1 h 44 min · 11,133 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 104-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche introduces the Udānavarga, an ancient Buddhist text preserved on bark in Central Asia, by anchoring it to a contemporary question: why do trauma survivors often fail to heal spiritually? He walks through the Udānavarga’s core verses on impermanence, desire, heedfulness, and the illusion of beauty—each revealing a source of suffering and pointing toward mental purification through virtue and meditation. He explains the text’s original purpose: not as scripture for scholars, but as practical instruction tailored to specific levels of practitioners. He then addresses a persistent problem in Western Buddhism: that traditional teachings rest on metaphysical assumptions (non-materiality, rebirth, karma) that modern students reject. He concludes by arguing that recent quantum physics validates Buddhist philosophy, making ancient teaching intellectually coherent for contemporary practitioners. For serious students with prior Buddhist study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 19112016Illia talk mp4 export simon 4 – KR.mp3
UUID: 77e765bd-1ea0-4d23-a7ab-d459e949e230
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Ilia Seminars
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~11,133
During the break. Why Australian soldiers with post traumatic stress syndrome when returned from Afghanistan tend to have such a high prevalence of suicide? I told you they are meditating on how they can experience it. But I think the answer is very simple. It’s largely because there is no spiritual opening after the experience of death.
Then they see death as an inspiration. There’s a Danish doctor who was attached to Delek Hospital in Dharamsala. And Delek Hospital has a section specializing in the rehabilitation of the victims of torture, Tibetan victims of torture in communist China. And this doctor had worked with South American political prisoners. So he had seen firsthand the damage, psychological and physical damage of torture by the Chilean and Argentinean military junglers.
And he told me, he actually came specifically to see me, he said he was really very shocked by the fact that the Tibetans he worked with had, generally speaking, levels of physical damage which were far higher than those of the victims of the victims in Chile and Argentina, because I think the Chinese gods did not expect them to survive and leave Tibet. But he said that there was little or no psychological damage. And it shocked him. He said there was none of the feelings of low self worth, self hate, depression, which really were characteristic of the victims of torture, in Chile and Argentina. He asked why.
And I said, what what I proposed to him was to come to see us at Sera and spend a couple weeks or even months in the monastery to see how the Tibetans lived and how they thought. And I told him, I I suspected him make a difference to his understanding, and that’s what he did. Came to Sera. He spent, I think, more than a month, a and a half or so. And at the end of his stay, he said he’s gonna write it up, and he’d send me a copy.
I’ve never received, but I think it’s written up. And he said, really, he could see how the Buddhist outlook would enable someone to go through an experience like that with little or no damage. Then this is someone who is not a Buddhist in any sense of the word, who is just judging on the efficacy of these techniques of mental training based on their experience. So there is definitely some independent evidence that these techniques of mental training do work. And now there were some doubts I wanted to bring up.
So obviously, in the light of Je Tsongkhapa’s quote, as you remember, the mind striving for liberation arises day and night. But if that’s the case, would have to be what we know as a mind arisen from meditation. In other words, it would have to be a mind arisen from calm abiding. It would therefore see that calm abiding is indispensably to enter the past. And I have some questions for you.
You had a little break. Minds are refreshed. You have reflected, even meditated on the topics during the break. I could hear very little conversation in the background. Mhmm.
So the question I would like to ask you is, if one has generated near death with emergence, is what a Buddhist or not? No. No. Okay. Why?
Other merchants generate the same book. Yes. Exactly. So can you see what the benefit of other religious traditions would be? Mere definite emergence is very powerful.
And there’s a much sharper debate than this one. If one has generated definite emergence, is only Buddhist or not? Only a Buddhist or If a Buddhist generated definite emergence, fully characterized definite emergence is one a Buddhist or not. So one views cyclic existence as of the nature of suffering. One is striving for moksha, for liberation, and one is striving day and night as one is listening.
But since Buddhists and non-Buddhist understand Mokśa, Buddhist speak of nirvana, non-Buddhist speak of Mokśa. Define the term Mokśa in Buddhist text as well. Since you understand it as a cessation of suffering, I mean, it is impossible not to credit the non-Buddhist traditions of India that like to the for instance, or some forms of with the capacity to generate a striving for liberation. And from a Buddhist standard, they cannot attain it. But definite emergence, definitely, they can create.
Do you see the distinction? With definite emergence, it cannot be found in non-Buddhist religious traditions. Fully characterized definite emergence. Fully characterized definite emergence. Yes, sir.
Okay. That’s good. Now the second that I have for you is in. Look at the lamrim. The somatopoi includes the general features of kava and of refuge in the past shared to being of the small soul.
Then in the verses of the generation of near definite emergence, there is no mention made of an act. As a matter of fact, as you will see in my next comment, the general features of karma are included in the path of the being as the middle scope in the three principles of the path. Why? I wish I had a camera. You see that it’s as a cause.
They they’re used in the middle of the scope as a cause to generate fully characterized effect of emergence. What is the what is the main object of meditation, path of the being of the middle scope? cyclic existence and cause effect. Okay. Technically?
cyclic existence. Technically. What is it? Technic Yes. Precisely.
The two first noble truths. The main object of meditation is a noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering. Yeah. Then where do you see the general features of karma? Causes of softness.
Okay. The general features of KAHMAN? Causality? No? And also, why are the two first truths not completely mentioned in the verse of the generation of fully characterized definite emergence in the three principles of the path?
You may not know the verse by thought. I’ll I’ll move back a bit. This is the first part of the verse on generating near definite emergence. You meditate on the human reverse of leisure and endowment and death with impermanence to generate turning away from the activities of this life. In other words, the path of the beam of the small scope.
This is the second part of the verse. You meditate on the infallibility of causality. Alright? So it’s actually the general features of causality and one specific aspect of it, and the sufferings of cyclic existence to generate fully correct right definite emergence. So here you can see that the infallibility of causality, which is part of the being of the small scope within the lamrim, becomes part of the path of the being of the middling scope the three principles of the path.
Question is, what? It’s the first question. Second question is, in the presentation of the path shared to the being of the middling scope, there is no mention of the two first noble truths. There’s mention of the sufferings of cyclic existence that could qualify as the first truth. But there’s no mention of the truth of origin, the afflictions.
Why? Are they summed up within causality? Possibly. That’s a good answer. Anyone else?
Yes. Yes. The two tools, the two first tools in the verse on generating fully characterized definite emergence. One is mentioned implicitly, the sufferings of cyclic existence. But the second, which is the most important, actually, is no good truth of the origin of suffering is not mentioned at all.
Yeah. And it that was it. Sorry. The origin of suffering, if you follow it through, is ignorance. Yes.
What exactly is the three principles of the path? As a literary text, as a literary form. We call it An instruction. Yes. An instruction, What exactly is an instruction?
Sorry. It’s a meditative. Sorry. It’s a path to meditate, the instructions to meditate. Yes.
Yes. An instruction. Steps. No. An instruction to key points.
It’s the absolute essence, eliminating everything which is subsidiary. When you start linking Lamrim Chenmo and the three principles of the path, you get a sense of what the very, very essence of Lamrim practice is and what is subsidiary in Lamrim Chenmo. Now clearly here Je Tsongkhapa is stating or implied that you can meditate on the four correct general characteristics of karma within the path sharedness of being of the small scope or within the path sharedness of being of the medium scope. Both are possible. But what is absent, completely absent in the three principles of the path?
It is quite shocking. So I assume you’re familiar with the text by now. What is completely absent? There’s no mention at all. The origin of suffering or something.
Yes and no. But, I mean, completely absent because that’s mentioned in the four noble truths. References? Yes. Exactly.
Exactly, Sheen. No mention whatsoever is made of refuge. Why is this surprising? Because refuge is a culmination of the path shared to being of the small scope Look at the presentation in Lamrim. The totality of the path shared to being of the small scope builds up to refuge.
So why is refuge not mentioned? There’s not a word. Who is the trainee of the three principles of the path? A practitioner. Yes.
Texts are taught for people in Buddhism. There’s no such thing as a general text. Texts are taught for subjects, for trainees. So who’s the trainee? Who is?
Great disciple. Probably probably, we’re not sure, but probably ordained. Definitely already a Buddhist, very sincere Buddhist. And therefore, the three principles of the path target really now that I have precedent. And as I mentioned in my second presentation here, there is this an important question about the three principles of the path.
How much of it is applicable to us? It is, if you look at Tsongkhapa’s works, it’s the eighteenth volume. It’s called the Tobum, the collected works. It’s basically covered when you put everything else, which can’t fit anything else. It’s a lekka.
Tsongkhapa’s collected works. And therefore, it was not necessary for Namlunchen’s trainee to generate renunciation. It had already been generated. And this goes a long way to answering some of the issues and the three principles of the path. It is a specific instruction for a specific practitioner.
Then the overall scheme is a general hermeneutical scheme, a general scheme of interpretation. Whether every key point can be applied to us, that’s another question that we have to understand. Was written for well, actually, who was who was the trainees of? Yes. But more specifically?
Monastics. No. Who are the trainees of Lamrim Chenmo? The monastics typically would undergo a program of study. Mhmm.
Not really. I do. Yes. Lamrim Chenmo monastics and many people, but Lamrim Chenmo was written for people who didn’t have the opportunity to study. So was the idea was that would provide everything a sincere, normal Buddhist needed to progress to full and utter enlightenment without having the luxury, the leisure of studying the great texts and the great monasteries.
So for this reason, Lamrim Chenmo was a template certainly for lay practice and is at the backdrop of monastic practice, but the monks, certainly the monks from the three seats, would practice based on the five great texts, which they integrate with Lamrim Chenmo. Then we are not able to do that. And now I thought we would do things a bit differently. So this is my Christmas present. These are the oldest Buddhist texts known.
So for those of you who have a Christian background, these texts correspond to the Dead Sea Scrolls. These are the Buddhist text written on bark from a Central Asian oasis called Gandhara. You know, Gandhara was so famous in the transmission of Buddhism from India to China. There were two routes. There was the silk trade root, and there was a sea root.
And much of what we know of early Buddhism comes from the oasis at Gandara or Duhuang in China. Where? Duhuang. Duhuang, you you know, I’m sure. And before approaching the Udānavarga, I wanted to cover with you briefly what the 12 fold division of Buddhist scripture is to give you a sense of how Buddhist scriptures are divided.
So one of the problems in early Buddhism was the huge amount of material. Typically, the Kangyur would have between a 103 a 108 volumes. These are Buddhist school teachings. And the commentary collection, the Tengyur, would have 223 volumes. How do you divide all this?
How do you structure it? Then there have been many attempts to structure it. And the three principles of the past are one, it’s structuration in terms of practice. But there is also structuration in terms of the literary genre. And the trifold subdivision of Buddhist scriptures is the most famous one.
The scriptures are subdivided in sutras. And you might think everything the Buddha taught was a sūtra. It’s definitely not the case. There are songs. There are numerous prophecies, like the prophecy of the coming of Nāgārjuna, the prophecy of the coming of Asaṇga, the verses, the gathas.
Some Buddhist traditions like Zen, Chan and Chan specialize in the utterance of gathas, of verses, of realization. Solemn utterances, and that’s what we shall be covering today, solemn utterances are the one exception to the rule that Buddha always taught for a trainee. Solemn utterances were not taught for a trainee. They were taught to ensure the perpetuation of the teachings. They were general statements of Buddhist doctrine not intended for any one particular person.
Then we have introductions, which basically are self descriptive parables. Buddhism has parables just as Christianity, but fewer. Legends, the birth stories, which are so famous. His Holiness reads birth stories of the previous lives of the Buddha every year at Bodh Gaya. It is a tradition which goes back to Je Tsongkhapa himself.
It’s a very inspirational one. And you find this verse stories actually both in the and in the. Long scriptures which refer to Mahāyāna Sutras. It’s a bit tongue in cheek because it’s true that all the Mahāyāna scriptures are wrong. Very wrong.
Marvelous deeds and instructions. Then Buddha himself utter instructions. This is what the three principles of the past is. It is something very concise, typically a letter, often not written to be published, but intended for one person, two persons, a group of monks or yogis meditating in solitude. And the texts you know as the Dharmapada, the verses of the Dharma, have existed in numerous forms throughout Asia.
It is an ancient Buddhist tradition which goes back at least two thousand two hundred years to collect key verses of Buddha taught and regroup them by topic. It’s an attempt to structure Buddhist teachings. These probably circulated text in notebooks. So they corresponded Buddhism exactly to the gospels in Christianity. Gospels in Christianity were, you know, little probably to notebooks at the beginning in which the sayings of Jesus were collected.
So we have a series of these so called dhammapada. We have dhammapada itself. You may have read it in English, I hope, which was passed down by a monk. It’s a beautiful text. Then you have another dhammapada known as the Udānavarga, which we find both in Central Asia and in Tibet.
That’s what we shall be talking about today. We have a third dhammapada called the Gandhari dhammapada with different verses, a different chapter subdivision, which we find in Gandhara and South Of The Silk Road. And then Tibetan monasteries were treasure troves because after the government invasion of India in the ninth century, the only place where the ancient Sanskrit and sometimes Pāli manuscripts survived in Asia was in Thailand. Simply because they were written on bark, and in India, it raped, and therefore bark just didn’t survive. And in Tibet, certainly in some areas, it never ever rains.
And a great Tibetan geshe, a highly controversial Indian scholar and an Indian scholar, Rahul Sankrityayan, traveled to Tibet in the nineteen thirties in search of manuscripts. And believe it or not, they found in a small Tibetan monastery, a Pāli manuscript of the Dhammapada, unpublished and unknown. I wanted to discuss the details, but basically, this is one example of the dharmapada chapter on heedfulness. And you can see that this is the Pāli version versus two one to two twelve. The partner version has some of the Pāli ones, but not all.
The Gandhali version doesn’t have any, has versions from other section except for the last two. And the Udānavarga doesn’t have any at all. So these different verses were seen as germane to different parts of the practice. It’s like manual. It’s like your notes.
You know, you can manual. The Arhats don’t have to write anything down, but later on, the disciples didn’t have to write things down. The Buddha said this, and this, and this, and this. What is this about? It’s mainly about death and impermanence, and what is this about?
It’s mainly about karma. And all this was connected. So it is one of the earliest attempts to structure what the Buddha taught. Overwhelmingly, these connections, the Dhama Pada, the Udānavarga, relate to the path of the being of the middling scope, the small in the middling scope. There is no material.
This is a marvelous statue of the Buddha from the main monastery in Minyak’s hometown, Chogongsang, which is these are one of the oddities of Buddhism and how it’s spread. It’s a monastery you go to pray to when you want good fortune. So now let us read together these verses, and I gave you the Sanskrit and I’ll translate them. Anitya Varga. Anitya means impermanence.
These are the chapters of impermanence. It is interesting that the Udānavarga begins by teaching definite impermanence. It really shows clearly just how fundamental that this is this is the very first verse in the Udānavarga. And all composite phenomena are conditioned. They are the subject of birth and destruction.
After being born, they will be destroyed. The several pacification of these is happiness. Who is delighted and gladdened by such a play? Why do those dwelling within darkness not seek freedom? Beautiful.
All composite phenomena, in other words, every everything which has parts will disintegrate. Alas, this is the nature of things. Our bodies will disintegrate. Our families will disintegrate. Our money will disintegrate.
Everything. Then Buddha asks, why do those dwelling within this darkness not seek for a lamp, not seek another word for a way out? Once one realizes this, why put effort in things which will just disintegrate, make sense to? Imagine someone who put huge effort in buying a car made of cardboard and paper. Mhmm.
That’s a matter of days before the first rain. Then once you see a real car made of metal as in the same league as a car made of people, how does that hold this? You would see the power of Buddha’s own words. It’s often quite quite shocking. Many people are seen in the morning, in the afternoon, some will no longer be seen.
Many people are seen in the afternoon, Next morning, some will no longer be seen. Thus, does the generations pass. In this room, some of you will not be here two years from now. Who? We do not know.
Ten years from from now, quite a few of you will not be here. You will have died and you will have left. Twenty years from now, this group of people will be under the bus. I mean, Then this is the pace of change. So in once you get a very strong sense of this, most human endeavor becomes profoundly futile.
Some die in the womb and some on the birthing ground. Likewise, some die for chronic and some fall weak. Some die old and some die young. Some in the prime of life, all will depart gradually just as ripe fruit falls to the ground. If there are verses which have a particular impact on your mind, I would strongly recommend that you memorize, and you repeat them.
It’s very tough to life when difficulties arise. A verse would just come to mind, and it addresses the problem. I don’t know if some of you remember the verse I asked you to memorize at the beginning of the year. The end of accumulation is loss. The end of being elevated is the soul.
The end of meeting is separation. The end of life is death. We will encounter it later in the dharmapharma. These are really verses worth memorizing. Life is hard and short, beset for suffering, and is also swiftly disturbed, just as a drawing made with his stylus on water.
The very part. But difficulty arises in your life. If these these words arise in your mind, life is After saying I have a son and I also have wealth, the childish leaves them both. If there is no self neither outside nor within, whose child And what is I want to analyze carefully who owns, who generates, where is the I which owns and generates? And you find this I is unfinable.
What is the difference inside? What it means is to dare to love one’s children apart from appropriation. If you say the child is a continuation of your body, well, my hand is a continuation of my body. I have no particular affection for it. I don’t want to lose it.
That’s about as far as it goes. If you say it’s because they’re cute, they want to treat other’s children as well. It is a sense of pride. It’s something very profound in men, which is this fear of death and the view that one’s children perpetuate oneself. My father, for instance, loved my sister and myself very much.
Then he had us when he was very poor. It was very clear to me that he loved us as a perpetuation of himself. And I remember I practiced feelings very much once because I was very philosophically inclined, and we were spayings. I was 15 or so. And I said, you see, your love for me is not meritorious in any way because you cannot choose not to love me.
Then my mother just he looked at me. I didn’t realize that my mother told me, you really hurt your father’s feelings. But it seems obvious to me there was no choice. Right? You cannot compliment a tree for growing towards the sun.
It’s the nature of the crew. But parents love their children automatically, largely because the species will disappear. And because they see in their children the perpetuation of themselves, both of which are illusions and fantasies. If reincarnation truly occurs, your child is another person coming from some assets. So after this, my father said to me, you were really an extraterrestrial.
It was hot fence too. No one has ever thought like that. And now we have this marvelous verse I ask you to memorize. It’s a beautiful verse. The end of accumulation is loss.
The end of elevation is collapse. The end of meeting is separation. The end of life is death. All of us, you know, win and lose. Sometimes money comes in, sometimes it goes out.
It’s a given that what has come in will go out. The end of elevation is collapse of the floor. Our reputations are like sine waves. They go up, and then they go down, and then they go back up, and then they go back down. The end of meeting is separation.
So many of our students are profoundly distressed when the relationship there collapses and so happy, you just you can see it on their face when they enter into a new relationship. But the very destiny of relationships is to close. Whatever relationship it is, whether it is a marriage, a partnership, having children, having friends, if you don’t separate for dying, one of the two definitely would die before the other. So it is a given that every relationship will end in tears. It’s a given.
And when you think about this, the great enthusiasm and self starting seems highly unwell. If you think of the relationship between parents and children, either the child would cry or the parents would cry. Either the child dies before the parents and the parents will cry bitter tears, or the parents die before the child and the child will cry bitter tears. It’s a good one. If the child is good, the parents will cry even more bitter tears when he dies, and he will cry more bitter tears when they die.
If the child is bad, the parents will cry bitter tears when he’s alive. Tears? They are always. And therefore, Buddha sent through sinful deeds, care, and through merit, a higher reward. Others who meditate on the path attain an uncontaminated nilmana.
What is taught? The cause and effect. More generally. What is taught in this stanza? In what stanza?
To follow the truths. The path of the being of the small and the middle school together. The first two verses teach the path of the being of the small scope. The last two verses, the path of the being of the middle scope. The path of the being of the small scope is a path a layperson is just trying to follow.
Then, normally, the path of the being of the middling scope is mainly for monastics. It’s a goal of monastics is nirvana. And then addressing death and age, Buddha says, age, you are foolish and evil. You behave badly, utterly destroying this pleasant form. Now for all of us in the West, particularly, you know, who are addicted to our bodies as a source of pleasure, You know, it goes a long way towards explaining the Western obsession with hygiene.
Know? Washing all the time, perfuming the body, cleaning the teeth, dyeing the hair. I mean, I remember when I went to Sarah, it was really shocking. In a couple of weeks, how many of our students had gray hair? They just turned old, but shocked.
And then probably thought maybe they didn’t bring enough hairline with them. But this is the view of the body. Continually tormented by disease, continually oozing filth, why would it be unsuitable to relinquish this body, bedecked with the sensations of age and death? And disease is basically a fairly continuous state of affairs. If you actually examine, cancer is the absence of disease and it occurs sporadically.
If one is not coughing, one is sneezing. If one is not sneezing, this hurts. If this does not hurt, that hurts. One has eaten bad food, then one’s bowel is turned mush. And, frankly, this body of ours, if we analyze, is revolting.
If you want to meditate on the filth of the the body, the best time to do it is once a day when you go to the toilet. After you’ve gone to the toilet, smell. This is this is a human body. When we crave another’s body, we crave what produces this urine feces that apart from the toilet in daily life, we sweat if we don’t shower, in my case, two times a day. What is covered is a film of sweat.
The body becomes sticky. If one doesn’t brush one’s teeth for two days, he get a deposit appearance, then the tongue becomes white. Mucus comes from the nose, from the ears, from the eyes. The fingernails become black. Imagine the human body of someone you find attractive after, let us say, a mere one month with no washing, no showering, no deodorant, no brushing one’s teeth.
This is why Buddha taught that monastics were only allowed to shower once a month, to wash once a month, and only have the body. You have a very clear sense of the dirtiness of the body. Because it’s one of our rude misconceptions that this body is clean. And therefore, Buddha says, when the time of death arrives, children will not be a refuge, no one’s father or relatives. You will have no refuge.
I have done this. I will accomplish that. After doing this, I shall do that. When this man rebels thus in absolute arrogance, Age, disease, and death will utterly destroy you. All of us, we spend our lives basically saying, in the past, I did this.
Now I’m doing that to prepare for that. Five years from now, I would have achieved this. I would have paid back my mortgage. I would have paid back my debt with a car. I would have put money aside.
My children would have graduated. I would then go and travel. And at the end of this life, what would be left? So the study of history in this respect is very helpful. If you look at men who were famous just a couple decades ago and now of which most of you have probably never heard about.
Let’s say the French president, Mitterrand, very famous in the nineteen eighties in France. Maybe he was stronger than what has heard of him. Yeah. Didn’t? Famous new left wing.
You know, as he approached the end of his life, beset with cancer of the prostate, he became just like the Egyptian pharaohs, frightened with the idea that he would be forgotten. He started building monuments. Big monuments across the arch of the. You know? Other French presidents erected museums.
You know? Now when you look back and you try to ask, what was the meaning of that life? What is hard to put to give an answer? Then in all cases, we can’t even erect a little pyramid. What is life in here?
The next chapter of the is karma. Kama in Sanskrit means desire, and this is the core Buddhist critique. The critique of desire, of the outwards going mind. From desires, torment arises. From desires, destruction occurs.
Should an abandoned desires, there would be neither torment nor destruction. From joys, torment arises. From joys, destruction occurs. Should an abandoned joys, there would be neither torment nor destruction. That suffering maturing from desires and joys is sweet at first, but the result is burning.
If you look at your own lives, I think you will find that this is profoundly true. Everything we desire is sweet when we get it. And from that point on, it is done. Whether it is children, whether it is wealth, whether it’s a house, friendships, partnerships, professional success is sweet at first, and then the disappointment setting until you wish you had never started down there. The monk experiences the sufferings of being monk, and the lay person experiences the suffering of being a lay person.
That’s exactly it. The monk experiences the sufferings of being ordained, of being celibate, of being poor, not eating well, being in the monastery of not doing what he wants to do, of being subject to the discipline of another authority, of not enjoying life. And the lay person experiences the sufferings of being a lay person. The lay person experiences suffering of enjoying life. The lay person experiences the suffering of having a husband or a wife because once you have a husband or a wife, there’s an other, then fights and disagreements are unavoidable.
The suffering of having children, the suffering of seeking forever more money, because once you have a partner, however much money you have is never enough. Then the suffering of having to satisfy the needs of the children, which increased with time. The suffering of seeing that my children will not accomplish what they should accomplish. Or sometimes it is just suffering of having children who excel and who cast what one did oneself in the bitter of it. My son, my daughter is brilliant, and I have not accomplished a fraction of what he or she accomplished.
And these are sufferings of many people. So monastics and many people both experience. It is not the case that when one becomes ordained, somehow one no longer suffers, Nor is it the case that when one ceases to be ordained and becomes a lay person, somehow one enjoys life to the full. The sufferings are the same. The source of the sufferings are different.
Men lack permanent desire since whatever the desire is lust for is impermanent. So as not to be reborn again, utterly abandoned mentally and enact, meant and enact, not going to the abode of death. And you can see here that Buddha Śākyamūni is teaching that meditation on impermanence enables us to at least partly abandon desire. It’s not a complete antidote, but it is a very powerful antidote. It’s meditation on selflessness.
If we meditate on the impermanence of desire objects, their whole over us disappears. Then it depends on what the person desires. Some people desire objects. Some people desire other person’s bodies. Some people desire status.
Some people desire money, which is a means to all of these. You can buy status. You can buy another person’s body. You can buy fame. But once you realize that another person’s body, status, fame, money, are impermanent, that what has value today may not have value, the attachment disappears.
Three years ago, one Australian dollar was worth 1.10 US dollars. Now, 1 Australian dollar is worth 76¢. Analysts are putting the Australian dollar at 50 to 60¢ to the US dollar in in the the next next five five to to ten ten years. Years. So the Australian dollar, which we see as a safe refuge in which to place our hopes for the future.
We save money to be able to buy happiness in whatever form we need, is losing its value. In India, people place their hopes in the rupee. Then the Indian governor, two weeks ago, ten days ago, declared that 501,000 rupee notes were no longer valid tender. Overnight, the savings of basically $809,100,000,000 Indians have been wiped out. Most peoples keep in India keep their money at home.
It’s only a little bit in the bank. They can deposit it from the bank for the limited amount. Artificially, it’s to basically struggle against corruption, eliminate corruption. The reality is it’s a huge problem for all. If your value is money, it’s basically just a piece of paper.
That piece of paper has value as long as there is a consensus that it has value and the government and the Muslim. It’s a very frenzy thing. And therefore, the Buddha taught just as a silversmith with silver, the intelligence should purify their stains gradually, instant by instant, a little at a time. Now this is a path which is offered to us, path of mental purification, progressive, incremental mental purification over a life. As you purify your own mind, the difficult experiences from the outside world would have less and less impact on us.
Interestingly enough, there will be few difficult experiences as well. If you desire all happiness, utterly abandon all desire. So utterly abandoning desire, you will obtain supreme happiness. For as long as you follow desire, you will not be satisfied. Hence the wise countering those attain contentment.
Then this is, I’d say, rather the opposite to the prevalent view of the West, for which desire is a road to happiness. I have actually never known someone who has become an existing one. You can try. The best way to learn these things is to try it for yourself. You know?
Desire is like so called. The more you grieve, the thirstier you do. The same could be said of pain. It’s a characteristic of the afflictions that they seem to provide happiness or relief, but the more we indulge in them, the less happiness or relief they provide and the more we are prone to them. Once you become accustomed to desire, satisfied your desire previously is the more sufficient, you need something bigger, stronger, better.
Bigger, stronger, and better may not be available. Then anger sets in. Then anger is an unpleasant sensation. So when anger arises, we have an instinctive wish to lash out. Lashing out makes us feel better, provides relief.
Each time we lash out, we become more prone to anger than next. Until eventually, even in this life, we end up all alone. In worst case scenarios, in jail. People who lose control of their minds like that, they end up behind bars. Krishna means craving.
Scented beings bound by craving mentally lust after the animal and the inner. The childish who take joy in calculating the corpse will obtain suffering over and again. This is very powerful. All desire is radically criticized. All desire is desired either for living or dead objects, animate or inanimate objects.
Living objects are people. Dead objects are things. Then probably the most powerful desire human beings have is sexual desire. But sexual desire is desire for a dead body. The body of someone who within a matter of time will be dead, which already at present, you know, is a filthy body.
A body which actually oozes fluids and secretions through all orifices, a body which can only be desired if it’s kept clean by constant scrubbing. I remember a very interesting conversation I had with an Indian lady in Bangalore. She was quite modern but very shy. And we were talking once, and she said, well, you know she she was married to an Italian journalist. She said, you know, the reason Westerners take showers all the time is because they always want to be ready to have sex.
And I thought that is exactly it. Doctors say anything else. But to constantly be ready for the opportunity of these peak physical experiences, we scrub, we wash, we perfume, we cut, we dye, we polish, you know, polishment. So you can see how the desire for another person’s body is really something which is if you analyze it as opposed to being controlled by instincts, it’s very irrational. Then this desire is a source of tremendous.
Those of you who are old, you must have experienced this many times. The peak experience of desiring another person, then the progressive disappointment, then the breakup, the non virtuous deeds in getting in the relationship, the non virtuous deeds in breaking up, and the anger, damage, reputation, then it starts over. Torment of those enslaved by women, the craving for whom it is difficult to abandon, would increase that grass drenched by the rain. The same can be applied to men for women. And the more one indulges in sexual desire, the more uncontrolled it becomes.
This case for all desires. The more uncontrolled it becomes, the more basically the person becomes close to handling. So here, what is the solution? The solution is to uproot the tree from the roots. Even though a tree is felled, that corresponds to śamatha.
śamatha. Through śamatha, the desires become more manifest. The mind is single pointed on its object. There is no desire. There is no hatred.
And once a person leaves śamatha, the desires are subdued. Someone who has attained śamatha does not succumb to the afflictions. But more that corresponds to fame, that does not uproot the tree. The seeds of desire, hatred, are still present, and they will and can manifest in the future life. And therefore one must uproot the tree and to uproot the tree one needs meditation on selflessness.
So you can see when you read the actual words of Buddha Śākyamūni, you need this background of belonging to help you because otherwise it is difficult to get it. Are you tired or shall we continue a bit more? Let’s continue. Then in Sanskrit is heat fullness. It is the quality we should train in to become karmic strategists to control.
Heedfulness means to be mindful of our mind, of our speech, and of our behavior. Heedfulness is the place of deathlessness. Heedlessness is the place of death. The heedful will not die. The heedless will continually die.
What is death different to here? Yep. cyclic existence. It’s a process of endless life. It is through heedfulness that it is possible to eventually escape from cyclic existence.
Whoever relies heathously on a woman would contingently experience these four. He will not attain merit, will not sleep happily, will become vase, and will go to hell. The past of lust, of craving, and desire. There was a case recently just the Australian news is a tremendous source of the in this case affecting the down. There’s a case in the present, covered in the age, of an Australian trainee who had been involved with a single mother, and they broke up.
And then he was it is certainly uncontrolled anger, the source of an anger cause for analysis. Now because the biggest source of desire most people can have is precisely this desire for another person’s body, And the biggest angle which arises is human beings. Is that systematically the case? And the person destroys their own life? The contaminations of one who does not do what is not to be done continually does what is to be done and is endowed as recollection and vigilance will cease.
He, whose contaminations have ceased, has attained the uncontaminated state. The contaminations here are the afflicting obstructions. And the strategy which Buddha teaches is to abstain from non virtue, to practice virtue, and to train in heedfulness. In other words, vigilance, if you prefer. Vigilance is the term we use when we speak in the con the context of concentration.
And this road leads to the cessation of contaminations, which is liberation. Priya Varga. Priya in Sanskrit means beautiful. And you find to this day many women in India called Priya. I must warn you, these are very powerful verses.
From beauty arises torment. From beauty arises destruction. If one has abandoned beauty, there is neither torment nor destruction. Reminds me of a marvelous line. There was a a western Buddhist this is a oh, what was I?
Excuse me. Western scholar. He he gave up with his and became a Roman Catholic. Okay. But when he was a Buddhist, he wrote a book about his all his experiences.
He was attending a teaching in in Wales in the summer. And during the break, it was very peaceful. He was looking just at the Welsh countryside and the lambs in the field, just a strong sense of beauty. And the lama who was teaching came up to him, saw him and said, yes, when I was young, I too saw beauty. Now I only see ugliness and death.
But this is the world we have to follow. But this the realistic world. Some of you are scientists. You take a microscope, and you look at microscopic life. It’s an endless process of destruction.
Beautiful fields are slaughterhouses, in which millions of insects die. Insect life is terrible. Spiders poison other insects and suck their fluids alive. You and me, this is most of us eat meat. We devise ever more refined ways of cooking the flesh of other living beings.
One says you should boil it. The other says you should roast it. The third says it tastes better stuffed. It’s done. Then many of us, you know, eat animals which are killed alive, thrown alive and boiling water.
Lobsters are thrown alive into boiling water. Oysters must be eaten living. One drops a piece of lemon on the oyster to see if it recoils. If it’s alive, it can be eaten. If it’s not alive, it cannot be eaten.
So our behavior is in no way different. Then when we fancy that by being vegetarian, we can avoid this comic burden, it is a fantasy. It’s It’s complete complete fantasy. Fantasy. To eat wheat, to eat barley, insecticides must be used.
Millions of insects must be killed. If they are not killed in that way, we eat organic, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, as Shakespeare said. It’s up to us to transform our mind so that we do not see beauty. Then if you actually think that this is a profoundly nihilistic and negative view of life, reflect in what you think is beautiful. At best, it is arbitrary and culturally bound.
At worst, it’s an imputation and distance. The attainment of mental peace and happiness, which occurs when the mind is withdrawn. And in our case, beholding the unworthy as worthy, yielding as beautiful, and suffering as happiness, the heedless are utterly mistaken. So for the being of the small scope, what is the path therefore? Someone who has performed merit, upon passing from this world to the next, arriving with merit as with relatives, excuse me, but yes, is utterly delighted.
Hence, through accumulating merit for the sake of the next world, merit in the next world will become the abode of the embodied. It’s beautiful words. It encapsulates the path of the being of the small scope. If we practice merit, virtuous karma, in this life, then we carry it with us at death in a way which isn’t possible for relatives, for wealth, for our body. And in the next life, we are reborn in what Buddha calls the embodiment of our merit.
It is a body created by our merit. The body we have in this life, the mind we have in this life, is a product of the virtuous deeds of another person in your previous life, our previous reincarnation. One life, two lives, five lives, 10 lives before. Then over that, we have no control. If we have congenital disorders, mental disorders in this life, it comes from our previous We can try to attenuate, but there’s little we can do.
What we can do is prepare the future. The future is prepared through understanding common strategies and preparing a good rebirth for future lives and a good mind. And therefore, as Buddha says, the learner to strive for the threefold happiness of being praised, gaining wealth, and having joy in the next higher rebirth should protect ethics. Ethics is the foundation, and ethics in a Buddhist context begins with nonviolence. Physical nonviolence, verbal nonviolence, and mental nonviolence.
Nonviolence means not to harm another, not to harm them physically, not to harm them by one’s words, and not to harm them you know, mentally, we don’t have the concentration to harm others, but we can generate angry thoughts towards others. Is the path for the karma. By uttering the lie, I would never perform a sin. The embodied who have utterly forsworn the one Dharma and destroy the next world are akin to someone who has swallowed an incandescent of gold and iron. It is very easy.
One who does not thoroughly subdue degenerated ethics is not an appropriate recipient for the offerings of the area. This stanza refers to Buddhist monks and monks who have broken their hearts. They have utter denial, saying, I would never perform this or that non virtuous deed. And they have foresworn the one diamond because monastic ordination is the foundation of Buddhist teachings. They have destroyed the next world, their own next world, their future life is destroyed They because of the power of domestic coordination.
Then one would be be born in another world. They are akin to someone who has swallowed an incandescent bowl of idols. They will burn from the inside. It is very easy, very easy to take vials, which one does not respect, does not protect, and then oneself is a recipient of the damage. Then such a person should not receive offerings from the laypeople.
And the offerings from the laypeople are sources of American laypeople, even if the person had broken their hearts, they people don’t necessarily know. But for the monastic, these are things are like eating a bowl of iron, which is. There’s another sense in which Buddha says, this will be taken out of their flesh in the next Because this is the work, the hard work of many people who struggle to earn a living, who are the faith, make donations to the Sangha. And if the Sangha is unworthy, then comically, this is extraordinary. Wherever one lives, there is no place karma does not penetrate.
Whether one dwells in space, in the midst of the ocean, or on the moon. Then whether one believes in karma or not, it makes no difference. It will be very nice if it was a matter of belief. You believe in it, works, you don’t believe in it, you’re scot free. It will be very nice.
The karmas which have been performed by a human being, whether they be virtuous or spiritual, will not be exhausted. Here, the Buddha teaches the general characteristics of karma, the fourth general characteristic. As they are, so will be the result. As long as their collection exists for so long, will that one be an active? As long as the karma is not completely experienced, for so long will the person experience suffering.
And here, there are two different positions among Buddhist scholars. Vasubandhu considers that one karmic imprint can lead only to the maturation of one life for impending karma. Asaṇga feels that one karmic imprint can lead as immaturation to seven lives. Now personally, I am more specific to Asaṇga’s position in Abhidharma Samuccaya. It seems Should at some point, It is their own destiny they are floating.
We are floating our own destiny. We already have forged a fair bit of it. The past, we have no control, Inasmuch as the maturation of whatever deed causes agony to arise and sobbing one’s face to be awash in tears, would have affected oneself, it would have been best not to have performed these kinds. In accordance with Buddha Shakhanini’s capacity to see past and future lives, Buddha taught what is to be done and what is to be abstained from. And the tears, we will call.
The suffering will be ours from disease, from physical suffering, from separation, from mental agony, then it is better not to accumulate the causes for two causes once we understand the correlation. And the opposite is also true. In as much as whatever one day causes no agony but joy and happiness, since the maturation will have affected oneself, it will be better to have performed in these companies. This is karmic strategy. But for this, we must understand what leads to happiness and what leads to suffering.
And then after that, it’s up to one side. No one can do it for one As my late teacher, Geshe Rabten said, if I could, I would practice with you, like making a torma, a little bit here, a little bit there. But he said, I can. So just as when rust corrodes iron and that corrosion devours it, likewise unexamined flaws and one’s bad karma lead to ruin. If you have seen rust corroding a plate of iron, at first, is invisible.
The iron looks as if it is stainless. And then if you keep checking, the rust appears and starts spreading and spreading, and eventually, the iron disintegrates. Likewise, initially, the person’s behavior seems impeccable, but the seeds of destruction are sown in the mind. And then they spread like a cancer, like a mental cancer. And eventually, death, This is a well which has been dry.
One cannot rely on lack of space. However, expertly, it has been done. It was well done. It was dry, giving out the stench of muddy water. But while it is true that Buddha taught the path of reason, in our case, the foundation for our practice is faith.
Because without faith, there is no beginning. Without faith, we will not begin to study to understand the rationale. If there is no faith or trust in what the Buddha taught, if there is not a smattering of trust in the future teaches, we don’t stop. Then if we don’t stop, there’s no opportunity to study, let alone to means the ascetic. In other words, the miracle.
Golden one. Just as an arrow held wrongly cuts one’s hand, likewise, through the wrong protection of virtuous training, one is led closer to hell. Just as an arrow held rightly would not cut one’s head. Likewise, if one protects virtuous training a while, one is impaled closer to the state beyond suffering. All vows, not just monastic vows, refuge vows, monastic vows, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows.
For that matter, the order of commitment to one’s teacher is a vow. If one’s teacher said you should do this and this and I, you say, I will, that is a vow, a very powerful vow. If these vowels are broken, they lead us lower and lower inevitably because of the amplification of the valve. And therefore, best common strategy is not to take vows until one is sure one can protect them. One has doubts, one should think.
Because common matures inevitably. The common of taking refuge, taking refuge while and then breaking refuge vials is in a future life, the incapacity to become a Buddhist, the incapacity to receive teachings. We we I’ve met people who complain about never meeting a teacher. I remember one lady, she said, whatever this teacher is in town, I’m out of town. When I’m in town, he’s out of town.
This is the common of having broken relations as spiritual teacher. So in our case, the key is to improve our merit. If we cannot improve it, we should make sure it doesn’t get worse. And therefore, we have to be careful. If we are careful, let’s say we do not engage in any Buddhist practice or any religious practice of any type of this stuff.
As long as we’re a decent person, we will stay where we know we will probably get a human being. Then it is tragic when as a result of Buddhist teachings of taking vows, of taking commitments which are broken, someone who could have attained a human being is reborn in lower realms. Then there is indeed a connection with the teachings, but how it matures, we don’t know. It’s much much wiser not to go there. And therefore, once one starts thinking of karma, one is well advised to be extremely careful in one’s kindness.
And then we have techniques for purification. We should learn these techniques, which should apply whenever vows are broken, one purifies I call someone who says after his head is hoary with old age, at present, am not old. I am middle aged, a foolish thought. So I said to some students once, the best thing they could do to improve their practice was to stop using makeup and dyeing their hair. Everyone looks at oneself in the mirror as one grows older, everyone thinks my outside is going ugly.
Impermanence, suffering, emptiness, selflessness. If you’re gonna memorize something for from today, memorize these four. It’s very powerful for the mind. If you think that all composite phenomena are impermanent, that all contaminated phenomena are suffering, and that all sentient beings are empty and selfless, and the mind is greatly transformed. So this is what I wanted to cover with you today.
I hope you liked my Christmas present. Yes. Yes. I didn’t wrap it up. My apologies.
Do you have any questions? Just a naive one here. If you don’t keep your promises to other laypeople, is that bad, karma? Not true. And the karma is the character in function of the relation to the person.
So if you promise your promise, let’s say, your meat grocer to buy a head of a cabbage, you don’t come. The is light. But if you promise, let’s say, your mother to do something and you don’t, or your best friend, the is much heavy. Then likewise, in a country like this one, you have to be careful. Pledges made to the government or to the community are karmically very heavy because there are pledges made actually to everyone in the country.
So welfare fraud is karmically very heavy because you are stealing from the country, the community. It is also just like theft in the summer, impossible to repair. Other questions, please. From the Sanskrit canon. Then the text are probably the same, but the selection of verses is different.
Is this available in English translated? Gereth Sparrow translated it thirty years without a print. You can try to get it. I think it’s wisdom. I don’t have it.
He’s a good translator. I think Rockwell it’s in your videography. Rockwell translated it at the end of the nineteenth century. I don’t have thank you. You have other questions?
Yeah. Please. I’m on which goes way back. I’m not sure if my scribbling is correct. Vaibhashik and Sattrathika do not accept the surfaces of phenomena, for instance.
Then Cittamātra and Mādhyamika accept the self-sufficiency of phenomena, and that is what is called emptiness. With bodhicitta alone, you cannot attain full enlightenment. To attain liberation, you need both definite emergence and the view of emptiness. To attain full enlightenment, you need both bodhicitta and the view of emptiness. In which view of emptiness?
The various schools of tennis display. So if you look back at the verses at the very beginning, the second verse almost certainly refers to bodhicitta because it refers to the signs of the victors. Then the signs of the victors are bodhisattvas. The Liberation and full enlightenment. Everything else is subsidiary.
Then for liberation, you need different emergence. For full enlightenment, you need bodhicitta. Just briefly, since this text that you’ve translated is obscure, is it going to be available, the translation? You can try to get Gareth Sparrow’s translation, it’s out of print. You know, print for thirty years or so.
It should be okay. I haven’t consulted it. And there’s a rockless translation, but that is an old one. That’s more than one century old. I can’t tell you how good it is.
I won’t be translating this. So I just translated a couple of verses for your sake. I thought I would work through it and see what would be interesting. I’d like to give you a sense of how you read Buddhist texts with the material we have here as a template. Because you’re gonna have to enter the study of the great Buddhist texts at some point by yourselves.
Maybe I will actually get the presentation for you. Ugly mountains. Than if I can’t find it. Yes, you will. So these are the points.
Now the basic problem we are dealing with as a Western audience is that Lamrim Chenmo was written for Tibetans in the late fourteenth, early fifteenth century. So the intended trainees no longer exist. Even modern Tibetans, for instance, don’t understand the Tibetan of the modernity as difficult for them. We like for us receiving teachings in Shakespeare’s language. Then a western audience starts from a very, very different place.
And as a result, the language teachings don’t resonate. Why don’t they resonate? These are the characteristics broadly speaking of Tibetans from the fourteenth century. Non materialistic, universal belief in correlation, universal belief in karma, universal belief in knowledge. This is the audience of Tsongkhapa.
It was unnecessary to demonstrate in any way the existence of these concepts. They were taken for granted. Just as let’s say in this group, everyone agrees that atoms exist. The ordinary western nowadays is deeply materialistic, typically, heavily influenced by the idea that the mind can be used to the brain, and feel that probably there are no consequences to virtue and non virtue apart from legal consequences. So you can see that the text of the does not address a modern wisdom.
There’s a gap. It’s actually of little or no benefit in my experience. People learn the system. They memorize basically some of the key meditations and eventually they goofed away, largely because it never entered their mind. It never clicked.
And what are the problems? What is the gap? Well, the first gap is establishing that the mind is non material, which is very difficult for Westerners. A majority of young Westerners nowadays deep down feel that the mind is a result of the brain’s activity. Then that I think can best address the quantum mechanics.
The second is having established that to establish that the mind transmigrates. That I think is quite easy. Once you believe the mind is nonmaterial, then reincarnation is a quite logical conclusion. And then having established that the mind reincarnates, what is very difficult is to establish that there is a link between these lives. Many westerners from the New Age background typically believe in reincarnation but don’t believe in con.
Like, you reincarnate and, gee whiz, this is great. You know? Just keep in the process. Yes. I mean, you hear this an awful lot.
You know? So establishing this existence of is difficult. And this is the gap between the present state of most young Westerners and where the Lamrim begins. The Lamrim begins basically here. The mind is not material.
There is transformation. There is karma. Then when one is teaching to an audience which does not accept these points, the audience just enters in the state of suspension of disbelief. They take the material on the wall, but eventually, it doesn’t connect with anything which they accept or believe that they need. And this is, I think, why we have rates of disaffection of fifty to sixty percent over three years.
Why? Basically, von Neumann’s argument is that if the mind were a molecule, were a byproduct of the brain, actually be part of the quantum system being considered. And there would be no reduction of what’s known as a state vector. So you need something which is not part of the quantum system to reduce the state vector. And then von Neumann considered only the mind could do that, and this was basically the position of his colleague in, actually, Eugene Wigner, and some other quantum chemists.
So it’s an important minority school of quantum mechanics. I’d say the majority school follows the Copenhagen position, which considers that quantum uncertainty and the reduction of the state vector arise because of the interaction between the measuring instruments and the observed phenomena. This is the the mainstream position. Then von Neumann considered that that was inadequate because you could group the measuring instruments within the observed phenomena. And if the mind was material, then you could group the brain within the observed phenomena.
And then what exactly is causing the reduction of the state vector? What is causing the uncertainty regarding the position of the particle, its momentum, and so forth to disappear? Then it’s the strongest argument I know. It’s experiencing quite a revival in physics these days, and there’s a lot of evidence from young physicists researching something completely different in quantum mechanics, which is the inequalities of Bell. The inequalities of Of Bell.
And I’m sorry. It’s a bit complicated. My memory is a physics student from a long time ago. But basically, the inequalities of Bell are a series of inequalities which were discovered by an Irish physicist in the sixties. And it was at first thought that they would not all necessarily be verified.
The evidence now is that they are, and the result of their verification is that the universe as we know it is nonlocal. It is non deterministic non local. It is nondeterministic, and it is possible it may be non physical. So there is very strong evidence now from theoretical physics that the positions of the Cittamātra and the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka schools are intellectually valid. It’s also evidence which puts in question world.
We We able to I exist independently of Phil. This from the standpoint of modern physics is absolutely natural nonsense. This is nineteenth century materialism. You know? People will laugh you out of the classroom in a classroom.
Then where we go from there is a question. As I mentioned here, a leading American astrophysicist after retirement published an editorial in nature in which he said, the universe is entirely mental. That’s all physics can say. After that, go figure. So what we can say and I I think I’m trying to stop here today.
What we can say is, at present, in 2016, you can be you can subscribe to the cutting edges of modern science. And by this, I refer to the physical sciences. Biology is fifty years behind the curve. But you can subscribe to the cutting edge of modern science and be a Buddhist. The evidence from physics supports the Indian models of reality, not the Judeo Christian ones and not the course materialism most of us knows.
Then I should put that that there’s a non-Buddhist school, Vedanta, which at present, fits perfectly with the descriptions of quantum mechanics. And that’s why when you speak with physicists, their main interest is the Indian schools. There’s no interest whatsoever in a dialogue with, let’s say, Christianity, Judaism, or Islam. So I think this is really for those of you who are interested, this is the way it falls to deepen your sense that the Buddhist presentation of mind is true. This first point.
And the young person who was doing his cutting edge research on the development of the collapse of the wave function in Austria, Then he himself says at the end of his article, just published two, three years ago, that it ushers a description of a word which is much stranger than you never said. Where did you sign? Gröblacher, G R O B L A C H E R Unfortunately now, know, very strange areas in. And thank you very much. Thank you.
I just want to leave a little read on physics. For those of you who are interested, this is the way forward. In Brisbane, there was a lady who asked us going to Vajrayāna, how do I deepen my understanding of emptiness? This was what last year. Is that this one in a setting.
Go to university and study quantum That’s where it’s happening. Glenn, did you want with me to think today? And you should know.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- torma balimta (Skt)
- An offering cake used in tantric rituals. In Tibet, tormas were usually made of tsampa, but other edibles such as biscuits and so forth will suffice. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is it bad karma to break promises made to other laypeople?
Yes, it can be, but the weight of the karma depends on the relationship with the person the promise was made to. Breaking a small promise to a meat grocer, such as promising to buy a head of cabbage and not showing up, is karmically light. Breaking a promise to your mother or your best friend is much heavier. Pledges made to the government or the community are also karmically very heavy, because they are in effect pledges made to everyone in the country. For this reason welfare fraud is karmically very heavy: it is stealing from the country and the community. Like theft in the summer, it is impossible to repair.