Heart Sutra — 2001-12-06

43 min · 2,611 words · 6 December 2001 · Buddha House Adelaide

Heart Sutra (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Heart Sutra (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Heart Sutra — 2001-12-06
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The three doors of liberation — being without nature, signlessness, and wishlessness — serve as Geshe Pema Tsering’s key to a dense Heart Sūtra verse in this 44-minute commentary. He opens by condensing the Lamrim sequence: renunciation, the three types of compassion (immeasurable, great, and superior), and the arising of uncontrived bodhicitta. He then maps the Heart Sūtra’s eight characteristics of emptiness onto those three doors, explaining how each applies to compound phenomena and, through the concept of a positing cause, to permanent entities like space. The session closes with a careful account of the path of seeing: its sixteen moments of patience and awareness, forty objects to be abandoned across the four truths, and a vivid analogy — seizing a thief, leading him to the door, ejecting him — to distinguish the uninterrupted path from the liberated path. For practitioners already grounded in Lamrim and emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 07 2001 12 06 HS.mp3

UUID: 8631d3c8-d850-470a-8c15-5dd4474871af

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Heart Sūtra (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2001-12-06

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 44.0 minutes

Words: ~2,615

So as Geshe-la has mentioned that we should reflect on the nature of this rebirth, precious human rebirth that possesses freedoms and endowments and is difficult to find difficult to find in terms of example and identity and so forth. So we need to reflect initially on that. Also, we need to reflect on death and impermanence that in fact, this precious human rebirth, is subject to death. It’s impermanent, and so on. The time of death is uncertain.

Then also to reflect on the nature of karma, the nature of action, of cause and effect, that this in fact, is non deceptive, that cause non deceptive non deceptively gives rise to result and result necessarily non deceptively arises from the cause. Then also to reflect on the fact that Samsāra itself is not an excellent state. It’s not a pure state. In fact, it’s a state that we cannot perfect. But in fact, is full of faults and so on.

Through meditating on these, one is able to develop renunciation. So reflecting in that way, one develops renunciation. But then if one includes other beings in this meditation, if it’s done for the purpose of other beings, then great compassion and bodhicitta is developed. If in fact one reflects on the nature of saṃsāra and so forth and develops the desire to, definitely emerge from saṃsāra, it’s renunciation. But if one does it for the purpose of other beings, then it is great compassion, which leads to bodhicitta.

So then then one meditates on these states, in a in a sense while they’re still artificial, they still require effort in order to generate. And then when they are established in a non contrived state, then actual bodhicitta is generated. So here, one is developing a noncontrived state of bodhicitta, which seeks the state of highest enlightenment for the sake of all beings. So, in fact, the root of bodhicitta is great compassion itself. But in general, there are said to be three types of compassion or three types of compassion can be enumerated.

So the first is say great compassion and then there is immeasurable compassion and also superior compassion. So initially, immeasurable compassion is that type of compassion that’s focused on limitless sentient beings or immeasurable sentient beings. So because it’s focused on immeasurable sentient beings, it’s immeasurable compassion. So then great compassion is compassion that’s focused on all sentient beings without exception. So in other words, compassion focused on all sentient beings, which doesn’t leave out any being whatsoever is great compassion.

So then we have superior compassion, and that superior compassion is really the compassion that is based on great compassion, which also has the superior intention, that I myself will, free every sentient being of all suffering whatsoever. So that type of compassion is termed superior compassion. So then on the basis of developing those three, then bodhicitta is is established when the uncontrived effortless arrival of that main mind, is conditioned by those three types of compassion, is established. So here, one needs to generate this type of mind internally within one’s own continuum. So this is the mind that I myself will attain the state of enlightenment, that I myself will attain enlightenment so that I may be in the best position, so that I myself may be able to free all sentient beings of suffering.

So this is, the type of mind that must, must be established by myself. One reflects in this way and, establishes the pledge or the commitment to generate this mind whether in this life, or in a future life, by thinking in that way then, one eventually is able to generate uncontrived bodhicitta. So now we just meditate a little bit on this. So then just thinking through these points, and then developing a strong aspiration to attain, the uncontrived aspiration to generate the state of Buddhahood for oneself so that one is able to enlighten all sentient beings. So now we’re dealing with the section in the text, really from the point where it’s stated.

Śāriputra, in that way, all dharmas are emptiness without characteristics, without generation, without cessation, without stain, without freedom from stain, without decrease, without increase. So this is the section of the text which is talking about path of seeing. And here, it’s talking about when it talks about these eight aspects, it’s talking about the three doors of liberation. So firstly, when it says emptiness, all dharmas are emptiness, then it’s talking about the door of liberation of So here, in fact, they’re teaching the three here, the Buddha is teaching the three doors of liberation, and the first one is the door of liberation of being without nature. So that’s with the words emptiness itself.

Then the the words following that, that is the words without characteristics, without generation, without cessation, without stain, and without freedom from stain, they teach the door of liberation, of of being without characteristics. And then the third door there, which is no decrease and without increase, they teach the door of liberation of wishlessness. So those three doors are doors of liberation are taught that section. So in fact, here three doors of liberation are enumerated. So firstly, the door of liberation of being without nature Mhmm.

And then which is emptiness itself and ending without characteristics, then being without wish or of wishlessness. So in fact, here, these eight aspects are divided up into the three doors, of liberation. For instance, the first emptiness they’re referring to, the door of liberation of being without nature. And then the next five refer to, signlessness, and the last two refer to wishlessness. But these three doors, can apply to any object whatsoever.

So here the first door of liberation is that of, being without nature. So this can be applied to, for instance, any compound or any object whatsoever. So for instance, our jars and so forth are, empty by nature or empty, of true existence by the very nature. Then the door of of signlessness specifically refers to the fact that the cause of compounds and so forth are in fact signless. So they possess the door of liberation of signlessness.

Then the third door itself specifically refers to the fact of the result. And here, the door liberation of wishlessness referring to the results of of the causal process. Yeah. So in fact, all compounded entities possess these three. That is of being without nature, being without a cause which possesses characteristics, and being without a result which which is possesses wish or aspiration.

For non compounds, then certainly the first doors of liberation applies. That is the door of liberation of being without nature. But the second two doors, that is the door of of being without characteristics, which he specifically refers to causes and being without wish or possessing the attribute of wishlessness, which specifically he refers to results, do not apply to non compounds. However, the second and third doors of liberation can be applied to permanent entities such as emptiness, space and so forth because there is a particular thing called a positing cause. And a positing cause which can be included within causation or included nominally within cause refers to the awareness which comprehends, space or emptiness.

So therefore, the positing cause itself, even in relation to permanent entities, lacks characteristics. So here, in fact, the positing cause, here nominally termed a cause, is that awareness, which, actually comprehends any particular object. But here, applying it to permanent entities, then the permanent entity itself can be termed a posited cause through the awareness which comprehends it. So if we here, for instance, one has space as an example. So space is empty of true existence.

Space itself is, therefore, by nature empty. It’s regarded as a positing cause. Therefore, it it lacks sign or it conforms with the door of signlessness. Also, in terms of the third, door of liberation, then the posited result also is established, which refers again to the, to say a permanent permanent entity here like space. And because it can be subsumed, therefore, within result through that, it is regarded as conforming to the third door of liberation.

That is the door of liberation of wishlessness. So this in fact conforms with the presentation of Geshe Tsongkhapa. So here in fact, this presentation is given by Geshe Tsongkhapa and also Atisha and then also in other other systems such as Mönlam Sherab and so forth. Now here this is referring this particular section of the the text is referring to the path of seeing. These words teach the path of seeing and the path of seeing itself is defined as the realization of truth.

So what that means is the initial perceptual realization of truth arises or the four truths arises at the beginning of the path of seeing, And the path of seeing itself therefore is qualified by, the realization of truth, the perceptual, non conceptual realization of truth. So in fact, here the definition of the, the truth of path is in fact realization of truth. Now if we’re the path of seeing, we have the path of seeing. Preceding the path of seeing is in fact the path of preparation. Preceding that is a path of accumulation.

So initially, the the definition of the path of seeing is the realization of truth. The definition of the path of accumulation is the realization of Dharma. And the definition of the path of preparation is realization of meaning. So these are the the general definitions given of these particular paths. After the path of seeing, we have the path of meditation.

And the definition of the path of meditation is latter realization. So firstly, have the realization of Dharma, then the realization of meaning, then the realization of truth, then realization or the fourth one, the path of meditation is defined as latter realization. Yeah. If we So if we divide up, if we classify the path of seeing, then there are sixteen moments to the path of seeing. So these are sixteen which are divided into eight moments of patience and eight moments of awareness.

So eight plus eight makes sixteen. So here the eight patience stages of the path of seeing relate to the uninterrupted path of seeing. And the eight awareness stages of the path of seeing relate to the liberated stages of the path seeing. So here we have eight moments of patience. These are in fact the uninterrupted path of seeing.

They’re uninterrupted path of seeing because they actually apply the antidote or they engage in overcoming what needs to be overcome or abandoned on a path of seeing. So here we have on the eight patient stages of the path of seeing, then the antidotes to the seeing abandonments, those objects to be abandoned on the path of seeing, are applied. On the eight awareness stages of the path of seeing, which correspond to the liberated stages of the path of seeing, then the antidotes have been applied and achieved separation or elimination of the objects to be abandoned. So it’s a little bit like, firstly, a thief entering one’s house, which is like the object to be abandoned. Seizing that thief and leading them to the door is like the path of the uninterrupted path.

And actually, ejecting them from the door and closing the door afterwards is like the liberated path, it’s seen. So in fact, there are forty if one expands, there are forty objects to be abandoned on the path of seeing. So in fact, these forty objects to be abandoned on the path of seeing are divided up into the four truths. So these four those four truths, of course, are suffering, origin, cessation, and path. So there are ten related to suffering.

There are ten objects to be abandoned on the path of seeing related to the origin of suffering. There are ten related to the cessation of suffering. And there are ten related to the path leading to the cessation. Yep. So the ten relating to the truth of suffering, therefore, include the five view objects of abandonment and the five nonview objects of abandonment.

So in fact, here, there are five non view objects to be abandoned, in terms of the truth of suffering at the time of the path of seeing. And they are attachment, anger, pride, doubt, and ignorance, . So then also there are five, five objects to be abandoned related to view. So they include firstly, transient view, then extreme view, wrong view, and holding those views as supreme, and then holding ethics and ritual as supreme. So in fact, these ten are to be abandoned.

So then how the forty, arise is because, therefore, firstly, one has ten. That is the five view and the five nonview objects of abandonment on the path of seeing that are to be eliminated in relation to the truth of suffering. Then there are, again, five view and five nonview objects of abandonment to be abandonment in relate to be abandoned in relation to the truth of origin, another five view and nonview in relation to the truth of cessation, and another five view and nonview to be abandoned in relation to the truth of path. So in all of these forty. So in fact, this comes up in the commentary.

In fact, in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra commentary it says that emptiness, and without characteristics are respectively the objects, of observation of, firstly patience and then subsequent awareness with respect to suffering. So here in fact there’s as stated before there are patience and awareness stages. And so in these patience and awareness stages, first in the patience stage the antidote is applied, then in the awareness stage the actual realization of the elimination of the object to be abandoned is achieved. So these occur first with the truth of suffering, then origin, cessation, and path. So all the objects to be abandoned on the path of seeing are abandoned by meditating on emptiness itself.

So there’s no difference in the antidote that is applied in order to overcome the objects to be abandoned. So here in fact talking of the sixteen moments of the path of seeing, that is the eight patient stages and the eight awareness or knowledge stages. Then these occur in an order. And prior to the arrival of what is called Dharma patience of suffering, then one firstly enters equipoise on the path of preparation, in which one is still conceptually comprehending emptiness. And then through maintaining that equipoise, one initially breaks through to the perceptual comprehension of emptiness.

When one breaks through to the perceptual comprehension of emptiness, then the actual antidote to seeing abandonments is first established. So this corresponds, initially to the, dharma patience of suffering. So which is the first moment of the sixteen moments. So when dharma patience is manifested, it acts as the actual antidote to that measure of the object to be abandoned at that point, which is say grasping at true existence and so on. So it is actually able to act as the antidote so that that state, that level of, object to be abandoned, is not able to manifest.

So, through applying that antidote at the dharma patience level, it stops the object to be abandoned from arising. And when the object to to be abandoned on that level is stopped from arising, in that moment, then truth of cessation is established, with relation to the object to be abandoned.

Key terms in this teaching

lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
three doors go sum (Tib)
Body, speech and mind. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top