Karma – 2014-10-04 – KR

1 h 54 min · 3,595 words · 4 October 2014

Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma - 2014-10-04 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching begins a study of Je Tsongkhapa’s In Praise of Dependent Origination, starting with motivation and renunciation. It explains the apprehension of a self as the root of self-cherishing and anger, and contrasts coarse and subtle selflessness of persons across the tenet schools, with the Prasangika view that the subtle self must be refuted. The speaker then examines whether the I can be found in the body, concluding the I appears but cannot be located when searched for.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 54m

UUID: 6232894c-a7af-4901-88d7-0d21c0184e5b

Date: 2014-10-04

Words: 3,591

So regarding the motivation, we should reflect on what happens in our own mind. If we take, for instance, non virtuous deeds, clearly, the motivation is powerful and stable. The deed itself is completely accomplished, and as to the conclusion, the deed is led to its full conclusion. The deed therefore becomes very powerful. On the other hand, when we contrast this with the way we perform virtuous deeds, the motivation is fragile and wavering.

The deed itself is often done incompletely due to distraction. And as to the conclusion, even though we ought to dedicate deed to the attainment of full enlightenment or liberation, more often than not, it is dedicated to this life. If we contrast the two, we can see the difference. Then why is this the case? Clearly, non virtuous deeds, the preliminary, the deed, and the conclusion of the deed are complete and powerfully accomplished.

With virtuous deeds, this is not the case. It would be ideal if virtuous deeds could be accomplished with the same intensity as non virtuous deeds. So why is this the case? If we take non virtuous deeds, the motivation is fragile, the deed itself is done in a tentative fashion, and the dedication is weak. Why would this be so?

Doubtless, it is true that we are accustomed since beginningless time to the afflictions, and under the power of the afflictions, we engage in these deeds easily. But if we look at the actual reality of the situation, the truth of the matter, if we examine our own behavior, is that we can see the results of non virtuous deeds. Therefore, we believe in them. It is easy to do them with a strong motivation to perform the deed and to lead the deed to its conclusion. In the case of virtuous deeds, it is very tentative because the results are contingent on the 12 links of dependent origination and are not immediately visible.

Ideally, therefore, for the next day or two, we should behave and view this period as a period of retreat. Then during a retreat, one is very careful, one is very wary of one’s behavior. It is an important occasion. One does not behave in any which way. So during the next day or two, ideally, when we receive these teachings on the profound praise of dependent arising of Je Tsongkhapa, we should behave as if we were in a retreat.

And then as a result of this, we will implant a powerful karmic imprints of roots of virtue. The reason for which the karmic imprints of non virtuous deeds are so powerful is precisely because they are performed in this very intense way. What motivation, therefore, should we generate? Since the topic which shall be initially explained is the selflessness of persons and meditation of the selflessness of persons is the foremost means to escape from a cyclic existence, the motivation which should be initially generated is renunciation or definite emergence, the wish to escape from cyclic existence. And what precisely is this renunciation which we should generate?

Ideally, we have it already, but if we do not, we should have some sort of understanding of it. This renunciation or definite emergence is a definite emergence from something, a definite emergence from cyclic existence. Therefore, one must understand what psychic existence is. In our present situation, we fall under the sway of the afflictions and the function of the afflictions is to trouble the mind in an unsuitable fashion. This becomes obvious to us if we take the example of anger.

When we are angry, it may may be quite pleasant for the duration of the anger. We have a lot of power and energy. Then when the anger has passed, we look back and we think, my goodness, how I have fallen, what did I do? The same thing is true for desire or for jealousy. Then if we take such an affliction as anger and we ask how precisely or why precisely does anger arise, anger arises from a self cherishing or an egoism which discards others, which throws the interests of others away.

And when this powerful egoism or self cherishing arises, we view ourselves as independent, totally non dependent on others. It is therefore quite akin to the apprehension of a self. Do I understand? Really? Good.

Regarding anger, anger has two components. One component does indeed depend on others. It’s contingent on the behavior of others. But, the largest component by thought, arises within our mind stream. And if we examine where precisely anger, for instance, arises from, clearly, it arises from the self cherishing which cherishes oneself.

This self cherishing itself is rooted really in two components. Self cherishing itself, but also in addition to the self cherishing which discards others, it is rooted in the apprehension of a self. Now for so long as we view self cherishing or egoism as a good thing, we would not make any efforts to get rid of it. Therefore, we should try from our side to see a little bit of its faults, and then we can start to eliminate anger. Eliminating anger is a big thing, but if we can reduce it a little bit, then that is quite extraordinary.

Now how do we counter self cherishing? There are two broad methods to do this. The first method to counter the self cherishing, which cherishes oneself and discards other, is the interchange of self and others. Instead of cherishing oneself and discarding others, we cherish others and we discard ourselves. This method is probably a method for bodhisattvas of dull capacities.

The second approach is to understand that the self cherishing which discards others has a cause, and its cause is the apprehension of an I. This apprehension of an I must be understood and identified, and for this, practice entails study, a detailed study of both the meaning of the selflessness of persons and of the selflessness of phenomena. Now generally speaking, in the Buddhist treatises, the apprehension of an I and self cherishing are taught to be different. Some scholars teach that they are one and the same, but our teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, in keeping with the Buddhist treatises, taught that they were different. Therefore, to be able to eliminate it, it is indispensable initially to study.

Therefore, let us generate such a motivation for What is therefore the source of self cherishing or egoism? The source of self cherishing is the apprehension of a self or the apprehension of an I. What precisely is this apprehension of an I? It is this powerful sense of an independent, autonomous I, which exists without depending on anything else. And there are numerous gradations in terms of coarseness and subtlety of such an I, but it is this powerful sense of I I which is involved.

Now, generally speaking, this apprehension of a self or apprehension of an I is a consciousness, it is a mind, specifically it is a mental factor. The topic itself is not an easy topic. Do not expect that you will be able to understand it at once. To give you an idea, this is a topic which in the great monasteries is studied after numerous years of study. Typically, three years of study of Dura and collected topics followed by seven years of study of Prajnaparamita or Perfection of Wisdom.

And after these ten years of study, one studies Madhyamika overview for a full four years to gain an understanding of both the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. Now when one hears about this, one might be overcome by laziness, the laziness of engagement in non-virtuous deeds and just fall asleep. Please don’t fall asleep. Put effort and try to study. There’s no place for sleep.

So when we speak of the apprehension of a self or the apprehension of an eye, what precisely is apprehended? What is apprehended is an independent I. Now there are numerous modalities of this independence from coarse to subtle ones. Fundamentally, there are two types of apprehension of a self, a coarse and a subtle apprehension of a self. In both cases, the self is the imputed object on a basis of imputation.

The basis of imputation are the aggregates. In the case of the coarse apprehension of a self, this self is seen as independent of the aggregates which are its basis of imputation. On the other hand, in the case of the subtle apprehension of a self, this self is seen as within the aggregates which are its basis of imputation. Understand. Understand.

No problem. Then in both cases, the object which is apprehended is nonexistent. In the case of the coarse selflessness of persons, the self or the I, which is the object of imputation, imputed without depending on its basis of imputation, which are the aggregates, is a nonexistent. Likewise, in the case of the coarse selflessness of persons, that self which is seen as existing within the objects within the base of imputation is also a nonexistent. Then where the mere I in the statement I I does exist, that I, which is the object apprehended by both the coarse and the subtle apprehension of a self of persons is a nonexistent.

And all of the schools of tenets from the Vaibhashikas all the way up to the Svatantrika Madhyamikas consider that this is an object of abandonment which must be abandoned to attain liberation. Now regarding the subtle self, the subtle self is actually considered as existent by all of the schools of tenants from the Vaibhashikas to the Svetantrika madameka. In other words, all of these schools of tenants consider that there is certain entity within the aggregates and that it exists from its own side. The Prasangika Madhyamika school alone considers that such an entity does not exist and considers that it is impossible to attain liberation without realizing the subtle selflessness of persons, affirming that the selflessness of persons taught in the other schools of tenets is a coarse selflessness of persons insufficient for the attainment of liberation. Therefore, the Prasangika Madhyamika consider that a self, which is an object of imputation existing within the basis of imputation of the aggregates, is nonexistent.

And therefore, the subtle self which the schools of tenets ranging from the Vaibhashika to the Svatantrika Madhyamika claim exists within the basis of aggregates as an entity which is established from its its own side is considered by the Prasangika Madhyamika School of Tenets as nonexistent and as an object of refutation. Therefore, this subtle self is not an object of refutation for the schools of tenets from Vaibhashika to Svatantrika Madhyamika, whereas it is an object of refutation for the Prasangika Madhyamika school. None of the lower schools of tenets therefore understands that the refutation of this self is indispensable for the attainment of liberation. For that matter, until Je Tsongkhapa himself manifested in Tibet, While this view was widely known in Tibet, it was not engaged in. And it is Je Tsongkhapa who taught explicitly that it is only through negating the presence of the object of imputation within the basis of imputation and through negating the establishment of the object of imputation from its own side that it is possible to attain liberation.

And since this view was nonexistent in Tibet at the time of Je Tsongkhapa, Je Tsongkhapa wished to study it in India where it was said to still survive. It was said that a disciple of Nagarjuna, Nagabodhi, still taught the view. Nagabodhi was one of the very great tantric commentators of the Guhyasamaja tantra. Then Je Tsongkhapa asked his teachers, the Nyingmapa lama, Chodrub Chen and Namkha Gyaltsen, for permission to travel to India to study under Naga Bodhi. And Chodrub Chen said to Je Tsongkhapa, you will face tremendous difficulties in traveling to India to study under Naga Bodhi, and at this point, Lama Umapa became the mediator of Manjushri for Je Tsongkhapa.

And then through the mediation, we would say nowadays a channeling of Manjushri by Lama Umapa, Je Tsongkhapa was able to eventually gain the ascertainment of the ultimate view, the Prasangika madhyamika view. And Je Tsongkhapa gained the realization of the penetrating view of emptiness through the oral instructions of Manjushri. As a result of this, he composed the text we shall be studying today in praise of dependent origination, which is a praise of Buddha Shakyamuni for having taught dependent origination. Then at this point, there is a question which I would like to ask you. When we think of the number of teachings which Buddha Shakyamuni gave on how many different topics such as compassion, love, empathy, forbearance, all of the aspects of the method and wisdom, component of the path, why is it that Je Tsongkhapa chose to praise Buddha Shakyamuni not for teaching bodhichitta or great compassion, but for teaching dependent arising?

That is the question. Then I’ll give you two minutes to think about it. Oh, yeah. Are you ready? That’s why Buddha Shakyamuni praised it.

Mouse. Yes. To eliminate, to refute the self both the coarse and the subtle self and the bad. But to differentiate the point of difference with Buddhism and Buddhist academies teachings is that dependent origination is the cause for liberation which separates it from other teachings and why he would be present on that Yeah. Alright.

I will finish it. Very good. So some of you came quite close and gave the exact answer. The reason for which Je Tsongkhapa praises Buddha Shakyamuni for teaching dependent origination and not for instance for teaching love, forbearance, compassion, and so forth, is that where there are numerous other great religious teachers in the world who in the past have imparted teachings, not one of them has taught dependent origination. It is the Buddhist specificity.

Only Buddha Shakyamuni taught it. These other teachers taught for many of them the existence of a self which was permanent, one, and independent, which is directly opposite to the Buddhist teachings. So this completes the introduction to In Praise of Dependent Origination. We will now start with the body of the text, and I will not teach the text word by word since we lack time, and we would all be dizzy as a result, but I will teach the summarized meaning. We will use the Tenzin Choepel Thubten Jinpa translation, and I’ll impart the corrections to you as we proceed.

So In Praise of Dependent Origination begins with the homage to Manjushri, which is absent in your English translation, This is present at the beginning of almost all the works which Je Tsongkhapa composed. Why does Je Tsongkhapa pay specific homage to Manjushri? In Leksheng Ningpo, the essence of eloquence, Je Tsongkhapa says in the prologue to Leksheng Ningpo, although numerous scholars of the past endeavor to understand the meaning of dependent arising, it is thanks to Manjushri that I was able to do so. Therefore, Je Tsongkhapa’s whole understanding arose in dependence on Manjushri. So the first stanza of In Praise of Dependent Origination, he who speaks on the basis of seeing, this makes him a knower and teacher unexcelled.

I bow to you, o conqueror, you who saw dependent origination and taught it, is the prologue, what is called in Tibetan Chunjer, the promise to compose the treatise. This is uttered in praise of Buddha Shakyamuni. Generally speaking, to be able to benefit others, one must first know how to benefit them, but in addition to this knowledge, one must have the desire to do so, unlike, for instance, the solitary realizers or the Prateka Buddhas who do have an understanding of selflessness, but lacking compassion have no particular wish to help others. The following shloka or stanza, whatever degenerations are in the world, the root of all of these is ignorance. You taught that it is dependent origination, the seeing of which would undo ignorance, focuses on the twin topic of dependent arising being emptiness and emptiness being dependent arising.

Now in this stanza, the term degenerations in the first verse refers both to the exterior degenerations or of the misfortunes and inauspicious events in the world at large, and the interior degeneration, the afflictions within the minds of beings. The root of all of these two generations is ignorance, and this ignorance is the ignorance which apprehends a self in the sense of the term. In the third line, you taught that it is dependent origination. This refers to subtle dependent origination, which is emptiness. Now here, what precisely is the object of negation or the object of refutation?

It is this independent I, this powerful sense of I existing independently of anything else. Now in this context, a very legitimate doubt might arise. After all, we say, I go, I come, my table, my rosary, my telephone, then this eye exists, it performs functions. The eye which is the owner of the telephone exists, and the telephone which is owned by that eye does exist, doesn’t it? Then clearly, when we say I I, that I does exist.

Even though it exists, what does not exist is the way in which that I or that mine is apprehended. So this is something we must investigate for ourselves, and we should check when we take examples such as my car, my house, or for instance, my cup of tea. Therefore, I would ask you for a couple of minutes to examine carefully from your own side where this I, which we have been talking about, exists, scanning your body from the top of your head to your toes. Is it in your crown? Is it in your ears?

Is it in your eyes? Where is it? Therefore, obviously, this I is not outside of us. It must be inside us. Where is it?

So check for yourself for a couple of minutes carefully to see where it is. Let’s start. The moment you’ve committed a long time, everyone’s sleeping. Right? So as to think carefully about it, and if one does, it’s quite odd, isn’t it?

So this I which eats meals, which recites its commitments, which does things, does it exist or not? What’s your answer? Does it exist or not? Yeah. What about the eye?

Does it exist? The eye? Yeah. I think. I said eye to check.

And you’ve got a lot of eyes, don’t you? Then you have lips eye. That’s obviously Well, the eye does depend on the basis of imputation of the aggregates. So what you say is correct. The eye does depend on the aggregates.

But my question is, when you search for an I in your body parts, the head, the arms, and so forth, do you find it or not? When I search my body, I I cannot find the I. But when I stop That’s exactly it. When you don’t search for it, when you search for it, it is in there. When you don’t search for it, the object of refutation appears.

And, Ananda? I got the sense What do you mean by a verb? Yeah. Mhmm. You maybe mean continuum.

Right? The fan or your eye? And mother? Not with that experience that we just did, but sometimes I find in meditation, this is breathing meditation, that there Therefore, to summarize our examination, when we do not examine where the self might be, there is obviously an I. It appears clearly to us.

The moment we search for where it is, it is unfindable, it disappears. Then the outsiders, non Buddhist schools, subscribe to the existence of a self which is the overlord of the aggregates. What this means is that the aggregates are included, if you wish, within the self or the I, but the I is not included within the aggregates. And this I or this self, in the existence of which they believe, is a phenomenon which is permanent, one, and independent. There’s another position in this matter, which is that of all the Buddhist, the lower Buddhist schools of tenets from Vaibhashika to Svatantrika Madhyamika, which believe that the I is within the aggregates and specifically the instance of the I or the person which is given is the aggregate of consciousness.

Well, clearly, therefore, when the situation is unexamined, it is obvious that there is an eye, and yet under examination, this eye is unfindable. This mere unfindability of the eye, you might think is emptiness, and I thought so myself for a long time, but His Holiness the Dalai Lama says this is not the case. The emptiness we are searching for can only be discovered when powerful emotions are brought into play, but this is a difficult topic, so we shall stop here for today. Oh yeah, stop here, then you have a lifetime, We shall stop here. Are you tired and worried?

Lit? I think. You’re not tired are you? No need to frustrate either. Yeah.

So I have a good lunch. Just to say that tomorrow at the end of the day there will be offering of body, speech and mind. So we’ll be, so if you would like to make an offering you’re welcome to do that. There’s the programmes for the weekend up on the wall out there and then we’ll be having a short session with question and answer as before with starting at one o’clock. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
Collected Topics dura (Tib)
A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top