Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1992-06-16 – Side 2 – KR.MP3
UUID: c74a52ea-135d-4d5f-89fb-6105cb853429
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1992-06-16
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 37 min
Words: 1,821
But if but if but all of these phenomena do exist in terms of when they are not investigated or searched for. So this is the way we can determine whether objects are self defining or not. If upon analysis we could find the object of investigation, then we would say that the object is self defining, that the object is inherently existent. If we can’t find it upon investigation, then we have to conclude it’s not self defining, that it’s not inherently existent. So therefore, we conclude because upon analysis we can never find the object which we’re seeking to investigate, that no phenomena are self defining, that no phenomena inherently exist.
And this would include that the I is not self defining or inherently existent. On the one hand, if we can refute by means of reasoning the non inherent existence of the I, then we might think, well, what need is there to do anymore? Why why bother to meditate on the on the non self non inherent existence of the I? If we do not refute by means of reasoning well in our meditation, then we’re going to accrue a great many important faults. We’re going to continue to suffer.
We’re never going to be free of cyclic existence. So how does that arise if we consider that? Though in fact, in reality, phenomena do not inherently exist. But simply because they do not inherently exist does not free us from the necessity to come to this understanding that they do not inherently exist. Why?
Because we possess a factor of ignorance which grasp at the inherent existence of phenomena. Though the phenomena do not inherently exist in reality, there is an awareness which is a grasping at the inherent existence of these phenomena. This self grasping conceives that all phenomena whatsoever inherently exist, truly exist. This is an awareness which is confused or bewildered with respect to the mode of abidance. It’s an unknowing with respect to the way things exist.
Out of this mistaken way of conceiving arises attachment, hatred, and pride, all the various afflictive emotions. Therefore, though in fact phenomena do not inherently exist, we still must come to that realization because we have a factor which grasps at the inherent existence of phenomena. What is it that is able to overcome, to destroy this conception that the I inherently exists, that the I truly exists? Though in fact the I does not truly exist, though in fact the I does not inherently exist. There is an ignorance which is a conception which grasps at the true existence, at the inherent existence of the I.
And the only factor which can destroy this conception is the wisdom understanding the emptiness of the I. There is nothing else which is able to overcome the ignorance grasping at the existence of the I than the wisdom understanding the emptiness of the inherent existence of the I. Why is that? The following is from a verse by Dharmakīrti. Explaining why it is only the wisdom realizing the emptiness of the I which is able to overcome the ignorance which grasps at the inherent existence of the eye.
From this verse it says that there is an awareness which is grasping at the inherent existence of the I. There is a wisdom which realizes the emptiness of the inherent existence of the I. These two awarenesses are incompatible. They are at opposition with one another. The awareness which grasped at the inherent existence of the I is a distorted conception.
It is a wrong conception. Whereas the wisdom which realizes the emptiness of the inherent existence of the I is non distorted. It is a correct conception. These two being mutually incompatible and the awareness grasping at the inherent existent I being a distorted conception, not being based in reality. It is the wisdom which is able to overcome the falsely based awareness grasping at the inherent existent I.
It is the wisdom which is based in reality which has the power, the ability to overcome this totally falsely based misconception as to the nature of the I since it is correct and based in reality. Progressing to the development of the wisdom realizing the emptiness of the inherent existence of the I, First we begin by listening to the various teachings, gaining an expertise which explains the meaning of emptiness and reading various books. We then think about what we have heard. That is to say, we involve ourselves in reflection. And then we finally meditate upon it using various reasonings.
Again and again, bringing to mind our understanding of emptiness in terms of the I. We will generate a wisdom which then begins to understand that the I does not inherently exist. As the power of this understanding increases, that factor which is opposed to it, grasping at the true existence or the inherent existence of the I will begin to decrease. Since it is a distorted awareness which is not supported by reality. To the point where this wisdom is powerful enough whereby it is able to completely eliminate from its very root this distorted awareness grasping at the true existence or the inherent existence of the I.
An analogy would be that upon first coming into the room, the room is very cold. We turn on the heater. Initially, the heater puts out some heat but because of the extensiveness of the cold, the room still remains cold. But gradually, as the heater remains on, the room slowly begins to warm up and to a point it’s reached when the heat completely pervades the room. The coldness of the room has been completely eliminated and the room is hot.
So the cold is comparable to is analogous to grasping a true existence. The hot is analogous to the wisdom realizing emptiness. So if we meditate well in this way, refuting the inherent existence, refuting inherent existence, coming to understand emptiness, then we will generate the wisdom of understanding emptiness. And this is the entrance way into the doorway of ultimate happiness. Therefore, we must meditate on emptiness.
So it’s necessary to meditate on emptiness and we’re going to make use of various reasonings to approach our meditation on emptiness. We’re going to meditate in terms of first the reasoning establishing the non inherent existence of the I and then we’ll extend this to non inherent existence of phenomena. We begin with the eye because it is the I which it is due to the grasping that inherently existent I which keeps us bound within cyclic existence, which is the root of our suffering within cyclic existence. And therefore, is this since we want to be free of cyclic existence, it is initially we begin by refuting the inherent existence in terms of the I. So in the future we’ll be looking at reasoned analysis establishing emptiness and how to proceed in meditation, how to refute inherent existence through analytical reasoning.
So if you have some questions? Can you experience phenomena as true without having a sense of self? Can we see? Can you explain a little bit more? You experience this table without experiencing the table?
What do mean by experience the table? Okay, without seeing it in nature. No, in relation to oneself, just the table itself. Can you see the table? Without the thought of I arising.
So what I ask is, Can you experience the table without the thought of I arising while you’re experiencing the table? And he said, Yes. It’s not definite whether there would be karma created. So I ask if it’s necessary that the thought I arise in order to create karma. And he says, No.
For example, if you’re running very quickly to get somewhere, you’re not watching where you’re going, you step on an insect, you’re creating karma. But at that moment there’s no thought of I. But then if there’s no thought of I, then the karma arises straight from that. There’s no experience of I am having a good or a bad time or whatever like that, is there? The result of that karma?
So as a result of that ripening of that karma created, one would have a thought of I am suffering. So you might get a headache and you think, Ah, I’ve got a headache. Yeah, I understand that. What point are you at? If you’re not having a subjective experience, then the objective experience of heat or cold or any of those things doesn’t really have a whole lot of meaning, does it?
There’s no suffering arising or happiness. When? Without a sense of How? Of When a superior is in meditative equipoise on emptiness, that person is experiencing There’s no thought of I, but there’s feeling. To get to your point.
I guess I’m my point is that there’s no conception of an I. The problem is subject object experience. Just object experience isn’t a problem. What do you mean just our life experience? I and way the world, you know, I and experiencing the world.
It’s just only the experience. The Buddha has no thought of I but experiences bliss. Has the feeling of bliss. So the sentient beings are not inherently existent. They do experience various types of suffering.
You cut them with a knife or you throw a stone at them, it hurts. They experience suffering, experience fear. That is to say, by doing this to them, we cause them harm. And the essence of practicing Dharma is to abandon harming others. So though beings do not inherently exist, it doesn’t mean they don’t exist.
They exist but they don’t inherently exist. How do we avoid the negative karma involved in day to day activities such as clean housecleaning and personal hygiene with regards to dust mites and other microscopic life forms? So within your mind, when you’re sweeping, for example, thinking, If I see an insect, I’m not going to kill it. I don’t want to kill any insect. To be full fledged killing, it’s necessary that there be an intention to kill.
So if one has no intention to kill and one does not see, then it doesn’t constitute full fledged killing. I often get confused between the terminology of inherently existent, naturally existent and truly existent. Are these the same or is there some difference between them? Rangzhin drupa, Ranjung drupa, So the meaning is the same, the difference in terminology. So the meaning is the same, the terminology is different.
For example, this object in English we call it a flower. In Tibetan they call it a metok. So it’s the same object. It’s just the difference in terminology that we use to refer to it. So the same holds to these three different terms.
So, if you have some questions, please speak up. If not, we’re going to stop.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.