Awakening Heart — 01112016SALAM 2 2 – KR

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 01112016SALAM 2 2 - KR
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 01112016SALAM 2 2 – KR.mp3

UUID: ffb77e56-98bc-4607-95e7-7a3e3450de99

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 5m

Words: 2,518

So there is a verse in Mahayana Sutra Lampara which defines Bodhicitta as that mind endowed with twin aspirations. So this stanza of Mahayashutra Lama Khara which refers to a a which refers to a special mind which is endowed with the twin aspirations is that which was taught. Then one can encapsulate the totality of the Lamrim, the path shared with the beings of the small, the middling, and the path of the being of the great scope within this notion of the twin aspirations. So often when we reflect on the Lamrim, we do not really feel a resonance with the path of the being of the small, the middling of the great or the great scope. We don’t really have an experience of the path of the being of the small scope for instance.

But it is said in texts that there is really a profound meaning to this definition of conventional Bodhicitta as a special mind endowed with both aspirations. Are you warming? You must be cold then. Yeah, then yeah. Okay.

I think. It’s better. You’re more asleep, right? Yeah. Then the totality of the Lamrim is encapsulated in this definition.

We often separate the paths of the beings of the three scopes on the one hand and Salam, the five paths and the 10 grounds on the other hand. But if we ask ourselves what precisely lies in the background or the backdrop of the 10 grounds, it is actually great compassion and bodhicitta. And we can see at once the connection with the lama. So the definition of conventional bodhicitta, a special mind endowed with both aspirations refers as far as the first aspiration is concerned to the cause of Bodhicitta which is none other than great compassion. Then when we move downwards from the cause of great compassion, we can move downwards through the paths of the beings of all three scopes.

And the proximate cause of great compassion is definite emergence. Now here, it is important when we refer to great compassion that it not be merely something verbal. It is instead something which must be experienced. His willingness to Dharai Lama emphasizes greatly this definition of conventional bodhicitta is special mind endowed with both aspirations. And it is a definition which in addition is rooted in text.

It is therefore a definition which we should understand. I think here none of us do not understand both aspirations at present. He’s strong. Have a clear mind, limpid mind. Uh-huh.

I am excited to somebody. Excited? So, please do not doze off and fall asleep, instead you should generate a vivid, a strong mind, literally be excited by the topic. So, this is for the definition of conventional bodhicitta, a special mind endowed with both factors. Now, bodhisattvas are beings, who have great courage.

They are called the, scions of the conquerors. But really the only distinction between Bodhisattvas and Prateka Buddha, solitary realizers or hearers is the presence or the absence of bodhicitta. Apart from this, there is no distinction. It is therefore this bodhicitta which is the root of their extraordinary mental fortitude. So this in this definition of conventional bodhicitta, a special mind endowed with both aspiration.

The first aspiration is the aspiration to enact the weal of others or to benefit others and the second aspiration is the aspiration for full and utter enlightenment. The first aspiration to enact the weal of others or to help others refers to great compassion, which is the cause of conventional bodhicitta. And great compassion itself is rooted in the paths of the being of the middling and the small scope. Since the cause of great compassion is definite emergence, and definite emergence is the main practice of the being of the middling scope. Therefore, the great and the middling scope are linked and both are rooted in the small scope.

So we finished all of So what are these twin aspirations? The first aspiration aspiring for enacting the will of others is the cause of Bodhicitta. It amounts to great compassion. And the second aspiration aspiring or wishing for full and utter enlightenment is the nature of Bodhicitta. Since the object of observation of bodhicitta is full and utter enlightenment.

So, this is why the three verses in the three principles of the path state, Moreover, should definite emergence not be upheld by pure bodhicitta in as much as it will not become the cause for full and utter enlightenment, bodhisattvas train in bodhichitta. So here the term moreover is very profound. And when one refers to definite emergence, one refers to uncontrived definite emergence. Uphel here means that Bodhicitta and specifically great compassion lie in the background of definite emergence, and there is therefore a mutual relationship between definite emergence. Definite emergence acts as a cause for great compassion, but great compassion relies itself on definite emergence.

In addition, the notion of the twin aspirations is probably rooted in a stanza of Nagarjuna’s Ratnavali in which Nagarjuna states that to attain full and utter enlightenment, it is necessary to rely on bodhicitta. Moreover, the meaning of the definition of conventional bodhicitta, a special mind which is endowed with both aspirations means that this is a mind which relying on bodhicitta, relying excuse me on great compassion wishes for full and utter enlightenment. So what is the meaning of conventional bodhicitta? Please speak altogether. So you have said precisely what it was and one should reflect carefully on the meaning here of the two aspirations which you have stated.

Then here when we speak of aspiring in Tibetan, we are referring to wishing the term is the same as the term used for desire. It’s better not to translate it as desire but the root is the same. So, once one has generated an uncontrived, in other words, a stable special mind which is endowed with both aspirations. Then one has generated within one’s mind stream the path of accumulation of the Mahayana. One has become a person on the path of accumulation of the Mahayana.

So here once one has therefore generated for the first time an uncontrived mind which is endowed with both aspirations. One has generated within one’s mind stream a Mahayana path of accumulation. One has become a person on a Mahayana path of accumulation. From that point onwards, and here one is referring to the future tense of the verb. From that point onwards, all of the states of mind such as great compassion, generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration, and wisdom, which are generated within one’s mind stream become Mahayana paths of accumulation.

So at this point, one can say that great compassion is a Mahayana path of accumulation. So therefore in the backdrop, in the background of the Mahayana path of accumulation lies conventional bodhicitta. Have already Shiva has already explained the transition to the Mahayana path of preparation, of seeing, and of meditation. But to repeat, once for the first time one has generated with conventional Bodhicitta in the backdrop, a concentration which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. At that point, one will have entered the path of preparation of the Mahayana.

Now, concentrations which are inseparable unions of calm abiding and insight can either be conceptual or non conceptual. While this concentration is conceptual, one remains on the Mahayana path of preparation. When through repeated habituation eventually for the first time, one gains a concentration, which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight and which is non conceptual, focused on emptiness, with conventional Bodhicitta in the backdrop, then one would have entered the Mahayana path of seeing. So, we have already explained all this material, but in brief, what is the meaning of the path of accumulation? Just the passive accumulation, the passive preparation.

So the meaning, yes, that is appropriate. The meaning is an insight focused on emptiness. So now? Path of seeing. Yes.

Yes. The direct realization of emptiness. So generally speaking, inseparable unions of calm abiding and insight can either be conceptual or non conceptual. When they are conceptual and focused on emptiness, one is on the path of preparation. When they become non conceptual, one has entered on the path of seeing.

Or you might want to think as follows, when motivated by bodhicitta for the first time, one generates an insight focused on emptiness. One has entered the path of preparation of the Mahayana and when motivated by Bodhicitta, one has generated for the first time a direct realization of emptiness. One has entered the path of seeing of the Mahayana. So regarding the concise definitions of the paths of preparation and seeing, when the path of preparation is defined as a clear realization of the meaning. The meaning refers to emptiness and a clear realization refers probably to insight.

In the concise definition of the path of seeing, the clear realization of truth. Here truth also refers to emptiness and clear realization probably refers to the direct realization. Now on the Mahayana path of seeing, one must abandon the abandonments of the path of seeing. So here if we analyze the process of perception when we perceive phenomena independence on the sensory consciousnesses, this sensory perception eventually induces conceptual minds. Now, when we perceive phenomena, phenomena are actually perceived as existing from their own side.

And we endorse this perception of phenomena from their own side. If I were to ask you, do phenomena exist or phenomena established from their own side? You would all say yes because otherwise, you would say it is impossible for things to function. We would just sit around without being able to do anything. Now this mental endorsement of phenomena being established from their own side is imputed grasping at true existence.

So here therefore, how precisely are the abandonments of the path of seeing abandoned on the path of seeing? They are abandoned independent on a concentration which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness and which is non conceptual. This concentration abandons the grasping at imputed true existence. But even though imputed true existence is abandoned, nonetheless phenomena continue to appear to our sensory consciousnesses as if they were established from their own side. When precisely is this abandoned?

This innate grasping at true existence is abandoned on the path of meditation. And this is why the path of meditation is in brief defined as subsequent clear realization. Now, what precisely is the path of meditation subdivided into? To subdivided into 10 grounds. Why precisely are there 10 grounds?

There are 10 grounds recording because there are 10 objects of abandonment on these grounds. So in brief, what are the five grounds and the five paths and the 10 grounds of the Mahayana? They are nothing else than on the foundation of bodhicitta, the repeated application of the antidotes to the ignorance grasping at an eye. Now what are these antidotes to the ignorance grasping at an eye? None other than the wisdom realizing selflessness.

And here, through repeated habituation, in other words meditation, these objects of abandonment are progressively abandoned. And in the context of talking about meditation, I would like to talk about the input importance of recollection or memory. Actually speaking of a recollection which recollects emptiness. It is insufficient to have a mere intellectual understanding of emptiness. Instead, one needs in addition this memory of emptiness and it must be a continuous recollection of emptiness.

This continuous recollection of emptiness is what will act as antidote to all of the afflictions within our mind stream such as pride, desire, avarice and so forth. So when we speak of memory or recollection, we are referring to non forgetfulness. Some of you may have heard of the of non forgetfulness. And here, a continuous recollection means a mental continuum of non forgetfulness in this case of emptiness. So here, when one refers to a continuum of recollection, this is a continuum of memory within the mental continuum.

And it is important to point out that without a mental continuum, a continuum of consciousness, we cannot posit persons such as I or you. So the way in which the mental continuum is posited on the basis of memory becomes clearer with an example. Let’s take the example of TBI’s kitchen And let us imagine. Let’s imagine that Tenzin goes in the kitchen and he sees breakfast or tea and which was made yesterday. And he says, this is yesterday’s breakfast or tea.

Mhmm. It is through memory that he realizes this is yesterday’s breakfast or tea. And at that point, he thinks, I ate this breakfast or I drank this tea yesterday. He has posited the object, thanks to memory or recollection, and he’s positing the subject, thanks to memory or recollection as well. You can see how subtle the understanding of Prasanika Madhyamika is in this context.

So this is a bit difficult for us to understand, but I think if we reflect on it over and again, it will become clearer. It is important to understand how in Prasanika Madhyamika, the person is posited on the basis of recollection and the continuum of consciousness. If there was no recollection of the past or the future person, there would not be a past and future person. Here, however, the person is not the same as the continuum of consciousness. It is said to be of one nature, but different isolates.

Baking and and eggs. A cousin is going to the kitchen for a big breakfast and I said, Rakesh, it has to be bacon and eggs. So let us imagine that Tenzin is in the kitchen and someone comes in the room and is observing what unfolds. And Tenzin sees yesterday’s breakfast on the table and he looks at it and he thinks, I this is the breakfast I ate yesterday. In so doing, through memory, the object is posited.

And then he thinks, I ate this breakfast yesterday. Through memory, again, the subject is posited. You can see in this way how the continuum of consciousness is posited independent on memory or recollection. Do you understand? Do you understand?

Sorry. This is how independence on the continuum of consciousness which is generated through memory, the person is posited. Then in the self same way when we speak of a concentration, which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight or an insight focused on emptiness, we are referring to a memory of the object of observation. Then what precisely, recollection of memory is within the sevenfold division of, loric of mind and awareness is debatable. Generally, it’s considered to be a subsequent cognizer.

So let us now meditate during a couple of minutes on how the continuum of consciousness arises in dependence on memory. So today no questions, only debate. The two topics are the meaning and function of recollection and the four paths. The Mahayana path of accumulation, preparation, seeing and meditation. Okay.

No. J here. J here.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top