into two, consciousness at the time of the cause and consciousness at the time of the effect. The consciousness at the time of the cause is the third limb in which the karmic imprint of the second limb is implanted.

But in addition, Je Tsongkhapa distinguishes consciousness at the time of the conception in the future lifetime, which would basically normally be included within the following limb of name and form. For Je Tsongkhapa, this is a subdivision of the third limb. It’s explicitly mentioned in Lamorem Chemo and yet strikingly enough, my apologies, you see you criticized Jetsonga but you get into trouble immediately. Strikingly, no mention is made at all of the subdivision in the Serraje monastic textbook. Then you might wonder, normally if something is not mentioned, it is either self evident or an abomination.

It seems to be the Tibetan states. What is striking is not only that Jetsh and Suki Gilsim does not mention it but there is one debate and debates are always with unnamed others which seems to refute this position. So it’s a very interesting case where between the composition of Lamrim Chenmo around 1402 if memory serves me well and Cicentrigi Gietze who was born around 1475 I think, ’74 and his composition of let’s say thirty years later, the stance within the Gelug tradition had shifted regarding the understanding of the third limb, the limb of consciousness. And indeed Jisinchuki Gilsson’s position is more coherent. It is really quite awkward to posit a subdivision of the third limb and to say that this subdivision includes an element connect with the fourth limb when the fourth limb as we will see is perfectly able to fulfill these functions by itself.

So Asaṇga used consciousness as the repository of karmic imprints, fetters of karma and the condition, in other words the cause for the subsequent limb of name and form. Now if we look at Jetsun Chokyi Gyaltsen’s definition of consciousness, you will see that no mention whatsoever is made of consciousness being present at the time of the next or the future rebirth just preceding the limb of name and form. For Jitsu Tsuki Gyirse, consciousness is a main mind. It is the only of the 12 limbs which is a main mind, which is oriented by the imprint of the projecting karma. So it is not just any consciousness, it is a consciousness which is affected by the impelling karma.

The following limb, name and form, is traditionally represented by a coracle or a small vessel. It’s a vessel if you wish of consciousness. Then name and form technically would be a non associated compositional phenomena since it includes both form and consciousness for beings of the desire realm certainly. It includes the form aggregate, in other words the body from the instant of conception and it includes four mental aggregates, which Japainian explained this morning, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors which Japainian calls formations and consciousness. Then I have skipped Asaṇga’s definition which is not terribly informative, but Jitsyn Chikki Gensen’s definition is.

For Jitsyn Chuki Gelsen, name and form is a thoroughly afflicted dependent arising, in other words, it’s dependent arising which has arisen as a result of karma and clashing. It’s a projected effect of the previous limb. The previous limb is obviously the limb of compositional factors consciousness and it has been upheld just after conception. Now this is a very interesting point in debate since frankly it is difficult to understand what Jitsuki Gilles said means by just after. Since the entry of consciousness into the union of what Tibetans call the blood and the fluid occurs at the very instant of conception.

So it leads to some rather nice debates. Now if we look at what all of this might mean in terms of what we know nowadays about the development of the embryo, broadly speaking, the limb of name and form extends from the very instant of conception when the spermatozoa second dates the egg, all the way up to approximately the level of development of the fetus at four weeks at a point at which none of the exterior sensory organs are still developed. Then it’s not that easy to get these pictures and the timing is still tentative so it might be the fifth or the sixth week but as far as I know it is broadly speaking up to the fourth week. And in this context, it is germane to mention the four types of births which Jabainye mentioned this morning, birth through heat and moisture, egg, womb and miraculous birth. The ones which interest us are the three first.

Birth through heat and moisture, Drechek, is just an ancient presentation, if you wish, of mitosis, miosis and partition. Since microscopes were basically unavailable at the period, this type of reproduction which can be either asexual or sexual, you know, was not fully understood. We have a better understanding now of what is happening but our understanding in no way invalidates the existence of birth through heat and moisture. Then birth to an egg is oviparian, birth non mammalian birth and birth to a womb is mammalian sexual reproduction. Miraculous birth is not recognized by modern biology and broadly speaking does not concern us in a study of the 12 limbs.

The following limb, the sixth loci Shadayatana basically refers to the point at which the sense organs have been formed in embryological development. Basil Chukki Giltsen gives an interesting analysis of the etymology of both sense organs and what I have chosen to call Lochai. The six sense powers are called powers, one go in Tibetan, because they are the masters of consciousness or its condition. Now this is something which has been very clearly pointed out by Geshe Jahmagir Tsai here during the teachings, which is that for ordinary beings like ourselves, our mind is totally controlled by sense input. It is the rare practitioner who is able to decouple his mind from sensory input and this is why the famous experiment in which a blank, a handgun loaded with blanks was detonated next to the ear of a western Buddhist monk who later turns out to have been Matthieu Ricard, while his brain function was being inspected by fMRI and the brain activity showed no reaction whatsoever to the detonation is a clear indication that we are dealing with an excellent meditator.

This is someone who is able to shut down sensory consciousness. Whether this indicates that he has actually attained calm abiding or not, I cannot say, but one of the signs of calm abiding, this was a case with the late Gishiraptan, is a capacity to totally shut down sensory consciousness. One is impervious and we sense any sensory input including pain. Now the definition of the six loci according to Gisen Chukki Gilsi is as mentioned in the previous limb, a thoroughly afflicted depolarizing, in other words, a limb which arises through karma and klesia, which is a projected effect and is a simile of the completion of the six senses. Now the six senses are the visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory, tactile and mental sense.

So since this definition mentions the six senses, it implies that the mental sense is not complete at the level of name and form. It is only complete from the level of the six loci onwards, and the trans similarly indicates that it is complete enough without being totally complete to the degree of being able to exercise its function. And the key point in this definition is the final three lines in red at the level of the six loci, the being is unable to enjoy the arising of the object to the conflation of object, sense, organ and consciousness. Now from a Buddhist standpoint, in my own case, I would take a great object of enjoyment which is a cup of coffee. I wish I could share it to you, but there’s only that much coffee to go around.

I am at present visually enjoying the cup of coffee through the conflation of my eye consciousness which sees the cup of cup of My visual organ which in this case would, I’d say from a contemporary standpoint be the retina, this fits very much with the definitions in Lorico Abidharma and the object itself which is the form and the shape of the cup of coffee. Now these three conflate, in other words, they get together and on this basis, visually, I experience the enjoyment of the anticipation of drinking coffee. Then when I taste coffee, we have the conflation of three objects. The consciousness, the gustatory consciousness, the gustatory organ which is within the tongue, which is probably a set of nerve endings, and the various elements in the coffee which induce taste, tartness, sweetness, etcetera. What happens at the level of the six loci is that this enjoyment is not yet possible.

The sense organs are de facto complete but it is not yet possible for them to be fully operational and this corresponds to the level of the fetus at approximately 16 of age. You can see here a very clear difference between the six loci and, my apologies, yes, and name and form. At the level of name and form, approximately four weeks, you basically cannot see any sense organ. There are tentative signs of an eye sense organ and that’s about it. Clearly at the level of the six loci around 16, the sense organs are almost completely filled.

We can speak of a simile of the sense organs. And therefore, the difference between the limb of name and form and the limb of the sixth loci is very clearly stated by Jitsongarpa. When the limb of name and form is established, one has a material nature, a physical nature. One is if you wish in a form aggregate whereas when the limb of the sixth loci is established, the enjoyer is established. Enjoyment is not yet experienced.

Do you understand the difference? It’s astonishingly subtle for an analysis of embryological development twenty five centuries ago. So what is the process of development of the body and the enjoyer? And here I will rely on some of the caveats Basso Chugi Gilti gives in the fourfold interwoven commentary on Lamrim Chenmo. Name and form establishes physicality.

The sixth loci establish the features of the body and the enjoyer is actually complete two limbs later at the level of, well this should actually be right here, at the level of the limb of sensation. It is at this point that we can say that the enjoyer is performing his function of enjoyment. And therefore, we still need to present the limb of contact, spachen. So contact occurs when these three objects, consciousness, let’s say a visual consciousness, a visual object form and shape, color and shape, and a sense organ are basically put together and it is the entering, in other words the beginning of the enjoyment of objects. So Jasun Shuki Gehitsen defines contact as a projected effect, indeed it’s a projected effect of the second limb of that given cycle of 12 limbs, which is upheld after being able to enjoy the arising of the object through the conflation of objects, sense, organ and consciousness, and which abides in the type of contingent aggregates which are able to know the causes of happy suffering and neutral sensations.

Contact occurs precisely at this point, I would say, in fetal development around the twentieth week. You have here a beautiful image of tactile contact, the enjoyment of the sensation of the thumb, a prelude to the enjoyment of the sensation of the mother’s nipple. And one of the biggest problems in the 12 limbs is to clearly differentiate a series of central limbs. The fourth limb, name and form, the fifth limb, the sixth lobe child, the sixth limb contact and the seventh limb sensation. It’s one of the most difficult problems in a sound presentation of the 12 limbs.

The rest is pretty straightforward. Especially a distinction between contact and sensation is not easy. Then sensation is typically symbolized by a man whose eyes and sense organs have been pierced by arrows since organs lead to suffering. Jitsyn Shugi Girtsen defines it as a mental factor, generally speaking sensations are all mental factors, which is the intersection of that as well, in other words a projecting effect as previously mentioned. But the key point here is in the third paragraph in which it is said that when sensation occurs, it is possible to experience delight, torment or intermediate in other words neutral sensations.

At this point, the sixth sense organs are not only complete but operation. So you could say that during the limb of the six loci, the six sense organs are in their inception during the limb of a contact, the six sense organs are complete but not functional and during the limb of sensation they are complete and functional. And some of the marvels of modern technology I was able to find some pictures of an embryo in utero experiencing precisely these sensations. I don’t think I have to explain what they are. You can see clearly that this fetus at approximately eight months of age is clearly quite delighted and this one is obviously not delighted at all.

Then when one sees pictures like this it is simply beyond me to understand how anyone could assert that they think this is not conscious. It would be very nice to know what the happy little fetus is thinking about. The following three limbs are the limbs which we will see in a couple of minutes when we present the 12 limbs in terms of projecting and completing limbs in the causal presentation lead to the next life. The first is a limb of craving Krishna in Sanskrit. Then it’s at this point that Asaṇga’s definitions are fairly uninformative.

Asaṇga basically links the limbs between each other. What is interesting in this definition is that Asaṇga asserts that craving induces birth and indeed craving leads to appropriation the following limb which leads to the tenth limb of existence which is the karmic potency immediately preceding the next birth which triggers the next birth. And this craving is very generally defined by Jitsangopad, it’s a craving which wishes not to be bereft of pleasant sensations and wishes to be free of sensations of suffering. In other words, any type of attachment to pleasure and rejection or hostility animosity towards suffering would definitely qualify as craving within this context. It is in other words for Jesuun Chukigilte, a desire, both craving and the following limb appropriation are desires which plants and nourishes initially the imprint of the projecting karma by means of any of the three sensations pleasant, unpleasant or neutral.

Then there is a debate about the term nourishes since frankly it seems function is more the function of the following limb, the limb of appropriation, which does indeed nourish and lead to completion. If we analyze which of the sixth, seventh and eighth limb can arise without ignorance, in other words, which of these limbs could arise for instance within Arhat, then we can see that the sixth and the seventh limb can arise without ignorance, but the eighth limb which is an affliction as well as the ninth limb necessarily require ignorance. The following limb is a limb of appropriation, upadana, which is merely an intensification of craving so great that it can trigger the maturation of the tenth limb and the eleventh limb birth. Jizenjiki Gilsson distinguishes four types of objects of appropriation. Sense objects which are generally considered to be the only objects of appropriation and three other objects of appropriation.

Evil views, grasping at wrong ethics and conduct as supreme and the view of the self. So just in Chuky Ginseng’s presentation of appropriation is much vaster than let us say the presentation of appropriation in traditional Theravada treatises. Appropriation typically would trigger the following limb, the limb of birth at the time approaching death. So at the time approaching death, great attachment to any of the sense objects. But for that matter, powerful evil views or let us say if one was, let us assume a very pious Nepalese, the thought I will sacrifice 60 buffalos so that I can live another five years would be a clear case of grasping at wrong conduct.

All this could act as a precipitating factor for the maturation of the following limb, the limb of existence. An appropriation is defined by Justin Chuky Gyetze as an inordinate, in other words tremendous increase in the previous limb of craving that desire which is, has become a powerful capacity to plant and nourish the imprint of the projecting karma. Here the distinction between the limbs of craving and appropriation is one of degree, not one of substance. And perhaps one of function since the limb of craving alone would be unable to lead the second limb composition of factors to maturation into the tenth limb, the limb of existence. The limb of existence is literally the seed of the next life.

It is a previous composition of factor in other words the second limb within that cycle of 12 limbs placed the redolence of karma that I’ve chosen to call Vassana Sanskrit redolence. Vassana means perfume in Sanskrit. Transited in Tibetan as Bakcha and commonly translated in English as karmic imprints. Then we go from something which is subtle and suffuses consciousness, which is Vāsanā in Sanskrit to the image westerners have when we talk of imprints which is hoof marks in the mind. You can see a very very big shift in connotation.

Then I think it would benefit us to go back to the Sanskrit and find what the Sanskrit connotates and then try to reinterpret the Tibetan in the light of the Sanskrit. So this redolence becomes able to lead to a future life which will be the two last limbs, the levels of the twelfth limbs through being nourished by craving and appropriation. Or as J. J. J.

Gillespie says it is a projecting karma which projects another existence once the two previous limbs of craving and appropriation have planted and nourished the imprint of the projecting karma. Now confusion arises because this limb, the tenth limb is called the limb of existence and it’s a common mistake when one studies the 12 limbs to assume that this refers to somehow the first instance of birth. It’s obviously not the case. This limb of existence is actually at the very very end of the previous life. It is that karmic imprint which precipitates the next life which is fully mature, fully matured by the eight and ninth limbs of craving and appropriation.

Then why precisely is it called existence? As Jasungopas says, it is and this is very common in Buddhist philosophy, a case of calling an effect by its name, by its the name of its cause. This is a very standard policy. I used to have some examples in English, but they skipped my mind at present. And the limb of birth, the eleventh limb needs little explanation, it is the actualization of limbs four through seven in the next life, which can be thousands or millions of lives removed.

More often than not, lives linked by the 12 limbs are greatly removed from each other. Energetician Zuki Giltsey says, it is thoroughly afflicted, we explained this means arisen from karma and klesha, dependent arising, which abides in the type of contingent aggregates of maturation as soon as conception into existence at birth under the power of the previous dependent arising of existence has occurred. In other words, birth occurs at conception from the standpoint of this presentation of the prevalence. Strictly speaking, you should probably celebrate someone’s birthday from the time of conception which is the Chinese and often we’d say Asian tradition. This birth is triggered, as is mentioned explicitly in the definition, by the previously in the tenth limb, the limb of existence.

Aging and death, the last limb, are basically the rest of the life from the instant of conception onwards. So you can choose to define birth as the period between the instance of conception and the instance of delivery or you can choose to define it as all the subsequent moments to conception. In either case, this is pedagogical. The goal is to point out that decay has begun at the very instant a being enters into this life. Then I will not elaborate on the definition of the dependent arising of death.

It is self evident subdivision of the twelfth limb. But I would like to present to you and it’s, to my knowledge, not translated in English. The Salishtamba Sutras very concise understanding of the 12 limbs which I think really summarizes things. If you could, it would be worth memorizing this. The sixth limb contact, the conflation of three phenomena is contact.

The experience of contact is sensation. The predilection for sensation is craving. Shempa is a very ambiguous term in Tibetan, which can be traced etymologically back to desire, but has actually acquired the meaning of conception. So I chose predilection to translate it. The increase of craving is appropriation.

The karma which generates birth or existence from appropriation is existence. The arising of the aggregates is birth. The maturation is aging, the disintegration is death. All of the items I highlighted in yellow are basically definitions of the corresponding limb. Contact is conflation, sensation is experience, craving is predilection, appropriation is increase, existence is a karma which generates birth, birth is a rise, aging is maturation, death is disintegration.

The Salishtamba sūtra is not very long but for some reason it has not attracted a lot of interest. I don’t know how to do it. If you all had iPads it would be high-tech and send it to you by email but what I can do is at the end of the presentation I leave it up on the board. How does that sound? So how are the limbs classified?

Jia Pei Nian gave a very clear presentation of that this morning. They are classified in causal and effect limbs. Obviously from a Buddhist standpoint, every impermanent phenomenon is both cause and effect. But some limbs have mainly a causal function and some have mainly a function as an effect. So the three first limbs are known as projecting limbs, ignorance, compositional factors and consciousness.

They are causes and limbs eight, nine and ten are also causes, these three actualizing limbs. So you have six causes. The four projected limbs, which as you remember are basically the embryological development, limbs four, five, six and seven are effects and the last two limbs, limbs eleven and twelve are also effects. So you have therefore six causes and six effects and you can remember the sequence if you remember three, four, three, two. You have three projecting limbs, four projected limbs, three actualizing limbs and two actualized limbs.

If you want to study the 12 limbs unfortunately, or maybe fortunately, there’s no other way to go about it to memorize. It’s extremely helpful later on. Then the general sequence of the 12 limbs, in other words not the sequence for one individual cycle, but the general cosmic sequence is from limbs one to 12. With projecting limbs first, projecting limbs after, actualizing limbs thereafter and actualized limbs at the end. But what becomes very interesting is to try to analyze the number of lives in which one cycle of the 12 limbs can mature and then to try to see how it breaks down in cause and effect.

So as Jhumpa Inyan explained this morning, life cycles of 12 limbs can only mature in two or three separate lives. These lives are not generally speaking subsequent. They can each be separated by thousands of other lives or millions of other lives. Then I have used mathematical notation, I hope you don’t mind. In two lives, there was life n and life n plus k at some point in the distant future, the limbs will manifest very simply.

The six causal limbs manifest in the first life, the six resulting limbs manifest in the next life. So limbs one, two, three, eight, nine, ten manifest in the first life and limbs four, five, six, seven, eleven and twelve manifest in the next life, in the future life. What this means is that, let us assume through ignorance one engages, let’s take a concrete example to ground us, out of the wrong view that all those who are not Muslim are worthy to be slaughtered in the name of jihad. One engages in the wrong activity of killing, the karma of killing then implants these karmic imprints on consciousness in life. At the end of that life recollecting the killing one has performed, one rejoices greatly in these deeds, this is craving, rejoices even more at the thought of what one has done, this appropriation.

This then leads to the maturation of that karmic impetus killing, the second limb which was deposited in consciousness and it manifests as a very powerful projecting karma, the limb of existence, the tenth limb which will precipitate rebirth in a future life in the case of a very heavy non virtuous deeds such as killing it might be in the next life. Let us assume as a hell being, then as a hell being you would normally have a miraculous birth So you would not go through much of these developments. If you were reborn as a human being, then you would be reborn in a violent land, a harsh land, a poor land. Your embryo would be name and form at the time of the formation of the sense organs will be at the level of the six loci. Contact would occur when they are complete and sensation when the first sensations are experienced.

This would lead to rebirth let us say in Afghanistan or in Iraq and after a very short life aging and death. This would be how lead 12 limbs would unfold over two lives. They might be subsequent, they would not have to be. The key however is that the six causal limbs always unfold in the first life and the six resulting limbs always unfold in the second life. Over three lives, each life can be separated from the other by thousands of years.

So you have life N plus K, life n, excuse me, the first life, life n plus k, the second life, and life n plus k plus p, the third life. The three first causal limbs unfold during life n. Ignorance, compositional factors and consciousness. The three following causal limbs, craving appropriation existence during life n plus k, and at some point in the distant future, the appropriated life manifests, the six effect limbs unfold. So let us say for instance that out of ignorance, all of our deeds are present are performed out of ignorance, One wishes to make an offering to a temple for the fragments of the teachings.

Then the second limb would be the limb of compositional factors that makes a vast offering to a temple let’s say in an impoverished area in China. As a result of this, that karmic imprint is implanted in consciousness, let us say during a life during the twelfth century. This is life n. That karmic imprint limb number two remains in consciousness, let us say for six hundred years. After six hundred years, at the end of another life in China, at the very end of that life, the reincarnation of that person experiences a very very strong wish for a happier life in the future and one associated with dharma practice in the temple.

This craving intensifies, it leads to appropriation and even greater sense that a life in a temple, like a single virtue, this is still contaminated, would be most beneficial and this causes the maturation of this second limb which had been dwelling in consciousness for some six hundred years. That becomes a powerful karmic imprint, limb of existence which precipitates then the following life, it could be the next life, it could be life in the twenty first century as a young child born in China, born in Australia, who goes through gestation is eventually born and at an early age manifests an interest in the teachings and expresses the wish of mourning. The death of that child would be the end of that person would be the end of that cycle. So this is how the 12 limbs would manifest over one life, over three lives. Then we have countless such karmic imprints within our mind screen.

So you can see how critical it is to understand the process of maturation of these karmic imprints. To purify all the karmic imprints, non virtuous karmic imprints in our mind is very difficult. But to try to make sure that only the good ones mature and that the bad ones have very little chance to mature is something which is realistic and feasible. And that can only be done if we clearly understand what afflictions are in the process of maturation of karmic imprints and obviously specifically the critical time which is the time of death. So the general causal sequence of the 12 limbs is the following, we have one limb of afflictions, one limb of karma and one limb of suffering.

The limb of afflictions comprises three afflictions, the first eight and ninth limb, ignorance, craving and appropriation. Karma comprises only two limbs, compositional factors in existence and suffering comprises the remaining limbs. Limbs three, four, five, six, seven, eleven and twelve. As Jabainian explained this morning, for afflicted dependent arisings these 12 links can also be very elegantly subdivided into the two first truths, the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering. The afflictions would for instance be the truth of the origin of suffering, the second world of truth.

So this is the meaning of this beautiful passage in Nāgārjuna’s Heart of Dependent Arising, from the Sri arise a two, from the two arises seven and again from the seven arises to the three, the wheel of existence itself repeatedly turns. Then I am convinced that none of you would understand what Nagaswami was saying if we hadn’t had this preliminary study. Because if you look back you can see clearly here from the three arise a two, from the two arise the seven and yet again from the seven arise the three. This is cyclic existence as Nagarajuna presented, there is no atma. From the limb of the afflictions within one cycle of the 12 limbs arises the limb of karma.

The limb of karma gives rise to another existence. In that existence under the power of afflictions, once again the cycle of the planet. And the destiny of every sentient being is therefore beautifully summarized by that of a tapestry which is being woven on a beam. The figures in a tapestry arise with the intersection of the threads, each thread would be one cycle of 12 We have had experience in the past beginningless cycles of 12 limbs, There are countless karmic imprints within our mind stream. All of the afflictions are present to a greater degree, greater or lesser degree within our mind stream.

They will trigger these karmic imprints in the future and this will be the unfolding of our destiny for so long as we ourselves choose not to. So for so long as we want to make a beautiful tapestry, to weave a beautiful tapestry, we will be practitioners or beings of small scope. When we take a torch and we say, move to all tapestries, we will be practitioners of the building scope. And when we become revolutionaries and we look at the other tapestry makers around us and say tapestry makers of all nations unite, then we will be on the path of the being of the great scope. So the 12 limbs enable us to understand the process of generation of saṃsāra and the process of extinction of saṃsāra, what’s known as the forward and the backward process of generation.

The dependence arising from the standpoint of the thoroughly afflicted is saṃsāra. The dependence arising from the standpoint of the thoroughly purified is the path to liberation. And the direct series in general involves the general causal sequence of the 12 limbs from ignorance to aging and death. Each limb giving rise to the following limb whereas the reverse series involves the same sequence in which the cessation of each limb gives rise to the cessation of the corresponding subsequent limb. The cessation of ignorance leads to the cessation of compositional factors, Then there’s a cessation, not as consciousness in general, at least not in the Mahāyāna, but consciousness as recipient of karmic influence, etcetera, etcetera.

So now what I thought we would do and this is a bit experimental is to try to see if we can present one cycle of the 12 limbs within a case of the reincarnation. And I was able to find these cases are difficult to find, a very interesting case, the case of a Burmese monk, venerable Usandimah. So Usandimah, in his lay state, he went by the name of Maung Soi Mint, was born in Upper Burma with extremely severe birth defects of both hands and feet. Groove like depressions which are known as amniotic band syndrome and an extremely profound birthmark on his neck which bled at birth. Between the ages of four and five, said yesterday this is fairly standard for children with memories of past lives.

He said his name had been Maungi and I’m sorry in these cases the names are difficult for me to pronounce and difficult for you to remember. We just have to sort of hang in there. Maung Yi had been a close friend of his mother before Maung Yi’s death. Then as a child he expressed a powerful wish to return to his native village of Yonebin Saok. He said he had wife and child.

He also clearly remembered having been captured by communist rebels, dragged into the countryside, tied to a tamarind tree and tortured before being executed. At age four, his mother had to go to his former recollected village to which he had never been when they’ve been sulk and he accompanied her. Think she probably would not have taken him if she had understood what would unfold because for all she was a trades person or she was handling trade matters, the little child ran away and when his mother searched for him she found him in the house of the late Ummang Yi surrounded by his sobbing family to whom he had declared that he was the reincarnation of Ummang Yi and to whom he had pointed out various elements of the house. When his mother came, the little child who was aged four or five years old introduced the members of his previous family saying, this is my wife, these are my children and he showed his mother around his estate. He remarked immediately that the house of Umangy had been changed and this was denied before being finally confirmed.

And then which is much more awkward, I’m sure if you have children you can appreciate, he refused to leave. You can imagine how it must feel to be told you’re not my mother. Who are you? The emotions involved are a classic signature of these cases. The child feels he belongs with the previous family.

The previous family very rapidly feels the child belongs with them. The new family are zerpals. He was able to recognize Umanghi’s clothes even though they can be mixed up with the clothes of silence. This is very similar to the recognition procedures used for great Tibetan lamas. There is no difference as far as ascertaining the mode of reincarnation is concerned.

Now what is very striking is that after monks we meet became ordained, he still retained clear memories of his capture by communist rebels and of his execution in the previous life. He was able to give details which were not readily available. And he recounted to Stevenson that he had been accused of being a spy for the British government. And one day he was a trader as he was coming out of Lulebin Salk on his horse, the communists arrested him. They took him to a place where there was a tamarind tree and questioned, in other words tortured him at length.

He was unable to give satisfactory answers. They then tied him up and killed him with a sword. And what is very interesting is that the communists asked him to say his prayers just before they killed him. Not out of any religious sense, but probably common in Burma and climate to make sure he did not return as a revenge for those. Then Maungi remembered that he prayed that he would be reborn soon as a human.

He remembered nothing after that moment until he was four years old. So here you have very powerful prayers at the time of death after extensive torture, prayers to be reborn as a human being. Such prayers are the sort of prayers which would very possibly lead to a rebirth as a human being in the immediate subsequent life. We would analyze in a couple of minutes how this might unfold in terms of the conflict. Then said that when he was young, he remembered clearly the six persons involved in his torture and death.

All had since passed on. And interestingly enough, these experiences had a very powerful impact as you could imagine. And instead of becoming a trader, which was a family vocation, he wanted to become a monk. And I was very struck by this passage because it is so simple and so sincere. I wanted peace so I became a monk.

People are otherwise in trouble. I do not want that or memory. There’s nothing very high flown here, nothing very pretentious but it’s very very simple and powerful. This is a type of sword which would have been used to amputate the limbs of Mount Saint Luke and eventually to decapitate. Now before going into an analysis of Venerable Usain Demar’s birth defects, I’d like to cover again the general incidence of birth defects with you, which I mentioned yesterday.

I told you that I think the most accurate data is probably Kennedy’s data. I don’t know of more recent data on birth defects, which give us something around one and some percent of the population with birth defects with a data pool of twenty million. Then other investigators have up to twice that incidence of birth defects. However, the extreme birth defects which characterized are very rare. It’s actually rare to see children with this type of birth defect who survive.

You can see that both hands had missing digits which look very much as if they had been amputated. Then the left forearm of Roussaint Dimas had a birthmark which resembles a rope. There was a depression which is not really visible here, you can just see it here and birthmark on the left wrist which would have been similar to that made by a rope with one’s hands were tied behind a tree. And you can see that the right big toe is abnormally short, it’s atrophied and certainly if you did not know anything about the case, you would assume that there had been tension and confusion. The lower left leg is marked by bands which are not terribly visible, but you can see them here, the white bands here also, here I think it’s very faint.

And these are deep looking dental bands unfortunately not visible on the foot which went deep in the flesh. And both the right lower calf and foot carry rope marks. Then Usanyamau’s mother said that all these birthmarks were bleeding at birth and healing had taken a full two months. As you remember Usain Yamal in his previous life was remembered being decapitated and the birthmark on his neck took a very long time to find a fadeaway in his porcelain. It took some four months to heal.

Then Stevenson obviously checked the obvious neither Usandima’s mother and his father were related in any way. There’s no consanguinity. There was no case of similar birthmarks in the family. So if we look at the unfolding of the recollected life of Usain Limat, we can see that in life one, he remembers being born as Maoongi around 1948, excuse me, unknown birth time, death around 4849. He was a trader, he was a friend of Maoong Sai Ming, in other words his future incarnation’s mother, tortured and decapitated by communists after being tied to a tree, and he prayed very powerfully, you can imagine how powerful such prayers would be under those circumstances, for a human rebirth before dying.

The next rebirth is in 1950 one year later. He has constriction rings and missing digits which bled at birth, birthmarks on the back of the neck which bled at birth, clear memories of Maungie’s life and death, and rapidly becomes ordained with the name of Usainima and to the best of my knowledge, he’s still ordained. So if we try to analyze these two subsequent lives in terms of the prevalence and I think we can because we seem to have a clear causal connection here. What would those prevalence be? What would be if you wish, the group of 12 limbs leading to the fourth limb name in form of rebirth as monksignate?

In his previous life, you have the six causal limbs, in his present life you have the six without hindrance. The first causal limb is ignorance, the ignorance of selflessness. The second is the karma, the composition of factors, intense prayers to be reborn as a human being just after torture. This is a very powerful karma character which is implanted into consciousness basically at the time of death. You can assume that he died thinking of this wish.

What would be the eighth limb of craving? Probably the desire to be free from suffering, to be reborn in a higher realm, maybe procedures found within, we have no way of knowing but it seems fairly natural. The ninth limb would be a great appropriation, great intensification of this wish and as a result of the ninth limb, the second limb composition of factors is activated and a powerful karma to be reborn as a human being, son of his friend Dao Saiming King, he makes a selfisher death process. This leads to conception and the birth of the embryo of Hmong Saiming. The sixth lokshire occur some sixteen weeks into pregnancy, contact some twenty weeks into pregnancy, sensation at some point later than that, birth on 03/13/1950 and the twelfth limb of aging and death would be his present life.

Then this is one of the stronger cases I have seen precisely because of the clear linkage between the tenth limb in the previous life and the fourth limb in this life. So as those of you who attended Kinslow Nbuchet’s teachings here remember, Nbuchet repeatedly emphasized that the cause to obtain a precious human rebirth, in this case it probably was partially a rebirth of leisure and endowment were initially pure ethics conjoined with the practice of generosity and forbearance to which had to be added stainless prayers. Ethics is a main cause, generosity and forbearance are cooperative conditions which lead respectively to functional financial conditions and a functional appearance and the prayer itself is actually the focus. Now we cannot say regarding Mang Sao Amit whether or not the three first causes were present. We do not know whether his ethics was purely probably worse.

We do not know whether he prefers generosity and forbearance but he might have. But we do know that very powerful prayers were made. And I hope this case illustrates to you the fact that what the great Buddhist teachers teach is not merely some sort of Tibetan or Asian rather quaint cultural tradition, which is to be studied before passing to something else. Instead, it seems to really describe reality. This is actually how things unfold.

And this case is a very striking one because clearly, if we ourselves wish for a human rebirth, all we have to do is to do what Usaini marked. If we have powerful thoughts, powerful wish to be reborn as a human being at the time of death, combined with the requisite amount of merit, it will happen and very possibly will happen in the next life. Then when we look at the birthmarks of Sandhya Mahan, have to ask ourselves, is there a physiological mechanism which can explain this? There has to be. It’s difficult to see birthmarks and hearing, you know, miraculously.

And the physiological mechanism is poorly understood, but is starting to be understood. It is known as amniotic band syndrome and is due to the disintegration of the amniotic bag around the fetus and the formation of strings which can lead to scars or partial amputation of the limbs. It is very poorly understood. It is just starting to be studied in The United States and the incidence is not well understood either, it seems to be very low. What is striking in the case of Usain Limach is that this mechanism was conjoined with clear memories of their previous life and recognition of family members.

So you can see here how biology and dharma interact. You can see here how the mind body interface functions. It is very rare for the anodic mind to rupture and for it to rupture in such a way in that the damage caused coincides with the recollected torture in a child who is able to identify where the victim of that torture lived, how he was tortured, who remembers who did the torturing. Statistically this is almost impossible to account for. So this is a depiction of the earliest known wheel of life to my knowledge at least in Cave 17 in Ajanta.

It’s obviously badly damaged by time. But this wheel of life basically is a graphical depiction of the 12 limbs. As you know, the 12 limbs on the periphery of the wheel of life. And I wish to conclude this talk by quoting from Nāgārjuna’s Bolichita Vivarano to show you how far reaching the teaching of the 12 limbs are. Nāgārjuna says, I accept the deeds which have arisen independence on the 12 limbs beginning from ignorance up to the 12 limb aging as akin to a dream or an illusion.

I do not accept some sentient being other than the squeal of 12 limbs revolving on the path of existence as enjoyment of causality. It is one of the most beautiful statements of the selflessness of persons which I know. And this is what I wanted to cover with you today. If you have any questions, I’d be delighted to answer them and if you don’t have any questions, I’d be just as delighted to have a cup of tea. Ilya, I just wondered if, from your study of cases, if you have a sense of how often the next life comes back, a person comes back into the same family or related?

The same family it happens was the case of the Julian and Jennifer Pollock. The same village is quite common. People accumulate common with respect to their surroundings and obviously we have to exclude and I’m sorry but we do have to exclude westerners from the equation. So our lives have changed so radically from the way people used to live let’s say in Asia or much of the world that we basically claim to qualify anymore. But if you look at life, the life of Tibetans, the life of Sri Lankans, of Africans, people basically never moved too much beyond their village.

Then the people they accumulated karma with respect to typically were members of their village as well. The odds of being reborn in the area were quite high. Then for westerners, now with the mobility, we have courage. Then it’s very difficult to say. Very difficult.

Stevenson studied both categories of cases. What he found was that overwhelmingly people would be, if they had human rebirth, would be reborn within the communities they came from. If they were Hindus in India, they would typically be reborn as Hindus. Then he developed particular care to the study of those who crossed, for instance, religious boundaries. Even though they previously collected birth was Hindu, they’d be born as Muslims or the opposite.

But they were very well. And this is obviously one of the reasons for which his holiness has placed such a strong caveat against the conversion of westerners to Buddhism simply because most westerners come karmically from a Christian background. So that is present within the mind stream. Obviously, them to have become Buddhist, some type of connection with Buddhism would have to be necessary. Does that begin to answer your question?

Well, then in that case, it’ll be difficult for for those people who have who have accumulated lots of bad karma to be reborn in Afghanistan. It will be difficult or easy? Difficult because they have very karmic very strong karmic bonds to their villagers. Well, they do but if the deed for instance which is performed is a very heavy deed of killing let’s say, then that deed is a dominant factor especially if it’s activated at the time of death. If that second limb, the composition of fact is activated at the time of death by powerful hatred, powerful rejoicing, becomes a tenth limb, then that would probably override any familiarity they might have with local environment.

I think this case is interesting because you can see perhaps through it that a human rebirth is rare. It’s something which has struck me working with Stevenson’s material. I actually had the opposite reaction to many westerners who approached the material. What struck me was the gaps between lives. There are huge unexplained gaps, fifty years, sometimes a hundred years, but there is no memory.

Yet I have always thought this implied either a lower or a much higher rebirth in which the memory simply were no longer something which are commensurate to our capacities to understand. The cases in Stevenson I saw of recollected animal rebirths with almost no memories. There was one Sri Lankan case you could infer that the person had been reborn as a horse from the fact that he remembered not being able to see to the right or to the left being very big, hairy and sweaty and being tormented by flies. That was the sum total of self awareness. There was not a mental statement I am a horse.

So when we study Stevenson’s cases we have to study the case and we also have to study what is left unsaid. Mine, I suppose, isn’t really so much a question but this, you know, the issue of the body deformities being caused well, the issue of the body deformities taken in the context of the 12 links then it implies that the body is not just a vehicle for the mind but the mind itself is involved in actually creating the body. So there’s a great deal more interdependence there. Yeah, and the, so the body isn’t simply the basis of the mind. The mind creates in the body.

I mean the body is a karmic product. Clearly, you know it is always said that if one wants a powerful body in a future life one should practice forbearance or patience in this life simply because forbearance in other words taking upon oneself responsibility is basically if you wish a metaphor or is similar to obtaining a body which is take able to take on burdens and. You have other questions? There seems to be a lot of dogs in our culture that think they’re humans entitled to Well, I can’t say. I knew one case at Sera which really gave food for thought if you don’t believe in animal rebels.

There was one dog whenever there was a pooja and whenever there was sojourn, he was an infant dog, wild, no fever. He would walk up the steps of the monarch. Don’t if Jabinha never saw this type of thing. It’s quite extraordinary. He would walk up the steps of the main assembly hall, enter with the monks, and he would go and he would sit on a dimoire in the row of monks facing the right way, you know, for the beginning of the puja or monastic confession.

Same dog, always the same dog, he was always here at all prescribed times. Then the disciplinarians, sometimes the display, sometimes the display would come, would point at him and would lead him out of the temple. Then I must recognize Ayo was said that he was a monk who had broken his vows. Many of us saw that. And then he was reborn as a dog with the habituation must be very difficult.

Right? The dog obviously what sort of understanding does a dog have? The dog senses that he was something else, he was something else but he doesn’t quite understand. That’s also why many Buddhist teachers do not encourage excessive familiarity with animals Because obviously, if we become too close to an animal, you know, we are in a sense starting to emulate, starting to imitate an animal. There is a risk associated with this.

Like I said, I do not refer to kindness towards an animal but excessive closeness. Do you have other questions? One thing I notice is I, I, I and it’s curious that I am a horse or I am a like some sense of understanding this self as something other than human because of, I think, little understanding of past and future lives, karmically. So what I’m saying is there’s lots of powerful I, but very rarely does that extend outside a human identity. And something about it because of its fixedness in this life and no knowledge of what previous existences have given rise to the situation I’m in now.

So what I’m noticing is when you said this person didn’t say I’m a horse and had all of the because horses are not generally conscious that they are horses. It’s just something about I didn’t have a very strong I then of I’m not explaining it very well Just that it’s very linked to a complete obsession with this life or yeah I I think I understand what you’re driving at. There’s two things. We as westerners, we have a deeply ingrained bias against the idea of animal rebels. Even those western esoteric or occult traditions like theosophy which basically believed in reincarnation, do not seem to have believed in animal reincarnation.

They only believed in human reincarnation. There is this very deeply rooted sense among Westerners of the human specificity, the human difference. You know, it goes way back certainly to Aristotle and as you know Plato believed in reincarnation. But that’s the first factor then. The sense of self in an animal I cannot say.

These are my extrapolations from this one case of a young Sri Lankan who in addition to remembering human lives remembered some elements of lives which must have been animal, but he never identified them as such. So it’s it’s really extrapolation. But I think this bias against animal rebirth was a long way to explain the resistance we find among most western Buddhist. I know a Lojong western Buddhist, Shinda Rinpoche, who was asked by another student whether she believed in animal rebirth and after long pause said no. Then obviously if one does not believe in animal rebirth, probably by influence one could say one doesn’t believe in any lower gram of rebirth.

Then does one actually believe in the karma and causality? I don’t know. And one runs into many problems as I mentioned in my talk on the lower balance here a year and a half ago, because if one is gonna draw a boundary between human beings who reincarnate and animals who do not reincarnate. Where precisely is that boundary drawn? If we assume, which is my case, that the theory of evolution represents a reality, then what happened?

So Paranthropus evolved into Osteroepithecus, eventually we got the man of Neanderthal and the man of Crimean, then nobody was reincarnating until suddenly Crimean appeared. Suddenly, at the time of the man of Kromanian, Kromanian started reincarnating, but man of Neanderthal never reincarnated. And if men of Neanderthal reincarnated, did, let us say, the level ten million years before that of Parenthropus, did Parenthropus reincarnate or not? And if Parenthropus reincarnated, how can we say that Parenthropus’ closest cousin, the chimp, or the vulnerable does not reincarnate. So once we have said that, why are we asserting that chimps and bonobos reincarnate and not gray parrots?

When there is actually a very interesting statement, a sort of Cambridge statement, sentencing. Where a group of zoologists and biologists assembled in Cambridge stated that the level of sentencing intelligence of grey parrots was so advanced that it warranted considering them as persons. And this is very far reaching legal implications in Western society. I’m not saying Ted should have the status of a person by law. You know Ted the little teddy bear?

I saw that it’s a Hollywood movie in which he tries to get legal status. That’s another story. But it’s very far reaching, isn’t it? Because if we are going and as Buddhists, this is something we assert but if in addition we consider it’s true that all living beings being incarnate and all living beings are persons. Buddhist not that all sentient beings are persons.

Then then the person has rights, doesn’t it? I was just wondering if you could continue with that, with the relationship between evolution and the 12 links. The relationship between evolution and the 12 links, you know, rhinoceroses and there’s such a vast variety of different sentient beings. You know, do they stay within their own kind or do they cross species or Are you speaking of reincarnation? Yeah.

Reincarnation and evolution. The question occurs across species actually. I think I view the two causal mechanisms as separate but super closed. You have genetic evolution. Then I am in no position to say whether strict Darwinian evolution or the modified modified forms which occur in the discord modern theory are more valid.

The modern theory seems more possible. But that refers to the biological substrate of the physical body. And Then you have the 12 links, the the karmic substrate. And these two basically exist separately but they are linked. In our case for instance as human beings, we are the result of a long process of evolution which took millions of years.

It’s fairly well established. We’re able to trace back I think to 14,000,000 at least. Then I consider all those living beings where we reincarnated as let us say Paranthropus when Paranthropus was dominant or perhaps as other sentient beings such as saber tooth tigers, mammoths, you know, and they were extinct. I mean obviously if you were living from killing mammoths then you would accumulate if you forgive me for the term mammoth karma. Right?

The chances of being reborn as a mammoth would be considerable and of being yourself on the receiving end of a pit filled with spears, does not the odds will not smell. Does that answer your question a bit? Not fully. Have joked to me and said, well, how can you believe that you could be reborn as a cockroach in your next life? And It’s difficult.

I mean, I agree with you. I know when my father passed on, it was very difficult for me when I asked myself, how could my father be reborn as an insect? Got this very And if you view the mind only as the intellectual faculties, then this is impossible to know. Clearly, the intellect of a cockroach is almost nonexistent. But if you consider that there is something which is called in time to the fundamental mind, which is that spark, if you wish, transmigrates from life to life, then that does not have to be endowed in manifest form with all of the mental factors.

Some may be, I’m sure cockroaches feel certain emotions. I’m sure they feel fear, the wide gamut of emotions which we have, the wide gamut of mental factors which we experience, cockroaches probably do not have. But if you observe animals you’re close to, it’s perhaps a good thing about having pets. You can see that pets have a much higher level of sentience than is usually attributed to them. Pets dream, they have hopes, they have fears.

They have clearly conceptual activity. I know someone who said to me that animals have no conceptual activity. This means they have no memories. But pets have a whole range of non conception and conception activities of main minds and mental factors. Then if my wife’s dog, Bobby has this whole range of mental factors, why wouldn’t the cat have them?

And if the cat does, why not the mouse? What if you start going really as far as insects are concerned, a Bungalowin Bachir points out, even an ant is afraid when you poke its nose with some native grass. Obviously, don’t know what the ant is thinking but it seems to react like that. Then the other question you are asking is a different one. That is a very difficult one to answer.

It’s a question of the boundaries of sentience. So how far down the ladder of evolution does sentience go? That I have no answer. Are unicellular organisms sentient? Are bacteria sentient?

And if bacteria are sentient, why are the cells of our body, in other words, unisexual organism which constitute a tissue not sentient because if every cell of my body is sentient, there’s a cacophony of voices here and I’m in trouble. So normally I assume they’re not. But when the sentience what level of biological organization the sentience begin and why? If you’re going to assert that any cellular organisms are sentient, you are pretty much bound to assert that plants are sentient because there’s no functional difference with an animal and vegetable cells. This is a phenomenon.

This is a physiology. If you could assert it’s only multicellular organisms and when? At the level of insects? Buddhists would say definitely at the level of insects. Definitely.

You have other questions? Yes. So my question thank you, Ilya. My question is about May I propose something since we’re going on after the hour? Would Japhanian join me and we take joint questions at present?

Would you like that? Or would you prefer a break Japhanian first? What do you think? Then I’ll take the last question, then we have a nice break. So my question is about, I think, Samil Hijak yesterday who I said yes.

Yep. So it seems like he entered the fetus in the third trimester sometime. And that I find completely believable. As far as I know, there’s some empirical evidence for yogi’s ability to enter dead bodies and then revive them under their different consciousness. Jim and I were talking about it last night and the question arises with regards to the fetus.

Whose karma causes that fetus to grow? So having my example, this person called Frank. Frank dies in October of a certain year. John is conceived in January of that same year. But then John dies before he exits the birth canal.

So basically, he’s still a fetus. And then Frank reincarnates, calling Frank two, in October year. So you have a fetus that’s been occupied by two different consciousnesses. Now whose consciousness directs the growth of that fetus? I can see Jabihin smiling.

We have two students here who think like Tibetan monastics. It’s Jill and Willy. Right? You’d be just at home at Serraje. These are monastic debate questions.

Excellent question. Well, there are several caveats to your question. The orthodox answer will be that at the time of conception, a consciousness enters the fertilized egg and that being dies in utero, let’s say in the eight months. And there would be then not reincarnation but possession of the fetus by another being. That would the orthodox answer.

And therefore, then if you try to posit this in terms of the 12 limbs, it starts to get really hairy. I’ll jump in and try. But if Sorry. The fetus has to be a fit vehicle for Frank number two So come it can’t just be, you know, it’s got to fit Frank number two’s karma. Yes.

Yes. That’s for sure. That’s for sure. That would be the, let’s say, orthodox answer. You’d have reincarnation at the time of conception, a cycle of 12 links initiates, it actually ends at the eighth month with the twelfth limb in utero.

We have a very strange case but it’s possible where the twelfth limb occurs without the eleventh limb having occurred. There’s no birth but there’s already been aging and death. Death for sure. And then there would be a case of possession which probably would not qualify for a presentation in terms of 12 limbs. But there’s another point you have to make which is that we do not know how much a fetal development can occur purely under biological impetus without any karmic component.

It’s clear that if you put a cell in the petri dish and it starts dividing by the ptosis, that cell will constitute a tissue. There is no karmic component involved in this. It’s a biological mechanism. How far how much of that is possible for a fetuses development? We don’t know.

It’s a difficult question. You start looking at the interface of reincarnation of biology, things become both interesting and very difficult. Very difficult. Then maybe we will stop here. We have 15 for a cup of tea and then we will reassemble here at 03:30.

Can’t try to finish by four.

Key terms in this teaching

completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How do biological evolution and the twelve links of dependent origination relate, and how can we be reborn as insects?

The two causal mechanisms are separate but closely linked. Genetic evolution concerns the biological substrate of the physical body, while the twelve links concern the karmic substrate. Humans are the result of millions of years of evolution, and beings may have been reborn in species that are now extinct, such as mammoths. Rebirth as an insect seems impossible only if mind is seen as the intellectual faculties. The fundamental mind, a "spark" that transmigrates from life to life, need not show all mental factors. Pets show dreams, hopes, fears and conceptual activity, so simpler animals may share some of this.

Scroll to Top