44 min · 3,822 words · 25 February 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Pema Tsering opens this 45-minute commentary with Lama Tsongkhapa’s teaching on rejoicing in merit: mentally celebrating the good deeds of Buddhas, bodhisattvas, hearers, solitary realizers, and ordinary beings — across past, present, and future — accumulates vast virtue with minimal effort. He contrasts this with the common habit of mentally rehearsing grievances (“meditating on anger”) and shows how cultivating joy in others’ virtue steadily erodes the ten non-virtues. Turning to the Heart Sūtra text, he unpacks the five aggregates as empty of inherent existence, using a concrete car analogy: however carefully you search, you cannot find “carness” among its parts, yet the car exists as a conventional label — the Madhyamaka middle way between nihilism and eternalism.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 13 HS 2003 02 25.mp3
UUID: 50c3118d-526b-49f9-a861-06e9b96cc234
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Heart Sūtra (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2003-02-25
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45.0 minutes
Words: ~3,818
Oh, yeah. As Lama Tsongkhapa said, if you want to reap, if you want to collect a large amount of merit for very little effort, then the best thing to do is to rejoice in other people’s good deeds or rejoice in good deeds. The reason that he said this is because it the accumulation of merit through rejoicing in other people’s good deeds is one of the best ways for us to accumulate a root of virtue. If we don’t participate in that, the things that we do that are actually creating merit won’t amount to that much. So the best thing for us to do in terms of creating merit is to rejoice in other people’s good deeds or other people’s and our own good deeds.
So even if we don’t actually like doing that much practice ourselves, we can get merit by just rejoicing in other people’s actions quite apart from that, if we don’t rejoice in other people’s actions, if we say, yeah, well, what’s that gonna come to? Then that actually becomes a non virtue. So in order to stop that non virtue coming about, in order for us to collect merits and to cultivate our roots of virtue, then we should be trying to rejoice in every little thing that people do, no matter what it is. So the the the idea is that if we if we just do things our own way and don’t think about what the things that other people are doing, then we don’t have the opportunity to create a lot of merit. So and the other thing is that if we don’t rejoice and if we say, that’s not that good an idea and when people other people are participating in virtue, then actually becomes a big non virtue.
So if we make a practice of rejoicing in other people’s virtue, then that becomes a positive thing for our mind and we create a lot of merit. The other thing is that when we’re doing this, we shouldn’t be just thinking about human beings or the people around us, the people that we see in everyday life and thinking about the good things that they do. There is actually five different types of beings in the world. There is Buddhas, there’s Bodhisattvas, there’s hearers, there’s solitary realizers and there are ordinary beings. So when we’re rejoicing in the merit of beings, we should be trying to take into account all five different groups of these and trying to get a mind that is very happy about the fact that they’ve done that.
So we should be trying to meditate on being happy about it. I’m trying to think of a way to translate it, it’s like meditate on being happy about being pleased with other people’s virtue and other virtuous things that people have done. So, this practice of rejoicing in other people’s merits is a really good meditation practice, it’s a really good way of getting a lot of merit without doing a lot of work. It becomes like a good tool for creating merit because even if we don’t want to do a lot of practice, even if we don’t have a mind that’s inclined towards that if we just merely think about all the good things that other people have done and meditate on that then we’re accumulating a lot of a lot of merit without putting out that much effort or without putting in that much effort so if we think about like that even the fact that we’re getting a lot of merit for not doing much should make us happy. So therefore, that can make us more happy to think about other people’s merit and goes like a cycle.
The other thing that rejoicing in other people’s merit does is it decreases the negativities in our mind stream. So we may think that that we actually have to put in effort ourselves to as well as rejoicing in other people’s merit, but this actually comes about because if we’re concentrating on other people’s good qualities and rejoicing in all the good things that they’ve done, then our ten non virtues, habits of doing the ten non virtues, our predispositions towards doing the ten non virtues actually lessen because our mind is full of joy from rejoicing in other people’s good deeds. Because most of the ten non virtues actually come from these concepts of anger and fear and things like that which actually come from a sense of hatred of some form. So if we are always rejoicing in what other people are doing and thinking about the positive things that other people are doing, then these things go down and down and down because our mind is full of joy. So even if we think, well, we don’t have a lot of merit, we haven’t done a lot of good things, we haven’t got much going for us in the way of merit, then if we’re trying to concentrate on what other people are doing then even if we we can’t let ourselves get down about the fact that we have no merit for ourselves because we have the opportunity to rejoice in in all the other beings merit and by rejoicing in their merit we can think well by the the merit that I’m creating by rejoicing in their merit, may I please attain enlightenment and be able to be of benefit to all sentient beings.
Because most of the time we actually meditate on anger. We have this idea of a lot of the times we meditate on anger we sit there thinking you know I really don’t like that guy he really annoyed me. What he did was really rude and I’m gonna go and say something to him. Yeah. I’m really gonna go and say something to him, and we go over and over again in our heads, and this is like meditating on anger, but if we’re concentrating on joy, then this idea of meditating on anger gets less and less.
And we actually have a habit at this stage of meditating on anger, of concentrating on anger. So really, if we think about it, this habit where we have of meditating on anger isn’t doing any harm to the other person. We’re not hurting their source of merit, we’re hurting our own source of merit. So this idea that we’re if we can get back at them in some way doesn’t work because we’re only hurting ourselves by doing this meditating on anger process, thinking about anger all the time. So if we have this, if we’re meditating on anger in this way and thinking about it all the time and pondering on about how much harm this other person has done to us.
We have to change the way we’re thinking and instead think that this person is only hurting us. No. First of all, we have to think that if I hurt them, then I’m gonna create negativity and they’re gonna get angry at me and they’re gonna create negativity so there’s gonna be this spiral of negativity between us. We have to think in that way and in order to stop that then we have to think well it’s not actually them that is hurting me, it’s the fact that they have negativities in their mind stream and they’re they’re under the power of karma and delusion in the same way that I’m under the power of karma and delusion so it’s the karma and delusion both of our karma and delusions are actually the problem and that we both are suffering because of our karma and delusions so then have a sense of compassion for the person that you’re angry at and a sense of compassion for yourself. And so we we should we have to be thinking that the things that are coming from their mind they’re not inherently existent they don’t exist from their own side they exist from our side so therefore they’re not an actual enemy that we have to destroy there is something that is caused by these delusions and so there’s something that we should have pity for it and at the same time if we have this idea if we have other negative emotions come up we can go through the same process in order to eliminate these negative emotions and then by doing that and then conjunction with that doing this process of rejoicing in the little good things that people do then things that we’re going to do that negative become things that we could do that are positive.
So that we can think that by us rejoicing in this, in the deeds of other beings, that we can do things in the future, can get enough merit to be able to do things, we can do practice, we can study, we can do all these things that will be of more benefit to our mind streams and if we’re thinking all of these with the idea that we’re doing all of it including the rejoicing in other people’s actions in order to be of benefit to all sentient beings then this becomes a really powerful way of changing our mind. And on top of that, we’re not just rejoicing in a limited thing. Not only do you have the five roots of virtue, the five collections of virtue of the five beings that we talked about before, Buddhas, bodhisattvas, hearers, solitary realizers and ordinary beings, but it’s also the the roots of virtue of these five types of beings from the past, from the present, and from what they can do in the future. So we’re talking about something that’s like an enormous concept that is all based on them doing meritorious and good things. So it becomes a very vast practice for us to try and cultivate in our mind and therefore becomes very beneficial.
So if we just want to go to sleep for instance and if we think before we go to sleep, yes, we start rejoicing in all the good things that these five different types of being have done, even the action of sleeping becomes something, it becomes something that is like a good a good mind to have in our mind streams, so that makes the whole time we’re asleep a virtuous action. So sleeping becomes a virtuous action. So this is really good because we don’t have to work really hard and we can be creating lots of merit. So we don’t have to we’re not really able even at this stage to work really hard, but we we can rejoice in other people’s and we don’t actually feel like working that hard most of the time, So this is a good way to create merit without having to do that. So at the moment we’re studying the Heart Sūtra and we may be thinking well I don’t kind of get the point of doing this because I’m not going to become an expert on emptiness in this life and this could be really difficult to get my head to try to be able to understand the Heart Sūtra properly in this life and then you may start thinking well what’s the point of studying it?
But the if you’re thinking this, then you can start thinking that rejoicing in the fact that you’re studying it, and that can turn your mind around even now. Okay, so the best thing for us to be thinking then in this case is that hopefully by studying this text now I can put some imprints in my mind so that later I can be able to understand it properly and then I can meditate on it properly and by meditating on it properly then I can reach Buddhahood in order to be able to help all sentient beings. So if we think in this way then it brings a lot of meaning to studying the text at the moment. So we should be thinking that by studying this, at the least, may I come back here in the next life as a god or a human, and if we are able, then we should also be thinking, may this be a cause for me to attain liberation and in the best possible circumstances if we’re able we should be thinking may studying this text become a cause for me to achieve enlightenment. So we can be thinking that by studying this text, may I be studying this text for the benefit of all sentient beings who are just like me, are stuck in Samsāra and they are suffering.
So by studying this text may I be able to achieve Buddhahood in order to separate them from this suffering. And with this thought in mind we should now meditate. Okay. First, before Geshe-la starts, have to say that I made two mistakes last week, and I just thought that I’d let everyone know so in case it was wrong in your notes and everything. The first one was that out of the four non virtues of speech, I got one of those wrong.
They were lying. That’s the first of the four. Then slander or divisive speech is the second. And then the third one was harsh speech, which I left out and said one was slander and one was divisive speech. And the fourth one is speaking nonsense.
That was one mistake. And the other mistake was that the fourth of the five aggregates is actually compositional factors, mental constructions or intellect and I said compounded phenomena. I just thought I should tell you that in case it’s in your notes wrong. Right. Now I can start this week’s.
So, last week we went through the question that Śāriputra actually asked Avalokiteśvara and that was: How should a person of the Mahāyāna vehicle practice the Prajñāpāramitā or perfection of wisdom view in order to be able to achieve Buddhahood. So that was the essence of his question to Avalokiteśvara that we went through last week. What we have to remember is that it’s not actually Avalokiteśvara that’s answering this. Avalokiteśvara was only speaking by the blessings of the Buddha. So the words that are coming from Avalokiteśvara are actually the teaching of the Buddha, not directly from Avalokiteśvara. So from this section, starts with: Address in this way, Noble Avalokiteśvara, the bodhisattva, said to Venerable Śāriputra, O Śāriputra, a son or daughter of noble family who wishes to practice the profound Prajñāpāramitā should see in this way.
Up until they see in this way is actually just a reiteration of the question that Śāriputra asked him. And then from there, where it says, Seeing the five skandhas or aggregates, and to be empty of nature also, that is So then from that point on, from form is emptiness, emptiness is also form onwards until the Buddha says, yes, it is so. That’s actually the extended answer that Avalokiteśvara gave Śāriputra. So it doesn’t actually come through in the first translation that I read from here, but in another one where it says, They should see perfectly that even the five aggregates are empty of intrinsic existence. Then they’re saying that they’re even.
Why it says even the five aggregates is because it’s not just referring to the aggregates themselves, but it’s referring to the sense of I that comes from the aggregates and the sense of mine that also comes from the aggregates. So, this sense of I and mine then can be related to the two selflessnesses of being the selflessness of the person and the selflessness of phenomena and it’s set in this way so people can have an understanding of the two selflessnesses in the order that they’re supposed to meditate and understand them. I. E. First of all understanding the selflessness of the person and then after that understanding the selflessness of phenomena which is here symbolized by the idea of my my things or my as opposed to I.
I’m going to find them because I’m not gonna say the five aggregates wrong again. Right. Okay. Now we’re right. Okay.
Okay. So the next part where it says to be empty of their nature, what it means in seeing that they’re empty of their nature, the word is means that from their own side they don’t exist and that from an objective side, the label that we put on them, they don’t exist. So therefore, it is showing that these two sides are empty of something and what it is that they’re empty of is the emptiness of true existence or emptiness of their own nature. Right? Or they are empty by nature.
You can translate either way. Right and so what it is that is empty of nature is the five aggregates. So you have to say that the aggregate of form is empty of its own nature, empty from its own side and has anything that we label on it is also empty and the aggregate of feeling is also empty from its own side and it’s empty of any label that we put on it and aggregate of mental constructs as well as compositional factors and consciousness are all empty of their own inherent nature and empty of the labels that we may put on them. So we have to see it serially and go through it in this way. So the example that’s used is the idea of, when we’re dreaming, like if we see a house in our dream, the house the dream house doesn’t actually exist, but our mind labels it as existing the way that in our dreams, lots of people come and go in our dreams, but the people aren’t actually there and when we wake up, we don’t see them.
But in our dreams, we’re labeling all the different people going, oh, that’s so and so and that’s so and so, but they’re not actually there. It’s just our mind labeling them. Okay, we have to say that they’re empty by their that they don’t inherently exist. So when we see something of being form then that is inherent, is empty of its own nature and doesn’t inherently exist. We have to say that it exists because we can see it but it doesn’t inherently exist, but it doesn’t in the way that we see it because every time that we see form, we see it as being inherently existed existent.
So even though that we Every time we look places and everywhere we go, we see all different kinds of form, we’re not trying to say that they don’t exist at all because we experience them but if you we can say that they don’t inherently exist because if you went to look for the their inherent existence, the thing that makes them inherently exist, no matter where you looked, you wouldn’t be able to find them. Despite the fact that everywhere we go we experience form and see form, if we actually tried to look for it, no matter how much we looked, we wouldn’t be able to find it. Okay. So for example, there’s cars around here. We have cars, we use cars, we say I’m gonna go in the car.
Right? And if we started saying well, there’s no car, it would make us a little bit it would be it would be a bit scary and our mind would be a bit how would you say not unsayable, our mind would be a little bit distressed, yeah? Because there’s no car. So, we wouldn’t have this thought of I’m going in the car because there’s no car, right? But then if we so we can’t cope with concept very well.
So we say oh there’s a car because I’m going in the car therefore there’s a car, right? But if we actually went to try and find the essence of car, if we actually went to try and find the car, we would not be able to find it, right? So but because we can’t cope with there being no car, we just say I’m going in the car, there’s car, we have this concept in our mind all the time that there’s car. So if we went looking for the car, we didn’t find it, there’s no source of the car, there’s no carness of car, we may get a little bit confused, but then the idea is not that we’re completely negating car, but there is a car, a merely labeled car, it’s just that the car itself doesn’t exist at all, it only exists as a label, by our label of car. So, what we mean when we say that we’re only labeling a car is that if we look into a car, we can’t say the wheel is the car, we can’t say the seats of the car, we can’t say the motor is the car, we can’t say the doors of the car or anything, or the skin of the car, the outside of the car, the shell of the car is the car.
When we say car, the thing that we’re labeling car is actually an amalgamation of all these different parts that we’re calling car. But we can’t find an essence of car because it’s just the amalgamation of different parts when we label it. So when we say car, we’re labeling the car car. The car isn’t coming towards us from its side. We’re labeling a collection of parts as being car, and the car as itself doesn’t exist as an entity within itself.
So if we say the car doesn’t exist at all, but it’s not there, then we’re saying that then we’re having danger of slipping into the extreme of nihilism by saying car is a non existent. But we’re not saying the car is a non existent. We’re just trying to stop ourselves from falling into the other extreme which is extreme of eternalism or the extreme of seeing as though they actually exist. Seeing things as if they have an essence and a root within them that makes them actually exist. So by saying that the car doesn’t actually exist, we negate the extreme of eternalism as well.
Okay. So the car doesn’t actually exist. It doesn’t exist in the way that it appears it exists to us, But at the same time, if we say the car exists by means of, a label, that means that the car exists in one way. So therefore, by not be going into the either extreme by saying it doesn’t exist the way we see it, but it does exist in another way, then this is how, this philosophy fits into a system called the Madhyamaka or
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.