Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-11-11 – KR.mp3
UUID: 3dfc5fe8-4df6-47cf-ad85-7816e4a7c2c2
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-11-11
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 29m
Words: 4,042
So we have at present completed the path of the being of the small scope and the majority of the path of the being of the middling scope. Certainly the presentation of the four truths and most of the presentation specifically of the truth of the path. Even though the path of the being of the small scope does not contain detailed explanations about past and future lives, there is a profound and intimate connection between the objects of observation of the path of the being of the small scope and future lives. If I were to ask you what is the mode of connection between the path of the being of the small scope and future lives, what would your answer be? If you could answer, answer quickly.
Quick, you know, quick, quickly. That’s it. Then that is precisely the answer since what is the object of attainment of the path of the being of the small scope? It is a higher rebirth, not the present rebirth since this present rebirth has already been attained but a future higher rebirth and this obviously is connected to future lives. Since the object of attainment of the path of the being of the small scope is a higher rebirth, one must also understand the means for attaining this object of attainment which are none other than an ethics which is an abandonment of non virtuous deeds and an engagement in virtuous deeds.
However, it is not sufficient for this acknowledgement of the existence of future lives to be a verbal acknowledgement. If someone asks us, do you believe in future lives? And you say yes, yes, this is simply not enough. There must be a profound conviction from deep within. Otherwise, the practice becomes a bit weird.
And since we are propounders of a past path based on reason, this belief in past and future lives must be rooted in reason and not mere faith. Now regarding the path of the being of the middling scope, this has a profound connection to past lives. Since the goal of the path of the being of the middling scope is to subdue the mind and the mind is under the sway of the afflictions, which are themselves under the power of ignorance, which is rooted in previous existences. Then Buddhist treatises present numerous powerful lines of reasoning to demonstrate the existence of previous lives. In these lines of reasoning must be investigated.
Otherwise, if one does not analyze them then when NWAS has a very coarse and primitive understanding of previous lives, one might think that oneself goes back for instance to the existences of one’s father and one’s mother. It is a very, very odd idea to think that our origin is merely the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. When one moves backwards into previous lives, this occurs by the means of a subtle consciousness. This is likewise what transmigrates into future lives. Then we can see that if it were asserted that it was our sensory consciousnesses which transmigrated, this would be very, very awkward, since our sensory consciousnesses and for that matter conceptual consciousnesses are interrupted during deep sleep and when we fall in a coma.
It is therefore something else which transmigrates. Now, probably from a scientific standpoint, we can reduce certain aspects of sensory consciousnesses to the activity of the nervous system. So the explanations regarding the subtle mind occur mainly in secret mantra. However, there are explanations regarding the nature of the secret mind in the Paramithayana as well. For instance, the Chitamatra school teaches the existence of a mind basis of all on Alayavijnana.
This is a bit difficult for us to understand but it is a profound and worthy topic. Chitamatra teaches that there are eight collections of consciousness of which the eight is the mind basis of all of the Alayavijnana but that we are unable to use the Alayavijnana even though it is within our continuum. There are actually numerous states of mind within our continuum which we are unable to use. Now this explanation of the Alayavijnana or the mind basis of all in Chitamatra occurs within the context of the Paramitayana. Therefore, this mind basis of all is what establishes continuity with previous and future lives.
Now, the relationship which was mentioned between the path of the being of the middling scope and the previous lives is as follows. Within the context of the presentation of the four noble truths, the noble truth of suffering is presented first. Now this suffering, these experiences of suffering within our continuum arise from afflictions such as anger or desire within our continuum and these are the second noble truth, noble truth of the origin of suffering. However, the origin of these afflictions lies in self grasping and from the standpoint of Chitamatra, self grasping is the operation of the seventh of the eight collections of mind. What is known in Chitamatra as Nyi, the afflicted mind.
Now this afflicted mind has both an object of observation and a mode of apprehension. These are actually slightly different. The object of observation of the seventh mind of Nyonyi is none other than the mind basis of all the Allayavijnana. Now it is not sufficient as far as past and future lives are concerned to pay mere verbal obedience to the concept. Instead, one needs to be profoundly and intimately convinced that if we go back in time to our birth and our birthplace and move mentally further back in time, we will eventually link with a previous life.
In this life, we have a father and a mother, but in the previous life, we also had father and mother. So, we could say over two lives, we have two fathers and two mothers, which from the standpoint of one life obviously is completely impossible. Then if we move further back in time from that previous life to the one before it, we find we have parents in that life before that as well, which makes three fathers and three mothers. So you can see that we are becoming closer to others and as we move all the way back in time, we realize that we have countless fathers and countless mothers. Then all of us in this world become extraordinarily closely connected.
This is very important, isn’t it? So in Buddhist text when it is said that all sentient beings are our mother and our father, obviously they are not literally our mother and our father in this life but there is not a single sentient being who has not been our father or our mother in a previous life. So you can see that the path of the being of the small scope is very closely connected to the existence of future lives. The path of the being of the middling scope is very closely connected to the existence of previous lives. Then it is critically important to ground the existence of past and future lives on reasoning and analysis.
Then she will inquire what the object of observation or the cycles of meditation of the path of the being of the middling scope other are, then there can be no other answer than the four noble truths. You are told repeatedly that the path of the being of the middling scope entails meditation on definite emergence or renunciation but this links to the four noble truths. Do you understand the topic? So the path of the being of the small scope has four topics of meditation. Death and impermanence, the lower realms, karma and causality and refuge.
Then the object of observation or the cycles of meditation of the path of the being of the middling scope are the four noble truths which when they are summarized, are summarized within cyclic existence and Nirvana. The first two truths, the truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering are psychic existence and the two last truths, the truth of cessation and of the path are Nirvana. Therefore, the Four Noble Truths are the topic of the path of the being of the middling scope and they are explained in the order of generation. In other words, first, one meditates on the noble truth of suffering, then on the noble truth of the origin, then on cessation, then on the path. Then I’m going start asking you questions because I teach all the time and there seems to be no benefit.
So, within the four noble truths, why is the noble truth of suffering taught first? Please give a short concise answer. So the reason for which noble truth of suffering and not just suffering is explained first is to understand the faults or the deficiencies of suffering and suffering is present within the mind stream of every one of us. It is not something out there which is isolated. But in the context of the noble truth of suffering, we are not speaking about your painful knees and head and so forth.
This is not what is talked about. Headaches, stomachaches and all this can be cured through medicine. Now when it is said you should know the noble truth of suffering, what is the noble truth of suffering referred to? Please give an instance or an example. Another?
So the origin of suffering is a noble truth of the origin of suffering. What is the reason for which, what is the reason for which the noble truth of the origin of suffering is explained after that of suffering? That’s okay. So, after the noble truth of the origin of suffering, the noble truth of cessation is explained in the third place. Now, after reflecting on the first noble truth, noble truth of suffering, it is said that we generate a mind wishing for liberation.
However, it is also said that at the level of the third noble truth, we also generate a mind wishing for liberation. These two minds wishing for liberation, what is their relationship? What is their difference? And why is a noble truth of cessation in the third but not the second place? This is, this approach of question and answer is a very good approach because on this basis, when you practice, your practice will be pure and in keeping with the teaching of the ancient Indian pandits.
Otherwise, if you practice in any which way heaven knows what you will achieve. Then I’m not saying that you’d have to practice, that’s not my business, it’s your business. It is definite however that if you think and meditate eventually experiences will arise. So the reason for which there is an important difference between the mind striving for liberation which occurs at the level of the first noble truth and the mind striving for liberation which occurs after the second noble truth, noble truth of the origin of suffering can best be understood in terms of the example I gave last time. And I’d like you to reflect on this example.
If someone falls into a profound precipice, then assuming he survives the fall, when that person looks up, he despairs and thinks I must definitely find a way to emerge from this precipice to be freed from this precipice. Then if after staying in this precipice for a couple days, a group of people, let’s say two people come and they look down and they say there was someone down there and if we don’t help him, he will definitely die. Then they seek for the means to help him and cast a rope down. When the man who has fallen in the precipice sees that rope, a second mind striving for liberation arises, which is rooted in reasons, because this person thinks, ah, I will be freed. There are the means for me to be freed.
There are two people up above who will help me with this rope. This is a difference between these two minds. The reason for which the mind striving for liberation which arises after the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering is rooted in reasoning and reasons is because after the second noble truth, we realize that the root of all suffering is within the mind, within the afflictions and that these afflictions find their source ultimately in the ignorance grasping at a self. This ignorance grasping at a self is a mistaken mind precisely because its object is mistaken. It is opposed by a true mind whose object is true, the lack of inherent existence of the self.
The self same way as in worldly affairs, we consider that truth is superior to lies. Likewise, as the strength of this true mind, the wisdom realizing emptiness increases in power, the strength of this false mind, the mind, the ignorance grasping at the self dwindles. Ultimately, this mind will be extinguished and eventually this ignorance will be abandoned. When it is abandoned, we have attained liberation. This is a noble truth of cessation.
It doesn’t matter, this is a takes a long time but we can see that this mind which strives for liberation can exist within our minds. So if we study liberation, if we practice eventually, it is definite that we will attain liberation. Yet at present, liberation is not present within our mind streams. Why is it not present within our mind streams? Because it’s opposite.
The ignorance grasping at a self is present. Therefore, it is important for us to study the enemy, to study this ignorance grasping at a self to understand what it grasps at. Now, when we try to identify the ignorance grasping at an I, it is important to understand what the object of observation of this ignorance is. Its object of observation is none other than the person who is the experiencer of happiness and unhappiness. But while this person exists, the question which arises here is what is the mode of existence, the way of existence of this person?
This is not something which we can leave unexamined. If we leave it unexamined, it seems very difficult to eliminate this ignorance which grasps at an I. This is why Chandakirti in his Madhyamaka Vatara entering into the middle way dedicates such an amount of time to the presentation of the understanding of the self and the I in the various schools of philosophy from the Tirthikas, the non Buddhist philosophers of India to all the schools of tenets up to Prasangika Madhyamika. Now, how do we proceed in this matter? We have agreed that the I exists but the mode of existence of the I is the question.
If we try to investigate the I when the afflictions are very strong, let’s say when anger is very powerful within the mind, I am not sure it will be possible to identify it with ease. The I is very powerful indeed, but we are overwhelmed by anger, then we know through experience that tends to be after we are angry that we look back and say, ah, this is what happened. Now, we all know that after anger has passed through our minds, we feel a sensation of shame and to sort of how badly we behave. But if we try to understand the mode of the existence of the I, a procedure which I can guarantee will lead to results is reflecting on the Four Noble Truths and then entreating the blessings of our spiritual teacher and as a result of this, we will eventually gain experience of the I. So this is how one should endeavor to proceed.
Now, this I if we investigate, we can see that if I were to ask you in this room, where is your I? I think all of you without exception would say it is inside myself. This is not an illegitimate position. This is actually the position of all of the schools of tenants beneath Prasamika Madhyamika. The I can be found within the aggregates.
However, if you examine to try to find where this I is within yourself, you will find that it is absent. It is not there. Let us now meditate in the context of generating the motivation for these teachings on the cycles of meditation or the objects of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope and of those of the being of the middling scope and if in the process, you are able to seek for and identify the I, so much the better. If that is not possible, even these recollections will be of benefit. We will do this for a couple of minutes.
The reason for which these explanations on the nature of the I were given is because the I is what is observed or the object of observation of the ignorance which grasps at an I or at a self and since this ignorance is the main counteracting force to the attainment of liberation and the attainment of liberation is the main goal of the path of the being of the middling scope, and explanation of this I is critically important. All virtue which is accrued during practice of the path of the being of the middling scope will lead to liberation. Then once you understand that in accordance with the Prasangika Madhyamika view, when we ask what the mode of existence of the I is, we find that this I exists independence on the innate conception which thinks I and on nothing else. At that point, this view that the I exists independence on the innate conception which thinks I is directly opposite to the view that the I can be found within the aggregates as the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations. And as this view that the I exists exclusively exclusively independent on conceptuality increases, the wrong view decreases and eventually disappears.
This disappearance of ignorance is liberation and this is what we are striving for, this is what we need. In brief, once one understands that the I arises independence on that innate conception thinking I, this counters or refutes the view that the I exists from the side of the aggregates, that the I can be found within the aggregates. That absence of the I from the side of the aggregates, that is a Prasangika view of emptiness. Now, should that I, that person which is an experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations actually exist within the aggregates, then we should be able to find it. Therefore, we should examine repeatedly and after examination, we will find that it cannot be found.
It is therefore not established within the aggregates. To put it bluntly, it does not exist within the aggregates. That non existence within the aggregates, that is a prasanika madhyamika view of emptiness. So we shall now enter the final section outline of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. As you remember, it’s subdivided into four.
Actually training in the thought, the criterion of having generated it, dispelling wrong views regarding that and ascertaining the nature of the path leading to liberation. The first, second and third outlines have been presented, the third right now and the fourth is subdivided into two, the base of which psychic existence is countered and the sort of path by meditation on which psychic existence is countered. Now, the issue before we enter into this fourth outline is what precisely is a base? In other words, a person who is able to engage in the noble truth of the path and such a base is the living beings, the human beings of this world of ours. It is not important whether one’s physical form is great.
Instead, even if one’s physical form is small like ours, it is one’s mind which is great which counts. There is no superior base for the attainment of liberation than a human body, a human rebirth. It is irrelevant whether a being is beautiful or ugly, large or small. What matters for seeking for liberation is wisdom and humans have great wisdom and great analytical capacities. Moreover, it is taught that within human beings, the supreme basis for the attainment of liberation is that of an ordained person.
Since someone who is ordained will have reduced their attachment to desire and will practice contentment and on this basis, they can gain a much more profound understanding of the two truths. Now the reason for which the base of ordination is supreme for the attainment of liberation is the practice of contentment. If one is ordained and one has no contentment then what is the point? Then even if you are lay people, you can also practice contentment. Then obviously if the goal is to benefit large numbers of other beings, then this is something altogether different.
It is important to understand why our two nuns, Tenzil Hamo and Anila are said to be noble in Tibetan. They are called noble or Tsunma because they are supposed to train in contentment and satisfaction. Then if ordination is not a basis for training in contentment and satisfaction, but leads to the increase of desires, then this is very awkward. Mental transformation does not depend on the clothing one wears. We know this very well.
Just changing clothing does not transform the mind. What transforms the mind is study and ordination is the basis on which through contentment one can engage in intensive study and transform the mind. Okay, Do you understand? Do you understand? Okay.
Then if you have good questions, I will take a couple questions. So in brief, the topic we covered today was the I. Now the I does exist but it is important to understand what its mode of existence is and this we understand through repeated reflection. How is the person who is the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant experiences different from the experience of virtue of the results of virtuous and non virtuous karma? There’s no difference at all.
It’s exactly the same thing. I use the term the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations because it is easier to understand than the experiencer of the fruition of virtuous and non virtuous karma but the meaning is exactly the same. I think a Dre, yep. Is there any relationship between the innate conception that perceives itself within the Prasangika view and the afflicted consciousness in the Chitamantra view? So this is a good question.
I won’t answer this time. We have two more lessons. I’ll answer during them if it’s agreeable to you. Then if I were to answer directly and bluntly, I would say there’s no relationship since the Prasangika mind which imputes a conception exists whereas the Chitamatha afflicted mind which imputes the I on the mind basis of all is a mistaken mind. But that is an answer from someone who studies Buddhist philosophy, it does not address the actual meaning of your question.
So this issue of the innate conception or innate conceptuality is a critically important one in Prasangika Madhyamika. It is clearly explained in Jankar Alpe Dorji’s tenant systems. However, it is not the case that innate conceptions do not exist in lower schools of tenants such as Svatantrika Madhyamica. It is merely the case that even though they exist, they are unable to identify them. Yet, yet, yet.
There are four types of laziness that we should abandon. Is that correct? I think I’ve only got three. I’ve got but I do not understand. The second, engaging in wrong deeds, and the third is ignorance.
Was there four? So I only recollect three. My apologies if there’s a fourth one. It seems there’s only three, yes. With the Citamatrans eight collections of mind, are all of those eight collections mistaken minds?
Or is it just the eighth mind basis of all, which is a mistaken mine? So to start with does not accept the existence of these eight collections of consciousness. They only accept six. Then in addition, I think for Chitamatra, the mind basis of all is not a mistaken mind. Stop here tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- Secret Mantra sang ngag (Tib)
- Another name for Vajrayana, so called because it should not be revealed to those not ready. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.