Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-11-19 – KR.mp3
UUID: c5ba6c4f-ea03-4cc5-801f-da04c86cffe9
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2014-11-19
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 35m
Words: 3,374
In as much as all of us are Lamrim practitioners, our mode or our way of thinking should be to place emphasis emphasis foremost on future lives and less on this life. And within the context of emphasis on future lives, to use the future lives as a gateway to liberation. In this way, one will accomplish one’s goal. Within the context of placing emphasis on future lives, this means in no way that we should relinquish our responsibilities to our families, to our relatives, our obligation to work and so forth. These are physical and verbal deeds.
It is our way of thinking which we should change. But don’t be afraid. Dharma does not entail giving up everything. Dharma is a matter of interior transformation. One continues with whatever physical and verbal deeds one engages in, but one must transform one’s mind from deep within.
For instance, if one wishes to travel to India, one would have to undertake a series of preliminary steps, preparatives before going to India. One’s goal is always to go to India, but one does what have whatever one has to do to prepare for this. Likewise, in terms of our practice, our ultimate goal is liberation. For this, we must attain a higher rebirth. And to attain a higher rebirth, we do whatever is required in this life.
As Jitsongkapa says in his Canticle of Realization, to attain the supreme path until a fully characterized basis is obtained, neither grounds nor paths can be hoped for. The supreme path refers to liberation. A fully characterized basis refers to a human rebirth endowed with the eight leisures and the 10 endowments. To attain a higher rebirth, the main cause is ethics. Ethics is the main motor for a higher rebirth.
However, it must be an unmistaken ethics both of engagement and of relinquishment. If one engages in an unmistaken ethics of engagement and relinquishment, it is then possible to hope for a higher rebirth. And therefore, within the context of generating the motivation for receiving these teachings, we should reflect on the enumeration of the 10 non virtues and resolve to counter them. This is how we should proceed in general. In particular, it is very helpful to check one’s own mind and see which of the 10 non virtues is the one which is dominant with our behavior and which other ones we seem to have no particular problem with and to focus on eliminating the dominant one.
And therefore, in relation with the motivation, let us reflect on the list of the 10 non virtuous deeds and which of the 10 non virtuous deeds is the foremost one we succumb to, what its faults are and how we can possibly counter it. Let’s generate. It is said that the foundation of the Buddhist teachings are the four noble truths. If this is the case, what relationship is there between the path of the being of the small scope and the four noble truths? The first two noble truths are the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
And the noble truth of suffering is or has four characteristics. The foremost of these characteristics is the characteristic of the feature of impermanence, which is subdivided into two, coarse and subtle impermanence. Coarse impermanence here refers to death and impermanence and it is indeed death and impermanence, which is said to be the beginning of the path of the being of the small scope. Therefore, it is within the context of this feature of the first noble truth, noble truth of suffering, that one can understand the practice of the being of the small scope. However, as far as the Noble Truth of Suffering’s feature of subtle impermanence, subtle impermanence is probably to be understood in terms of the path of the being of the middling scope since it connects to karma and causality, which in turn find their root in ignorance.
This is a very helpful way to think about things. So within the context of the explanation of the tenfold path of white and black karma, in other words, the 10 virtuous and non virtuous deeds, you formulated a doubt last time which is a very good one. Let us consider, for instance, the virtuous deed or strictly speaking, the ethics of the abstention from killing. The instance which was given for the ethics of the abstention from killing is to turn away from the intent to kill another, to relinquish killing. And the question you addressed was, if this is the example which is given, is it always necessary to have initially generated the motivation to kill another being before turning away from this?
It is not always necessary to generate the motivation of killing before relinquishing it. In keeping with a passage in the Bodhisattva Charavatara, when one has engaged in an ethics of abandonment of killing, this ethics of abandonment of killing remains with oneself whatever deeds one performs on the outside, whether one goes walking, sleeping, or whatever. So let us take an example to illustrate this. Let us consider the case of someone who is basically an alcoholic, who drinks large amounts of brandy or beer. And eventually, one day after a physical examination is told by his treating physician that as a result of his alcohol consumption, he has a severe interior disease and he must relinquish, he must abandon forsake the consumption of alcohol.
Understanding the nature of his predicament, this person will give up alcohol. This does not mean that the desire to drink does not arise within his mind, but he understands fully the consequences of drinking and does not engage in it, the motivation to drink does not arise. Likewise, in the case of killing, once one has given rise to the motivation of abandoning, killing, then this motivation accompanies us in whatever we do. Therefore, what is it which keeps us at a distance from the 10 non virtuous deeds? It is ethics.
Ethics lies between us and the 10 non virtuous deeds. In this matter, I’d like to give an example which I think is a rather good one from my homeland. We have, as you know, in Tibet large dogs and we often say there are two types of dogs, those who stay at home and those who are always on the run. However, whether a dog belongs to the first or the second category, if you tie him down to a stake, he will stay tied down to that stake. And the stake here is a stake of ethics.
So once the mind is tied down to the stake of ethics, virtue arises. And therefore, to take the example of theft at present, if we should see something which we crave and the motivation to steal it arises within our mind. However, reflecting on the consequences this will have for our future lives, we turn away from the act of stealing. This is undeniably a virtuous deed, it’s a virtuous deed of the abandonment of stealing, but it is only an example. It is not the case that every virtuous deed of the abandonment of stealing necessarily entails initially the generation of the motivation to steal before turning away from that motivation.
Therefore, I would like to believe all of you at present know the list of the 10 non virtuous deeds in the correct sequence. If not, I will have to interrogate you again until you have learned it. Now what is important for us in this context is to examine our own situation to see which of the non virtuous deeds is the most prevalent or the most threatening to ourselves. In my own case, I can say that within the four non virtuous deeds of speech, it is definitely idle talk. And within these three mental ones, it is covetousness.
I don’t know what is the biggest problem you face. As said, I stand guard in front of the fortress of my mind, and whenever whenever an affliction arises, I counter it. Then in my case, as I said, idle talk is the main obstacle I experienced at the level of speech and this is something we incur very easily, if we’re talking about politics or worldly affairs. Likewise, covetousness arises very easily when we go into a shopping mall or a store and we see shoes, clothing or some other item we like. At that moment, when that desire for the object is amplified and leads to a decision to possess the object, covetousness has arisen.
Then in the case of harsh words, I have to be very wary because I am practicing my English upon volunteers. It is possible I will give offense without intending to do so. Then obviously, in the monasteries, we do not leave the monastery a lot and when we do, we do generally by pairs. We do not socialize a lot. So the opportunities for idle talk are very limited.
Here the situation is quite different. Therefore, the best approach in training one’s mind to abandon the 10 non virtues is to identify the non virtue we engage in the easiest, which is the most dangerous for us. And then to try to restrain from that deed. If unfortunately we do, we should generate a strong sense of remorse in the evening and then engage in the twin activities of confession and restraint. Then the majority of the 10 non virtuous deeds are natural misdeeds.
As natural misdeeds as opposed to prescribed misdeeds, these are misdeeds for all irrespective of whether they are lay persons or ordained irrespective of whatever vows they may have taken. Then for those of sharp faculties and good understanding, the first nine of the 10 non virtuous deeds are natural misdeeds. These are misdeeds for whomsoever engages in them. Regarding the tenth non virtuous deed, one views the issue is much more delicate. It depends on whether, for instance, one is a Buddhist or not, whereas engaging in the first nine of these non virtuous deeds is non virtuous whatever one’s religion or absence thereof.
Then regarding one’s views, I think it is critical to ascertain the reality or lack of reality of the base of wrong views. For instance, a Buddhist standpoint, wrong views refers to rejecting the existence of the Four Noble Truths of karma and causality and of the triple gem. The question has to be whether the formal truths karma and causality and the triple gem are real or true or not. Clearly, if they are real or true, then rejecting them would become a natural misdeed. On the other hand, let us take for instance the case of God, the creator.
In my own case, don’t accept the existence of God, but if it were demonstrated that God existed, then my rejection of God would become a wrong view. Then if it was a case that God, the demurrage, the creator existed, and I refuse to acknowledge the existence of God, then this would be a clear case of wrong views. On the other hand, if god did not exist in reality, then my rejection of the existence of god would no longer become a wrong view. Do you understand? Then I hope you all know the term on such as deeds in sequence.
And whether you do or not, please feel free to ask questions at present. Ask as many questions as you know, as you wish. Do not be shy and stay in your corner. That is I quote Geshela literally rather stupid behavior. If on the other hand you ask the questions, your understanding will blossom, it will increase.
Then the first questions I would like to take are the questions regarding the identification of the 10 non virtuous deeds and their sequence. If there are no questions about that, we will take the other questions. The order of sexual misconduct coming after stealing, given that sexual misconduct is against the actual person, why would that come third instead of second when the stealing is about a possession rather than a violation against a a person? Oh, this theft harms people. It doesn’t harm the thing at all.
Thing is just matter, isn’t it? So if we take the case of your car, Geshe assumes you have a nice white car and someone were to steal it from you, imagine the suffering you would experience. Then I gave Geshela, I think you are thinking of rape. He says, child abuse. Geshela said in every single case, this is sexual misconduct compounded by other aspects of behavior like drinking and so forth.
So if you take the case of incest, incest is a sexual misconduct, but the sexual misconduct of an extremely severe form. Within sexual misconduct, there are numerous graduations. So violence such as, for instance, beating someone would be included within the constellation of killing even though it’s not a complete perfected deed of killing. So the sudden Vinaya independence on this, that occurs. Please be mindful of the fact that not all of the non virtuous by any means are included within the 10 non virtuous deeds.
It is just a list and what is important is for us to identify the non virtuous deed to which we are the most prone. No. Probably they would be within the category of idle talk because harsh words are words directed to a person such as saying, what a dog you are, what a donkey you are, what an ox you are, and the other party must understand this. So if you take your dog to the vet to be using euthanized because he suffers of an incurable disease, you accumulate the karma of murder and you also accumulate virtuous karma. So on the one hand, to having the dog euthanized, you will reduce the lifespan of the dog by a couple of days.
So this reduction, this forceful reduction of the lifespan is a deed of killing. The deed of killing is complete, therefore you will experience the karma of killing. However, there are two motivations present. The core motivation and the superficial motivation. The core motivation is empathy or compassion.
This is virtuous. Therefore, you will experience maturation of empathy or compassion as well as the maturation of the intent to kill. My question relates to the which says in first part in the killing categories according to the compendium of determinations are five basis perception attitude affliction and conclusion As I understand it, compendium of determinations is Chitamatra. Would if it is Chitamatra, would this five fold division only make sense to a Chitamatra? I have to borrow your copy of.
I have to translate back to peculiar of determination in Tibetan. It’s not the Chitamatra system. It is a common presentation. All deterred systems are the same in their presentation of deeds such as killing. They all accept this presentation.
It is a natural misdeed. Therefore, they all accept the same presentation. So it’s the same thing. The lie in this case has a component of virtue. And he used the example of the existence of God.
There is a story in that’s come from the world about a woman who was asked for a relic of the wood from her son. And he brings her a dog’s tooth. And she reveres it as though it is a relic of Buddha. And she gains realization due to her strong faith. There’s no difference.
If one has faith in God and independence on this profound faith, qualities and even realizations arise, it is due to the faith they arise. That the the top order is the lying and then divisive, and then harsh words, and gossiping is the last one. But if you examine the dominant one, the daily life, you do the gossiping a lot, is the more, that means that the gossiping is more dominant and also they accumulate more heavy non virtues than the rest? Yes, if one engages in idle talk on a daily base and one does not purify to the application of the four antidotes, then it becomes more and more powerful and becomes as powerful as lying. And another question.
Provided that it’s unmistaken in both engagement and relinquishment. And I wonder if Krishna could just give an example of the engagement and relinquishment in an unmistaken way. Of an When we speak of the unmistaken engagement and relinquishment, an ethics of unmistaken engagement and relinquishments, this is an ethics in which one engages unmistakenly in virtue and relinquishes unmistakenly non virtue. I guess the the question is, what does unmistaken mean? So the term unmistaken here refers to abstaining from evil deeds in this life, which give rise to evil results in future lives.
So I said to Disha, perhaps you are thinking of the mistaken understanding of Muslim extremists who view the killing of infidels as a virtue. Then clearly, murder, killing is a non virtuous deed. So this is a mistaken ethics. Then we don’t have to put names on things. We just have to make sure our own ethics is a mistake.
As I understand it, the modern contraceptive pill works in two ways. One, it prevents the sperm freely swimming, so fertilization doesn’t take place. And the second way is that it causes the body to reject the embryo. Now I’ve long thought that to use the contraceptive pill with that knowledge that So the question you’re asking is a question of abortion. This is clearly treated in Vinaya.
If as a result of medicine abortion occurs, it is murder. If it occurs naturally, it is not. Can can I do a supplement to that just to just to explain? In the West, there is the practice of birth control. One way of doing that is to take a pill every day, and that creates a condition within the body where pregnancy does not occur.
The other one is where you can take a pill after the act, and that is important. Now what Lily is asking, I think. No, no, I’m getting the same thing because e fertilization takes place. Generally speaking, like to talk about idle talk. Idle talk.
Regarding idle talk, engaging in talk about non dharma, at what point does that become idle talk? For example, talking about football, when does that become idle talk? So what he said in the British treaties is is that talk which is meaningless is idle talk. Talk which is meaningful is not idle talk. Then we’re talking of something which has no target.
So clearly, as far as football is concerned, there’s a goal. Anything which is related to one’s studies would not qualify as meaningless talk. The texts refer to something which involves a waste of time. And another. Sorry?
Your voice keeps dropping as you talk. So if two people are in love, yes? If two people are of the same sex and deeply in love, their physical act of sex does no damage to each other, how is that a non virtue? Then it’s a good question. It is something you have to analyze the scriptures carefully about.
In the case of male homosexuality, there is a high risk of sexual misconduct. In the case of female homosexuality, probably not. Well, let us take the case of adultery for instance. So if one cheats on one’s wife and has a mistress, then this is something which is at odds with the laws of most countries and is at odds very much with what people call natural ethics. Important topic, particularly amongst the young in this country.
Please And that and that there are many people who of the same sex who have really, really long standing. They’re like marriages. They’re lasting for decades. They support each other in sickness and in health. And they are like old married couples.
And they’re actually a significant proportion of the population that engages in. He said, ask me, what are we gonna do with it? I said, you answer. Yeah. That is just alright.
Just stop tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.