41 min · 1,972 words · 1 September 1992
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a commentary on the Heart Sutra, explaining emptiness as the absence of inherent existence and how the sutra’s ‘in emptiness there is no form’ passage refers to the meditative equipoise of a bodhisattva. It distinguishes truth as agreement between how a phenomenon appears and how it exists, and covers the five Mahayana paths. It ends by explaining why only a Buddha can directly realise ultimate and conventional truth simultaneously, through removal of the knowledge obstruction.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1992-09-01
Duration: 41 min
UUID: 4017e375-e4ab-4166-a77b-edbe935f8eb7
Words: 1,968
All of these these various phenomena which we’re we’re listing, for example, we say that there’s no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind. We say that there is no attainment, no non attainment, etcetera. These are all explaining emptiness. So if you read from where it says, Shariputra, form and emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no recognition, etcetera. So what what does this mean?
You know, it is Chenrezig who is speaking to Shariputra, and he’s saying, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no recognition, no compositional factors, no consciousness. In general, the all of these things exist. I mean, form form exists. Emptiness, feelings exist. What this means here is that for a bodhisattva for a bodhisattva’s exalted wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness.
For that exalted wisdom, then all of these various phenomena do not exist. There’s no form does not exist. Feeling does not exist. Recognition does not exist. So for that for that exalted wisdom, the non the nonexistence of form is emptiness.
The nonexistence of feeling is emptiness. For that awareness, the nonexistence of form is emptiness. For that awareness. So, you know, last teaching, I I I ask you a question, two questions of how do we posit the existence of true existence. And in terms of the text, where the first question is being answered from the words form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is no other than form, down through to consciousness is all empty.
This is a this is an answer to that first question. That is to say that they do not naturally exist. Therefore, they do not truly exist. And then we have been discussing now in terms of the second part of the question where it says, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no no recognition, etcetera. All of the remainder of that part of the text is is answering that second question in that for an exalted wisdom, a meditative equipoise on emptiness, there is no form, etcetera.
So that first part of the question is being answered in terms of an abbreviated manner by the line at the end of the second paragraph where it says, analyzing the five aggregates by nature empty. And this is what we said. If things do not naturally exist, then they they lack true existence. And this then it goes on to expand in this where it says form is empty, But if you then but the second type of way in which emptiness exists is being explained otherwise in terms of where it uses the word, in emptiness, there is no form. It doesn’t say doesn’t even mention the word naturally existent.
It just says in emptiness, there is no form. So this is a second mode of positing emptiness. So one one mode of positing the existence of true existence is where it says are by nature empty. That is to say that the lack of natural existence is emptiness. The absence of natural existence is emptiness.
So it says, you know, analyzing the five aggregates by nature empty. By nature empty. That is to say that the that the it it the nonexistence of its nature is its emptiness. The the nonexistence of an of an inherent nature. Nonexistence of its nature is its emptiness.
The the the nonexistence of its of its nature is its emptiness. The existence of its nature is true existence. The the existence of its nature is true existence. The nonexistence of its nature is empty. Now another way in which the mode of true existence is is set out is in terms of where it says, therefore, Shariputra, in emptiness, there is no form.
So what this is referring to is that for the for the awareness of which is meditative equipoise on emptiness for that awareness, there is no form. If there were form, then what thought would there be? If form did exist for this awareness, what thought would there be? It would be that this form would have to be truly existent. If this form existed for this awareness, then the form would have to be truly existent.
We we should understand that when it says, in emptiness, there is no form. If form existed for an exalted wisdom of meditation and equipoise on emptiness for that awareness, then it would have to be truly existent. And in the case of form, it would have to be truly existent form because truly existent form does not exist, then there is no form for that awareness. And the same applies that there are no feelings, no recognitions, etcetera. That in order for them to exist for such an awareness, they would have to be truly existent.
Because they are not truly existent, then they they don’t exist for that awareness. There is no form. There are no feelings. So we we we should try to understand the reason why if form existed for such awareness, it would have to be truly existent. You know, we should question, but what is the reason why it would have to be truly existent, if it existed for such an, an exalted wisdom directly realizing the meditative wisdom directly realizing emptiness.
For that awareness, only emptiness exists. Only emptiness exists for that awareness. And and what is the reason for that? That only emptiness is appearing to this awareness. If it appears to this awareness, it must be empty, and it must be a truth.
That is to say, it’s a mode of appearance. The way it appears, the way the phenomenon appears, and the way that it exists accord. That is to say, there must be an agreement. The way the object appears and the way that it exists must be an agreement. That is to say, that’s what we mean by true.
And here we need ultimate truth. Among the two truths, conventional truth and ultimate truth, it is the ultimate truth if it’s the way it if the way it appears and the way it exists are in agreement, and this is what appears to such an awareness. So when the way of appearing in the way of existing or abiding are in agreement, then we say it is true. If they are in disagreement, if they are discordant, then we say it is falsity. Mi bden pa.
So when if the mode of a if the mode or the way an object appears in the way it exists or abides are in agreement, that they’re harmonious, concordant, they accord with one another, then it is a truth. If they are in disagreement, then they are said to be falsities. Conventional conventional phenomena, phenomena such as the five aggregates, the twelve links of dependent origination, are falsities. That is to say their way of appearing and their way of existing are in disagreement. If form existed the way it appears, then it would be a truth and would appear to this awareness.
But because it is not a truth, if the way it appears and the way it exists were in agreement, it would have to be a truth and therefore it would be truly existent. But it does not appear, it is not the truth, because it does not appear for the awareness, which is realizing the truth, the ultimate truth, and therefore it is not truly existent because the way of appearing and the way of existing of form are not in agreement. So it’s somewhat difficult to realize what we mean when we say that the mode of appearance, the way of appearing, and the way of existing or the way of abiding of form are in disagreement. For example, you know, we can take any type of conventional phenomenon such as a flower. They’re all the same.
And how does it appear to our eye consciousness? Due to the influence of this ignorance, it appears to exist truly. It appears to truly exist. But in fact, because that’s the way it appears, but it does not exist truly. It does not truly exist.
Therefore, the way it appears and the way it exists are in disagreement. Therefore, it is a falsity. For example, someone says something to us and it does not accord with the actual fact that we say that he is he’s false, he’s a liar. It’s same. Yeah.
How are you? So we’ll stop. We’ll stop there. I’m being asked what you’re doing. I have a question for you.
So with respect to the universal vehicle, the Mahāyāna, there are five paths. What are the five paths? Anybody else answer? On? What’s Path accumulation.
Preparation. Seeing. Meditation. So we’ve passed through the first four after meditation. Now we’re going to later on, we’ll we’ll talk we’ll discuss the fifth.
Which of these five paths, which of these five paths directly realize What is the measure of generating the first What is the measure of generating the first path, developing the first path? What does it require? I mean, he’s going to grade you. What is the measure of generating the first path? So with respect with respect to the awakening heart, there are there are two types.
There is nominal and actual, or that is the artificial and nonartificial, and the same holds true for renunciation. What are those two? What are the two levels of Which of those are generated upon entering into the path? So there are two mind generations. So mind generation means the awakening heart.
And so there is the artificial and nonartificial mind generation and artificial and nonartificial renunciation or determination to be free. So upon entering into the first path, one generates the the actual or the nominal. Is that called nominal? Yeah. So in order to enter into the first path, it’s necessary to generate the actual or the nonartificial awakening heart and renunciation.
So those who have not entered in the path have nominal awakening heart and renunciation imputed. I’m very happy with your answer. That’s very good. So if it would be good for all of you to know this. So there are five paths, path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning.
When we first have direct realization of emptiness, we attain the path of seeing, the third path. When we have actual, not artificial, awakening heart and renunciation, we attain the first path. If you didn’t know this, then you can generate the path and not know it. So So one question. Good question.
Yeah. Yeah. Geshe-la asks and teaches. So, you know, as ordinary people, if we were to meditate on emptiness, then we will be able to realize emptiness. We will be able to see emptiness, which is the ultimate truth.
But in the case of all beings except for Buddhas, that is non-Buddhas, they can only see or realize conventional truths and ultimate truths alternatively. They cannot see them simultaneously. It is only a Buddha which can directly a Buddha directly and simultaneously realizes or sees both ultimate truth and conventional truth. So there’s only a Buddha which is able to have realization of both of these simultaneously. So why is that?
We need a reason. So why is that? All non-Buddhas have an obstruction which prevents them from simultaneously directly realizing the two truths. This is known as the knowledge obstruction. A Buddha has abandoned, removed his knowledge obstruction, and therefore is able to simultaneously and directly realize the truth, whereas non-Buddhas have an obstruction or a hindrance to be able to directly realize them simultaneously.
A Buddha can do it with one awareness, and non-Buddhas cannot. This is the reason that we have to abandon knowledge obstruction, the obstruction to omniscience.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.