Heart Sutra — 1992-06-02

Buddha House Adelaide

Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra — 1992-06-02
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 1992-06-02 – Side 2 – KR.MP3

UUID: a173b1e9-9856-496f-aa14-7e49f6522c1a

Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche

Collection: Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 1992-06-02

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45 min

Words: 2,747

The I cannot appear to the mind. That is to say, without the five aggregates appearing and dependent upon the appearance of those five aggregates, the I is then designated. So without the five aggregates first appearing to the mind there’s no basis for designating I. We have to consider how the I appears to the mind. In proceeding in our meditation on emptiness, we’re going to make use of a four point analysis.

And the first of these four points is identifying the object of negation. Then we have to identify the pervasion or the entailment. Thirdly, we have to identify whether the I is truly existently one. And fourthly, whether the I is truly existently many. What do we mean by emptiness?

The word in Tibetan is tongpa nyi. Nyi. Tongpa, this word tongpa simply means empty. That is to say, it’s a negation of other. It’s a nonexistence of something.

The negation of something. The nonexistence of something. Like, If I don’t have anything in my hand, I say, My hand is empty. If I don’t have any money in my purse, I say, My purse is empty. If I don’t have any food in my stomach, I say, My stomach is empty.

If there’s no people in this room, we say the room is empty. So it denotes the non existence of something. So empty denotes a nonexistent factor, something that doesn’t exist. For example, we say my purse is empty, there’s a non existent factor of money. When we say I’m hungry, that’s a non existent factor within the stomach.

Say my stomach is empty, there’s a non existent factor of food. In order to understand emptiness we must understand what is the non existent factor. What factor is not existing? What factor doesn’t exist? Without understanding what doesn’t exist then we can’t understand, without identifying what doesn’t exist, we cannot ascertain emptiness.

For example, in today’s teaching there’s one student and Buddha House his name is Doc. Okay? So we say, Is Doc here today? Now if someone knows who Doc is, he’s got this big round belly, and we say, Someone is able to recognize doc. They just simply look around, No, doc is not here today.

But if somebody doesn’t know doc, doesn’t recognize doc, then they can look around all day long and they’re not going to be able to say whether doc is here or they’re teaching or not. So we have to be able to identify what is nonexistent. And what is nonexistent is what we mean by the object of negation. However much we look, if we don’t know what is nonexistent then we’re never going to know whether it exists or not. For example, in the case of a thief.

But not only do we have to be able to know, we have to be able to recognize it precisely. In the case of a thief, you know, they say, Somebody stole something and we say, Well the thief wears white clothing. There are many people who wear white clothing. So when the thief wears white clothing, it would just create some kind of doubt. We wouldn’t be able to catch the thief because there would be many individuals who would wear white clothing So there would be a doubt as to who it actually was.

So we have to be able to identify precisely if we’re going to actually catch the thief. It’s not necessary to know it roughly. So just as if we were going to shoot an arrow at a target, we have to know exactly what our target is if we’re ever going to hit it. So it’s not to say that we identify very precisely what is the object of negation. You know, if we were to we can present an analogy between our understanding of emptiness using this thief, if we simply say that the thief wore white clothing.

That simple general identification of the thief would be analogous to saying emptiness is the nonexistence of true existence. Emptiness is the nonexistence of true existence. We really haven’t identified the thief. We really haven’t identified what emptiness is. If we’re going to identify the thief, we have to know precisely.

Otherwise it’s simply going to remain in doubt. It will remain unfocused. Likewise, to simply think, Oh, I think emptiness is the nonexistence of true existence, really isn’t to be able to identify what we actually mean by emptiness. Recognizing the object of negation is the most important point in coming to an understanding of emptiness. We have to identify well this object of negation.

If we identify it well, then upon examination we can come to a quick understanding whether it exists or not. If we don’t identify it well we’re never going to be able to ascertain well, we’re never going to be sure whether the object negation exists or not. It’s just like in the case of being able to know what the target is in order to be able to hit it. We have to recognize, identify the object of negation. We not only recognize it in terms of reasoning, not merely in terms of reasoning, but we should recognize it in reliance upon our own experience.

How is the object of negation being held within my own mind? What You know, we have within our minds self grasping. We have a conception of true existence. We have grasping at the object negation. And it’s extremely powerful.

It’s extremely stable. Due to the fact of this grasping at the object of negation, that is said, having this conception of true existence, we generate attachment, we generate hatred, we generate pride. Out of these very afflictive emotions we engage in various actions. We create karma. Out of this, we experience suffering.

So the root of all of this is within our own mind. It’s very stable. It’s very powerful. This self grasping is like a companion who’s always with us. So we all all of us have an instinctive conception of I.

The I instinctively appears to the mind. It appears to all of our minds. And we have to try to observe that I and examine its appearance. How does that I appear to us? So in general the I exists.

The I which goes, the I which sleeps, the I which eats, which talks, which meditates. In general, there does exist the I which is designated, labeled to the five aggregates. So if we expand upon this a little bit, there are three ways in which the I appears. That is to say, there are three types of conceptions of I. Three types of conceptions of I.

So there are three ways in which the I can appear to the mind. That is, there are three types of conceptions of the I. The first type of conception, the way of appearance, is the way the I appears to a person who has realized emptiness. That is someone who has generated the correct view of emptiness. Because the I generally exists, then even for such a person who having realized emptiness, the I still appears because it exists.

The appears. The way that I appears toward that person, that’s the first way of manner of appearance. The second is for a person, an ordinary person who is not involved in an examination, an investigation as to the nature of the I, as to whether the I truly exists or whether it naturally exists. Just the I which is arising to this ordinary person, the way it appears toward an ordinary person not involving investigation of the nature of the I. That second way of appearing of the I.

The third way is when examining, investigating as to whether the I is self defining or naturally existent or not. And there is a conception which holds that the I is truly existent or naturally existent or self defining. That third way of appearing of the I. So with respect to this first way of appearance of the eye, that is to say the way the eye appears to someone who has realized emptiness. For them the I appears to be merely imputed by awareness and is qualified by not truly existing.

So the I appears to be merely imputed by awareness and qualified or characterized by being not truly existent. That’s the way the I appears for such an individual, for that particular individual. Then the I as it appears to an individual who is not involved in analysis as to whether the I is self defining or whether it’s not self defining. The I appears even to animals. That the animal thinks to go eat an insect or to steal some food.

This conception of I appears. An I appears to even animals. For most of us the I appears and it’s not in terms of whether it’s being analyzed as to its being self defining or not self defining. It is the I which walks, the I which talks, etc. This is the way the I appears to such a type of an individual.

Then, so this the I which is ourselves, the I which is conceived of as ourselves. This is the I which works, the I which eats, the I which goes. This type of I, which we’ve just described with respect to the second type of person, also appears to the first type of person, even to a person who has realized emptiness. This I as the self appears to that individual also. But then there’s the third type of I, the I which appears to someone who accedes to the self defining I.

This I which appears to be a self defining I or a naturally existing I. And this is the object of negation, the truly existing I. This I does not exist. So the I which is appearing to this third individual is the I which is the object of negation. This I, imputed upon observing the five aggregates, the I appears.

I there’s two different schools which we’re going to discuss this in terms of. Autonomy Middle Way School and the Consequentialist Middle Way School. Tonight we’re going to discuss it only in terms of the Autonomy Middle Way School. So the way that this I appears in terms of the Autonomy Middle Way School appears as follows. It appears to be not posited by the force of awareness but to be objectively established by way of its own mode of subsistence.

It appears to be not posited by way of awareness but to be objectively established by means of its own mode of subsistence. That’s the way this I appears. So Talking about the way the I appears is this third type of awareness. It appears to be not posited by the force of awareness but to be objectively established by means of its own mode of subsistence. And what does that mean by way of its own mode of subsistence?

It appears to be independent in terms of the collection of the five aggregates, appears to the I, appears to exist independently, not dependent upon other than itself. So in terms of the collection of five in those terms, in terms of the collection of five aggregates, the I appears to not depend upon other, to exist independently. Then there arises a conception which accedes to that appearance thinking, Ah, that’s the way it is. That’s the way it exists. This conception which accedes to that appearance and grasps to this as in fact the way the object exists is self-grasping, mis-knowing, ignorance, the awareness which is grasping at the object of negation.

We have to recognize this object negation within our own experience. But it’s quite difficult to ascertain this because it does not appear clearly to us. The way in which we’re grasping at this object of negation, the I. Now what is the method whereby we can make it to appear clearer to ourselves? We can generate a sense of great happiness, a sense of great suffering, when we have great fear.

In those occasions when there’s great emotional experiences, a great liking or disliking, then at those moments we examine. It is at these moments when this conception is operating at its strongest, when the object of negation is appearing at its clearest. This is the method whereby we can gain an actual appearance, experience of how it appears. So for example, someone calls us says harsh words to us. And we we begin to generate anger.

It is at the moment of generating anger that the object of negation appears clearest to us. I should have said that this is when the conception, grasping at the I, is most forceful and the I appears the clearest. One method of practice is a practice called Chö. Chö. Chö.

That is a method whereby to method which is used to be able to recognize the conception grasping at the I. Recognizing the object of negation is the most difficult aspect of coming to an understanding of emptiness. We have to make a great effort in being able to identify the object of negation. Once we identify the object in negation, then we simply apply a reasoned analysis and we can come to an immediate understanding that in fact it doesn’t exist. Why haven’t we understood emptiness up to now?

Because we haven’t properly identified the object negation. Then identifying the object and negation is the doorway into understanding emptiness. So just as in the case if we were to close the gate out here in front of Buddha House, would be no way you could enter. You couldn’t gain access to Buddha House. Likewise, of these four, the doorway into understanding emptiness is the first, recognizing the object of negation.

This is the gateway into the understanding. And by means of this coming into the doorway and in the latter three points, then we can come to an in a gradual manner, we can come to an understanding of emptiness. So we’ll take a few minutes for questions. I’ll drink tea. So, it’s necessary to refute the object of negation.

The object of negation is the non existent factor. This is what phenomena are empty of. Phenomena are empty of the object of negation, this non existent factor. Emptiness is a negation. It is a non affirming negation of a nonexistent factor.

So just as in the case if we were very sick and we took medicine. While we’re sick, we’re suffering. And by means of taking medicine, we’re able to eliminate the suffering. What is being negated, what is being got rid of is the suffering. And what is promoted is well-being.

What we’re seeking to negate is what appears to be not posited by way of awareness but which exists objectively from its own side. This is the nonexistent factor and we have to negate its existence. We negate that it exists. This object we’re negating here is the subtle object of negation. This is what we mean by subtle emptiness.

There are varying degrees of subtlety of the object negation. There are the coarse object negation and the subtle object negation. So there are two levels of object negation. The object negation is posited by the autonomy of Middle Way School and that which is posited by the Consequentialist Middle Way School. The one posited or asserted by the Autonomy Middle Way School is coarser and therefore it more easily appears to one’s mind than the one which is posited by the Consequentialist Middle Way School, which is more difficult because it is more subtle.

Therefore, because there are two levels of object of negation, there are correspondingly two levels of emptinesses, a coarse emptiness and a subtle emptiness. And the Buddha taught these two levels in accordance with the level of intelligence of the students. For those of middling intelligence, he presented the object of negation in terms of the Autonomy Middle Way School. If he had presented the more subtle version of negation to them, they would not have been able to understand it. But those of the highest intelligence, he taught the object of negation in terms of the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school and means in his explaining of the Dharma.

Whatever would be a benefit to a particular disciple, he explained it in those terms.

Key terms in this teaching

Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top