1 h 1 min · 6,921 words · 12 August 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Richard Bradshaw, a lawyer, talks about applying Buddhist ethical discipline to his legal work. He draws on Tsongkhapa’s teaching that restraint from harm is the primary ethical discipline, and on Shantideva’s advice to examine the mind before acting. He describes the professional ethics rules he works under and the difficulties of keeping calm and patient in land rights and defamation cases. The talk ends with a short question session.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 2m
UUID: 5a4027db-a53a-46cc-b8b0-61cc9e2b28e7
Date: 2012-08-12
Words: 6,917
Richard, Richard Bradshaw. And once again, I’ll just ask Richard to introduce himself and his topic. Thank you, Richard. I better turn this off, otherwise, I shall interrupt myself. Okay.
My name is Richard Bradshaw. I should say that I’m certainly not qualified to talk on this subject of ethics for a number of reasons, of which my failure in this. How do I put this on? You’re gonna show me how to do this. I just say I’m not qualified to talk on the subject of ethics, but I will do my best.
I am a lawyer. I have been a lawyer since 1971, I suppose. 1973, was ’74, I was admitted in The UK as a lawyer. I’ve been in Australia since 1979. I’m a partner or a director in a law firm, relatively small law firm, five partners in Adelaide.
We have offices in Clare, in Port Augusta, in Whyalla. And we also visit Roxby Downs. The name of the firm is Johnston Withers. The Johnston is Elliot Johnston, who died last year. Was a left wing law firm, very left wing law firm.
He was a member of the Communist Party, the first communist communist judge in Australia, I think. Continued to be a member of the Communist Party until such time as he became a judge, a Supreme Court judge in South Australia. I’m an employer. Well the firm is an employer of 14. There are there are five partners or five directors of the firm.
We are an employer of 14 additional lawyers, three conveyancers, and 23 support staff. I describe myself as a commercial lawyer, but my areas of specialty are in the area of land rights and native title and in defamation. So you might quibble with me as to whether I really am a commercial lawyer in that sense. Now, I need to have a purpose in talking to you. So I’ve tried to identify some purposes.
I suppose people have views about lawyers. They may think that they are unethical or that at least that they’re not ethically bound. I that I at least try to establish to your satisfaction that we are actually very ethically, at least we’ve got plenty of rules, professional ethical rules as well as which govern conduct and as well as obviously the law. And to remind myself as much as also to remind myself as much as you about the relevance of the perfection of ethical discipline, a daily battle. And I’m very grateful I must say to Jampa Tenzin for assisting in giving her examples of of the sorts of ethical dilemmas that she’s faced with which are far greater than I think than mine.
I would say that, at least as a psychologist though, she’s at which she’s dealing with tends to be dealing with individuals, whereas I’m in land rights and native title, I’m dealing with groups of people which have its own complications. And I’m not going to justify my lack of calmness in responding that I am dealing with groups. Thirdly, to discuss and reflect on certain kinds of ethical challenges experienced in my legal practice. Now what are the constraints that I’m subject to? Well, I am actually subject to the Australian solicitors’ conduct rules.
I’m gonna have a chat about them because they do talk about ethics rather a lot. I’m subject obviously to the law, and I seek to impose on myself ethical discipline of of the perfection of ethical discipline, albeit unsuccessfully. I do try and remind myself daily. Now turning to the Australian solicitors conduct rules, the second of these says that the purpose of these rules is to assist solicitors to act ethically. There’s also a division between what constitutes unsatisfactory professional conduct and what constitutes unprofessional conduct.
And we there’s a conduct board and complaints can be made to the conduct board. And if the conduct board considers that a solicitor is guilty of either unsatisfactory conduct or see it more seriously unprofessional conduct, then there’s a there’s an issue before the disciplinary tribunal which is established under the Legal Practitioners Act, which can result of course even being struck off. The paramount duty of a lawyer is not to the client. Paramount duty of the lawyer is a duty to the court and to the administration of justice. And there are certain rules that deal with, with those questions, in particular.
There are other fundamental ethical rules, ethical duties to act in the best interests of the client in any matter in which the solicitor represents the client. Fair enough. There’s the duty to be honest and courteous in all dealings in the course of legal practice. Of course that’s pretty difficult at times. Dealing with other parties, dealing with the state, dealing with clients as well, know, subgroups of clients.
I’m not talking about dishonesty. I’m talking about courtesy, generally speaking. And there’s an obligation, a duty to deliver legal services competently, diligently, and as promptly as reasonably possible. There’s a duty, to avoid any compromise to integrity and professional independence. And there’s an obligation, a duty to comply with the rules and the law.
So then you move into further rules about dishonest and disreputable conduct. About the giving of undertakings and the obligation to comply with them. There’s obligations about communication. Making sure that the client understands and make informed decisions. There’s a duty of confidentiality in relation to client information.
But that duty is not an absolute duty. There are exceptions. For example, there’s an exception to disclose for the sole purpose of avoiding the probable commission of a serious criminal offense. And there’s also an exception for the purposes of disclosing the for the purpose of preventing imminent serious physical harm to the client or to another person. Then there, of course, there are issues of conflicts of interest concerning former clients, of current clients, the conflict of interest in relation to one’s own personal interests so that, obviously can’t promote my own interest.
There’s an obligation to continue to act, unless the contract, the retainer agreement is terminated by mutual agreement or now the period of time expires. I can’t simply decide I don’t like it any longer that it’s all too much. At least I can’t do it without justification and unreasonable notice. There’s a heavy duty increasingly more and more so on communication regarding costs. In this country as well, it should be noted that we do not have a system of allowing for contingency fees in the way that they do in The United States.
So we’re not in a position to act to provide for a proportion of compensation or damages to be awarded, say in a personal injury claim or in a defamation action or whatever. We can’t say we’ll take it on. If if we win, if if you win, then we will take a third of the damages, for example. It’s simply not allowed in this country. You can enter into a contingency, a complying contingency agreement.
Complying contingency agreement has to be in circumstances where there’s a risk, a significant risk that the action will not succeed. So you can take it on in other words on a no fee, no and then no win no fee basis. And you are in a position to negotiate an agreement up to twice so that you can agree to that the client will pay up to twice the Supreme Court scale rate. Which of course would be vastly less than the sorts of percentage of damages that can be paid in The United States. There’s an obligation to maintain independence, which seems to be surprising.
So you’re not simply to act as a mouthpiece. You know, you can’t client can’t simply tell you what was it what I want to say in court. You say it for me. Well, no. You can’t do that.
And you’ve got to exercise a forensic judgment after appropriate consideration of the client’s instructions. There’s an obligation to be frank, honest in court, not to deceive or knowingly mislead, and to correct any misleading statement as soon as possible after becoming aware of of of the mis misleading information you may have provided. Now I’m not a criminal lawyer, but obviously there’s substantial provisions regarding, what you do with guilty clients who go and tell you that they’re guilty. And you’re quite constrained in those circumstances. You probably know that from watching plenty of television programs where the solicitor or barrister concerned is constantly trying to prevent the client from saying, yes I did it.
So there’s also you know there is an obligation that to that if the client goes and says or if a witness goes and says that the evidence they gave was a lie. You’ve actually got a duty to the court to inform the court in those circumstances. So these are surprising perhaps obligations but they’re there in the rules. We are pretty heavily bound by what are, you know, ethically ethical rules entrenched across the country by the solicitors Australian solicitors conduct rule and enforced through the Legal Practitioners Act in each state. So the law obviously provides for the Legal Practitioners Act, the Trust Account rules, the General Criminal Law, there’s provisions regarding partnerships and corporations and trade practices legislation, other laws generally speaking which constrain.
Now so far as ethical discipline of the perfection of ethical discipline. As I think was discussed yesterday was discussed yesterday a fair amount that in the primary restraint or the primary ethical obligation is the discipline of restraint. As was pointed out, it’s the attitude of abstention that turns the mind, this is what Tsongkhapa says, that turns the mind away from harming others and from sources of such harm. In particular, from the 10 non virtues, of killing, stealing, sexual misconduct doesn’t tend to be a problem, I must say, work, fortunately. Lying, harsh, malicious idle speech, ill will, covetousness, and wrong view.
Now it’s the harsh, the malicious, the at times, perhaps idle speech, the ill will that tends to be a problem in professional life. The other two ethical disciplines of gathering virtue of the six perfections of acting for the welfare of others. But I I find at least, and fortunately, this is at least what, Lama Tsongkhapa and, and his holiness are saying that that, you know, the first, the restraint is the most important one. Tsongkhapa refers to it as the lotion which protects against the torturous heat of the afflictions. And perhaps some comfort if one he says that if one trains the mind in such restraint, the other two will easily follow.
So he goes to show there’s a long way to go in the in the first. His Holiness in this wonderful book, Ethics for the New Millennium. It would be great reading for all lawyers as well as for others. Divides perfection of ethical disciplines really. I mean he talks about an ethical act which I suppose is really ethical discipline of restraint.
From what he calls the spiritual acts. So an ethical act is where you refrain from causing harm to others experience or expectation of happiness. Spiritual acts are described in terms of qualities of love, compassion, patience, forgiveness, humility, tolerance which he says etc which presume as some level of concern for others. He is emphasizing that you cannot be loving and compassionate unless at the same time we curb our own harmful impulses and desires. And says that when under the influence of negative thoughts and emotions we become oblivious to the impact of our actions.
How often, when I feel that, you know, anger and resentment and lack of calmness how much my mind is clouded and my judgment is clouded. And Shantideva in the guide to the Bodhisattva’s way of life in chapter five says, whenever I have the desire to move my body or to say something first of all I should examine my mind and then with steadiness act in the proper way. Whenever there is attachment in the mind, whenever there is the desire to be angry, I should not do anything or say anything but remain like a piece of wood. Good advice and if I have another lawyer with me, which I do at times, it’s advice I should follow. So I can say that as a lawyer in the areas of I specialize in, it’s a story of of of some effort on my part of frequent failure, of a loss of mental calmness, a lack of patience leading to resentment, anger, malice, and ill will.
But, you know, each day, you’ve got to start the day with three reflections. I can control my mind today. I can’t control anybody else’s mind today. I can yes. As Elias said yesterday, I can speculate, perhaps, on what’s going on in there in somebody else’s mind, but I certainly can’t control it.
And today is a new day. And what happened yesterday is past, and I can act differently today. I try to remember. So moving on to the to the duties. As I’ve mentioned, the duty to the court and the administration of justice, my duty to the clients, my duty to other parties including that of honesty and courteous courtesy, of of integrity and so on.
Duty of confidentiality about so I can’t in saying that I have an an obligation of of integrity and honesty in my dealings with others, that doesn’t mean I can breach my duty of confidentiality. I have a duty to my partners, which at times is difficult. I can’t say that it’s always easy in working with four other people. We have we have different viewpoints from time to time. I obviously also have a duty.
So I have a duty to my firm. I have a duty to make money, which is difficult. But if the firm doesn’t make money, well then I can’t employ the significant numbers of people. So whilst it would be nice to be doing a considerable amount of work And we do a considerable amount of work without getting paid. But ultimately we’ve got to keep the business going and pay the employees.
We obviously have duties to behave properly towards them, not discriminate, not to bully, not to do a etcetera, to to train them. And then I’ve also got a bit to remember that I have a duty to others. I have a duty to Pamela, for example. And to I feel I have a duty to you and to the Buddhist community and which I as it happens, I’m not the only Buddhist in the firm, but I am the only Buddhist partner in the firm. That’s for sure.
I think that there are others, I have to say, who whose ethical discipline is better much better than mine. Of course, being a Buddhist is is respected. Not because of his holiness. And so but the failure on my part is because his holiness is held in such high regard by everybody and that I’m labeled. I’ve in that sense, I feel that I have a responsibility, a greater responsibility.
I don’t think that I sort of feel that my you know, one of my other partners who’s, you know, who’s a good Catholic. I don’t think that he feels that he’s letting down the Catholic church or the pope. Perhaps this may be a level of self cherishing or self centeredness on my part. I feel a great a great level of disappointment when I when I fail for that for those reasons. Or in part anyway.
So my specialization areas of land rights and native title and defamation. There can be some misunderstanding as to what land rights and native title constitute. So I’ll just very quickly address, seek to address this. Obviously land rights in broad terms, we’re talking about a right to ownership, possession, occupation, use, development, control over access and decision making in relation to land. This country has had land rights legislation in the Northern Territory since 1976 in this state with the Pitjantjatjara legislation in 1980.
So there’s been statutory land rights legislation. When we on the other hand when we talk about land rights legislation we’re not really talking about control of the level of control that at least a sovereign people would have to decide what decisions they’re going to make in relation to their land. It’s very circumscribed. So far as native title is concerned, native title is we’re talking about an intersection between the common law of Australia and the traditional laws and customs, and the rights and interests which pursuant to those traditional laws and customs give rise to rights under those laws and customs and connection under those laws and customs. So it wasn’t until 1992 that the High Court in Mabo made this decision, made that decision.
But what it has meant is that only those who are in a position to demonstrate that their traditional laws and customs traditional in the sense that they are rooted in the laws and customs that existed at the time of sovereignty, which may have changed, but are nonetheless, one can say that they are rooted in those and that the law that the rights and interests are also rooted in the rights and interests that existed at the time of sovereignty. That those rights and interests have been maintained pursuant to the laws and customs as maintained. And connection has been maintained pursuant to those laws and customs. Where that exists, where that exists in relation to land or waters, then Australian law allows an intersection. Where the common law can recognize those rights and interests where they haven’t been extinguished by the acts of the new sovereign.
This new sovereign that was established in 1788 or whenever it was 1829 in some instances in the Torres Strait in the eighteen seventies. Now of course, I’ve come to this, you know, I am a white fellow lawyer. I’m not an ab I’m not an aboriginal lawyer. And so from that point of view, I am providing advice on what the white fellow law says on this subject. Native title is a cause of great resentment because it allows certain people who can demonstrate this continuity to have recognition of rights.
Those who because of greater levels of dispossession, greater levels of discontinuity disconnection will not be in a position to do so. So I’m working in those fields. By extension it covers also the issue of compensation but compensation for this disposition is only allowed for since 1975 when the racial discrimination act came into force. Prior to that the sovereign power was in a position by a lawful act whether through legislation or the lawful act of the executive to dispossess by granting say non inconsistent titles such as freehold or perpetual leases or other leases or to use land for an inconsistent purpose inconsistent with native title to extinguish that that native title or to impair the native title without any entitlement to compensation. So it’s only as a result of the racial discrimination act since 1975 that there’s there is an entitlement to be compensated for.
So in most instances therefore most of the extinguishment occurred pre ’75. Again the cause of great resentment as to why there should be this continuity of this this injustice perpetuated. There’s issues with regard to national parks, management of national parks, co management of national parks, heritage issues, protection of aboriginal heritage sites, say, negotiating with mining companies, other development issues. There can be commercial agreements entered into other than negotiating with mining companies, say tourist ventures, particularly say the development of of the acquisition of tourist resort on traditional land. Negotiating in relation to health, the establishment of health services, government funded, but aboriginal controlled, buying agencies, airlines, etcetera to assist the greater control over people’s lives.
So that is what an that’s what a land rights native title lawyer is engaged in doing. So what are the sort of ethical challenges that I as a lawyer in this field I’m faced with. Well of course it’s a political area. There’s no escaping the fact it’s a political area because it challenges existing power relations. Most of the time that is what in some way or another a lawyer in the field is doing challenging power existing power relations.
It’s, I mean, I’m pleased to see that his holiness is very much supportive of social justice issues, but I have to be wary, about promoting my own political views and bear in mind that sometimes in fact my own political views are quite at variance with the political views of my clients. So there is a division between law and politics. I do want to just quote Dean and Justice Dean and Gordon in Mabo just to remind you regarding what a significant decision that was. But also to point to the sort of criticisms that were leveled against them, and how in the issue between law and politics, it’s it’s important to to bear this in mind that I that I feel compelled to ensure that I don’t overstep the line between between between acting as a essentially as a politician or you know political lobbyist and being a lawyer. They said inevitably one is compelled to acknowledge the role played in the dispossession and oppression of the aborigines by the two propositions that the territory of New South Wales was in 1788 terra nullius in the sense of unoccupied and uninhabited for legal purposes and the full legal and beneficial ownership of all the lands of the colony vested in the Crown unaffected by any claims of the aboriginal inhabitants.
Those propositions provided a legal basis for and justification of the dispossession. They then go on to say the two propositions in question provided the legal basis for the dispossession of the aboriginal peoples of most of their traditional lands. The acts and events and I’ll emphasize it, the acts and events by which that dispossession in legal theory was carried into practical effect constitute the darkest aspect of the history of this nation. The nation as a whole must remain diminished unless and until there is an acknowledgement of and retreat from those past injustices. In those circumstances, the court is under a clear duty to re examine the two propositions For the reasons which we have explained that re examination compels their rejection.
The lands of this continent were not terra nullius or practically unoccupied in 1788. The Crown’s property in the lands of the colony of New South Wales was under the common law which became applicable upon the establishment of the colony in 1788 reduced or qualified by the burden of the common law native title of the Aboriginal tribes and clans to the particular areas of land on which they lived on which they or which they used for traditional purposes. Now those two judges were severely criticized by many lawyers, by many conservative lawyers for overstepping the mark by talking about this constituting the darkest aspect of the history of the nation and that the nation as a whole remain undiminished remain diminished on the grounds that this was a political statement rather than a statement of law. So far as the just progressing further this issue of law and politics, clearly there has been dispossession, powerlessness, loss and undermining of traditional structures, a loss of religion in many places, a loss of ways of life. There’s great problems with, gambling of of, grog, of drugs.
And yet, the is actually even more traditional activity in some respects than there was, because it’s because of vehicles that are available because of the ability to the the telecommunication system. So people will travel thousands of miles across the Western Desert for example. So on the one hand there’s a loss and there’s an undermining and on the other to some degree there’s a greater level of religious or spiritual activity of kinship relations are wider, but there’s certainly a diminution of traditional knowledge and authority. I am not an aboriginal person And this is a con something that I need constantly to remind myself that I am not in a position to put my my head into their heads. Whose law?
Well, I’m advising on white fellow law. As difficult as that is, that’s what I’m being asked to advise on, not on their law. And I can only advise on the intersection between our law and their law to the extent that that’s relevant. Except that their law is relevant. And it’s their political objectives, not mine, and that I must be clear as to what the dividing line is.
Yes, I’m advising on sort of straight law legal issues. The there are issues which are both legal and political that I get involved in necessarily. There are legal reform issues and then there are issues that are simply ones that are that are political that I need to that I feel that, if I get involved in, then I am diminished as a lawyer in being able to deal with, the state or with third parties. But, that is an undermining of my honesty and credibility as a lawyer. So there can be plenty of misunderstandings as to the role of and duties of a lawyer on the part of my clients.
I think that there is an expectation that lawyers can do anything, that, there’s always going to be some legal reason as to why you can interfere. You can go along to the court. You can get an injunction. You can do anything. There’s also a misunderstanding as to who the client is.
I insist that my client is the community, that the people as a whole. I’m not acting for individuals, and I do not see that there is a conflict. So that the fact that there are minority views, which are being expressed does not mean that I have a conflict because I’m not acting for individuals. I’m not acting for subgroups. I’m acting for the group as a whole.
And the group as a whole has have processes for making decisions. Now of course there are differences of opinion regarding broad objectives. There are differences of opinion actions in pursuit of those objectives. The broad objectives will include objectives of land rights, the political struggle for the recognition for the grant and for the recognition of legal rights, for the acquisition of economic rights. Social recognition of social rights or human rights of the people of the society of the individuals.
But of course, in relation to land and heritage and culture and continued practice of the religion. But there can be, of course, tensions between those particular rights, the tension between the rights of those who want to leave the land as it is, and at least that they have the perception that they want to leave the land as they they’re they as it is, and those who want to benefit from economic development that may occur. Of course, that desire to participate in economic development or derive economic rights may be based on the fact that government is going to dictate in the final analysis anyway, and that therefore they wish to derive the maximum economic benefit that they can. There tends to be in my view a gross misunderstanding on the part of the wider community as to the sort of tensions that exist within Aboriginal groups, Aboriginal community in facing those difficulties. And in particular I think that you know there are many within say within the green movement, who don’t see that this desire to uphold what they perceive as being some greater traditional law and custom that needs that needs to be protected by aboriginal people in relation to their traditional land should be at the expense of their desire to participate in the economy.
And of course, if you have the view that ultimately the state is going to succeed, then it’s even more understandable because of course ultimately the state does have the power compulsory to acquire. So when you go and look at for example, this is a bit of a digression I appreciate the what’s happening at James Price Point or in relation to the Wild Rivers legislation for example in Queensland. That in relation to James Price Point in the Dampier Peninsula one can say well we don’t want there to be this gas hub there. We want to protect the whales, etc, etc. But ultimately of course the state is subject to environmental protection legislation.
The state is in a position and has threatened compulsory acquisition in relation to that land. So when that’s the case and there’s the opportunity for substantial economic benefit, it’s not surprising that most aboriginal people, and I think it is true most aboriginal people who are sick and tired of not deriving their economic benefits are going to throw their weight behind that. And whilst the options need to be part of my duty is to explain the options is having explained the options, having gone through all the alternatives, then act in accordance with the instructions. Now I’ve said that there’s plenty of conflict. There is conflict and it’s difficult to deal with that conflict without succumbing.
I find it difficult without succumbing to afflicted emotions which cloud and obscure and can become the issue. Now they do become the issue. You know there’s to imagine of course that there’s a single view is simply not the case. You know there can be people who want to reopen fundamental questions. Who want to discuss issues, minorities who want to challenge a well established issue of what the objective is.
Alternatively they want to change the policy and as to how it’s implemented. Now with regard to the latter of course it’s appropriate if circumstances have changed to revisit and to go through and to consider the alternatives. But those can be stressful. Meetings can be difficult and to remain calm is necessary. But in my case, I have difficulty.
I have to confess. Then there’s of course the case of how to to become, how to be patient, how not to get angry or in other words, how to advise fearlessly, because I need to as to what the law is and as to the options and remain focused and dispassionately I. E without being affected by negative emotions. Then there’s a question of how to promote client groups interests in court with the government and with others and remain true to one’s ethical obligations from that point of view. That sort of deals with native title and land rights questions.
So I’m just because I can see that the clock is telling me that it’s 09:48. I’ll just quickly deal with issues of defamation and hope that I have a few minutes left for some questions. And actually if you’ve got matters that you’d like to raise on the issue of of of on that issue, I’m happy to to deal with it. What I might do is I might just very quickly try to just deal with defamation. So defamation you probably know is is relates to the damage to a person’s reputation usually through verbal or written communication to another.
So it requires a communication to a third person. This the defamatory publication causes distress, mental anguish, feelings of hopelessness etc. There’s a desire for validation for vindication or at least a restoration of reputation. His Holiness does talk about the importance of a good reputation but I don’t think that I think people can become unbelievably obsessed with their reputation. Now historically I think that there’s been generally, you know there’s print and broadcast media has been the subject of most defamation matters.
Although there have always been issues with regard to fam what are fundamentally family disputes, neighbor disputes, employment disputes. When they’re those I try to just I try to head them off because I’m not a family lawyer. You know, I don’t deal with fences. I I’m not the employment expert in the firm. I try to decide, well, that’s really not my bailiwick.
However, with the with the Internet, I mean, this is now vastly more of a problem. It really is because, you know, family disputes are on Facebook, you know, on Twitter. You know, and then so there there are there’s all the social media which just has fun really, really made this much, much worse. I mean, within the aboriginal community, for example, within my, you know, client groups, they were all on Facebook. And they’re all, you know, I’m not saying they’re all saying nasty things about each other, but if they’re symptomatic of what’s happening, you know, it’s pretty dreadful, frankly.
So there’s a lot more going. And so people become obsessed about their perception of other people’s perception of them. Alright? You know, if I’m working for a client who has a balanced life and continues to work, isn’t obsessed, isn’t harming themselves by in this way, then it’s relatively okay. But those that have this extraordinary and it really, this rep, there’s this reputation that’s there.
It’s really solid. It’s permanent. It’s unchanging. There’s nothing that they can do about it apart from pursuing this court case for example. And however long it takes and they can’t work because this their reputation is out there.
Well I sort of throw out there. What does an ethical lawyer do in those circumstances? I mean as I said I was very pleased to hear Jampa Tenzin’s view in not entirely dissimilar sets of circumstances that I do ask myself am I helping or am I hindering? But at the same time I’ve got to take on take on on board my duty as a lawyer. But I can’t I can’t simply decide I don’t like this anymore.
I’ve got to continue to provide the options, hope that a more sensible approach can be adopted. I can of course point to the fact that mitigation requires them at least to make some effort. Now in the case of defamation there is the entitlement to general damages simply for the distress and in order to demonstrate that they are vindicated. So that compensation in defamation is A a vindication and B it’s compensation for the distress that has arisen. You have a limit to the amount of damages that can be awarded in relation to general damages.
Then there’s an economic loss. You don’t have to you don’t have to demonstrate economic loss but if you can demonstrate economic loss then the economic loss is additional to the general damages. So you can say, well the client is saying, I can’t work anymore because my you know, there I am. You Google me and this is what you see. And and it would be nice to say, you know, Michael Kirby, if you Google Michael Kirby, what happens?
The first thing that you will see is a ton of stuff about him, you know, trolling using commonwealth cars for trolling for rent boys. But the fact is that he is you know, he’s a judge or former judge with an international reputation that he can handle that. But that is the case that if you you Google him that’s what you’ll find. Whereas for other individuals for whom their professional life they feel is absolutely ruined. That say an academic who finds that where does their academic record appear about, you know, five pages in and all this dreadful stuff about them which may or may not be all lies, which is what appears.
And you can become obsessed with a feeling of hopelessness. I can never get a job. Okay. So it is in this area it’s a fairly constant struggle of trying to do the right thing of not harming people by continue by by really by promoting their continuing obsession. And I do my best I hope to try to mitigate that.
Okay. So as I say, I feel that I have ethical dilemmas. Sometimes I handle them okay. Sometimes I feel very disappointed with myself. I’m sure that everybody else has similar ones.
Perhaps that’s of some assistance in your understanding of of what a lawyer does, at least a lawyer in these areas. Okay. Are there any questions or comments? Are you pointing to something in particular? Well, in the case of aboriginal people, yes.
Well, I mean, I was thinking about this this morning that, I’m supporting or trying to to assist Aboriginal people to be able to exercise their hunting rights over areas of land. You know, and make essentially I’m trying to ensure that they have as much control over decision making in relation to their land as they can have. And they can decide for themselves as to how they’re going to be able to exercise those rights. I really Well, I’m not clearly I’m not I wouldn’t be supporting their hunting of human beings if that’s what they were engaged in doing. That would have that would certainly be a breach of the law in any event.
I’m also faced and I did mean to address this, but of course there is a tension between the rights of the individual and the rights of the society. So that I am supporting the in that sense, the society’s right to continue to live a traditional religious life, spiritual life. Now if they are continuing to practice circumcision, sub incision, scarification, body scarring and so on. So there can be a number of people who will a number of young men for example who want to resist that. And yes, I will be acting in accordance with the instructions of my client group for the purposes of trying to preserve not that level of constraint, but at least to preserve the society’s right to continue to to live that life style.
To continue to have traditional spiritual activities, traditional business in quotes as it’s called. Yes. Yes, of course. And you know the obligation to have firearms registered and where that you know, all of the requirements of the law. And from that point of view, of course, there can be the conflict between, well, we should be recognized as a sovereign people.
How dare you tell us that your sovereign has a right, you know, imposed upon us to dictate these laws and customs. Well, you know, what am I to say? I can only say, well, you know, am here not to advise on what on your law or what you would like what you would like the law of this country to be. I’m only here to advise you as to what the law is. You And you don’t like the law about firearms.
You don’t like the law about the welfare of animals. Oh, okay. But in in part, I’m also saying to people, well, you can make a political decision about this, but no, I can’t go to court and seek an injunction. It’s not going I’m gonna be laughed at. It’s not gonna get you anywhere.
And furthermore, it will actually undermine your credibility. Whereas if you decide that you’re going to stand in front of the bulldozers or you know protesting in relation to this, whatever it is, well, you can make your political statement. That’s your right to do so. I mean, to be heard in our society and to promote it. I can’t do that.
And don’t expect me to do it for you. Well, of course, looking at The United States from the comfort of this country, I look with absolute horror at the way in which judges appointed in The United States on on political grounds. On the other hand, of course, each time there’s a new judge in the high court here, we know what processes are being considered. I mean, you know, the next judge, Justice Gageler, will is automatic. I mean, of course, in The United States, they will continue until their dying day in order, you know, in the in the Supreme Court.
They will stay there until their dying day and this is viewed as essential seems for the purposes of the preservation of the independence of the judiciary. So that they can control when they leave and you know if you’re a democratic democrat you will retire at a time in which Obama is the president and otherwise you presumably Clarence Thomas who’s going to be there for a huge length number of years because he’s still pretty young will wait until there’s a Republican there. In this country they were forced to retire at the age of whatever it is 70, I think. And so you’re going to lose some of the very best judges. And then the government in power at that time at the federal level will be able to after consultation decide who should replace.
But it is that they have you know at least they’re taking they’re considering who is respected within the legal profession rather than deciding strictly on political grounds.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.