Four Noble Truths — 2015-10-28

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths — 2015-10-28
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-10-28 – KR.mp3

UUID: c456c184-6c1d-4207-bb6e-67f81b549018

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2015-10-28

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 27m

Words: 3,934

So the verse in the three principles of the path, the essence of the meaning of all of the utterances of the conquerors refers to renunciation or to the path of the being of the middling scope. So this verse, the meaning of all of the utterances of the conquerors is extremely profound since in as much as it refers to definite emergence of renunciation, this means that all of the teachings of the Paramitayana and the Tantrayana, all of the teachings without exception find their root in renunciation. Why is this the case? It is the case because the topic of the current middle turning of the, excuse me, the topic of the turning of the wheel of the law of renunciation or the topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is none other than the four noble truths. Then this induces a particular feeling of happiness in the mind when one reflects that the innermost essence of all the teachings of the conquerors is actually none other than the four noble truths and you can count them on the fingers of one hand.

It’s very important. Then the two first truths, noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering when summarized refer to cyclic existence. The two last truths, the noble truth of cessation and of the path when summarized are liberation. The cessation of the two first truths, the cessation of psychic existence is none other than liberation. Then psychic existence and nirvana are none other but respectively the first two truths, the truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering and Nirvana is none other but a cessation which is a cessation of cyclic existence.

In other words, the two last truths of cessation and of the path. Therefore, the totality of the teachings of Sutra and Tantra are summarized by the four noble truths. This means that the Mahayana, in other words the Paramithayana is also summarized by the four noble truths and when we refer to the Paramithayana, we must understand the Four Noble Truths as a foundation to which in addition are added compassion, empathy, altruism, and the perfections such as the perfection of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance, of enthusiasm and of concentration. Now when we understand in this way, practices such as compassion and love as interconnected with the Four Noble Truths, then these practices become extraordinarily profound. So when on the foundation of this practice of the four noble truths, one adds the practices of compassion, of love and of empathy, then probably love, compassion and empathy become practices of the Mahayana.

Then, the Four Noble Truths can be seen as the trunk of the tree of the Mahayana, of which the branches and the leaves are the practices of compassion, love and empathy and the practice of the perfections such as generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm and concentration. Then clearly, the first two truths, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering are present within our mind streams. What is absent within our mind stream is the truth from the standpoint of the thoroughly purified. In other words, the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation and the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path. Then the foundation of all of the grounds and paths is none other than emptiness.

For instance, it is when we pass from the wisdom arisen from hearing to the wisdom arisen from thinking regarding emptiness that we will have entered the path of preparation. Then as we deepen our understanding of emptiness, eventually we reach the path of seeing and then move upwards on the grounds, the first, second, third all the way up to the tenth ground. However, it is probably possible to say that the identification of the noble truth of cessation occurs independent on the four noble truths themselves. So the four noble truths are therefore critical because once we understand the first two truths, the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering, and it is not sufficient to understand them, we must also identify them within our own mind stream. Then the question which arises is, is there such a thing as a cessation of these two truths?

In other words, noble truth of cessation. And the means for this cessation, that which enables one to eliminate the two first truths is none other than the wisdom realizing emptiness noble truth of the path. So when we say that Buddhadharma is profound, it is profound because of the four noble truths. If we were to set the four noble truths aside, then the other practices taught in Buddha dharma, such as a practice of compassion, of empathy, of love, the training in generosity and ethics and forbearance, in enthusiasm. All this is shared with the other religious traditions.

There is no difference. Therefore, the core of the Mahayana is none other than the four noble truths. The core of the Hinayana, in other words, the Shravakayana and the Pratyaka Buddhayana, the path of the hearers and of the solitary realizers is none other than the Four Noble Truths. And through training the Four Noble Truths, as one deepens one’s understanding of the wisdom realizing selflessness, in turn, ignorance dwindles and in this process one eventually reaches the noble truth of cessation. Likewise, the principal topic of the five subjects of learning in the great monasteries, in other words of the perfections, Paramita, of Madhyamika, of Vinaya, of Abhidharma and of Pramana, Buddhist logic is none other than the four noble truths.

Then, obviously it will be absolutely exhausting to study these topics and secret mantra in addition. However, the principal subject here, the principal object to be ascertained is none other than the four noble truth. Then we engage in vast and profound studies in the great monastic seats. But in reality, the principal topic, the principal subject is a four noble truth. Then if we take Paramanavartikam of Dharma Kirti, the famous text on Buddhist logic, Its first chapter is dedicated to impermanence, which is one of the four characteristics of the first noble truth of suffering.

The second chapter is generally dedicated to the four noble truths. And the third chapter is dedicated to an understanding of the 16 characteristics of the four noble truths and of yogic direct valid cognizers. Then in the case of Parkin, the main focus is emptiness and specifically the conjunction of calm abiding and of insight. And the presentation of the grounds and the paths. Then as far as Madhya Amica is concerned, the main topic is emptiness.

This is the noble truth of cessation. Then Vinaya is none other than a presentation of the limbs enabling one to attain liberation, the verbal and physical limbs, in other words, the coarse verbal and physical behavior to be abandoned. The principal topic of Abhidharma is none other than a presentation of the afflictions which are present within our mind stream and which are the principal obstacle to our attainment of the truth of cessation. Then when we summarize the afflictions, we end up with the two truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering. And therefore this verse from the three principles of the path, the meaning of the essence of all of the utterances of the conquerors which refers as was said to definite emergence and by extension to the four noble truths is extraordinarily profound since the four noble truths are the essence of all of the Buddha’s teachings and they are the specific utterance of the Buddha.

So the afflictions which are presented in the context of Abhidharma are the main opponent which must be eliminated to attain cessation. So this body of us is one in which considerable suffering can be experienced due to various causes such as the thickening of the blood in the arteries and so forth. Then these are all physical sufferings. I shall not explain this in detail. We covered this many times.

What matters is an understanding of mental sufferings and the cause of mental sufferings, which are the afflictions. Then this is something one must understand for oneself. There is little benefit in others explaining this to oneself. Then when one addresses people who have no connection at all with the teachings and they ask one how precisely should I counter anger within my mind stream? It is very difficult to provide an answer which is going to help them.

If we say you should eliminate ignorance grasping at yourself, this is completely useless. Then it is perhaps best if we say you should practice forbearance and patience, but forbearance and patience are not Lojong antidotes to anger. They only counter anger briefly. And then if we for instance, say, well, you should meditate. If you meditate single pointedly on something, then manifest anger will disappear.

Yes, but who meditates and who can meditate single pointedly of anyway? They don’t really even begin to enter the teachings because most such people really wonder is it at all possible to eliminate anger? Is it at all possible to eliminate desire? Can envy and jealousy be eliminated? And these doubts arise because they are intimately convinced that anger, jealousy and desire arise independence on exterior phenomena.

And for so long as one has not completely eliminated exterior phenomena and exterior provocation, anger, desire and jealousy cannot be eliminated. Then people who have that outlook consider that the cause of the three poisons is outside of us. They do not begin to enter the teachings. Then they will say things like, well if someone starts punching me, how can I practice forbearance? And what is implicit in such an assessment is the idea that the causes for anger are exclusively exterior to ourselves.

There is nothing within our mind. We bear no moral responsibility for this. I suspect that from your own sides, you understand that even though, let us say anger does depend on an exterior object as a condition, it nonetheless encounters its fundamental cause within our own mind. It is an evil state of mind within ourselves which triggers this. Then there is a quote in Shantideva which I will summarize which says, well after all, we have countless numbers of enemies so even if we manage to eliminate one, what’s the point?

There’s countless others. Then, Shantideva puts this very elegantly in a stanza in which he says, instead of covering the surface of the earth in leather, let us instead cover the soles of our feet in leather, the result will be the same for less effort. Then the best is for us to train our minds to counter anger since this is the way the world at large eventually can counter anger. However, when we address people who have no connection whatsoever with the teachings and wish to explain to them how to eliminate anger, there is very little we can say apart from practice forbearance, try to practice love. So at present, anger is not present within our mind streams.

But we all have experienced the arousal of anger and therefore we should ask ourselves how precisely does anger arise within our mindstreams? When we address people who have no connection with the teachings, it is very difficult to explain anything to them, let alone the origin of anger. For we ourselves, when we investigate when anger comes from, I shall not try to explain to you what precisely self cherishing or the grasping at self is. I think this would be difficult for you to understand but we can all see that anger arises from this conception which thinks I, I. So when we refer here to this conception or this predilection which thinks I, I shall set aside the 12 links, it will make things too complicated, everyone will get confused.

But if we ask what we mean by this, it is that mind which thinks of the person who is the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations and which arises from deep within ourselves. Think therefore carefully that this very tight, this very narrow mind which thinks, I referring to the experiencer of pleasant sensations and unpleasant sensations, this precisely is that which does not exist. The conception, the predilection which thinks I is that which does not exist and this is what must be countered. Therefore, reflect carefully on the fact that the more powerful the conception or the predilection, which thinks I referring to the experiencer of happiness and the experiencer of unpleasant sensation is, the more powerful and the more intense respectively desire and hatred become. This is a case because this mind is a mistaken, a wrong mind.

If we contrast it for instance, with the faith in let us say, Buddha Shakyamuni or our teacher, the faith which observes Buddha Shakyamuni or our teacher, can such a faith induce afflictions? No. It cannot because such a faith is not a mistaken mind, it is an authentic mind. Then if you were to ask somebody, is this I which is the experience of pleasant sensations and of unpleasant sensations, something which exists within you or not, probably most people would think it exists maybe somewhere within the mind or maybe within the brain or something of that nature. And yet, when we examine, we cannot find it.

Once one is convinced that it does not exist, I am not saying that we will have eliminated the afflictions but the afflictions will be greatly reduced. Then, if someone believes completely 100% that this I which is the experience of pleasant sensations and of unpleasant sensations exist, then nothing can be done, right? Then if on the other hand the person does not believe that such an I exists, then this is the beginning of the teachings. This is actually the essence of the teachings. So, it is generally referred to the eyes, generally referred to as the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations and of the maturation thereof.

We will set the term maturation aside and just focus on the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations and let us then meditate at present for a couple of minutes on whether such an entity exists or not. So the outline of the path of shared with the being of the middling scope is subdivided into two. The second part, the actual training of the mind on the path shared as a being of the building scope is subdivided in the following outlines. The first is the measure of having trained the mind. The second is countering the opponent forces.

And the third is ascertaining the path leading to liberation, in other words the means for liberation. So this outline, thinking and training the mind in the path of the being of the middling scope summarizes the totality of the four noble truths. Specifically, the first two truths are summarized in the presentation of the outline on thinking and the measure and the means for attaining cessation refer to the noble truth of cessation. Now within the first outline, identifying the mind seeking for liberation and means therefore this outline is complete. The second outline, the means for generating this is in turn subdivided into two.

The first is reflecting on the faults or the defects of the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. The second is reflecting on the 12 limbs of dependent origination. So the first sub outline which is reflecting on the thoughts of the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering has broadly speaking been covered. We ask the question, where does the noble truth of suffering come from? And we can see that the noble truth of suffering arises from the afflictions which leads us to an understanding of the noble truth of the origin of suffering.

So in this context, when one inquires what precisely the noble truth of suffering is, what it is true that suffering such as a suffering of a headache or a stomachache is indeed a noble truth of suffering. It is not noble truth of suffering as it is referred to in this context. Since the cause of a headache or a stomachache are exterior physical conditions and they can be cured through going to the hospital and taking medicine. Instead, in this context, the noble truth of suffering is that suffering whose causes are the afflictions. So we shall consider that the presentation of the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering is over and at present begin an introduction to the noble truth of cessation and of the path.

What is the noble truth of cessation? So when we understand that this I which seems to appear from deep within ourselves as the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations does not exist. That this I in other words, is not established from its own side at that point, this can be called emptiness and this qualifies as the noble truth of cessation. The more we become accustomed to the idea that this I does not exist within the aggregates or is not established as the aggregates, in other words is non existent, then the more this ignorance which apprehends the I as existing from its own side dwindles. The mind which considers that the I is established from its own side and the wisdom which realizes that the I is not established from its own side are mutually contradictory.

Therefore, as this wisdom which considers that the I is not established from its own side increases, the ignorance which considers that it is established from its own side decreases. These two, if you wish, are akin to light and darkness or to heat and cold when we turn the air conditioner As this mind which grasps at an I dwindles, eventually it is possible to abandon it with its seeds. When it is abandoned with its seeds, we say that we have attained liberation and we say that the afflictions have been abandoned. So, this covers the third noble truth, noble truth of cessation. The fourth one, that of the path will be presented later.

At present, I will take your questions individually. Then there was no point in my saying all this, you have no questions. Geshela taught earlier on about when the foundation of the practice of the four noble truths, when one adds to that practice of compassion, love, and empathy, then probably compassion, love, and empathy become practices of the Mahayana. I understood I thought that Mahayana practice included bodhicitta, and I I don’t see where bodhicitta is in the Noble Truths. So Gesheema referred to bodhicitta when he talked of altruism.

That altruism which is rooted in a powerful resolution and is backed by the four noble truth is none other than bodhicitta. Then if I start giving a commentary on bodhicitta convention and ultimate and so forth, we’re never gonna get anywhere. There’s a lot to be talked about whether bodhicitta is a main mind, a mental factor and so forth. And? You are second.

Okay, my pleasure. Speaking of main minds and mental factors, you would say, that’s funny, you know. Why not beautiful? Because it means Keshe was beautiful. No.

No. No. I meant I meant that the teachings were beautiful. No. I don’t like beautiful, you know.

Where does Lorig fit within the subject of the, within the five subjects that that Geshela outlined? Where does LORIG fit in that? So in the monasteries, Abhidharma is subdivided into two. You have the lower Abhidharma of the Hinayana schools which is Abhidharma Kosha and the higher Abhidharma of the Mahayama schools, Asanga’s Abhidharma Samuchaya. Loric draws from both.

I thought one of the five topics was Pramana. What are the final topics? Five topics. I thought the five topics that he he said today were the Paramitiana, the Abidharma, Pramana, Vinaya, and the Majumika. And then I couldn’t figure out where Parchan fits in.

So could make Geshela maybe go through the five topics again? There’s five. I’ll give them in the Sanskrit. Paramita, yes Paramita, if you wish, then Madhyamika, then Abhidharma, then Vinaya, and Pramana. And Nada.

How to establish the fact that nirvana and enlightenment does not exist on their own side? Could you repeat your questions, please? How to accept how to understand nirvana and enlightenment are also empty. Precisely the lines of reasoning which are applied to emptiness not being established from its own side can be applied to nirvana not being established by its own side or from its own side. So if you examine within yourself to find this experience of the sensations of happiness and unhappiness when you have not found it.

That mere unfindability is emptiness. Yeah. Chris? When we did the meditation, Geshe laude, you asked, can that self be found? And I couldn’t find it within my aggregates and then I thought, well, I am doing the meditation, therefore that’s a concept.

And then I found, I immediately wanted to grasp onto that is my concept. And so it seemed to be there was a part of my mind chasing another part of my mind, in a recursive manner. And I wonder if Michel could help me out. So probably in a nutshell, the way to proceed is after understanding what this experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is, to seek for it within one’s aggregates. In other words, to seek for it individually within each of the five aggregates.

Another? Andre. Andre. If I heard correctly, as the wisdom realizing emptiness grows, the ignorance grasping itself recedes, and also the seeds of that ignorance recede. What are the seeds of the ignorance?

What is meant by the seeds? So when we speak of seeds, broadly speaking we are referring to karmic imprints. Now in the prasangika system it’s a bit different but here seeds are the capacity, the potency to give rise to the ignorance which grasps at itself. Another, Natalie, I was just thinking about what Geshela was saying about non Buddhists being how they can counter anger. And Geshela mentioned patience and forbearance would be very useful.

Would generosity be a good thing to add to that list so that they can improve their karmic imprints so that at some stage they can start to understand the truth of suffering? Because that seems to be something very difficult for Westerners to grasp. It is taught that it is through the practice of ethics that the foundation for obtaining a higher rebirth is obtained and that generosity is an ancillary practice to obtain wealth or prosperity in a future rebirth. Neither has any particular relationship with an understanding of the four noble truths. Yeah, another adjustment.

Then, have you understood the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering? Correct? This foundation must be there otherwise we can’t really talk about the noble truth of cessation. Then I talk about the noble truth of cessation more the next time and more the following time and more the time after that. Have you understood the noble truths of suffering and the origin of suffering?

Okay. So I’m not asking you to realize anything. I’m just asking you can you give examples of the noble truths of suffering and the origin of suffering? Then within our mind stream, it’s already there. Yeah, yeah, stop here to that, thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Shravakayana nyen thö kyi thegpa (Tib)
The Hearer Vehicle. One of the branches of the Hinayana. The path of hearers (shravakas), practitioners who strive for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a spiritual guide or teacher. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top