Karma – 2013-06-29 – KR

1 h 39 min · 12,621 words · 29 June 2013

Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma - 2013-06-29 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk presents the Buddhist teaching on karma: its four general features (definiteness, increase, non-experience of uncollected karma, and indestructibility unless purified). It covers projecting and completing karma, the ten non-virtuous deeds, the four conditions that make a deed complete, factors that amplify karma, and the four forces of purification. A question and answer session follows.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 39m

UUID: eba4667e-7b00-4bf1-8e2a-301f9da14a23

Date: 2013-06-29

Words: 12,617

Siddhi cannons, right? I didn’t imagine Vasubandhu like that myself either, but Then we shall continue quietly with the Buddhist presentation of ethical causality, we are here fully now within the religious context, if you wish. And to present karma traditionally, is done through presenting first the general features of karma, those of you which are Lojong Buddhist students have probably heard about these already, which are that karma is definite, karma increases, one does not experience, karma one has not accumulated, and karma which is not purified is indestructible. We will cover each of these general features of karma one by one, and I must say I feel it is one of the most helpful analytical meditations you can do. When I was young, I would go on walks in the woods in Switzerland and meditate on the general features of Karma.

It was a tremendous benefit for my mind, because you can see all the pine trees as results, right? The results of a karmic seed. Then if you think of the seed being tiny, and you look at these gigantic pine trees, and you start analyzing the growth of the forest in terms of the four features of karma, it’s a great help to the mind. So the definiteness of karma refers to the fact that what are known as virtuous actions always produce happiness, karmically. They do not produce happiness in a mundane sense in this life, but the karmic result of a virtuous deed is happiness, at some point in the future.

And the karmic result of a non virtuous deed is unhappiness. How precisely was this, ascertained? Buddha Śākyamūni basically, ascertained this through his omniscience. It is through observing karmic results of happiness and unhappiness in this life, and tracing their causes back in time to the individual cause, which gave rise to them, that the Buddha was able to give us a karmic road map. This karmic road map is what we endeavor to follow.

The Buddha discovered that happy deeds in this life, which were consequences, arose from a given non virtue in the past. Suffering, which was a consequence in this life, arose from a given non virtue in the past, and neutral sensations were the product of neutral deeds, and extrapolated this to the future. In other words, virtue engaged in in this life would lead to happiness in future lives, non virtue in this life to suffering in future lives. This is the foundation of Buddhist practice. One who strives to live in accordance with karma and causality is a Buddhist.

One who does not is not a Buddhist, irrespective of what the person says or believes. Then karma is an increasing function of time, and this is the uncommon feature of karmic causality as opposed to mundane physical causality. Je Tsongkhapa points out in Lamrim Chenmo that this amplifying feature of karma is the uncommon feature of karma. There’s no clear explanation for it. I personally believe that down the line, if we are ever able to ground Buddhism on physics, which is not as far fetched as it might seem, we will find there is something to do with quantum interactions.

But it is clear that chaos theory in mathematics provides a very good simile for karmic amplification. Now you have heard probably of chaos theory in the context of, for instance, meteorology. It is a way of studying very large complex systems, where the small modification of one component of the system can have huge effects down the line. So there is a famous example of the butterfly flapping its wings in China and causing a couple years down the line a hurricane in America. Now the features of systems which are can be analyzed in terms of chaotic motion or chaos theory, is that they are highly sensitive on initial conditions, which is a case for karma.

Everything hinges basically on the the complete karmic deed with the four features, and they are recurrent. In other words, the deed which leads to a result gives rise to a result which itself can lead to that deed again. We will talk about that later. Such systems, which are highly sensitive or have high dependency on initial conditions and are strongly recurrent are systems which lend themselves to this huge amplification which characterizes karma. Pabongka Rinpoche gives a very coarse or simple example of karmic amplification, stating that karma, a given karma accumulated at time t zero on day one, will double after twenty four hours, and therefore we would be dealing with a linear function of karma as a function of time.

My personal hypothesis is it’s more some type of exponential function, where you have a slow increase and there is very rapid, actually gigantic increase as time increases, but it’s impossible to quantify. So we do not know this for sure. In any case, all the great Buddhist thinkers have underlined that this amplification of karma is an uncommon feature of karmic causality, which makes karma dangerous, powerful and dangerous. Because unpurified karma amplifies, small virtuous karma over time can have huge effects. Small non virtuous karma over time can also have huge effect.

Therefore, it is to our advantage to understand the karmic laws well to live in function of a karmic strategy. The third general feature of karma is that one does not experience karma which is not accumulated. A karmic result of happiness and suffering in this life will only occur if that karma has been accumulated by that person in the past, otherwise it will not. This has far reaching consequences for our practice, because it means, for instance, that the prayers of intercession, which are so popular in Western Buddhist centers, are basically meaningless. We see during Lama Chöpa a lot of students asking for prayers for the sick and so forth, and I would always see Khensur Rinpoche’s face at this moment become very hard and blank.

He had to put up with these requests for the sake of the students, but these requests are basically meaningless. You cannot pray for another person. Obviously, you can. It’s to your benefit to do so. But they, unless they are very close karmically to you, we’re talking of parents and children, teacher and disciple, will reap no benefit.

Therefore, to put it bluntly, there is no prayer of intercession in Buddhism. As you saw in the Dalai Lama quoted famously this passage from sūtra, in which the Buddha says, I am my own Lord and I am my own protector. As Buddhists, we are alone. We are alone with our own past karma and the present karma we accumulate. It is up to us to inflect our lives or not.

The Buddha is a teacher. More than that, the Buddhas of all times cannot do. If prayers of intercession were effective, I am quite convinced all of us would already be bodhisattvas, because the great beings, the Buddhas of the past and the present are praying for us and trying to find means to help. But each of us is locked in our own mental continuum with our own karma. Then the reason for which this has to be emphasized is because a lot of effort can be wasted in these prayers of intercession, whereas the experiences are contingent on the karma we have accumulated or not.

So that effort must go into purifying the non virtuous karma we have accumulated, and the past we have little control over, but the future we do have control over. We can at present accumulate virtuous karma. And then obviously prayers for the others are of benefit to us. It increases our empathy and our compassion. But that is it.

Finally, karma is indestructible. Karma which is not purified and which has not matured dwells within the mind stream until the end of time. Then you can see why an understanding of karma is critical for us. If you are unhappy at present, it comes from past karma. Once that karma has started to manifest, it can no longer be purified.

You can attenuate it a bit. Purification is no longer possible. Before it has begun to manifest, it can be purified. And therefore, the effort for simple practitioners like us must go into a twin process of purification of past non virtue and accumulation of future virtue. This is manageable as long as we know how to purify, what was done in the past which we may know of if it was done in this life, or we may suspect if it comes from past lives, and accumulation of virtue for future lives.

Then we will cover in the rest of this presentation the process of maturation of karma, what virtuous and non virtuous karma is, how to purify it, to know how to behave in this way. Now a fundamental division of karma in terms of its importance is a distinction between projecting and completing karma. Projecting karma is karma which will impel or create, if you wish, an actual life, an actual rebirth. It’s obviously the heaviest type of karma in terms of its result. As a result of this karma, you will live the life of that being.

As a result, for instance, of ethical restraint, let us say, to give an example, 25 lives ago, and some of you maybe were British, you have been reborn in Australia. That karmic imprint is a projecting karma which has created this life. Within that life, just if you wish, projecting karma is like the canvas. And then, obviously, the quality of the painting does depend on the canvas. If you have a shoddy piece of canvas which falls to pieces, no painting has a chance to survive.

But fleshing the details inside the canvas, that is the function of completing karma. Completing karma covers the events within this life. One may have been reborn as a human being in Australia, this is a projecting karma, and then on top of that, one was, in addition to being ethical in a past life, extraordinarily generous. One might want to be born as a mining magnate, with for no particular reason billions of dollars at one’s disposition. Or one may have been an ethical person in a previous life, but a very short-tempered person, violent towards his or her family. As a result, one is reborn as a human being in this life, but one experiences numerous accidents, indeed violence.

So we have projecting karma defining the life, and completing karma fleshing it up. Then projecting karma can be virtuous or non virtuous, and the lives can be virtuous or non virtuous lives because of the ratio of suffering to happiness. Lives of gods or demigods in humans are lives which are overwhelmingly happier, whereas lives of animals, predators and hell beings are lives in which the amount of suffering is progressively higher, at least at its highest in the life of hell beings. So you can see that if karma can impel a rebirth and condition large swathes of that rebirth, it is very important to know what to practice and what to avoid. And in this respect, Buddha Śākyamūni taught 10 non virtuous deeds which were reformulated by Vasubandhu in his Abhidharma Kosha.

It’s a non exhaustive list. It is by no way, unfortunately, the list of all the non virtuous deeds one can do, and I have grouped them in terms of karmic amplitude. We have physical, verbal, and mental deeds. The least karmically potent deed is the verbal non virtue of gossip, followed by insults, followed by divisive speech, and followed by lying in function of the impact it has on the exterior life of the person. You can see that gossip has little impact apart from making one waste one’s time, whereas lying can lead someone to take a totally wrong decision.

And then moving upwards in terms of karmic amplitude, have sexual misconduct, adultery, but other forms of sexual misconduct, stealing, and obviously killing. However, mental deeds can also be very powerful karmically, and PowerPoint limits what I can do, so we start with the least harmful mental non virtuous deed, covetousness, a form of desire, if you wish, followed by harmfulness, and the most extreme form is wrong views, which always seems to Westerners to be some sort of dogmatic statement. It isn’t. Because basically, in function of your world view, you will choose to live and to act a certain way or not. If for instance, you are convinced that the fundamental principles of an ethical life are nonviolence, you will naturally lead quite a virtuous life.

If you are convinced that holy war, jihad, is legitimate and actually a road to heaven under certain circumstances, you will in perfect good conscience and faith engage in extremely non virtuous deeds. For this reason, wrong views are considered the heaviest of the mental non virtues. The most prevalent non virtue or mental non virtue which concerns us in the West is nihilism. What I called last year’s nihilism soft or soft nihilism. The sort of nebulous idea that basically there is nothing before birth and there is nothing after death.

That the mind is pretty much the brain, that nothing has really a lot of meaning and nothing has any consequences. Now such a viewpoint is never formulated that bluntly, but it is probably the dominant worldview in our society. Such a viewpoint destroys any foundation for ethics. And then you will only lead ethical lives until you are tempted. You will consider yourselves ethical persons until the opportunity of adultery arises, and having married someone who isn’t quite as successful as you wished him or her to be, upon being courted by someone who is extraordinarily successful and flamboyant, you will invent numerous rationalizations to engage in adultery, considering yourself throughout as an extremely ethical person.

Likewise, not facing any, and I can speak because I used to be a very wealthy person, not facing any particular financial temptations, you will consider yourself quite ethical in your management of money. Then it’s a very different story when you have a lot of money in the bank. Suddenly, possibilities which yield, let’s say, 12 or 14%, but which call for bending one’s principles a bit, become very tempting, as opposed to investment possibilities which yield, in those days, a 46%. Unless you have been able to found a solid ethics before, it will be impossible to adopt an ethical stance at this point. You will rationalize whatever type of behavior you wish to engage in.

This is the main argument in favor of normative ethics. For this reason, this presentation of the 10 non virtuous deeds is very helpful. I have listed here the permutations between projecting and completing karma, which really ties into the previous chart, but I wanted to bring up the 10 non virtuous deeds first. With good projecting comma and good completing comma, have a good rebirth in good conditions, so you’ll be born as a wealthy Australian. I won’t mention names, you have imaginations.

With good projecting karma and bad completing karma, you have a good rebirth, a human rebirth, but bad conditions. You’ll be reborn as an Indian beggar. With good projecting karma, excuse me, with bad projecting karma and good completing karma, you would have a bad rebirth with good conditions, and the best example I can think of are my wife’s two dogs, Bobby and Mindy, who are Westies, but who have living standards which would put children to shame in most countries in the world. Finally, with bad projecting karma and bad completing karma, you will be reborn as a dog in India. So you can see how it is critical to understand karmic mechanisms from a Buddhist standpoint if you want to take control of your rebirths.

This life is, broadly speaking, spoken for. The completing karma impelling this life has matured. The projecting karma has matured. We are born as human beings. The completing karmas are maturing as we speak.

You’re born in Australia, then other completing karmas may mature. You may, for instance, inherit, or you might go bankrupt. Those are completing karmas maturing in this life, but there’s relatively little control. From the next life onwards, you have complete control, if you understand the mechanisms. Now, what are the conditions which lead a given karma, karma in Sanskrit means deed, to its result?

In other words, what makes a karmic deed complete? What enables the arrow to strike the target for better or for worse? Why do we want to understand this? It’s not clear at a philosophical interest. It is because we want to live strategically.

Therefore, we want our virtuous deeds to be complete, and we want our non virtuous deeds to be incomplete. We strengthen our virtuous deeds as much as we can, and while we do try to avoid non virtuous deeds, the reality is that many of us are unable to avoid a lot of them, then we weaken them. And then we shift the karmic balance. So for a deed in general, virtuous or non virtuous to be complete, it must have a basis, a motivation, an actual performance of the deed, and a completion of the deed. And this is Je Tsongkhapa’s four point presentation.

I won’t enter too much into Asaṇga’s presentation, which is difficult, but if you can keep the four points in mind, basis, motivation, performance, completion, And analyze systematically before you engage into virtuous deeds, if all four are present, and if they are not, try to strengthen them. And when you feel that you are at the point of succumbing to non virtuous deeds to weaken one of the four, over time your situation will improve dramatically. Let us take one deed and see what will turn it into a complete deed, and I have chosen a deed of killing and a very controversial one, because it is extremely widespread. Late term abortion, which is very heavy deed of killing from a Buddhist standpoint. This is the actual mechanism of a late term abortion, which actually occurs through a partial delivery of the infant, and obviously in a late term abortion, the head is too large to leave the mother’s womb, and therefore the child is descerebrated.

The brain matter is sucked out from the skull, and the headless body with the remains of the skull are then flushed out of the mother’s womb. This, from a Buddhist standpoint, is a deed of killing. And in many cases, while late term abortions are generally illegal, they are allowed medically in some cases, and abortion is legal in most Western countries. So it is something we should be aware of. It’s illegal deed of killing in the West.

What is the basis? Remember we said that there are four components. Basis, motivation, performance, completion. The basis of killing is a living being, and according to some Buddhist thinkers, it has to be another living being and not oneself. You cannot kill a non living being, that’s pretty obvious.

But the question is, does suicide count as a deed of killing or not? It’s a non virtuous deed in either case. But for Je Tsongkhapa, suicide is a deed of killing. Whereas for the great Indian thinker Asaṇga, suicide is not a deed of killing, because one is putting an end to one’s own self. Personally, I follow Jetson Gopal’s review in the matter.

In either case, it is a heavy non virtuous deed, since it’s often accompanied by very negative mindsets. The basis must be present if, for instance, you shoot somebody with the intent to kill that person, but that person has already died at the time the bullet penetrates the body, you would not have completed a complete deed of killing because the base is not alive. If one were to perform an abortion and the infant to be aborted was actually dead, stillborn. Then, even if one went through all the motions with the motivation, the deed would not qualify as a complete deed of killing because the basis is not present. The motivation is critical.

First, one must have a correct perception of the being. This refers to, for instance, being hallucinated or under the influence of drugs. If someone who is insane sees a living being as a tree and chops the tree down, killing thereby that living being, this is not a complete deed of killing, because perception is absent. It’s non virtuous deed, but it cannot be said to be complete karmically. Motivation, the will, either general or specific, must be present.

The general wish to kill is this general statement, for instance, I am a doctor who performs late term abortions, and I’m fully aware that in so doing I’m putting an end to the life of these children. It’s a general wish to kill. A specific wish to kill is, I shall abort this child and no other. Either of these can be present, and for the deed to be a complete deed of killing, it must be performed under the influence of an affliction. In other words, desire, anger, or hatred.

If it is performed under the influence of a virtuous state of mind, it is not a complete deed of killing. For instance, if a doctor were to perform an abortion because the mother’s life was threatened, and the doctor, out of compassion for the mother, decided to perform this abortion, such a deed is a non virtuous deed, but it is not a complete deed of killing because the doctor is not motivated by an affliction. If the motivation was a wish to earn a salary, in other words, stupidity, it would become a complete deed of killing. Then I will skip rapidly the perception, the motivation we talked about, and regarding the affliction, which is really of concern for us, you can see three different afflictions leading to abortion. One can abort out of desire, thinking, let’s say the mother would think, will abort this fetus because otherwise my boyfriend will leave me.

He doesn’t want a child. This is desire. Or anger, I will abort this fetus because I hate to be a slave to my body. Or ignorance, which is very widespread, aborting a fetus thinking it doesn’t matter, it’s not alive or it’s not sentient. In either case, these are afflictions, and as such, contribute to a complete karmic deed.

The third feature for a complete karmic deed is performance, and it makes no difference whether one kills oneself or performs a deed oneself or orders another to do it. The general who orders a soldier to shoot another soldier accumulates the karma of killing in the self same way as a soldier who does the shooting, perhaps more so because he has greater freedom. The woman who requests an abortion accumulates a karma of killing just as the doctor who performs it. Perhaps again more so, you have to analyze the function of the situation. Neither case, whether one kills oneself or another, the means are irrelevant, whether it is in the case of an abortion with a scalpel or any weapon, with drugs or medicine, or for that matter through paranormal powers.

If one had the capacity to cause one’s prayers to come to fruition, while some Indian yogis have to concentration to cause events, and one were to prepare or concentration to cause an abortion, this qualifies as a deed of killing, for oneself or for another. The final feature for the deed to be complete is that as a result of the deed, the victim must die before the killer, otherwise the deed is not complete. So if the mother who has requested for an abortion dies before the abortion is complete, she has accrued a non virtuous deed, it’s not complete. It’s not a deed of killing. So if we look back rapidly on the features, you can see that it is critical to understand, to keep in mind, these four features for a complete karmic deed: a basis, a motivation, a performance, a completion.

And if one is in the very difficult situation in which one has to perform a non virtuous deed, one has to weaken these features. This means, in the case of an abortion, you cannot weaken the basis. The child is there. You can change the motivation from a motivation of anger with the child to perhaps a motivation of sadness and being pregnant. Regret at performing the abortion, this weakens the karmic nature of the deed.

It is still not virtuous deed, but weakens it. Performance, we will talk about this later in much greater detail. Obviously, the more painful and gruesome the deed, the heavier. Again, in mercy killings, for instance, which does happen commonly in hospitals, when I was young it was never spoken about, but my father is a cancerologist, we knew about many cases. In either case it must be as clean as is possible.

Then you can greatly reduce karmically the weight of the deed. Obviously, if you can transform the motivation into a virtuous motivation, then it’s yet another situation. So let us now enter into some more detail into our analysis. This is the path which leads to a complete deed of killing in the case of abortion. The initial thought is the abortion of a fetus.

If it is dead in utero, there is no killing. Whatever motions one goes through, comically. If it is alive, one must have the intent to kill the fetus. If the fetus dies by accident or if the fetus is aborted to save the mother, this does not qualify as a complete deed of killing. Then not only must there be an intent to kill, but a mindset which is afflicted.

I took the example of anger. If the mindset was compassion, again, it would not qualify as a complete deed of killing. Then with this mindset of anger, if the fetus is not aborted, again the deed is not complete. The fetus must be aborted, and if the fetus dies, after the abortionist or the parent, the deed is again not complete. The fetus must die before the abortionist or the parent.

In this case case, one has a complete deed of killing. Such a complete deed necessarily leads to a karmic result unless it is purified. So such a complete deed of killing necessarily leads to a rebirth in the lower realms, or in the case of a deed of killing a fetus, it’s very difficult to see how it could lead, It could be completing karma because the deed itself is very heavy. We will talk about the heaviness of the deed later. Now, as we said, we we have to put in place karmic strategies.

And one of the components we can include in a karmic strategy are vows. Vows and pledges amplify the potency of the deeds we engage in. If we take one day vows, for instance, then any virtue we accumulate during that day is magnified, and any non virtue we accumulate during that day is magnified by the vow. If we have monastic vows, novice or fully ordained monk vows, whatever virtue and non virtue we accumulate is greatly magnified. These vows function like amplifiers, like the amplifier in a stereo set, which amplifies both the music and the noise.

So you want to have a very nice CD, then you amplify music. And if there’s a lot of noise, you amplify noise. The amplifying potency of the vows depends on the power of the vow. If we have a karmic deed k zero, it can be amplified by the weight or the strength of the deed, which we shall talk about in the next couple of minutes. It can be amplified very heavily by patimoksha vows, the vows of individual liberation, novice monk and nun vows, lay vows, day vows, and so forth.

It will be amplified even more by Bodhisattva vows, since the focus of Bodhisattva vows is all beings, and the amplification of tantric vows is gigantic, since Pabongka Rinpoche says tantric vows inject an amplification of a factor of a 100,000. Karmic strategies entail taking on board levels of amplification which we can handle. Vows are like swords, which cut both ways. They can cut the foe or ourselves. The vow we protect works for us.

The vow we do not keep destroys us. The wise person does not take more vows than he or she can connect. I saw this many times in my life. It is very sad when one sees people often of good will who have taken on more vows than they can keep, and then the person’s life takes very much a turn for the worse, because vows are powerful. Vows are very powerful.

Normally, karma matures in future lives, but through the power of vows, karma can mature in this very life at the end of their life. Now the issue I’d like to address with you is weight or karmic amplification. This is this level of karmic amplification. I can see all your faces are very serious when I talk about this, and this is very good, it means we are communicating. If you were looking at me delightedly, would be very worried.

Karma is a serious topic. Karma can be amplified through attitude, performance, absence of any antidote, clinging to the perverse view and basis. And it is critical to understand this because we want to amplify virtuous deeds, and we want to make sure there is no amplification of non virtuous deeds. So first, we try to make our non virtuous deeds, but ideally we don’t do them. But if we are caught in a situation where we are doing them, we try to make them incomplete.

And then we try to eliminate any amplification. In the case of virtuous deeds, do exactly the opposite. We try to guarantee they are complete, and we co opt as much amplification as we can. So, what is amplification through attitude? The intensity of an affliction would qualify.

A deed performed with intense anger, when the person is shaking with anger, with intense desire, or profound ignorance, will tremendously amplify indeed. The greater the intensity of the affliction, the greater the karmic amplification. Amplification can also occur through performance. For instance, if we take the case of abortion, delighting in the abortion, being very glad that one has aborted, encouraging others to do it, writing about it, posting on the Internet on the importance of taking one’s life in one’s hands, premeditating it, talking very carefully about it with one’s physician, reading carefully, a very considered decision amplifies the deed. Doing it repeatedly, which is very common in Southeast Asia and in Eastern Europe, abortion has become a means of birth control.

Again, amplifies it. Doing with it with elaboration, a late term abortion. The fetus is ready for delivery. I describe the means which we use, which are barbaric. Finally, inflicting it onto someone who is defenseless.

Forced abortions in China, in Tibet. The very nature of an abortion is that an abortion is inflicted on someone who is defenseless. The fetus is defenseless, and the inflictor, the mother, has a close karmic relation with the fetus. So the deed as such is a heavy deed. The following factor which can amplify is the absence of any antidote.

The person has no vows, there is no purification applied, there is no shame. Shame and guilt are not non virtuous mental deeds as such. They are they are neutral deeds. Shame and guilt for a non virtuous deed is a virtuous state of mind. It’s something you should encourage within yourself.

Virtuous and feeling good are two very different things. A lot of virtuous deeds which don’t feel good, there’s a of non virtuous deeds which feel very good. So if you have done something wrong, the greater the sense of shame and the greater the sense of guilt, the better. It reduces the karmic weight of the deed. It may not feel good for this life, and I am fully aware that I’m flying smack in the face of pop psychology, but this is a Buddhist center.

I should point out that Rinpoche has told me privately many times when referring to Australians, and I am sorry to say this to you, they are a shameless people. Because as a culture, Australian culture, Western culture in general, but Australian culture, it’s extreme, not believe in shame. One has done something wrong, one makes believe it hasn’t been done. It’s very, very Australian. I’ve been here only four, five years, I find it quite striking the degree of denial sometimes you see with people.

Instead of, as we would say in in The States, just taking it on the chin like a man. I’ve done something wrong, I apologize, I will not do it again, feeling ashamed and embarrassed. This weakens the karmic power of the deed tremendously. Whereas if one hides a deed, if one refuses to recognize one has done it, then the deed becomes very heavy. So when I was in the monasteries, I was always very struck when I saw the older monks assessing the weight of an infraction, that one of the main factors they took into account was, has an attempt been made to hide it or not?

Any attempt made to hide it made the deed much heavier. Whereas if the person was profoundly ashamed and embarrassed, confessed the deed, this lightened the deed karmically, and from the monastery standpoint the response was different, very different. Then absence of antidote includes no merit accumulated, so the person has not had a virtuous life until then, and no particular understanding of the teachings, in other words, no understanding of how to reduce the karmic weight of something one has done. All of us make mistakes, but if one has studied the teachings, one understands how to reduce the weight of these mistakes. A fourth factor of amplification is clinging to the perverse, which is an extreme form of ignorance, to believe that it’s commendable and virtuous to engage in non virtuous deeds.

Holy war, which we have done in the West as well as any other group, abortion, animal sacrifices and whatnot. And finally, a fifth factor amplifying the deed is the basis. The closer the victim or the beneficiary, the more defenseless or the more holy, the weightier is the deed. So a close friend is a weightier object than someone we are indifferent to. A fetus is even closer, it’s a member of our family, and is defenseless.

Parents are probably this is my own assessment, I mean, you could probably redistribute these in terms of weight depending on your relation to these individuals. But if you were close to your parents, you have been on the receiving end of a lot of kindness from your parents, then non virtues committed towards your parents become very heavy. A monk by his status as a renouncement, and a bodhisattva by the vow to help others. So you can see that a given deed, which is complete, might be of moderate impact if it was, let’s say, let us say, harsh words uttered in anger because someone has defrauded us and uttered to someone we have never met, we just have met in a business setting. Such a deed would karmically be of moderate weight.

It’s a verbal non virtue speech, which is a moderate non virtue. It’s uttered with moderate anger. The recipient is someone we don’t know very well. They have defrauded us. In other words, there is actually some rationale for our anger.

It is a non virtuous deed which will mature in a future life. But words of extreme spite uttered as we are shaking with anger to our parents who have been extraordinarily kind to us, because they will not allow us to go to a party when we are 16, are words which karmically are extraordinarily heavy. They are heavy because of the emotion we are shaking with anger. They are heavy because there’s really no justification, and they are heavy because of the recipients, parents from whom we have received great kindness. So it is in this way through assessing the weight of our deeds that we can live strategically.

Now let us address the issue of the maturation of karma, and if I wanted to make a caricature I could say these are your choices. I think we all agree that it looks much much nicer up to the right, right? We have three categories of karmic maturation. Effects of maturation, causally concordant effects, and environmental effects. Effects of maturation we talked about already, higher or lower rebirths, one can be reborn as a human being, as a child.

This is an effect of maturation, that effect gives rise to an entire life. And these lives are included within the pyramid of cyclic existence. So the causes for rebirth from the hell realms to the god realms are what are known as mutable karma. This can be virtuous or non virtuous karma, but it is karma which is not created in one of the Dhyanas, one of the states of advanced meditation. Virtuous karma needs to rebirth as a human or demigod or a god.

Non virtuous karma to rebirth as an animal, a hungry ghost or even in the hell realms. Of these realms only two are visible to human beings, humans and animals. Others can be visible in meditation or through siddhi. But rebirth in this whole section of psychic existence occurs through virtuous or non virtuous deeds. Rebirth in the two higher God realms can only occur for advanced meditators through training in the jhanas.

The cause for this rebirth is known as immutable karma, it is actually meditative concentration. So if one has attained the first, the second, the third or the fourth dhyana, one will be reborn as a god of the form or the formless realm, which is misconstrued within Hinduism as liberation. These are actually states within psychic existence. Probably none of us in this room can ever hope to attain such a state. You would qualify if you attain calm abiding and progress to the first jnana.

These are the highest states within psychic existence. Then after the maturation effect, have the causally concordant effect, a complicated name to indicate a result which is similar to what caused it. You were reborn as a child, but because you were angry in your previous life, you were reborn as a human child with a strong proclivity towards anger. Anger arises easily. It could be desire, it could be ignorance, it could be spite, it could be envy.

If we see these proclivities within our mind, and one does see them in children, we know this probably comes from the past. Causally concordant effects are therefore effects with an a given life, which resemble the karmic cause which created them. I knew an Estonian girl, she had become a very good Buddhist practitioner, and she said two things to me, it was very striking. No, no real understanding of Buddhism when she said them, but those things which come from the heart are really striking. The first thing she said was that the most delightful smell she ever experienced was the smell of cow manure.

Then that one really struck me. I never heard of anyone who thought cow manure smelled really good. And then shortly after, she said that she took a particular delight in stealing. From infancy onwards, it was a source of happiness to her to steal. Now this is a causally concordant effect.

So this person has a human rebirth, the effect of maturation as a human being, then obviously must have engaged in stealing a lot in a previous life. The causally concordant effect is there’s a habituation with stealing. And then the environmental effect is the environment in which the person, is born, in this case, this girl was born in a very poor family, which is the environmental result of stealing poverty. This is a picture from Iraq, from the Guardian. You would be reborn in a country in a state of war, as a human being, as an environmental result of having engaged in violence in previous lives.

Then, obviously for us, it is very important to subdivide the deeds we engage in, and try to make sure that whatever virtuous deeds we have mature as higher rebirths, and then if we engage in heavy non virtuous deeds, to try to modify the deed as much as we can so that they mature as causally concordant effects or environmental effects, to try to reduce, in other words, the potency of the non virtuous deeds. Now let us take an example of how all of this might function. Karmic maturation of a deed of killing. In the first life, one commits a complete deed of killing with four features. A base, an intention, a performance, and a completion is complete.

This deed as a ripening effect leads in some future life one plus k, doesn’t have to be the next life, it can be ten, twenty lives down the line, to rebirth in a hell realm. That is an entire rebirth. That at the end of that rebirth, when the karma, the maturation karma is exhausted, in future lives one will have short brutal and violent lives. And even later on, one will live in a violent country in which the food is bad and the medicine is ineffective. In red you have the causally concordant effect, and in green you have the environmental effect.

And down the lives, one will still enjoy violence and killing through habituation from this first life, which can lead again to another complete deed of killing. At which point, the whole cycle begins again. And then the habituation obviously becomes greater and greater over time. So the question which arises now is, we have huge amounts of complete karmic deeds in store within our mind stream. What matures first?

And according to Vasubandhu, and I think the overwhelming majority of Tibetan Buddhist scholars agree, the heaviest karma accumulated matures first. Therefore, it is critical that our virtuous deeds be heavy and our non virtuous deeds be light. If, broadly speaking, we have deeds of equal weight within our mind stream, it’s the karma which manifests at death, which matures first, which causes the next life. If that is equal, it is habit which kicks in. We may not have performed deeds which are particularly heavy, but we perform them every day.

They might be prostrations, if we take virtuous deeds, or it might be white lies, if we take non virtuous deeds. It’s not very heavy, but we performed it every day. And finally, if all of these are equal, is a comma done first. So what we see here is that there are three components which are really important. Heavy karmas must be controlled.

It is critical that the time of death be peaceful, and that the person be encouraged to have virtuous thoughts which will cause a virtuous karma to mature at death and lead to a happy rebirth. And habits must be turned into something to our advantage. Habits are things generally which work to our disadvantage, But if we can gain small virtuous habits, it’s a very easy way to transform ourselves over the weeks, the months, and the years, and to eventually improve. And I think this has been one of the very great lessons which Khensur Rinpoche gave us. If you can lead a, or if we can lead, a regimented life, fairly monotonous, in which we engage in virtue consistently, over time this can have tremendous impact.

Now regarding the speed of maturation of karma, how quickly can karma mature? Generally, karma matures in future lives, but for extremely heavy or weighty deeds, karma can mature in this life, at the end of this life. Deeds committed towards one’s teachers, towards one’s parents, deeds of extreme cruelty or of extreme kindness can mature in this life. It is rare to see a dictator who dies in bed. If you take the greatest dictators of the twentieth century, Stalin and Hitler, both had very difficult deaths.

As you know, Stalin was poisoned and was left in agony in his rooms for days. It seems the deal was performed by Lavrenty Beria, the head of his intelligence agency, and died crying for help. You all know of Hitler’s death. These are probably the maturation of extreme non virtues in this very life. So the question at present is how does one purify past and present negative karma?

It’s a given we have it. You can see here the Barkhor around Lhasa, where Tibetans engage in the simple practice of prostration with repentance for non virtuous deeds, to try to purify their past non virtues. It’s a simple and powerful practice for simple people. Purification is not easy. To purify, one must confess one’s non virtuous deeds.

If one is a monk or a nun, it may be to one’s abbot. If one has Bodhisattva or Tantric vows, to one’s Guru or to the visualized assembly. But even though confession has been performed, karmic purification is not automatic. As Je Tsongkhapa says, it is not definite that some particular person can eliminate their karma. Nonetheless, confession is not senseless, because this is all we have.

So confession must be engaged in over and again until we get clear signs of purification of karma. These signs you will know if you study the great texts to receive teachings, they can be dreams, dreams of purification, of meeting one’s teachers, particular experiences of lightness, then one is entitled to think that perhaps some of that non virtuous karma has been purified. How does one purify karma? One uses the four forces. The first is the force of the base.

Non virtuous karma is accumulated either with respect to others, other living beings, or with respect to Buddhas. If it’s accumulated with respect to others, main means to purify it is a practice of bodhichitta, since when we practice bodhichitta, we commit to attain full enlightenment for the sake of others. If it is committed with respect to the Buddhas, the Buddhas themselves are not affected by our non virtuous deeds, but we are very heavily affected by these, then we should recite sutras, the Confession sūtra, for instance. The second of the four forces is remorse. As Milarepa said, the greater the remorse, the greater the purification.

By remorse I mean repentance, shame, guilt. The more powerful the guilt, the greater the purification of non virtuous deeds. The third force is a force of self restraint. This is the pledge not to engage in that deed again. It is in mental determination.

If it is a deed we find very difficult to avoid, such as drinking, let us say, then we take this pledge for a length of time which we can handle one day, two days, a week. Then, once we have finished this one day period, I think if we’re Australian, we have to relax a bit, but then, after a couple days, one can take the pledge again. Then over the weeks, over the months, one becomes accustomed to restraint. Eventually, can take this pledge for longer periods of time, and one’s mind stream improves. Finally, the actual antidote is the fourth force, is the actual process of purification.

One can recite the name of the Tathāgata, as in the Confession sūtra of the 35 Buddhas, which is mainly for purifying Mahāyāna infraction, one can recite mantras, sutras in the Mahāyāna or the Theravada tradition, one can meditate on emptiness or selflessness, one can perform offerings, one can erect statues of the Buddhas, but this is subsidiary to the central component of purification, which is remorse. It is remorse which actually purifies. If there is no remorse and one just engages in the deed, it is far from clear whether there is purification or not. The question is not one of social formalism, the question is one of karmic maturation. Will this deed mature or not?

So this is why Je Tsongkhapa said, Buddha said that non virtues are light for the knowledgeable who regret their non virtues, restrain themselves, do not conceal their sins and do virtuous actions as remedies. However, non virtues are weighty for those who make a pretense of being knowledgeable and do not do these deeds. There’s a famous Tibetan proverb, the non virtue of the wise is light, and the non virtue of the simple is heavy. It is profoundly unfair, but it is very true. The wise understand the mechanisms of purification of karma and even engaging in the heavy deeds put great effort at purification, such as Jetsün Milarepa, the greatest Tibetan yogi, who, to revenge the torments which were inflicted on his mother, killed most of his in laws using black magic, and was nonetheless able to attain full enlightenment in one lifetime through ascetic practices which beggar the imagination.

So clearly, if someone knows something about purification, Milarepa does. And Milarepa says, it is the greater the remorse, the greater the purification. There are categories of karma which are said to be impossible to purify. Specifically karma accrued with respect to a community and the Sangha in particular. Because the Sangha as a community is constantly changing, and is therefore an extremely powerful and potentially dangerous karmic object.

If we have a Sangha of 10 members in a small monastery, perhaps the most dangerous position karmically is that of intendant of the monastery. If the intendant of the monastery takes for his own usage something which is not allowed for him to use, let’s say, something as simple as a broom which has value, which he has not been allowed to use by the Sangha, and uses it, and then realizes he has committed a non virtuous deed, let’s say a year, a year and a half later, such a deed is very difficult, if not impossible, to purify, because the Sangha will have changed in the meantime. New monks will have come, old monks will have will have left. He may operate restitution, but the restitution will not be to the same community. And for this reason, we are taught that among karmic objects, the Sangha, and by extension any community, the community of a dharma center, is a dangerous karmic object.

Basically because even small deeds are amplified and are very difficult, it is set or impossible to purify, simply because the community keeps changing. So let us see if there are some metaphors which enabled us to understand better karma and causality. You may have heard of fractals, which are extremely interesting mathematical objects, self replicating objects. See, if you look at this fractal, you can see that the large design is actually reproduced inside itself. If you were to take a magnifying glass, can be reproduced inside itself indefinitely.

Fractals seem to me to be a very good metaphor for karma. There are some criteria which are necessary for fractals. One doesn’t concern us, fractal dimension. To do, self similarity and recursive generation. Self similarity means, and recursive generation, both mean the function invokes itself.

Now we can see when I was a young student of mathematics, this had a big impact on me. In fact, I don’t know if you are attuned to mathematics or you feel like vomiting when I talk of mathematics, so if you are in the first category, please listen. If you’re in the second category, think of something else. But fractal functions such as Weierstrass functions are functions which reproduce themselves inside themselves. If you were to, let’s say, amplify this section, you would find here a copy of the whole function, and as you keep on magnifying, you find more and more similes of the function within it.

This is very common in natural phenomena. You find that snowflakes, for instance, have a fractal structure. You find a copy of the snowflake within itself. Coastlines typically are fractal. It’s very striking, not exact fractals, but stochastic or approximate fractals.

If you magnify the British coastline, you can see within the British coastline what looks like subcoastlines. The lungs show a fractal structure. The vascular structure of the lungs, if magnified, seems to show almost a replica of itself. So do of all things, cauliflowers, you can see this very clearly here, and so do ice and snowflakes. So how does that concern us in the context of karma?

Because something very similar seems to be at work over the lives with karma. The first rebirth after a non virtuous deed in a of killing is a hell rebirth, but in the next rebirth linked to that, we find factors akin to hell. This is a recursiveness, the repetition, a liking to kill, as well as an environment which is harsh. In the following rebirth, we still find the liking to kill in a harsh environment, and eventually a new need of killing may lead us into the same cycle. So there is, and I don’t want to stretch the metaphor, but there is some type of similarity in fractals, which are mathematical objects, and karma.

In the case of fractals, have self similarity as you magnify the fractal, you see more and more of the same. In the case of karma, you can see that these three categories of effects, ripening causal and environmental, share key similarities and fractals show recursive generation, in other words, they invoke themselves, you have a function with a function as an argument, you have the same thing in karma where the deed of killing eventually leads to another deed of killing, lives down the line. It’s not a necessity, but it is a strong tendency. Then I could not resist to show you a picture of this beautiful painting of Hokusai, the great wave at Kanagawa, which actually uses a fractal structures. And I would like to conclude with a quote from His Holiness to try to connect what we have done today with the situation of the world at large.

We see it really since 2001 and 2008, but even perhaps earlier. As I listen to the constant stream of reports about money and finance, about crises, conflicts and war, it often strikes me that the complex problems we face in the world, problems of corruption, environment, politics and so on, almost always indicate a failure of moral ethics and inner values. At every level, we see a lack of self discipline. Thank you very much. Then, if you are not too tired, I will be glad to take whatever questions you might have.

Yes, please. It’s unknown. Until now it was thought that it was impossible for quantum phenomena to manifest at a level higher than the molecular. With very simple molecules like an H4, which are small molecules, then a cell is gigantic by that standard. This recent British study very shocking, there’s no other word for it, because it means that quantum phenomena are manifesting at orders of magnitude which are basically billions of times what was thought possible.

I mentioned the study, it’s still in the process of being confirmed. If it’s true, it’s revolutionary, because one of the direct consequences is that quantum phenomena might manifest at the level of the neuron. Then this is what physicists like Henry Stapp have been saying for a long time, which is that the brain is actually a neuro quantum mechanism. And this opens the door to the mind body interface issues which he and others have been addressing. This is very interesting research, very interesting.

Thank you very much, Ilya. My question is about time and the multiplication of karma. It’s not about the quantity of, multiplication. In my own basic understanding and using some basic logic, the only reason that I can really think of other than relying on scripture for a karma to multiply over time is because it has to satisfy or it allows the satisfaction of the first karma to be, experienced before the second. The cause of the, first karmic deed to be experienced before the second karmic deed.

That is the only, reason that I can think of in a logical way that would necessitate, karma multiplying. I’ve had tried to have a look at the sources that Je Tsongkhapa relied on in the Lamrim Chenmo for this multiplication. And I asked Geshe-la a question one time, he said he would look it up, but I don’t think he had time. I understand that this is a very complex issue, and I’m very keen to find, this the original sūtra or reference that gave birth to this, this idea. I must give you the same answer as Geshela.

I have to look it up. Je Tsongkhapa points it out as something which is so uncommon, it differentiates ordinary causality from karma and causality. So I did use the technical terminology, but one speaks of inner and outer interdependence. Inner interdependence is interdependence within the context of the 12 links. Outer interdependence would be causal interdependence of physical phenomena, such as, let us say, I don’t know.

You spark a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, and you end up with molecules of water, h two o, you know, then you have a causal relationship between the two. Now according to Je Tsongkhapa, the distinction between inner and outer interdependence is this process of amplification, which characterizes the 12 links, but does not characterize the exterior causality. Then in the case of karma, as you know, there are three categories of phenomena in Buddhist philosophy. Outer phenomena, which are accessible to the senses, phenomena which are accessible to an inferential valid cognizer, in other words, to logic, and extremely subtle phenomena, which are only accessible to an inferential valid cognizer based on conviction. Most categories which or phenomena which interest us as Buddhists fall in the first two categories, especially the second category.

Phenomena accessible to an inferential valid cognizer, in other words, The general features of karma fall within this category, but the specific instances of karma fall within the third category, In other words, they cannot be substantiated through logic alone. It is the Buddha’s omniscience which was able to determine these facts, because you are actually looking at processes which occur over a huge number of lives, and even very advanced clairvoyances are unable to do this. I hope that answers your question. I’m having a dialogue with my vet at the moment because I have a dog who is failing with some sort of liver disease. Clearly I don’t want to euthanize the dog but I want you to comment on my vet’s point of view which is that in this privileged country I have the power to save this dog much suffering in the terminal parts of her illness.

How does that influence karma and what do you think of that as an approach? My motivation is to save her from suffering but I feel like it’s the wrong thing to do. The question really is whether you look at this life alone or many lives. If you look at this life alone, then the vet’s position is illogical position. Indeed, if this life is all there is, then humane euthanasia is probably the way to go forward.

If you look at many lives, then this rebirth as a dog is one which has led to the maturation of a karmic non virtue, manifesting as an effect of maturation in this life. The difficult death, all deaths are difficult, but liver cancer is difficult, enables further maturation of non virtue. If that non virtue can be allowed to mature in this life, it will not mature in the future. I think certainly from a Tibetan Buddhist standpoint, you would be encouraged to do everything you can to assuage a dog’s pain, pain killers, but to allow the natural process to run its course. The same thing applies to human beings.

Then obviously within the realm of possibility. As you yourself are the owner of the dog, you are close to the dog, therefore such decisions do carry a certain amount of karmic weight for you as a person. The problem is she’s been a loyal faithful friend and I don’t want to part with her, I don’t want to kill her, but I don’t want her to suffer. Well I think there are many means now even in veterinary science to reduce the suffering with painkillers, all sorts of means. Chris Ridley had the same problem with his dog and Rinpoche also encouraged Chris to just let things follow their natural course.

I think it’s preferable. Madam, first perhaps. If you go into the lower realms as a rebirth, To be reborn again out of those realms, I mean is the same process of rebirth as we have in the human and animal kingdoms, the same type of procreation, the same in other realms or how do you how are you reborn or how do you have a rebirth in those lower realms? I mean, by what process? It depends.

There are four types of rebirth according to Abhidharma. You have rebirth from an egg, from a womb, miraculous rebirth, rebirth from heat and moisture. Now, rebirth from an egg and from a womb are what we call oviparian and mammalian rebirths, which we see in the animal reign. Miraculous rebirth occurs for some of the gods and in some of the hell realms. Then rebirth from heat and moisture basically is probably what we would call spontaneous generation with fungi and certain modes.

If you take the various animal realms, mammals have excuse me, animals have both oviparian and mammalian rebirth. Preta’s, according to the Buddhist texts, are born from the womb. Preta mothers deliver their children. In the hell realms, normally the rebirth is miraculous. In other words, not miraculous in the good sense of the term, it’s not a very nice thing, but instantaneous.

Then the precise nature of the hidden realms, that is very discussed. That they exist, I think, one thinks really carefully, is not difficult to understand. Whether they are really realms like the one we live in at present with a physical location, or some of the Buddhist texts say located under Bodhgaya, that is another question. My root teacher Geshe Rabten said that in his opinion the hell realms were mental. I’m quite sympathetic to that viewpoint myself.

Does that answer your question? Are there other questions? Thanks Elia, for your lecture. Elia I’m just a little confused about if someone is born in the human realm, someone is born in the human realm in a very wealthy position say. A good position.

Yes, yes very wealthy but they do really bad things so they were you know a person of great influence but they do really bad things how do those two things come together? Because surely if they’re born in a human realm with a lot of wealth and privilege they’ve done a lot of good things. How do they then do all these bad things? Well, which is not uncommon, yes. It’s very common.

Basically, the karma of maturation led to a human rebirth. Then they also had, they had both a good projecting and completing karma, human rebirth, and life as a wealthy person. You have, however, a causally concordant karma from perpetuation in past lives, which starts to mature. They’re not born as a human being, they are very wealthy, but in some previous lives, for instance, they were accustomed to abusing of their power. They may have been very generous, they may have been ethical, but they may have been bossy as only the head of a state or a dictator can be.

This can lead to excess. Capricious, perhaps, in a previous life? Yes. You would have to look at the individual situation and then to know what the specific cause of a specific karmic effect is, that is very difficult. Karmic effects share a similarity with their cause.

You can say something general. For instance, someone who has a violent temper in this life, if there’s nothing in this life to justify it, from a child who just gets a violent temper, this is a comic result which arises from a comic cause which is similar to it at some point in the past. In other words, in the past this person indulged heavily in anger. Then in this life, this person can start to restrain this anger. If they do, in the future they may have a slight proclivity to being hot tempered, but much less.

Even in this life they can perhaps eliminate it or at least over time do so, you know, and can improve. Keep in mind also that it is All of us in this room are basically from the standpoint of society are ordinary people. We are not very wealthy, we have no real power, no one listens to us, we don’t matter. Then we are virtuous because we have no choice. Right?

It’s a very different situation to have real power, which I think perhaps nobody in this room has had. To have billions of dollars to be at the head of the state, to have everyone stand up when you enter in the room and bow, then slight weaknesses in the character become very quickly very powerful. Very quickly. I mean, a case in point is if you study the lives of some of the great dictators. If you read the life of Adolf Hitler, Adolf Hitler was actually a very nice child by all accounts.

He’s a very sweet boy, very devoted to his parents, to his mother especially, who died of cancer, cancer of the throat, I think. And you and some of you may know this, his mother’s treating doctor was Jewish, and Hitler attributed later on in life his mother’s death to this doctor. Then as Hitler progressed in life, you have if you read the life of Hitler’s face, like, a very sensitive person. An artist studied architecture, not very successful, a young German who was idealistic, was courageous. He volunteered in the army, he was not physically fit, he served during the first World War as a male nurse.

He was awarded the, Iron Cross, which, take my word for it, was not easily given, especially to male nurses. So this was a man of undeniable courage and integrity. Then what happened? Here you have somebody, if you look at their early childhood, there’s nothing which should lead this person to becoming one of the most feared and hated dictators in human history. And there are explanations, but I think they are a little bit beyond this this presentation.

Ilya was rereading the chapter in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand and it mentioned different types of karma and said one of them was karma accumulated without doing anything, and I didn’t understand that. Yes, for instance the karma of rejoicing. Rejoicing is a very powerful means to accumulate karma. If, for instance, one rejoices in a virtuous deed, depending on one’s own spiritual level, one can attain, accumulate karma which is inferior, equal, or superior to that of the person who has done the deed without doing anything oneself. Likewise for non virtuous deeds.

When we confess non virtuous comma, we say, which I have done, I have led another to do, which I have rejoiced in. Rejoicing is a particularly powerful means to accumulate karma, and it is powerful and dangerous. We live in democracies, we talk of the news all the time. If we rejoice in our country’s going to war, we accumulate the karma of killing. Depending on the specificity of our rejoicing, we can accumulate a very large karma of killing.

If we rejoice in, for instance, someone’s getting ordained, we accumulate an important part of the karma of their getting ordained, that virtue. Therefore we have to be very careful with our minds, our minds’ reaction to events, because without acting physically ourselves, just through our mental response to events we can accumulate a lot of karma. This is why Je Tsongkhapa said, and I think Pabongka Rinpoche repeats it, Rejoicing is the most powerful practice of all. In our case, for instance, we may not be able, as Bill Gates did say, to fund research worldwide against malaria, but we can rejoice from the depths of our hearts, then we accumulate great virtue. Here at the center, I was very surprised last year, when Osama bin Laden was assassinated, because this is really what happened, that some students rejoiced in his death, publicly.

Then someone asked me, I said, You have accumulated the karma of killing. Depending on the intensity of the rejoicing, more of a karma of killing than the people from SEAL Team 6 from interior. So rejoicing is very powerful in both ways. Does that answer your question? Yes, thank you.

Didn’t realize it included mental. Thought it was saying you didn’t do anything, I couldn’t understand. Yes, yes. I was wondering if you could speak to what I think is a general misconception of karma in the West. I’m not quite sure exactly why it’s not true, I just don’t think it is.

That’s this idea of karma that, you know, say if I splash a glass of water over you, then in three years time I will get a glass of water splashed over me. And it’s quite erroneous I think, but I’m not really, I don’t understand why. Well, it’s a bit of a caricature, right? Because karma doesn’t mature in three years normally, and then obviously it’s never exactly the same thing. But as all caricatures, it’s rooted in some reality, which is that the effect is similar to the cause.

It’s of a similar type. It’s not identical. So, I hope you haven’t gone around splashing glasses of water on people, but if you have, you may not have someone splash a glass of water on you, but since karma is amplifying, it might be a huge bucket. Does that go towards answering You your can understand an awful lot of karma if you think that karma is similar in type to its effect. Karma is the deed, the cause.

Right? The root kri in Sanskrit means to do, you know. Then the effect shares something with the karma. Right? It is not exactly similar, but the fruits of chill of the chili plant which has grown from chili seeds have something in common with those chili seeds.

If you plant chili seeds, you will not get pears, however hard you try. How do you differentiate it from the karma which has been attenuated by purification? Don’t understand what you mean by how I You you differentiate have the karma, matured karma, alright? And you can, it goes back to the cause of the previous lives, which is, is that purported? And my question is, if that, how do you differentiate a karma which is proportional to the cause and a comma matured comma which is which could have been much, much more serious in the previous lives Then it’s been purified or Someone with clairvoyance would know.

We don’t have clairvoyances, we simply don’t know. For us, really, the priority is to purify as much as we can. Then in our cases, in this life, know what we did. So we know what to purify. In past lives, we don’t know what we did.

Then it’s better to have a scattergun approach. You purify everything on the assumption that in past lives we have committed deeds of killing, we have committed deeds of theft, of sexual misconduct, of lying. A very great German writer, Hermann Hesse, once said that he could see all the sins and evils of humanity within himself. I think it is very true. I think if we are really sincere with ourselves, we put self righteousness to the side, we look inside ourselves, probably there’s not one of us in this room who can say, There is one heinous deed I would never do, whatever the circumstances, whatever my upbringing, whatever the situation.

It’s very difficult to say that. My family experiences particularly, you see, my family was largely massacred during World War II, in the civil war in Yugoslavia, and what we saw was very striking, it was that perfectly ordinary people became monsters, and that other perfectly ordinary people became saints, and nobody knew. Nobody knew. You know? Nobody knew.

There was no way to predict. No way to predict, you know. My father saw many such cases. He was in a concentration camp. Didn’t, you know He said it was during the events you could see.

And the Tibetans, I have known closely, have told me the same thing. Because after the Chinese occupation was actually in the tragedy, in the crisis, that some people had extraordinary resources nobody had ever suspected, and others, high lamas, went to pieces. You see? So I think we should have a lot of humility and hope that when we are tested, we fare pretty well. I think it’s good to look inside oneself.

Very good. Do you have any more questions? Yes. In the examples, had several times someone falling into the lower realms and then obviously after a long time being born again as a human and talked about habituation. But my question is, I understand it’s very difficult once you fall into the lower realms to get out, how does that occur?

It’s very difficult. That’s why I put a pyramid of the realms because from a Buddhist standpoint, most beings are in the lower realms. Then it only happens because of pre existing karmic imprints prior to their falling at the lower realms, which encounter circumstances which allow them to mature. It’s difficult. I have karmic strategies for our two dogs, and they hinge on teaching our dog Bobby how to restrain his appetite for food, which is very difficult, but I hope it will lead to some virtuous manifestations.

And to control our dog, Mindy’s, how should I call it, coquettishness. Then, thank you very much for today. Just a quick commercial before everyone goes. If you haven’t had a look at the symposium that will be in August, I think it’s tenth and eleventh I think off the top of my head. Please check it out on our website.

We do have posters here as well. There’s a lot more detail on the website and having been to a couple in the past, they’re fantastic experiences and very similar to this type of format. If you would like, please come along and prices and that are on the website and on the posters. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
siddhi ngö drub (Tib)
A realization or attainment, either common or supreme. Common siddhis refer to psychic powers acquired as a by-product of the spiritual path; supreme siddhi refers to great liberation or enlightenment. LYWA
tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

If someone is born human with great wealth and privilege, they must have done much good, so how can they then do terrible things?

This is very common. The karma of maturation led to a human rebirth, and good projecting and completing karma gave a life as a wealthy person. But a causally concordant karma from perpetuation in past lives can start to mature, for example a habit of abusing power or being bossy, even in someone who was generous or ethical. Karmic effects resemble their causes, though the specific cause is very hard to identify. Ordinary people with no power are virtuous because they have no choice. With real power, wealth and everyone bowing, slight weaknesses of character quickly become very powerful.

Scroll to Top