35 min · 2,819 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 35-minute Q&A, Kyabje Rinpoche addresses questions reflecting contemporary concerns. He opens with the ethics of image destruction and collective karma, then tackles a striking question: if environmental collapse killed all humans, would that manifest as group karma? He explains the Buddhist doctrine of cyclic world destruction and how widespread disasters result from similar past actions. The philosophical core explores selflessness versus emptiness across Buddhist schools — why different traditions define these concepts differently and why realizing selflessness of the person precedes realizing selflessness of phenomena. He concludes by distinguishing deluded doubt from the investigative doubt that drives practice. For practitioners with some philosophical grounding.
File metadata (for organising)
File: KRFNT5CD2 – KR.mp3
UUID: 0a346e0a-094a-451e-8ea4-16d3ead4b415
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,823
Destroy these images or shrines and temples are doing it with a very negative set of mind. So therefore, the the result, of course, is a negative karma. They’re creating definite negative karma. Out of ignorance, they create negative karma. So, definitely, it is a negative karma which has been created.
The second part of the question is which what can we do as Buddhists to stop such actions? This, of course, is a very difficult point because those those those who destroy images, etcetera, out of a negative state of mind or ignorant state of mind is they already have a preconception that this is maybe something which they’re doing which is right for them. So for us to actually try to stop them and reason with them because they don’t may not have they may they will not have faith in the Buddhist teachings or Buddhist images as being holy and so forth because they don’t have that faith. It is difficult for us to reason with them and try to stop them from doing those actions. Now it will be even worse if we took up actions out of force.
If we took up force and reacted in a violent way, then that would even worsen the situation. It would also prevent them from creating negative karma, but we ourselves will be creating negative karma. So the the the the the only thing that we can really do is to actually make very strong prayers, do virtuous actions oneself and make strong prayers dedicating it towards their their their ignorance and their delusions and ignorance and negative set of minds being eliminated. Now to pray and dedicate one’s prayers for them to have a positive set of mind and a a wisdom mind and to be free from the the delusions, which create which which makes which influences them to create negative karma. That is the best we could do as Buddhist.
So other than meditating on love and compassion towards them, it is very little we can actually do to to prevent or stop them. So yesterday you talked about the world systems and the living beings. One of my concerns is that our planet is suffering extreme suffering due to humans’ exploitation of nature and might even in our lifetime cease to be able to sustain potential conditions for the existence of any life form. If or when there should occur a dramatic change in our environment, which could cause the planet’s self destruction and where we could all spontaneously suffer death and thus leaving no human or any living being to take rebirth in, would that be considered to be the ripening result of group karma? If such phenomenon exists, the end of our cyclic existence, or will those who are still bound to cyclic existence experience further suffering by being bound in an intermediate formless state?
I think this is exactly example of in which you used of us question not to be formless state until some other life form will appear and then maybe millions of years for us to take rebirth so that we can continue our cyclic existence. And for those who are already Buddhas, Bodhisattvas, Dharma protectors, where will they abide? Thank you. Generally speaking, wherever there are natural disasters or any kind of form of disaster where many beings dying together, it is described as being a ripening result of group karma, which means that all of these people who are affected by the disaster have done similar actions in the past, some time or another in the past, where now at this time, it so happens that it ripens for all of these beings at the same time. And and and then and then the like so, therefore, they experience the result in a in a similar way together.
If the if the world system as we know now were to come to an end such as through the destructions of, like, nuclear bomb or some sort of, you know, natural what we call man made disasters, then the people who the the beings who if if even if if everyone were to die, that would definitely be a result of the beings who are at that time in the world, the beings who are at that time in the world, all experiencing together the results of having created the negative karma in the past of having done similar things of killing killing others and so forth. So the the the direct cause for one’s life to end in a drastic way, in a what we call in to make one’s life short is a result of having engaged in the act of killing previously. So, therefore, those beings who are who who die in such a in such a state at whatever time is definitely a result of of created the karma of the past. So that that is definitely the case. And, actually, it is described in the teachings in the in the teachings that there there is definite era of destruction on on on in this in this on this on this The destruction there that there’s, like, a series of destructions, such as the destruction through fire, destructions through wind, destruction to the water, and the earth element.
So the destructions of the four elements would occur at a certain time where where eventually the whole world system will not not remain as we know now. However, as described in the teachings, for that era to come, there’s still many, many thousands of years yet to to you know, for it to happen. I think this is just a statement expressing my deepest appreciation for appreciation for the Dharma talk, the four noble truth. I’m very impressed with the English translation in English, but I wish that the whole session should be more comprehensive and simple as I have very little knowledge of the four noble truth. I hope that I’ll be able to understand well after the whole session.
I think I hope so too. Is realization of selflessness and emptiness the same? If not, would it be easier to realize emptiness before realization of selflessness? If not, would it be easier to realize emptiness before realization of selflessness? There cannot be one answer to this question because of the fact that there are different Buddhist schools which have different interpretations of selflessness and emptiness.
To give a very brief outline of the differences between the four different schools in Buddhism, First of all, the four Buddhist schools are known in the Sanskrit name as the Vaibhāṣika, the Sautrāntika, the Cittamātra, and the Mādhyamika. Amongst the four, the Mādhyamika school is considered to be the most supreme. And then the Mādhyamika itself is divided into the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika school and the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school. Now now if you take, like, five different schools with the classification of the Mādhyamika school, then the first two schools, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika school Now the Cittamātra school, which also known in English as the mind only school, the Cittamātra school, they do not specifically assert the term emptiness, but they believe they assert that there’s selflessness of a person and a selflessness of phenomena, the rest of the phenomena. And that is also true for Mādhyamika school within the Mādhyamika school, the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school also assert that there’s selflessness of person and selflessness of other phenomena.
Now, the selflessness which are explained in the first two schools the first three schools, the Vaibhāṣika, the Sautrāntika, and Cittamātra school, they assert the selflessness as being a self which is devoid of a independent what we call the specific term is sometimes difficult. I’ll just refer here, that they’re devoid the self is devoid of a supervisory self that is a different entity from the five aggregates. So that is a level of selflessness that lower Buddhist schools assert selflessness to be. Now, what we call Svatāntrika Mādhyamika School assert that there is selflessness of a person and selflessness of other phenomena and that they are that they are they are are they are different in when you when you realize one, it’s not necessarily you realize the other. So in other words, if you realize selflessness of a person, it doesn’t necessarily mean that you realize selflessness of other phenomena because realizing selflessness of a person is much easier relatively than realizing selflessness of other phenomena, and there’s that there what what we call grossness and subtleness between the two.
So realizing selflessness of a person is more grosser, so therefore easier to realize, and realizing selflessness of other phenomena is much more subtle and more therefore more difficult to understand and realise. Now the the highest Buddhist school, the the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school, assert that selflessness of a person and a selflessness of other phenomena is exactly is completely what we call identical. It’s the same thing. When you when you realize selflessness of a person, you you will also realize the selflessness of other phenomena. So so so, therefore, a selflessness of a person and a selflessness of other phenomena is the same thing.
So the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school, there’s no difference between selflessness of a person and emptiness. Selflessness and emptiness are synonymous. They’re the one and the same thing. Whereas in the lower Buddhist schools, as I mentioned earlier, there’s difference between selflessness and emptiness. Selflessness more specifically, selflessness of a person and emptiness, which they refer to the selflessness of other phenomena.
In the in the the Prāsaṇgika school, even though they assert that there’s no. So in the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school, even though there’s no subtlety subtle subtlety and grossness between selflessness of a person and a selflessness of other phenomena, they’re still due to the basis on which it is relied upon, they can be one can be easier than the other. So therefore, the realization of selflessness, the realization of selflessness of a person is easier in comparison to the realization of selflessness of other phenomena. Why? Because a person is just one one phenomena yourself, and one begins by realising selflessness of oneself easier, then realisation of selflessness of other phenomena follow after realising selflessness of a person, of oneself.
So therefore, even though there’s no subtlety and grossness between selflessness of a person and selflessness of other phenomena, selflessness of a person is easier to realize because of the basis itself, the basis of imputation. So any other questions? No. No. Sorry?
Then I just come on to Yeah. Yeah. Sure. One of the delusions mentioned was doubt. Doubt.
Yes. Doubt. Yes. I understood that the Buddha actually encourages doubt so that we don’t follow too readily a false path to truth. Can the Rinpoche please comment on that?
Thank you. To be more here, we need to be more specific. The the doubt which is listed in the six delusions, the six root delusions, is more specifically known as a deluded doubt. So that means that it is a doubt more it’s it’s a specific doubt where it has a doubt of the validity of the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, the Three Jewels, the validity of karma, cause and effect. And the doubt again, also within doubt, there’s a doubt which is leaning more towards the positive and leaning towards the negative.
So this is a specific doubt which is more a doubt which is leaning towards a negative that is more like, don’t believe that, you know, I I I don’t believe that Three Jewels can exist, that they have the ability or the validity of saving us or protecting oneself. I don’t believe that I don’t have the belief that cause and effect is valid. So that sort of doubt where one still has room to change, but still it is sort of more leaning towards the doubt is leaning towards the opposite. It is the fact that it is not valid. So it has a lack of conviction, a lack of conviction in the sense that conviction and the validity of whatever one is doubting.
Therefore it’s a more specific doubt called the deluded doubt. To be even more specific, the doubt can be divided into three types of doubts. The doubt which is leaning towards the possibility of something or another to be true or existing, the doubt which leans towards something as being not true even though in reality it is true or valid, leaning to the where to the side where one is not accepting and thinking that it’s not true, and then the doubt which is sort of like a neutral sort of doubt where thinking it could be true or could not be true. It is possible to be so or could be possible not to be so, sort of like in a a state neutral state where not being really sure either way. So now in this specific case, the the doubt as listed in the six delusions is a doubt which is leaning towards the positive the negative side of the negative side where it is like leaning towards a possibility of something like the Three Jewels and the validity of karma and so forth not to be true.
Yeah? So it’s a more specific doubt. To give an example of the useful doubt is the doubt which is useful as indicated by yourself earlier, would be the doubt, for example, of which arises after hearing teachings on, for example, like emptiness. Now earlier, one may not even have heard the word emptiness or selflessness. Now one comes to a teaching and starts hearing about selflessness or emptiness, then that starts rising, that starts making one to have sort of like doubts in one’s mind, the doubts which is like, Oh, this teaching on selflessness or emptiness, first one may have a feeling like it’s interesting.
Then as one begins to understand a bit more, one may think, oh, how is it? Is it this way, or, you know, is is the explanation of emptiness to be this way, or is it that way? You know, what is the correct way to understand emptiness? Not being sure of the actual correct understanding or even an intellectual understanding, not knowing which is the correct way to assert emptiness and having doubts of which could be true. That sort of doubts are all very positive doubts.
Those doubts will make one to even go further and study more and listen to more teachings. If one didn’t have any doubts that one had to be clarified, if there’s no doubt arising in the mind that one wishes to be clarified, one will not pursue in furthering one’s knowledge. So those are the doubts which are on the positive side, the positive doubt. Having a doubt of you know, having some sort of conviction that it can be true that it’s true, but yet not knowing exactly how it is and then having doubts and wishing to clarify it. So So a positive doubt which will lead into the actual understanding and realization of whatever one is pursuing could start off with a doubt which is a neutral doubt.
First of all, not even know, when one first hears about emptiness, one may have a feeling like, oh, it could be true, could not be true, you know, not really knowing much about it at all. And then then as one hears more teachings on emptiness, for example, then one may start leaning towards the fact that one one’s doubts may arise to the point where, oh, this seems actually to be true. I don’t understand exactly how it is true, but it really seems to be true. And then later, with that doubt and wishing to understand more by pursuing and and and studying, as mentioned earlier, when one actually gains first by gaining intellectual understanding, then when that intellectual understanding is furthered and one actually gains the wisdom of the direct experience, the direct realization of emptiness, then that is when the doubt is completely ceased as to whether emptiness is true or not because at this point, one has a direct experience to the direct realization of emptiness. So so, therefore, this is how the doubt from a very neutral state leads on to being a positive doubt, then eventually to actually realizing and completely knowing the object, which thereby eliminates all doubt.
So so we do, unfortunately, are running out of time. So because there’s limited time for renting of the hall. So so, therefore, before we end our session this evening, we’ll all together do a dedication dedicating all our merits of the previous two or three nights. Thank you. Yeah.
So first, we’ll be offering a mandala offering as a thanks for very kind to offer the teachings.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- ripening result
- One of the four ways we can experience the results of an action; the ripening result is the actual realm we are born into when we take rebirth. LYWA
- root delusions mulaklesha (Skt); tsa wä nyonmong (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these are the afflicted or nonvirtuous minds that subsequently lead to the secondary delusions. There are six: attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, afflicted doubt and afflicted view. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
- According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is realizing selflessness the same as realizing emptiness, and is it easier to realize emptiness before selflessness?
There is no single answer, because the Buddhist schools interpret selflessness and emptiness differently. The lower schools and the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika distinguish selflessness of a person from selflessness of other phenomena, which is called emptiness. Realizing one does not necessarily bring the other. Selflessness of a person is grosser and easier to realize, while selflessness of other phenomena is more subtle and harder. In the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika school the two are identical, and selflessness and emptiness are synonymous.