Ilia Seminars

55 min · 7,308 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Ilia Seminars (Ilia Durovic)
Ilia Seminars (Ilia Durovic)
Ilia Seminars
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 55-minute seminar, Ilia Durovic introduces the Three Principal Aspects of the Path by first establishing why Westerners come to Buddhism: suffering incompletely addressed by materialism or welfare systems. He contrasts the monotheistic traditions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) with the Indian philosophical traditions, showing that while monotheisms attribute suffering to human wrongdoing and seek remedy through divine connection, the Gangetic traditions—Buddhism, Vedanta, and others—trace suffering to mistaken perception of reality. He argues that without an accurate understanding of how things actually exist, negative emotions intensify, compounding suffering. Durovic then outlines the structure of the Buddhist path across three scopes, emphasizing that the view of emptiness and interdependence is essential for both liberation and full enlightenment but unnecessary and potentially harmful for those pursuing only higher rebirth. The seminar concludes with a discussion of the critical verse from Je Tsongkhapa and how the four Buddhist schools of tenets agree on the base (suffering cyclic existence) and goal (liberation or enlightenment) while differing on the interdependence one must realize. Suited to those with prior study of Buddhist logic and Tibetan philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 31062017IliaSeminarPartA – IS.mp3

UUID: f00135a9-c794-4f6c-aa4e-c649e0a7d2f4

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: Ilia Seminars

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~7,303

Good afternoon everybody. I think everybody has either been here before or knows Ilya so I won’t take up time with introduction other than to say thank you so much Ilya for another of your seminars on Three Principal Aspects of the Path. As usual, a short break and yeah, over to you, Ilya. Thank you. Those are the best introductions, right?

The non introduction. Then since we shall really be covering as of today’s view, which is the innermost essence of the Buddhist teachings. And since I think a majority of those in this room are Buddhist, then those of us who are Buddhist shall take refuge at present by making three prostrations to the statue of Buddha Śākyamūni behind me. And we will recite together, I hope you know them, the refuge verses in Sanskrit. Then as of this session, there will be a slight change in format.

As you know, since 2010 approximately, I have relied very heavily on PowerPoint for these presentations. Largely because after I had been giving teachings for two years at TBI, I realized that the traditional mode of Buddhist presentation was not resonating with the students. And that it had it was necessary to try to bridge the Buddhist teachings with modernity and modern understanding. So for this, I have used PowerPoint for the last seven years. And then the glitches we’ve had with the projector the last two times, let me to think that perhaps the time had come to split the presentation into two categories.

I will start again these presentations bridging modernity and Buddhism next year. And I will also give traditional Buddhist presentations. Now for the first, I will rely on PowerPoint and for the traditional Buddhist presentations, I will not. Largely because I find PowerPoint is a very restrictive format and it prevents me in this case from adapting the teaching to the students who are present. So one ends up with something which is used either too advanced or not advanced enough.

You know? And also, frankly, because, it is a Buddhist tradition that the teachings are tailored to the students, it’s not possible to do that with PowerPoint. It’s pre prepared. Then if we have a lot of students coming from the tenets class, the presentation may not be advanced enough. And if we have a lot of beginners, the presentation may be too advanced.

Therefore, today I will rely very little on PowerPoint, just rely on it to put the text up on the screen. And you will have to take careful notes because I will assume, in these classes on the view that most of you have been attending teachings at TBI regularly. I will be taking for granted a knowledge of Lorig, of tenets, to a degree of Sa Lam and some of the Cittamātra course. We unfortunately cannot indefinitely go over beginners material over and over again. And then here really, we will be starting With the stanza at the top of this PowerPoint page, for those of you who have the text, it is on page three of the text, the reason for which the view is necessary.

The captions here are from His Holiness the Dalai Lama’s commentary. Then, because the view is really the distinguishing feature of the Buddhist teachings, I would like as I have generally done in these presentations to start by taking as broad a view as possible and then focus in during the rest of this presentation or this teaching. So basically, at present you are what? Two, four, six, eight, ten, twelve, 14, maybe 16 in the room. Some of you are of Buddhist culture and are therefore rooted to a degree in the Buddhist teachings.

The majority of you are not and are Westerners. Then it is not a normal step for a Westerner to come to a Buddhist center. The majority of westerners do not. And why? Do you need other copies of the Three Principal Aspects of the Path or you all have a copy?

You do have a copy? You can have that one. So as I was saying it is not a normal or common step for a westerner to come to a Buddhist center. Unlike, those of our students who are, of Asian culture for which it is part of the traditions, you know. So why precisely are you here?

Since a majority of westerners never go to a Buddhist temple nor have any interest in ever going. Largely speaking, I suspect because you come out of personal suffering. Now, this suffering has a variety of forms. For a small minority of our students, it is physical suffering. Typically, disease or chronic physical pain which simply cannot be addressed by modern western medicine.

For others, I would say majority, it is one of the modalities of mental suffering. It can be mere dissatisfaction with one’s condition. It can be existential anxiety at the approach of one’s death and the absence of any answers. It can be a more damaged mind where the person has lost control of their mind for a long period of time and you end up with states of chronic anxiety, of depression, or even in extreme cases, full blown mental disease, such as schizophrenia and so forth. Then, why come here?

If we look at human history, this issue of human suffering has basically been central in the genesis of all the great religions. And they can broadly be speaking be subdivided into two families and this is a very coarse and simplistic subdivision. We have the monotheistic religious traditions. In other words, Judaism, Christian Christianity and it’s the recent offshoot of basically Judaism which is Islam. And we have, again, very broadly speaking, what I have called the Gangetic traditions.

The religious traditions born in India in the basin of the Ganges from approximately, let’s say, the seventh sixth to seventh century BC, and the process of generation is still continuing. Both these great religious traditions or groups of traditions try to address the problem of human suffering. So we ourselves, as westerners, we are culturally products of the monotheistic traditions. We may not be Christian or Jewish, some of you might be of Muslim origin, but at the end of the day, we were raised in families where these core beliefs resonated. And therefore, we are informed by the monotheistic answers to the problem of suffering.

So the monotheistic answers to the problem of suffering in a nutshell is that creation was perfect. It became imperfect by the thought of man. This is known as a fall, if you wish. And that perfection can be reclaimed through following the advice of an all powerful creator. This is the law in Judaism and Islam or by communion with that creator through a person.

This is a person of Jesus Christ in Christianity. Now around the sixteenth century, this view of things became less and less tenable in the light of first the great discoveries and then modern scientific development. As a result, I’d say from the late nineteenth century, especially the twentieth century onwards, a majority of westerners have completely discarded the traditional beliefs in the existence of a god, in the existence of salvation, in prayer to god as a means to salvation combined with works, faith, or grace depending on the Christian religious tradition, you know, and have turned to material answers as the means to eliminate suffering. And the contemporary consensus in all Western countries is that suffering is random. It happens.

It is due to socioeconomic conditions, and it can be addressed through increasing the level of prosperity of society and targeting this prosperity that is what is known as a welfare state. Australia is a perfect example of this. Australia is a massively secular society, perhaps one of the most secular western societies. I think perhaps the most. And the cure of suffering is the welfare state.

Most of you, not all, but many of you are on welfare, one form or another. It can be pensions, disability benefits, what do they call it, new start, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. Your personal problems are addressed by the state. In other words, your actual refuge is the state, the welfare state. Then, obviously, this works quite well to a degree.

Our societies are more prosperous than ever before. Course, physical suffering has been greatly reduced. Mental suffering, it is more complicated. But this approach, which is a materialist approach, which is present, I’d say, in all our mind streams at present. This approach to solving the human predicament, this approach to suffering eventually breaks down.

And it’s when it’s break when it breaks down that many of you look elsewhere and typically you look to Buddhist centers. Buddhism has become the default option in most or for most interested in spiritual traditions. It’s not a state of affairs I think Buddhists are particularly keen upon. No one wants to be the default option. We’d like to be a positive informed choice, but that’s the way it is.

So why is Buddhism the default option? That’s what I was asking you at the beginning. Why are you here, in other words? Basically, Buddhism is the spiritual tradition which is the closest to materialism. If you are interested in spirituality and you want to take one step out of the materialist shell, Buddhism, which has always described itself as the middle way between the two extremes, is easily accessible.

And it is here that the distinction between the outlook on suffering between the monotheistic and the Gangetic traditions is very important. As we said, in the monotheistic traditions, suffering is incidental to creation. It is due to the wrong choices of man. It can be repaired by repairing this bond with the creator through following the will of the creator or some type of connection with the creator through a person. This is not at all the view in the Indian religious traditions in which Buddhism was born.

In the Indian religious traditions and especially those born in the Ganges, the problem of suffering was perhaps even more acute than in Palestine, which is the birthplace of most of the world’s monotheistic religious traditions. And the analysis of the great sages which you find in the Upanishads and Buddha Śākyamūni evolves in this milieu is that suffering arises from the inadequation between the way we see the world and the way the world is. Suffering, in other words, arises from mistaken perception. This is a fundamentally different analysis from that of the monotheistic tradition. There is no common ground whatsoever.

Then within that analysis which is that the suffering not just of human beings but all living beings arises because the way they perceive the world and the way the world is are different. There are numerous answers to the core question which is how does the world actually exist? So all, almost all of the Indian religious traditions, whether you look at the Upanishads or Vedanta or the various schools of tenets in Buddhism, the four Buddhist schools of tenets, all agree without any ambiguity that sentient beings, in other words, with a consciousness perceive the world differently from its actual mode of existence. And it is because their perception is different from the way the world actually exists that suffering arises. The greater their perception is at odds with the actual mode of existence of the world, the greater the suffering.

And this mistaken mode of perception of reality and of persons leads to the negative emotions what are called the afflictions klesha. The more intense one is mistaken in one’s perception of other persons and physical reality, the more powerful the desire, the more powerful the anger, the more powerful the jealousy, and as a result, the greater the suffering. So here you can see that the difference between these two great families of spiritual traditions is profound. The first, the monotheistic traditions are in my book, True Religions. The second, the Indian spiritual traditions, I feel, are better described as philosophies.

I am not sure that the term religion as we use it in the in the West, or for that matter, the term spiritual apply. These are philosophies because the focus is on a change of the mode of perception of reality. And therefore, all of the Indian traditions have endeavored to understand two things. The mode of existence of the person and the mode of existence of phenomena or the outer world. Not out of an abstract philosophical interest as let’s say is the case of Kant’s philosophy in in in the West.

But simply because after understanding the actual mode of existence of oneself in the world, the goal is to transform one’s mind to see things as they are, and in this way to eliminate suffering. This transformation occurs through concentration and analysis which are called meditation. Meditation is this inward process of the mind, which first concentrates on something which it really wishes to transform the mind in the function of, and then analyzes this to deepen its understanding. This is called concentration and analytical meditation. There is nothing else to the Indian spiritual or philosophical traditions than this.

This is all there is. Then the differences become very major. As we said broadly speaking, all the Indian traditions, and we shall start using a present technical terminology, that the base, in other words, cyclic existence which is the uninterrupted cycle of lives of all sentient beings is unsatisfactory. None has gone so far in condemning it as Buddhism, which describes it in terms of the eight, the six, and the three sufferings. But all agree it is a state of affairs one wishes to escape.

There’s no difference at all. If you read Chāndogya Upanishad or Brihadaranyaka Upanishad in the Indian, in the Hindu tradition, or you read for instance the Fire Sermon of the Buddha, you have the same sense of profound dissatisfaction with the base, which is described as what must be abandoned. cyclic existence. And already at this point, a very basic issue for westerners who convert to Buddhism is that they don’t believe that the base exists. They don’t believe in cyclic existence.

It is clear that someone who comes from a materialist tradition, would consider that before this life there was nothing and after this life there was basically nothing. Then the idea of a cycle of lives in which, for instance, a mental consciousness reincarnates from life to life is an intellectual curiosity at best. And why one would want to escape to it is even less obvious. So the first step is to generate a profound conviction in the existence of the base of cyclic existence. And this I think as I’ve mentioned many times here can best be done through studying the works of professor Ian Stevenson which reduces very substantial reasons demonstrating the existence of reincarnation.

Not just among human beings, but from human beings to animals, animals to human beings. I have given these cases at TBI many times over the last ten years now. Now, once one is convinced of the existence of the base, in other words, once one’s mind has ceased to be this extremely small and narrow western mind, which is focused on this life alone. And one realized that this that this life is, if you wish, as one grain of a rosary, and there is basically an infinite number of grains linked by this red string which is the mind. Once one understands this, one’s scope has broadened.

The next step is to analyze the nature of this space. And here, I think Western converts to Buddhism face another obstacle, which is that typically life in the West is comfortable. The rest of the world wants to emigrate here, basically. So it says something. Right?

The rest of the world wants to dress like us, wants to speak our languages, wants to study in our schools. So obviously, as far as this life is concerned, we are number one. Right? There’s no debate. Then if this life is so comfortable, why exactly would you want to escape from the state of affairs?

So for most westerners, it is very difficult to see cyclic existence as an object of abandonment. Because cyclic existence, if it is just an extension of this life, sounds very nice and this is the situation with the new age groups. We typically believe in reincarnation, have a sort of nebulous belief in karma and causality, but don’t really see why you should make any effort to escape from the whole state of affairs. But here, one has to think very carefully, first of the existence of lower rebirths. So I try to demonstrate this here, drawing again from Stevenson’s research.

And then, within a human life, one has to think about the various sufferings one encounters. And when one thinks about that, then the idea of going through the state of affairs over and again becomes very difficult to take on board. For instance, in this room, a majority of our students are middle aged or elderly. Those of you who are elderly are facing directly the suffering of aging and death. Then, it’s quite interesting to see the reactions of our students when they hear that one of their own is ill, possibly terminally ill.

It’s often interesting for me to see that at that point, the students enter into something akin to a state of shock. This is a clear sign of lack of meditation on death and impermanence. It means that it has remained theoretical. Now this is one of the numerous suffering, the suffering of aging and death, which is a given for all of us. Within the eight sufferings, we have the suffering of birth, which we do not remember.

Aging, which all of us are experiencing or will experience. Sickness, which some of you will experience, and death, which we all will experience. And then we have the sufferings which so many in Australia have started to experience after the GFC. Encountering what is unwanted. Not encountering what is wanted.

Not getting what one desires. Now this, I can see, I have seen over the years on your faces. How many faces have changed here? How many faces when I came to TBI were young and fresh and are now aged faces, bitter faces. This bitterness this bitterness is a good thing.

This bitterness opens the door to some type of spiritual development. So the first step is therefore to meditate on these eight sufferings in. The six sufferings of cyclic existence are general sufferings which we all experience on a daily basis. The first which has become again very acute since 2001 and especially 2008 for Westerners. The rest of the world has been living through this, you know, for many, many decades.

It’s a suffering of uncertainty. We have entered an uncertain world. Those of you who are studying for a profession have no guarantee that they will have a job when they finish their studies. Those of you who are on pensions have no guarantee that you will continue to get your pensions. The rules are changing under our feet.

The fact that the rules are changing is not something which is abnormal and which should be resisted. This is the way things are. This is a suffering of uncertainty. The fact that one day a student is healthy and the next day has cancer or is in a coma or is under psychiatric treatment or has happened to one of our students who was with me in India is dead. The student went to Kushinagar and collapsed on the road from a stroke and she was dead.

The Chapat Chirpal, the monk who was here, came to bang on my door and asked what do I do with the body? I had to drive it to Mysore, right? In a taxi. There’s no ambulances in India. Right?

Very few. Then the second major suffering of cyclic existence which is prevalent in our lives is a suffering of dissatisfaction. Whatever we have it is never enough. As soon as we get it, we aspire for something else and it is our misfortune that we live in societies whose economic model is built on fostering dissatisfaction. And therefore, we are encouraged to desire as much as possible.

It’s a little bit like going to a pub to slake your thirst and being served, I’m told this is done. Beer with salt inside. Right? Well, the more you drink, the more thirsty you are. You know?

Then our entire society is built on this market. Whether you watch television, you go on the Internet, you read the papers, you go downtown, there is a constant attempt to foster desire. This desire forces us to lead lives which we are actually unable to live. And this suffering of dissatisfaction has led, especially since the GFC in all Western countries, to an explosion of debt. Many of our students’ lives have collapsed because of debt.

You know? Those who have are desperately trying to retain their situation. Those who don’t have want what those who have have and borrow to get it, mortgaging their future. And this is not just a human situation in Australia, it’s a human situation in The UK, United States, in Europe, in Venezuela for that matter. The situation of all living beings.

Then the remaining four sufferings, we have obviously the suffering of being born over and again which we do not remember, but by all accounts midwives say that birth for the baby is an extremely difficult and painful experience. Some yogis are said to remember this moment. It is extremely challenging. The suffering of dying over again, then those of you who wish to know what the suffering of death entails should ask Chris, who is in palliative care, and a Lojong and very solid and reliable Buddhist practitioner. Chris was telling me a couple days ago that most of your patients are materialists, don’t they, when they die?

And the death is one of great suffering, you were telling me. You feel craving on such a state that it indicates rebirth almost as a preta, right? And this is what one experiences if there has been no mental development of any type. As I said to my wife a year or two ago, know, materialism is a philosophy of the young, the handsome, and the rich. While you are young, handsome, and rich, you can get away with being materialistic.

And when you grow old, ugly, and poor, no one wants to be your friend, no one wants to lend you money, no one wants to be your husband or your wife, right? Then materialism is awful, right? So the wise, whether you’re young, rich and intelligent, try to find something more than materialism. So as we said, the other suffering, the fourth suffering is suffering of dying over again, and then we have a suffering which so many here have experienced in the last ten years, a suffering of falling from the high to the low. Where the person had a very high living standard, was unable to maintain it.

Then I have known extreme cases where the person took ridiculous risks to try to maintain a living standard which is no longer affordable. Then we have had among our students, among people I know in Europe, people I know here, bankruptcies, depression, cancer, as a result of stress, mental disease. This is suffering of falling from the high to the low, combined with great dissatisfaction, great craving. And the final suffering which is perhaps the hardest one to accept is the suffering of being alone. All of us in this base of cyclic existence, we are completely alone.

Our friendships, relationships, our children for whom we sacrifice so much don’t value us. I mean, it’s always quite interesting in parental love that it’s a one way street. Parent loves and the child is the recipient. What they love back is an open question. Those of you who have poor parents, I think you can confirm this.

Right? So you have made great sacrifices for your children. At the end of the day, what for? Once said, I thought it was very profound. He said, he never understood the rationale of the love parents had for their children.

He said it seemed to him to be something genetic, but why? He could never figure it out. I thought it was very profound. I could never understand why people have children. Obviously, we are programmed biologically for this.

You know, if we didn’t have children, the species would cease. But I think in this room, one of you is happy with your children. Right? Okay. They’re young.

Wait ten years. We’ll talk in ten years. We’ll talk in ten years. So these are the six sufferings and the three sufferings I shall not talk about. We’ve talked about them many times here, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and all pervasive suffering.

So this from the Buddhist standpoint is the nature of the base. And within the three paths, the path of the being shared with the small, the middling, and the great scope. True Buddhism begins with the path shared with the being of the middling scope, which is a heartfelt deep wish to escape from the base of cyclic existence. The path shared with the being of the small scope, which is turning away from this life and striving for future lives is a prelude. This is actually shared with all or almost all of the non Indian Buddhist traditions.

It is justified by Nāgārjuna in Ratnāvali in his Precious Garland by saying that higher rebirths are necessary for the attainment of liberation and most of us will be unable to attain liberation within one life. Therefore, we must prepare as a foundation a string of higher rebirths in which we can practice life after life so that eventually we can attain liberation. And this is the sole rationale for the path shared as a being of the small scope, which otherwise one finds broad aspects of in Christianity. Let’s say Christianity teaches ethics, teaches morality, teaches loving kindness, teaches restraint to quite a degree, you know, then all of this leads to a higher rebirth. The Christians do not believe in the existence of past and future lives, but that makes no difference.

You know, they still will attain a higher rebirth as a result of this. Likewise, a Hindu who is a vegetarian, practitioner of a Himsa, of nonviolence, who does not drink, who endeavors to help us, definitely will get a higher rebirth. But this is only in a very subsidiary sense part of the Buddhist teachings. The Buddhist teachings begin the fully characterized Buddhist teachings begin with a path shared with the being of the middling scope, and culminate with a path of the being of the great scope. Now, for both of these, the view is indispensable.

Whereas the view is unnecessary for the path shared with the being of the small scope. The view is even potentially dangerous for the practitioner on the path shared with the being of the small scope simply because typically practitioners on the path shared with the being of the small scope practice based on faith. Understanding is limited, the view can be misleading. And this is why Nāgārjuna says in Ratnāvali that there is a profound difference between the extreme of eternalism and the extreme of nihilism. They are not symmetrical.

The Buddha’s teachings are middle way between the extreme of eternalism and nihilism. But someone who subscribes to the extreme of eternalism, in other words, the belief in the existence of a god, will on that basis get a higher rebirth. Someone who subscribes to the extreme of nihilism will not get a higher rebirth, but will be reborn in the lower realms. Because nihilism, the belief in nihilism, in other words, that there is nothing before this life and nothing after this life, precludes any type of ethics. Then an objection I have often heard to this viewpoint is that everyone knows very good and sincere atheists.

Then here you have to distinguish rather carefully. The first question is, is the belief really heartfelt? Does a person really believe that the mind can be reduced to the brain and that there is nothing else or not? Or is it just verbally held? A lot of people are, especially in Christian societies, atheists because they had problems with strict religious parents in their upbringing.

But the Christian teachings are there in the background. Such a person will still lead an ethical life by indirection, if you wish. And then the second issue which has to be brought up is even if the person is a sincere nihilist, you have to keep in mind that here, overwhelmingly, people are not put under pressure. Lives are easy. The question is how do you behave when you are put under real pressure?

And that doesn’t mean that your benefits have been cut by $10 a week. Right? Then under real pressure, if and this is my sincerely held opinion and, you know, rooted also in Nāgārjuna. If there is no spiritual backdrop, the person will over time return to the state of an animal. Of this, am convinced.

There is a veneer of civilization which is a lot thinner than most of us believe it is. And when the knife is on one’s throat, unless there is something greater than one’s life, then we are overwhelmed by animal instincts. And then there is no ethics worth talking about. So for this reason, the two extremes are not symmetrical. And this is a strong Buddhist argument against conversion of those of other religions.

Because most of the other religions subscribe to the extreme of eternalism. Then on that basis, one definitely can attain a higher rebirth. And therefore, one should not meddle with that because of the risk of the person falling in the extreme of nihilism, which then leads definitely to the lower realms and specifically to the cold hells. So this is why says, since one who is not endowed with the wisdom realizing the mode of abiding, in other words, selflessness, albeit having become accustomed to definite emergence in bodhicitta, will be unable to sever the root of existence, strive at means to realize interdependence. And we will spend most of this conference commenting on this stance.

So I have given you already some major pointers here. We will first read this answer together and then I would like to present it as best I can from the standpoint of the four schools of tenets. So here’s the mode of abiding refers to selflessness in the broadest sense. Now this this text, the Three Principal Aspects of the Path is written from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. So this refers both to the selflessness of persons and of phenomena.

And the wisdom realizing the mode of abiding abiding is the wisdom realizing emptiness. Now this wisdom realizing emptiness as we said, is indispensable both for attaining the goal of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, in other words, liberation. And for attaining the goal of the path of the being of the great scope which is full and utter enlightenment. The difference between attaining one goal or the other is the motivation and these two motivations are given. The first is definite emergence.

Motivated by definite emergence, if one meditates on emptiness, one will attain liberation. But one will not attain full and utter enlightenment. Whereas motivated by bodhicitta, if one meditates on emptiness, one will attain eventually full and utter enlightenment. In both cases, for the path shared with the being of the middling and the great scope, the path shared with the being of the small scope is just a preliminary. It creates the conditions for one to be able to practice uninterruptedly life after life.

So the goal is a very far reaching one. Now here, the critical point in this verse is the last line. Strive at means to realize interdependence. You will notice that Je Tsongkhapa is not talking about selflessness but interdependence. It is something we will talk about shortly.

But the question which arises and this is the question from the standpoint of all four schools of Buddhist tenets, the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra, Madhyamaka school, which all share the same understanding of the base of saṃsāra as of the nature of suffering marked by the eight to six in the three sufferings. The question which arises from the standpoint of all schools is which interdependence? In other words, what do you meditate upon to gain liberation of full and utter enlightenment? So cyclic existence is the object of abandonment. The question now is the means.

There is general agreement about the result in the Buddhist schools of tenets. The result, depending on one’s motivation, is liberation of full full enlightenment. There’s no disagreement. There’s no disagreement about the nature of the base. It is a saṃsāra, which can be described as in terms of the first two noble truths, noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering.

And within the noble truth of suffering in terms of the eight, the six, and the three sufferings. Or if you want a more precise description, our individual saṃsāra is our individual set of 12 limbs. The interconnected links of 12 limbs which each one of us, you know, goes through life after life after life. So there is complete agreement between Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra and Madhyamaka about the base and about the result, the objective attainment. Although the Hīnayāna school say that aiming for full and utter enlightenment is unrealistic, it is sufficient to aim for liberation.

They in no way deny the existence of Bodhisattvas and they no in way in no way deny the existence of full and utter enlightenment since their teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, was a fully enlightened being. They just say it is unnecessary to strive for something that difficult to obtain. Individual liberation is sufficient. Whereas the Mahāyāna Schools of Tenets put as their goal the attainment of full and utter enlightenment. Both the two broad divisions of the schools of tenets Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna agree as far as the existence of the object of attainment of the other school is concerned.

There’s no difference. Do you understand so far? They disagree regarding the desirability of the object of attainment if you wish. And then, for all four schools of tenets, subscribe to the belief that one can generate either definite emergence or bodhicitta. They differ in their understanding of selflessness.

The two lower schools of tenets assert only the selflessness of persons. The two higher schools of tenets, in addition to the selflessness of persons, assert the selflessness of phenomena. And selflessness is intimately linked with interdependence, so their understanding of interdependence differs slightly. The understanding of interdependence differs slightly. Then here, before we enter any detailed presentation of selflessness, if you have any questions on the first part of this presentation, I’ll be happy to take some.

Just in regard to the being of the small scope, I was thinking about how the monotheistic religions promote ethics and selflessness and qualities like that, charitable selflessness and so forth, and how that brings one’s actions more in line with reality while the view maybe remains not as in line with reality and that is what leads to a higher rebirth? Yes, that’s exactly it. That’s exactly it. If you present it in terms of method and wisdom, the method component of the path specifically in Christianity, and to a lesser degree in later forms of Judaism like Hasidism, is quite compatible with the Buddhist method component of the past. The generation of love, of compassion are broadly speaking similar.

The base is much smaller. So the base in the monotheistic traditions is only beings with a soul, which means human beings. Then beings who do not have a soul, in other words the animal realm, were created to serve human beings. So one of my old, old friends, she was the main sponsor of Tārā Tulku Rinpoche who taught, Madame Manon Ansermet. Her father was a very famous Swiss conductor, Ernest Ansermet.

And she, as a little child, she had a pet rabbit. This was in Calvinist Geneva, where Calvinism was really practiced quite purely. And during one of the numerous moves of her father, they dropped inadvertently a dresser on the rabbit, which obviously was killed instantaneously. And little Anne burst into tears. And the Protestant minister, the family minister was helping, scolded her very sharply and said, you should not cry for these inanimate creatures.

They have no soul. They were merely created by God to serve man. And she was like eight or nine years old. And then this is what turned her to Buddhism later on. So, While indeed Christianity does teach loving compassion and does teach empathy.

These are limited to human beings. And that aspect of Christianity in particular is highly compatible with Mahāyāna Buddhism which is why Mahāyāna Buddhism has spread so much in the West as a religious alternative, whereas Theravāda has not. Right? Then the view, the Christian view has no common denominator at all with Buddhism. There’s no relationship.

God is an inherently existent being. Then you could say that creation is not inherently existent through being created by God. But in the meantime, you have asserted the existence of an inherently existent being. And the Buddhist critique of all monotheisms has been that when you assert the existence of a truly created creator, then because that creator is truly existent in the fullest sense of the term, very powerful negative emotions can arise on that basis. And this is what we see now in The Middle East.

The law of that creator is broken by some, you know, and people truly believe that Allah or Yahweh, you know, passed the laws in Leviticus for Judaism, passed the laws in the Quran for the Muslims, and then someone who breaks these laws and drinks, who now in Syria even smokes, I’m told, you know, is offending the Almighty. Right? And the almighty is truly existent. On this basis, tremendous hatred arises. This is the root of the Buddhist critique of this notion.

Indeed, it reduces the hatred. No. It should reduce. The hatred one has for other beings who are all seen as participating in creation. In Christianity, they’re described as sons.

Right? Sons of the father, you know. But in reality, what it does is that it fosters tremendous hostility to all those who are seen as countering the plan for creation. And the plan for creation, certainly in Judaism and Islam, is encapsulated in the law. So we are in two radically different mental universes.

There’s no middle ground. However, someone who is post Christian from a western background finds it easy to pass to Mahāyāna Buddhism. The difficulties arise with those elements of Mahāyāna Buddhism which are not part of the western background, specifically the existence of cyclic existence. And even more so, the suffering nature of cyclic existence. It was striking to me a couple days ago when Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen was talking about these topics, I could see on the faces of some students an extremely negative reaction.

One student asked whether desire was necessarily wrong. And from a Buddhist perspective, there is no debate. Yes. From a Christian, Jewish or Muslim perspective, there’s a very big difference. You have legitimate and illegitimate desire.

Desire was created by God. Then desire in a family for one’s wife is legitimate and praised. Actually, both in Judaism and Islam, not marrying is a sin. It counters the will of God, which as you remember from the book of Genesis, go forth and procreate. You know?

Then Christianity has had to wiggle its way out of that room because of the influence of the Greek monastic traditions. But, obviously, when one is comes from a culture in which distinction is made between legitimate and illegitimate desire, then converting to a religious tradition in which all desire is an object of abandonment is difficult. Likewise in Islam, there’s a very clear distinction between legitimate and illegitimate anger. You find this to a degree in Judaism. The righteous anger of the just, the anger of anger of the prophet Elijah for instance, in the book of Kings.

Then that righteous anger is holy anger. It’s virtuous. And I remember a very strange conversation I had with an old Muslim. It was strange because he was waving a knife all along, you know. So I was quite worried about my future.

I was in a train going to Mysore, a sleeper, and I was ordained at the period. And there was this old Hindu gentleman, a Brahmin, and his friend was a non-Muslim, but they had been retired officials, you know. And George Bush had been doing what he had been doing. And at the period, I was American, and Americans were extremely unpopular. So this this old pair, they were very nice and kind until they learned I was American.

And then this old Muslim gentleman grabbed a fruit knife and started shouting that he hated George Bush while waving the fruit knife at me, you know. And I tried to calm him down. It took a couple hours, but in the course of the conversation what was striking was to hear him defend anger as something which gave him strength, something which was necessary, which allowed him to affirm himself. He came out with some rather outrageous statements in the process. I remember him saying to me, in my family, only I beat.

I am the only one I’m sorry to the ladies. I’m the only one who can beat my wife. My son cannot beat my wife. He tried once, I beat him. And I was listening to this.

Okay. You know. And then as we became better friends, eventually what came out was that he suffered from recurrent episodes of deep and profound depression, obviously triggered by these fits of uncontrolled anger, you see. All this to say that when we change religious traditions, which is the case of most westerners in this room, and when we convert to another family of religions, the monotheistic family to the gangetic family, we bring baggage with us. We must be mindful of the baggage we bring.

In our cases, as Westerners, it is typically a distinction between legitimate and illegitimate desire. And basically, especially in the West nowadays, view that desire is not really a problem. Anger is basically, you know, a problem from Western standpoints. Right? Then that is simply not compatible with the Buddhist teachings.

You know? So this we have to be mindful of. And then perhaps we will take a break now, unless you have other questions. And after the break, will start entering into a more careful analysis of the selflessness of persons. So I will contrast the belief in the self of persons in the Upanishadic tradition and the selflessness of persons in the Hīnayāna schools.

And then we will talk about the selflessness of phenomena and what the meaning of interdependence in this verse of Je Tsongkhapa is.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top