Meditation — 2016-06-22

1 h 41 min · 4,963 words · 22 June 2016 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Meditation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Meditation (Khensur Rinpoche)
Meditation — 2016-06-22
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 101-minute teaching, Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen offers a systematic framework for understanding Buddhist practice through the lens of the three trainings: ethics, concentration, and wisdom. He begins by establishing how all of the Lamrim (the graduated path to enlightenment) can be summarized and encapsulated within these three trainings, and how they must be developed sequentially. He then pivots to distinguish between three types of mind that arise in Buddhist practice: the mind arisen from hearing (intellectual understanding), the mind arisen from thinking (ascertainment by valid reasoning), and the mind arisen from meditation (single-pointed, uncontrived realization). Using concrete examples such as impermanence and the visual perception of his yellow monastic robe, Geshe Jampa clarifies the crucial distinction between conceptual minds, which perceive through mental images, and non-conceptual minds, which perceive directly. He further subdivides meditative minds into those focused on objects and those focused on subjects like compassion, and explains why most practitioners in the desire realm must carefully check which type of mind has actually arisen in their practice. The session concludes with a Q&A addressing the relationship between calm abiding and the path of preparation, and the progressive development of realization. Aimed at serious students of the Lamrim already familiar with Buddhist philosophy.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2016-06-22 – KR.mp3

UUID: 88f34ada-802e-497b-93dd-4927d5b3ff79

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Meditation

Date: 2016-06-22

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,957

As is said in the Guru Puja’s Lamrim prayer, bless me to uphold the banner of liberation by means of the treasure of the Aryas, these three trainings. Now in as much as we are beings who are striving for liberation, then we have to rely on these three trainings. Khensur Rinpoche repeatedly used to say rely on the three trainings, rely on the three trainings. Then what is precisely meant by going for the three trainings is something we must examine? Then for ourselves who wish to practice, our practice must be summarized or encapsulated within the three trainings, which are the training of ethics, training of concentration and the training of wisdom.

And this is something we ought to study. Then I reserve the privilege not to follow always the outline to the letter but from time to time to explain dharma in general, linking all the various topics since it is in this way that one can increase one’s understanding. Then initially one must engage in extensive hearing. In other words, extensive study and this extensive hearing of the, Lamrim enables us eventually to pull or encapsulate Lamrim within this process. So as Tsongkhapa says in his Song of Realization, that summary of the essence of all scriptures.

And it is indeed in this way that the Lamrim should function. We should summarize the totality of the scriptures within the topics of meditation of the Lamrim. Not summarize them in any which way, but summarize them within the specific topics. Then, the presentation of the three trainings begins with the presentation of the training of ethics. The first subdivision of which is how to subdue the mind by ethics and the second of which is the result of that subjugation.

So these three principles of the path, in other words, excuse me, the three trainings. In other words, the training in ethics, in concentration and in wisdom must be engaged in sequence. The training in ethics initially amounts to a taming or a subjugation of inappropriate physical and verbal behavior. And this leads the mind to be withdrawn inwards. This inward withdrawal of the mind in turn enables us to engage in the training of concentration, in which the mind rests single pointedly and clearly on a virtuous object of observation.

And after this, then it is very easy to give rise rapidly to a factor of wisdom which is the training in wisdom. Then the second outline, the enumeration of these three principles of the path from the standpoint of the result is as follows. First, the three trainings throughout, not the three principles of the path. The first training, the training of ethics has two results, rebirth as a god or as a human being. The second training, the training in concentration leads also to two results, rebirth in the formless realm or the form realm.

In other words, the higher realms. And the last training, the training in wisdom leads to the attainment of liberation. We will drop this topic, I won’t translate. So these three principles therefore are trained in these three trainings are trained in sequence. The training of ethics initially gives rise to the training in concentration.

And the training in concentration eventually gives rise to the training in wisdom. The totality of the Lamrim can be summarized within the three trainings. For that matter, the totality of the three baskets of the teachings can be summarized within the three trainings. We can see clearly as far as the path of the beings of the three scope, that the practice of the being of the small scope can be summarized within the training in ethics. The practice of the being of the middling scope can be summarized within both the trainings in concentration and in wisdom.

In the practice of the being of the great scope can also be summarized both within the trainings of concentration and of wisdom. Now when one refers to the three trainings, the training in ethics refers to an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues. The training in concentration refers to calm abiding or śamatha. And the training in wisdom refers to insight or vipassana. So if the path leading to liberation can be summarized within the three trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom, then what is meant when refers to something or someone who is superior to the three trainings.

That which is superior is actually the listener or the practitioner who engages in the three activities of hearing, thinking and meditation. Then it is very helpful to avoid confusion to distinguish between that which is practiced, the three trainings, and he or she who practices a practitioner which is the being engaging in hearing, thinking, meditating. Then it is very helpful to check whether one study and practice of Lamrim can be summarized within the three trainings or not. If it can and there are aspects of one’s practice which still cannot be fitted within the three trainings, then that aspect of one’s practice is inappropriate. So this is for that which is practice the three trainings.

As for the practitioner, it is none other than the minds arisen from hearing, thinking and meditating focused upon this topic. What exactly is hearing in this context? Hearing in this context refers to either hearing teachings from one spiritual teacher on a given topic such as the Four Noble Truths or reading in a folio, a treatise explanations of the Four Noble Truths. However, one must distinguish between hearing and the mind arisen from hearing. The mind arisen from hearing is said to be present once in dependence on hearing, understanding has arisen.

Now the the mind arisen from hearing does not necessarily arise from hearing sound. Here, hearing can also refer to viewing texts on the Four Noble Truths, which obviously are very beneficial for one’s mind. Now regarding the mind arisen from thinking, Initially, as was explained through hearing, one either receives teachings or studies texts on the four noble truths and in dependence on hearing or reading texts. An understanding of the topic, the four noble truths arises. That understanding is the mind arisen from hearing.

When after that, through analyzing repeatedly that understanding, one eventually gives rise to an ascertainment by a valid cognizer of the topic in question, in this case the Four Noble Truths, then the mind arisen from thinking is said to have arisen. Now, the mind arisen from meditation is said to have arisen when after generating a mind arisen from thinking focused on its topic, let us say the Four Noble Truths. In other words, after generating a valid cognizer which has realized the Four Noble Truths. One then generates a mind which is focused single pointedly on its topic, the Four Noble Truths and in addition to being focused single pointedly, one experiences no physical or mental hardship. At that point it is said that the mind arisen from meditation has been generated.

Then it is important here to make a clear distinction between the process of thinking and the mind arisen from thinking, the process of meditating and the mind arisen from meditation. So thinking here is the cause. Its effect is the mind arisen from thinking. When through repeated thinking, in other words, analysis eventually, one gives rise to a valid cognizer which realizes its topic, in this case a Four Noble Truths. Then thinking has acted as a cause for the mind arisen from thinking that valid cognizer.

Likewise, one must not confuse meditation and the mind arisen from meditation. When through meditation, and meditation here refers specifically to calm abiding. In other words, training the mind incrementally on the nine mental abidings until eventually one reaches a single pointed mind which is bereft of physical or mental hardship. In other words, which experiences both physical and mental pliancy. That meditation eventually gives rise to the mind arisen from meditation.

Meditation here is a cause. The mind arisen from meditation is the effect. Now here, when we speak of calm abiding, we are referring to a mind which is focused continually on a virtuous object. And by continually, we are not referring to a short period of time, let us say a minute or for that matter an hour or a day or even a month. We are referring to a mind which can focus on its virtuous object for years on end.

Now, such a mind is not accessible within the desire realm. Such a mind is a characteristic of the higher realms. Now, in a nutshell, one could say that the mind arisen from hearing is understanding. The mind arisen from thinking is ascertainment by means of a valid cognizer And the mind arisen from meditation is a mind which is single pointedly and continuously focused on its object. Here you might wonder what the distinction is between understanding on the one hand and realization by a valid cognizer on the other hand.

And this can become clear if we take the example of impermanence. So if we generate a mind arisen from hearing regarding impermanence, in other words an understanding. This is an understanding which will be aware of the existence of the two forms of impermanence. Coarse and subtle impermanence. It will understand that coarse impermanence refers to the disintegration of entities such as this building or to the death of persons.

And then as one analyzes coarse impermanence and breaks it down into ever subtler parts, eventually one reaches a point where one understands the momentary transitoriness of phenomena. This is subtle impermanence. So, this is for understanding. Now what is meant by realization by a valid cognizer? Let me take the example of my outer monastic vestment, my Chögu, which is yellow as you can see.

Now, there is no doubt whatsoever in my own mind that my Trikhang or my outer monastic vestment is yellow and you all see it as yellow without a single exception. And if I were to ask you, there’s not a single person in this room who would say it is not yellow. Now it is this sort of definiteness which is characteristic of valid cognizers. So now we shall pass to the minds arisen from meditation. But before, it is very helpful to distinguish between conceptual and non conceptual minds in this threefold subdivision.

So minds arisen from hearing and minds arisen from thinking are almost certainly exclusively conceptual. There are no non conceptual minds arisen from hearing or thinking. As for minds arisen from meditation, there are both conceptual minds arisen from meditation and non conceptual minds arisen from meditation. Now as was said, the minds arisen from hearing and the minds arisen from thinking are exclusively conceptual. As for the mind arisen from meditation, it is either conceptual or non conceptual, both instances are present.

Here, it is therefore helpful to understand the distinction between conceptuality and non conceptuality. Both conceptual and non conceptual minds are present within our mind stream. However, when we reflect about the future or the past, In the case of the past, instance, the past is gone. So if someone were to ask us what precisely did you do yesterday, we have to stop and reflect on what we did yesterday and when we do, a mental image appears to our mind of what we did yesterday. This mental image is known technically as a meaning generality.

It is similar to its appearance or the appearance of its object. And based on that meaning generality, that mental image, we are able to answer the question what we did yesterday. So one of the characteristics of conceptual is a mixing of what we identify as the object and its meaning generality. Clearly what appears to the mind when we think of what we did yesterday is not what we did yesterday but an image of what we did yesterday, a mental image. But by means of that mental image, we are able to access and talk about what we did yesterday.

In the same way as when we look at the reflection of our face in the mirror, clearly that reflection is not our face. Yet thanks to that reflection, we are able to correct aspects of our appearance. Now, regarding non conceptual consciousnesses, all of our sensory consciousnesses are non conceptual. What is meant by there being non conceptual is that they perceive exclusively the present. They can neither perceive the past nor the future and the objects they perceive, they perceive without relying on a mental image.

They perceive them nakedly. Whereas conceptuality necessarily perceives its object by means of a mental image. Then both conceptual and non conceptual minds are present within our mind stream. This is a distinction between them and it is something which is of benefit for us to reflect about. Okay.

Now moving onwards to the minds arisen from meditation. There is two subdivisions of minds arisen from meditation. Minds arisen from meditation which are focused on objects and minds arisen from meditation which are focused on subjects. Minds arisen from meditation focused on objects would be for instance, the mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence or the transitoriness of phenomena. Minds arisen from meditation focused on subjects would be focused for instance on great compassion, bodhicitta and so forth, which are states of mind.

Minds arisen from meditation which are focused on subjects such as for instance, focused on great compassion involve the mind being turned into what it is focused upon. In other words, the mind becomes or falls under the sway of great compassion. And whatever one does, one does under the power of great compassion, not for hours or even days or even weeks or even months, but for years on end. This is a mind arisen from meditation focused on great compassion. So it is therefore very important here to understand that the mind arisen from meditation which is focused on great compassion is a mind arisen from meditation which is focused on a subject and not an object.

It’s focused on a subject, in other words, a mind and in the process it becomes that mind. Otherwise, if it were focused on an object, then this would mean that we would have to focus on the totality of sentient beings in this world to generate great compassion for them which is not possible. Now regarding the mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence. Such a mind would be focused single pointedly on impermanence and in addition would be focused uninterruptedly for a long period of time on impermanence. Such a mind is said to be a mind arisen from meditation which is focused on an object, not a subject.

So when it is said that we should rely on minds arisen from meditation, This clearly would not apply to sense objects such as form, sounds and so forth. Instead, it would apply to topics one had studied and what would initially need to give rise to a mind arisen from hearing regarding the subject. In dependence on that will give rise to a mind arisen from thinking and as a valid cognizer realizing that object. And in dependence on that will give rise to a mind arisen from meditation focused on that object. So for ourselves therefore, when we meditate on the Lamrim, we should check whether the focus we have on the Lamrim is a mind arisen from hearing or not.

It is a mind arisen from thinking or not. And finally, if it is a mind arisen from meditation or not, then for ourselves, minds arisen from meditation are difficult, almost impossible to access. Some maybe do have access to them. Do you understand? And therefore we should check has a mind arisen from hearing being generated or not?

Has a mind arisen from thinking been generated or not? And what is very difficult? Has a mind arisen from meditation been generated or not? Minds arisen from the meditation are extremely difficult to generate since when a mind arisen from meditation has been generated within our mental continuum, a new totally new line of thought arises, a new view of things. And now in brief, what was presented today was first the three trainings.

The training in ethics, concentration and wisdom. And it is for us to examine whether the totality of the Lamrim can or can not be subsumed within the three trainings. And secondly, the three types of mind, the mind arisen from hearing, from thinking and from meditation. Then I believe that when one tries to apply the framework of the minds arisen from hearing, thinking and meditation to the Lamrim. And specifically to meditation on the Lamrim.

Overview meditations, Chagom in Tibetan would probably be exclusively minds arisen from hearing. Then, contrived experiences of a topic of Lamrim would be minds arisen from thinking and uncontrived experiences of a topic of Lamrim would be minds arisen from meditation. Let us therefore now meditate during a couple of minutes on the three trainings and on the three types of mind. Please open the prayer book, page one. We want to recite one, b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six Mandala offering, verse one and three.

Thank you. So therefore, the practice of the being of the small scope is subsumed within the training in ethics and the practices of the beings of the middling and of the great scope are subsumed within the trainings in concentration and wisdom. So the path of the being of the small scope is subsumed within the training in ethics because the main aspect of the path of the being of the small scope is the pure protection of an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. If such an ethics is present, probably one has gained the realizations of the path of the being of the small scope. Now the reason for the which the path of the being of the middling scope is said to be included within the trainings of concentration and of wisdom is because the foundation of that path is a generation of uncontrived definite emergence.

And uncontrived definite emergence arises in dependence on calm abiding, which is the mind arisen through meditation. Therefore, the path of the being of the middling scope is included within the trainings of concentration and wisdom, likewise for the path of the being of the great scope. Okay. So I will take questions at present. I would like to ask you to ask pure questions, in other words, questions on topic.

One question per person only. And when everyone has finished asking their questions, if there’s time, you can ask another question. Okay. Mhmm. So is he?

Speakers. The the meditation is with conceptual and non-conceptual. Is it both together, or is it exclusive? No, there is no mind which is both conceptual and non conceptual at the same time. Minds which are arisen from meditation can either be conceptual or non conceptual.

Just as for instance in this temple, we have both Westerners and Asians. We have no one who is at the same time a Westerner and an Asian. After you. Geshe-la, could I clarify please? I think at the beginning tonight you said that minds arisen from meditation were not of the desire realm, they were of the higher realms.

But towards the end I think I understood that it is possible for someone in the desire realm to have a mind arisen from meditation. Yes, indeed. Broadly speaking, minds arisen from meditation are minds of the higher realms. However, even though we ourselves are beings of the desire realm and at present within our mind stream, there is no mind of the higher realm. Nonetheless, through training our minds through repeated habituation and meditation, we can generate these minds from the higher realms eventually.

The reference to the yellow garment, was that a valid cogniser from sensory perception, or would that be a non conceptual mind? Oh, a non conceptual mind. Yes. The mind which perceives the yellow color of my yellow monastic garment is a sensory cognizer and it sensory is direct cognizer. We would have an agreement that this is yellow because we’ve been taught that it’s yellow.

So wouldn’t that be a concept? The easiest way to think about it is that the bare appearance of that yellow color to your eye consciousness is an appearance of yellow to a visual consciousness. It’s non conceptual. But when you go home and you reflect about this monastic vestment and you think it is yellow and that color appears to your mind, that is conceptual. Regarding the, mind arisen from meditation, focusing single pointedly on an object such as impermanence.

It seems to me that impermanence has numerous objects of observation within that topic. So I’m finding it hard to understand how a mind could focus single pointedly on what appears to be numerous objects of observation. When we say for instance that mind arisen from meditation is focused on coarse impermanence. What that means is that such a mind is not only focused uninterruptedly on coarse impermanence but in addition, one experiences no physical or mental hardship while focusing on coarse impermanence. The sequence for giving rise to a mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence or the four noble truths is a probably a definite sequence.

One must initially give rise to a mind arisen from hearing focused on the topic then to a mind arisen from thinking then to a mind arisen from meditation. However, when we speak of a mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence, we are really speaking of a mind arisen from meditation focused on subtle impermanence. And one initially gives rise to a mind arisen from thinking focused on subtle impermanence then to a mind arisen from meditation focused on subtle impermanence. Now, a confusion may arise when we speak of minds of the higher realms. A calm abiding for instance is definitely a mind of the higher realm.

It’s for us to check whether calm abiding is present or not within our mind stream. But if it is present, that does not mean that we are beings of the higher realms. All it means is that we have a state of mind characteristic of the higher realms within our mind stream. I’m not quite sure how to put this as a question, but maybe Geshe-la could comment on the observation that in summarizing the teachings in terms of the small scope can be summarized in the training and ethics, the middling scope concentration and wisdom, the great scope concentration of wisdom. Ethics is also within the middling scope, if I understand correctly.

When it’s underpinned by definite emergence, it’s a higher training in ethics. And then it also is a perfection of ethics as one of the six perfections. What does that say about the significance of ethics, I suppose, within the three scopes? So yours is a good question here when we refer to the training in ethics, we are specifically and only referring to an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. We are not referring to Bodhisattva or Tantric ethics.

Ethics in general is threefold. We have Prātimokṣa ethics, the ethics of individual liberation. Paramita, bodhisattva ethics, and tantric ethics. That is a separate issue. Regarding your question, your question arises from a confusion between the direct perception which perceives the color yellow and the conceptual mind which says this is yellow and is induced by that direct perception.

The direct perception which perceives the color yellow just sees the appearance of yellow nakedly without a name. Then in dependence on that, a conceptual mind which recognizes yellow as yellow arises. This is a very common confusion. So it is a confusion which is addressed in-depth in the sevenfold treatises on Pramāna, the example which is given is the visual consciousness which perceives the color of a cup. That visual consciousness merely perceives the color of the cup, nothing else.

But that induces a conceptual mind which is actually a memory recollecting what cups are which identifies this as a cup. The conceptual excuse me. The non conceptual sensory consciousness which sees the color yellow of Geshe-la’s monastic robe is followed almost instantaneously by a conceptual mind which identifies this as a yellow monastic vestment. Because the time interval between these two states of mind is so short, they are often confused but they are different. Then when your questions are pure, I can give this type of clear answer.

If your questions are impure, then I would have to think before providing an answer. Geshe-la, what type of body does being in the pure realm have? And is there a difference in the experience of calm abiding for being at the form realm as compared to being at the formless realm? So regarding your first question on the bodies of beings in the Pure Lands, Obviously, is something one can only answer based on texts. We have no direct experience.

But beings in the Pure Lands are probably or do not probably experience birth from a womb. In other words, mammalian birth. Instead, they are born by miraculous birth. Then they do not consume ordinary coarse food but instead consume the food of concentration. Regarding your second question, the distinction between calm abiding in the form and the formless realms.

The distinction is in terms of the object of calm abiding. One is a coarse object, The other is not a coarse object. And yeah. Can Geshe-la give an example of a conceptual mind and a nonconceptual mind that is arisen through meditation? That is has arisen through meditation.

So if we take the example of impermanence as an object of meditation, a conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence would be a mind which is focused single pointedly on impermanence but does not see it nakedly, sees it through a mental image of impermanence. Whereas a non conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on impermanence would see that impermanence or for instance emptiness in a completely naked non conceptual direct fashion. Then for those of you who have studied Sa Lam grounds and paths, there is a much simpler explanation. The minds arisen from meditation of the path of preparation are all conceptual. The minds arisen from meditation of the path of seeing and meditation are all non conceptual.

Then if you study the five and the fifteenfold subdivision of the paths and Sa Lam, then this understanding of conceptual, non conceptual minds becomes very easy. You apply it to the paths. It’s just a follow on from my previous question. Given everything that’s been said tonight about minds arisen from meditation and calm abiding, could you comment on the kind of calm abiding then I believe is necessary to enter the path of preparation? I believe last night it was said that to enter the path of preparation you must have calm abiding.

So what could you comment on what kind of calm abiding that is? So there is much to be said about this. But in brief, the interval, between the moment, when one has entered the middling path of accumulation, and the moment at which one has attained a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness is interval of the middling path of accumulation.. But wasn’t it my question, Leah, it was wasn’t it said last night that to enter the path of preparation, you needed a calm abiding, not a calm abiding focused on emptiness.

I was wondering what is that calm abiding if they’re so difficult to attain? No. One one will have obtained calm abiding before entering the path of preparation. At the first instant of the path of preparation, one will need an insight focused on emptiness. So from the first moment of the great path of accumulation onwards, one has attained a calm abiding focused on emptiness.

However, when one engages in the practice of insight analysis within the context of that calm abiding focused on emptiness and one tries to continue to analyze for long, that analysis harms the calm abiding and distracts the mind from its object. When one reaches a point where that analysis in no way distracts the mind from its object and in addition, the physical and mental bliss of pliancy induced by analysis are generated, at that point one would have entered the path of preparation. So, calm abiding is a mind which does not analyze. It is focused single pointedly on its object. Wisdom on the other hand analyzes.

So these two, abiding and insight are actually contradictory. Their functions are different. Sorry, Geshe-la. My mistake. I just realized what I was meaning was the very first part of the examination.

Sorry. I said preparation. Met last night that you needed calm abiding to enter the past. No problem. Both the path of accumulation and preparation are important, so listen carefully.

Then regarding Natalie’s question on the Pure Lands, don’t think of the Pure Lands as magnificent realms with great buildings and so forth. That is really not the correct outlook. When we concentrate and focus eventually that experience within ourselves, that is what gives rise to the pure lands. As the mind through habituation is purified evermore, evermore subtle appearances will appear to that mind. Okay.

Goodbye here tonight. Thank you so very much. Please open the page nine. Eight b, nine, ten, eleven, twelve. Sorry, things happening here in Adelaide.

Key terms in this teaching

desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

In meditation, can a mind be both conceptual and non-conceptual at the same time, or are the two mutually exclusive?

No mind is both conceptual and non-conceptual at the same time. The two are mutually exclusive. Minds that arise from meditation can be either conceptual or non-conceptual, but never both together. As an example, in a temple there may be both Westerners and Asians present, yet no one is at the same time a Westerner and an Asian. In the same way, a given mind falls into one category or the other.

Scroll to Top