Nature of Mind – 2015-04-03 – KR

1 h 29 min · 3,092 words · 3 April 2015

Nature of Mind (Khensur Rinpoche)
Nature of Mind (Khensur Rinpoche)
Nature of Mind - 2015-04-03 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaching on the twelve links of dependent origination, explaining ignorance as a mental factor that drives karma and how karma impels future higher or lower rebirths. It contrasts karma with the afflictions behind it, notes that reflecting on selflessness makes virtuous deeds a cause for liberation, and includes a question and answer session on emptiness, cyclic existence and the ten non-virtues.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 29m

UUID: 069d5de2-708b-48c2-8289-6676bfc727dd

Date: 2015-04-03

Words: 3,088

Then tomorrow and after tomorrow, after lunch, it is it will be pleasant to go for a walk in the parks around here. Then while one is having lunch, it is or it would be of benefit to discuss the 12 limbs of dependent origination and to exchange questions and answers. And this is the case because in such a way, you can address your doubts regarding the 12 links and improve your understanding and your studies. So if we summarize the presentation of the 12 links in this chart, you have three causal links followed by four effect links, followed by another three causal links, which is the actualizing limbs, followed by two effect links, the actualized limbs. And the first group of three limbs, these three projecting limbs or these three projecting causes comprise ignorance, compositional factors, and consciousness.

These three actualizing limbs include or comprise craving, appropriation, and existence. Then the four projected limbs are name and form, the six loci, contact and sensation. And the two actualized limbs, the two actualized effects are the eleventh and the twelfth limb birth and aging and death grouped as one in the twelfth limb. So the presentation of the 12 links is therefore done in this way starting with the three first links, ignorance, compositional factors, and consciousness which are the three projecting causes or the three projecting limbs. And regarding the first limb, this is the limb of ignorance which is defined in Jetsun Chökyi Gyaltsen’s Ancillary Topics on Perfections as a mental factor ignorant regarding suchness which has become the motivation of impelling karma and is subsumed within one series of dependent arisings with itself.

Page three of your definitions. So it is important to understand that ignorance which is subsumed within the 12 links is from within main minds and mental factors a mental factor. So what could one give us an instance of ignorance from within the 12 links of dependent arising for an ordinary being. This would for instance be the innate apprehension of self or the view of the disintegrating composite within the continuum of an ordinary being. So this ignorance which can be either grasping at a self, the view of the composite aggregates or mere ignorance within the 12 limbs is what is the motor of karma?

And it should be understood in terms of its nature, its definitions and its instances. Well, listen carefully, and I will try to explain this as clearly as possible. So generally speaking one could say there are three different types of impelling karma. There is the impelling karma for a virtuous rebirth, the impelling karma for a non-virtuous rebirth and the impelling karma for good objects of enjoyment in a virtuous rebirth. So when we speak of karma, what are we referring to?

Karma is a part of the mind. It is a mental factor and its function is to push the mind towards its object, an object which is concordant with it. So it might be easier to understand if it is put in this way, the function of karma is to push the mind towards activity which is in keeping with it. So what are the modes of accumulation of impelling karma? It is a fourfold process.

Initially, ignorance, the first step of the process gives rise to either desire or anger, the second step of the process. Motivated by either desire or anger, the mind in turn is orientated or focused towards an object. The fourth step of the process is an action with respect to that object. So as was explained previously, one can distinguish three types of impelling karma, karma which impels towards the higher rebirth, towards the lower rebirth and which impels objects of enjoyment. Now regarding the first category, how does karma impel towards a higher rebirth?

Do we understand? So if we understand the topics in this way incrementally, first, second, third topic, then this will be a great benefit to us. So returning to our fourfold presentation of the accumulation of impelling karma, one starts out with ignorance and this ignorance in turn causes one to divide beings between oneself and others. On this basis, desire arises and this desire amplifies and turns into craving. This is the second point.

The craving then gives rise to a wish or an aspiration, the wish for a higher rebirth for oneself in future lives. In dependence on this wish, the mental factor of intention orients the mind towards its object and causes it to engage in deeds in keeping with it. Impelled by this intention, the mind is then focused on an object and engages in physical or verbal deeds in accordance with this. If at this point, one engages in the practice, let us say of prostrations or the recitation of mantra, one will have accumulated what is known as virtuous karma. So this is for virtuous impelling karma.

On the other hand, should one engage in verbal or physical activity with the intent of harming the life of another, Then one will accumulate non-virtuous impelling karma which will lead to a rebirth in the lower realms. Should one, however, restrain from this, one will accumulate virtuous impelling karma. So what does therefore karma impel here? It impels in a future life a higher or lower rebirth. So how at present would one accumulate non-virtuous impelling karma causing rebirth in the lower realms.

In the four step sequence presented previously, initially there would be apprehension of an I followed by the arising of an affliction such as anger. This would lead the mind to focus upon a deed in keeping with that. And the fourth point would be the performance of a verbal or physical deed. So if we analyze this in greater detail, we can see that from apprehension of an I, the ignorance which apprehends an I arise simultaneously the distinction between self and other, mine and others. This in turn gives rise to a sense of others as being at odds or in disharmony with oneself, which gives rise to the concept of enemy.

Then, once one starts thinking in this way, one day the wish to harm the life force of one’s enemy arises. This is the second point. At the third point, the mind focuses on deeds which are in keeping with that intent and this leads to the fourth point, which is verbal or physical action harming the life force of another person. At this point, one will have accumulated a non-virtuous impelling karma causing rebirth in the lower realms. Then regarding the third type is which leads to enjoyment in future lives, should one wish to experience good results in future lives?

Then motivated by the ignorance which apprehends a self, which is step one, one then engages or one then generates an intention which is motivated by the wish of experiencing prosperity as a result in future lives and motivated by this wish, one’s mind in turn turns towards objects in keeping with this and one engages in deeds such as giving food or giving money to another with the hope of experiencing happiness in future lives as a result. When this karma has arisen, the very second instant of that comma is an intention, which is a mental factor and this has the potency to stain or to implant a karmic imprint within the consciousness of the person concerned which is the third limb from within the 12 limbs. Now within this sequence, ignorance is considered to be a mental factor, impelling karma is a mental factor, and for that matter so is motivation. There is some doubt regarding beginningless ignorance in this matter. The question we should address every time to determine whether we are dealing with a mental factor or not is whether the concerned entity is a part of the mind or not.

If it is, then it is a mental factor which is part of the entourage of a main mind. Then it is evident that there is cyclic existence within our mind stream since anger and the coarse afflictions are present within our mind stream. Through reflecting repeatedly over the faults of these afflictions, the wish to be freed from them will arise within our mind stream. At this point in general, all of the physical, verbal and mental deeds we engage in become virtuous deeds. Specifically, one should endeavor to reflect on the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons as much as possible, even though it may be very difficult for us to realize it.

One should keep in mind that all of the deeds of body, speech and mind engaged in within a reflection on the selflessness of persons become automatically thereby a cause for liberation. So we shall stop here. At present, I would like you to ask questions, One question per person, clearly formulated. And then after everyone has asked a question, you can ask more questions if you have any. All deeds of body, speech and mind engaged in within the context of reflecting on the selflessness of persons become automatically thereby the cause for liberation.

So this is an extremely important point from Lamrim Chenmo. If after repeatedly focusing on the thoughts of the afflictions, one generates a wish to be freed from the afflictions and one engages in virtuous deeds of body, speech and mind. Should these virtuous deeds of body, speech and mind be subsumed by an understanding of the selflessness of persons or an understanding of emptiness. They are not only virtuous deeds, but they become a cause for liberation as well. Yeah?

So one must distinguish. If such a scholar is studying these texts after seeing the faults of cyclic existence and with a profound desire to be freed from cyclic existence, then any understanding of the surfaces of persons accrued in this way when it is conjoined with virtuous deeds becomes a foundation for the attainment of liberation. However, if it is a mere study of the view out of curiosity without such a desire, that is not the case. So it is for this reason that when questions are asked regarding emptiness, what we should say is in general, questions regarding emptiness are good questions. However, from your standpoint, do you actually understand what cyclic existence is and do you understand what the faults of cyclic existence are?

If you do, your questions on emptiness are profoundly meaningful. Otherwise, it’s just blah blah. So we have no access to the motivation of the other party, so we must examine their motivation. Then if the motivation is good, this is profoundly meaningful. Otherwise, emptiness is just a mere absence and not terribly relevant.

I’ve always had difficulty differentiating Your question is methodologically flawed. If you take the third limb of consciousness and if you were able to eliminate its mental factors, obviously nothing would be left since when we eliminate the parts of something, that part is no longer left. So if we eliminate the mental factors of sensation, of attention, of intention and so forth, obviously there is no main mind left. So if one has an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues and within that context, the wish to harm another person, to harm their life force arises. Then if motivated by the wish of not damaging one’s ethics and not being reborn in a lower realm, one abstains from engaging in this deed precisely because one has an ethics of the abandonment of the non virtuous, one will accumulate virtue.

So it is not the case that just abstaining from killing people in general causes one to accumulate virtue. Instead, it is when one has within one’s mind stream the ethics of the abandonment of the non virtues and one restrains the impulse to kill another person who has harmed oneself that that path of abandonment which arises within one’s mind is a virtuous deed. So before taking Richard’s question, I would like to point out that when questions are answered from your side your side, even if it’s not your question, you should listen carefully to the question. You should then listen carefully to the answer. If you proceed in this way, a large number of wrong views will be dispelled.

You should not think this doesn’t concern me and just hang around. As I said, initially strive at much hearing. In other words, one should hear over and again these topics. It is very difficult to understand them the first time one hears them. But through repeated hearings, through familiarization over time, one’s understanding will definitely increase.

You will not have accumulated karma since you will not have accumulated physical or verbal karma even should the wish to kill another party arise as long as it is not concluded by a physical or verbal deed which causes that to happen, the karma of killing would not be accrued. Grant. There is a difference. It is clear that both dharma or religious and non religious practitioners understand the thoughts of anger. For instance, in daily life, it is well advised to say to friends and children, don’t get angry.

If you get angry, you will get into trouble. You may eventually even get to be thrown in jail, and you will face difficulties of this order. This is very different from the advice given in a dharma context in which it is said, if you generate anger, you will be reborn in the lower realms over and again. There is a difference in motivation. When our parents advise us not to allow anger to rise within our minds, they are doing this thinking of the difficulties we will encounter in this life.

Whereas, when from the standpoint of instructed not to allow anger to arise within one’s mind, this is done thinking of the hardship which should be experienced in future lives. What you say is true. Virtuous deeds find their origin in ignorance and therefore, virtuous deeds are the cause of cyclic existence. They are the cause for higher rebirth. It is therefore critical for us to be able to identify clearly what cyclic existence is, and this is not easy.

Yes, most definitely. Since the origin of coarse afflictions in this life is to be searched for in causes and conditions which can be traced back to previous lives. And therefore, if we apply forcefully the four opponent forces forces to previously accumulated non virtuous deeds, then these causes from previous lives will no longer be operative and will no longer allow coarse afflictions to arise in this life. Yes. I mean, abandoning the views of suchness is a wrong view.

You’re asking for the karmic consequences of wrong views. The result is a lower rebirth. And? So within these three non virtuous mental deeds, in other words, covetousness, ill will, and wrong views, the two first, covetousness and ill will, would fall within the second of the four categories, the intent or the wish. Yeah.

So when one plays these video games and for hours on end, one shoots at images of others who are seen as enemies, then all of the evil motivations associated with killing as well as rejoicing in the successful video death of another person are present within one’s mind stream. But as another real person is not on the receiving end of these deeds, impending karma is not accumulated. The deed is not complete. However, much sin, much non virtue is accumulated in the process. The anger itself will not give rise to virtue, but the focus on eliminating self cherishing will.

Well, in general, yes, but whether through reflecting carefully on the thoughts of self cherishing, one would still be able to give rise to anger is an open question. And another? Well, yes, there would be sin since one watches these movies out of craving, doesn’t one? Precisely because one is unable to abandon watching these programs. Yes.

It is desire, it is craving. While one does not accumulate directly karma through these three mental non virtuous deeds of covetousness, ill will, and wrong view, one accumulates indirectly non virtuous karma through these three mental non virtues since the two first of them act definitely as wish which gives rise down the line to the accumulation of non virtuous karma. You can see it is important to reflect carefully on what is meant by impelling karma and on the fact that the deed, the verbal or physical deed, gives rise to impelling karma arises in dependence on a wish, which is none other than an affliction. And Nanda? Definitely.

You see, covetousness is related to desire and ill will is related to anger. Yeah. Why then if covetousness How would it be possible to include all of the afflictions within the 10 non virtuous deeds? The list of the 10 non virtuous deeds is just the easier non virtues which we are able to abandon. Then in the case of anger, anger will manifest through physical and verbal deeds.

Since there is an infinite number of afflictions such as anger, desire, jealousy, envy, so forth, how could they all be included in the 10 non virtuous deeds? Ordinary beings like ourselves are or fall under the control, under the sway of angers of anger. However, for the sake of others, teachers can manifest the aspect of anger without themselves being under the control of anger. They are able to use anger, which we are unable to do. So this is not possible in the Paramitayana, the vehicle of perfections.

It only is possible within highest yoga tantra. And? And also? Yeah. Generally speaking, covetousness, ill will, and especially wrong view are the motivation which underlies a large number of the non virtuous deeds.

They do not become karma. One must maintain the distinction between the actor and the action. Karma is action whereas covetousness, ill will and wrong views are part of the sphere of the actor. I hope so. For sure, you will accumulate sin, but it will not be the sin of physically harming the body of another.

So we shall stop here for today. You have asked numerous good questions. And for tomorrow, I would like to ask you to reread the material we covered today. And if you reread it, numerous additional doubts will arise in your mind. Please ask those questions and your understanding will increase.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top