Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-10-04 – KR.mp3
UUID: 987ef983-1324-4211-9d32-bacfe3cb22ce
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-10-04
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 40m
Words: 3,712
Then, if you need to go, you know, where, during the teachings, it’s perfectly okay. Because it’s a little bit low time for two hours. So So if you need to go, it’s better to go. Otherwise, if you restrain yourself, diseases can arise. So the three verses in Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path.
The innermost essence of the teachings of the conqueror. The path, the instruction praised by the sons of the victors and that practiced by the fortunate ones refer respectively for the first verse to definite emergence which is the essence of the teachings of the Buddhas. The second verse refers to bodhicitta and the third verse refers to training in emptiness. So the practice of definite emergence is the signature if you wish of the path of the middling scope. This is obviously grounded on the practice of the being or shared with the being of the small scope.
We shall not enter in the practice of the being of the small scope today, it would take a lot of time. Generally speaking, we can say that there are two ways of generating definite emergence. The first is very much in accordance with the graduated stages of the path through training incrementally in all of the practices leading to the generation of definite emergence. But there definitely is a second way of giving rise to definite emergence which occurs within the minds of those of very sharp faculties who observe this world of ours and see that let alone animals, all human beings exclusively wish to attain happiness and to eliminate suffering. Yet, nobody ever is able to attain independent stable happiness.
On this basis, such beings of sharp faculties generate definite emergence. And therefore, those of SHARP faculties are dissatisfied with what this world can offer seeing that it never leads to permanent and stable happiness. Now I have talked repeatedly here about mental and physical suffering. We shall not enter into this again. We mentioned that however satisfied one might be with one’s physical condition with the exterior circumstances which surround one mental suffering still arises.
As a result, Aarya Deva in his quoted in says, in this world, the high experience mental suffering and the low experience physical suffering. This world experience unceasing suffering. This is a very profound verse. Those of high social status have no material suffering but they experience mental suffering. Those of low social status in poor countries do not experience so much mental suffering as cause physical suffering.
So this is a very profound stanza. It is quoted in Lamrim Chenmo from Ariadeva. If you think about this by yourselves, your outlook on life will change. And therefore, such a practitioner would be unsatisfied with the mere experiences of this world. Now this does not mean that one should discard physicality.
We are physical beings, we rely on a body therefore we do need exterior objects. However, as His Holiness has pointed out, it is when instead of just doing what is necessary to provide for this life that one dedicates one one’s whole life, one wastes one holds one’s whole life in the pursuit of material affairs that problems arise and this is why one has to practice differently and look at things differently. Such a being of sharp acumen realizing that none of the exterior objects can provide durable satisfaction will turn his or her mind inwards and seek for interior satisfaction. Focusing evermore for instance on one object of observation which eventually will enable him or her to attain calm abiding and interior happiness. Definitely such beings exist.
It’s a bliss arisen from calm abiding. And such beings then believe that calm abiding is liberation. Then they eventually progressed to the higher levels of concentration believing these are stages of liberation. Eventually it is possible for such practitioners to realize that this is not liberation. So I would encourage you not to base your practice on faith and conviction but to base it on your own analysis.
See for yourselves, This is my own opinion. Do you understand? Then you see once you meditate intensively and attain calm abiding, the afflictions are interrupted for the duration. This is an extraordinarily comfortable pleasant state. Then these beings believe this is liberation.
We say it is not, but they sincerely believe it is liberation. So it is definite that such a practitioner of sharp acumen will understand the deficiencies, the thoughts of the afflictions and will wish to be freed both from physical and from mental suffering. Then entering in a state of single pointed concentration, the afflictions will not manifest. This however is not sufficient and it is at this point that one focuses on dependent arising and this leads us to the noble truth of the origin of suffering. So dharma is not rooted in faith.
It should be rooted in one’s own analysis and reflection. Faith does indeed provide a preliminary basis but that is all. Then for activities such as reciting one’s commitments daily to turn into dharma is very difficult unless one meditates them and it is difficult to meditate one’s commitments. Then from your own side, you should study and reflect on topics such as these and this should not just be a matter of casually looking at texts and then setting them aside. It is a matter of integrating the topics.
Nowadays, we have extraordinary technical possibilities with the internet and so forth. Almost all of the teachings of His Holiness the Dalai Lama are available in English on the internet for free. I heartily encourage you to listen to these teachings to reflect on them. In my own case, I put some twenty to thirty years of study in my life. I’m not saying that I have studied a lot but I can vouch that although it doesn’t come at once, if you focus repeatedly on these topics over time, it will come.
Then His Holiness has mentioned that many high Tibetan masters have gained such realizations even some westerners and I would therefore like to encourage you instead of wasting your time to listen to these teachings of the holiness when you go around your daily activities. For instance, when you’re driving, you can listen carefully to teachings on the view and by the view here, we refer to the four noble truths, the two truths, interdependence, emptiness and so forth. In my own case, from time to time, I watch television to improve my understanding of English. It’s not something I particularly enjoy doing because it’s difficult to understand but it is of benefit. So it is not good to award television or the internet for the sake of distraction.
This is not helpful. Instead, we should try to turn this life into a meaningful human life and therefore when we use these tools such as a television, the internet, we should use them for meaningful purposes. Then occasionally, if you are really tired to relax, you may do something else that’s up to you. Definitely such beings we talked about previously of extremely sharp acumen do exist and without receiving any teachings, just understanding the unsatisfactory nature of the world. They will train in concentration and eventually I am convinced they will be led to an understanding of subtle interdependence therefore to an understanding of emptiness.
Then setting this category of uncommon being aside, there are people like us who have received from the very beginning teachings on the graduated stages of the path. Teachings which describe what cyclic existence is, what its faults are, how one should try to turn away from these faults, the means for attaining liberation, what liberation is and so forth. Then we have covered the presentation of the Noble Truth of Suffering and specifically of the suffering generated by afflictions such as anger. So all of us even though anger is not present in our minds at present know from past experience the sort of suffering anger generates within us. Let alone the suffering it generates within us, the type of behavior, shameful behavior, it leads us to manifest on the outside.
Perhaps the less said about that, the better. Then as you all know when someone becomes very angry, their face changes and then you as an outsider might look at him and say, my goodness. This man’s or this girl’s face has changed. When great anger arises in the mind of someone, it’s as if their mind settled in an animal nature, isn’t it? Then these afflictions such as anger caused desire, envy, jealousy and so forth.
When they arise induce great suffering within ourselves and when one thinks why would it be inappropriate for me to stop experiencing this suffering, why should I not stop experiencing it? At that point when that thought arises spontaneously in my opinion, definite emergence has arised. This is a bit akin to the spontaneous wish for breakfast when we get up in the morning. So yesterday, we explained the sequence of the four noble truths and as you remember, the noble truth of the origin of suffering which is a cause is presented in second place and the noble truth of suffering which is its effect, its result is presented in the first place and the rationale for this was explained. But there is another doubt which arises because the noble truth of cessation itself is presented in the third place.
Now one might wonder, if the noble truth of cessation is something which arises as a result of that wish for liberation which understands the faults of suffering, why should it not be placed in the second place after the noble truth of suffering since one would just have understood the faults of the deficiencies of suffering. Why instead is it placed in the second place? So the topic of the four noble truths as well as definite emergence are topics specific to the path of the being of the middling scope. So for so long as one is studying the topic of definite emergence and the four noble truths for so long is one training at the level of hearing within hearing, thinking and meditating. So quickly, within the Four Noble Truths, what is the first?
And second? And the third one? And the fourth one? Thank you. Very good.
Very clearly. So your clear answers are a clear sign that you are accustomed to study which is excellent. Study is fundamental at the beginning. It is the practice of hearing. Without hearing or listening, there are no possible realizations later on.
Then once at the level of the first noble truth, one understands the deficiencies of the noble truth of suffering, the uncontrived wish for liberation arises. Why therefore is the noble truth of cessation not presented in the second place? If you have an immediate answer, please give it otherwise we will continue. And clearly, clearly in short, no more. Yeah?
Yeah, Diane. And mother? Judy. Don’t you have your own? In short.
And? So very good. No problem. Your answers are rooted in study. They are sign of study.
However, the reason for which the noble truth of cessation is not presented in the second place but in the third place is rooted in the understanding of dependent origination. So once we notice these sufferings within our mind stream and we try to find from what or by what these sufferings are induced, it is obvious, it is evident that they are induced by afflictions such as anger, desire, envy, jealousy and so forth. Then at that point, the question of the origin of these afflictions arises. Their origin evidently can only be self cherishing, in other words egoism or the apprehension of a self. So we shouldn’t ask ourselves where the afflictions in the mind of some other party arises.
That would be a very strange way of looking at things. Instead, we should ask ourselves where do the afflictions in my own mind stream arise? We should check our own selves. Now from your own side, can you see that the root of the afflictions is self cherishing or egoism and grasping at the self? Is it a 100% clear for all of you?
Lily, not clear for you, So do you really see that it is independence on self grasping that these afflictions arrive or not? All people, all people, for all people. All of you are the same. If you don’t like, if you don’t like them. It should be evident that mental suffering arises from the afflictions.
Is that simple, clear? Yeah, is that clear? So it should be fairly self evident that when the mind is profoundly troubled by anger, this is suffering. Then this anger itself obviously arises independence on another person as a condition, but that other person is not the ultimate source of the anger. Can you see that the ultimate source of that anger is your own egoism or self cherishing or not?
Then that’s okay. Otherwise, we’re wasting our time here, right? Me too. So once one has this type of personal experience, then one can quote from scriptural authorities the works of the great Indian pandits and so forth. Otherwise, it would be quite odd to keep quoting from the great pandits without any personal private experience.
And in this context, there are two quotes which are highly relevant. The first is from Ariad Devas 400, the Chatuchataka in which he says, it is from the self that attachment to family and friends as well as from the self that hatred for foes and enemies arise. And Dharma Kirti in his Pramana Vartika says, all the afflictions arise from the view of the disintegrating composite mediated by desire. If one has this experience that all of the afflictions arise from self cherishing or egoism and in addition, one connected with the great quotes from scriptural passages of Ariadeva and Dharmakirti then one’s realizations become very stable. And therefore as Chandakirti says in Madhya Makavatara, all of the afflictions without exception arise from the view of the transitory composite views are erected on that basis.
So if one trains in this way, first gaining personal experience and then linking this personal experience to such scriptural passages by the great pandits of ancient India, then one’s experience becomes very stable. These works of the great pundits of ancient India, they were not composed on a whim. These were composed after very careful analysis and reflection. So it is clear that anger arises in dependence partly on the condition of another person But it would be very odd if it arose totally independence on another person. Is it clear to you at present that war, the other party is a condition for the horizon of anger, the main cause is within yourselves.
This is a result of study. Then you should combine your study with practice and experience back and forth. In this way, you will gain understanding. Exactly. You know?
And therefore, we should target the ignorance which grasps at a self for so long as we have not eliminated the ignorance which grasps at a self for so long will we wander within cyclic existence. This is what is explained in the process of the 12 limbs whether one chooses to enter into these details or not. This is the rationale for the explanation of the 12 limbs. The first of the 12 limbs is beginningless ignorance. For so long as beginningless ignorance is not eliminated, for so long will we wander in cycle of 12 limbs after cycle of 12 limbs.
All of us are beings who are striving for liberation. Therefore, our target is the ignorance grasping at a self and this is where things become delicate because the ignorance grasping at a self is a consciousness and its object, the I must be identified. And this is why Je Tsongkhapa says in the three principles of the path, if one is bereft of the view of the ultimate irrespective of how long one trains in definite emergence in bodhicitta, it will be impossible to sever the root of existence. Therefore, focus on dependent origination. This means that bodhicitta and definite emergence alone will not be able to lead us beyond cyclic existence and this why the great bodhisattvas even though they train extensively in definite emergence and bodhicitta train also in the view.
And it is precisely this nature of the I or the Atman which is the main topic on which on the one hand the non Buddhist schools of tenets, the ancient philosophers of India focused and it is also on the nature of the I that there are numerous different modes of explanation within the Buddhist schools of tenets. This is extremely important. Then because it is important, it is also difficult. This is why there is no disagreement between Buddhist and non Buddhist religious traditions regarding the practice of love, of compassion, of bodhicitta, of kindness, of generosity, of ethics and so forth. But there are major disagreements regarding the view, in other words, the nature of the I.
There’s no disagreement basically regarding the method aspect of the path between the great religions but there is major disagreement regarding the view. Then inside the Buddhist monastic manuals, there are some debates about whether Bodhicitta is in main mind or a mental factor but those are interior debates. Then the non Buddhists believe in an all doer, a god in other words. The Buddhists attribute the functions of god to ignorance. Having presented the first two noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering.
At present, we have to trace the origin of suffering to its own origin which is none other than the ignorance of self grasping. Now what might be the antidote to such an ignorance? We say it is emptiness but it is something which is difficult to understand. It is a mere verbal assertion and therefore since all of us recognize that the I exist, we say I I, that means there is something there. The disagreement hinges on the mode of existence of this I.
Since there is really no benefit in my making the dramatic statements to you which will not be integrated, instead, let us take a couple minutes and meditate and ask ourselves what exactly is the mode of existence of this eye? This is why when the guru gives an introduction to the view, the first question he asks the disciple is where is your I? Then if the disciple is new and has never thought about this is a very awkward question. Where exactly is my I? I say I I I but where is it?
So this is something which I would like us to analyze. So we have explained what liberation is and therefore what the mind striving for liberation is. This I have at present and with this as a motivation, I would like us to engage in these meditations. Mhmm. Yep.
Just a couple of minutes. So now we will recite prayers. Page one, refuge in bodhichitta for teachings, invocation, Vora Measurables, prayer of the seven limbs, and then page nine, the mandala offering verse sorry. Page five. Verse one and three of number six.
What happened about I? Strange. So this topic of the I is the main topic which divides Buddhists and non Buddhists. Non Buddhists, the ancient Indian philosophers have their own presentation of the I then within Buddhism, we have a multiplicity of presentations. The Vaibhashikas give one instance of the I, the Sattrathikas, the Chitamatas, the Sauthentikas, the Prasanthikas have different versions of this.
So here when we speak of trying to gain some type of experience, it is something which is difficult for us to do since at present, we are engaged in study in the context of the wisdom arisen from hearing. Then such a wisdom relies mainly on the sensory consciousnesses which are unstable. We would still have to develop the wisdom arisen from thinking at which point we could hope to give rise to a valid cognizer and then the wisdom arisen from meditation where we would gain some type of experience. So there is no debate about the existence of the I. It is of the evidence since all living beings, animals included, have a sense of I.
If you take for instance this rosary I am Geshela is holding, then there is clearly an owner of the rosary, Geshela himself, and a rosary which is owned. Likewise, if you speak of your parents, then there is quote unquote an owner of the parents and parents who are owned. The same thing is true for all objects. If you were to say to Geshela, your rosary is not your rosary, it’s mine. Who in this temple would say such a thing?
So we’ve all decided that the I exists. So I am in a way saying I have any type of experience of selflessness or emptiness but it is important to gain an understanding of the mode of existence of the I, of this I which experiences pleasant and unpleasant events. Otherwise, if we were to end up by saying there is no I whatsoever then this would be very awkward position. Do you understand? Okay.
Then it’s very odd when you start actually investigating who this I is, who does the walking, the eating and all the activities. This is quite important. So we all agree that the I exists but what is its mode of existence? How do you feel about that? You could say that the mode of existence is the reason of existence of the I.
So you can see that we say I go, I come, I do this, I do that but really we don’t have a clue what the I doing all of this is, do we? Then we were progressively given introduction to emptiness. So we shall perhaps stop here and you should study and reflect on these topics and combine the study and reflection with your experience. Yep. Stop here today.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.