Grounds and Paths

1 h 35 min · 3,912 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 95-minute talk, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen guides students through foundational Buddhist practice with unusual depth and candor, opening with the proper motivation for Dharma study: uncontrived bodhicitta, or—if that is too difficult—a contrived wish to benefit all beings. He then unpacks why the preliminary meditations matter more than they first appear. Working through the eight leisure conditions and ten endowments that define a precious human rebirth, he does not simply list them but invites listeners to honestly audit whether they possess all of them. He probes a subtle difficulty: if lower rebirths cannot attain the path of accumulation, how do beings in hell escape? He then moves to meditation on death and impermanence, distinguishing between two kinds of fear—one that paralyzes, one that motivates ethical discipline and aspiration for better rebirths. Throughout, he connects these seemingly abstract preliminaries to the five paths and the ultimate goal of liberation, and closes with sustained Q&A that reveals how the Tibetan monastic colleges debate fine points of text. Suited for practitioners with some background in Lamrim study or those encountering Buddhist soteriology for the first time.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 01-700101_1005-01.mp3

UUID: 397d3386-798a-45fb-b826-eb6fe4c25c9d

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Grounds and Paths

Date: 1970-01-01

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,912

So in this context both for teaching and explaining Dharma, the motivation in this context cannot be one’s own benefit. The ideal motivation is to have a motivation which apprehends the teachings with an uncontrived bodhicitta. Alternatively, should this not be generated, it is acceptable to have a contrived motivation of bodhicitta. So one might confuse the motivation on the one hand and bodhicitta on the other and therefore to clarify this somewhat, the goal which one is aiming for is that state of the two bodies of a Buddha which is being attained for the benefit of all sentient beings as vast as space. So, the motivation is that wish aiming for that state.

Motivation on the other hand is that motivation or that wish to engage in the practice of the beings of the three scope with bodhicitta having apprehended it. This must be a motivation engaged with at 100%. Please generate for the following two minutes as usual such a motivation. As a holy being Chekawa said, practice the preliminaries. This profound statement refers to the fact that although the main topic of the treatise we are studying, which is the three principal aspects of the path.

In other words, definite emergence, bodhicitta and the correct view. Nonetheless, it is necessary to practice preliminaries before engaging in these. The preliminaries are specifically meditation on the precious human rebirth through identifying the precious human rebirth, understanding its great importance and its rarity, meditating on death and impermanence and on karma and causality. Once one has trained correctly in the preliminaries, in other words, the identification of the precious human rebirth, understanding its great import and its rarity, meditating on death and impermanence, on the disadvantages of samsaric existence and on karma and causality, it is then easy to generate renunciation bodhicitta in the correct view. However, before understanding those preliminaries, in other words before understanding the precious human rebirth, karma and causality, death and impermanence and so forth, one needs to have profound faith in the triple gem.

One must have a deep rooted conviction in the existence of past and future lives and one must have some sort of an understanding of karma. Otherwise, it is impossible to gain real benefit from the preliminaries. Geshe-la explained the distinction between practice during the session and practice between sessions and within the session between the heading or the beginning, the middle and the conclusion of the session as well as the applications to be engaged in during the session. If you do not understand the applications, it might be good to inquire during the question and answer session. And therefore initially after resting upon a comfortable seat, one should reflect on the fact that the body we have obtained at present arises from mind and that mind is under the power of the afflictions.

The afflictions themselves find their origin in the innate apprehension of an inherent existence of self which has led us to the predicament we are in at present. And therefore, initially, we want our mind no longer to be under the control of desire, of ignorance and of pride. Then we wish to gain the capacity to set our mind on whichever object we set it on with the firmness of Mount Meru. And finally, we wish to be able to send our mind or focus our mind on whichever virtuous object we wish to focus it upon. So our goal is to withdraw the mind inside whereas until now it had been constantly running to the outside.

And if we were to focus the mind for instance on identifying the precious human rebirth, then to focusing it well on this topic, the mind can indeed be withdrawn from exterior objects within. So if what we think is meditation involves crossing our legs in full lotus and sitting there blissing out, Geshe-la suspects that most probably our mind will instantaneously start wandering out and being distracted. Therefore, the way of training the mind is to choose a focus and to focus the mind well and stably on this focus. For instance, on the identification of the precious human rebirth. So when we speak of training the mind, the term is the same as study in Tibetan.

What we mean by training the mind is taking the example of identifying the precious human rebirth, identifying the eight leisures and the 10 endowments. Regarding the eight leisures, we refer to them as leisure or dalwa in Tibetan because it is a state of leisure or of freedom which enables us or which gives us all the outer and inner conditions for the practice of Dharma and enables us to practice. And to understand the eight leisures, we must understand the eight states which are incompatible or at odds with this. These eight states are being reborn in the three lower realms, being reborn in a far off land, being reborn as a barbarian, being reborn as a long life deity, being reborn as physically or mentally defective, and being reborn with wrong views. These are the eight incompatible conditions with the eight leisures.

The eight leisures are the opposite thereof. And therefore, how would one proceed? One would first reflect carefully on these eight incompatible states and after reflecting on these reflect on the eight absences which are the states of leisure and this one’s mind goes through these over and again. Geshe-la suspects that there is nothing else than this which can be posited as meditation. So these three lower realms are self evident.

As for the far off or barbarian lands in Tibetan, Geshe-la suspects these are lands inhabited mainly by animals. Fourth incompatible state is often called that of a barbarian. This actually refers, you would say in Australia to a bogan. Someone living in the countryside or in a village who is totally uninterested in anything. Regarding the sixth inappropriate or discordant state, it is that of rebirth as a long life god.

This is somewhat difficult to explain to you. Basically it refers to rebirth as a divine being. There are multiple divisions of these into the realms of the gods of the desire form and formless realms but specifically many of the gods, the gods actually of the form and formless realms are reborn there as a result of dhyana, of concentration and stay in non conceptual states throughout their entire life. In such lives, there is no possibility for any practice. The seventh discordant state is literally called that of one with incomplete organs.

In other words, someone who is physically or mentally defective. To practice Dharma, we need to have the appropriate sense organs. Without eyes, without ears, we are unable to study or to listen to teachings. The final leisure is that of lacking wrong views. Wrong views here specifically refer to innate wrong views.

We have at present many acquired wrong views and these innate wrong views refer above all to disbelief in the triple gem and disbelief in karma and causality. And therefore, the eight leisures are the absence of these eight discordant states. It is being endowed with the full conditions which these eight discordant states are absent of. The 10 endowments in turn are subdivided into two, five endowments from one’s own side and five endowments from the side of others. And within the five endowments, the first endowment is being reborn as a human being.

The second endowment is being reborn in a central land. There are several definitions in the text of a central land. The first is a land in which the holy dharma is present. The second is one in which there are followers of the dharma. The third is a land in which there are 10 members of Sangha or even according to some texts 20.

The third endowment from one’s own side is having complete organs. Geshe-la suspects this has the same meaning as the seventh freedom, the freedom from being physically and mentally defective. The fourth endowment from one’s own side is not having wrong views. And the fifth is having faith in the base. The base here refers to the triple gem.

And the five last endowments are the five endowments from the standpoint of others. The first of these is that a Buddha has come. We live at present in an age during which a Buddha has come. The Buddha Śākyamūni has taught. The second endowment is that the Dharma still exists.

This is the case nowadays. The third endowment is, excuse me, the second endowment is that he taught the Dharma. This is the case. The third endowment is that the dharma still exists, this is the case nowadays. The fourth endowment is that there are practitioners or followers of this dharma.

And the fifth endowment is that love and compassion are still present. These are the love and compassion which wish to free beings from suffering. So Geshe-la had already broached this topic last time and had given the root quote. He therefore suspected you should have a fairly good understanding of the topic by now. So Geshe-la thinks it would be great benefit if we carefully reflected for five minutes on whether from our side or not we have fulfilled all of these eight leisures and these 10 conditions.

Therefore let us take five minutes. Geshe-la has just explained the topic and think carefully from your side whether or not you have these eight freedoms or eight leisures and whether or not you have these 10 endowments, then Geshe-la is not quite sure whether we can meditate or not. If we can, so much the better. If we can’t, just think about it. Therefore, one must meditate carefully on whether one has or not these eight freedoms and these 10 endowments.

And if one does have them, one should rejoice. Opinion probably most of you in this room do not have the eight freedoms of the 10 endowments completely. However, we will talk about it quietly during the question and answer session. And you can ask questions at present. Concise questions.

What do you think? Do you think you have them or not? So if you don’t have them, we have to complete them. If you have them, then you rejoice. Perhaps you won’t have them then.

Definitely, wrong views are one of the biggest obstacles and clearly, if you do not have 100% conviction in the existence of past and future lives and in the existence and operativity of karma and causality, then it is absolutely clear we don’t have a precious human rebirth. The crux is accepting or not accepting past and future lives and accepting or not accepting karma. Examine for yourselves within the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments. Do you have every single one of them or not? Do all of you understand? Mhmm.

Yeah. Good. It’s good to understand this foundation, the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments. It’s not important to know the number of the eight freedoms in the 10 endowments. What is important is to check does one have them oneself or not. That’s what matters.

Are they all present or not? So do you see the present? Present? Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Good. Good. Very good. So in the text it is said that a central land is a land in which 10 members of Sangha are present alternatively in which 20 members of Sangha are present.

Paul, it is true that what you say that based on computers and the Internet, we have access to the teachings everywhere in the world. The presence or absence of computers and the Internet and the presence or absence of the teachings through them is basically irrelevant. A central land is defined in function of whether or not there are people who practice these teachings. Without people who practice the teachings it would be very strange to speak of the central land. So one must meditate carefully on these fine points of the eight freedoms of the eight leisures and the 10 endowments.

And regarding the second subdivision of this topic, its great relevance, its great meaningfulness. There are two divisions thereof. Its great relevance ultimately and its great relevance contingently. Regarding the first subdivision, the ultimate relevance of a precious human rebirth, ultimate here refers either to liberation or to full enlightenment. However, as a preliminary to obtaining both liberation and full enlightenment, a higher rebirth is indispensable.

Geshe-la was asking me how much you know about grounds and paths. I said a little bit. Then basically to attain the state of liberation or full enlightenment, one must initially have progressed moving forwards through the path of meditation. For that, one must have progressed through the path of seeing. For that, one must have progressed through the path of preparation.

For that, one must have progressed through the path of accumulation. Moving forward, upwards on the basis of a human rebirth, one progresses through the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation to attain the goal, the path of no more learning, which is liberation or full enlightenment. It is impossible to progress on the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning without having the foundation of a higher rebirth. It is impossible to progress on them from a lower rebirth. So within the three great seats, Sera, Ganden and Drepung, there are six monasteries.

Each of the six monasteries has its own presentation of the basis on which it is possible to progress upwards through the five paths. The uncommon presentation of the textbook author of Sera Je monastery is that it is possible to attain the path of accumulation of the first path only on the basis of certain lower rebirths. This is not accepted by any of the other monasteries. It is not possible to attain any of the higher paths on the basis of lower rebirths. So here the problem which arises is that if one asserts that it is possible to attain the path of accumulation from certain lower rebirths then it means that perhaps states such as śamatha can be generated in the context of lower rebirths.

So this is open to question and to doubt. More fundamentally, Geshe-la would like to ask us to reflect carefully on the following situation or the following problem. If it is not possible to attain the path of accumulation on the basis of lower rebirth, how is it possible for beings reborn in the lower realms to attain higher rebirths? Are there possibilities and if so, what are they? So from the one point, this is quite a difficult line of reasoning.

From another standpoint, it is quite straightforward. So people who don’t accept the existence of past and future lives of karma and causality have no such doubts. When you accept the existence of past and future lives and karma and causality, the doubts increase in number. So we have completed this section and have reached the presentation of meditation on death and impermanence which is extremely important. So on the one side, Geshe-la suspects some of you may get really uptight at the thought of hearing about death and impermanence.

On the other hand, from the standpoint of Buddhist practitioners, these meditations on death and impermanence are indispensable as a prelude to Buddhist studies. Generally speaking, it is said that when one meditates on death and impermanence, one gets quite uptight. So many people believe that just living without ever thinking about death is the supreme type of perception of discrimination. However, the supreme discrimination is to meditate first on death and impermanence and on that foundation engage in all purposes of Dharma. So the goal of meditation on death and impermanence is not to give rise to a state of depression at the thought that one is abandoning one’s parents, one’s friends, one’s money and one’s body.

The reason for which it is said in text that this fear is not a form of Dharma practice is because this is of no benefit for the practice of Dharma. The way to meditate on death and impermanence is within the context of having reflected that we have been born in this life as a result of karma and causality and therefore that the duration of this life is circumscribed by that. And therefore reflecting that we have entered this life under the power of karma and causality and that when we leave it we will be impelled again by karma and causality to land. We do not know where and we do not know which condition. It is in this context that we reflect on death and impermanence thinking, the fear of death and impermanence must give rise to a wish within me to strive for rebirth in a higher state.

Therefore, there are two fears of death. The first fear of death was already explained as a fear of death motivated by anguish at the thought of being separated from what one desires, one’s body, one’s possessions, one’s wealth and one’s family. Such a fear of death, the fear of being separated of the objects one lusts and craves for is probably not a path to liberation. The second fear of death which is a fear of death rooted in the desire for happiness and absence of suffering in future lives on the other hand is probably a path to some type of liberation. The goal here therefore is to give rise to that attitude which is ready to undertake effort for the sake of one’s happiness and lack of suffering in future lives thinking what will happen to me when I leave this body behind.

And what is the root thereof in keeping with Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra in which it is said apart from ethics there is no road to higher rebirth. The gateway to happiness and future lives is that ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. And therefore the same way as there are two types of fears of death. One which is constructive and the other which is not. Likewise, regarding meditation on death and impermanence, Paul, our goal should be to realize death and impermanence by means of a valid cognizer.

If this is not possible at least we should gain strong familiarity with it as a basis for engaging in an ethics which abandons the 10 non-virtues in this life and then one relates these topics to each other and one goes from the one to the other. And if we look at our present physical base, in other words our present body which is that of a being in a happy rebirth, then we can see it is the result of causes accumulated by our physical base in previous lives, specifically the abstention or abstaining from the 10 non virtuous deeds and Geshe-la suspects that it is certain that that being in a previous life which led to ourselves either had direct realization through a valid cognizer of death and impermanence or had thought about them carefully. So there’s some major doubts here and Geshe-la would like to destabilize you since this is a good state of affairs. And therefore, we’ll toss these doubts at us. That’s regarding non-Buddhist practitioners.

It is generally said in numerous Buddhist texts that non-Buddhist practitioners cannot gain direct realization of impermanence. On the other hand, it is well known that non-Buddhist practitioners such as the Hindu Yogis practice the dhyanas and on the basis of the dhyanas can reach the form and the formless realms. They also seem to be able to meditate on death. Therefore, what level of the meditation on death and impermanence do they practice? And therefore, what gives rise, what impels a happy state in future lives, it is actually meditation on death and impermanence which impels it.

Why is this? It is because the mind which understands death and impermanence or the mind which reflects on death and impermanence is the antidote attraction to the vanities of this life. In addition, what gives rise to the state of liberation? It is none other than that wisdom which spontaneously realizes the absence of inherent existence of a self of persons. The more one reflects about these things, the deeper one’s mind, one’s understanding, and one’s perceptions become.

And therefore, so in dependence either on a reflection or a valid cognizer which realizes directly death and impermanence, The mind striving for the weal of future lives is generated. in dependence on a mind which realizes incontrovertibly and directly the selflessness of phenomena, the mind striving for liberation is generated. These two work in tandem. And therefore, it is said that the wisdom which realizes the selflessness of phenomena is the antidote to samsaric existence. Likewise, the mind which realizes death and impermanence is the antidote to attraction to the vanities of this life.

They work in tandem. We will stop here for today. We have some twelve minutes left. If you have questions concerning today’s teachings, please feel free to ask them. Otherwise, if you have no questions regarding today, you can ask questions regarding the former teachings.

So this is a difficult question. Basically, the duration of our life depends first and foremost on what is known as the impelling karma from past lives. However, it also depends on one’s physical health within this life. Nonetheless, one’s physical health within this life is less important than one’s interior mental health. Are there other questions?

Yes. No. Not at all. If one is born in a country and one has in that country at birth the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments and one moves to a country where the teachings are not present, one would hope one would continue to practice in that new country, then one would still have a precious human rebirth. Then it would be very strange and regrettable if changing countries one gave up on practice.

Are there yes. So the reason for this is because, to put it bluntly, it’s a divine rebirth and divine rebirths are the result of past virtuous causes. These past virtuous causes give rise to a result of maturation which is of the nature, in this case, of samsaric happiness. No. Geshe-la does not think that not having committed the five heinous crimes is one of the 10 endowments since King Ajatashatru is said to have attained the state of a once returner even though he had killed his own father, which is one of the five heinous crimes.

Geshe-la thinks you are asking. You’re asking about the difference between being born with wrong views and acquiring wrong views? Why? Geshe-la would suggest it. Get a pen.

Think about it carefully. Write it down and ask it next time. Are there other questions? Yes. So again, I don’t understand your question.

What what yes. You take refuge. And that taking refuge is not practice. For one’s own self. Okay.

Yes. No. Taking refuge for one’s own sake alone is Buddhist practice. It is the practice of both the hearers and the solitary realizers. So the indispensable preliminary is a strong sense of renunciation or definite emergence.

On this basis one can then extend the strong wish that others be free of suffering just like oneself and that others gain happiness in the future just like oneself.

Key terms in this teaching

dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
two bodies of a buddha sang gye kyis ku nyi (Tib)
The truth body or dharmakaya, the result of the wisdom side of the practice and the form body or rupakaya, the result of the method side of the practice. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top