1 h 54 min · 8,376 words · 20 October 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. On the first morning of a three-day teaching on the Four Noble Truths, the Dalai Lama addresses an international audience of Singaporeans, Vietnamese, Indonesians, and visitors from Romania and beyond, speaking a mixture of English and Tibetan through interpreters. He begins by contextualizing Buddhism as an ancient but increasingly global religion now relevant to contemporary ethical crises, particularly through its concept of interdependence, which he argues offers wisdom for environmental, economic, and social challenges. He then explains his thirty-five-year dialogue with modern scientists, clarifying that Buddhist engagement with science concerns neither proof of next lives nor conversion, but rather the investigation of mind, emotion, and secular ethics—domains where Buddhist philosophy and practice offer unique empirical insights. Finally, he introduces the Four Noble Truths themselves: suffering and its two levels (physical and mental); the causes of suffering rooted ultimately in ignorance; the logical possibility of ceasing suffering through wisdom; and the path of practice that follows from this understanding. Throughout, he emphasizes that knowledge and critical reasoning, not mere faith, form the foundation of genuine Buddhist practice.
File metadata (for organising)
File: The ; 20 October 2009 (Day 1 of 3; Morning) Video (HQ) Teachings on Tibetan B….mp3
UUID: e0ccf4e8-4f89-44be-99e4-439d35028076
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~8,373
So so now today, some, language problem. Language problem, those, people who come from Singapore and also from Hong Kong, they prefer English. It seems to see they wanted to examine my English. So so it is not right. Lama’s English examined by student is not right.
But okay, it doesn’t matter. So anyway, so as far as I can speak through English, then I try. But then, of course, the the as a real explanation about Buddhadharma or Buddhist philosophy, then, of course, my English not adequate. So if I try, they how should they try to speak, I mean, through English, try to, explain about Buddhist philosophy, then Buddhist philosophy will become very poor because of my ink my English very, very poor. So now I think some kind of mixture.
Some part English, this is some part, is it Tibetan? So we have little complication with the translation. Chinese translation Okay. Like that. So now, today, the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra, a recitation of the Prajñāpāramitā Sūtra, in Vietnamese.
Vietnamese. Vietnamese. Like that. So so at the beginning, please recite. Now, with a great community of monks and great community of all sufferers.
At that time, the Bhagavan absorbed in the concentration or the concentration on the categories of phenomena called the profound illumination. Also, at that time, the Bodhisattva Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and behold those five aggregates to also be empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of Buddha, the Buddha said this to the Buddha, how should any son of the lineage Thank you. Is asking is to what is the k. The stance of which they said after the hospital trip?
What’s in English? Seven. Seven. Mhmm. Good.
So spiritual brothers and sisters, once more, I have the opportunity to give lecture on Buddhism to mainly Singaporean and then also Vietnamese and people from Hong Kong and then also some Indonesian. So indeed, I’m very, very happy. Buddhism actually, historically, is the Asian religion, one of the important Asian religion. Now today, because of technology, because of the availability of information of different culture, different religion, So on this planet, even some remote area, there are some people now showing interest about Buddhadharma. Now for example, now here, this time, one group from Romania, about I think 80 or 90 come from Romania.
So we only know Chachysko, that dictator. But I never been Romania and we have very little contact but I little bit surprised this is some group from Romania is to come, showing interest about Buddhism. And then also some people from Latin America, Argentina who speak Spanish, like that. So these are the indication. And also I know, I think in Uganda, some African of course, South Africa, there are, quite number of people who are showing interest about Buddhism including some native people.
And also I think Uganda or some one country where some I think Buddhist temple. I saw the picture like that. So like Christianity, anyway, is international religion. Something like that. So the Buddhism also becoming like that.
So of course, all major religious tradition now originally come from different part of the world, but now today become something the old religion like that. So in any way, traditionally, Buddhism come from India, from Asia. So many people in Asian continent traditionally Buddhist. Of course, China, huge country, most of poverty nation that historically, generally, Buddhist country like that. So we all this is student of same teacher.
That’s Buddha Śākyamūni. So we are follower of Buddha Śākyamūni. And the, Buddhadharma, one of the ancient world religion, at the same time, very relevant today’s world. Of course, all other major religions also is irrelevant, but particularly Buddhism is an emphasis. They sort of some kind of infinite altruism, compassion, not only the human being, fellow human being, but also you see the entire sentient being.
And very much emphasis on non violence. So that is today’s world really need that message. Then Buddhist philosophy, Buddhist concept, concept of interdependency, concept of interdependent, because interdependent. That that view, again, something very relevant today’s world because now today’s world, the I think mainly human population increase, much increase, then using resources now increasing, much increased. And then also technology, way of life also has much changed using much technology.
So as a result, there’s some impact on natural environment. So here, our concept of interdependency, very helpful to develop the attitude of whole world, whole planet itself, like environment, not something separate but we sent in being particularly 6,000,000,000 human beings, is it very much sort of related with that? Our future depend on the planet’s sort of ecology, proper ecology. So therefore, let’s say, the this interdependence the concept of interdependency bring us the fuller awareness that how important we’re taking care of the planet. Then in economy also, now global economy, not only nation to nation but also continent to continent heavily interdependent.
Is it that also brings is it the Buddhist concept of interconnectedness or interdependent? Well, like that. So I think our health viewpoint also, this concept of interdependency, physical health.
Mental health very much interlinked. So now modern medical scientist begin to realize in order to, in order to how should they in order to take better health, you should there is no point to neglect about our emotion because of stable, calm emotion, calm mind is very important for physical health. So all these interdependency, that’s the reality. So the concept of interdependency interdependent this is that bring us the concept of holistic. So it is very relevant today’s world.
In ancient time, like we Tibetan remain Tibet, high attitude, people call roof of the world, and no knowledge and the practice, the reality, not much not much connection with outside world. So through centuries, we remain like that. Now today, that kind of real reality no longer there, completely changed. So I often use it telling or expressing. Now today’s world, according to this reality, now century old concept of we and they is no longer there.
Now we must consider entire world as a part of we because individual’s future depend on rest of the world because of the new reality, environment issue, economy issue, all these things. So therefore, the Buddhist concept concept of the Sanskrit and rough translation, interdependency. Is it that concept really relevant today’s world? So sometimes I talk I’m also talking to some Muslim friend. From religiously, they are Muslim.
Nothing to do with the Dharma. But there are, I mean, people on this planet. So therefore, the Buddhist concept of interdependency is something useful for them also. I usually sit telling half joke, half serious. So like that.
So in concept of interdependency originally come from Buddhadharma, but it is something applicable to this world, today’s world, irrespective whether believer or whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist or whether believer or non believer. So some my scientist my sort of scientist friend, after our discussion of sort of how to say casual talk about the Buddhist concept of interdependency, Then some of them really impressed this idea, this concept. So they they love this concept. Usually, you see these people, let’s say the more they have some sort of understanding. Everything, you see, was the the basis of these existing as particles.
Many, many things you see in war. And something happened there, its effect, field here. So like that. And the quantum physics like that. So therefore, some scientists with their love, with this concept.
There are some of them, not religious person. They as they broadly say, they don’t believe about next life or these things. But it’s impractical, did this life. They said they found this concept is something very relevant to do. Like that.
So so this Buddhist or Buddhist teaching, one of the ancient religion but also relevant today’s world. Then, I think many of you may know now more than thirty years, I think nearly thirty five years, I had some, what’s it, a contract with scientists because since my childhood, I have keen interest about modern science and modern technology. Of course, my knowledge still very limited, but I have keen interest about modern science. So Oh, Tibetan. Then I can I can recite?
Not this not necessarily depend on translator. So at the initial stage, when I express my desire, to discuss or to meet scientists and to discuss about thing, about reality or external things or these things. And some my friend warned me science is killer of religion. So be careful. So then I thought the basic Buddhist, what’s the day, way of thinking, particularly the Nālānda masters of the way of thinking is a very critical way to examine.
Even Buddha’s own word is critically sort of examine, examine, analyze. Then some of the Buddha’s own teaching. If that concept goes some contradictory with our reasons, then they take is it that Buddha’s word is interpretable. Interpretable. Oh, interpret.
Interpretable teachings. Not acceptable unless you take different meaning or different interpretation. So that’s a knowledge of master sort of way of thinking. And Buddha himself made clear, oh, my follower should not accept my teaching out of faith, out of devotion, but rather through experiment, investigation by yourself. So that way of sort of thinking is very much scientific way.
So I often use it for expressing. If scientist, I should they prove the nonexistence of next life, not just mere sort of not finding, but proof nonexistence, then theoretically speaking, Buddhist must accept that. So therefore, I thought it’s a no no problem, no danger, discussed with modern science. And I believe it’s a science because as a result of meeting with many scientists, their mind very brilliant and true scientist, no feeling of different nationality, but true sense of international internationalism there. And also their attitude towards everything is very, objective.
So so therefore, I always happy meeting with genuine scientist because of my respect, admiration. They are brilliant mind and very objective, very unbiased. Their mind very open. Through investigation. If some new things which in the past is never sort of thought such such thing, if there is something through investigation there, they are ready to accept.
So it is quite, unbiased and open mind. So you see, meeting, discuss with modern scientists. Eventually, now after 20 more than twenty years, it become very clear. The dialogue with modern scientists modern science. And I usually call Buddhist science, not Buddhism.
That means we are not discussing with scientists about next life or about buddhahood, about salvation, moksha. That’s our business. So we are just or neither we are trying to prove or support from science about Buddhism. That also no. More than two thousand five hundred years passed, Buddhists survived without support of science.
So still we can survive. No problem. So but simply, you see the modern science are highly developed. Now scientists themselves now accept the moral thing, moral principle or moral thing, moral ethics. You see, the science is simply trying to seek the truth or the reality.
There is no sort of idea. Take long term. Adopting positive and actions and discard negative things. Scientific way, no point no idea of good or bad. Simply try to seek the reality.
That’s all. So if we, carry the research, they already did some kind of objective there. We want that. And then to achieve that through scientific research or reasoning, it’s biased. So when we carry investigation or modern science or Buddhist Buddhist science or Buddhist approach, we must neutral.
Anything can be possible. First level, we are trying to the trying to seek the reality. At that time, no question of positive or negative. Once we found the reality, then the second level, the question whether useful or harmful or neutral. Let’s come later.
So therefore, among the scientists now, and particularly the medical scientists now showing the calm mind or positive mind very good for our health. So they are beginning to think how to bring calm mind. So that now related with the moral ethics. It’s not talking about next life. I’m not talking about God.
Simply, in order to be more also the healthy body like that. So therefore so in that respect, when the subject subject subject subject about mind, about emotion. Then the best sources of the information about mind or emotion, these in Asian religions, Hinduism, and Buddhism. Because there is tradition of practice of Samādhi, single pointed mind, training mind. So more information upon mind and also emotion.
So therefore, time passes. More and more scientists now showing eagerness to get information from eastern sort of tradition about mind, about emotion, then how to tackle these different emotions. Meantime, we Buddhist, say, in in Buddhist text, it’s already mentioned about particles or subatomic particles, already mentioned there. And also cosmology, these things mentioned there. So therefore, it is important to learn from the modern what’s it, scientific knowledge about cosmology, about matters, modern physics, especially quantum physics like that.
These are very, very useful for Buddhist. I think up to now what damage happen is now for example, myself, I’m Buddhist. I’m Buddhist practitioner, firm believer of Buddhism. But now I do not accept the Mount Meru. On the on the flat world in the center Mount Meru, and the sun and the moon go like that.
That I no longer accept. So I take the liberty. Buddha give us you should examine my my sort of teaching. So a Buddha say it did a different text. They he ex he described or explained different form of world, different form of planet.
So no problem. So like that. So therefore so like that, you see the learning about matters, about external things from modern science, immense health. So the, persona, let’s say, or discussion or share, each other Share. This concept, Buddhist scientists, that’s something something new and something quite useful.
Now more and more books
The first day about these discussions now now coming. More and more now coming. So like that. So now here, I usually some people, you see, refer dialogue between science and Buddhism. I have that’s not correct word.
The correct word is firstly, we have to make usually, I make three sort of three parts Buddhism, three parts. Buddhist science, Buddhist concept of philosophy, and Buddhist religion. So the we are discussing or engaging discussion or dialogue with modern science, modern scientist about the first level first level of the the first part, Buddhist science, not Buddhist religion, not Buddhist philosophy sometimes such as interdependency. This philosophy, this concept sometimes involved. And then also, some scientists actually use the much interest about the ultimate reality just mere sort of what should they?
Discrimination. Right? Without, without the Any strings. Having any Independent existence. Existence.
So such concept is some scientist is showing interest. But there is some Christian friend also is showing, interest about this, concept such as emptiness. So one of my Christian friend, oh, very wonderful Christian monk, he of course, we I mean, many many Christian friend and also some Muslim. This is showing interest about practice of love, compassion, forgiveness, tolerance, these things because these are common practice. Then did this particular Christian monk, now he no longer with us.
This particular sort of Christian monk, you see, showing interest about the Buddhist concept of the emptiness. Since I we know each other very well, so I told him, this is not your business. This Buddhist unique concept, so therefore, better don’t think. I really feel a little anxious. You see this concept eventually, you see, bring everything relative, no absolute.
That I think very harmful for as a monotheistic religious religious practitioner. The sort of faith towards god, absolute, independent, I think, harmful for that sort of pursuit of faith. So therefore, I deliberately told him, better not think that. So like that. So it is some part of Buddhist concept involved or dialogue with, modern scientist.
But then the third Buddhist religion, never. We we never use a touch. And for my part, another reason, my main aim, main motivation, dialogue with scientists and also, oh, yes, scientists and thinkers. Main object wait. Main object, Suraj.
Main object. Objective. Our main objective is is it to bring deeper awareness about moral ethics, about right thinking of mind. Moral ethics. Because now we are lacking that.
Because of that, lot of unnecessary problems happening. So therefore, and among millionaires, very rich, very rich family, They have no worry about money money or these things. But as an individual, I found some are very unhappy person. And also in the in the society, among the young student, among the younger people, also also sometimes let’s say there’s some violence, some unnecessary problems, these things happen. So we need some effort to promote this inner value.
But if this effort based on religious faith, then become difficult. So therefore, India’s tradition, secularism. I think that is very important. So here, secularism does not mean disrespect or rejection of religion, but rather respect all religions. Recently, met, the opposition parties, India’s opposition party’s leader on my old friend, mister Advani.
He told me while we casual talk, you see, he told me one of the reason India successfully established democracy. The main one main reason he mentioned to me is two centuries, thousand years here in this country, there’s one tradition, respect people from I mean, people who have different views. He mentioned more than two thousand years during Buddhist time also, one school of thought that Indian language is called Charvaka, who deny existence of next life or existence of god or Buddha, nothing. It’s just dislike. So that’s called Charvaka.
So rest of the Buddhist school rest of what’s the philosophical holder consider rest of the difference of tradition, spiritual tradition, consider this Charvaka philosophy is nihilism. So much sort of debate and criticize, you see, that view, Charvaka view. At the same time, they describe those people who holding that view, they call sage sage. Yes. There is they consider these people also rishi.
Rishi means or rishi means, they don’t understand. Sage. Sage. Sage. A Tibetan word, So worth it, respect.
So he mentioned that. As far as viewpoint is concerned, nihilist nihilist so condemn. But as a person, respect it, worthy respect because they take certain views with their own reasons or logics. So like that. So he mentioned that.
So these Sarvaka people actually non believer. So thousand years respect these what’s the day, philosophical. Traditions. Traditions. Traditions.
So that means respect non believers view also. So I feel and also many my friend is agree same view. Now we must develop a method promotion method of promotion promotion of moral ethics without touching religion. Purely, not only non sectarian, but purely Secular level. Secular way.
It is very possible. It should be. Then another another word I think secular means now here. Secular moral ethics means universal value. If we approach these moral ethics through religion, now for example, such as through Buddhism, that’s then not universal, universality only for Buddhist, such as Christianity or Islam or Hinduism, then just one portion.
So therefore, we really need secular way to promote these things. Now here, the work with scientist is it for promotion of secular ethics. That’s my main motivation. So nothing to do with religion, nothing to do with Buddhism. Of course, my appearance as Buddhist monk, that cannot change.
So among the scientists, there’s one Buddhist monk there. But my talk, never talk about Buddhism, Buddhist religion, only Buddhist science. So I remember the in early period, the one, I think, neurologist. The Francisco. Francisco.
Neurologist, by the way. Great scientist. He of he also Buddhist, well known Buddhist. So in our discussion, you see, he usually say, sometimes he explain about Buddhist view. Then sometimes, of course, as a scientist, so our main discussion is regarding such a sort of scientific sort of topic.
So sometimes he mentioned when he shift the topic, scientific discussion to Buddhist view, then he say, now I wear Buddhist cap. Then he say something, explanation according Buddhism. Then he say, now I’m wearing science cap. Then the scientific view like that. So I also you see, when I participate with scientist discussion about this dialogue, Robe, of course, there, but I actually, you see, wearing the science cap.
Not talking about next life or next or say about nirvana or these things. So like that. So main motivation is promotion of secular values. So now here, Buddhist science, Buddhist philosophy, Buddhist concept, and Buddhist religion. This actually Buddha, when he his sort of first Dharma wheel or first teaching about the Four Noble Truths.
The way he explained he’s explained about Four Noble Truths, three parts. So during the four noble truths teaching on the four noble truths, the first Buddha gave the teaching on the nature of the four noble truths, and then there’s the function secondly, the function of the four noble truths, and then the function together with the the resultant result of the Four Noble Truths. Oh. So there’s there’s three portions. The first one, simply explanation about reality.
That portion not mentioned of positive or negative, and practice all disorder, Risten. Right? Not mention that. Then after knowing the reality, and since we want happiness, do not want suffering. Then second level, he mentioned the So the Buddha taught that we should understand what suffering is and abandon or overcome the cause or the origin of suffering.
This way. No. So this shows then third result. So this shows, first part, I believe, Buddhist science. Second part, then second part and third part, Buddhist concept of possible that is possibility of cessation of causes of suffering.
So therefore, it is worthwhile, you see, to make effort to elimination, to eliminate the sources of causes of suffering. And this possibility to achieve permanent happiness or joyfulness because the complete elimination of causes of suffering, that is permanent happiness. So that’s what Buddhist Buddha himself, you see, taught that way. So I feel Buddha also make something like three part. Buddhist follow Buddhist science and Buddhist concept and Buddhist practice or Buddhist religion.
So what point am I talking now? What what what point am I? Now I myself is lost. So the point is, is it Buddhism? Yes.
Yes. Now I remember. I’m trying to say Buddhism is relevant to today’s world. Some sense? Yes.
Now, whenever I give lecture on Buddhism, even Tibetan, I always emphasis explanation about the concept of, as a the reality, concept of possibility of elimination. These mainly Buddhist sort of, concept of Buddhist philosophy rather than Buddhist religion. Because it seems to me, say in Buddhist country, like Tibet, China, And, of course, I never been, Vietnam. I think generally, Korean, I never been, but number of the Korean, you see, occasion, of meeting many Korean. So anyway, you see, it seems, oh, when I first visited Singapore, I think in late sixty, I think ’67 or something like that.
Then the audience, some go to sleep. Then when I give some Initiation. Initiation. Then everybody very, very, very alert. Tibetan also like that.
So unfortunately, not much interest to learn about Buddhism, but just faith. That’s not Buddhist way. If just faith sufficient, then why Buddha taught so many sort of teachings. And also, you see this Nāgārjuna and these great knowledge masters, you see lot of explanation about Buddhism. Why?
Just faith sufficient. Then I think much easier. Buddhism, no need for study. Years. Years.
So therefore, knowledge is very essential. I think the reason very clear. Buddhism, no idea of creator. Buddhism, something like self creation, our self creator. So Buddha himself, originally, ordinary centered being.
Eventually, he created through his own effort. He utilized all his potential eventually become Buddha. So Buddhahood, he himself created. So the seed of buddha, we call or Sanskrit word. The meaning is seed of Buddha or nature of Buddha.
We all have that. So therefore, Buddha himself, you see, his own highest level of Attainment. Attainment. Achievement. He himself created.
So he taught his follower, you have Buddha nature. Realize that and create buddhahood by yourself. He can’t help. He simply show the path or method. So the from that that viewpoint, we can say according Buddhism, no external creator but ourself as creator.
So therefore, the Buddhist way Buddhist way of practice or approach is utilize oh, then then another word. I think another word. The Buddha Dharma or Buddha state, nobody want suffering, but we always facing suffering. So since nobody wants suffering, that therefore, Buddha called the ultimate source of suffering is ignorance. So the the I said the force or counter force of ignorance is only wisdom, not just a wish.
So pray, prayer, faith, some form of wish. Just wish faith, not direct counter or oppose opposition of ignorance. So the the counter counter force of ignorance is knowledge. So knowledge, not just a mere faith. Knowledge means through analyze, through study.
So therefore so therefore, it’s a Buddha state. Human body is something important. Why? Because of this intelligence. Because Buddhist way of approach is utilize human intelligence maximum way through that way bring new concept or new awareness, new conviction through that way transform our destructive emotion or transform transform emotion.
That means destructive emotion reduce, constructive emotion increase. That’s the way. So therefore, in order to utilize our intelligence maximum way, knowledge is very essential. Just for initiation. Initiation where?
Initiation by a high lama and some some articles put in put put on your hat. Not sufficient. We ourselves must make effort. That’s important. So therefore, as a Buddha, you see state, I show I show you the path of salvation.
But whether salvation achieve or not, entirely up to you. He mentioned that. So he put all responsibility to on us. He he do not want to take responsibility about ours for the future. He quite clever.
I think this is reality. You know, the the successful life of student entirely develop the student, not on teacher. Of course, teacher must show with sincere sort of feeling of sort of care or sense of concern responsibility or sense of Care. Care or sense of concern. With that motivation must be there and can teach.
But ultimate responsibility is relying on student themselves. So that’s the Buddhist way. Therefore, knowledge is very, very essential. Knowledge also is to some stories, some some ancient lama through meditation and some vision, a mystical vision. The next next day, he fully sort of full full knowledge, full full knowledge gain gain full knowledge.
I think such things are very, very rare. We should not follow that way. These also from the Buddhist viewpoint, because their previous lives study and fuller knowledge and then this new life, not apparently not study, but this this has an impact of the previous lives of study or knowledge still there. So then due to some causes or conditions, some factor, Then with blessing of, some higher Buddhist or Buddha, then sometimes it possible. But we, generally, I think entirely depend on our own effort.
I have the name of Dalai Lama. So from the Buddhist viewpoint, of course, my previous lives is a I feel some connection, my dislike with previous lives. But then present my sort of experience, of course, the experience is very, very limited in spite of big name Dalai Lama, but actually very little experience. And knowledge also very limited because I’m quite a lazy student. So but inside that, you see that much knowledge and experience come through effort.
Now my age, over 74 years, still I’m studying, reading, thinking with certain deeper as a contemplation. Contemplation. Contemplation. Yes. Oh, contemplation.
Yes. Like that. So therefore, my spiritual brothers or spiritual Buddhist brothers, sisters, the study is very, very important. Uh-huh. So then then another thing I want to share with you is my number one commitment is, as a human being, as one of the 6,000,000,000 human beings, I’m trying to trying to make clear, we human being, everyone want happy life and want a successful life.
For that, they we must we must pay more attention about our inner value. Through that way, you get more inner peace, more self confidence, more truthful, more honest. These are sources of happy life, and these reduce our stress or tension and fear. More compassionate mind, more honest way of life, you have proud, you can be transparent. Nothing to hide, nothing to fear.
No need pretension. Right? Pretension. Pretension. Well, No.
Pretension. Pretension. Pretension. No need hypocrisy, truthful, honest, transparent. These are then reduced tension, stress, fear, and built more self confidence.
So inner strength come. So that’s number one commitment as a human being. The second level, then I am Buddhist and particularly more acquaintance with follower of other religion such as Christianity, Islam, different Hinduism, and Jainism, Sikhism, and Zoroastrian, and Judaism, more acquaintance. Right? Yes.
Sort of the more sort of conviction. Oh, all these tradition wonderful, really carry same message, message of love, truth. Here, truth means conventional level, not ultimate reality, then different different views there. So honesty, transparency, all these, all these traditions, they have same sort of message and same potential. And different views, different philosophy there.
It is necessary. I usually have joke, you see, with respect Buddha. Seek permission from him. And I I I I tell him the audience. Buddha, our teacher, our beloved teacher, but he taught contradictory philosophies.
You see, among his different sort of teaching, there are different concept, different philosophy. But these difference not only just mere minor differences, but also you see fundamental differences. So these are contradictory philosophy. So then, Buddha taught these contradictory philosophy not not out of his own confusion. Certainly not.
Sometimes, a little bit like the word, a little bit disrespect, but Buddha like drunk. One one day, to some people, taught certain philosophy. The next day, another people, another group, taught different, not that. Certainly not that. Or Buddha deliberately want to create more confusion among his own disciples.
No. Or in order to make quarrel among his own follower, you see, one follower hold this philosophy, one one follower is he holding another sort of philosophy, then let them fight. No. No. No.
Certainly not. So then the answer is, Buddha taught this contradictory philosophy necessary because of the listener or audience. There are different mental disposition. So like to some people, hopefully, including myself, the Mādhyamika philosophy’s viewpoint is very, very suitable. It’s very effective to me.
To some people, the Cittamātra philosophy, mind only school of thought. That philosophy, much more effective. To some people, there are those for whom just the mere concept of absence of independent self. Just that, more suitable. So Buddha, the main reason Buddha why Buddha taught different contradictory philosophy is necessary because of different mental disposition among his follower.
So what we learned from this, yes, on this planet, to many people, the concept of god, concept of creator is much more effective. I have some Christian friend or some Muslim friend. They have sort of devotion to god, faith towards god. So often when they mention about god, when they chanting some prayer, weeping, tear. And their practice also totally devoted to well-being of others other human being.
I think as far as service to humanity is concerned, particularly in education field, I think our Christian brothers and sisters, I think made maximum effort, maximum sort of sort of service. Recently, I was in Ladakh. There are small Ladakh Christian community there. So I whenever I visit there, they also invite me. So I went there, then I told them on this planet, last few centuries, I think in the field of education, I think Christian brothers, sisters really made tremendous contribution for education everywhere.
Some of course with motivation of conversion, but generally, I think that they really dedicated for well-being of fellow human being. We Buddhists, I think very little truthfully speaking, isn’t it? Nowadays, in in in twentieth century, some Hindus like Ramakrishnan is now devoting for education and health. I think copying from Christian brothers, sisters doing. And also nowadays, we Buddhist Tibetan Buddhist monasteries also now taking education, care of education for younger people like that.
All these, I think we are copying from our Christian brothers, sisters sort of practice like that. And some some area in India where there is some Tibetans settlement there, some are quite remote. But there, we can we can see some missionary hospital or school. Those nuns, Christian nuns, monks, totally dedicated their life for well-being of these poor people. So they are sort of what is it?
The enthusiasm or they are sort of dedication, selfless sort of effort come from their faith. Submission, total submission to God and fulfillment of God’s wish to serve fellow human being. Isn’t it? So therefore, is it all, and Muslim also. Sometimes we get the impression that Islam is
More militant. That’s wrong. You will find there are Muslim who really is a practice of love, compassion, these things. Yeah. So therefore so more acquaintance with this follow-up different tradition, we get the conviction.
All major tradition have same potential and same message put aside those philosophical things. Oh, some my some not my some my friend she told me some Christian and and some some Christians, they said, they feel Dalai Lama now coming to Christian countries. So he’s really now bring more people to help. Understandable. Of course, understandable.
That is, you see, concept of one truth, one religion. That is sometimes, you see, create difficulties. We Buddhist also, if we feel only Buddhist can go better life and other, go hell, wrong. Of course, nirvana, that is something different. The the concept of nirvana entirely depend on the concept of selfless selfless theory, soulless theory.
No soul theory. So that’s something different. That’s something very unique about this Buddhism like that. So otherwise, you see, all major traditions have the same potential whether they accept the next life or not. From Buddhist viewpoint, definitely, they bring good next life.
That’s quite sure. So therefore, really worthy to respect all major traditions With knowing, we need humanity need variety of religion, different way of approach. And then genuine respect, genuine admiration can can develop. So that’s my second sort of commitment. So here, I think some among the audience, some Christian practitioner, I heard there’s some Christian practitioner also who’s here.
So now we all once we accept religion, then we should be serious and sincere. If religion remain our knowledge and our daily practice, daily way of life is something different, then you are not very that that shows you are not very serious. Then through that way, no benefit. So other hand, if the teaching or advice from the tradition, from the religious tradition implement and become part of our life, our way of life, then you get real experience, real value. And your whole thinking change, whole behavior change.
So we should be whether we accept religion or not, that’s up to individual. Once we accept, then we should be serious and sincere. In economy matter or some other matter, some little hypocrisy here and there, okay, understandable, and the politics may be okay. But in religious field, I think hypocrisy is I think no room there. We should be very sincere.
It is very important about that. Now about Buddhism now. Oh, Buddhism or Buddhist tradition, mainly, it’s two, sort of two two traditions, Pāli tradition and Sanskrit tradition. Sanskrit tradition I think Pāli tradition is the origin, the basis of Buddhadharma, which now Thai, Burma, or Sri Sri Lanka, Cambodia, in these countries, they practice, they follow Pāli tradition very sincere basically, very, very sincerely. Wonderful.
And then later in India, Buddhism then becomes something academic level. So there, Sanskrit is the some important academic language. Yes. No. So like master like Nāgārjuna, all these great master, then is it they, sort of what’s it they?
The language they use Sanskrit. And also, according Sanskrit tradition, when Buddha carried at the time of Buddha there, he also used to taught some teaching in Sanskrit. What? The Pāli tradition, the people who hold the or Pāli tradition not to believe that, not accept that. And also some modern history and also is not.
What’s the day? Not the not that kind of view. But like Nāgārjuna, these are great master, very intelligent people. They never satisfy just a word. They always investigate critically.
So therefore, if the Sanskrit Sanskrit sort of teaching text not taught by Buddha, then I think in Nāgārjuna, such a brilliant people, I think do not accept. Right? Did will not ask will not so did not accept. Right? Did not.
Will not. Have accept. Will not accept. But then Nāgārjuna’s own writing, many quotation of Sanskrit text by Buddha’s own word. And also some of his follower like Candrakīrti.
Nowadays, I’m reading one of the important Candrakīrti sort of commentary about Mūlamadhyamakakārikā. Wonderful. So I’m reading. Of course, not much time, but whenever I have time, I say I read little bit. Bit by bit like that.
So they take quotation of Sutter. So therefore, it is clear. You see these great, brilliant, logic kind of a logician, Buddhist master, these must examine these texts whether authentic text of Buddha’s own word or not. So I believe Buddha also is taught Sanskrit sort of version. Many time, I think more than I think forty years ago, I met one Hungarian Buddhist Buddhist scholar.
He told me at Buddhist time, the Sanskrit word Sanskrit language not not used there. So Buddha, even you see, do not know Sanskrit language. So all these Sanskrit texts has come later created by Buddhist masters like Nāgārjuna. These people later created, not Buddha’s own word. So once he told me like that, maybe two or I don’t think.
I’m quite sure. Nāgārjuna, I think much better knowledge about India’s sort of India’s history, I think. So sometimes I argue with sort of different modern different views. Firstly, Nāgārjuna Indian. So logically, if you if you if you use common sense, I think India’s history should know better by Indian, number one, than western scholars.
Then secondly, time timing. Nāgārjuna came only after four hundred years since Buddha passed away. So the person who come after around four hundred years of Buddha’s death, his kind of knowledge should be better than those people who’s who talking about India’s history after two thousand five hundred years. Then thirdly, Nāgārjuna not like, I think, let’s say, a person who just faith towards Buddha. And little bit because of dull.
I don’t think you should like a little bit to say dull. I don’t think like that. As I mentioned earlier, he had the courage to examine Buddha’s own text through reasoning. So he must examine. This is really taught by Buddha himself or not.
I think he must examine. So through these reasons, I believe the Sanskrit tradition taught by Buddha. However, there’s differences. The Bali tradition, Buddha publicly taught. Then these like Sūtra, as he he taught very few human beings who have some special sort of as a karmic as a day virtues who have the ability to see not only Buddha, but also some other deity type of Buddhismas, our, or like this.
So therefore, Buddha taught some the the how’s it there? Those Sanskrit text, usually, some that people call the Buddhist sort of text or Mahāyāna text. As it is, not publicly taught, but selected in the few individuals with some the sort of higher beings, other higher beings like that. Then particularly Tantrayāna is taught only very few individual. So like that.
So therefore, it’s quite quite understandable. You see the those records. You see, what is the The three councils that were held to compile the teaching of the Buddha. These recorded. So in this, only Pāli, Pāli tradition.
And then, another follower of Nāgārjuna, great master, a logician. He mentioned these Sanskrit Buddhist word. So those who compiled these teachings were Maitreya, Lord Maitreya Mañjuśrī. So the sort of skeptical view about so called Mahāyāna text, You see, even before Nāgārjuna, already there. So in Nāgārjuna’s own word and also, in their text, is in their some special effort is to prove that Mahāyāna text taught by Buddha.
So that means during that period also already some Buddhist already denying denial. Right? No. Denying. Yeah.
Like that. So now, I think from the logical viewpoint, for example, Four Noble Truths and particularly the third noble truth, cessation of suffering. In the Pāli Sūtra, it seems not much reasoning, you see, to prove the possibility of achieving cessation. Then the Sanskrit text, a lot of sort of reasoning to prove a possibility of cessation and therefore achievement of that secession is possible. And all these reasons ultimately is based on our daily experiences.
So that’s the Nālānda sort of, what should they, Sanskrit tradition sort of way of thinking. So therefore, the Sanskrit tradition is very, very helpful to build the healthy Buddhism. Without Sanskrit tradition, I think difficult. We have to rely on Buddhist word. Like that.
And then we Tibetan case. The person who introduced Buddhism in Tibet was another follower of Nāgārjuna’s tradition around seventh seventh, eighth centuries, the great master Shāntarakshita. Shāntarakshita. Great master.
Great philosopher, Madhya philosopher, and also, I said a great logician. In his writing, we can see that author is really wonderful logician, a wonderful philosopher. So therefore, Tibetan Buddhist tradition, since you see, start from such master, not only just the meditation, but emphasis importance of logic and the holder of philosophy. So therefore, till now, I think Tibetan tradition, there is sort of tradition of emphasis, the study and logic, the critical way, critical examination. That’s become something very alive into the tradition.
So so because of these masters, of course, Guru Padmasambhava also at that same time as he came, but he mainly, you see, teach or taught some tantric teaching. But publicly, they were holding Buddhadharma in eighth century, the Shāntarakshita. He himself, monk, bhikṣu, and he so he he he established monks or Monasticism. Monasticism. And then also he carried teaching, debate these things like that.
So that’s background. Now my main point or main main teaching about four noble truths. Now I I switch my language now, Tibetan. So after his enlightenment, before long after his enlightenment, the Buddha taught the four noble truths at Varanasi. And with regard to the teaching on four noble truths, first, he said that this is the noble truth of suffering and so forth, which is to say teaching the noble truth from the
Point of view of the nature of the the Four Noble Truths. Mhmm. Now why why he is he taught for four things? Suffering is causes, at a permanent happiness or joyfulness has its own causes. That shows basic Buddhist concept interdependency.
Now here, interdependency, there are two level of meaning. One meaning is law of causality. Everything everything which momentarily changing must happen due to its own causes and conditions, must be continuation. Another level of meaning of interdependency is that deeper that is also the things if we try to investigate the deeper level of reality, then there is sort of contradiction, appearances, and deeper reality. So if we go beyond appearances, try to know the reality, then something different picture, the absence of independent existence.
So then, describe the things are designated by thought. By names and thoughts. So that’s another level of interdependency. In Tibetan word, So with regard to dependency or dependent arising, There is the dependency of dependent arising and then dependency in terms of being designated. So the first level, on first level, now you see this four four number two is to come, law of causality.
Now he mentions suffering because suffering is our main concern. There’s no other reason. Simply, we have the feeling of I. And with that experience of pains and suffering and pleasure, that’s there. And there there you see pains and pleasure, there also you see two levels.
One mainly what’s it? Sensory level. Sensory level, pleasure, happiness, or satisfaction, and suffering, pains. Another mental level that I think we obviously experience in our day to day’s life. Sometimes mentally, very happy, but physically, some pain.
Isn’t it? Sometimes, you see physically, very well, no problem, but mentally, so much worry. So there are two levels. Mental level or two kinds, mental level experience, pain and suffering and pleasure, and physical level, pain and pleasure, physical level, two things. Between these two, the mental level is most superior.
Again, our daily experience. Physical pain, we can subdue by mental thinking. Now for example, if you have some sort of serious pain, then if you think just pain, then feel more uncomfortable, more worry, more concern. But if you think the next patient who not only pain but also say they already got something, something, something, Then thinking that, oh, compare that, my case is better. Okay.
Then mentally now, different attitude. So the physical pain, at that moment feel little better. Isn’t it? So therefore, mental experience is more important, more stronger than physical experience. The physical experience can subdue by mental attitude.
Mental suffering, very difficult to subdue by physical comfort. As I mentioned earlier, those are people who billionaire, lot of money and naturally due to money, lot of friend must be there. Although this friend really, human friend or money friend, still we have to investigate. But in any way, there are a lot of friends. That but but, you know, is it such people?
Physical level, everything okay. All the facilities there, but mentally, always suffer, always uncomfortable or fear or doubt. So too much stress, too much sort of anxiety, fear, doubt, jealousy. So that mental level of suffering cannot subdue by physical comfort. So therefore, the now here, you see two levels, suffering and pleasure, two levels.
Now this suffering by nature, we do not want. So just, you see, remove this suffering by wish, no. By prayer, no. Only since this suffering or experience due to entirely due to its own causes and the condition. Therefore, logically, in order to remove or in order to reduce this suffering, we must tackle the causes of the suffering.
So Buddha taught second truth, causes of suffering. Then now important Buddhist philosophy, philosophical concept, whether there is possibility to eliminate these causes of suffering. As I mentioned before, ultimate causes of suffering is ignorance. So now what kind of ignorance? There are so many different level of ignorance.
So the secondary levels of ignorance limitless. So we must investigate. There must be some basics of ignorance for for from that different sort of ignorance or different sort of emotions has come. So, you see, we must look the deeper level what is the ultimate base ultimate cause or the basis of this ignorance. Then the many ignorance on the level of conventional way or appearances.
This ignorance is come or based on ultimate ignorance or ignorance of ultimate reality. So all these are actually Both these types of ignorance, which are which is to say that ignorance with regard to conventional things and ignorance with regard to the ultimate nature of things are both misconceptions. So any misconception, logically, there’s opposition. Misconception is there is something but looks differently. So ignorance or misconception.
So the truth, something different is a truth. Reality or something different than that. So the reality is different from how things appear to us. So now for example, lie, any lie, basically no foundation. But truth, there is foundation.
Clear? So lie no matter how sort of what’s the clever, but if you more investigate, then there’s no cause of the truth. So therefore, it it also it will disappear. It cannot sort of stand that way. The truth means the reality.
I mean, truth means the the reality. So reality always remain there. So knowing the truth is opposition of the lie like that. And these two, for temporary lie sometimes stronger than truth. But through in this through time passes, the truth always stronger.
Now, that’s the basic sort of concept. Now, the ignorance no matter how powerful, but there is forceful antidote that is wisdom, which knows the reality. And that there you can further strengthening through reasoning, through further investigation. The ignorance, more investigation, more further sort of what’s the day because of the experiment, then, you see, it is weakness become. It become weaker, weaker, weaker like that.
So from that way, possibility of third truth, cessation of suffering. Of course, we need a lot of explanation. Then once we have we develop the some sort of awareness, the possibility of elimination of causes of suffering, Then since we do not want suffering, therefore, naturally, you see, we want to follow the method to elimination of the causes of suffering. That means Noble truth. No.
Tell him to. Four Noble Truths, four ideas come that because we do not want suffering, according to the law of causality, law of causality, then we must tackle the causes of the suffering. Then the possibility of cessation of cessation of of suffering or suffering’s cause, that’s the cessation of suffering. So since if there’s such possibility there, then we must follow the method. That’s for for for for for for for for no?
I think for for for taking care of physical, now lunchtime.
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.