Heart Sutra 1992 – 23 HS 1992 08 25

44 min · 1,596 words · 25 August 1992

Heart Sutra 1992 (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra 1992 (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra 1992 - 23 HS 1992 08 25
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a teaching on the twelve links of dependent origination, explaining how they arise under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions, and how they are reversed by purification through the direct realization of emptiness, with ignorance as the root. It then discusses that for a superior in meditative equipoise on emptiness the twelve links do not exist, and that true existence would mean natural or inherent existence. The talk ends with questions for students on true existence.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1992-08-25

Duration: 45 min

UUID: da4d077c-c175-4155-a5d1-a36549f78626

Words: 1,596

Seed in a field. It’s been watered. There’s soil. Every element is there. It’s ready to sprout.

It’s just ready to sprout. And likewise with a latency, they’ve been activated and it’s just ready to express that karmic potential. That state is the tenth link which is called existence or I call it coming to be. Existence or coming to be. The tenth link.

And due to these three links, the eighth, ninth, and tenth, the craving, grasping, and coming to be or existence, the consciousness enters into a particular combination of sperm and ovum and this constitutes rebirth, the eleventh link, birth or rebirth. So the consciousness has entered into a combination of sperm and ovum, and that moment is rebirth. The second moment begins the aging process. That is to say the zygote is beginning to take form. The first moment is rebirth.

The second moment is aging process begins. We usually say that we think of aging process as becoming old. Well, here, the very second moment of rebirth, after rebirth, the very next moment after rebirth, the aging process begins. Then gradually one grows old and then finally dies. So this is the twelfth link, aging and dying, aging and death. Aging and death.

So this process occurs under the influence of karma. And therefore, it is termed a dependent arising completely of the afflictive emotions. Is dependent arising in the category of afflictive emotions. Dependent arising. So what we are describing is the way in which the arising, how these twelve links arise.

A previous cause gives rise to a latter result and it’s and gradually, these the twelve links unfold in an arising manner. So these twelve links describe how we continue to circle within cyclic existence. Having completed one set of twelve links, another set of twelve links will arise in a continual fashion, continuing to circle within these twelve links. Quoting from a line by Nāgārjuna in which that ignorance, as I say, misknowledge, is eliminated through the wisdom realizing emptiness. The foundation of this entire process that we’ve been describing, the root is misknowledge.

And so in order to cease this process from occurring, to stop this process from occurring, it’s necessary to eliminate its root cause, that is to say, ignorance. And what is it that eliminates ignorance? It is the wisdom which realizes emptiness. The wisdom which realizes emptiness is able to remove ignorance, misknowledge, and therefore is able to remove the root cause of this continual process from being perpetuated. So the method for ending cyclic existence is to remove the root of cyclic existence, which is misknowledge.

And how do we remove that misknowledge? By the wisdom realizing emptiness. The way in which we are freed from cyclic existence is through the elimination of misknowledge. If we can cease misknowledge, then cyclic existence will end of itself because its root has been removed. If we do not remove the root of cyclic existence, then there’s no way to stop cyclic existence. So for the superior, in meditative equipoise, for the consciousness of the superior, the wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness, the twelve links of dependent origination do not exist.

Such as, it says in the text, There is no ignorance nor is there a destruction of ignorance. There are none of these all the way up to there is no old age and death. There is no destruction of old age and death. So it’s referring to there are none of the twelve links of dependent origination existing for that particular consciousness. So for such a consciousness, that is the superior wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness, the twelve links of dependent origination do not exist.

There is no ignorance for such a consciousness, nor is there destruction of that ignorance. The destruction of ignorance, for such a consciousness there does not exist the destruction of ignorance. There does not exist the destruction of actions, destruction of consciousness, destruction of name and form, destruction of sources, destruction of contact, destruction of feelings, etcetera. It is the wisdom which directly realizes emptiness that removes the ignorance or the misknowledge contained within these twelve links of dependent origination. Whatever we do, if we do not generate the direct realization of emptiness, there’s no way to remove this root ignorance, this root misknowledge.

How is that misknowledge able to be removed? It is only the direct realization of emptiness which has the power to eliminate this root misknowledge. So, if we remove ignorance, misknowledge, if we destroy it or we eliminate it? Then by eliminating misknowledge, then we eliminate, we destroy actions. Destroying actions, we destroy consciousness.

Destroying consciousness, we destroy name and form, etcetera. That by destroying the previous, the latter is destroyed. By eliminating the previous, the latter is eliminated. So this manner of describing the twelve links of dependent origination is in terms of the category of purification. We described it in terms of the way in which the twelve links arise in terms of the afflictive emotions.

Here is the way the twelve links arise in terms of purification, purification of the afflictive emotions. By the direct realization of emptiness, ignorance, misknowledge is eliminated. By removing ignorance, which is the motivating force for the accumulation of karma or the commission of action, then no new propelling karma is created. That is to say, no new types of karma which propel us to take rebirth within cyclic existence are created. Previous karma is still present, but having once directly realized emptiness, we no longer newly create propelling karma, that is the types of karma which propel us to take rebirth within cyclic existence.

So once having eliminated the actions of newly created propelling karma, then we eliminate the third link of consciousness. And having eliminated the third, we eliminate the fourth, name and form. Then the fifth is eliminated, sources. The sixth, contact. The seventh, feeling.

Eighth, attachment. Ninth, grasping. Tenth, existence. Eleventh, birth. And twelfth, aging and death.

In this manner of presentation of the twelve links of dependent origination is the twelve links of dependent origination in the category of purification. And this purification categorization of the twelve links of dependent origination does not exist for the wisdom in meditative equipoise on emptiness. We’ll stop there. Today I’m going to ask you a question. So I’ve discussed the fact that there are two factors with respect to the existence of true existence.

The existence of true existence? What are those two factors? You ask a question? You have an answer? I told you that to ask a question.

Yes, you did. So, we’re talking about the measure of true existence. True existence doesn’t exist, but the measure of true existence exists. The measure, the measure, the measure, parameters. If all phenomena naturally existed, then true existence would exist. If all phenomena naturally existed, then true existence would exist.

So, non-natural existence is the non-existence of true existence, which is emptiness. So non-natural existence is the non-existence of true existence, which is emptiness. If true existence existed, then what? Independent existence, natural existence, true existence are all the same. Natural existence, inherent existence, true existence, independent existence are all the same.

So, the second is that as we’ve just been talking about, if a conventionality existed for a superior in meditative equipoise on emptiness, then it would have to ultimately exist. It would have to truly exist. If a conventionality appeared for a superior’s wisdom in meditative equipoise on emptiness, it would have to truly exist. So, we just said that there is no form, no sound, no smell, etc. We also said there are no twelve links.

In general, these things all exist. So what does it mean when we say that they don’t exist? It means that they don’t exist for a superior’s wisdom in meditative equipoise on emptiness. For that wisdom, these don’t exist. If they existed, then they would have to truly exist.

So we keep saying they don’t exist. They don’t exist. If they existed, what fault would there be? Yes. There’s no movement.

There is no — no movement. So there would be no birth, no destruction? So the two ways in which things can be truly existent: if they naturally existed, then they would be truly existent. The example that you just gave is with respect to this first. For example, if the flower naturally existed, then it would have no production.

It would have no disintegration. It would truly exist. The second one is that the other way in which true existence would exist is if the conventionality existed for a superior in meditative equipoise on emptiness, then it would truly exist. So what are the two? Have you used an example of a flower?

With respect to the flower, what are the two ways it could be truly existent? If the flower were naturally existent, it would be truly existent. One, first. If the flower existed for a superior’s meditative equipoise on emptiness, it would be truly existent. We can apply this to everything else.

We can say if the eye were naturally existent, then it would be truly existent. If the eye existed for a superior’s meditative equipoise on emptiness, it would be truly existent. So, not relying upon causes and conditions. Not relying — not included, not relying upon causes and results. Today I ask you questions.

You’re always asking me questions. Next time I’m going to ask you a question so you should think about what we’ve just said.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top