45 min · 1,240 words · 22 September 1992
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This question session is a debate format in which the audience divides into two sides to put questions to each other about the Heart Sutra teaching. The discussion covers why phenomena can move and change because they lack inherent existence, the two kinds of space (conditioned and unconditioned) as non-affirming negations, and the three characteristics an object must meet to be designated as something, such as a flower or a person.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1992-09-22
Duration: 46 min
UUID: e5b5de07-23db-44f6-9420-9f78d266f3a4
Words: 1,236
So we have completed the teaching and as was mentioned in the last session that today would be devoted to questions. So today in this question session, we’re not going to do it as we have done it in the past. We’re going to do it differently. And we’re going to divide up into two sides. And one side will put questions to the other side.
And then whoever amongst the other side is able to answer, then they can give the answer. And then the latter side will then put questions to the former side. And again, whoever on that side will answer the question. So this is a way we can this is quite beneficial. It helps to create doubts and to eliminate our doubts and to develop our wisdom.
So it’s an extremely beneficial method. So dividing it in half? So divide down the middle? So to the right and left. Who’s going to ask the first question?
Motion. Motion is empty. The empty is the motion. It’s because all phenomena are empty, that is say lack inherent existence, that things have motion. That is to say that they’re able to arise and fall, they’re able to come and go.
If weren’t empty, if they weren’t if they were inherently existent, then there wouldn’t, there would be no motion. Okay. You ask this side. You can put a question to the other side. Who doesn’t think there’s a permanent phenomenon?
Who doesn’t think who said there wasn’t? How many people think there’s no such thing? Oh, Leslie. I heard you. Leslie.
Which what what kind of space? So there are two kinds of space, conditioned space and unconditioned space. The definition of unconditioned space is the negation, the factor which is the negation of obstructability. So when move, the table obstructs. It can’t it can’t go.
You’re obstructed from going. That the nonexistence of that obstruction. So there’s nothing which obstructs your hand. So, this emptiness is space. This vacuity.
So a vacuity which does not resist. And when you move your hand, there’s nothing tangible which is resistant, which acts as a resistant. Pardon? Because they’re hair. We have to feel that.
The thing is, meaning in terms of way that classical physics So the wind, the air is formed. Air is formed. So when the air is moving quickly, it makes the sound of wind. It’s formed. So, the air is not space.
If there were no space, then we wouldn’t be able to move around. So this vacuity of space, if it didn’t exist, then we wouldn’t be able to raise our arm, lower our arm, move it back and forth. Airplanes would not be able to fly through the air. So as you mentioned previously also in terms of the similarities between emptiness and space, that they both are non-affirming negations. In the case of emptiness, emptiness is the negation of true existence.
And in case of unconditioned space, the unconditioned is the is a negation of conditioned or arising from cause and conditions. Space which does not arise from cause and conditions. So it too is a a non affirming negation. Another question? If form is emptiness, what form does emptiness take?
What was that? Form can take the form of any phenomena. You said emptiness is form? Emptiness is form. No.
You said form is emptiness. What form does form take? So what form does emptiness take? That’s a different question. What’s the answer?
Emptiness. What is the meaning of emptiness is form is emptiness? What is the mean? Is mean? Jim is saying there’s a quotation in the text which says form is emptiness.
What does that quotation mean? So? What question do wanna put? I’m making up. My question.
Oh, you wanna repeat it? Form is emptiness. Therefore, what’s the form of emptiness take? And it’s been answered. And what is the answer?
Judy have an answer? What was your answer, Judy, when you’re answering? Is that right? Takes the form, if you like, off of any phenomenon. I don’t know whether that’s possible to translate.
No, mean, you’re using the word form in two different ways, actually. No, and the question is in what aspect? What aspect does emptiness take? It’s a play on the word form, I think. Anyway.
If phenomena do not exist from their own side, then we can call a cat a dog. Why can’t we can we call a cat a dog? Is it does that make it if we call a cat a dog, does that make it a dog? If we call a cat a dog, does that make it a dog? Yeah.
If everybody everybody calls a cat a dog, it transforms it into a dog. What happened? What happened to dog in the house? So, in answer to Pamela’s question. You have an answer to Pamela’s question?
If everybody says that true existence exists, does that make true existence existent? If you were to impute a person to a horse, does that make it a person? If you were to call. Everybody does it. Everybody, that means everybody.
So he didn’t say everybody? But everybody doesn’t say that, do they? So all phenomena do not inherently exist if we were to does it make the flower a person? Does that make the flower a person? Someone ordered it.
Kimball? But not all sentient beings designate flowers as people, do they? So in order for something to be that, in order for something to be that, it must satisfy three characteristics. Merely being imputed is not sufficient. Merely being designated is not sufficient.
All sentient beings do not designate this flower as a flower, But it’s not necessary that they would, that they didn’t at all designate as a flower to be a flower. There was a first person who gave it the name flower. The initial giver said, what should I call this object? I’ll call it a flower. And then others said, well, what is this?
And he said, it’s a flower. And it became known as a flower. So I didn’t give the name flower to this object. I was told that it is a flower. I didn’t give it that So, the three characteristics that an object must satisfy in order to be that.
Three characteristics. One, it must be a valid basis of imputation to be that. The second is it must not conflict with worldly convention which designate it as that, which understand it as that, and it must not be in conflict with an ultimate knower which designates it as that. For example, if we were to designate the flower as a person, we cannot designate the flower as a person because the flower is not a valid basis for designating a person. And it must be a popular worldly convention.
It is known as a popular worldly convention. A popular worldly convention. It not contradicted by a valid analyzer understanding the ultimate. So in order for an object to be that, it must satisfy these three characteristics. Merely designating as that doesn’t make it that.
So the questioner, my questioner? So I’ll give you the first. In order to realize emptiness, the first point is the point of ascertaining the object of negation, ascertaining the object of negation. Do you do you remember those the the latter three?
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.