Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-11-04 – KR.mp3
UUID: 9e2a545a-5b7f-4988-bccd-30e4131a65c6
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-11-04
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 27m
Words: 3,869
So, in brief, the main object of ascertainment of a being who is striving for liberation is samsara and nirvana. Therefore the main topics of focus for a being striving for liberation are psychic existence and nirvana. And psychic existence itself is subdivided into the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering and these in turn are subdivided into the 12 limbs. Likewise, when the 12 limbs are summarized, they turn into the two truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering and when these are summarized, they eventually turn into cyclic existence. In the same way as the thoroughly afflicted when expanded leads to the 12 limbs likewise, the thoroughly purified in other words Nirvana when subdivided leads to the noble truths of cessation and of the path and when further subdivided leads to the 12 limbs in the reverse sequence.
The main topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is the four noble truths. From the standpoint of the object of attainment, it is none other than the noble truth of cessation and the means for that attainment is a noble truth of the path. The reason for which at present we have not gained such an attainment is the presence of the afflictions within our mind stream and this refers to the noble truth of the origin of suffering where the suffering arisen from that is a noble truth of suffering. So first I’d like to ask you some questions. The four truths in general, are they permanent or impermanent?
Then since a couple are impermanent, which ones are impermanent? Which is permanent? Somebody said that the truth of origin was permanent, right? So you’re all in agreement, the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering as well as the path are impermanent. Everyone’s in agreement?
And the truth of cessation is permanent, right? Why? What is the other answer? Oh yeah. Why is cessation permanent?
Generally speaking there’s a consensus, the truth of cessation is a permanent phenomenon. Then why it is a permanent phenomenon then there’s considerable disagreement between the various schools of tenets. Then, Japat Shepal, even though your answer is incorrect, there is a little rationale for it because you probably are thinking that the noble truth of cessation arises from the noble truth of the path. What are the other reasons for which the truth of cessation is permanent? Yes, yes, it is consciousness.
So the question I’m asking you is why is cessation permanent? What Chris said is basically it, cessation is permanent because emptiness is permanent. As far as the view is concerned in the Lamrim, the view which is presented is the prasanika view and in such a view, emptiness is our cessation. Now obviously in the lower systems of tenets, there are cessation which are ultimate truths and there are cessation which are not ultimate truths. So therefore, within the four noble truths apart from the third noble truth, all are impermanent, right?
Then obviously cessation and the origin, excuse me, suffering and the origin of suffering are present within our continuum. So it is obvious that they are impermanent. Then as far as cessation and the path are concerned, they are not present within our continuum. It’s difficult for us to understand them. So now as far as the sequence of presentation of the four noble truths, as you know, one presents initially the noble truth of suffering, then of the origin of suffering, then of cessation and of the path.
This is a sequence in which they are studied, the sequence in which they are practiced and later on when one attains for instance, the path of seeing, one will understand them in this sequence. Now, the sequence of the Four Noble Truths in the treatises which cover the Four Noble Truths, there are various debates which hinge on the fact that this sequence is inappropriate. The rationale for this sequence is that the noble truth of suffering is presented first, the noble truth of the origin of suffering second, cessation third and the path fourth, because it is through understanding the deficiencies of the noble truth of suffering, and therefore of the afflictions that eventually the wish to be freed from this arises. Now we are all accustomed to state verbally, if not from the depths of our hearts that it is through understanding the thoughts of suffering that the mind wishing for liberation arises. But at this point, the major doubt which arises is since the noble truths are presented in sequence, then after presenting the faults of suffering, the second noble truth should be the noble truth of cessation and not the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
Yet the noble truth of cessation is presented in the third place. Why is this the case? And obviously the doubt is the noble truth of cessation is presented in the third place instead of being presented in the second place. Yet, it is through observing the faults of the first noble truth, noble truth of suffering that the wish for liberation arises. Therefore, the noble truth of cessation should be presented in the second place.
Then there are numerous rationales for which answer to this doubt presented in Buddhist treatises. The main ones hinge on the fact that after understanding the first noble truth and therefore after understanding the thoughts of suffering, what is generated is a mere mind wishing for liberation. Then whether this mere mind wishing for liberation is present within our mind stream or not, this is something we ourselves know. All of us are beings who are striving for liberation, for utter liberation, aren’t we? The reason however for which the noble truth of cessation is presented in the third place and not in the second place is because in addition to a mere mind striving for liberation, we need a mind striving for liberation based on a rationale or on reasoning.
So after reflecting on the first noble truth, the noble truth suffering and the faults of suffering, indeed, a mere mind striving for liberation arises within our mind stream. However, the rationale for which the noble truth of cessation, which is put in the third place is not put in the second place immediately after the noble truth of suffering is because we have to ask ourselves a question, is it possible for me to attain such a cessation or not? Is such an object of attainment possible? And we have to generate a mind striving for liberation based on reasons. So there is somewhat of a difference between these two minds.
Then I’ll give you an example, listen carefully and based on this example, I think you’ll understand that there should be a difference. Be careful, listen to me. So let us imagine someone who is in a completely deserted area and this person accidentally falls into a very deep precipice. Now, when this person has fallen in the precipice, they realize they cannot afford to stay more than a minute or so in the precipice and they must try to gain liberation to be freed from the precipice but is it possible to go back up or not? Of course, I do understand.
Precipice, A big hole in the ground. All of us have fallen. So this person who has fallen precipice in at the bottom of a cliff, This person is filled with tremendous fear and there is a tremendous wish to be freed from the state of affairs to go back up. But is it possible or not? Then at this point, a group of people have come to the edge of the precipice and they look down and they see this poor man at the bottom and they think this is terrible, this is awful.
He is going to die for for sure if he remains down there. Then they try to find a means to save him and find a long coil of rope and toss it down the precipice. The man at the bottom of the precipice sees the coil of rope, he sees the group of people at the top and suddenly he realizes, I am saved. There is a rope, in other words, there’s a means to get up from the bottom of the precipice and there’s a group of people on top who will help me. Do you understand?
Then, in keeping with this example, we can understand the four noble truths. We are in the situation of the person at the bottom of the precipice. Then we have an understanding of the noble truth of suffering and definitely we wish to be free from it. But how? What does it means to be freed from it?
Therefore, the first section, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering refers to the first part of the example. The second section refers to the second part of the example, the generation of a mind striving for liberation based on a reason. You understand? The second part of the example corresponds to an uncontrived or spontaneous mind striving for liberation or an uncontrived or spontaneous definite emergence. Now, the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation is an abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions.
However, how is it an abandonment which is an abandonment of the afflictions? This occurs in dependence on causes and conditions. What are the causes and conditions? The noble truth of the path. So what is the means for the attainment of the noble truth of cessation?
The noble truth of the path, in other words, the wisdom which realizes emptiness. What is it at present which prevents us from training in this wisdom? The fact that it is blocked by the afflictions. We are suffused with the afflictions, but this wisdom which understands emptiness can lead to the reduction of the afflictions and the eventual attainment of the noble truth of cessation. Please listen carefully, so I have explained the wisdom which realizes emptiness and its opponent force which are the antidotes.
The afflictions, excuse me. Now, what precisely does this wisdom which realizes emptiness targets? It targets the foundation of the afflictions, which is none other than the ignorance apprehending at a self or the ignorance apprehending at an I. This ignorance apprehending a self is that mind which considers that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations, in other words a person, is established from the side of the aggregates. Now, this wisdom realizing emptiness focuses on the basis of the afflictions which is the ignorance apprehending a self.
Since this ignorance is a consciousness, it has an object. What is its object? Its object is the person being established from the side of the aggregates. So, the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations being established from its own side as the aggregates is the object of refutation. It’s not being established from its own side as the aggregates is the opposite of the object of refutation.
As the two are contradictory. So we must reflect carefully on the fact that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is not established from the stand side of the aggregates. But we have to find reasons for this. It is clear in terms of personal experience that we have a feeling or a sensation that the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations, in other words, a person, the person really exists within the aggregates and yet, when we seek for it, it is unfindable. This mere unfindability, this is emptiness.
Therefore, the fact that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is not established within the basis of imputation which is the aggregates is the wisdom realizing emptiness. The mind on the other hand, which considers that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is established within the basis of imputation which are the aggregates, is the ignorance which grasps at the self. The objects of these two minds are opposite. Therefore, as wisdom increases, the ignorance which apprehends itself decreases. Just as for instance, a lamp and darkness, as the light of a lamp increases, it dispels darkness.
So the best would be to gain a realization of this emptiness by means of a valid cognizer. But this is rather difficult for us at present. However, if through repeated familiarization with the fact that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is not found within the basis of imputation, which is the aggregates, we eventually become familiarized with this. Then, as this familiarization increases, we can see that the ignorance will decrease and eventually one day that ignorance will cease. That extinction of that ignorance, that is a noble truth of cessation.
So it is for this that we should train our minds and study. So, through understanding that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant experiences is unfindable within the basis of imputation which is the aggregates. This innate sense of I which exists within us and which is the root of both desire which makes people seem close to us and hostility which makes people seem far from us will progressively dwindle and eventually disappear. This is what we need. Then, then as this mind which understands that the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensation cannot be found within the basis of imputation, which is the aggregates increases in force.
At the same time, the conception or the predilection for a self progressively decreases. Now, we can see that even if we don’t gain a full extinction of this ignorance, nonetheless a reduction is very pleasant. Geshela said it’s a little liberation. Then this powerful predilection or conception of an I leads us to a totally mistaken relationship with other beings. After all, other beings are exclusively our parents or our teachers.
Okay. So all of us have this sense that the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations, in other words I mean by this, us who experience what is nice and what is unpleasant is findable within the aggregates. And yet under investigation, under analysis, it turns out to be completely unfindable. That unfindability is emptiness and this is what we should focus upon. Then in the context of training and the motivation for a couple of minutes, let us reflect on this.
Okay. So now regarding the outline of the path shared with the being of the middling scope which was distributed during the teachings on the four noble truths. There are four main subdivisions of this outline. First, identifying the mind striving for liberation. Secondly, the means to generate it.
Excuse me, secondly, the criterion of having generated it. Thirdly, dispelling wrong views regarding that. And fourth, ascertaining the nature of the path leading to liberation. Now the first outline actually training in the thought cause because we actually must train in the thought, calls for a study of the two first noble truths. The noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering.
The second outline, the criterion for having generated it is what we are covering at present and this refers to the criteria for having attained liberation and the criteria for having generated definite emergence. Then the words renunciation, the words liberation are easy. They seem to be uttered all the time. But what matters is the criteria for having generated an uncontrived or spontaneous definite emergence of renunciation. As the wisdom which realizes emptiness increases incrementally in strength, likewise, the ignorance which grasps at itself decreases.
Eventually that ignorance is extinguished. At that point, we will have attained liberation. The mind which strives for this state is a mind which is striving for liberation but as we made a distinction previously, it must be a mind striving for liberation with a reason. And then it is independence on this that we can hope to gain liberation. At present, we all have a mere mind striving for liberation.
But what is required is a mind striving for liberation as was explained previously based on reason, on reasons and independence on that one will attain the noble truth of cessation. Now once such a mind striving for liberation based on reasons is established, we will be a being who has entered the path. So this is what is referred to as realizations. It hinges on emptiness. And then through the ascertainment of emptiness, we will deepen our understanding of emptiness after having entered the path.
Now the third outline of the past shared with the beings of the middling scope is dispelling wrong views regarding that. There is only a couple topics within that. The main one is a doubt which arises and which runs as follows. Since the path shared with the being of the small scope is when all is said and done a training path for bodhisattvas, it is inappropriate for bodhisattvas to focus on abandoning cyclic existence. This doubt is answered by saying that initially they trained to understand this and then move beyond it.
So at present, I would like to take questions regarding emptiness and the object of refutation. When you from your own side investigate to find whether the person is established within the aggregates or not, Do you find such a person under investigation or do you not? Yeah, When I’m at home and I get up off my cushion, somebody insults me then I suddenly find the it’s as if I haven’t done any analysis. Yours is a good way of thinking, indeed all of us saying in that situation, this inherently existing I will not disappear at once. But when it arises within your mind, you should ask yourself what is its mode of existence?
Present when we’re talking of I and saying I I, it is a mere verbal I. It is a mere word. However, through these discussions and this analysis, when the I rears its ugly head, maybe you will recognize it. So, I won’t say anything more, ask your questions. So does the I exist within the aggregates?
And if so, what’s the consequence of that? So the key to understand is that the ultimate viewpoint and that is a viewpoint presented in the Lamrim is the Prasangika Madhyamika viewpoint. And according to Prasangika Madhyamika, there is no I within the aggregates. There is because there is many I’s. I just want to know the consequence of his position.
If he is saying that there is no I that exists within the aggregates, what’s the consequence? What’s the wrong sort of what comes out of that from a wrong point of view? What’s the wrong position there? Do you understand? Not really.
If Geshela is saying that there is, no I that exists within the aggregates, what actually is the result if you posit an I that does exist within the aggregates? First thing is that it should not be a mere verbal statement from your side. If deep within yourself you feel that there is an I inside the aggregates, then according to Prasangika Madhyamika, that feeling is ignorance grasping at itself. Then it’s not so much a case of what are the faults of this viewpoint as a question, what is the reason for which such an I should exist within the aggregates? What is the reason?
What’s the reason for which there’s an I inside the aggregates? But there’s an iron inside the aggregates, I guess, because there are many aggregates. Another question? Yeah. Come.
Okay. I’m I’m quite confused. If cessation does not exist apart from the mind that abandons the afflictions and if emptiness is the emptiness of a particular existence of an object, that would seem to imply that a permanent phenomenon and an impermanent phenomenon coexist? If so, how? This is not incompatible even though the mind is impermanent, it is not the case that all of the qualities of the mind are minds or that all of the qualities of the mind are impermanent.
Since the mind is not truly established, then that true establishment asserted regarding a non truly established mind that is non existent. That is emptiness. That is a noble truth of cessation. Another, I needed another question. Somebody else.
Sorry, could I hear the definition of the aggregates, five aggregates again? Definition of what? The five aggregates. Definition. So the form aggregate is our physical body.
The aggregate of sensation are the experiences of sensations of feelings within us. The aggregate of discrimination is the mind which designates this is this, that is that. The aggregate of compositional factors are minds which are neither sensations nor discriminations and the aggregate of consciousness refers to main minds. Per second. If Geshela said about the generation of a mind striving for liberation based on reasons and then we will have entered the path.
Is that entering the path, would that be a result of the wisdom arisen from hearing, wisdom arisen from thinking or wisdom arisen from meditation? That mind striving for liberation based on The name Yes, definitely. This mind which is striving for liberation based on reasons is a mind which understands the existence of liberation. In other words, of an abandonment of the afflictions based on reasons. Mckenzie, Amanda.
Amanda. Okay. My question might be around the fact that I don’t get this whole teaching. But, like, my question is, do all forms of mental suffering arise from ignorance? And I’ll give the example, like, the man in the hole, when he feels sad or fearful, he hasn’t been unethical or being afflicted in the way that we think about anger or jealousy or anything like that to lead to a meant like a mentally afflicted mind.
He’s just fallen in a hole and feels sad and fearful about it. So does that mental suffering still arise from ignorance? So, I’ve mentioned this a couple of times, so I don’t want to go into it in great detail again. But let’s imagine this poor man was fallen in a precipice. Then certainly after a day, a very powerful sense of self grasping will arise within his mind stream and this will fuel all the afflictions.
Then after a week, probably nothing will arise, he will be dead. However, I suspect that you were thinking of something else. Not all suffering arises independence on the ignorance which grasps at an I. Occasionally, suffering arises which does not depend on this. One question.
So in some sutras, I’ve heard that the Buddha said that the Hinayana arhats in mental absorption after attaining liberation are exhorted by the Buddha to become fully enlightened beings. If liberation is a permanent phenomenon, how is that possible? So that is indeed the case Buddhas do manifest to say to these Arhat’s what you have obtained is not the supreme liberation set forth and attain the supreme liberation. This in no way affects the permanence of the liberation they have attained. You say it’s a Hinayana Sutra but it’s not a Hinayana Sutra.
It’s a Mahayana Sutra. How could something like that be in the Hinayana Sutra? Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.