Emptiness — 2016-06-14

1 h 45 min · 2,763 words · 14 June 2016 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness — 2016-06-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 105-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche examines whether the path of preparation itself qualifies as a valid cognizer in Buddhist epistemology. He works through the distinction between direct (non-conceptual) and inferential valid cognizers, then explains that the path of preparation perceives emptiness through a mental image rather than nakedly — like seeing one’s reflection in a mirror rather than one’s actual face. From this pivotal insight, he develops a detailed analysis of conceptual versus non-conceptual minds, showing that renunciation, bodhicitta, and great compassion are necessarily conceptual states. The teaching concludes with a substantive Q&A where students explore the Heart Sūtra’s teaching on emptiness, the distinction between karmic imprints and memories, guru-reliance and protection from lower realms. Pitched at serious practitioners engaged with Buddhist philosophical study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2016-06-14 – KR.mp3

UUID: 69284424-769f-4f66-8ea6-442da2f2afe7

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Date: 2016-06-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,758

Okay. Regarding the path of preparation, in Lorik, in the study of Pramāna, an important topic of discussion is whether the path of preparation itself is a valid cognizer or is a consciousness which is not a valid cognizer. And I would like to ask you what you think about this. So, you, studied Lorig a while ago, but it is good to cover this. So is the path of preparation a valid cognizer which is a direct perceiver or is it an inferential valid cognizer?

Now when I say is a path of preparation either of these two, obviously this doesn’t refer to the totality of the path of preparation. Since the path of preparation includes for instance, the, six perfections. The perfection of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance, of enthusiasm, of concentration and of wisdom. Now regarding the differentiation of the path of preparation, the analysis whether it is a direct guided cognizer or an inferential valid cognizer, it is important to remember that the transition from the last instant of the path of accumulation to the first instant of the path of preparation is a transition from a meditative equipoise to meditative equipoise, from meditative equipoise focused on emptiness to meditative equipoise focused on emptiness. So the first instant of a path of preparation, in other words, that meditative equipoise which is focused on emptiness is not a valid cognizer.

It is a mind which is a non valid cognizer. And within the five minds which are not valid cognizers, the sevenfold divisions of mind presented by Lorik, it is a subsequent cognizer. And the reason for this is that that first instant of the path of preparation which is a meditative equipoise cognizing emptiness does not cognize emptiness by its own power. It cognizes emptiness by the power of a preceding instant of mind in its continuum. Therefore, it is not a valid cognizer but a subsequent cognizer.

It is not a valid cognizer. And therefore, since valid cognizers are divided, into direct valid cognizers and inferential cognizers, that first instant of the path of preparation is neither a direct valid cognizer nor an inferential valid cognizer. That, first instance of the path of preparation is not a direct valid cognizer simply because direct valid cognizers are necessarily non-conceptual minds. And that first instance of the path of preparation is a conceptual mind, an ideation. So Lorig is an extremely important topic in as much as we are trying to actualize interior happiness and that interior happiness depends on our inner view.

And for this, there are numerous inner states of consciousness which manifest. We don’t dedicate a lot of thought or effort into inner happiness. In other words, mental happiness, the happiness of the mental consciousness. Since overwhelmingly, we are focused on sensory satisfaction, the satisfaction of the sensory consciousnesses and the sensory consciousnesses depend on exterior physical entities. Therefore, to satisfy sensory consciousnesses, a study of mental consciousness is not terribly relevant.

Now from a Buddhist standpoint, what is critical is one’s inner view and the transformation of the mind. And this depends on numerous factors such as minds, mental factors and so forth which we study therefore. So the first instant of the path of preparation is not a direct direct valid cognizer. Why? Because direct valid cognizers are necessarily non conceptual and the first instant of the path of preparation is a conceptual mind.

Now why is the first instance of the path of preparation conceptual? The first instance of the path of preparation is focused on emptiness. Its object is emptiness. But how does it perceive emptiness? If it was a direct cognizer, it would perceive emptiness nakedly, non conceptually.

But it does not perceive emptiness in this way. Now when we speak of naked perception, it’s like the perception by the eye consciousness of the table in front of Geshe-la. So how exactly then does the path of preparation, the first instance of the path of preparation perceive emptiness? What is the mode of perception? Through repeated habituation and meditation, that first instant of the path of preparation imputes something out there.

It is a factor which appears as emptiness and this is what is perceived. It is similar to So let us take an example to make this clear. Let us imagine we meet an acquaintance and he asks us what precisely did you do yesterday morning? Then we engage in a mental process of reconstruction of yesterday morning. And in our mind, we see, well, yesterday morning, I woke up and then I made coffee or tea and then I meditated, you know.

And on this basis, once this mental reconstruction has occurred, we can answer the question. Now this mental reconstruction is a creation of a mental image, what is known as a meaning generality. And it is on the basis of this meaning generality that conceptual minds function. For this reason, it is said that that which recollects now what occurred in the past is conceptual. So this is something you can understand based on personal experience.

Instead of referring to emptiness, the selflessness of persons of which we do not have personal experience. So in this context, it is said that conceptuality occurs for instance when we recollect now what was done previously. Then there are an almost infinite number of conceptual minds within our mind stream, conceptions within our mind stream. All our memories are conceptual. Generally speaking, as was mentioned, mind is subdivided into non conceptual and conceptual minds.

Now, within the mental continuum of an ordinary being, it’s a sensory consciousnesses which are non conceptual. In other words, the five sense consciousnesses seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting and touching. If however you were to say to me that you do not accept that the sensory consciousnesses are non conceptual, then I would say okay. But in that case, you would have a very very hard time giving one single instance of a non conceptual mind within the mind stream of an ordinary being. If you analyze such a mind stream, you find a huge number of conceptual states of mind.

But apart from sensory consciousnesses, basically no non conceptual minds. So the first instant of the path of preparation does not perceive emptiness by means of a direct valid cognizer. It perceives it by means of an image, a meaning generality. Then how does this occur? It’s best understood by means of an example.

If we look at our face in a mirror, then obviously we would casually say that’s my face. But if we are precise, even though in dependence on the face in the mirror we can correct aspects of our appearance, in reality what appears in the mirror is merely a reflection of our face, an image of our face. So precisely the reflection of our face in the mirror is not our face. That is self evident. However, we do say I can see my face in the mirror.

It is true that in dependence on the reflection of our face in the mirror, we can do all sorts of things about changing our appearance. Therefore, the first instant, of the path of preparation, basing ourselves on this example, the meditative equipoise which is the first instance of the path of, preparation does perceive emptiness. But how does it perceive it? It does not perceive it nakedly. It perceives it by means of a mental image of emptiness.

This mental image of emptiness is constructed in dependence on the long study of great treatises on emptiness. It is in other words, a mental imputation which arises in dependence on our study and so forth. So what is the meaning of conceptuality? Conceptuality is a mind which understands its object through or by the means of a meaning generality of that object. Now, this is for conceptual states of mind.

What about non conceptual states of mind? Well, if we accept the position of Buddhist scriptures that the five sensory consciousnesses are non conceptual states of mind, then that is the prime example. All five sensory consciousnesses are non conceptual states of mind as well as the mental consciousness. So what is then the mode of appearance of phenomena to sensory consciousnesses to non conceptual consciousnesses? Sensory consciousnesses do not perceive past phenomena.

They probably do not perceive future phenomena. They perceive only present phenomena. Therefore, to non conceptual sensory consciousnesses, only the present appears. So we will set aside the issue of the paranormal cognitions which can perceive, the actual state of events since they can perceive, past events in our non conceptual minds. These only arise through great habituation.

Then if you want to give instances of non conceptual consciousnesses within our mind stream, the straightforward examples are the sensory consciousnesses. If you wish to give non sensory consciousnesses as instances of non conceptual consciousnesses within our mind stream, that is a bit difficult. Then you could give the case of reflexive awareness, reflexive consciousness, but that is not accepted by the Prāsaṇgika system which asserts it’s a mere, imputation of lower systems of tenets. Now if you were to ask what the meaning of a non conceptual consciousness is, we could say that the meaning of a non conceptual consciousness is a consciousness which understands and apprehends its object without relying on a meaning generality. So this is a distinction between conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses which is well worth reflecting about.

So, the first instance of the path of preparation is not a direct valid cognizer, cognizing emptiness. Is it then an inferential valid cognizer, cognizing emptiness? No, it is not an inferential valid cognizer, cognizing emptiness. First, because it is not a valid cognizer. It arises in dependence on a previous mind.

And secondly, and this is quite an important point, because inferential valid cognizers are either minds which have arisen from hearing or minds which have arisen from reflection. And the first instance of the path of preparation is a mind which has arisen from meditation. So let us now meditate during a couple of minutes on the nature of the first instant of the path of preparation. Is it a direct valid cognizer or not? Within direct valid cognizers, what would it be?

Is it a conceptual mind or not? Open the prayer for page one. We recite one b two three four in the page five. Number six, mental offering. Verse one and three.

There’s a lot of food for thought here in the presentation of conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses. For instance, probably both renunciation and bodhicitta could only be conceptual consciousnesses. It is very difficult to see how they could be anything else. Then as to mind such as great compassion, obviously they would be conceptual consciousnesses. What precisely is the status of these minds within the mind stream of a fully enlightened being is another question altogether.

Well therefore, the first instant of the path of preparation is not a valid cognizer. It is however a yogic perceiver in as much as it is a mind arisen from meditation. A yogic perceiver focused on emptiness. So once uncontrived definite emergence or stable renunciation is generated, one has entered the path of accumulation. Such an uncontrived renunciation can only be a conceptual mind.

One doesn’t see how it could be non conceptual. Likewise for bodhicitta, likewise for great compassion, likewise for that matter for the four first perfections, generosity, ethics, forbearance and enthusiasm remain conceptual minds throughout. How could they be anything else? Mhmm. So I would at present take a couple of questions.

Mhmm. Natalie. Hello? Give to Natalie. My question is about the first moment of the path of preparation.

And Geshe-la talked about the image of emptiness which is like using the example of the mirror as as one sees one’s face. Can can that being or when they’re in that moment of seeing that image be in danger of thinking that they have realized emptiness and get sort of stuck there? At that time, someone who is perceiving emptiness conceptually cannot think he’s perceiving it nonconceptually. So someone who perceives emptiness directly or nakedly has entered the path of seeing. Then, how does the person prepare for this?

They prepare for this by means of meditating on emptiness through a meaning generality. So to attain, or with the purpose of attaining direct perception of emptiness, how does one proceed? Through repeated habituation with emptiness. So just, to follow on from that answer, the person seeing the image of emptiness, would they know that that’s an image in the way that when we look in the mirror, we know that we’re seeing an image or our reflection and not our actual face? The key here is to understand that you can realize emptiness by means of a meaning generality.

Another? I have a question from last week. Are karmic imprints and memories synonymous? No. From the standpoint of Buddhist treatises, memories are consciousnesses.

They are mnemonic consciousnesses. Karmic imprints are potencies. They are not consciousnesses. This is a question that I’ve been wanting to ask for quite some time. It’s about the Heart Sūtra where Śāriputra is advised to analyse the five aggregates by nature empty.

Form is empty. Emptiness is form. Emptiness is no other than form, etcetera. And then goes through the four aggregates the other four aggregates. And I understand the form is empty, but I really can’t get the emptiness is form.

Can that be explained in the same way as a concept, so arising in dependence upon causes and conditions and it’s therefore empty of inherent existence just as the five aggregates? So basically the first section of the Heart Sūtra form is emptiness simply refers to the emptiness of form being emptiness. Then the second part, emptiness is form. I don’t remember exactly but it has something to do with the relationship between the imputed phenomenon and the basis of imputation. Chris.

Geshe-la, it says, at the path at the level of forbearance in the path of preparation, one will not fall into the lower realms. I’m just trying to reconcile that with the seventh advantage or benefit of relying on the guru where it says by relying on the guru, serving, making offerings and putting to practice the teachings, one will be protected or one will not fall into the lower realms. Does that mean that that needs to be qualified by saying that over progressive lives, the guru will provide protection until one reaches the level of forbearance and the path of preparation? Or can Geshe-la help me to reconcile those two? So at the level of forbearance of the path of preparation, one is certain not to be reborn in the lower realms.

However, even before that point, one may not be reborn in the lower realms for instance at the level of the path of accumulation. Nonetheless, one lacks that certainty. So in the eight advantages of correctly relying on the guru, does that imply then that one will perhaps I can ask it again. How, in which way does that statement that relying correctly on the guru is a protection, from falling into the lower realms, and without having achieved even the medium part of the path of accumulation? So someone who engages correctly in reliance on the spiritual teacher will have the conviction that he or she will not be reborn in the lower realms.

But that conviction cannot be grounded rationally on reason. At the level of forbearance of the path of preparation, then one definitely will no longer be reborn in the lower realms. So there are two ways of being reborn in the lower realms. The first is through the power of the afflictions and the second is through mental focus. Now, through the power of the afflictions, obviously, how could someone at the level of forbearance of the path of preparation and above have powerful afflictions?

Then, it does occur for beings who have entered the path, to generate afflictions, but it is rare. Molly? Stable face, right? Very short one, Geshe-la. In the context we’re talking tonight, does a conceptual mind necessarily imply analysis, analytical thinking?

No. Not necessarily. For instance, doubt is a conceptual state of mind and doubt is not analytical. It is divided. So now, during the discussion session, we shall discuss as much as we can the difference between conceptual and nonconceptual consciousnesses.

Okay. Please.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top