45 min · 2,705 words · 16 June 1992
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains the Heart Sutra line ‘analyzing the five aggregates, by nature empty’, identifying the object of negation as inherent existence of the aggregates and the self. It distinguishes phenomenal selflessness from personal selflessness and argues that a truly existent self would make karma and cyclic existence impossible. It illustrates dependent arising and the search for the self through the six elements and the hand example.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1992-06-16
Duration: 46 min
UUID: cde0ede8-f456-46a2-be00-c4415749bae8
Words: 2,701
So in discussing the line, you should look at it like this, Analyzing the five aggregates by nature empty. This is the entire abbreviated meaning of the discourse of the heart of wisdom. It has the complete subject which is being discussed and it is extremely important section. Looking at this line, analyzing the five aggregates by nature empty, last time we discussed what the five aggregates were or are. The aggregates of forms, feelings, perceptions, mental constructions, and consciousnesses.
And they are the basis which is going to be qualified. And the quality which is going to be discussed in terms of this basis is the emptiness of natural existence. Here it says, Nature by empty. They are empty of natural existence. That is to say, we’re discussing emptiness in terms of the five aggregates.
The five aggregates are not naturally existent. They lack a way of establishment in that they do not naturally exist. This non natural existence of the five aggregates is the emptiness in terms of the five aggregates. And this is what we’re seeking to realize to understand that the five aggregates are empty and they’re empty of natural existence. So we have to what is the we have to identify what we’re trying to refute.
We’re trying to refute that the five aggregates are established by their own nature. That the five aggregates are established by means of their own nature. This is the object of negation. What we have to identify is the object of negation. And the object of negation is that the five aggregates are established by way of their own nature.
Being established by way of their own nature is what we’re trying to refute. It is the object of negation. It is that which we’re trying to refute. So when we refute the natural establishment of the five aggregates, we establish the emptiness of the five aggregates. That the five aggregates are empty.
We establish the fact of the emptiness of the five aggregates by refuting that the five aggregates are established by way of their own nature. Quoting a verse by Śāntideva where he sets out, If the imputed object is not identified, then its non existence can never be ascertained. We have to identify what it is that does not exist if we’re ever going to establish that in fact it does not exist. Previously we said that we used an example of a person. If we’re searching for a particular person, then we have to be able to identify that person to establish whether they exist at any certain place.
If we aren’t able to recognize that person, then we can never ascertain whether that person exists or not at a particular place. And what we’re trying to identify is the object which is being grasped at by ignorance. And in this case, it is the true existence of the five aggregates or the inherent existence of the five aggregates. Ignorance is grasping at the inherent existence of the five aggregates. This true existence of the five aggregates is the factor which is being superimposed upon the five aggregates.
This superimposed factor of true existence is the object which is to be negated. And we must identify what is this factor which is being superimposed upon true upon the aggregates. In general, there are many ways in which emptiness can be divided. There is the division of emptiness into 20, into 18, into 16, into four. But if we were to condense the condensed most division of emptiness is into two.
According to a verse from Candrakīrti where he says, the method whereby to remove all faults and to free oneself from cyclic existence is by means of the understanding of selflessness or emptiness. And these are condensed into two. So we’re going to There are two selflessnesses or emptinesses. The most abbreviated or condensed division. The five aggregates are phenomena.
The emptiness or the selflessness which qualifies the five aggregates. That is to say, the emptiness in terms of these five aggregates is termed phenomenal selflessness or emptiness of phenomena. Phenomenal selflessness or emptiness of phenomena. I did say the emptiness or the selflessness which qualifies or is spoken of in terms of the five aggregates. It’s phenomenal selflessness or emptiness of phenomena.
Exemplifying what we mean by phenomenal selflessness or emptiness or phenomena. A flower is a phenomena. And it’s non establishment, it’s non inherent establishment. It’s non inherent establishment. It’s non non inherent existence.
Actually the word is establishment but existence is alright. It’s non inherent existence is the emptiness of the flower. The flower being a phenomenon, this is an example of phenomena emptiness of a phenomena. Or we can say phenomenal selflessness. It means the same.
We can take another subject. Example, the table. The basis of the emptiness is the table. The non inherent existence of the table is the emptiness of the table. The non inherent existence of the table is the emptiness of the table.
The basis of the emptiness is the table. So those examples of phenomenal selflessness or emptiness of phenomena. Now the five aggregates are the basis of imputing, designating the I, the self, the person. These all mean person here rather than saying being. I’m going to use the word person.
Being, self, I. These are same synonymous terms. So the I is imputed to the five aggregates. The non inherent existence of this I, of the person, is personal selflessness or emptiness of persons. Personal selflessness or emptiness of persons.
So the term selflessness and emptiness are synonyms. Mean the same thing. Selflessness, emptiness mean the same thing. So we have the emptiness of phenomena, which is phenomenal selflessness. We have emptiness of persons or personal selflessness.
So there is emptiness in terms of phenomena and there’s emptiness in terms of persons. By persons I mean beings, okay? But I’m just saying persons. There’s emptiness in terms of persons, emptiness in terms of phenomena, that which is not persons. So the non inherent existence of the five aggregates is the emptiness of the five aggregates.
The inherent existence of the five aggregates is the object of negation. The inherent existence of the five aggregates is the object of negation, the object which is to be negated. The non inherent existence of the I in terms of these five aggregates is the emptiness of person or the emptiness of self. The inherent existence of the I is the object of negation in terms of the I. So we have We have two areas of emptiness.
We have the emptiness in phenomenal emptiness in terms of phenomena, emptiness in terms of persons. Of these two, which should be meditated upon first? Either of these two, we should initially meditate on the emptiness of persons. That is to say, the non inherent existence of persons as opposed to the non inherent existence of phenomena. So there are two objects of negation.
We said that we should initially meditate upon the emptiness of the I. The object of negation in terms of the I is a self defining I or inherently existent I. Self defining or inherently existent I. This is the main object of negation. There is a second object in negation.
That is the ignorance which grasp at or conceives of an inherently existent I. This is an awareness, a type of awareness, ignorance which grasps or conceives of an inherently existent I. This too is an object of negation. Therefore, there are two objects of negation. Why is it necessary to to we said there were there were two objects in negation.
There is the inherently existent I and the awareness which grasps at the existence of the inherently existent I. Both of these are to be negated. Why is it necessary to negate both of these? Firstly, the inherently existent I does not exist. But awareness there is an awareness, that is to say ignorance, grasped at the existence of an inherently existent I.
It is grasping at the existence of something which does not exist. in dependence upon this is what we term self grasping. The grasping of a type of self does not though it does not exist, is grasped to exist, is conceived of to exist. Out of this, based upon this grasping at a nonexistent to exist, there arises the various afflictive emotions such as attachment, hatred, pride, ignorance. All the various afflictive emotions are generated dependent upon this factor which grasps at a nonexistent to exist.
Out of generating these afflictive emotions, we engage in various types of actions of body, speech, and mind. That is to say, we create negative karmas. Of these karmas, due to the force of these afflictive emotions and karmas, we continue to circle within cyclic existence undergoing various experiences of suffering. It is for this reason that both of these are to be negated. That is to say, brought about a cessation to be stopped.
A naturally exist a naturally existent I does not exist. But what if it did exist?
What if a naturally existent I did exist? If it did exist, then it cannot be refuted. It cannot be negated. If the naturally existent I did exist, then the awareness which grasps to its existence would in fact not be false. It would be true.
That is the reality. It would be concordant with the way things are. It would not be a distorted conception. It would be concordant. And therefore, it being concordant, it being true, then the various afflictive emotions such as attachment, hatred would not be generated.
We would not generate and therefore we would not generate karma. Not generating karma, then there would be no future lives. Being no future lives, there would be no cyclic existence. There would be no liberation. There would be getting rid of faults.
There would be no development of excellent qualities. For example, the tape this table exists. The table exists. The conception which conceives the table to exist is a factually concordant conception. Therefore, in dependence upon this factually concordant conception, various types of afflictive emotions do not arise.
Attachment does not arise. Hatred does not arise. Pride does not arise. Karma does not arise. Dependent upon the influence of a factually concordant conception.
The Buddha taught that all phenomena whatsoever are dependent arising. Therefore everything relies upon something other than itself for its existence. There is nothing which does not rely upon other factor than itself. The I is a phenomena which relies upon other factors for its existence. It depends, for example, upon the five aggregates.
It is established in terms of the five aggregates. Therefore, it depends upon the five aggregates for its arising. Therefore, it is a dependent arising. Because it depends upon other, it does not independently exist. Because its existence depends upon other, it does not independently exist.
Does not inherently exist. Therefore, if something were to inherently exist or independently exist, it would rely upon nothing outside of itself. It would not rely upon, for example, causes and conditions. It would not rely upon its basis of imputation. And the same holds true of the I.
The I is a dependent arising which arises dependent upon the five aggregates. So we can look at, on the one hand, the non inherent existence of phenomena and persons in terms of being dependent arising. But to continue with the reasoning, we can cite the example as given by Nāgārjuna. Nāgārjuna was one of the greatest masters of emptiness who ever lived in India. The Buddha, when he was entering into non abiding beyond sorrow, non abiding parinirvana, was asked, Who in the future can we rely upon?
Whose teachings can we rely upon with respect to profound emptiness? And the Buddha said that you can rely completely upon the teachings of Nāgārjuna. The Buddha prophesied the coming of Nāgārjuna who would clearly and completely be able to explain emptiness as it was. And he did this to the most profound extent in a text called Prajnaparamula or Root Wisdom. Nāgārjuna quoted a verse from Root Wisdom and explaining the meaning of that verse.
We are all the same. We are composed of four elements earth, water, fire, and air. And then space and consciousness. So there are six elements. We consist in terms of these six elements.
Now if we look at these, each of these elements is not the person. The collection of these elements is not the person. The shape of these elements is not the person. There is no person other than the six elements. This is the way in which the non-inherent existence of the person is established.
When we meditate, have to carry on a meditation in terms of reason analysis. For example, we’re going to look for the I. This I. Now the I in fact, does exist. I go, I stay, I work, I eat food.
This I exists. But when we search for this I, when we look for it, we look in terms of the five aggregates. None of the five aggregates are the I. The collection of the five aggregates is not the I. If we analyze the five aggregates themselves in terms of the body, if we analyze the five aggregates each internally, we see that of which they are constituted.
For example, the earth element. The earth element is the solidity, the hard factor of the body. This indicates the presence of the earth element, the solidity. The earth element is not the I. The water element, that is the various fluids in the body, none of them are the I.
The fire element, this is the warmth of the body which promotes digestion, etc. Metabolism, this fire element is not the body. The wind energy element, that is to say that factor which animates the body is not the I. So none of each of these four elements is the I nor is the space element the I nor is the consciousness the thinking factor of our awareness. That is not the I.
Nor is the collection of all of these six elements the I. Nor is there something other than these six elements which we can find to be the I. When we search for the I, we do not find it. When we investigate, when we search, we are not able to find the I. That is to say the nominally existent I.
When we search within the body, we search the collection which constitutes the body, the aggregates, we search outside the body. Upon searching, investigating, the I is not found. If the eye were to be found upon analysis, then the eye would have to be a self defining eye. It would have to be truly existent. It would have to be inherently existent.
in dependence upon the reason that upon searching we are not able to find the I, we therefore conclude that the I is not self defining. It is not inherently existent. It is not truly existent. If we were to conclude, upon searching we are not able to find the eye, if if if upon searching we are not able to find the I, if we were to conclude, I don’t exist, the I in fact does exist. The the eye does exist.
It exists in terms of ordinary worldly awarenesses which does not search nor investigate the nature of the I. That is what ordinary worldly awareness does. For example, you know, that the hand exists. You know, I I I have a hand. It’s my right hand.
And it does all kinds of things. It it can write. It it’s very functional. So we all know that the hand exists. But when we analyze, when we investigate, what is the hand?
And we begin to look. Is hand? This No. Is this the hand? This the hand?
No. Is No. Is this the hand? No. Is the flesh is this flesh the hand?
No. Is this flesh the hand? No. Is the bone the hand? No.
None of these are the hand.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- parinirvana
- The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.