Grounds and Paths

1 h 13 min · 3,331 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 74-minute session, Kyabje Rinpoche structures the Buddhist path to enlightenment through the framework of substantial causes and cooperative conditions. He opens with the five Mahāyāna paths and ten grounds, then explores a subtle philosophical question: whether bodhicitta (compassionate intent toward enlightenment) remains present during meditation on emptiness, and what this reveals about differences between the bodhisattva and tantric paths. His central argument is that wisdom realizing emptiness is the only direct antidote to ignorance, yet both wisdom and compassion must be inseparably present for full enlightenment to occur. He then examines sensory and mental consciousness through careful logical analysis—a foundation for understanding how consciousness and memory persist across lifetimes. Throughout, he emphasizes rigorous questioning and debate over passive acceptance. Pitched at serious practitioners with philosophical training.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 22112016Salam – KR.mp3

UUID: 2c186099-a788-4844-8ae8-338f02c80f97

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Grounds and Paths

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,326

So within the presentation of the paths of the Mahāyāna, we have the five paths, path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning And in addition, we have a presentation of the 10 grounds. Now generally speaking, when we refer to the 10 grounds, they are presented within the context of the path of meditation since the all 10 grounds are extent within the path of meditation. It is true however that the first ground is subdivided between the path of seeing and the path of meditation. So what exactly is the purpose of the presentation of the five paths and the 10 grounds? In so far as it takes a very long time to attain full enlightenment, the goal of this presentation is to generate enthusiasm or mental fortitude to giving a sense of which realizations can be attained at which level.

Then in the Vaibhāṣika system of tenets, one does not enter into a detailed explanation of the paths of seeing, of the 10 grounds and so forth because the Vaibhāṣika teach that one progresses from the level of warmth of the path of preparation all the way to full and utter enlightenment in one meditative session, actually in one meditative equipoise and therefore there’s no distinction between meditative equipoise, subsequent attainment and so forth. The 10 grounds therefore are all present on the path of meditation and we shall not explain the grounds individually. We would all get a headache in the process. It is sufficient to say that each of the 10 grounds opposes one specific level of innate grasping at true existence and these are opposed by their respective uninterrupted paths. So the path of seeing is therefore a cognition which cognizes emptiness And naturally before this cognition which cognizes emptiness, it is indispensable to have generated a motivation which is great compassion and bodhicitta.

Now here a delicate point arises because when one speaks of a meditative equipoise on emptiness, this means that the mind is single pointedly focused on emptiness. And Jangchub Chökyi Gyaltsen asserts that bodhicitta although non manifest Yes. So just in other words, the monastic textbook author of Sera Je asserts that bodhicitta is non manifest, cannot perform a function but does exist during meditative equipoise on emptiness. The other textbook authors such as Pänchen Sönam Drakpa assert that bodhicitta is absent during meditation, meditative equipoise and emptiness. It’s a very delicate point.

So, here the distinction between the Pāramitāyāna and Tantrayāna is substantial. According to the Pāramitāyāna, even though there is an inseparable union of method and wisdom, in this case the method bodhicitta precedes the wisdom which is focused on emptiness. There is not as in tantra, a mind which is of one nature or in different isolates uniting method and wisdom. So whereas Jangchub Chökyi Gyaltsen, the author of the monastic textbooks of Sera Je monastery asserts that even though bodhicitta is present during meditative equipoise on emptiness, it is non manifest. The authors of the monastic textbooks of the other monasteries assert that bodhicitta is merely absent during meditative equipoise on emptiness.

Then on the one hand it is strange for bodhicitta to exist but to be non manifest during meditative equipoise on emptiness. On the other hand, it is also strange for bodhicitta to be completely absent during meditative equipoise on emptiness. Now, the strangeness if you wish is not evident if one has not studied carefully text. But this is a clear case of the incapacity in Pāramitāyāna to posit method and wisdom as of one nature but different isolates. So here it is important first to understand, why, bodhicitta must exist during meditate meditative equipoise, albeit being non manifest.

And secondly, why it is necessary to engage in meditative equipoise on emptiness. It is necessary to engage in meditative equipoise on emptiness because there is a substantial distance separating our own mind at present from our goal, the state of full enlightenment. And this distance arises from the presence of the afflictions to omniscience within our mind stream. So what precisely is the antidote to these afflictions to omniscience? In other words, what precisely is directly opposite to these afflictions, to omniscience, which are the ignorance grasping at a self?

None other than the wisdom realizing selflessness. Now neither compassion nor bodhicitta are direct opposites to the ignorance which grasp at a self. Therefore, they cannot act as its antidotes. So as Dharmakīrti says in Pramānavārttika, it is because love and so forth is not opposite to the ignorance grasping at itself that it cannot act as its antidote. So therefore this recollection which recollects emptiness is what one trains in on the path of seeing.

And then when again one focuses on emptiness motivated naturally by great compassion and bodhicitta, one will have entered the path of meditation. And at that point, the progression through the 10 grounds of the path of meditation corresponds to an ever subtler mind. We can see as we analyze that the mind focusing on emptiness must become ever subtler And likewise, the levels of ignorance grasping at itself must become ever subtler. Now, While it is asserted that there is no difference in terms of the view of emptiness between the Pāramitāyāna and Tantrayāna. It is a Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view.

We can nonetheless see that the emptiness focused upon would become more subtle in the process. So here progressing in this way, eventually as is said in Abhidharma, one reaches the point where the darkness which covers phenomena is dispelled, and at this point, all objects of knowledge appear. We can say that they appear because the darkness covering them has been severed or dispelled. And at that point, one will have attained the wisdom of omniscience, the state of omniscience. In other words, one will have attained full enlightenment or the path of no more learning.

At that point, all of our consciousnesses will have become omniscient, and it is said that we will see all phenomena exactly as if we held them in the palm of our hand. At that point, we will have attained enlightenment So therefore, eventually through training our mental consciousness, we will reach a point where this mental consciousness becomes the omniscient wisdom. In other words, in which we have reached full enlightenment. And here, to avoid confusion, we must distinguish clearly between the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of this state of omniscience. The substantial cause of this state is the wisdom realizing emptiness.

However, that alone is insufficient. It needs a cooperative condition which is compassion and bodhicitta for this attainment to occur. Now, clearly, both, these causes are required. If the substantial cause, the wisdom realizing emptiness alone were present without the cooperative condition of great compassion or bodhicitta, then the realizations would be the same as those of hearers and solitary realizers who after all have a complete wisdom realizing emptiness. On the other hand, if the cooperative conditions, great compassion and bodhicitta were present, but the substantial cause, the wisdom realizing emptiness were absent, then we would face the contradiction that for instance bodhisattvas of the first ground would have already attained full enlightenment.

Then one of the major problems with the presentation in the Pāramitāyāna is that it is not possible to present bodhicitta and great compassion as of one nature but different isolates with the wisdom realizing emptiness. And major issues arise at the level of full enlightenment. What exactly is present? Are bodhicitta and great compassion present? And if so, what is their nature?

What is their function? Now once one is able to posit these as of one nature in different isolates with the wisdom realizing emptiness, there is no difficulty whatsoever. So, it is therefore important to understand that both the substantial cause, the wisdom realizing emptiness and the cooperative conditions which are love, great compassion and bodhicitta are required for the attainment of full enlightenment. If both are not inseparably present, it is impossible to attain full enlightenment. If they are individually present without the presence of the other, it is impossible to attain full enlightenment.

So this is therefore the purpose of the attainment of full enlightenment. I would like to point here that your questions are extremely important in are being able to explain these topics. Without your questions such as the questions last time about sensory consciousnesses and what exactly was the visual consciousness, the auditory consciousness and so forth and whether they existed or not, it would be very difficult to know what to explain. Likewise, as far as full enlightenment is concerned, since we have not attained full enlightenment, it can only be explained in the light of your questions. Then you can imagine that since the function of a Buddha is to dispel the suffering of all beings and Buddhas have the capacity to dispel the suffering of all beings individually to identify and dispel the suffering.

How extraordinary it would be if such a being were to manifest in our world at present. You can see the world is beset by war and civil strife. Imagine if such a being were to come. And such a being has the wish to place every single other being in a state of happiness. Whether this is possible or not is another question, but he definitely has the wish to do so.

Such a being would be of extraordinary benefit to this world. So full enlightenment therefore is a magnificent goal but this is not a state which will we we will attain through folding our hands in prayer. This is a state which is attained through study and effort. This is the only way to attain it And you can imagine the extraordinary level of happiness one would experience if one were able to attain such a state. Then setting full enlightenment aside, imagine the levels of happiness we would attain if we could generate for instance its precursors, bodhicitta or great compassion within our mind stream.

Now these are true and authentic happinesses which arise from deep within ourselves. These are not the transitory and ephemeral happinesses which arise when we rely on exterior sense objects. These happinesses are meaningless because they last only an instant, they are transient. So sensory consciousness as you know are fivefold. The visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory and tactile sense consciousnesses and apart from this naturally we have mental consciousnesses.

Now mental consciousnesses are easy to understand. It is the mind which thinks this is this, this is that and so forth. But as your questions last time revealed, sensory consciousnesses are much more difficult to understand. And actually, they were the source of a lot of research and confusion for great scholars. What exactly is a visual consciousness for instance?

So if we take the sensory consciousnesses, let us take for instance the gustatory consciousness. When we eat a meal, it might be sweet or sour. Now what precisely is the gustatory consciousness? The taste of the meal elicits a sensation. This is a pleasant or an unpleasant sensation.

That pleasant or unpleasant sensation itself is the gustatory consciousness of that meal. So what exactly if we take the visual consciousness would be the cooperative and substantial causes? The decision we take a visual consciousness observing forms. It can observe either shapes or colors. Now at this point, the cooperative condition of that visual consciousness would be the subtle visual organ within the eyeball which probably corresponds to what we know as the retina in English.

This would be the cooperative condition. What precisely would be the substantial cause? The substantial cause would probably be the nervous influx which travels along the optical nerve from the retina. So now how exactly can we identify the visual consciousness? If during a process of perception, we can block the activities of the mental consciousness, what is left would be the visual consciousness.

Otherwise we will confuse the two. And how do we put an end to the mental consciousness? If we put an end to the mental consciousness, there’s obviously no thought. there’s no thought, there’s no speech, no language. If you put an end to all sensory consciousnesses, then you’re sleeping.

Right? Dead. What about people in a about people in a coma? Sensory consciousnesses are gone, but they’re alive. So in Buddhism we follow the path of logic, then we follow this path, it’s not an issue of what one accepts and one doesn’t accept.

So now for instance, in the state in which we are able to put at end to sent to mental consciousness. All that is left is sensory consciousnesses. On the other hand, when we put an end to sensory consciousnesses, then obviously we are sleeping and naturally in the state of deep sleep, probably there is no mental consciousness either. Then as you remember, Je Tsongkhapa says in the Three Principal Aspects of the Path, once definite emergence has been generated day and night, at that point it will have been fully generated. Then should this be the case, it would mean that definite emergence could be generated during deep sleep since this is part of the night.

And then this would extend to other realizations such as a realization of emptiness. So this is for the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of sensory consciousnesses. However, from my personal perspective, what is really important is to understand clearly the substantial cause and the cooperative conditions of the person. Now generally speaking, when we refer to the person, we are referring to the mental consciousness. This does not mean that they are the same, but they are of one nature and different isolates.

And here, it is important to understand clearly what the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of these are. Then whatever composite phenomenon we consider arises in dependence on causes and conditions and specifically in dependence on substantial causes and cooperative conditions. Then please listen carefully at present during a couple minutes, even if you understand only thirty, forty or 50% of what I explained, that will be very good. It will be ideal to understand a 100%. So at present, let us examine carefully the issue of the substantial causes and the cooperative conditions of the mental consciousness.

And in our own cases, when we speak of mental consciousness, we’re actually speaking mainly of memory or recollection. Now, some of you may subscribe to the view that their substantial cause is probably our parents. From a Buddhist standpoint, from the standpoint of Buddhist texts, this is an unacceptable perspective. Then what precisely would the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of memory or recollection be? Let us take the case of our remembering this morning something which we did yesterday morning.

Then our capacity to remember this is due to the existence of a substantial continuum connecting yesterday’s mental consciousness with today’s. Then for instance, how is it that I cannot remember what Jampa Trepa was thinking about this afternoon? Because we have different mental continuums. Then for instance, what Jampa Trepa was thinking about this morning, I am unable to remember but he is. Why is that the case?

That is the case because the mental continuums are different, separate. Then if we try to move backwards in time, we can see that within our own mental continuum we can recollect what we did or thought ten years ago, not everything but most, nine years ago, eight years ago and so forth. Then when we examine the substantial continuum of our memory and move backwards in time, we can see that it is impossible for the substantial continuum of our memory to find its substantial cause in our parents. If that were the case, then we would recollect what our parents recollected or knew, and there is not a single person in this world who is able to do that. Therefore, it is self evident that our memory substantial continuum and that of our parents are different.

Do you understand? Good, good, thank you. Then if it were the case that our previous substantial continuum of memory eventually connected to that of our parents, let us say to that of our mother, then we would be able to recollect what our mother thought. And someone would say, when I was a child, this is what my mother thought. No one says this.

Then in my own case, the earliest memories, definite memories I have around age four. Some go earlier than that, one can move back up to maybe age three or so, But in every single case, these memories are in no way connected to those of my mother. And from the standpoint of Buddhist texts, if one were able to proceed further back in time, eventually one would connect to the substantial continuum of memories of the previous existence. So, it is possible to posit the union of the spermatozoa which comes from the father and the ovum from the mother as the cooperative condition of our continuum of memories. Since our continuum of memories needs a cooperative condition, but the question is, what can we posit as its substantial cause?

Then we can recollect what we did yesterday, what we did last week, what we did last month, and when we observe our own minds, we can see that there is a continuum of memory, a continuum of recollection. And this substantial continuum is different for each person. For instance, in my own case, I cannot recollect what Jampa Trepa did. So these are two different mental continuums. Then personally, I consider that the substantial continuum of my own memories abuts eventually when we go back enough on my previous life.

Whether you yourselves believe in this or not, I don’t know. Then it is not sufficient to relax back and with a blissed out smile on one’s face to say, yes, past lives exist. Yes, future lives exist. This is of no benefit whatsoever. Instead, one must through careful examination generate the strong conviction that one’s own past lives exist and one’s own future lives will exist and therefore that there are rewards for correct behavior of body, speech and mind in this life and in the future as well.

Then, I can’t speak for other Buddhist countries, but certainly, in Tibet, people who have not studied have a very, very odd outlook on Buddhism. You will hear people say, you have to rely on the triple gem. And if you behave badly, the triple gem will get angry with you. Then this is very weird. Silly, you know.

So at present, let us reflect first on the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of full enlightenment. Secondly, on the substantial cause and the cooperative condition of sensory consciousnesses. And thirdly, on the substantial cause and cooperative conditions of mental consciousnesses. Let us meditate on this during a couple of minutes. Please open the prayer book page one.

Page five. So so we will have discussion for fifteen minutes on the three topics which were covered. Mhmm. So this is the substantial cause and cooperative condition of full enlightenment. The substantial cause and cooperative condition of sensory consciousnesses, and the substantial cause and cooperative condition of mental consciousnesses.

Then I would suggest that you analyze carefully and that you debate with your translator. This is the way to move forward instead of huddling on your doubts and never expressing them. So if you express your doubts you debate with your translator, he’ll be delighted, then, you know, we will all progress and deepen our understanding. This is how one proceeds in the great monasteries. You must.

Then we have direct experience of this and if one stays in one corner and say says, I can’t express my doubts, this is the royal road to stupidity. Okay. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top