Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1992-07-28 – Side 2 – KR.MP3
UUID: 0546e70d-2bde-4256-9506-04d3c28ad351
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1992-07-28
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 40 min
Words: 2,046
Hello? So the third fault which would arise if the flower and the and the emptiness of the flower were identical would be just as just as with respect to the flower, there are the various parts such as the leaf stem petals, various colors, white, etcetera. Likewise, because emptiness of the flower is identical, then these would all exist with respect to emptiness. With respect to the emptiness of the flower, there would be the various petals, leaves, petal stem colors, white, etcetera. But in fact, the emptiness is an extremely subtle phenomenon.
It is a non product and therefore color and shape and form do not exist with respect to it. Then the fourth thought would be that the effort put forth by one who is striving for liberation by means of trying to realize emptiness would be meaningless because one can directly see the flower, then all of this effort to see emptiness is meaningless because the flower and emptiness would be the same. Because we can see the flower directly and because the emptiness of the flower and the flower are identical, we can just look and see the emptiness of the flower. We don’t have to go through a lot of meditation and make effort. So because these four faults would accrue if the emptiness and the form were the same entity, if they were the same, they accrued these four faults, then we can understand that they are not the same but they are different.
Though they are the same entity, they are different. They are distinct but same entity. They are not identical. They are not identical. They are different but same entity.
So these are excellent modes of reasoning to establish, to prove that the flower and the emptiness of the flower are not the same, that they are distinct, separate, different. So, though they are not identical, though these two, the flower and the emptiness of the flower, are not the same, they are in fact the same entity. Just as we said that the chili and hot flavor were the same entity. They are not different entities. But if we were to assert that the flower and the emptiness of the flower are different entities, that is to say that the flower is one entity and there is a different entity which is emptiness of the flower, that they are different, not the same entities, then four faults would accrue if we were to assert that.
If the flower and the emptiness of the flower were different entities, then as Rinpoche was demonstrating, we could set the flower here and we could set the bell, which represented the emptiness of the flower over here, and there would be no relationship. They would be unrelatedly different. They would be different entities. Okay. If the entities of emptiness of the flower and the flower were different, then what faults would arise?
We’re saying if they were unrelatedly different, then the wisdom realizing the emptiness of the flower would not be able to affect the conception which grasped at the true existence of the flower, that it would not be able to harm it. It would not be able to eliminate it. The realization of the emptiness of the flower would not be able to eliminate the conception which grasps at the true existence of the flower. They would be unrelated. If the realization of the emptiness of the flower was not able to affect the conception grasping at the true existence of the flower, then there would be no way in which we could destroy the conception grasping at the true existence of the flower.
If that being the case, if we are not able to destroy the conception grasping the true existence of the flower, then there’s no way we’re able to abandon that conception which grasping the true existence of the flower. Therefore, there would be no liberation and no Buddhahood. So if the flower and the emptiness of the flower were different entities, that would say there was no relationship between the two, then the realization of the emptiness of the flower would not be able to eliminate the conception, grasping at the true existence of the flower. But in fact, it is by means that due to the force of the realization of the emptiness of the flower being able to eliminate the conception, grasping at the true existence of the flower, that liberation is attained. That this realization of emptiness of the flower has the ability to remove from the very seed of the conception grasping at the true existence of the flower that we’re able to attain liberation.
And this is only because these two are operating on the same entity. Then on the other hand, at the place of the existence of the flower, there is the existence of the emptiness of the flower. At the place where there exists the flower, there exists the emptiness of a flower. At a place where there does not exist the flower, there cannot exist the emptiness of a flower. And the very existence of the flower, this is the key point, the very existence of the flower negates the true existence of the flower.
The flower is the basis of the negation of true existence. That is to say, the flower is the basis of emptiness. The basis of negation is the existence of the flower. If the flower didn’t exist, then the true existence of the flower couldn’t exist. If the flower didn’t exist, then there couldn’t be a truly existent flower.
If the flower didn’t exist, then there couldn’t be the emptiness of a truly existent flower. So if the flower didn’t exist, then there would be no basis to posit the emptiness. So it is only in terms of the existence of the flower that the emptiness is able to be posited, that emptiness is able to exist with respect to the flower. So the flower must exist for the emptiness of that flower to exist. So if if there are various faults which accrue if the if the the flower and the emptiness of the flower were different entities, if they were not the same entity.
So you should think about this, that in general, the nature of these two is that they are different but the same entity. So we have discussed these four characteristics in terms of form, but this will later on be spoken of in terms of the remaining four aggregates. That, these same four qualities that we’ve attributed to form is attributed to feeling, perceptions, mental constructions, and consciousnesses likewise. So we can proceed to apply these same four characteristics to the remaining four aggregates. Just as we have said that form is empty, we can go on to say that feelings are empty, perceptions are empty, mental constructions are empty, and consciousness is empty.
And likewise, when we say that emptiness is form, likewise we can go on to say that emptiness is feelings. Emptiness is perceptions. Emptiness is mental constructions. Emptiness is consciousnesses. And just as we said emptiness is no other than form, likewise we can go on to say that emptiness is no other than feeling.
It is no other than perceptions. Is no other than mental constructions. It is no other than consciousnesses. And just as we have said form is no other than emptiness, likewise, we can go on to say that feeling is no other than emptiness, that perceptions, mental constructions, and consciousnesses are no other than emptiness. So we can proceed in detail in our meditation in terms of the five aggregates in this way.
Also, can proceed in terms of, as we did in terms of form, that form does not naturally exist because it is dependent arising. That is to say, it arises dependent upon causes and conditions. We can apply that same reason to the remaining four aggregates. The aggregate of feelings does not naturally exist because it arises dependent upon causes and conditions, etcetera. We are proceeding in this way, these various forms of establishing an emptiness in terms of these various objects, implant extremely powerful dispositions to the eventual realization of the wisdom, understanding, emptiness.
It is like planting seeds. However much we’re able to plant seeds and implant extremely potent seeds, then to that same degree we’re going to come to an understanding of emptiness. That by implanting these powerful seeds of this realization, simply providing a very slight condition will be sufficient to gain a quick realization of dharma. And to the same With the same speed that we are able to generate the wisdom, realizing emptiness, to that same speed we will attain liberation. That is to say, will be able to completely eliminate our suffering.
So no one else can do this for us. It is the effort that each of us, each ourselves must make in order to attain liberation, in order to eliminate our suffering, that we can proceed by implementing the method of gaining the realization of the wisdom, understanding, and emptiness. But no one can do it for us. We have to do it ourselves. If we don’t implant the dispositions for the realization of emptiness, then we will never develop the wisdom realizing emptiness.
This isn’t the case if we do not plant a seed, then no sprouts will arise. If we do not make this effort, then we will remain forever in suffering. So it is only we as humans who can implant these seeds for the eventual realization of emptiness. But even that is not sufficient, just being human. We must have the meaning of emptiness set forth by a fully qualified teacher in order that the proper seed be implanted for its ultimate realization.
So, the essence of the teaching set forth in the heart of wisdom is the meaning of emptiness. Through this listening to this teaching, is an extremely wonderful opportunity to implant the seed of the wisdom in order to gain realization of emptiness. We’ll take a few minutes for questions. How about if I ask my first question and then it’ll solve this problem. Alright.
So emptiness cannot perform a function. It is permanent. In order to perform a function, it must be a thing, a product. I’ve got another question. If somebody wants to meditate on emptiness without specific motivation So it’s So it’s difficult to understand why someone would meditate well on emptiness simply without any particular motivation, an unspecified type of motivation, neither a skillful motivation nor an unskillful motivation.
The purpose of meditating on emptiness is to eliminate suffering, to find happiness. Out of that motivation, one would go on to make effort in meditation on emptiness. In order for it to become a cause for liberation, it has to be a skillful motivation. It can’t be something unspecified or neutral. So really that curiosity would not constitute meditation?
They constitute meditation. They are simply trying to gather knowledge in the sense of meditation, in the sense of cultivation, cultivating their mind, Something trying to gather knowledge. So they’re not the same. The emptiness of the table only exists with respect to the table and emptiness of the flower only exists with respect to the flower. Yeah.
Tonglen? So there are three types of wisdom. There’s the wisdom arising from listening, wisdom arising from reflecting, wisdom arising from meditation. And I think maybe I’ve gained a rough wisdom arising from listening. I haven’t gotten the other two yet.
So, whatever phenomena that we investigate, Whatever phenomena that we examine, upon examination, it is not found. This applies to all phenomena whatsoever. If it was findable upon analysis, it would have to truly exist. But when we don’t examine, when we don’t analyze, the object is found. So, when we don’t analyze the object, we can find it.
For example, where’s Jampa? Where’s Dale? Where are my shoes? My shoes are outside. But when we begin to analyze the object for the shoe, we don’t find it.
So when we don’t analyze, we are able to find it. When we analyze, we aren’t able to find it. This applies to all phenomena.
Key terms in this teaching
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.