Grounds and Paths

1 h 43 min · 2,671 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 103-minute seminar, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen guides students through the Mahāyāna paths of seeing and meditation as understood in Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka philosophy. He begins by defining these paths in terms of what they abandon: imputed and innate obstructions to omniscience. He then explains the distinction between imputed phenomena—those created by thought or cultural consensus, like the Buddhist concepts of rebirth and the mental continuum—and innate phenomena, which arise naturally in the mind such as anger, desire, pride, and jealousy. The core teaching distinguishes how afflictions are abandoned: only afflicted doubt is cast off on the path of seeing, while desire, anger, pride, and ignorance are progressively abandoned during the path of meditation through subtle subdivisions of the innate grasping at true existence. Extended Q&A follows, exploring whether anger and desire can be non-conceptual consciousnesses and how conceptual afflictions like self-cherishing generate experiential mental states. Intended for serious Buddhist students studying tenets and the progressive stages of the spiritual path.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 15112016salam – KR.mp3

UUID: 3f24bb74-9efa-41af-9f61-21a216e8c33c

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Grounds and Paths

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,675

So when we wish to define Mahāyāna paths of seeing and of meditation, They are defined as respectively Mahāyāna paths of seeing of Mahāyāna paths of the clear realization of truth and for the Mahāyāna path of meditation, Mahāyāna paths of the subsequent realization of truth, one just adds the term Mahāyāna to clear realization. So the differentiation between the Mahāyāna paths of seeing and of meditation is made in terms of their respective abandonments. The abandonments on the Mahāyāna path of seeing are the abandonments of the path of seeing and those on the Mahāyāna path of meditation are the abandonments of the Mahāyāna path of meditation. First and foremost, these are the obstructions to omniscience or Jñeyāvarana and in Buddhist treatises the obstructions to omniscience are defined as that which interferes with the attainment of the state of omniscience. So here the abandonments of the Mahāyāna path of seeing are imputed abandonments and the abandonments of the Mahāyāna path of meditation are innate abandonments.

So here’s the distinction between the imputed abandonments of the path of seeing and the innate abandonments of the path of meditation can best be understood as follows. Imputed phenomena are typically phenomena which are artificial. For instance, this table, the cup, this building, these are all phenomena which have not existed from the beginning in this way. They are made, they are made of matter. Now regarding innate phenomenon, the term innate in Tibetan, in Sanskrit refers to phenomena which are not manufactured such as for instance water in general or air, wind and so forth.

Now when we apply the terms imputed and innate, which we explained in a general context to the mental continuum, things become very elegant. If we take the case of the mental continuum for instance and the position regarding this depends on schools of tenets. Past and future lives are said to be my past life and my future life. Now, not everyone accepts the existence of past and future lives. So, on the other hand, there are other religions which consider that this world and all the beings within it are created by God, by a creator.

This position is not accepted by Buddhism. Therefore, these views are said to be or imputed. Likewise, the existence of a mental continuum is not accepted by all. For that same reason, it is said to be or imputed. Now, when the term innate is applied to events in the mental continuum, it applies to mental events such as anger, desire, spite, jealousy, competitiveness.

These are all innate within our mental continuum. These are not something which arises in dependence on tenets. For instance, we will say, I’m not terribly prone to anger, but he is. However, on my side, I’m prone to spite or jealousy. In other words, we all accept the existence of these afflictions and these afflictions are abandonments of the path of meditation.

So, therefore when we apply these terms innate and imputed to the mental continuum, things become very interesting. If we take for instance, the various paths, the path of accumulation, of preparation, and so forth, which are explained in the Buddhist treatises. While we ourselves accept their existence, non Buddhists do not accept their existence. Therefore, these would probably be imputed and you can see therefore that the category of imputed phenomena related to the mental continuum is quite large. Then there are numerous subdivisions in the context of imputed mental phenomena such as consciousness, affirmative phenomena, negative phenomena and these are things we should study quietly.

So at present regarding the distinction between imputed abandonments of the path of seeing and innate abandonments of the path of meditation, we must progressively describe this. So regarding the five root afflictions, which are desire, anger, pride, ignorance, and afflicted doubt, we have to ask ourselves which are abandonments of the path of seeing and which are abandonments of the path of meditation. Now within these five, only afflicted doubt is an abandonment of the path of seeing. The remaining four are abandonments of the path of meditation. So, therefore, only afflicted doubt would be an abandonment of the path of seeing and the remaining would be abandonments of the path of meditation.

Now within these, which are sensory consciousnesses and which are which are non sensory consciousnesses in your opinion? Desire, anger, pride. Ignorance, and afflicted doubt. So Andy’s answer is the right one. The three following afflictions which are afflicted doubt, pride and ignorance are necessarily conceptual.

And the other two, in other words, anger and desire can also be non conceptual, can also be sensory. And we should also reflect on the fact that within these five only afflicted doubt is an abandonment of the path of seeing, the remaining four are abandonments of the path of meditation. Very boring, you know. If you say then I’m very worried. So all of these five are consciousnesses.

I would like to think no one in this room will say that they are matter or form. I would be very annoyed. Then within these five, some are sensory consciousnesses and some are mental consciousnesses. Now regarding the distinction between the innate apprehension of true existence and the imputed apprehension of true existence. When we observe objects such as the stand in front of Geshe-la and through numerous lines of reasoning, we justify to ourselves the notion that the stand is established from its own side, is truly established.

And here we are speaking for the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, then that is grasping at the imputed true existence of the stand. On the other hand, when merely perceiving the stand or the cup, it seems to us as existing from its own side without further analysis. That is the innate grasping at the true existence of the stand or the cup. So as we said, there are therefore abandonments of the path of seeing and abandonments of the path of meditation. The abandonments of the path of seeing are the imputed apprehension of true existence and the abandonments of the path of meditation are the innate apprehension of true existence.

Their respective antidotes for the path of seeing are the wisdom realizing emptiness. So now for the path of meditation, the abandonment of the path of meditation is the innate apprehension of true existence. This innate apprehension of true existence is subdivided into 10. We have the great, middling and lesser, innate apprehension of true existence, each of which is subdivided into three. The great is subdivided into the greater, middling, and lesser.

The middling into the greater, middling, and lesser. And the lesser into the greater, middling, and lesser. And the final lesser apprehension of true existence is subdivided into two, the coarse and the subtle innate apprehension of true existence which makes 10. So the reason for this complex subdivision of the object of abandonment of the path of meditation is that most probably every consciousness we have is able to gain a realization of emptiness and this can act as an antidote to a level of apprehension of true existence. So at present regarding the five afflictions which are not the view, which were mentioned.

In other words, desire, anger, pride, ignorance, and afflicted doubt. It is really helpful to us to reflect carefully which of these are sensory consciousnesses and which of these can only be mental consciousnesses. As was explained, pride, ignorance and afflicted doubt can only be mental consciousnesses, whereas desire and anger can be sensory consciousnesses. And we should analyze to see why this is the case. So we have to analyze carefully for instance why both anger and pride are abandonments of the path of meditation.

Is it possible to have anger once one has entered the path of meditation? Probably not. Probably what is referred to here is the abandonment of the seeds or the potencies of anger within the mental continuum. So let us now reflect during a couple of minutes on why the three afflictions non related to the view which are pride, ignorance and afflicted doubt can only be conceptual consciousnesses. In other words, whatever is one of these three is necessarily a conceptual consciousness.

During a couple of minutes. Page five. Number six, mandala offering. Verse one and three. So please ask your questions at present.

Short and concise questions. Can Geshe-la tell us again about the desire, anger, pride, ignorance and afflicted doubt? Is it which one is the non conceptual and which one is conceptual? So, pride, ignorance, and afflicted doubt are only conceptual. Then, desire and anger can either be non conceptual or conceptual.

So the way to look at it is as follows. If we take anger and desire, why are they non conceptual? How can they be non conceptual? And if we take pride, ignorance, and afflicted doubt, how why can they be must they be conceptual? So we can understand how sensory consciousnesses can have anger or desire, through the following example.

We could take the visual or the auditory consciousness, maybe let us set the auditory consciousness aside for now and take the visual consciousness. How is it possible for the visual consciousness to have anger? Well, we can see when we ourselves are angry in general that we become flushed and red. And actually our eyes are no longer of the same color. They become red as well.

In other words, the visual organ is affected by anger. Yes. They can arise but there’s no necessity. Okay. You can.

Both are conceptual, neither is nonconceptual. And another question. Okay. Was said last week that once we are able to dispel this ignorance, we will be able to know all objects of knowledge. And then it was said that that which dispels such ignorance is its opposite, that its opposite was not great compassion or bodhicitta but the wisdom realizing emptiness.

But then it was later said that the object of attainment, full and utter enlightenment, its cause was conventional bodhicitta. So I’m trying to understand it was first that the cause was not great compassion of bodhicitta but the wisdom, realizing emptiness and then it was said to be conventional bodhicitta as the cause of full enlightenment. Both method and wisdom are necessary to attain full and utter enlightenment. It is not possible to attain enlightenment in dependence on method alone. In other words, in dependence on great compassion or bodhicitta.

Otherwise, if this was the case, then the moment one had attained the path of accumulation of the Mahāyāna, one would have attained full and utter enlightenment. Likewise, the wisdom realizing emptiness is not sufficient in and of itself to attain full and utter enlightenment. Otherwise, hearers would attain full and utter enlightenment which they do not. Yeah. The latent potencies of anger that remain at the level of the path of meditation, how can these latent potencies be conceptual and latent potencies necessarily a non conceptual minds?

So, potencies are not consciousnesses. Anger is a consciousness. Now, once anger has dissipated, there remains in the mind the activity, the trace, the potency of anger. This is not a consciousness. It is a non-associated compositional phenomena in the mental continuum.

Let us examine our present situation. In your minds at present I assume there is no anger. In my mind at present there is certainly no anger. Now, we say that in general, we have no anger? No.

How does anger arise within our minds? Anger arises from the potencies or the traces of anger within the mind, and therefore we cannot say that the continuum of anger is severed. Geshe-la, I’m struggling to understand how desire and anger can be sensory consciousness because both depend on ignorance which is conceptual. So, that is not difficult here when we speak of ignorance. What are we talking about the motivation which is conceptual?

Then motivations can be higher or lower motivations. From a lower base motivation, anger can arise. But the source is ignorance which is conceptual and Geshe-la, you referred to the face being flushed etcetera, the physical appearance but then one could say the same thing about pride that we talk about somebody having their chest puffed out or that’s conceptual but there’s a physical appearance. I’m not sure if that’s what Geshe-la is saying that the physical appearance of anger is non conceptual because to be angry you have to define or impute enemy onto somebody or a difficult circumstance. The same with desire, you have to say that is something to be attracted to and that has a conceptual basis to it.

You do all that when you desire something. So then I let you discuss whether pride is exclusively conceptual or not as your doubt indicates. And then regarding the arising of afflictions from sensory consciousnesses, afflictions such as desire or anger, the excuse me, from conceptions. The best way to understand this is reflecting on self-cherishing. in dependence on self-cherishing, both anger and desire arise.

Now, self-cherishing is conceptual. Yes. One question here. Can you give an example of sensory consciousness that involves desire? Then the example I could give you is that of looking at the food while one is enjoying a beautiful meal.

One looks at the very tasty food, then there is desire. When Geshe-la answered the question before, I got a little bit confused. For desire and anger, Geshe-la said it’s actually generated by self-cherishing and self-cherishing is actually a conceptual mind. And I just wondering how can conceptual mind of self-cherishing generate a non conceptual desire and anger? So I think your doubts arise from a confusion between substantial causes and conditions.

If we take the example of planting rice in this world, then when you plant rice, rice has one uncommon cause which is the grain of rice. That’s the substantial cause of the sprout of rice. But that substantial cause alone will not give rise to a sprout of rice. You need in addition numerous conditions, manure, sunlight, water and so forth. Now, is the same thing in the generation of anger from self-cherishing.

self-cherishing, which is a conceptual mind, is not the substantial cause of anger, but it is the condition of anger. So I think your confusion arises from the lack of distinction between causes and conditions. So phenomena to arise need a substantial cause, but that is not sufficient. They need conditions which are unrelated to that substantial cause and self-cherishing would be a condition for the arising of anger. Do you understand?

Okay. So in our case, as you see, we have numerous causes and conditions. Then your viewpoint at least those that widespread in the West is that your father and mother are your uncommon cause, your substantial cause. This is a profoundly wrong view. Very, 100%.

These are merely conditions. Your parents are conditions. So this is something we have to study. Our parents are not our substantial cause. Our parents are merely conditions.

Our substantial cause is our mental continuum. Could Geshe-la give an example of desire and anger, the non conceptual example and the ex and the conceptual Mhmm. So for non conceptual anger, I would give the case of the eye consciousness once one is possessed by anger, once face has become red, the eyes have become bright red, one sees things differently. Then for conceptual anger, I would give the case of an angry motivation towards an enemy. That is conceptual.

So at present discussion by pairs as usual. Please discuss why the five afflictions non related to the view which are desire, anger, pride, ignorance, and afflicted doubt can be subdivided into three which are conceptual that is anger, excuse me, that is ignorance, afflicted doubt and pride and two which are non conceptual or conceptual and that is desire and anger and discuss why. Mhmm. Okay. Necessary and sufficient conditions.

Sufficient condition Page nine.

Key terms in this teaching

grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is wisdom realizing emptiness or conventional bodhicitta the cause of full enlightenment, or is great compassion alone not enough?

Both method and wisdom are necessary to attain full and utter enlightenment. Enlightenment cannot be attained in dependence on method alone, that is, on great compassion or bodhicitta alone. If it could, then the moment one attained the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one would attain full and utter enlightenment. Likewise, the wisdom realizing emptiness is not sufficient in and of itself. If it were, hearers would attain full and utter enlightenment, which they do not.

How can self-cherishing, which is a conceptual mind, give rise to anger and desire, which are non-conceptual?

The doubt comes from confusing substantial causes with conditions. Take rice: the grain of rice is the uncommon, substantial cause of the sprout, but it alone does not produce a sprout. Conditions such as manure, sunlight and water are also needed. Anger arises in the same way. Self-cherishing, a conceptual mind, is not the substantial cause of anger but a condition for it. For phenomena to arise they need a substantial cause plus conditions that are unrelated to that cause. In the same way, our parents are merely conditions, not our substantial cause, and the widespread Western view that they are is called profoundly wrong. Our substantial cause is our mental continuum.

What are examples of nonconceptual and conceptual anger (and desire)?

For nonconceptual anger, the example given is an eye consciousness when one is possessed by anger. The face has become red, the eyes have become bright red, and one sees things differently. For conceptual anger, the example given is an angry motivation towards an enemy, which is conceptual.

Scroll to Top