Heart Sutra — 1992-06-09

Buddha House Adelaide

Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra — 1992-06-09
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1992-06-09 – Side 2 – KR.MP3

UUID: b3555a75-7cf4-47b3-afa0-34fd4bd4fd8b

Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche

Collection: Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 1992-06-09

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 40 min

Words: 2,109

Ordinarily, when we see the flower, the flower appears to be not posited by an awareness but to exist objectively by way of its own mode of abidance. To exist objectively from its own side. The flower appears not to be posited by the force of awareness but to exist objectively from its own side. This way of existing, this appearance is the object of negation. That’s not quite right.

So an object which is not posited by the force of awareness but exists objectively from its own side is the object of negation. In fact the flower is empty of that way of existing. It is this combination of this type of this way of appearing and the emptiness of this way of existing which constitutes illusion. Emptiness is very subtle. It’s difficult to understand.

So when we meditate on the emptiness of, say, the flower, we are trying to understand that the flower does not truly exist. That is to say, we are trying to understand that the flower is not objectively established from its own side, not being posited by the force of awareness. That it is empty of that way of existing. This is what we’re trying to understand. So if we try to refute this way of existing by means of reasoning, we would proceed by saying, If it in fact truly existed, if it truly exists then it must be either truly existently one or truly existently many.

If it is truly existent, the flower must be either truly existently one or it must be truly existently many. If it’s not truly existently one or truly existently many, then it doesn’t truly exist. If the flower were truly existent, it would not rely upon causes and conditions. For example, it would not rely upon seed, water, soil, etc. It would exist from its own side.

So from one point of view, the flower in fact does rely upon causes and conditions such as the seed, soil, and water. It needs these causes and conditions complete for its existence. But not only that, it must also be posited by an awareness. Cannot come into existence without being posited by the force of awareness. When we look at the flower, we are positing the flower thinking there’s a flower, there is a flower.

We’re positing the existence of that flower. We’re positing the flower. So when we see the flower, we are imputing. The flower is being imputed. In other words, designated, labeled by the awareness.

It’s labeled upon the leaves, the stems, the petals. Upon those, we label flower. A flower would not appear to us if we did not impute it. So initially someone thought of this object. What should we call this?

I think I’ll call it a flower. So this name giver gave the name flower initially to this object. Having been designated, labeled flower, when we see it, then there arises the we posit it as being a flower. So for a Tibetan, don’t call it a flower, they call it a mehtok. Someone came across this and they said, A Tibetan came across this.

They said, What should we call it? Let’s call it a metok. And so they applied this label, metok, to this object. Now when Tibetans see this object, they thought this is a metok arises in their mind. They label it.

The metok is being imputed by the force of their awareness. So whatever we call it initially, it’s necessary that it had been designated by means of a term. And depending on having been designated in that way, the awareness is able to posit that object in terms of that label. Its existence is posited in terms of that label that we’ve given this object. Without having done that, the object could not be posited.

So the existence of the flower comes about through being posited by the force of an awareness. The flower does not exist from its own side. If it did, then it would this is what we mean by way of it would exist truly existently. It would truly exist. If it existed that way, then if it was a flower from its own side without having ever been necessary to be called a flower, without having to be designated by an awareness, then even if someone didn’t know English, someone who doesn’t know English, when they saw this object the thought would arise in their mind, Ah, there’s a flower.

So a flower does not appear to the awareness of someone who does not know English? So it is necessary for an object’s existence that it be imputed by an awareness. For example, if in the case of a newly born child, if it were born to a Tibetan, and child’s just born, they look at what should we call it? Let’s think of a name. And then they give a name.

Let’s call it Tashi. So they designate it. They label it Tashi. And dependence upon being given that name, Tashi comes into existence. Before, having been given that name, Tashi didn’t exist.

And in the case of English speakers, there’s a newborn baby and what should we call it? That’s called Jim. So it depends upon the baby being called Jim, Jim comes into existence. Without having been labeled Jim, then Jim didn’t exist. Jim is dependent upon the labeling process.

So in dependence upon being labeled with a name or a term, the object comes into existence. The baby was given the name Jim. And in dependence upon that process of labeling and designating, the object came into existence, Jim. Now if Jim truly existed on the other hand, then immediately upon birth, whoever would see that baby would think, Ah, there’s Jim. Because his existence having been established in terms of that name, by having been labeled Jim.

Whenever we see Jim, it’s Oh here comes Jim. If in fact Jim was truly existent, then immediately upon birth immediately upon birth, then whoever would see that baby would think, Ah, there’s Jim. Whoever, immediate upon death, if Jim would if it were truly existently Jim, whoever saw that baby would say, Ah, there’s Jim. Without relying upon this labeling process. So all phenomena whatsoever are posited by means of an awareness in terms of labeling, being designated by an awareness, being posited by an awareness, being labeled by means of terms.

So if an object were not reliant upon being posited by an awareness, were not reliant upon being designated or labeled. It would be truly existent. It would not rely upon causes and conditions. It would not rely upon anything outside of itself. Due to the force of grasping a true existence, when the I appears, it appears not to rely upon the aggregates.

It appears not to rely upon being posited by an awareness. Acceding to that appearance, we then generate the various afflictive emotions. Out of those afflictive emotions, through the force of those afflictive emotions, we then create karma actions, negative actions. Out of those negative actions, we then experience resultant suffering. Due to the force of this misconception, we take rebirth again and again and again, going through the process of birth, old age, disease and death.

Birth, old age, disease and death. We keep circling in this cycle of existence and continually tortured by various sufferings and we are not able to attain the bliss of liberation. Emptiness is extremely important. Necessary to realize that the object being grasped at by the grasping of true existence does not exist. That this awareness which is grasping at true existence is a mistaken awareness.

This is brought about by developing the wisdom understanding emptiness. As our wisdom realizing emptiness increases, the force of our grasping at true existence will decrease more and more until it’s finally completely eliminated. With the elimination of grasping at true existence, then the very root of all of our suffering and our afflictive emotions is completely eliminated. Because by eliminating the root, the afflictive emotions and this grasping at true existence, then anything which grows out of that root, the various branches, are eliminated. Thereby we eliminate all that is a result of those roots.

That is birth, old age, disease, and death. Thereby we achieve a stable, unchanging bliss and peace of liberation which is completely divorced of any suffering. We have to carry on a meditation of making use of reason analysis as to whether things exist truly or not. Whether things are truly existent or not. In our meditation we should examine whether the object is not being posited by an awareness but is in fact established objectively by means of its own mode of subsistence.

Is that the case or not? We have to investigate using reasoning. This is the way we proceed with our meditation on emptiness. So if our meditation is to proceed well, we have to have steps in the process of our analysis. We have to think, What must I investigate first?

What must I investigate secondly? What must I investigate thirdly? What is the object which I’m trying to refute? In this process of reasoning, it’s two sided. There is something which is being negated on the one hand and something which is being established on the other.

In terms of we should think, Well, what is it I’m trying to negate? What is it I’m trying to refute? Is it or is it not truly existent? We have to investigate again and again refuting the object. As our ability to refute the object increases, forces of our understanding will increase.

And we will come to a definite determination as to the nonexistence of the object of negation. We will gain realization. Necessary to train. Whatever we’re involved in, if it is to go well, it’s necessary that we be accustomed, that we be familiar, that we be trained efficiently. And this requires effort.

So initially, we have to make effort in our training in order to ensure that it goes well. Having trained well, we will come to an understanding and we will gain the results of our training. And then we can make use of it. Is also in worldly terms. So whatever it is that we’re training our mind in, it will continue to improve day by day.

Today, our ability of the mind will increase. Tomorrow, the ability of our mind will have increased over today. It will then also be more developed one month from now, one year from now. And the potency of the mind is continually increasing. Mind has this capacity.

We can easily understand that. So in this process that we’re working through is where we’re contemplating and meditating. We’re trying to achieve a great result. We have a great goal. That is to say, stable happiness where there is no suffering.

And this is not easy. It’s a difficult goal to attain. Initially, when we haven’t trained in any type of work, is difficult. Whatever it might be. There arises the thought, Oh, this is hard.

I can’t do it. But we all understand from our reasoning and our own experience that everything that we initially do is going to involve this type of difficulty. Today we’ve been discussing the way of proceeding in meditation in terms of the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school. And we said that if something is truly existent, it must be either truly existent in one or truly existent in many. That is to say, if something is truly existent, it must exist as a singularity or as a multiplicity.

And we proceed in this way of meditation in order to come to understand its emptiness. So there are many benefits to be derived through proceeding in meditation on emptiness. But if we were to speak of the most prominent of these, there are three. Proceeding in this way of meditation, we will plant seeds. We’re planting the seeds of the eventual realization of emptiness.

That’s one. Secondly, we are accumulating a great deal of merit or virtuous actions. That’s two. And the third is that we are harming our grasping at true existence. We are damaging our grasping at true existence.

So there are these three benefits, major benefits. From the next teaching onward, we’ll be talking about emptiness in terms of the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school. So if you have some questions, you can ask questions. It’s But it didn’t come into someone’s awareness in about 1937, I think. Does that mean that since people were unaware of Pluto before 1937, it didn’t exist?

Key terms in this teaching

Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top