Four Noble Truths — 2015-10-14

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths — 2015-10-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-10-14 – KR.mp3

UUID: 6dd1cc50-420d-4049-9d4b-1444807bc832

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2015-10-14

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 14m

Words: 3,294

Contentment with the happiness one has is extremely important. Now generally speaking, one can divide happiness or suffering into two categories, physical and mental happiness. And contentment with the physical happiness one has is particularly important. Physical happiness depends on the sense consciousnesses which in turn depend on exterior physical objects. So the feeling of happiness induced by the visual consciousness occurs independent both on the visual consciousness and on the eye sense organ, independence on exterior physical objects forms which have both shape and color.

So for instance, regarding the way of relying on contentment as far as happiness induced by the visual consciousness is concerned, Nowadays, most of us are heavily dependent on forms and images to induce a sense of satisfaction. It is clear that if we are not careful with this, this can be quite dangerous and can induce also a tremendous loss of time. Then this is a danger for all those who are young, let us say from the ages of two and a half all the way up to let us say the age of 30. A tremendous amount of time is wasted watching movies and shows on the internet, on television and so forth. Then one’s own self from one’s own side chooses to watch these programs, these movies uninterruptedly on the web.

Then setting everything else aside, there is great damage to the eyes to start with. Then using the internet for serious purposes like study would be excellent but in reality even though this does happen, it is exceptional. The overwhelming usage of the web is for having fun, for entertainment, for speaking with one’s friends, for wasting time. So this probably does not concern you as a community since you are generally above that age group but if you have friends, children, partners who are always on the internet, always on the web, always with their iPads, then you should explain to them the faults of such an approach and I am definite that they will listen to you then I’m often asked how precisely can we prevent this from happening? Then I suppose apart from stealing the iPad, I’m not quite sure what can be done.

Then parents often rely on the web, on iPads and on computers to keep their children quiet. I have often heard it said that if the children are not glued on the iPad, then they’re up to some trouble. Obviously, the parents first and foremost must understand the dangers and the faults of this addiction to the internet and then on that basis, they can explain it to their children. Then during the formative years between let us say age two or three all the way up to let us say 16 or 17, if the parents emphasize this over and again, even though it may not be 100% effective, I am sure it would be sixty or seventy percent effective. Then past that age, past the age of 16 or 17, then the young adult has his or her own outlook on things, his or her own mind, then parental advice has little or no relevance.

Then obviously, it may be beneficial in the short term to allow a child to use the internet to keep him from Lojong damage. But this cannot be a panacea. Then you probably have direct experience of this having raised your own children and I suspect you also have experienced the obduracy of older children who no longer listen. But even in those cases, you should give good advice if you love your children. If you love your offspring, then you should advise them of the dangers of the internet, the dangers of this excessive reliance on imagery and then they probably will listen a little bit.

It would be a great shame if for the sake of short term satisfaction, the Lojong well-being of your children was durably damaged. Then in the old days, family relations were very happy, very pleasant. You would wake up and everyone would talk to each other, the parents would talk to the children, the children would talk to the parents, they would have breakfast together, talk over breakfast and go to their activities, have lunch together, talk over lunch, have supper together, drink tea together, eventually before going to sleep, they would talk some more and as a result, the family bond was very close. Nowadays, everyone is glued in front of the Internet, everyone is typing away. I have even seen some people who during meals type away on their portable telephone.

Even during meal times, they don’t talk to their relatives. This is a great tragedy. This is a sign of extreme addiction to distraction. If for instance, when you are eating a good meal, you are distracted by what is on your iPad or on your portable phone, I doubt you can experience the taste of the meal. I doubt you can experience simultaneously the pleasure of distraction on the iPad and the taste of a good meal.

Then what’s the point of a good meal? Then I think parents should therefore explain to their children the dangers and the faults of this reliance on the web and on distraction and the qualities of other types of behavior and likewise I feel that teachers in schools should explain to their students the dangers of the internet and of this excessive reliance on distraction and the qualities of other types of behavior as much as is possible in a school setup. Then at present I can only speak from my own standpoint as a Tibetan and the way things are done in Tibetan culture. Normally, the person you list listen to the most is the person who has been the most kind to you and the kindest person to oneself is one’s teachers and after one’s teachers, one’s parents. So when one’s teachers or one’s parents say something to oneself, then one definitely listens and in 6070% of the cases one tries really to live up to what they expect.

Then obviously here in this society I’m not quite sure how things function, I’m still gaining experience and whenever I talk about this, the students say this is too difficult, we can’t live this. Then if that is the case, I am sorry. Different countries have different systems. Then, it will be very strange if we human beings didn’t pay heed, didn’t listen to those who were kindest to us because after all a dog, a cat listens to its master who is kind to it and pets it, comes when they pet them. Then if a human being is not doing what an animal is doing, what are human beings?

Human beings have very powerful, sharp, concentrated minds. It is obvious if we think about this that we will understand that those who are kindest to us are those who teach us something, our teachers and our parents, and that we should repay their kindness and then progressing in this way, we move upwards. Then in Tibet, when we speak of the kindness of a teacher, we are speaking mainly of the kindness of a teacher of dharma and teaching dharma is kind precisely because this is teaching the means to obtain mental happiness, studying the nature of the mind, understanding the mind. Then our parents are most kind because it is thanks to our parents that we have obtained our physical body. You can see therefore how the kindness of the teacher is related to mental happiness and the kindness of the parents is related to physical happiness.

Nowadays, most of the studies we engage in are studies to actualize physical happiness, material happiness, but actually studies which lead us to mental happiness are extraordinarily important and are rare. Then mental happiness can be actualized to eliminating the thoughts in the mind, the mental thoughts which trouble the mind And for this we must understand what these mental thoughts are. These mental thoughts include doubts, they include fantasies, they include anger, and we must analyze what precisely these are. If we take the case of anger, for instance, clearly all of us can identify what anger is. But what are its attributes?

Is anger matter? Is anger mind? Anger is obviously mind. Is anger permanent or impermanent? If anger is permanent, then nothing can be done about it.

It is impossible to eradicate. If it is impermanent, it has a cause. If we eliminate the cause, we eliminate the result anger. Okay. She asked me, he said these mental studies are extremely important.

Do they occur in western schools? I said, apart from an itsy bitsy bit, not at all. Then he said this must be improved. So it is therefore important if we take the case of anger to understand the means to eliminate anger, the means by which anger arises and so forth then all of us certainly understand what anger is at present in this temple. We are listening quietly to a teaching, no one here is angry because if people are angry, as you will know, their face completely changes, it becomes dark red, so no one’s face is dark red in this room and then we have to try to understand what anger is.

If anger were permanent, then we would be angry continuously, obviously we are not. Anger is impermanent. If it’s impermanent, it has a cause. What is its cause? How do we eliminate it?

So anger clearly is impermanent, it is changing, we can see it changes and therefore if we can find the means to eliminate it, we will be able to generate true mental happiness. Now there is an asymmetrical relationship between mental and physical happiness. When mental happiness is generated within our minds, then normally our bodies are at ease too. The opposite is not true. Even if we have perfect physical happiness, it does not necessarily translate into mental happiness.

Then it is important for such an understanding to have studied Luric awareness and knowledge. Lorig is probably not dharma. It is not a specifically Buddhist topic. This is a category of studies which was engaged in by the philosophers of ancient India to understand the differences between for instance valid cognizers and inverted cognizers, between sensory consciousnesses and mental consciousnesses and clearly once one understands the difference between sensory and mental consciousnesses, in turn, one can clearly understand the difference between physical happiness and mental happiness. Then these are extremely important topics.

So if one has the time instead of wasting that time, one should dedicate it to studying LORC and to discussion mutual analysis of LORC. So we are at present covering the path of the being of the middling scope and the main topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is the four noble truths, the noble truth of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation and of the path. Now, in brief, every contaminated phenomenon is none other than the noble truth of suffering. And as is said, one must know the noble truth of suffering, one must abandon the noble truth of the origin of suffering, one must actualize the noble truth of cessation, and one must train in the noble truth of the path. So initially, one must know the noble truth of suffering and therefore one must be able to posit a difference between the suffering consciousness and the noble truth of suffering.

So, initially, one must be able to identify clearly the noble truth of suffering. And one must also identify clearly the threefold subdivision of suffering into the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. Now, if I were to ask you to give an instance of the noble truth of suffering and you were to say, for instance, the pain of a stomachache or a headache or that sort of pain, then although this might be true, it is really not closely related to the topic because the pain of a stomach ache comes from instance from eating poorly cooked or undigested food and this is cured through ingesting medicine. Then it is said that one must know the noble truth of suffering. Here, obviously what is meant by this is that one must know the fourth, the deficiencies of the noble truth of suffering.

And I am sure you understand that this does not mean to understand the fourth or the deficiencies of a stomachache. Instead, the example which I gave you last time as an instance of the noble truth of suffering was the mental sensation of suffering which arose as a result of a powerful emotion of anger, a powerful sensation of desire, or a powerful sensation of envy. In every single case, this is an instance of the noble truth of suffering. The suffering of a stomachache is not in particular related to the afflictions. It may be broadly related to a craving for good food which causes us to eat too much, but fundamentally it’s linked to exterior physical causes.

Do you understand? Very easy. I think way easier for you. So when our teacher Buddha Shakyamuni said, you should know the noble truth of suffering, he was not referring to the suffering of a stomachache, of a headache and so forth whose faults are self evident to us and whose treatments involve involves the ingestion of medicine. Instead, he was referring to the suffering which arises, for instance, from anger.

In other words, the suffering from the afflictions whose cause is to be understood, it is none other than the ignorance grasping at a self and which therefore can be eradicated. So please listen carefully to me. When we are referring to the subject, the noble truth of suffering, we are referring to that mental disturbance, that mental suffering which arises as a result of powerful negative emotions such as anger, in other words, which arises independence on the affliction. This is a subject, so whether you are taking notes, whether you are thinking about it or whether you are meditating about it, this is what you should identify as a noble truth of suffering. Do you understand?

Okay. Then, it is these coarse afflictions which give rise to suffering, isn’t it? If it was a pleasant experience, then why would we bother? As is said, it is out of wrath that the mind is disturbed and therefore when or if I were to ask you to identify, to give an instance of the noble truth of suffering, an appropriate example would be that state of mind which is disturbed by afflictions which have fallen under the sway of anger. And therefore, when we analyze the noble truth of suffering, an instance of which would be for instance, a state of mind which is troubled as a result of anger.

We can clearly see that this is an impermanent phenomenon, therefore an effect which has a cause. When we try to find its cause, we find that the cause is none other than the anger which induces it. This cause is what we would posit as an instance of the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. So if I were to ask you to give me an example or an instance of the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering, you could say anger, you could say envy or jealousy. And at present, let us generate the motivation to receive these teachings through first reflecting on the noble truth of suffering and then reflecting on the possible causes of the noble truth of suffering which are none other than the noble truth of the origin of suffering, including anger, desire, envy, jealousy and so forth.

And then let us ask ourselves, is it possible to generate a mind wishing to abandon these causes, the noble truth of the origin of suffering or not? Let us reflect on this for a couple seconds. I would like to clarify one small point. I mentioned that in Tibet, our teachers came first and our parents came second. This in no way applies to me.

I do not have such a motivation in saying this to you. A teacher is someone with qualities. I do not count as someone with qualities. Therefore do not view me in this way. I am quite sure you yourselves understand this clearly.

Now regarding the Noble Truth of Suffering, the Noble Truth of Suffering has four characteristics. It has the characteristics of impermanence, suffering, selflessness and emptiness. The first characteristic is particularly important. The characteristic of impermanence means that the noble truth of suffering changes and change can be subdivided into two, coarse and subtle change. By coarse change, we refer to the interruption of the continuum of a phenomenon, the destruction of a house, the destruction of an object, or one’s own destruction at the end of one’s life.

It is said to be coarse impermanence because this destruction occurs independent on other causes and conditions. So when we speak of coarse impermanence, we are for instance referring to death and impermanence. In other words, we are referring to our selves having to relinquish our bodies, to our having to relinquish our aggregates. This is something which has already been decided. It has already been decided that we will die.

This is a case of coarse impermanence since one typically dies as a result of a disease of something else. So as for subtle impermanence, let us take for example one hour. One hour is subdivided into sixty minutes. Sixty minutes are each subdivided into sixty seconds and the second is subdivided into a a gigantic number of smaller instance of time. Now phenomena undergo coarse impermanence, in other words, the severance of their continuum and disintegration as a direct result of the fact that they are disintegrating instant by instant.

So I would like to answer a question which was asked last time regarding the difference between subtle impermanence on the one hand and its understanding and emptiness on the other hand and its understanding. There are important differences first regarding the object of negation. The object of negation of subtle impermanence is none other than permanence. Permanent phenomena do exist, whereas the object of negation of emptiness is a non existent phenomenon. In addition, there’s a difference as far as the nature of these two entities are concerned.

The nature of subtle impermanence is none other than the mode of instantaneous disintegration. This is something which we can understand fairly easily. The nature of emptiness is something which is much much more difficult to explain. Therefore, is a difference as far as nature is concerned regarding the ease or difficulty of understanding. Now, I have a question for you.

Please give me an instance of the noble truth of suffering. You can speak quickly, you don’t have to raise your hand. Another. So you have answered in keeping with your own understanding and the understanding of the purpose of teaching the noble truth of suffering. The noble truth of the origin of suffering?

So that’s it precisely. Well, first one reflects on the noble truth of suffering and then the origin, the source, the cause and this is the noble truth of the origin of suffering. So, you have understood that suffering arises independence on what, on its cause, which is a noble truth of the origin of suffering. Then you can give us instances all of the afflictions which fall under the sway of anger, of jealousy and so forth. And you do what you want.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top