1 h 56 min · 9,020 words · 20 October 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 116-minute afternoon teaching, speaker Ilia S. Durovic introduces the Four Noble Truths by exploring how suffering manifests in human experience. He explains that suffering exists on three levels: the obvious pain everyone recognizes, the subtle suffering-of-change where pleasurable things eventually bring dissatisfaction like a new car or accumulated wealth, and the deepest level—the pervasive suffering of conditioned existence itself, driven by ignorance and destructive emotions. Durovic emphasizes that compassion and wisdom are not merely biological impulses but trainable mental qualities that grow through reasoned conviction and daily practice. He illustrates this through anecdotes about post-surgical recovery, the importance of genuine smiling, and the contrast between foolish and wise selfishness. He concludes by connecting all four truths: understanding suffering naturally motivates the desire to overcome its causes, realize cessation, and practice the path leading to liberation.
File metadata (for organising)
File: The ; 20 October 2009 (Day 1 of 3; Afternoon) Video (HQ) Teachings on Tibetan….mp3
UUID: 7197eb85-e9fd-487d-b1b5-8af0ad18540d
Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~9,022
Now continuously, the explanation about point of the truth. Suffering generally experience, a kind of experience. Inanimate objects. Inanimate objects. Without any sensation or feelings.
Mhmm. So only Buddhist call sentient being who have the experience of mind. With the mind, the experience of feeling. With sensations where feeling. Feeling or sensation.
With that, pains and pleasure, these things there. So it is part of mind. So therefore, it’s sort of causes also very much related with mind. So therefore, the causes of suffering, two kinds, action, motivation. Among the motivation or generally, every action, I think most of the most of the action or those action which deliberately carried, there is there must be motivation.
Motivation is the main mover of all verbal action, physical action, or mental action also. So therefore, now, when we talk the the among the causes of suffering, the action is not just actually, not, I mean, actually, action not action generally, but here, action which carried by, destructive emotion. That is you said. So therefore, the ultimately, the sources of suffering is destructive emotion. Now, for example, the destructive sort of action and sinful action such as killing, stealing, or sexual what is it?
Misconduct. Or sexual abuse or rape. These these physical action, then global action lie, telling lie. Divisive talk? Defamatory talk.
Sorry. Wicked words, sorry. Yes, it is. Harsh language. Oh, the harsh language.
Yes. Harsh language. All these is naturally some kind of destructive emotion and too much attachment or greed. These are the main motivation. Without these motivation, these destructive action will not come.
With full compassion, respect others. Right? Respect even respect others viewpoint, then, although in traditional level, sometimes necessary to argue, but in deeper, no anger, no hatred. Respect them. So therefore, the all this destructive action are ultimately carried by destructive emotion.
Now here, destructive why why why we call destructive or constructive? In the sense, we want happiness, pleasure. That we consider positive. There’s no absolute positive and negative. There’s no absolute.
But then, generally, we want happiness or pleasure. So therefore, we consider that as positive. Pains, suffering, we do not want. Therefore, we consider that as negative. So on its own causes, There are causes level also.
Those causes which create pains is destructive. Those sort of emotions on those thing which create a pleasure or happiness, joyfulness. Since that result consider positive, so the causes of that then we call constructive. So compassion and these things are positive emotion, constructive emotion, anger, hatred because bring more trouble, therefore consider destructive emotion. Then another I think reason, these destructive emotions such as anger, hatred, as soon as that develop, our mental state disturb.
The positive emotion such as compassion, forgiveness, that very much helpful to maintain calm mind. Although sometimes too much sort of, too strong sense of concern of others well-being. For immediate, there may be little disturbances but that that disturbances you actually voluntarily voluntarily sort of other happen. You deliberately pay much attention about others well-being by deliberately, intentionally. So therefore, some sort of little disturbances from that sort of service level, some disturbances but deeper level, full of strength, full of self confidence.
So without full sort of self confidence, you cannot develop genuine sense of concern of others well-being. Clear. So the person who have the ability to to to feel strongly the others well-being, they are in deep level full self confidence. So therefore, although sense of concern of others well-being sometimes may bring little disturbances, but that that’s on superficially. Or surface way, surface Superficial now.
Oh, surface in deep down. It even is strengthening our self confidence like that. What happened? I think something wrong. It’s voluntary now.
Okay. So so the negative emotion such as, oh, no. I think I I already just mentioned. So therefore, from that viewpoint also, we can say some of these emotions are destructive. Some of the emotion are constructive.
All the, actions and other sort of, also the mental, mental thinking which brings more happiness, more joyfulness, not only oneself but others. And also, you see certain sort of mental quality, immediately create some positive atmosphere, isn’t it? If on the throne, if I say more anger and shouting, then within in this whole, some kind of dense atmosphere will develop, isn’t it? More sort of peaceful mind, the atmosphere, some kind of peaceful atmosphere create. So therefore, there is sufficient reason to call some emotion destructive, some emotion constructive.
Right? And also the action, constructive action, helping, serving, which bring comfort physically, mentally. Such action is constructive action, positive action, positive karma. Karma Sanskrit word, meaning is action. Then killing, beating, scolding, those are the harsh word.
These things uncomfortable matter. So harmful, therefore, destructive. So both level, action level, motivation level motivation level, the two constructive, destructive and neutral. So these are the the explanation about Samudaya. The second Second Noble Truth.
Oh, Second truth. Truth of cause of suffering. Now, this case is mainly now result suffering. So the motivation or action also the negative side, so, these destructive emotions, destructive action. No further more detailed sort of explanation.
Then the suffering, what is suffering? According our Conventional things. Maybe, yes, conventional. Conventional sort of conventional way, the suffering we consider pains, these are suffering. Buddha taught suffering the three levels of suffering, three kinds of suffering.
Suffering of suffering, that is the suffering which common not only we human being but also the animals also to experience, consider or recognize as a suffering. But that’s suffering of suffering. Then the second level of suffering, there’s suffering of change. Change. A suffering of change.
Like, when when we, in the, let’s say, in wintertime in in shade. Shadow. When you feel little cold, then go to the sun or sunny place and feel very comfortable. Then remain, ten minutes, fifteen minutes, thirty minutes, one hour, two hour, then you feel too hot. Is it?
The initial feeling of pleasant now reduce, and the feeling of uncomfortable now increasing. So the Buddha state, they actually the initial sort of comfortable feeling is not really pleasure or comfortable or pleasure, but the the the what’s the the suffering gradually reduce. That appears you as a pleasant. If you see the remaining sun, hot, it’s truly a source of Happiness. Pleasure, source of comfortable, then more because we use that, you should feel more pleasure.
That’s not the case. Too much brings suffering, uncomfortable. I think we just finished our lunch. So when you feel hungry, initial level, the food very tasteful and seems very nice, then half full. Then that taste a little reduced.
Then usually full, then even the someone is bring more food, then you feel, oh, bad, bad. I don’t want you to see that. Isn’t it? That kind of feeling is it happen, isn’t it? So these are the the shows or indicate very nature of the reality.
There’s certain things that initially feel, pleasant, happy. And the but then the same sort of source continue then bring uncomfortable. And I think those as I said, I think, material facilities. I think the, when you buy one car, the few months, you feel this car is very nice. I think even during dream, also you you may dream that car, isn’t it?
Even some birds drops as it happened. You feel, oh, how bad? Like that. Isn’t it? Then six months, one year, the same car, but you feel, oh, this is bad.
Now I want to buy another one. Isn’t it? And especially, you say your neighbor, you see, having some new car. Then you you really feel my car, I’m just bad now. Now I want to buy another one.
So same car, but our attitude change. The same source initially bring some satisfaction. Later, something something, I’m sorry. You feel revulsion, repulsion? No.
Like that. So these Buddhist call suffering of change. Then like money, initially, say, very nice. And then 10,000, 100,000, millions, thousand millions, billions like that, trillions. Meantime, these also you see bring more anxiety, more worry, more suspicion.
And then sometimes because of wealth, because of money, you make it. Because of money, among your brothers, sisters, some quarrel. Even if it’s children, parent, some quarter. Perhaps poorer family.
Maybe more harmony, more friendship, genuine human friendship, more wealthier family. These are sort of friendship becoming more artificial. So all these, ordinary people consider something positive. Actually, these becoming source of suffering, source of problem. So that Buddha state suffering of change.
Second level. That animals, no ability to realize that kind of suffering. Only we human being. We have longer memory, more in intellectuals intelligence. Intelligence.
So therefore, you see, we have the ability to realize these are ultimately suffering nature. Secondary second Second level. Then third level, that’s the so long our life, our existence under domination of ignorance. That very existence, that very sort of This karmic aggregate karmic aggregate that we have. Oh, the I think another word may be like this.
The very body, body is the basis of our mind, grosser level mind. Mind, there are many different level of, many different different levels. Grosser level of mind, more deeper, deeper, deeper. In our daily experience, now this moment, we are talking. So we we are using the grosser level of mind.
Grosser level of mind, very active, hearing, seeing, the yes. Gross level mind, very, very active. Now, dream state, I don’t know what I think. During sleep, without dream, more deeper level of consciousness of mind. Well, usually we call unconscious unconscious level, I think.
So in any way, Buddhist term, another level of mind. Then from that level, little grosser, then dream state. According to the scientific sort of research of brain wave, deep sleep without dream more subtle. Then another level come, then the dream happen. Isn’t it?
And I let go like that. So that’s another level of the mental state. Like that, when we faint, something like that, coma. Again, you see the we experience deeper mental state. So like that.
Finally, when we when we die, the initial initial level, little sort of sensory, then gradually, you see, reduce, reduce. And then finally, breathing stop. Heart beating stop. Then within short period, the circulation of blood and brain cease, then brain dead. Further still, now there are variety.
Some people after that, still very, very subtle conscious of mind still within the within the body. So indication, some people after death, although clinically death, but his or her body remain very fresh. Some cases, one week, two weeks, three weeks, that. It actually happened. Now here at Dharamsala or here in India, number of cases it happened after death, clinically death, but body remained very fresh a few weeks like that, including my own tutor, senior tutor.
After his death, he, obviously, at at last, you see he got some stroke, little paralyzed, but with that remain few month. Then after he death, some doctor from Delhi, he said, come, check. But his body remained very fresh. And thirteen days remain very fresh. So last year, another practitioner as well as great master scholar, top scholar, actually, the ex Ganden throne holder.
Ganden throne holder. Oh, in throne holder of Yellow Hat sect. Last year, he, when he passed away, I received the information. Then after, I think, three, four days, I received, report. His body still remain fresh.
Then I sent I’m I I I sent one sort of a text message to our clinic. What do mean? Telehealth. Telehealth hospital. Telehealth hospital.
Since result of our discussion with scientists, so some scientists, they said they want to check this dead body whose body still remain fresh. So some equipment, some simple equipment, you see, remain there. So previously, I think I think more than ten years ago, you see, one simple machine was remain there. But then, quite strange. You see, sometimes that machine available, sometimes not available.
So when machine available, nobody die. When some you see, that kind of death is to occur, then machine not available. So then last year, when I received that information, that master, after three days, his body still remain fresh. So then I immediately asked them, now this is opportunity, Golden opportunity might be better. Yes.
Yes. Don’t you worry. Golden opportunity, I asked them, go there as soon as possible. They went, with machine and all the wires is put on their dead bodies with the head, then three weeks remain fresh body. Of course, at this moment, I think I cannot mention the name of the scientist on top scientist.
Scientist, a very special specialist about brain. You see, later or at that time or later, you see, he told me the data from that sort of that exam. Right? Yes. Exam.
Test. Test. Test. Say, after about a week, after his death, about a week, then already his wires was there. Some short moment electric sort of wave recorded.
He’s surprised. He missed. Scientifically, is impossible, but it happened. So of course, usually as a scientist, scientific sort of test or experiment, just one case, we cannot sort of decide. There must be more cases than can confirm.
So this is one one occasion. So therefore, let’s say, still too early to sort of definite sort of because of the Conclusion. Conclusion. Yes. That.
So that we we consider according Buddhist philosophy explanation about mental state. There, at that state, the innermost of subtle mind still remain in the body. So as soon as that subtle mind depart from the body, then body immediately, you see, decay. Decaying. Decaying.
And also some sign, one sign, blood coming from nose. So then, I had also sometimes you should say that that body remain like this. Looks still alive, but actually dead. Remember that. And as soon as you see that, a subtle mind depart from dead body, then go like that and smell start, then the liquid come from nose like that.
So that we that is the most subtle level of mind. So all this grosser level of mind come from more subtle mind like that. So the negative emotion, destructive emotion can go up to grosser level of mind active. Then more subtle level of mind, the dream state also you see destructive emotion can go. Still grosser level.
Compare that that very subtle mind, compare that dream state mind, very gross. All this destructive emotion up to to the just the end of the gross level of mind, then beyond that, destructive emotion cannot go. Then too subtle, too subtle. The subtle subtlest is the mind. Very subtle.
So that is some kind of the very, very deep thoughtlessness state of mind. So that that kind of mind can go up to Buddhahood. And according tantric sort of tantric sort of System. Tantric system. A subtle mind beyond our thought, beyond the deeper way.
The deepest level. Oh, deepest level. Is it that we call one of the buddha nature because it is continuation. No end, no beginning till buddhahood it go. So now, you see, the the third level of suffering is the body and the grosser level of mind which based on this body, these are actually dominant by ignorance.
So all the body and mind which under influence or control by ignorance, that’s, the third level of suffering, the deepest suffering. So this is the third type of suffering which is called the pervasive suffering of conditioned existence. So when we talk about, the being under the influence of, the karma and ignorance, this third type of suffering that we are talking about. So among the grosser level of mind, you see, as I meant earlier, constructive, destructive. So eventually, destructive emotion completely eliminated.
Then that we call salvation. I think this I think come next. So that’s the explanation about of course of suffering. Second, Noble Two. Then third, cessation of suffering.
As I mentioned earlier, the pains and suffering are kind of experience. It is ultimate causes ignorance. So ignorance, as I mentioned before, always this counterforce, wisdom, understand the reality. Yes. Wisdom which is misconception of mind which is a misconception and which sees the truth as it is go directly against each other.
Mhmm. So therefore, one there, another cannot remain. Another limit another is there, the opposite, you see, cannot. So that’s I think major law. When heat there, cold reduce.
When cold stronger, heat reduce. That’s nature. Opposition, contradictory, and matters feel also. There is Because of contradiction, change possible. Without contradiction, change, no no possible.
No No. Impossible. Like that. So now in the terms of mind, mind is formless. So in terms of contradiction in the mind, it’s The way Right.
Mind apprehends things. Apprehension, the way the mind apprehends things. Voice. Truth Voice. Voice or lie voice, both are voice.
But how how to make distinction, lie and truth? So when you tell a lie or when you tell the truth, how you differentiate between the content of these two speech? So similarly, mind, ignorance also mind. Wisdom also mind. But now is a contradiction is one mind realize the reality.
One mind fail to realize the reality. And worst case, just it’s totally wrong. Totally wrong. Misconception. Yes.
Right. No. Totally wrong about the object. So therefore, you see two opposite cannot go together forever. One becomes stronger, another become weak, another stronger, another weak.
So similarly, mental level also like that. Ignorance without opposition, ignorance acting like master. Gradually wisdom come, realization or awareness come, then ignorance become weaker, weaker, weaker. Then another factor, main mind, very nature of main mind as I mentioned earlier, pure. All these distorted mind are all level of more grosser level.
So when grosser level cease, wisdom can go with subtle mind because wisdom have profound concrete concrete concrete Oh, concrete ground because of truth. Distorted distorted information, no solid ground. It’s quite clear. The view of the wisdom, more investigation, more thing, it become clearer, clearer, clearer, and become
Convincing. The ignorance or distorted sort of view, more investigate, it become weaker, weaker, weaker. So through that is the reason. Firstly, wrong view, no base, no solid base. The right view, solid base.
Second factor, both, both are also the part of mind. So mind itself continuity continuation there. Not like physical sort of training. Physical training like boxer, right? Boxing boxer or jumping.
Every time when for example, Olympic, you see the game, you just start. You have to because of that, you have to work. You have to train at least a few months, especially train necessary. A few years is the ability which few years ago you have without continue continuously, it may Decline? No.
Decline. Yeah. Makes so it it may it’s weak. So we need, once again, once more effort. What extent?
Mental quality, not like that. Once you thoroughly, you see, trained, it always remain continuously. One difference is physical need new effort. Mental level, no need. There are new effort.
Yes. It go continuously. Once you gain some experience, then always remain at that. Then third factor. Third factor is very nature of the mind is neutral.
Neither destructive nature or constructive nature. It’s quite clear, our daily life. For example, it’s those people who always very much sort of short temper, right, always show anger. But that person, twenty four hours not remain with anger. Cannot remain angry.
And also is it a person who always is very much angry person. Occasionally, to some people, to towards some people, loving kindness also there. I think one time, I usually before my I think visit Israel first time. Some, as a media, Israel come here and some sort of discuss, some talk. Then they naturally is a holocaust.
I see that subject is also involved. Then in some way, I’m Buddhist. So Buddhist viewpoint in like Hitler when he was young or that kind of strong hatred towards Jews. Not from his childhood, not by nature, but due to factors, due to certain environment, then that kind of extreme hateful hateful sort of views develop due to certain factor. I mentioned that.
Even this is like Hitler. They said in deep insight, the seed of compassion there. That’s Buddhist viewpoint. So then later, you see, I noticed when I actually visit Israel, when I reached there, some people ask me, they got impression. I’m some kind of sort of favor about Hitler.
So they consider Hitler from right from the beginning is so bad. Clear. So something something like this is negative people, absolute negative. So no no time be positive, that kind of attitude. So there’s Buddhist viewpoint.
You see, today is negative, next day may become positive. Today is positive may become negative due to different sort of factor, isn’t it? That’s just Buddhist view. So therefore, I mean, the point is our mind, no matter how negative, but not always remain that negative negative negatively. Occasionally, some positive because of the thinking come or compassion.
Full of hatred, but occasionally, some compassion can come. So that shows very mind is neutral. Otherwise, the very mind is negative negatively. Very mind has a heated hateful hated full No. Full of hate.
Oh, something very negative. Then that person will never experience any positive Experience. Positive thinking, positive view because very nature of that person’s mind is negative. So from the birth to death, twenty four hours must be negative. That’s not the case.
So our basic mind neutral. Due to some environment, some other factor, it become the, something like the office, the real head, more or less neutral. That head can receive advice from negative side or from positive side. So then the advice or influence from negative side become stronger, then the leader become more negative. When the his or her favor little reduce and more favor this more positive side, then influence from this side increase, then leader also becoming more positive like that.
Clear. Main mind, neutral. So that’s third factor. So now combine three. Wrong views, right views cannot go forever together.
And wrong views, no proper base. Right view have proper base. Then second, both views are part of mind, so it is continuation there. So get used that. For example, right view increase.
Time passes increase. More right view increase, become more solid. Solid. Solid. Then wrong view become weaker weaker.
Right view, I I I think I always mentioned the right view have a solid base. So therefore, there is was the thinking more, it gained more strength. Wrong view, no proper base. So therefore, there’s a never never can, never never be. Develop.
Develop infinitely. Develop infinitely. Oh, like that. Now third third factor, the main mind is pure. So combination these three factor, then the concept of possibility of elimination of destructive emotion.
That’s the cessation of causes of suffering. What do you think? What do you think? Some sense? So therefore so now third sort of noble truth, the cessation of suffering because cessation of causes of suffering, then suffering automatically cease.
Now that’s very important now. We have to think very seriously Our faith towards Buddha must come through analyze, experiment Buddha’s teaching. Through that way, towards Buddha come. If our faith towards Buddha simply based on all historically or two thousand six hundred years ago is when Buddha Śākyamūni happened and a marvelous person and a wonderful person, Just mere that faith, very, very kind of Buddhist faith, as I mentioned earlier, intelligence is very important. Wisdom very important.
Therefore, faith also must based on reasons or logics. Compassion also must based on reasons like that. So therefore, the in order to develop single pointed faith towards Buddha, first, we must study what Buddha state, what Buddha taught, and those point which Buddha state and carry some experiment on our low level. Of course, we cannot experiment high level, but low level, we can, we can experiment. So therefore, the the faith must based on reasons or investigation.
So here, main thing is and also the desire to achieve salvation. We must learn or must study the possibility of the cessation unless we develop some understanding, some sort of conviction. Oh, it might be possible. Unless we develop that kind of thing, then our desire to achieve cessation is just a mere word. And similarly, desire achieve buddhahood, just a mere word.
We all Buddhist, we should recite, I want to become Buddha, I think thousand times. In order these sort of our chanting become something, something effective, we must learn these things. My own case, of course, knowledge, as I mentioned earlier, very, very little. Experience was very little. Even though this very little, there’s more more study, more knowledge and analyze.
And the different books, different text mentioned that you see something something something here, something here, something here, something here, then to tell us actually. Tell tell To bring them together. To bring them together. This is saṃsāra is from here. Samsāra is from here.
Then by yourself, analyze. Make something like parcel. Pass. Some information put here. Something put here.
Then gradually and think think more, think more, think more, and also make connection with our daily experiences. Then gradually full picture of form of truth. Then you develop real trust, conviction towards Nāgārjuna, towards Buddha. That’s Buddhist sort of faith. Buddhist was the This is the way to take refuge in There are two levels of, of course, in all religion, particularly in Buddhism.
You see, there are two levels. One level of Buddhist, you know, without much thinking. Sometimes I teasing. Is it Chinese? Without knowing what is the meaning of?
Or what is the real system. It pray to a myth of how we gain some benefit. Without knowing that, there’s something and some some cases, I think our self, also myself, you see, some 100 thousands reside in some mantras, sometimes without sort of thinking. So just looking here and here and here and here and then residing or something like tape recorder, like that. Not like living sort of living recitation, just tape recorder.
So therefore, the thinking thinking, analyze, analyze position is key factor for all sort of for Buddhist practice. So so one, without sort of knowing these things, but simply praying Buddha. And the ultimate reason is my family Buddhist, so I’m Buddhist. My parents is go to temple and making a meaningful offering. So I I I’m sort of repeating that as a true symbol.
So that’s one level. We Buddhist with Tibetan also, they say they without knowing the real meaning. But sometimes I joking. This sound, the is the Sanskrit word. So sometimes we little bit hurry and little bit too long.
So money. So Money. Money. Money. Like that.
So so there’s one letter. Of course, no harm. Just as see, out of blind faith, is he carrying some prayer, recite Buddha’s name? Oh, Very good. But then another level, Buddhist, like usually, all these Buddhist text wrote by these here now the painting, 17 Nālānda masters.
Traditionally, eight scholars. So traditionally, for the last six hundred years or so, we mentioned the what are known as the eight six ornaments and the two supreme masters of India. So together eight. Yes. So then I I felt actually some of my favorite sort of master like Buddhapālita, not there and not there, not there.
There. So these masters, my most favorite because of favorite masters, so I thought, oh, must we include these these these masters? So so I add a few more masters. So altogether, this is 17, masters. All text wrote by these masters at the beginning shows the, goes through the, four factors known as, the the purpose of writing the text and so forth.
So that means, you see, the reader or person who going to study these text must be must have critical investigation. Critical. Critical view. So firstly, they wonder what’s the content of the text. The second, what useful about that content?
And then also, not only temporary sort of benefit but long term benefit. Investigate these things, then develop desire to carry study about that text. So all text is mentioned that way. So that means all these text meant for secondary Buddhist who are critical. Right.
Not just blindly accept. Right. Yes. Like that. So therefore,
So the main disciples for whom the text were written are those main student. Main students for whom the text were written were are are those of the disciples with or students with sharp intellect, which means they do critical investigation of what they study. So now it is, I want to appeal or request, to you, of course, Buddhist. Please pay more attention about study and the fuller knowledge about Buddhism. That’s very, very essential.
So now there’s a third for noble truth. Once we have clear picture the today’s sort of situation and the possibility of our future destination or possibility, then we get the we get the enthusiasm to practice. So the fourth noble truth, that’s path. Now here, path actually, the practice of Dharma at all major all majorist tradition has three three levels, physical level, self discipline, and also some cases, there’s a certain sort of that dress, and restrain certain physical reaction. So that’s the practice on the physical level.
Then on the verbal level, also restrain some destructive word and always truthful, honest. These are verbal action. Practice on verbal action. All these two entirely depend on mental mental level. So mental level, the all the destructive emotions must resisting.
So these are the way of practice. First level. That’s morality or conduct, sir. Moral conduct. Oh, moral conduct.
Physical level, verbal level, mental level. Now here, most of destructive emotions due to ultimate source the cause, ignorance. Therefore, the all our body biological factor. You see, they biologically, there is some basis of this destructive emotion such as attachment, anger, hatred, these biological factor. Because for our survival, we need certain actions.
Action bring together, action to expel. To draw in those who those which are helpful to one Those favorite thing Help. Bring closer and those as a harmful aspect. So for survival, it is necessary. Even plant also is have both so to answer the bird thing.
It’s quite natural. Natural. Natural. Natural. Let’s say, some seed is in order to spread their seed.
Some have certain sort of sort of facility fly with wind as it goes far away like that. I’m wondering here, is there some karmic link or not? I don’t think. I don’t think karmic link. These are nature.
So the biological factor, there is some sort of system or law. Call it. I think sunflower, you see they like, I think the, for example, like sunflower. Morning, sun come from there, go like that. And then moon, noon like that, and afternoon go like that.
So as if they need sunlight. This is not motivation motivated consciously, but biological factor, isn’t it? I think during night, sunflower go like that. Maybe I think it preserve some warmth, maybe. And those who see plant in desert, you see, they have some kind of equipment to keep water and very little water, they can survive.
So these all is by nature. So we we human being also So these I think certain emotions are biological factor. Because in order to survive our body and certain action need for that since most action carried by motivation. So motivation level, there must be some something which which one to expect. That’s anger, hatred.
And, something which we bring together, which we need. So attachment like that. So emotions and the physical, the emotion, there’s very close connection according, some scientist. They say when anger comes, anger develop, the blood goes more on arm muscle, so ready to fight. When fear develop, the blood goes like to run away.
So these emotions is our physical very much close relation like that. So therefore, some extent now I I think, someone who can actually hear the compassion. When I give lecture on compassion, I always make a distinction. Compassion in our conventional sense, our usual sense, our compassion is biological and very much mixed with attachment. And that compassion, oriented about others action or about others attitude.
So action oriented. So therefore, towards our enemy, since their action is negative towards you, so the action oriented compassion cannot go to your enemy. Instead, anger, hatred. Now towards your friend, very nice to you because their attitude nice to to me and their attitude is something very friendly. Therefore, your compassion, your sense of concern, your love goes towards them.
So very much action oriented. So that very much mixed with attachment. And since these things are action oriented, so biased. Only that kind of compassion only towards your friend, not your enemy or not neutral people. So limited, biased.
That’s biological factors, compassion. We, everybody, come from our mother. At the time of our young age, immediate after birth, even at the time we are in mother’s womb, mother’s compassion is extremely important for the child. After after birth, after born, after birth, next few months, few years, mother’s affection, mother’s care is extremely important. This is question of survival.
Without mother’s care, even birds Birds and other animals like cats or dogs, you can see. Without mother’s care, the youngster cannot survive. So therefore, biologically, for their survival, someone else care is highly necessary. Now that sense of care, sense of willingness come out of compassion. So there’s very logical so so that procedure there like that.
So we all equipped that kind of compassion. Already there, seed of compassion already there because we survived with mother’s milk, with mother’s care. Nobody can argue. I think here, few thousand people here, I think those individual who received maximum care, maximum affection from our mother, those people, even today, even this this this this age, I think deep inside more warmth. Those people who at any who at at young age lack of mother’s care or orphan orphan orphanage away.
Orphan. Or orphan. Or some cases, parent bully, abuse, and develop in the atmosphere of cold family. I think today here on on the on the the surface, it’s the same, normal human being, but deep inside, I think little bit cold feeling. So these people, difficult to show genuine sense of concern because you yourself grown up such atmosphere lacking these things.
It’s quite clear. So physically also, those children who lack affection, not sufficient just food, shelter, but affection immense important. Monkey, some scientists experimented. Monkey, some young monkey with mother, some young monkey separate from their mother eventually become big differences. Those young young monkey with mother, more playful.
Those young monkey who separate from their mother always bad mood, always fight. So we are same. Same nature. Same basically, same species of mammals. So that’s the biological factor.
Now take that biological factor compassion biological factor, take that as a seed, then utilize human intelligence, the value of compassion, the destructiveness of anger, hatred. Utilize these reasons and also experiment through experiment. Some scientists experiment or our self experiment and watch or judge, watch then our neighbors, those neighbor who always fight, who always angry, who always sort of quarrel. I think even children in this family, little bit more anxiety, more fear, like that. Those family, the parent, calm mind, peaceful, compassionate, their children including their pets, much more peaceful, much more happier.
Isn’t it? So use our conscience and look these things, then we get conviction. Compassion is so important. Important. And as I mentioned this morning, for our physical health also is compassion is so important.
Some scientist describing anger, hatred, actually eating our immune system. Compassionate mind helping to sustain our immune system. Like that. Last year, I went through surgery. I was a gallbladder.
A lot of stones there, so through surgery, it removed. So since then, some occasion when I talk people, some people usually I just make clear, among the audience, some people is to come out of curiosity. There’s no problem. As among the audience, some people may come that believe that Dalai Lama have some miracle power. That’s nonsense.
There are some people, may have this sort of feeling that Dalai Lama have healing power. So then I mentioned, last year’s my surgery scientifically proved that I have no healing power. Isn’t it? So my point is, is it that after the surgery, although the surgery quite serious. You know, you see by gallbladder, you see they enlarged almost three times from normal size.
And in it, what we call pus. Right? Pus. Pus. So usually, you see this that kind of surgery takes only fifteen, twenty minutes.
But my case, it took three hours. So quite complicated surgery. But then after that, immediate afters of surgery, quite painful quite painful and very difficult to move like that. Just lay down like that. Otherwise, it’s quite painful.
But then within five days, recover fully. So at that time, the doctor state to me, your physical level is very good. So they recover so unusually, very quick. So then I believe my mental state, comparatively, quite peaceful. So while I’m sort of I mean, the yeah.
I always stress the importance of compassion. Then, naturally, I myself must practice that. Otherwise, my my talk become hypocrisy, isn’t it? If I might talk yeah, because of that. If my talk is it should be sincere or truthful, then I myself, you should practice that.
Although my my experience very limited, but still I practice these things. So as a result, I
Think the mental level quite calm, quite peaceful. So like that. So that’s from my own experience, I can tell you peace of mind is very, very useful for our health. So everybody is taking care about health, isn’t it? Taking different medicines, gong you, ginseng, qi gong.
So, and also the yoga, difference of yoga, all these meant for good health. So, therefore, we must pay more attention about another factor which bring good health. That’s peace of mind. Clear. Then another, another sort of point, I mentioned beauty.
Physical beauty, important, but more important is mental beauty. Emotional beauty is much more important. Isn’t it? Now world is so much materialistic way of life. So you see, lot of money spent for cosmetic way.
Cosmetic. Cosmetic for physical beauty. Nobody pay attention about the inner beauty. That’s a mistake. I think we must pay more attention about our inner beauty.
That’s very essential. Like that. So therefore so now second level of compassion. Through reason, through experiment, use common sense, common experience, and the scientific findings develop conviction of importance or usefulness of compassion. Now that compassion oriented not action or attitude, but oriented towards a human being or the being or Suffering beings.
Suffering beings. Oh, the the being like that. Suffering being. Being itself, not action. So trained to compassion is oriented being itself, not action.
So now that compassion become unbiased compassion. As far as your enemy is concerned, their action is negative. But that being or as a human being, still human being, they also have the right to overcome suffering. They also have the desire for happy life, overcome suffering, and every right there just like me. So on that sort of understanding, that awareness, then develop sense of concern of our enemy.
That’s real compassion. So unbiased. Not oriented action, but but towards the being itself. That develop only through reason training, not biological. So that compassion develop stronger, stronger, stronger.
Then the act there goes a, anger, hatred, jealousy reduce. And all negative, because of that, negative actions automatically cease. So long you have the genuine sense of concern, well-being of other. Killing, impossible. Stealing, impossible.
Abuse, because of sexual abuse, impossible. Telling lie, impossible. That’s a harsh word. Impossible. That’s a divisive word.
Divisive talk. Go ahead. Come on. No. Divisive talk.
So all these non virtuous action then automatically cease. Now for example, restrain killing variety. Just think about law. If I kill one human being, I have to go to the prison or worst case is death sentence. So out of that fear, restrain killing.
One level. Another level, thinking if I kill, I meet because of the serious sort of sin. So I I have to sort of face the consequences. Therefore, refrain from killing. Another level.
Another level, I I love this sentient being. This is human being. This is sentient being. Just like myself, his or her life is so precious to him or to her. Therefore, their life as secret as my own life.
So out of that respect, restrain from harming them, killing them. So they are variety. Isn’t it? Different motivation.
The motivation motivation Yes. So out of these three different motivations, the first two do not include the third one and or the first one does not include the second. So abstaining from killing terms of this so on to meet these three levels of killing or refraining from the killing at the level of, let me call, thinking, first of all, about law And then secondly, call it, refraining from killing because you see that it has negative consequence on you. And at the third level, you think of out of total compassion for the other beings, you feel you refrain from killing. So out of these three, they call ways of killing or showing restraint in killing, the first the last ones kind of subsumes the first two, whereas the first two do not they could subsume the third one.
Uh-huh. From the viewpoint of virtues, the first action, although recent killing, but no virtues, just out of fear of law. The second, there is some virtue. Understand, if I kill, I have to face consequences. So then restrain some virtues there.
Then the third, out of compassion, out of respect in their life and consider as dear as my own life, reaping immense virtues because of different motivation. Same action, but big differences of motivation there. So bodhicitta, infinite compassion, infinite altruism. Physical level, more or same, but mental level, big differences. Clear.
Like that. So Bodhisattvas and all these 17 great masters always embracing the altruism. It’s extremely sort of useful. It’s altru infinity altruism is real jewel, real precious. Buddha become as it is, because of the holy because of that mind.
So that mind altruism, even worldly life, the present life, more compassionate mind there, more calmness, more inner peace, and even compassion altruism, even bring more friend, more smile. A smile is something I think unique thing about human being. Is it the attitude of anger, I think common dogs or many many others sort of beings have the ability to show they are angry, their anger. But real loving kindness, compassion, and smile, I don’t think. Some monkey may have ability to smile like that or they are showing their teeth or real smile.
I don’t know. So I think among the difference in mammals, I think very few who have the ability to show smile. So then smile, I usually see sort of as a day joking smile just showing teeth. They are also different sort of different things. Some smile, a sarcastic smile.
Some smile, diplomatic smile. These are not genuine human smile. Intelligence or aggressiveness that brings this sarcastic smile or diplomatic smile like that. These smiles brings instead of calm or happy, more fear, more doubt. So genuine smile, not thinking about others well-being, others sort of because of the wealth or others power simply on human level that human being just show the attitude of human brother, human sister.
That’s a genuine human smile. That really brings comfort. Isn’t it? When I pass them through, it’s in different places. It’s my nature.
I always is I consider them as a human being. So just with that kind of feeling, I always smile. So then most cases, they’re also showing response, very sort of very beautiful attitude. Some occasion, when I look look at them and smile, then they say they they they look they look at more serious. But then I have liberty to to change my face.
No problem. So first, you yourself should extend the possibility of their smile. Right on the right on the beginning. You yourself familiar like that. Then impossible to bring some smile, isn’t it?
Like that. So like that. So therefore, so altruistic attitude. As soon as we develop some conviction, goodness of that, From that time, from that on, day and night, including dreams also become more nice dreams. Less nightmares.
Right. Yes. Like that. And then day by day by day, month by month, year by year, decade by decades, your life become more pleasant. Less fear, More peace.
So be respected whether believe next life or not. Whether believe God or not, be kind person. That’s important. We have selfish. Selfish is important, but extreme selfish is negative, destructive.
So I often is telling or sharing with people. We are selfish, but with human intelligence, we should be wise selfish rather than foolish selfish. Then our intelligence is not wasted. Taking care of oneself. But best way taking care of oneself is taking care of other.
If you devote yourself to, you know, in the practice of altruism, taking care of others, taking them more important than yourself, then you’ll be able to fulfill your goal as well. So the conduct. Moral. Moral. No.
Moral conduct. Moral conduct. Moral conduct. In order to carry moral conduct, we need certain kind of right view. So that we call wisdom.
And that wisdom not just sufficient not sufficient just sort of understand or awareness of that right view, but you should familiarize that view. So for that, mindfulness is very essential. So morality, samadhi, that. The three trainings. Three training.
So with regard to the three trainings, the first one is that of the training of morality. Now in order for one to practice morality, one has to have an understanding of causality, how cause and effect work and not leaving that understanding just on the level of intellectual understanding, but actually integrate that understanding within your practice. And therefore, in relation to the understanding of causality, you should check whether your body, speech and mind are being conducted according to the law of causality that you have understood or not. And for that you need mindfulness, which is defined as this factor or mental factor which checks, which familiarizes with the object that you have already known. And through this mindfulness, you are you will be able to concentrate develop concentration.
And so this is about so far, we have covered nature of the Four Noble Truths or the teaching based on the nature of the Four Noble Truths. And then on the basis of that, we need to understand the next level of the Four Noble Truths, which is to understand what suffering is and to to overcome or eliminate the causes of suffering and then to actualize the third level third cessation and then actually practice the path.
So with regard to the first point which is where the Buddha says you should understand the suffering within which there are three types of suffering. The first one, which is called suffering of suffering, is something that even animals are aware of as being something painful and unwanted. And the second type of suffering, changeable suffering or change is something which even the non-Buddhist system, followers of non-Buddhist systems also understand as being something unwanted and like the ancient Indian non-Buddhist traditions. And then it’s also within the practitioners of non-Buddhist traditions, there are those who have reached that of the fourth level of concentration Brahma and where the sensation of feeling is only that of neutral sensation. And so even at that level, they have to a certain degree overcome this suffering of suffering And they understand that changeable suffering is something unwanted.
But we hear, when we talk about overcoming suffering, as the Buddha says to understand suffering, what the Buddha meant is this most important type of suffering that we have to understand, which is that of pervasive suffering of conditioned existence. And this kind of suffering is brought about because of the dominant causes of the karma or actions and our destructive thoughts and emotions. And so the kind of psychophysical aggregate which are under the influence of these two factors, actions and the destructive emotions, as well as the cycle birth through these kind of factors is known as that of the suffering of pervasive conditioning of conditioned existence. Since this third kind of suffering comes about as a result of our karma and delusions, if you can develop this sense of not wanting to have that kind of suffering, then what we should do is try to overcome put an end to this kind of suffering. So with regard to that, what you want to do is that of trying to overcome the three poisons.
The three poisons desire, hatred and ignorance, out of which the main cause of this suffering is that of our ignorance. And so when you see the possibility to of overcoming this kind of suffering, what you can see is what you can feel is that of the the wish or the desire to overcome this very cause of ignorance and take or consider the ignorance itself to be one’s enemy that you should overcome. Now with regard to the ignorance itself, there are different schools of thought which some of which consider ignorance to be called affective false emotions whereas others consider it to be what is known as cognitive obscuration. Now this difference lies in interpretation of or understanding of the subtlety of suchness or emptiness. And so accordingly, according to the difference in the understanding of subtlety of suchness, their recognition of identification of ignorance also differs.
So some of them say ignorance is actually cognitive obscuration whereas others say it is afflictive thoughts and emotions or delusions. And now here also what comes in is that of what is known as the selflessness of phenomena. And so the holding on to a self identity or phenomena having some kind of independent identity is either taken as a cognitive obscuration or the delusions depending on how they interpret suchness. And according to master Nāgārjuna, these poisons that and this kind of ignorance that we are talking about is identified as being a delusion, destructive emotion as opposed to that of the cognitive obscuration. And also in the sutras, there is mention of understanding the suchness or emptiness in order for us to reach the state of arhatship in either through the system of the Hearers or Solitary Realizers.
So this shows that this kind of apprehension or grasping on to its true nature of things is that of the destructive emotions. And therefore, so long as you have a wish to go out of this saṃsāra, this kind of conditioned existence, the suffering of conditioned existence, yeah, to that extent, would want to close look at the cause of it and to overcome that cause naturally within yourself. And so this wish to overcome this ignorance is, in other words, that of wishing to go out of the saṃsāra to reach nirvana. And for that to overcome that of the destructive emotions. And the more you want to overcome this destructive emotion genuinely through understanding it correctly, there is the greater wish to attain that of nirvana.
And so based on your understanding of true understanding of the possibility to overcome this delusion, the destructive emotions, you will have to that extent a greater desire to attain that of the nirvana. And it’s like trying to overcome one’s enemy. If you want to defeat one’s enemy, what you have to know is that you can actually you are more powerful or can overcome the enemies. And then accordingly, you will use the different means to crush your enemy and to be victorious. And so in order for us to have this great this, I call, full sort of confidence in overcoming the the the the ignorance, And one must see that this kind of suffering is something which we can overcome, which we can put an end to.
And therefore, once you have that kind of confidence to progress, to actualize the path, you have this confidence in overcoming the delusion, the ignorance, then you will seek that of the path that which would overcome it. So in this way, you have to understand how you should understand be aware of suffering and think of overcoming the suffering, causes of suffering and then actualizing that of the cessation and then practicing the path. After this session, are you arranged some discussion? Have you arranged some, discussion session after this teaching in the afternoon here? So that I think useful.
So further discussion can be useful. Then perhaps tomorrow tomorrow is a two session. Like today, I think at the beginning, I want to take some questions and also including from Chinese audience, from Taiwanese audience and anyone. So I want to take some questions. Although yesterday, we have some question and answer, but there’s so many questions there.
So not sufficient time, so I would like to take some questions. Okay. Then like that. And thank you. See you again tomorrow.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.