1 h 36 min · 4,458 words · 21 June 2016 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 96-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen provides a detailed technical breakdown of the five Buddhist paths of development, focusing especially on the threefold and fourfold divisions of the path of accumulation and the path of preparation. He explains how practitioners enter the path by generating a stable experience of definite emergence and walks through the progression of the small, middling, and great path of accumulation—emphasising how calm abiding is necessarily developed before entering the path, yet calm abiding focused on emptiness only arises at the middling stage. He clarifies the crucial transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, which occurs when analytical wisdom combined with calm abiding enables continuous investigation of emptiness without losing focus. He also provides extended discussion of the three wisdoms arising from hearing, thinking, and meditation, with concrete examples showing how these differ in their modes of arising. The final section addresses multiple audience questions about karmic imprints, the seeming contradiction between meditative equipoise and insight, differences in enlightenment timelines between Buddhist philosophical schools, and how practitioners can assess their own progress without false claims. Pitched at serious students with prior philosophical training.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2016-06-21 – KR.mp3
UUID: 69ab9d5f-7d5a-41ae-b3a7-41ba610a6420
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Grounds and Paths
Date: 2016-06-21
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,452
So even though we have already explained them, I would like to cover again the threefold division of the path of accumulation, the small, middling and great path of accumulation as well as the wisdoms generated from hearing, thinking and meditation. And if there is time, we will pass on to the fourfold division of the path of preparation, warmth, peak forbearance and supreme dharma. But that seems difficult. We’ll probably cover it next week. So from within the five paths, the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing meditation and no more learning, The great seats devote special attention to the second path, the path of preparation.
There is a separate section of the first volume called the general meaning of Jorwa dedicated to the path of preparation because there’s a large number of difficult points to be covered. Then there is no separate section on the path of accumulation. There is no a general meaning of the path of accumulation. Then there is no, such section on the path of seeing meditation and normal learning. They’re just small, fragments.
So when one passes from the state of one who has not entered the path to the state of one who has entered the path, one enters the path at the level of the path of accumulation. And probably the main criterion for entering the path of accumulation is a stable experience of definite emergence. Once this is generated, one has entered the path of accumulation. So what precisely is the meaning of the first subdivision of the path of accumulation, the small path of accumulation? It is the preliminary accumulation of merit with liberation as its goal or for the sake of attaining liberation.
Then there is nothing special to be said about the small path of accumulation. When one passes from the state of one who has not entered the path to having entered the path, one enters the small path of accumulation. So when one speaks here of the small, middling and great path of accumulations, one is not speaking of persons or beings. One is speaking of realizations or consciousnesses. Then, I believe that the middling path of accumulation ranges from the moment when one endeavors to generate a calm abiding which is, observing emptiness up to the point just before one has attained that calm abiding focused on emptiness.
So there’s a fair bit of food for thought here since there are several types of, beings or practitioners. There is one category of practitioner who attains realization of emptiness before entering the path and after this enters the path entering, in other words, the small path of accumulation. And there’s a second category of practitioner who does not attain realization of emptiness before entering the path, enters the path first at the level of the small path of accumulation and then gains realization of emptiness. Now, regarding calm abiding, calm abiding will have been attained before entering the path. Since to enter the path, one must generate a stable experience of definite emergence and such a stable experience of definite emergence is a mind arisen from meditation.
All minds arisen from meditation rely on calm abiding. Therefore, one will have to have calm abiding to generate a stable experience of definite emergence. However, it is only at the level of the middling path of accumulation that this calm abiding will be focused on emptiness. So it is definite that calm abiding will have been attained before entering the path. Then as said, there is two categories of beings who adjust before entering the path.
One will have gained realization of emptiness and the other will not. However, a calm abiding focused on emptiness is only attained at the level of the middling path of accumulation. An example will illustrate this. Let us consider, a famous, Indian cook, a great, specialist of Indian cooking. Then even though he is famous for Indian cooking, if he has to cook Australian food, it won’t happen at once.
He will need some time to become accustomed to the Australian way of cooking. He needs, in other words, experience. Likewise, even though one has attained calm abiding and calm abiding can be focused on any object, one nonetheless needs experience to focus it on emptiness. You might wonder why is it the case that one has necessarily attained calm abiding before entering the path. But somehow calm abiding focused on emptiness only occurs at the level of the middling path of accumulation.
Simply because whatever object one will have attained calm abiding upon it to say, the representation of a deity or whatever. When one changes object of observation, there is a period of habituation. When one changes to emptiness, there is a period of habituation which is required. Then the great path of accumulation would range from the moment one has obtained a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness up to the moment immediately preceding the obtaining of an insight which is focused on emptiness. The path of preparation in turn ranges from the first moment during which one has obtained an insight focused on emptiness all the way up to the moment immediately preceding direct perception of emptiness.
And please try to retain this well within your minds. Try to retain the meaning of the small, the middling, the great path of accumulation, the path of preparation. Don’t think we keep hearing this over and again. Try to think this is a special uncommon explanation. Now at the level of the great path of accumulation, even though one has attained a calm abiding which is single pointedly focused on emptiness in an uninterrupted and clear fashion.
Nonetheless, one has not attained an insight which is focused on emptiness. Why is this the case? When a mind of calm abiding is focused on emptiness in a continuous and clear fashion at the level of the great path of accumulation. There is no factor of analysis present. So a factor of analysis, in other words, a wisdom which analyzes emptiness must arise.
However, if this wisdom is maintained continually, it will lead to distraction from emptiness, the object of meditation. So here we need first a calm abiding, in other words a Samādhi, which is focused on emptiness. This is a mind whose factor of appearance is stable and clear. But this mind, this mental factor which is a Samādhi or a concentration is insufficient. We also need an additional mind which is a component analyzing emptiness and this is of the nature of wisdom.
Now, in Buddhist psychology, we speak of main minds and mental factors. Here, we have a main mind. In other words, a mental consciousness which has two mental factors present which are different substances because they have different functions. The first of these is a concentration, a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness, its object. The second mental factor which coexists with the first is at the same time a factor of analysis.
In other words, a wisdom which analyzes emptiness. So, during the great path of accumulation at the beginning when calm abiding is focused on emptiness and one endeavors to analyze the object of observation emptiness with the factor of wisdom. If one tries to analyze for a fairly long period of time, analysis harms calm abiding and one is distracted and one loses the object. Then over time through habituation, the analysis lasts longer and longer and when finally it is possible to analyze the object for so long as calm abiding is focused on the object, one has attained insight and one has entered the path of preparation. So at the point where one passes from the last instant of the path of accumulation to the first instant of the path of preparation, one has passed from a meditative equipoise to a meditative equipoise.
That first instant of the path of preparation is a meditative equipoise and there is disagreement among scholars of what precisely it is. Most scholars consider it is not an inferential valid cognizer. It is not an inferential valid cognizer, they say because it is a mind arisen from meditation. If a mind is arisen from meditation, it is necessarily not an inferential valid cognizers since inferential valid cognizers are necessarily minds arisen from thinking. So here, there is a distinction which has to be made between minds arisen from hearing, thinking and meditation which is quite important.
So within the subsidiary volume of there are debates regarding the first instant of the path of preparation. In other words, the first instant of the path of preparation is a meditative equipoise in which one has entered after the last instant of the path of accumulation. Is this first instance of the path of preparation an inferential valid cognizer or not? The answer is the first instance of the path of preparation is not an inferential valid cognizer because it is a mind arisen from meditation. If a mind is an inferential valid cognizer, it is necessarily a mind arisen from thinking and necessarily not a mind arisen from meditation.
Now, inferential valid cognizers or inferences are broadly speaking the same thing. These are minds which occur within analysis. At the level of the first instant of the path of preparation, we are within a meditative equipoise. There is therefore no analysis. This is a mind arisen for meditation.
Now regarding an explanation of the minds arisen from hearing, thinking and meditating. A mind arisen from hearing and it is saying regarding the four noble truths to pin it down could either arise in dependence on hearing teachings on the Four Noble Truths imparted by one’s spiritual teacher or one’s preceptor or alternatively through reading oneself in a text, an analysis of the four noble truths. So, sometimes people think that because one refers to the minds arisen from hearing, they necessarily arise from sound. This is not the case. It can also occur through reading.
So, this therefore applies to studying texts as well. Probably the meaning of hearing and of studying are quite similar. When one studies a text, initially one apprehends a text visually which would correspond to hearing and then one reflects on its meaning. Now when we ourselves without relying on a text anymore reflect on the meaning of the four noble truths, their mode of abiding, where precisely would this fit within minds arisen from hearing, thinking and meditating? It is through this sort of analysis that one gains an understanding of these concepts.
This is very elegant because it is in this way that one basically encapsulates one’s studies. So this is for hearing, not for the minds arisen from hearing. The minds arisen from hearing arise independence on hearing through either receiving teachings for instance on the four noble truths from one spiritual teacher or through reading a text on the four noble truths. So once this initial understanding which is a mind arisen from hearing has occurred Through repeated analysis, one investigates that is say the Four Truths. And at the point where in dependence on that analysis, definiteness has arrived.
In other words, one has generated a valid cognizer. At this point, a mind arisen from thinking regarding the Four Noble Truths has been generated. So one analyzes, one analyzes, one analyzes and when through the force of analysis, a valid cognizer has been generated, then one will have generated a mind arisen from, thinking. A mind in other words, which has been induced or caused by thinking. Now regarding the minds arisen from meditation.
All calm abiding is necessarily a mind arisen from meditation. Not all minds arisen from meditation are calm abiding. And here, if we take the case of the Four Noble Truths, if we try to generate a calm abiding focused on the Four Noble Truths and here there are numerous methods of establishing calm abiding. But in accordance with Asaṇga’s Abhidharma Samuccaya, one establishes it here by means of the nine mental abidings. And after the nine mental abidings focused on the four noble truths have been generated, when a clear mind is focused on the four noble truths continuously and specifically when the bliss arisen from pliancy arises, at that point, one has generated a calm abiding focused on the four noble truths.
So here, minds arisen from meditation. In Tibetan has two components. Meditation or is the cause. To arise is the result of that cause. So meditation on an object gives rise to its result.
The mind arisen from meditation. So this is probably adequate as a presentation of minds arisen from hearing, thinking and meditation. Here specifically focused on the four noble truths. And what is very helpful is to ask oneself, when I generate a mind which is arisen from hearing focused on the four noble truths, what is required, what are the criteria? And I generate a mind arising from thinking focused on the four noble truths.
What is required? What are the criteria? And finally, I generate a mind arising from meditation focused on the four noble truths, what is required? What are the criteria? So if we take the wisdom arisen from hearing focused on the four noble truths, We can sense that it occurs or arises as a mixture for instance, if one is reading a text of the visual consciousness which is focused on the text and the meaning of the text.
Now, this is not the case with the minds arisen from thinking focused on the Four Noble Truths which arise exclusively for reflecting on the Four Noble Truths without any visual component if we’re studying a text. Now as far as the minds arisen from meditation are concerned, they no longer arise from thinking, they arise spontaneously. Now, in as much as, to enter the small path of accumulation, one must have generated a stable experience of definite emergence. And a stable experience of definite arising is a mind arisen from meditation. What precisely is the base of this stable experience of definite arising?
It is an experience of the four noble truths and the question which arise and one must analyze here is whether this experience of the four noble truths must be a mind arisen from meditation focused on the four noble truths or not. Now whether when one studies the Four Noble Truths, one is able to generate an experience, a realization from meditation of the Four Noble Truths or not is a difficult question. It is difficult because minds arisen from meditation are minds of the higher realms. Our minds at present are minds of the desire realm. But to generate a mind of the higher realm, we have to withdraw our minds within ourselves.
The more we withdraw them within ourselves, the more subtle the mind becomes. And this is obviously not easy. So let us now meditate during a couple of minutes on the minds arisen from thinking, from hearing, from thinking and from meditation focused on the Four Noble Truths. These are the three minds we need for the Four Noble Truths, Whether minds arisen from meditation are required for ordinary studies is another issue altogether, probably not. Okay.
We like to open a prayer with page one. We recite one b two three four and also page five, number six, Mandala offering, verse one and three. So once one has generated an uncontrived mind of definite emergence, then actually it becomes very straightforward to generate calm abiding should one wish to do so. Because this uncontrived mind of definite emergence is a mind which has turned away from the vanities of all lives. As a result, such a mind is very, very heavily withdrawn inwards.
In as much as in our case, it is precisely because our mind is focused on the outside world that the afflictions are able to use exterior objects to arise. When a mind is very heavily inward, withdrawn inwards, the afflictions do not arise easily and all such a mind of definite emergence would not be necessarily a fully characterized calm abiding. Nonetheless, in terms of its nature, it is quite close. So once the mind is very heavily withdrawn inwards and there are numerous levels of mind ever more subtle within the levels of mind within psychic existence. We have for instance the minds of the form and the formless realm, which are the most subtle minds which exist within psychic existence.
And then naturally, there are numerous ways to proceed for instance at the level of the stage of generation. Even though there are no specific instructions to generate calm abiding. Nonetheless, one generates something very similar to calm abiding without ever for instance relying on the five antidotes eliminating the eight faults and so forth which makes us all rather dizzy. So there are naturally numerous ways of generating calm abiding such as that in keeping with Abhidharma Samuccaya and other texts. But here the key is this inward withdrawal of the mind.
And at that level, the generation of calm abiding and that of definite emergence meet or connect. If you have questions, I will take two questions. How do, karmic imprints relate to a mind that how karmic influence relate to there was a three different types of minds that arise from thinking, contemplating, and from meditation. Karmic imprints are explained in Buddhist text to be potencies. Then, the minds arisen from meditation are minds.
So the two are two different things. Are you asking about the implantation of karmic imprints? Is that your question? Karmic imprints are not explained to be minds in Buddhist scriptures. They are said to be potencies.
And as they are impermanent phenomena which are neither matter nor consciousness, they actually are called non associated compositional phenomena. Here. Up there. I’m just hoping I’ve got this right. Last Wednesday at the teaching, Geshe-la talked about the difference in the time factor from reaching enlightenment for different schools.
So as I remember it, Sautrāntika and Mādhyamika down to Vaibhāṣika believed that once you get to, I think, the path of seeing, it’s then very, very quick to reach enlightenment. With Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, it’s many countless eons. Could Geshela explain why the schools have a difference of opinion about how long it takes to reach full enlightenment once one is on the path? So Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrantikas assert that one must accumulate merit for three countless eons before the path of accumulation. And then one proceeds in one meditative session from the path of preparation to the path of no more learning. That’s the position of Hīnayāna.
Then the Mahāyāna schools, in other words, Cittamātra and Mādhyamika probably have the same position. They assert that one spends one eon progressing from the path of accumulation to the path of seeing. A second eon from the first ground of the path of seeing to the seventh ground of the path of seeing and a third eon on the last three pure grounds, the eighth, ninth and tenth ground. I heard an apparent contradiction that I’m asking to have explained or resolved. In the first instance, in the when the first case, Geshela said that the first moment of the path of preparation is one of insight focused on emptiness.
And subsequently said that the first instant of path of preparation is that of meditative equipoise, which is a meditative state not involving analyzing. That’s what I understood, which would appear to be a contradiction. Is it or did I misunderstand? Could you repeat your question in brief? Okay.
The first moment of the path of preparation is that of insight focused on emptiness? That’s one proposition. Second proposition is the first instant of the path of preparation is meditative equipoise that being a meditative state that does not involve analyzing. I will reformulate you that. So my apologies, I understand what you are referring to.
That first instance of the path of preparation is not an inferential valid cognizer because inferential valid cognizers are the first instant of a mind. And that first instant of the path of preparation is not the first instant of that mind. It isn’t used by something else. It is however a mind single pointedly focused on emptiness. So your doubt is a good one and it is one I have had myself.
However, here the first instance of the path of preparation cannot be an inferential valid cognizer because inferential valid cognizers are the first instance of the mind. And here, the first instant of the path of preparation arises from a previously existing mind arisen from meditation. Okay. Another? Other questions?
The question I had before, I’m not sure that it was completely answered. I actually wanted to know why there was a difference between the high schools and the lower schools in how long it takes to reach full enlightenment. I’ve been sitting here thinking perhaps it’s because the high schools are focused on bodhichitta But could Geshe-la actually explain why? There’s no difference in length. So there’s no difference at all in the time it takes to attain full enlightenment for the Hīnayāna schools and the Mahāyāna schools.
There is a difference in the way that time is spent. So the Hīnayāna schools assert that three countless eons are spent before the path of accumulation and then one progresses in one meditative equipoise from the path of preparation to the path of no more learning simply because they do not accept the existence of subsequent attainment. The Mahāyāna Schools of Tenets also assert that one needs three countless eons to attain full enlightenment, but the time is spent differently. One spends one eon from the path of accumulation to the path of seeing, one eon from the first to the seventh ground and one eon from the eighth to the tenth ground. This difference is due to the fact that the Mahāyāna schools accept the existence of subsequent attainment after the meditative equipoise.
No difference in length. I’m just curious about the process of self assessment, self evaluation in proceeding from one section of the path of each of the accumulation and preparation, does the practitioner say, I have now achieved this particular level And if so, is that done at the time or afterwards out of the meditation process? Is it done in a discussion with a teacher? How does one avoid marking oneself up when one shouldn’t? You know, how how does one assess oneself at each point?
Because it’s a very precise from one moment, you know, into a next level. Guess you’ll comment. Then there is as you say very precise attainments for each level as one progresses on the path and if one has those attainments then one can be quite sure one has reached that level of the path. Then as to talking about it, why precisely would you talk about it? You see in Buddhist scriptures, if you are a Bhikśu and you make false claims, you have broken your root vows, right?
So if, our Bhikśu who is not an Arhat says, I am an Arhat, he has, committed a root infraction of monastic vows. Okay. And? Questions relating to terms. First, I would like a definition of merit.
Second, in terms of insight in the West that carries the connotation that it’s a product of analysis, What I’m What? Insight in the West seems to carry the connotation that it is a product of analysis. I’m understanding it in this context that insight that is conjoined with calm abiding is simply holding the object of emptiness without an without analysis. So I’m wanting to check if I’ve understood insight to mean that. And the the third part of the question is relating to and what is the mechanism of how the karmic imprints affect the mind?
I have many questions. Your third question was? So regarding your three questions, the meaning of merit is as follows. The collection of merit is the group of virtuous causes which act as the cause for both the form body and the enjoyment body of a Buddha. Now your second question, insight is defined as a wisdom within which the bliss of pliancy has arisen after it was focused by the means of calm abiding on its object.
And your third question regarding the mode of implantation of karmic imprints in the mind. If we take the case of the Four Noble Truths, when one reflects on the Four Noble Truths, at the end of that period of reflection, one discards the object. One thinks of something else. And what is left within the mind at that point is the karmic potency of having reflected on the Four Noble Truths. Another?
No. Yeah. Yeah. Just a question to follow from the last point. How does that karmic potency then affect the next moment of of mind?
Karmic imprints are not consciousness. Right? Then, to say they dwell within consciousness is awkward. The way I tend to conceptualize it is almost it’s like gravitational potential energy. It’s unmanifest.
It’s latent. Has the potential to generate kinetic energy or an action almost in the way that a curvature in space is not a material object, but it is a mere potential to affect the movement or action of an object. That is how I conceptualize it, and I don’t know if that’s an accurate metaphor or not. So the location if you wish of the karmic imprints differs according to the schools. Prāsaṇgika says it is the mere I.
Then Cittamātra says it is the mind basis of all, the Alāyavijñāna and Sautrāntika Mādhyamika says that it is the mental consciousness. Now regarding the mode of maturation of the karmic imprint, if we take reflecting on the Four Noble Truths, when we reflect on the Four Noble Truths and we stop reflecting on the Four Noble Truths, a potency is implanted in the mind. This potency is present and will be activated the next time we reflect on the four noble truths. Okay. Just one and two.
Could I ask why ethics is prerequisite to calm abiding? Ethics. That’s an excellent question. The reason for which ethics is an indispensable preliminary to calm abiding is because through ethics we restrain the mind from exterior distraction or wandering outwards. And this is a preliminary inwards withdrawal of the mind which enables us then to generate in sequence the three trainings: ethics, concentration, and wisdom.
This is why the three trainings are presented in this sequence. Okay. We shall stop here for today.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Why is ethics a necessary prerequisite for developing calm abiding?
Ethics is an indispensable preliminary to calm abiding because through ethics we restrain the mind from exterior distraction, from wandering outwards. This restraint is a preliminary inward withdrawal of the mind, and it enables us to generate in sequence the three trainings: ethics, concentration, and wisdom. This is why the three trainings are presented in that order.