Grounds and Paths

1 h 2 min · 3,028 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 62-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen presents the foundational framework of grounds and paths according to Ngulchu Gyaltsen’s classical system. He opens by establishing the definitions and divisions of grounds and paths: grounds as clear realizations that serve as the basis for good qualities, and paths as the states of mind generating those qualities. He systematically unfolds Hīnayāna grounds, which are subdivided into the paths of hearers and solitary realizers, examining the eightfold subdivision of hearer grounds, including lineage, seeing, diminishment, and freedom from attachment. The teaching then progressively covers the five paths experienced by hearers, especially the path of preparation with its four subdivisions—heat, peak, forbearance, and supreme mundane quality—and moves into the path of seeing, where the selflessness of persons is realized directly for the first time. He explores the distinction between meditative equipoise and subsequent attainment, introduces the uninterrupted path and path of release, and explains how afflictions are abandoned through direct antidote. Suited for serious Buddhist students with previous exposure to Abhidharma teachings.

File metadata (for organising)

File: G&P 25 Mar – KR.mp3

UUID: 607eba8d-e962-4a17-9d49-d63ebd3af609

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Grounds and Paths

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,027

So since to understand grounds and paths correctly, it is crucial to understand our own system. As of today, Geshe-la will start presenting our own system in the grounds and paths teachings and this is the second handout you have received positing our own system. And then from among the two presentations of grounds and of paths, they will be presented in terms of a threefold division of definitions of grounds and paths, divisions and the meaning of terms or the etymology of grounds and paths. So on Page one of presenting our own system, which is Ngulchu Gyaltsen’s necklace of learned explanations, the definition of a ground from within a division of grounds and paths is a clear realization, an Abhisamaya, of one who has entered a path that serves as a basis for the many good qualities that are its effect. Generally speaking, grounds, paths and clear realizations are synonymous.

However, here to clarify the specific meaning of a ground, a ground is said to be first and foremost a clear realization which generates many good qualities. In other words, a grounds is that from which countless good qualities of the mind arises. Secondly, it is in the definition a basis. Basis here is to be understood actually as the cause for the arising of the many good qualities of the ground. And the term clear realization here actually is synonymous with a path, and this refers to the states of mind which are generated.

And moving onwards, when grounds are divided, there are two divisions, Hīnayāna Ground and Mahāyāna grounds. Hīnayāna grounds are grounds of the lesser vehicle, are defined in almost an identical way to, the general definition of grounds with a difference that they are restricted to beings of the lower vehicle. So the definition of a Hīnayāna ground is a clear realization of one who has entered a Hīnayāna path that serves as a basis for the many good qualities that are its effect. A Hīnayāna path here is a path in which one strives for one’s own welfare. And this includes the five paths of the, the path of the hearers, and the five paths of the, the paths of the solitary realizers.

So Hīnayāna paths can be subdivided into 10 subdivisions. So when these are divided into eight, moving onwards in your text, there are the following subdivisions. The ground of lineage, which refers to the path of accumulation and preparation of a shravaca, of a hearer. The ground of the eight, which refers to the very first instant of the path of seeing of a hearer. In other words, the uninterrupted path of the path of seeing of a hearer.

The ground of seeing, which refers to the path of complete liberation of a path of seeing. The ground of diminishment, which refers to the abandonment by a hearer of sharp faculties of six of the nine fold subdivision of afflictions which are to be abandoned. Such a being is said to be one who has not yet reached the state of a realizer. The ground free from attachment, which refers to freedom from attachment, which is included within attachments of the desire realm, from the threefold realms of desire form and the formless realms. The ground realizing realized and the produced, which simply refers to the attainment of the of a hearer, of a.

And then the two remaining of the eightfold subdivision, the ground of hearers and the ground of solitary realizers. The ground of hearers refers to the uninterrupted path which is attained when all of the nine subdivisions of the afflictions are completely abandoned. These refer to the three categories of afflictions divided into the coarse, the medium, and the subtle. And then once again, a threefold subdivision of each of those three categories. And the ground of solitary realizers refers to the uninterrupted path which arises when those nine categories of afflictions are abandoned by a solitary realizer.

So in this case, both the hearer and the solitary realizer would have applied the direct antidote to each of the afflictions. Moving onwards with our text, other grounds such as the ground of seeing white actions as its aspect are similar. Geshe-la says, the term the ground of seeing white here merely refers to the ground of lineage which is indicated in the first eightfold subdivision. Moving onwards, also when these are condensed, these here refer to the eightfold subdivisions. They are condensed into two, as they’re condensed into the two grounds of hearers and solitary realizers.

When we condense this eightfold subdivision, we end up just with the division into the grounds of hearers and solitary realizers. And then the very bottom of page one, the definition of the ground of a hearer is, moving on to page two, a clear realization of a hearer which serves as a basis for the many good qualities which are its effect. This is just a modification of the general definition of a ground to fit hearers. As usual, these are grounds because they are the foundation from which good qualities arise. And the characteristic, as Geshe-la explained, of both hearers and solitary realizers is that they strive for their own benefit.

Both strive for liberation. However, the main difference is that where for both the main object of meditation is the selflessness of persons. Solitary realizers are hearers of uncommonly acute capacities, the acutest of the acute, who even though they train as solitary realizers for one hundred eons under the guidance of their teachers in the very last life before they attain the state of an Arhat will train completely alone. And for this reason, they are said to be solitary realizers or Pratyekabuddha. And then moving onwards, when these are divided, there are two, the ground of a hearer, ordinary being, and the ground of a superior hero.

So hearers are divided into two categories, hearers which are ordinary beings, which refer to hearers on the two first of the five paths, which are the path of accumulation and of preparation, and hearers which are ārya beings, or superior beings. This refers to hearers on the three last paths, starting with the path of seeing. A hearer on the two first paths will train first in meditation on impermanence, and after attaining direct realization of impermanence, will then train in single pointed concentration in calm abiding, in śamatha, and will combine śamatha with special insight, with Vipashyana, on selflessness, the selflessness of persons in this case, and upon realizing the selflessness of persons, such a hearer which was an ordinary being becomes a superior being or an ārya. In contrast to hearers, the main focus of the Pratyekabuddha, the solitary realizers in this system, will be meditation on non duality. And then moving onwards with our text, the definition of the ground of a hearer ordinary being, in other words an ordinary being which is a hearer, is the Tibetan actually skips a whole section between square brackets, which is what Geshe-la glossed.

A clear realization of a hearer which serves as a basis for the many good qualities which are its effect, and a clear realization which is included in the continuum of a hearer of an ordinary being. Now, the gloss in the square brackets is actually not the one which Geshe has adopted. Geshe-la feels that the Tibetan relative particle, meaning literally that and in addition, refers when it says that merely to the fact that such a being is a hearer and not necessarily to what is included within square brackets in your translation. Then moving onwards with our text. From among these, the definition of a hearer’s path of accumulation.

So these are the two definitions of the paths of a hearer, which are an ordinary being, is a clear realization of the doctrine of a hearer. The doctrine here, Geshe-la says, refers specifically to the teachings of the Buddha which were intended for hearers. And in this context, the hearer is practicing mainly the accumulation of merit with respect to the teachings. And the definition of a hearer’s path of preparation is a clear realization of the meaning of that. That actually does not refer to a hearer as is indicated in your English translation, but to the doctrine, to that doctrine.

When it is said at the level of the path of preparation that a hearer has a clear realization of the meaning of that, that means that there is still doubt within his mind regarding the topics taught. But the doubt is less than the mental habituation to the doctrine and the conviction. Then when the first, the hearer’s path of accumulation is divided, there are three, great, middling, and small. Actually the hearer’s path of accumulation starts with the small, then progresses to the middling, then progresses to the great path of accumulation, and then the second path starts, the path of preparation, which is divided into four, heat, peak, forbearance, and supreme mundane quality. And then moving onwards with our text, when the first, the hearer path of accumulation is divided, there are three, small, middling, and great.

When the second, the hearer path of preparation is divided, there are four subdivisions, heat, peak forbearance, and supreme mundane quality. The meaning of these four subdivisions is as follows. The first subdivision of the path of preparation of a hearer, which is heat, uses a simile of fire which produces heat to indicate the beginning of the process of the extinction of the afflictions, which will only be completely extinguished from the root for a hearer at the level of the uninterrupted path of a path of seeing. Until that, point one cannot speak of an abandonment of the afflictions from the root. So at the level of the path of preparation, the focus of the training is in insight meditation on the selflessness of persons conjoined with calm abiding, and the eventual generation of an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight, which will give rise to the first instant of the path of seeing, where the afflictions are abandoned from the root.

Now with respect to the second subdivision of the path of preparation, peak, it is called peak because at this point, one can say that one is reaching the peak of virtue in as much as from this level of the path of preparation onwards, anger will no longer arise in the continuum of the being at that level, or at the following level, the level of forbearance or patience, one will be able to act on the resolution of never being reborn again in the lower realms, and from that point onwards, one will no longer be reborn in the lower realms. And the last subdivision of the path of preparation, supreme quality, literally in Tibetan supreme Dharma, in your translation supreme mundane quality, refers to the fact that this is actually the highest level which can be attained by a mundane or an ordinary being. Now each of these four subdivisions of the path of preparation, heat, peak, forbearance, and supreme mundane quality, is subdivided into three. The first three are subdivided into three, and the last, supreme mundane quality, will not be subdivided because there is only one instant of abiding at the level of supreme mundane quality before entering directly the path of seeing.

And moving onwards with our root text, the definition of the ground of a hearer superior, or a hearer which is an ārya being, is a clear realization of a hearer superior, which serves as the basis for the many good qualities which are its effect. The grounds of a hero superior are subdivided into three. A hearer’s path of seeing, where the first instant of direct perception of the selflessness of persons occurs. A hearer’s path of meditation, and a hearer’s path of no more learning. And moving onwards, the definition of a hearer path of seeing is, at the very bottom of page two, a clear realization of the truth of a hearer which arises after the completion of a path of preparation of a hearer which is its own cause, and which is produced before the path of meditation of a hearer which is its own effect.

So what this definition is indicating is that a hearer’s path of seeing can only arise as a result of a hearer’s path of preparation. And therefore, it necessarily arises after a hearer’s path of preparation. However, it is not a hearer’s path of meditation or no more learning. Therefore, it arises before these two and is bracketed as it were between these two. A much simpler definition of a hearer’s path of seeing, as Geshe-la says, is just to state that a hero’s path of seeing is a clear realization of truth.

Truth in this context refers to truth as it is understood by the Śrāvaka trainees, in other words, to the 16 subdivisions of the Four Noble Truths. And at this point, the 16 subdivisions of the Four Noble Truths are clearly realized in a new fashion for the first time. And then, at the bottom of page two, when this, in other words, a hearer’s path of seeing is divided, there are three subdivisions. The exalted wisdom of meditative equipoise of a hearer’s path of seeing, which refers to the direct realization of the object of realization of a hearer, such as selflessness, but such as emptiness also, since there are hearers which directly realize emptiness, followed by the exalted wisdom of subsequent attainment of a hearer. This refers to the instance which follow the exalted wisdom of meditative equipoise of a hearer’s path of seeing, but which are not an exalted yogic knower.

And finally, the hearer path of seeing, which is neither of these. These refer to those states of mind within the mental continuum of a hearer, which are neither hearer wisdoms of meditative equipoise, nor exalted wisdoms of subsequent attainment. Then moving onwards on page three of your text, the definition of the exalted wisdom of meditative equipoise of a hearer’s path of seeing is a clear realization of a hearer’s truth, which is a meditative, equipoise focused single pointedly on selflessness, which is its object. When this is divided, there are three subdivisions, the uninterrupted path of a hearer’s path of seeing, the path of release of a hearer’s path of seeing, and the exalted wisdom of meditative equipoise of a hearer’s path of seeing, which is neither of these. The two first of these subdivisions actually are yogic exalted wisdoms, Geshe-la says, while the latter is an exalted wisdom, but which is not necessarily focused on the object, selflessness.

The definition of an uninterrupted path of a hearer’s path of seeing is a clear realization of the truth of the hearer, which is a meditative equipoise one pointedly on the selflessness of persons, and which serves as the actual antidote for the acquired afflictive obstructions, which are the objects of abandonment which correspond to it. So if we try to understand the process of progression here from the path of preparation through to the path of seeing. That very last instant on the path of preparation, which is the instant of supreme mundane quality within the fourfold subdivision, is an instant where selflessness is still realized through a meaning generality. And in the very following instant which arises, which is the first instant of the path of seeing, selflessness or the topic of realization of the hearers, is realized nakedly without a meaning generality. That first instant of the path of seeing of a hearer is called an uninterrupted path, of the path of seeing of a hearer.

This uninterrupted path of the path of seeing of a hearer is actually the direct antidote to the afflictions. The path which arises as a result of it, which is called the path of release, in Tibetan, actually is a state in which the afflictions have been abandoned. So it is really this very first instant of the path of seeing of a hearer, the uninterrupted path of seeing of a hearer, which acts as the antidote to the afflictions. And this is what explains the definition of a uninterrupted path of a hearer, path of seeing in your text, middle of page three. A clear realization of the truth of a hearer, which is in meditative equipoise one pointedly on the selflessness of persons, and which serves as the actual antidote, the direct antidote, in other words, for the acquired afflictive obstructions, which are the objects of abandonment which correspond to it.

The term acquired afflictive obstructions here refers to those afflictive obstructions which are acquired through reasoning, such as, for instance, the conviction generated within oneself in the existence of a self of persons, which is rooted in reasoning. This is one of the many modes of conviction, the existence of a self of persons, which must be dispelled. Generally speaking, there are two categories of hearers, hearers of sharp and of dull faculties. And the hearers of sharp faculties will abandon the eight objects of abandonment of an uninterrupted path of a hearers path of seeing through the application of the eight knowledges, which are an eightfold subdivision of the Four Noble Truths, and then in turn will abandon the eight objects of abandonment of a hearer’s path of release through the application of the eight subsequent knowledges. However, there is another mode of abandonment of the eight objects of abandonment of a hearer’s uninterrupted path, and of a hearer’s path of release, where they are interwoven as it were, and the uninterrupted path which leads to the abandonment of the first object of abandonment by the first patience is interwoven with a path of release and followed by another uninterrupted path, which is followed by a path of release.

So we end up with 16 moments, eight moments of an uninterrupted path, and eight moments of a path of release, which are interwoven. This would be explained later.

Key terms in this teaching

five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top