Heart Sutra — 1992-06-23

Buddha House Adelaide

Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra — 1992-06-23
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1992-06-23 – Side 2 – KR.MP3

UUID: fc8e9dfd-a990-4a2c-8c6a-901e5510887f

Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche

Collection: Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 1992-06-23

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 38 min

Words: 2,253

So if if we have already analyzed it, if if something exists, it must be either the same or different. And now we are forced to move on to the fact that if the self and the basis of imputation, the aggregates, are not inherently one, then if the truly existent self in fact exists, then it must be inherently different than the aggregates. So in general, I exists. Here we’re looking, we’re trying to examine whether the truly existent I is inherently different than the aggregate. That is to say, this truly existent I?

Is it inherently other than the aggregate? Inherently other than aggregate. We’ve concluded it’s not the same, so it must be different. It must be other than the aggregate if it exists. So we we we proceed with analysis.

We we begin to set aside the various constituents of which are the five aggregates. We set aside the form aggregate. We set aside the form aggregate. Then we set aside the feeling aggregate. Then the aggregate of perceptions.

Aggregate of mental construction. And finally the aggregate of consciousnesses. Now if this truly existent I is inherently different or other than the five aggregates, having set having set to the side the five aggregates, there should remain a truly existent I. We should be able to recognize something which we can call a truly existent I. But in fact, we find nothing left over.

So we’re we’re searching for the truly existing I, And we search each of the aggregates. The aggregate of forms is not the I. The aggregate of feelings is not the I. The aggregate of perceptions is not the I. The aggregate of mental constructions is not the I.

The aggregate of consciousness is not the I. There’s nothing other than those which is this truly existing I. For example, a a goat, a sheep, and a horse are three distinct types of animals. Their existence is not dependent one upon the other. That is to they can exist without relationship to one another.

If we have these three animals, if we remove the goat and the horse, then we will have a distinct animal, the sheep, left over because the existence of the sheep is not dependent upon the existence of these other two. They’re unrelated as far as their existences. But in terms of the truly existent I, if it exists unrelatedly different than the aggregates, then having removed the aggregates, we should, just as in the case we found the sheep, have a distinct I left over. But we don’t. So that’s the first fault.

Another fault would be if I were self definingly different than the aggregate or the I were inherently different than the aggregate. That is to say unrelatedly different just as a horse and a cow or a cat and a dog. They are unrelatedly different. What would happen if the I and the aggregate existed in that same manner of relationship? If we’re analyzing whether the truly existent self and the aggregates are unrelatedly different or unrelatedly other.

Just as the nature of a horse is unrelated to the nature of a cow. Or another example, just as the nature of a vase or a pot is unrelated to a pillar. Likewise, if the natures of the self were unrelatedly different to the nature of the aggregates, though the aggregates undergo birth, aging, disease, and death because the I is unrelatedly different, the I would not undergo birth, aging, disease, and death. Just as just as the aggregates arise and disintegrate, aggregates have a nature of arising and disintegrating. Therefore, they are a product.

But because the I is unrelatedly different, the I would be a permanent phenomena, would be a nonproduct. So the aggregates are are product, whereas the I would be a nonproduct since it’s unrelatedly different. If the I were a non product, then it would not be a taker of rebirth. It would not the eye would never would not be sick. The I would not be hungry.

So if the if the I and the aggregate were self definingly different or that is to say inherently different, then all of these various faults would accrue. Therefore, the I and the aggregate are definitely not inherently existently different. This this ascertainment of this is the ascertainment of this fourth point, freedom from difference or multiplicity or many. So having proceeded through these four points of analysis, one concludes that if the I is inherently existent, it must be either inherently existently one or inherently existently different with the aggregates. It must be one of these.

If the I is inherently existent, it must be inherently existent in one or many or different than aggregates. And we have concluded that the I is not inherently existent in the one with the aggregates and we have concluded that the I is not inherently existent different than the aggregates. Therefore, we are forced to come to the conclusion that the I is not inherently existent. And this is the way we should proceed in meditation. So if one proceeds in this matter of meditation, again and again analyzing through various reasoning, again and again coming to the understanding that the inherently existent I does not exist at all, then there begins to appear an absence of the inherently existent I begins to appear to the mind.

This factor or the absence of an inherently existent I is a non affirming negation. When this appears to the mind, one has realized emptiness. Analogy would be, you know, if you had some extremely precious article, it was very valuable, very important to you, and you had two boxes and you were quite certain, definite, that you had placed it in one of these boxes. I mean, this is really an important, precious article to you. And you want to take great care of it.

And you strongly thought to yourself, I know it’s in one of these two boxes. The this precious article that we’re that we’re quite certain exists, even though in the meantime a thief has taken it is analogous to the inherently existent I. We’re quite certain that this inherently existent I exists somewhere within So one day we went to make use of this precious article, this valuable that we’ve placed securely away in either of these two boxes, which we’re quite sure definitely there within one of these two boxes. This article is so precious to us that we have a clear vision of what it appears to us, what it looks like. And so we one day, wanting to make use of it, we opened the first box.

And we know exactly what we’re looking for and we look within that first box with, Ah, it’s not there. We looked very carefully, and we concluded, ah, it’s not in this first box. So this first part of this analogy is analogous to looking for the truly existing I, which we sure exists, either one of two places. And just as in the case of looking in the first box, concluding that it’s not there by means of the third point of freedom from singularity or identity, we come to a definite conclusion that truly existent I is not one with the aggregate. So for sure it’s in the other box.

No question. It’s not in this first box, it’s got to be in one of these two boxes. So we go with it. Well, we go with speed to look into the second box. And we open the second box and lo and behold, we discover it’s not in the second box either.

We know it’s very clear what it is we were looking for and we don’t see it within the second box. And we discover it’s nonexistent, of something we clearly understand should be there. Know exactly what we’re looking for and then we don’t find it. And for many people, out of this experience there arises a fear or an anxiety. When this nonexistence of something we thought definitely existed appears to our mind, some kind of fear can arise.

There’s no other place to search. It has to be either in if it still exists, it has to be within either of these two boxes. There’s no other place to look. And we find, Ah, it doesn’t exist. So we know exactly what we’re looking for.

And what we’re looking for is the object of negation in terms of the meaning of the analogy. That is to say, this is an appearance of something which in fact doesn’t exist. Something which clearly appears to us but which in fact doesn’t exist. And just like the article had to exist in one of the two boxes, likewise, the object negation, that is to say the inherently existent I, must either be the same, inherently the same, or inherently different than aggregate. There’s only these two possibilities.

And upon analysis, we are not able to find the inherently existent I, and we come to the conclusion that we come to a realization of When there is this realization of that something that you strongly conceived of to exist does not exist, that is to say, when there is the understanding that the inherently existent I, in fact, does not exist. For those of duller faculties, there arises fear and anxiety. For those of sharp faculties, upon this realization, there arises great joy, a great bliss, fearlessness. Once, Je Tsongkhapa was giving a teaching at Sera, and he and amongst the audience was one of his students by the name of Sherab Sangye.

And Sherab Sangye, during the course of the teaching, had an initial understanding of emptiness. And for Sangye, upon an initial understanding of emptiness of the self, it is possible to fall to the extreme of I don’t exist at all. When one comes to an understanding that the I does not inherently exist, it’s possible to think that I don’t exist at all. And for some, this is the source of fear. And this is what happened to Sherab Sangye.

So Sherab Sangye had this realization of emptiness and he became frightened thinking that in fact he didn’t exist at all. Out of his fear, to secure himself, he grabbed onto his shirt. And Tsongkhapa was able to understand what Sherab Sangye was experiencing. And Sherab Sangye came from a place called Nam Tong, Nam Tong. And therefore he was referred to as Nam Tong Pa.

And he said, ah, Nam Tong Pa has just ascertained the nominal existence of himself. So some experience fear at this point. We are fearless with respect to emptiness because we have not seen it. For some who see it, they become frightened. The mode of proceeding in our meditation is as follows.

The I is not self defining or inherently existent. If the I is inherently existent, it must be inherently existently the same or it must be inherently existent inherently existently different than the aggregates. But the I is neither inherently existently the same nor is it inherently existent different than the aggregates. Therefore, the inherently existent I does not exist. If if the inherently existent I were inherently existently the same as the aggregates, then various faults would accrue.

If were inherently existently different than the aggregates, then various faults would accrue. So we should analyze in terms of these faults and come to a definite conclusion that the that the I is not inherently inherently differently inherently the the same. Come to that definite conclusion and proceeding that the I is not inherently inherently different than the aggregates. Come to that conclusion and then conclude that, Well, if it exists at all, it must be either of these two, it is neither of these two, and come to the definite conclusion that the inherently existent I does not in fact exist. And develop a strong conviction in the conclusion and then abide single pointedly in meditation upon this conclusion that one has come to and gradually developing this conviction and this ability to abide in meditation upon this until realization is gained.

So once we have realized the the emptiness of the I, then it’s quite a simple matter to realize the emptiness of all various phenomena. For example, the table. We can apply the same reasoning that we applied with respect to the I and we quickly come to a realization that the table does not truly exist. We can take any object. For example, if the table inherently existed, then it would have to be inherently same or different in its basis of imputation.

And we can quickly come to a realization of emptiness of all phenomena merely by thinking about them, having come to this initial realization. We can come to this understanding quite easily. So some of you have a long way to go, and it’s late. So we won’t have questions tonight, but we’ll we’ll have questions at the next teaching. So as your homework, do you have a week to realize emptiness?

So next next week next week, you should report how things went. If you meditate, then you should develop some qualms about it. If you don’t think about it, then you won’t develop any qualms with respect to emptiness. It’s good to develop doubts, qualms. If you don’t have any doubts with respect to emptiness, you’ve already realized it.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top