Calm Abiding – 2012-09-29 – KR

1 h 53 min · 4,470 words · 29 September 2012

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding - 2012-09-29 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher explains calm abiding (shamatha): its benefits, the role of recollection and ethics, the six conditions for attaining it, and the correct meditation posture. He covers the five faults that obstruct it, starting with laziness, and the antidotes to each. He presents calm abiding as indispensable for realising emptiness. The session ends with a question and answer segment.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 53m

UUID: 849d84d9-4d17-4856-a981-bf12fa6d5c87

Date: 2012-09-29

Words: 4,466

I forget because I thought little bit lumpy. I’m putting part left in my room. So average hemo, big lumpy the small or the the small one. For the sake of auspiciousness. Okay.

I’m gonna. It’s too bulky. No. I will rely on disorder for auspiciousness. So a commentary on calm abiding, Shiné, your mind should be relaxed and loose.

And, Geshela’s mind, likewise, he will try to make relaxed and loosed. It is very fortunate that you are able to dedicate these three days of the long weekend which amount to a vacation to the study of calm abiding or Shine. Three days comprise seventy two hours. Now it would be difficult to dedicate all seventy two hours to study and practice. But realistically, we can dedicate over three days, ten hours per day, in other words, thirty hours to study and practice.

During this period, you should only read texts on calm abiding and focus on this topic. If your reading and attempted practice on the one hand and Geshela’s explanations meet with each other, then this will be most beneficial for both parties. Very important. There are numerous texts in English on calm abiding, and it will be difficult for you to read them all. Geshela would therefore like to suggest that you ask your translator to recommend one which is appropriate for your level.

There are texts which are easy, intermediate, and advanced. Now regarding the practice of calm abiding, as Ratnākaraśānti, the author of the Concise Perfection of Wisdom said, through effort alone there is no attainment. Effort must be conjoined with skill and means. This means, Geshela says, that effort alone in the field is not sufficient. Effort must be conjoined with an understanding of the topics and then one attains realization quickly.

Then for training in abiding, you must rely on someone who has experience. There are many people who write books on calm abiding who have no experience in calm abiding. And if you rely on those texts, your time will be wasted. So you should ask your translator which texts to buy and purchase them. It’s only a couple dollars, and this is for your practice.

Anila as well gives classes on calm abiding and you should also rely on her advice and during the following three days try to put effort continuously in this practice. No. The practice of calm abiding is a common practice, a shared practice between Buddhist traditions and other traditions. However, in the Buddhist context, there are both ordinary and ultimate goals which can be attained through the practice of calm abiding. So initially, one should reflect on the advantages or the qualities of developing calm abiding and in dependence on this great delight in the practice of calm abiding will arise.

To give a very good example. As Je Tsongkhapa says in his concise Lambrim, turning dhyana into the lord which rules the mind. Our minds, and Geshela feels his mind as well, are desirous minds. These minds must be controlled and they can be controlled through concentration through dhyana. Dhyāna or concentration here refers to calm abiding.

What is the function of a king, of a monarch? It is to rule over his subjects. Here, who are the subjects? Actually, the evil doers. They are none other than our desirous minds.

And as Je Tsongkhapa develops this concept further in the following verses, if one sets it unmovably, akin to the king of mountains, one will engage in all virtuous objects. So here setting it unmovably means that the mind with dhyana, with concentration does not waver. It is focused single pointedly. It is focused single pointedly on what? In the same same way as water in an irrigation channel, it is focused single pointedly on a virtuous object.

Je Tsongkhapa’s text moves on, induces the great bliss of serviceability of body and mind. We all know from experience that when we try to engage in virtuous deeds within a matter of minutes, our body and mind become unserviceable. We are afflicted by bodily pains and mental disruption. However, once one has attained Samādhi, in other words, once one has attained calm abiding śamatha, one is able to focus on virtue easily indefinitely. Je Tsongkhapa’s concise Lamrim moves onwards with the verse understanding this deep powerful yogis.

Understanding this refers to the fact that to train in calm abiding or concentration one must initially have studied and powerful yogis refers to yogis who are striving for calm abiding. So don’t be worried about this. Geshela will proceed slowly. And he feels it is important to explain initially the purpose of generating calm abiding, the means or the capacity for generating calm abiding, and what is incompatible with the generation of calm abiding. This must be done incrementally.

Otherwise, if from the beginning forcefully one tries to generate calm abiding, one most definitely will not succeed. The mode of studying in the great monasteries is not conducive to this. One debates intensively on calm abiding and then one pushes it aside and no one attains calm abiding. That’s very important. So don’t worry about it.

Don’t be upset about it. We will proceed slowly. So even if we try to do something quickly with our hands or with our feet, there is a risk of falling or of trouble, let alone with our minds. So without physical hardship and setting one’s mind at ease, we will proceed. So in this context, it’s important to explain the nature of calm abiding.

The Tibetan term has two syllables, which means peace or calmness, and which means to dwell or to abide. Here, the term peace means to block the mind’s outward movement towards sense objects, to withdraw the mind inwards. Nepa, to dwell, means for the mind to dwell on whatever object of observation it chooses. When this outward movement of the mind is blocked and the mind is able to focus on whatever object of observation it chooses with full serviceability, one has attained a Samādhi, a concentration. As Śāntideva says in his Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, seizing the wild elephant of the mind with the rope of recollection, fasten it to the pillar.

Here, recollection is compared with a rope with which we actually seize the wild elephant of the mind. It is difficult to say, generally speaking, that we lack recollection or memory. The Tibetan term means actually memory as well, But what we can say is that we lack stable recollection or memory. This therefore has to be fostered. And therefore with the rope of recollection, we must fasten, we must tie the wild elephant of the mind to the pillar of the object of observation.

Śāntideva also says in his Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, any activity whether it is the recitation of mantra or any virtuous deed is meaningless if accomplished in attentively for however long one engages in it even for eons. This is very clearly corroborated by passages from the Buddha’s Sutras. Such activities when they are engaged in inattentively are a waste of time. And as Śāntideva says further on in the bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, whatever activity one engages in must be held by the mind to the force of memory. Otherwise, why are you engaging in it?

What do you feel about this? And since all of our activities have results in function of the mind which engages them and the mind in turn depends on memory, on recollection, we can see how critical memory or recollection is. As you remember from the introduction to the graduated path, there are three types of behavior which have to be avoided by disciples. Disciple should avoid being like an upside down vase, like a vase which is contaminated and like a pierced vase. Clearly, when one lacks memory, one has features for instance of the contaminated vase among others.

In dependence on what does the power of recollection increase? It increases in dependence on ethics, specifically on the ethics of an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. Why is this the case? Because whenever one is engaging in any activity of body, speech, or mind, it is recollection or memory which stands at attention and prevents body, speech, or mind from engaging in inappropriate deeds. It’s very helpful to think that it is through the recollection or the memory of ethics that we in turn abstain from non virtue and that in turn our mind can be focused on an object.

If you think about it in this way, this would be helpful to you. It is not very difficult to understand. Not difficult. A little bit easy maybe. It’s not sufficient to think about it.

One must think about it and put it in practice. Otherwise, if one thinks about these things and sets them aside, there is no benefit. Therefore, initially, studies and then one puts one studies into practice. My apologies. Yeah.

My body is not what it used to be. So it is therefore independence on ethics that one generates recollection. As a sūtra mentions, through training in ethics one gives rise to recollection. Through recollection, in turn one gives rise to concentration. Through concentration, through śamatha, one in turn gives rise to insight.

So it is important to reflect about this carefully and to remember it. If at present you are a bit dull and don’t assimilate what is presented, it will be difficult later on to recollect it and to practice it. And therefore it is extremely important to realize that it is through the practice of ethics that recollection increases or memory increases in its power. As the recollection increases, in turn concentration increases and eventually one attains calm abiding. Therefore, as the quote from sūtra says, from ethics one attains concentration and through concentration in turn one attains insight or Vipassana.

The practice of śamatha leads to an abating of the afflictions of the desire realm, what are known commonly as the afflictions of the desire realm. However, it is the practice of insight of vipassana which is a consequence of the practice of calm abiding which leads to a dwindling of the afflictions of the formless realms. So one can say that the practice of calm abiding leads to a dwindling of the coarse afflictions and the practice of insight leads to a dwindling of the subtle afflictions. Specifically, the meditation on selflessness, which is the core of the practice of insight is necessary for the subtle afflictions to be eliminated. This attainment of according to scripture occurs within the context of the generation of the nine stages of calm abiding.

And even an attainment of the second stage of calm abiding within the nine is of great benefit. There’s tremendous benefit in training the mind even in the second of the nine levels of calm abiding. Since Śāntideva says, having bound the mind, the wild elephant of the mind with the rope of recollection to the pillar of the object of observation, all fear will be eliminated. We know for ourselves that most worldly beings, when they encounter difficulties in their lives, find solace in alcohol and drink. This is of no benefit whatsoever since alcohol stupifies for a couple hours but after the potency of the drink has vanished, the problems return.

However, the capacity of even the second level of calm abiding to pacify the mind is far greater. Since, it is indispensable for a realization of emptiness to have attained at least śamatha and in turn śamatha is necessary for realizations of bodhichitta and of definite emergence or renunciation. It is thinking of both these contingent and ultimate attainments that we should generate the motivation to receive these teachings on calm abiding today. So the main purpose for developing calm abiding is for the mind to be able to dwell in a stable fashion on its object of observation. We need this in all of the activities of our life.

We see for instance even when we study, if we are unable to focus on our object of study, we accomplish nothing. Most of us recite commitments. If we are sincere with ourselves, we can see when we recite our commitments that our mind is not concentrated for even one minute on our recitation irrespective of the total length of the commitment. Our mind wanders off as we perform our recitations. This is why both His Holiness and the Dalai Lama and Kyabje Kangurwa Rinpoche have emphasized the importance of attaining calm abiding.

And thanks to His Holiness repeated emphasis on the topic, countless number of great practitioners have gone in the mountains behind Dharamsala to try to attain calm abiding. Geshe-la does not know who actually has attained calm abiding. Some have certainly attained the second, third, fourth, fifth level maybe above that, it’s hard to say. Think about it. We’re all in the same boat in this matter.

When we do our commitments, if we observe how our mind is behaving, then within the three times, the past, the present and the future, our mind is either in the past remembering things which happened to us or we recite our commitments or it’s in the future thinking about things we should be doing and so forth. Our mind is never in the present focusing on the commitment and when occasionally it is, most of the times it doesn’t understand what we are reciting. We are all the same in this matter, aren’t we? And yet if we think about it, it shouldn’t be that hard to obtain calm abiding. Since to obtain calm abiding, we don’t need the view of emptiness.

We don’t need bodhichitta. We don’t even need renunciation. All we need is the mind’s capacity to remain in a focused and stable fashion on its object. So to accomplish calm abiding, one needs certain conditions, these so called collections for the accomplishment of calm abiding. And these are explained in Lamrim Chenmo.

They are six fold. One needs to dwell in a harmonious setting to have few desires, to be contented, not to try to accomplish numerous activities, to have pure ethics and to have given up desire and other fancies. Now within these, the first is to live in a harmonious setting. In other words, as Maitreya says in his Mahāyāna sūtra Lamkara, in a good land. What is precisely a good land?

A good land is a land in which it is easy to obtain food, in which one is not threatened by carnivorous animals, in which one does not not encounter foes or enemies, but only friends, and in which one is not afflicted by numerous diseases. These are the four features of a good land. Now, if you check for yourself, you can see that to generate calm abiding, you need on the one hand, food, you need to be in a harmonious setting with little or no no noise, you need friends to help you in your practice, and you need to be free of disease. If you analyze, you can see that in Australia, you have all of these conditions. So to generate calm abiding, one needs first and foremost a quiet place to live in.

And you can see that if the environment is very noisy, the mind will go out and follow as it were the noise. And then in a scattered fashion, the remaining conditions one needs to generate calm abiding pure ethics since ethics is that restraint of the mind from being scattered outwards and one also needs to generate calm abiding few desires since desires likewise scatter the mind outwards. A scholar is mentioned in the Lamrim who asserted that it was not necessary to have all of the conditions to attain calm abiding. To this, Atisha famously answered many centuries before in his Bodhipathapradipa, that even should one meditate for thousands of years without the six conditions for the attaining of calm abiding, one would not attain them. It’s not terribly difficult to have these six conditions for the generation of calm abiding.

Certainly living in a harmonious setting, have already. Ethics is not difficult to practice. Then reducing desires, that is something we have to examine. Now regarding the posture to be adopted to generate calm abiding, one should sit in the posture of Vairochana, the purified aspect of the form aggregate on a comfortable cushion, which is neither too high nor too low, if possible with one’s legs in full Vajrasanā. Otherwise, in half half Vajrasanā is acceptable.

One’s arms should be in this posture with the right hand set above the or the right palm set above the left palm, thumbs touching. One’s head should be bent slightly downwards with the gaze extended along the sides of the nose. One’s back should be straight and regarding one’s breath, one should allow the breath to come in and out naturally. One’s mouth should be slightly open in its natural position with neither the lips nor the teeth touching, and one’s tongue should touch the tip of one’s palate. It is said that there is great significance in this.

There’s particular meaning in adopting this posture. You will see for yourselves that if you adopt it, there’s a particular feeling. The mind is different when you just adopt the correct seven or eight fold posture if you include breathing. Then in addition, it instills faith in others when they see us meditating in this fashion. Whereas, if we just sit in any which posture with a robe thrown over our shoulders, there’s a very great risk of falling asleep instead of meditating.

It’s a big risk. And it is therefore extremely important to adopt the correct posture. It is very beneficial for us. Numerous reasons are given for this in the Lamrim. You should check them for yourselves.

The outline for training in calm abiding given in the Lamrim is extraordinarily profound since it comprises the totality of training in calm abiding. The outline is as follows. How to train in calm abiding before engaging in calm abiding? How to train during the actual engagement in calm abiding? And how to train as a follow-up of calm abiding?

How to train before engaging in calm abiding involves focusing on the elimination of the first thought which is laziness as well as the application of the antidotes to laziness. How to train during the practice of calm abiding involves eliminating the second thought which is forgetting the oral instruction, forgetfulness in other words and the application of its antidote which is recollection. How to train in the continuation of calm abiding involves eliminating the core fault of calm abiding which is sinking and agitation and the application of its antidote which is vigilance. So exists in English. And even though it’s very long, Geshela says it will be of great benefit for you in reading it.

And the middling is also translated in English. It is quite shorter. You could read it as well. If you read it, then things will stay in your minds better. And upon engaging in calm abiding, the foremost obstacle, the foremost thought is laziness which actually prevents prevents one from engaging in the actual practice.

So this laziness which refuses to engage in the practice is what we must counter. So there are five faults of the attainment of calm abiding. The first is laziness. The second is forgetfulness, specifically forgetfulness of the instruction or the object of observation. The third comprises two, which are sinking and agitation.

The fourth is non application. And the fifth is inappropriate application. These five must be eliminated to obtain calm abiding. The source for Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation of the five faults within the Lamrim is Maitreya’s Madhyantavibhaga and Mahāyāna sūtra Lamkara. Specifically, the Madhyantavibhaga identifies by name the five faults.

So how do we counter this initial laziness which prevents us from engaging in the practice and reaping its fruits? We counter it through reflecting on the qualities, the purpose and the advantages of calm abiding. Then we will find it easy to engage in practice. This laziness will not arise. To give an example, Geshela says, he would like to take his own case.

He thoroughly enjoys studying English because he understands the benefits of studying English. Then whenever he has a spare moment, he memorizes a couple extra words. This is no hardship whatsoever for him because he really understands the benefits. In our cases, Geshela suspects that since we understand fully the advantages of reading and speaking Tibetan as the gateway to the Buddhist teachings, we would probably study with great enthusiasm Tibetan if we could. The only thing which is lacking from our side is the time to do so.

And the reason for which studying Tibetan is critical is because Tibetan is fundamental for Buddhist studies. While it is said that all the Buddhist scriptures originally existed in Sanskrit, Tibetan is definitely the second most important language for Buddhist studies. When one thinks about this, then one will have no difficulty whatsoever in studying Tibetan. Even if one has to go hungry or if one is thirsty or lacks rest, studying Tibetan will pose no difficulty whatsoever because one understands the benefits. Taking this as an example, we can see in turn how to practice to eliminate laziness in the context of calm abiding.

We reflect on the qualities of calm abiding and as Maitreya says, once mental and bodily serviceability have arisen, all can be enacted. This means that once one has eliminated laziness, one is able to accomplish whatever one wishes to accomplish. And therefore, acting in accordance with Je Tsongkhapa’s quote, relying on the base and what is based upon on the cause and the effect, which refers to the four subdivisions of the antidotes to laziness. One gives rise initially to faith and that faith which is the first antidote in turn gives rise to aspiration. Independence on that aspiration, one then gives rise to enthusiasm and that enthusiasm finally gives rise to the fourth antidote which is pliancy.

Otherwise, if one just starts mumbling the words faith, aspiration, enthusiasm and pliancy without understanding the process of generation, there will be no benefit. And therefore to generate calm abiding and concentration in general, a faith which is the foundation for giving rise to calm abiding is necessary and independence on this eventually a fully qualified calm abiding which is none other than a concentration which as a result of concentration has given rise to both bodily and mental pliancy will arise. This is how one has to proceed. So the foremost topics which we have covered this morning, have been first, a presentation of the qualities of calm abiding and how to give rise to calm abiding. And secondly, a presentation of the first of the five faults which interfere with the generation of calm abiding which is laziness.

Then Geshela will continue gradually the explanations this afternoon. So we have finished for this morning. And at present, Geshela will take your questions. Yes, please. It’s an excellent question.

There is no definiteness about when a calm abiding must be engaged in. However, the presentation in Lamrim Chemo is that calm abiding must be definitely engaged in, in other words, at the latest, at the time of the practice of the great vehicle. Now generally speaking, Geshela from his own standpoint feels that calm abiding is indispensable to gain realization of emptiness. Therefore, one must train in calm abiding before striving to meditate on emptiness and gain direct realization of emptiness. Calm abiding is not necessary to progress upwards in the paths of the beings of middling, of small and middling capacity.

So there is no definiteness. However, if one generates calm abiding then one’s progress will be extraordinarily fast. So there is nothing wrong in starting to practice it right now and even for one or two minutes to try to train your mind in the topic. Generally speaking, it is taught that śamatha is a common, in other words, a shared path between Buddhist and non Buddhist in numerous scriptures. And then generally speaking, most of the non Buddhists would probably rely on a virtuous object.

Alright. Having few desires and the sixth. Okay. It’s a very good question. Then Geshela feels that the second and the third collections or preconditions for the attainment of calm abiding which are few desires and contentment refer mainly to physical desires which must be limited.

Whereas the sixth precondition which is abandoning desire in general and as well as fancies, in other words, conceptuality, refers more to mental desires. What did change? So for beginners, it is important to focus 100% of the mind on the object because if we don’t do this, there is no type of attainment which is possible. Then eventually down the line, it is possible for a part of the mind to engage in other activities, but that is certainly not the case at the level we’re at at present. So reflecting on the fact that to lead all sentient beings to full enlightenment, oneself must eliminate all one’s faults and attain all qualities and therefore must attain full enlightenment, one searches for the means to do so.

And the means to do so is that direct realization of emptiness, which is only possible in turn independence on special insight. A special insight with emptiness as its object is only possible independence on the generation of calm abiding. And with this, we have established a link between calm abiding and attaining full enlightenment for all sentient beings. Most definitely. Once we have attained calm abiding any practice we engage in, we will accomplish much faster.

Without calm abiding, we will be beset by the thought of laziness and will not achieve anything. We are all the same at present in not understanding clearly what the benefits of calm abiding are and thinking, probably renunciation can be attained without calm abiding, although it helps to attain fully qualified renunciation. And as for bodhichitta, we also have some doubts regarding the relevance of calm abiding. However, as far as the direct, experience of emptiness is concerned, we can assert unequivocally that calm abiding is indispensable. So all of us should reflect on the benefits of calm abiding and as a result of this reflection, we will strongly wish to engage in practice.

We will stop here for now. So we will stop here for now and after lunch we will gather for some questions and discussion. All right. You don’t post station. Post station.

You don’t need don’t You You don’t don’t You don’t need need.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top