1 h 32 min · 4,432 words · 19 April 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains conventional or opaque bodhichitta through the equalization and exchange of self and others and the sevenfold cause-and-effect method, moving from affectionate love and great compassion to great resolve. It then turns to ultimate bodhichitta, explaining that realizing emptiness is needed and describing the selflessness of persons as being imputed on their basis of designation. Questions from the audience are answered throughout.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 32m
UUID: 032936b6-4d06-4837-a832-e484457d4e5d
Date: 2014-04-19
Words: 4,428
Mhmm. Did you have good lines today? Yes. Good. And Question?
Yes. Do we answer? And question and answer. As Shantideva says in his Bodhisattvacharyavatara, having generated just one instant of spontaneous bodhichitta, one becomes worthy of the title, scion of the conquerors, and worthy of homage by all the gods of this world. The meaning of this profound stanza is as follows, once one has generated uncontrived, in other words spontaneous bodhichitta, one is deemed worthy of the title bodhisattva, scion of the conqueror by other Buddhas and bodhisattvas, and one is worthy of being an object to which prostration is offered by gods and deities.
This does not mean that actual prostration is offered, but one is worthy of prostration. And therefore, once one falls under the sway of bodhichitta, then one is of benefit to immeasurable sentient beings, just as, for instance, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, who is under the sway or controlled by bodhichitta, is of benefit to innumerable others. This is how one should think about it. Foremost among our sufferings are mental sufferings, Physical sufferings are sufferings such as disease and so forth which are easy to counter using the control of exterior conditions, but mental suffering can only be countered through dharma. Such a practice is not only a practice which has great qualities for oneself, it is extraordinarily beneficial for others, and therefore, it is akin to vast waves of good practice.
This basically completes the presentation of bodhichitta from the standpoint of the training of the equalization and interchange of self and others. As you know, the sevenfold mind training presents Bodhichitta from the standpoint of the equalization and interchange of self and others, and not from the standpoint of the sevenfold cause and effect lineage. The lineage of the equalization and interchange of self and others can be traced back all the way to Then for those of you who have a bit of an acquaintance with Lorig, from within minds and mental factors, bodhichitta is generally considered to be a main mind since it is referred to as Chitta or main mind. However, it has two objects, its first object is all others, all sentient beings and its subject, second object is its goal, which is full enlightenment. To give rise to an uncontrived bodhichitta which aspires to free all sentient beings from suffering and lead them to full enlightenment, initially, it is necessary to generate great compassion.
Therefore, it is necessary to generate a great compassion, which wishes to free all sentient beings from all pervasive suffering as the preliminary cause for the attainment of This great compassion arises in dependence on affectionate love. Affectionate love here is the fourth of the seven stage cause and effect generation of bodhichitta and therefore it comprises within itself the potency of these three first stages, which are recognizing all sentient beings as one mother, one’s mothers, recollecting their kindness, and resolving to repay their kindness. As it collects, contains within itself the potency of these three first stages, it can act directly as a cause for great compassion. Now generally speaking, the practice of the equalization and the interchange of self and others contains within itself all the qualities of the sevenfold cause and effect practice for the generation of bodhichitta, the opposite is not true. This is a very vast topic which I shall not enter into now, you may want to reflect on it by yourselves.
And from this point onwards, from the point of the generation of affectionate love onwards, the procedure is the same for both methods for generating bodhichitta, the equalization and the interchange of self and others, and the seven fold cause and effect generation of bodhichitta. In other words, we have level four affectionate love, level five, great compassion, level six, the great resolve, and then the generation of bodhichitta. Then at present, I will take your questions concerning the path of the being of the middling scope alone. If you have questions, please ask them and please make them short. Either on the path of the being of the middling scope or so.
Yeah. Shall I can I test my understanding of both of the smaller and the Could you could you repeat? Actually, I can’t hear you. Could I please test the my understanding of the lower or the smaller scope and the medium scope? My understanding is that volition gives direction to karma.
In Volition. The smaller Volition. Or motivation gives direction to karma. So in the smaller scope we’re essentially training our minds towards virtuous volition or motivation so as that we can give rise to a better rebirth. In the middle scope we’re essentially trying to dismantle the mechanism of karma through understanding emptiness therefore not applying a direction to the karma we create.
Is that understanding correct? And if so, does that mean that the common thread between the small scope and the medium scope is karma and two different understandings of the way that karma is applied. The common what? The common thread? Prayer.
Thread. Thread. Excuse me, I’m going deaf. It is true that there is a motivation specific to the being of the small scope, but one cannot say that generating such a motivation is the main practice of the being of the small scope, since other practices of the being of the small scope, such as understanding karma in accordance with the practice of the being of the small scope, meditation on death and impermanence, and on the suffering of the lower realms are also important practices of the being of the small scope. This morning, Geshela said that we know that because of self cherishing unpleasant states of mind, for example anger, jealousy, etcetera arise.
Isn’t this as much about self grasping? Aren’t these unpleasant states of mind caused by as much by self grasping as they are by self cherishing? And therefore, a an issue of the path of middling scope. Envy and competitiveness arise from both self cherishing and self grasping, they have numerous causes. I’ve heard the teachings on the four seals and I do not know which are the teachings on the four seals which I’ve heard are the fundamental differences between Buddhism and particularly Christianity are they located in the middle the middling scope?
Mainly the Four Seals are included within the practice of the being of the middling scope, but some elements are included within the practice of the being of the small scope, such as the meditation on the fact that all composite phenomena are impermanent. What is the second seal? The first I understand is all conditioned phenomena are impermanent the second is all compounded phenomena are something The third is all phenomena lack an inherent existence. And the fourth is nirvana is peace. I don’t know what the second is, if I have them any them right.
The second is that all contaminated phenomena are suffering, that’s mainly the practice of the being of middling scope. It is connected to the noble truth of suffering. Are you asleep? Looks like. I think maybe such.
Sorry, Geshela if you said this a 100 times but I just want to clarify as I’m probably you know not even a being of small scope is it bad to try and do any of the the Tonglen practices? Should I wait or is it okay to start trying to habituate my mind a little bit? I’m not quite sure there of the body Chita practices. Can we start when we feel ready or should we wait? You can definitely practice Tonglen giving and taking even if you are not a fully characterized being of the small scope.
However, the Tonglen you practice will not be a fully characterized Tonglen since you will neither have compassion nor love. Even though you’re not a fully characterized being of the small scope, you can meditate on the totality of the path with, for instance, an overview meditation. When you make an overview meditation, you cover Tonglen as well. I thought the questions were about the middling scope rather than the great scope. No problem.
If you want to ask questions about the great vehicle, that’s fine. Okay. Geshela of course provided an example, a fairly extreme example this morning about present day practice of Tonglen. The training of in love. Was this possible in reality and gave the examples?
And yes, gave the example of more than a 100 who have immolated themselves and practiced exchange of self and others in that respect. Geshela was advancing this as on the face of it a supreme act of benevolence, whereas His Holinesses discouraged such actions, at least in the face of it. Would Geshela comment on that? What Mr. Holiness said was that if one practices self immolation motivated by anger or irritation, then this is a great tragedy.
Did say that it was extraordinary that there are beings who can engage in such an ultimate sacrifice motivated by the wish to benefit others and Tonglen giving and taking. However, that since there are few Tibetans, this is something one perhaps should not engage in, and one should avoid it motivated by anger. I have a question about the material covered this morning but it’s not about the middle scope so I assume that’s okay. In Pabongkar Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand under the line building up the taking by starting with yourself he says meditate in the morning that you’re taking on the sufferings you will experience in the evening and so forth. That makes sense to me.
In Geshe Chekawa’s mind training like the rays of the sun he says begin by taking upon yourself all your own actions and disturbing emotions and then put them in your heart and thereby think you are freed from these sufferings and their causes. I’m having difficulty intellectualisingly taking the sufferings away from myself, putting them in my heart and then being free from the suffering. What is your English source? What is what text are you relying for Geshe Chekawa? Our mind training like the rays of the sun.
Okay. The commentary, the commentary. It’s a very very loose translation, very loose, And then after putting them in your heart what do you do? It’s page 73 of the translation by the Library of Tibetan Works and Archives and it’s halfway down the page and says imagine that these, the sufferings, fall in black heaps similar to trimmings of hair on your present mental and physical aggregates and think that you are thereby freed from these sufferings? Most of the passage I don’t quite understand.
So I told Gishela, I’ve checked the translation of Gishela, Chekhawa’s translation here, it’s extremely loose. You can’t rely on it, it uses English colloquialisms. I haven’t checked the text of Namkha Pel’s commentary, I will check it and let you know. This translation that we’re talking about, page 74 down near the bottom says Geshe Sharawa remarked that this doctrine of training in love and compassion by way of taking all sufferings and their origins upon yourself and providing others with every happiness and virtue is a practice for banishing fear. And then Pabonga Rinpoche says in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand on page five forty eight Visualise that the things you take do not disappear or get put to one side, so obviously the sufferings of others, they are taken right into the centre of your heart.
It is good if this makes you fear for your very life. So one says you should fear for your life and the other one says it’s a practice for banishing fear. I cannot give you an answer at present. And also we have to text to check the Tibetan texts for the terms. I would just like to understand a little bit more about great resolve before one generates great compassion, was great resolve.
Before one generates great compassion? Yes, so, just before we started having questions, you speak louder Just before we started having questions, uh-huh, We were talking about the generation of affectionate love and the steps of that. And one of the steps is the great resolve, having great resolve. I was wondering if Geshela could talk about what would be involved, entailed in great resolve. Great resolve arises after both affectionate love and great compassion.
Since the great resolve arises after both affectionate love and great compassion, it is intimately connected with the realization of emptiness. Finish? Okay, it’s stated in some traditions that self is an ideation or a concept. So they train in non conceptuality with the belief that while there is no notion of self, self does not exist. So can Geshela comment on how an innate sense of self persists without the thought I am?
Which traditions? I believe some Zen traditions. I am not very familiar with Hua Xiang’s thought, I will look into it and answer you later. Just going back to Natalie’s question. My understanding was that Great Resolve was number six in a list of seven where the seventh was generation of bodhichitta.
And the first three were seeing all sentient beings as one mother and recollecting their kindness and wanting to repay kindness. Is that right? And in which case, what was four and five? And which, what is character, what comprises then affectionate love? Are they the first three, if that comes before great compassion?
And is distinct from great compassion? Your question is what’s the difference between affectionate love and great compassion really? Is there a seven fold list ending with great resolve and generation of bodhichitta of which the first three are seeing all sentient beings as one mother, in which case what is four and five because I missed it. Recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mother number one, recollecting their kindness number two, repaying their kindness number three, affectionate love number four, great compassion number five, the great resolve number six, bodhichitta number seven. Between affectionate what what is the fourth step and the fifth step in that There is a slight difference in aspect between affectionate love and great compassion.
Affectionate love focuses on the happiness one wishes to impart on sentient being or to sentient beings, great compassion focuses on the suffering of sentient beings and the wish to free them from this suffering. Alright, good. Have a seat. Have a seat please. So this completes the presentation of conventional or opaque Bodhichitta, and we will pass to ultimate bodhichitta.
But I’d like to recapture or represent the material briefly. Once we have generated within our mind stream, based on the equalization and the interchange of self and others, This bodhichitta which wishes to lead all sentient beings to the state of full enlightenment, this is of extraordinary benefit for ourselves, but in and of itself, it is of no particular benefit for others. Then at this point, having generated conventional or opaque bodhichitta, one should really take the bodhisattva vows and start practicing engaging bodhichitta, but we shall set this aside and address the issue of how one should practice. Having generated conventional or opaque bodhichitta, one should then ask the question, where does one’s own suffering and that of others arise from? It arises from karma and affliction.
Karma and affliction arise from ignorance, ignorance can be countered by the wisdom which realizes the selflessness of phenomena, at this point one strives at generating such a wisdom. I mentioned yesterday that in the great Indian treatises, ultimate bodhichitta is generated first and conventional or opaque bodhichitta is generated afterwards. Whereas in the tradition of the graduated stages of the path of the Lamrim, it is the opposite. Conventional bodhichitta or opaque bodhichitta is generated first and ultimate bodhichitta afterwards. The reason comes here.
Then those of you who didn’t listen to the answer yesterday, put some effort at listening now because it will be repeated. So the reason for which one generates ultimate bodhichitta first is because one realizes that both oneself and others need to be able to generate the wisdom realizing emptiness, since the wisdom realizing emptiness or selflessness is the counter which focuses on ignorance, it is therefore indispensable. There is a quote in sutra which explains this very clearly, Buddha Shakyamuni says, I do not liberate beings from suffering by removing it with my hand, nor do I wash it off with water, nor do I free beings from sufferings through imparting my blessing, I free beings from suffering through imparting them teachings on emptiness. You like emptiness? I’m asking you whether you like it.
It’s a bit difficult, isn’t it? As Aryadeva says in his Chatuhshataka, initially accumulate merit, then focus on selflessness, finally analyze carefully the extremes. In this way you shall become learned in the four truths. The meaning of this stanza is that after engaging in the preliminary practices, one should train in an understanding of the subtle selflessness of persons, the fact that persons are empty of being autonomous entities. Just as Shantipa taught that initially one should train one’s mind in an understanding of the emptiness of the person being permanent, one, and independent before proceeding to an understanding of the person’s emptiness of substantial autonomy.
Whereas Chandrakirti taught that from the very inception, one should train the mind in the Prasangika view. These are differences of presentations of the various scholars. So when one speaks of the persons being empty, of being permanent one and independent, it is important to understand initially what is being negated, what the object of negation is here. The object of negation is a person which is permanent, one and independently established. Such a person is known as the soul or the Atman.
Now this person is seen by the non Buddhist schools which accept it, I do not believe there is a single Buddhist school with that which accepts such a person, but is seen by the non Buddhist schools which accept it as a permanent entity which exists within the person once the aggregates are discarded, specifically at death when the body is burned, this soul which is unchanging and is never destroyed is what transmigrates into the next life. Such a soul, which is independent of the aggregates, such a person which is independent of the aggregates does not exist. For instance, when I drink a cup of tea, actually it is on the basis of the basis of imputation, my aggregates which grasp the cup of tea and drink it that you will say imputing Geshela upon them, Geshela drinks a cup of tea. Likewise, when my consciousness aggregates sink into sleep, on the basis of the basis of imputation sinking into sleep, you will assert Geshela is falling asleep. There is therefore an intimate relationship between the imputed person and the basis of designation on which it is imputed.
And therefore, a person which is established as permanent one and independent does not exist. Persons are empty of being permanent one and independent. It is probably the case that beings who have not been exposed to tenets, in other words who do not have philosophical training, will not subscribe to the view that persons are permanent one and independent. However, the sense of the person being an autonomous substantial existent is present naturally within our minds. And the view that the person is empty of being permanent one and independent is understood to be the subtle selflessness of persons according to the lower schools of tenets, and is understood by the Prasangika Madhyamika School to be the coarse selflessness of persons.
Now regarding the persons being empty of being an autonomous substantial entity, this is to be understood as follows, the object of negation of emptiness of a person’s being a substantial autonomous entity is a person being established as an autonomous substantial entity, and the view that the person is established as an autonomous substantial entity entails that independently of one’s constituents, such as one’s legs, one’s hands, and so forth, there is an enjoyer and an owner of these constituents whose relation to these constituents is akin to that of a king to his slaves. This is what is negated. Now with this Prasangika view of the coarse selflessness of persons, the object of refutation is the idea that persons are substantially autonomous existents. According to this view that persons are substantial autonomous existents, the person, in other words, the terminological self is akin to a king, whereas his constituents, the bodily parts and elements of consciousness, are akin to servants. The relationship is asymmetrical, in other words, whereas the constituents of bodily parts and parts of consciousness depend on the terminological self or the king, the king himself or the terminological self does not depend on the bodily parts or the constituents.
This view is mistaken. Why is it mistaken? It is mistaken because it presumes that the person does not depend on its constituents, whereas the constituents depend on the person. This is not the case. Not only do the constituents depend on the person or the terminological I, but the person or the terminological I depends on the constituents.
Therefore, one can say the person is empty of being a substantially existent autonomous person because it depends on its constituents. This is an important point. If you can understand it, you will benefit greatly. Precisely because the person depends on the basis of imputation, one cannot say that the person is autonomous, since what is autonomous does not depend on anything else, and this is the reason for which the person is asserted to be empty of being an autonomous substantial entity. Once one has understood that the person depends on its basis of imputation, the aggregates, and that therefore the person is empty of being an autonomous substantial existent, this ushers the path to an understanding of these subtle selflessness of persons in keeping with the Madhyamika Prasangika view, Since one asks oneself, when the aggregate cease to exist, does the person cease to exist or not?
And this is a case because if one proceeds mentally through eliminating each of the aggregates of a person, initially the form aggregate, then the aggregate of sensation, then the aggregate of discrimination of compositional factors in the consciousness, then one can see that if one eliminates the form aggregate, the remaining aggregates cannot function as a basis of designation for myself, since I am an entity which has a body, which has a form, likewise if one eliminates the aggregate of sensation, then the three remaining aggregates can no longer function as a basis of designation for myself, since after all I am a sensate being, and so forth. Understanding this, one understands that the person is not only not an autonomous substantial existent, but as well is not established from its own side and is not inherently established. Therefore, the person from the Prasangika view is unfindable within the aggregates under ultimate analysis. If however, it were findable, it would be dependent on causes, on conditions, on terms, and on conception. His name, You didn’t think you’d hear about them, did you?
So if it were the case that the imputed phenomenon the person could be indeed found within the basis of imputation, then the imputed phenomenon could not be merely conceptually or nominally imputed on the basis of imputation. This will become evident if we take the example of Australia’s Prime Minister, Tony Abbott. If Tony Abbott were not merely a merely imp if Tony Abbott’s being a Prime Minister were not a mere nominal and conceptual imputation, this would mean that whenever or as soon as the aggregates of Tony Abbott are created, Tony Abbott would become Prime Minister, he would therefore have been Prime Minister from the beginning, and since this would apply to Julia Gillard too, you would have two prime ministers. Therefore, if Tony Abbott being a prime minister was not conceptually and nominally imputed, he would have been a Prime Minister from the very beginning. However, this is not the case, as you well know there was vote after vote after vote, and as a result of all these votes, an electoral decision was taken, and it is as a result of this electoral decision that the process of nominal and conceptual imputation on Tony Abbott could occur and he could be called prime minister.
Since these are the thoughts, should a person be findable among its basis of designation and not be a mere nominal and conceptual imputation on its basis of designation, the person is not findable among its basis of designation, nor is it a mere nominal or conceptual imputation on its basis of designation. It is empty, in other words of inherent existence. It is empty of existence from its own side. And therefore, in a nutshell, persons are merely imputed on their basis of designation. They are mere nominal and conceptual imputations.
The person’s existing within its basis of designation is the object of negation, and its emptiness of existence within its basis of designation is its emptiness of inherent existence, its emptiness of existence from its own side. The ignorance which spontaneously apprehends a person as existing within its basis of designation is the inherent ignorance which is to be countered. And as progressively one counters the wrong view that the person is inherently established as its basis of designation, the correct view that the person is a mere nominal and conceptual imputation on the basis of designation increases in strength. As it increases in strength, the strength of the innate ignorance apprehending the person as in existing inherently within its basis of designation abates, and as this ignorance abates, the production of karma and so forth, the 12 links abates as well. As one develops affectionate love and compassion, one’s understanding that the root of cyclic existence is this misapprehension of phenomena deepens, and one understands that the only way to help beings is for oneself to gain realization of the true mode of existence of phenomena, and then to help sentient beings to rely on it.
In so doing, one starts to train in wisdom. It was a bit difficult, wasn’t it? So we will stop here for today and resume tomorrow. Mhmm. This time tomorrow, we’ll be incorporating body, speech and mind offering for Geshela.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Where are the Four Seals, the teachings that mark fundamental differences between Buddhism and Christianity, located within the scopes of the path? Are they in the middling scope?
The Four Seals are mainly included within the practice of the being of the middling scope. Some elements of them, however, are included within the practice of the being of the small scope. One example is the meditation on the fact that all composite phenomena are impermanent.