Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-07-04 – KR.mp3
UUID: b23c2f53-aa30-4d22-9bca-88b430dc324f
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Bodhisattvacaryavatara (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-07-04
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 55m
Words: 7,545
So we remind ourselves that we’re discussing tonight the antidote to anger which is patience. And patience forms the, title of the chapter of the text that we are studying. We’ve been talking about the various antidote. Well, the the main antidote to anger being patience. And we’ve also spent some time covering the various faults of anger and anger and hatred.
It’s very important that each morning we if we are able to spend some time reflecting upon these two things, that is the virtue of patience and its ability to be the antidote of anger and the faults of anger and hatred. If we’re able to devote even if it’s just five minutes every morning reflecting on the things that we’ve covered, then it would be of immense benefit to us throughout the course of our day. So when we wake up in the morning, we wake up in the comfort and security of our own home. And we wake up with a chance we wake up knowing full well that after some time, we’re going to have to go out into the world, and we’ll go out where we’re either around, family and friends or we’re at work or we’re very busy. So we know that this the moments that we have when we first wake up are quite precious to us because we are we do enjoy such comfort and security in those first moments of waking up in the morning.
It is also the best time for us to be at for our mental clarity And it’s an important time that we should be able to apply to thinking about important things. And maybe some people wake up and, think about the stages of the path or what whatever topics people have that they are interested in. But it is extremely beneficial if we use that moment when we first wake up still within the comfort and security of our home, still yet to be influenced by outside factors that we use that early morning clarity to think carefully about the nature of anger, the harm that anger causes, and the benefits the benefits of being able to practice an antidote to anger and patience. We think about the people that we are going to spend our time with throughout the day. We’ll be around maybe our parents or our children or partners or friends, relatives, associates, whoever.
And we know that throughout the course of the day there will be most likely situations will arise where we might be prone to feeling angry or discontented or when there will certainly be some things that happen in the course of the day that can make us feel angry. If in the in the morning we’ve been able to establish within ourselves a very clear picture of the harm that anger is going to cause in all our relationships, That anger is going to cause the harm that anger will cause in terms of us trying to achieve whatever it is we’re trying to set out to achieve in the course of the day. If we’ve spent time first thing in the morning analyzing the benefits of patience and the dangers of anger and hatred, then throughout the course of the day we’ll have we’ll have set up part of our mind to be alert to, to be aware of the potential for anger to destabilize ourselves and to be able to be ready to apply that antidote which is patience. So if when we wake up in the morning, are able to devote ourselves for five minutes, even if it’s just maybe two or three minutes.
But if we are earnestly using a few moments in the morning each and every morning to analyse the benefits of patience and the faults of anger and hatred. If we’re able to do it one morning and then the next morning and then the morning after and then become get into the habit of doing it regularly each and every day, then the benefit is enormous. You will begin to habituate habituate yourself to being alert to the signs of anger. Because you will have reminded yourself each morning of the dangers of anger and the harm that it is going to cause to your your social relationships, your family, to to the work you’re trying to accomplish. If if it has been if you have held that in your mind early in the morning, each and every morning, and become habituated to it, you will be alert to this first signs of anger.
Now we’ve all had the experience of getting angry and sometimes of getting really angry. And we know that it is an uncontrollable state. We have experienced that as an uncontrollable state where strong anger has overwhelmed us. But if we’re able to get into the habit of waking up every morning and devoting these really crisp clear moments to analyzing the faults of anger and hatred and the benefits of patience. Having habituated to that later on sometime in the future when that first signs of anger begin to well up within us we’ll be able to catch it straight away.
We’ll be able to catch it and say, no, here it comes. Here it comes. Oh no, it’s such a here comes danger. Here comes danger. Here comes danger.
And you’ll be able to be able to create some space between the moment that whatever the stimulus is that occurs and the way that you will react. And you’ll be quite amazed. You’ll be quite amazed that this you’ll get an ever lengthening period of time in which you’ll be able to catch yourself before being and before the anger overwhelms you. And in fact if you have if you have engaged in this practice continually, you’ll find that anger doesn’t have the power to overwhelm you anymore. Instead, you’ll find that you’re able to have a voice within you will be saying, oh, no.
Anger’s arising. Oh no, anger’s arising. I must stop it here. I must stop it here. I must stop it here.
And you’ll know you’ll have all the good reasons of why you need to. You won’t even need to think about those reasons in the moment, but because you’ve spent time in the morning habituating yourself to the faults of anger and the benefit of patience, it will become natural to you. Now this is something that is not even a religious or a Buddhist dharma expression or teaching or practice. It’s something that will quite clearly just benefit anybody in any walk of life in any kind of living situation they find themselves in. Now of course within the context of us learning Buddhism and trying to train and practice, we read the advice of Shantideva in this text.
But the point one of the points here is that it benefits everyone in every walk of life and in every kind of living situation. If you are really able to make a habit of thinking on the faults of anger and hatred and the benefits of patience And stress the point, make a habit of it. Not just do it once this week and maybe once next week, once next month, but do it every morning even if it’s only two or three minutes. It’s absolutely certain that it will be of great benefit to you. Now of course when we’re engaging in these kinds of contemplations it is always recommended that we’re able to get up and find a comfortable meditation, place to meditate and assume a very upright and correct posture and be able to fix our mind on these things.
But of course, what’s more important is that we do it, not that we assume a very important meditation posture. So if you’re better off staying under the covers with the blanket pulled up around you and thinking of these things, then it is far better to do it like that than to get up and sit on a cushion and not do it. And this is and the importance is that it’s done, Not not that you get up and do it in a specific way. Be as comfortable and as warm and secure as you want to be, but just make sure you do it. So we understand when we assume and meditate, when we undertake to meditate and to meditate on something, for example, if we’re meditating on emptiness, what we’re really saying when we use the word meditate.
What the word meditate in a Tibetan, the word is gong. What this word implies when Geshela uses the word gong is habituate. We are habituating our mind to something. So for the example if we’re meditating on emptiness, we habituate Meditating on emptiness means habituating our mind to the the wisdom that understands emptiness. Now in the context of the faults of anger and hatred and the benefits of patients, what we’re doing is habituating our mind to the onto these topics.
So understand that what it means to meditate on patients, the benefits of patience and the faults of anger and hatred means to not simply sit up straight and appear as if you’re engaged in some single single pointed focus. What it means is to habituate your mind so that over time what you’re actually doing is retraining your instincts. So behaviour becomes instinctive Because to habituate our mind to something is to train ourselves so that certain responses become instinctive and not contrived. So when we refer in this phrase meditating on the benefits of patience and the faults of anger, we’re really saying is habituating ourselves. So if we think about for ourselves what the nature of anger is like, what anger is like when it arises, and the methods that we have for quelling anger.
If we analyze into that, we can see that one of the great opponent forces to it is compassion. Because compassion is the opposite of anger and hatred. It’s impossible to maintain these two opposite things in the mind at one time. So if we think in the activities in the course of a day, we engage in activities some that bring us pleasure and some that bring us feelings that are unpleasurable and we think if we’re able to see that the things that are pleasurable to us it’s very much easier for us to cultivate this mind of compassion and a sense of peace and well-being. So when we come to situations where the various causes of anger are presented to us we have to have methods for overcoming this anger And what we talk about is having this being able to establish a mind that overcomes anger.
And to this mind that we call establishing the mind that overcomes anger is made possible by the practice of patience. So we take for there are many situations in our lives where we are prone to feel as if we are being compelled into being angry, where we feel anger arise and that can happen in situations when we’re having to look after children or we’re having to be in a relationship and maintain a relationship. These situate these kinds of situations will always present the opportunities for us to become angry if we’re able to if we’re unable to keep a check on our minds. Now we take the example of small children who let’s say children who are aged from about the ages of four, five, six or seven, eight even older around that age. It’s very easy that they can misbehave and do all kinds of things.
Well, it’s natural that they would behave like that because they have young immature minds that and they do not have the skill or expertise to fully control their mind. So in response to that, if you get angry, it’s hardly a stellar example of being able to overcome. You have a mature and responsible mind that is capable of controlling its behavior and its anger. When a small child behaves as is natural to a child for us to respond in a way that is in fact quite childish then it’s of course not a it’s not a very beneficial state for either the child or the people. Now Geshela says from experience you can see when children misbehave that parents often seek to placate their behaviour by buying presents for them and giving them a present and feeling as if that’ll shut them up for a little bit.
But we know from experience that it’s impossible to have a continual supply of presents to keep giving to children to be able to quell their, to keep them in control. But what we need to remember is the nature of their mind is such that they don’t have the maturity to control their mind. So we do have that potential and we do have that skill. And so in response to them behaving as is natural to them, we should not forget the skills and attributes we have to be able to control our mind. And so Geshela reflects on the time when he was young up until through the ages of seven up until about the ages of eight or nine.
He cannot remember any situation or event where his mother got angry. And it should be remembered that it was a very hard life in Tibet. And there were a lot more hardships to be endured in Tibet than what there are here. This was referring to your exemplary behavior. Until about ages 11 or 12.
So we understand and to put it concisely that patience is the best possible way for us to be able to apply a powerful antidote to anger and to stop anger and hatred arising within our minds. And it is something that if we analyse and think about we will come to that understanding and that realization. And what we need to do is habituate ourselves to this instinct within us to be able to immediately rather than giving over into the throes of anger because we all have that experience that uncontrollable moments of anger that we can’t catch it. It slips through our fingers and we’re angry before we know it. But if we’re able to use a couple of moments every single morning over not just days but over weeks and months and over a long period of time.
If we’re able to habituate ourselves to benefits of patients and the power of patience then it means that we will not only increase the virtue that we’re able to accumulate through the through the but our actions through our behaviors because without anger we will of course it will be it is natural that we will be able to without without being confounded in any way we will be able to behave in a virtuous way and we will also be able to enjoy far greater happiness. These two results that will come from being able to have habituated ourselves to this instinct of patience at the moment of anger. Now it’s not something that can be done just a little bit here and then forget about it for a while and do it for another day or a couple of days or wait until something bad happens and then do it then. The only way that we can really habituate our mind to a new behavior is by reinforcing it every single day and it only takes a few minutes. It really only takes a few minutes, but the benefits are great.
Not just in terms of the virtuous behavior we will effortlessly be able to perform, but also in terms of the greater happiness that we would we are going to experience. And now if we can use the next couple of minutes for us to set our motivation and make this promise to ourselves that we’re going to sincerely apply ourselves to understanding the the qualities of patients, the benefits of patience, and its ability to be able to overcome and act as an antidote to anger and hatred and all the faults that stem from a mind that becomes overwhelmed by anger and hatred. So if we could set our motivation now for the next few minutes we are determined through the course of the teaching to use this moment as our moment of study to prepare ourselves for the practice of being able to accomplish perfect patience. So if we just do that now for the next couple of minutes. So now we begin to our root text, Shantideva’s The Way of the Bodhisattva or Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life.
I think we’ve arrived up to verse nine. You’ll see that I have a bit of a disadvantage here in that Geshela has memorized the text. Having failed to do that myself in the last one does I admit my faults in that regard. But Geshela, first before we begin, wants to remind us that there are some Buddhist topics that we study that are very complicated and are very hard to deconstruct and require a lot of abstract thought and a lot of references to other things that have been written and various commentaries. Topics such as emptiness and minor mental factors and these types of teachings where most people would have known have had some experience of these teachings and the ability they have to really send us to sleep and make us really struggle mentally to come to grips with them.
In this text, however, this text is so beautifully written and it is so precise in the meanings that it conveys that it is a perfect text to really apply yourself to with a great deal of energy because there’s no there’s no there’s no dark lane ways that you’ll get drawn down to distract you on tangents of trying to come to understand or make sense of it. It’s very clear. It’s very direct. In the Tibetan, is very beautiful. But most importantly, the meanings are so precise and the effect it has on our minds when we really go full force into trying to make sense and understand it.
It’s extraordinarily beneficial and it’s a really wonderful text to be able to study and it’s a joy to study. So we go on from verse nine, which talks about us, whatever actions that we engage in, whatever behaviors we engage in throughout the course the day, whatever events we are drawn into. We we have to make sure that we understand that nothing that we attempt to achieve will ever be accomplished once we allow our mind to be drawn away from a natural and calm clear state. And once if we are trying to accomplish a certain kind of virtue associated with a practice or any kind of happiness, whatever it is that we’re seeking to achieve, once our mind is destabilized, once we have allow ourselves to become unhinged, not only will we not achieve what we’re hoping to achieve, but in fact we will actually we will cause things to We will cause the virtuous parts of our mind, the virtuous behaviors that we are capable of achieving. These will begin to decline.
And so literally the verse reads, whatever befalls me, I shall not disturb my mental joy. For having been made unhappy, I shall not accomplish what I wish, and my virtues will decline. And so it goes on to say that we should when we come across situations where we’re unable to change an event that is unpleasant to us, there’s really no point for us to destabilize our our mental our joy. It’s really no point for us to become worried about something that we cannot change. And if we are able to bring about a change to something, then of course, again, there’s no need to disturb our equilibrium because there is a path, there is a way that we’re able to bring about something beneficial to a situation.
So either way no matter what kind of situation befalls us, it’s there is what Shantideva is stressing is that there is no point for us to relinquish this this state of mental joy, this state of inner happiness, of peace and happiness. It is not worth relinquishing in any situation. If it’s a situation where there is no clear remedy, then that’s how there is. There’s no clear remedy and that is the way things are. No reason to destabilize our mind.
If there is a remedy, then well and good, there is a remedy. No reason to destabilise our mind. Verse 10 reads literally why be unhappy about something if it can be remedied And what is the use of being unhappy about something if it cannot be remedied? And we all have the experience where we look around to the people who are near and dear to us that we we naturally, quite naturally, wish that they would be happy, that they would be free from any problems or turmoil, and we delight in the fact that they are able to achieve happiness, that they are able to achieve success. It’s something that we we relish and we delight in.
And yet when we see people who we’re not close to, people that we can, by distinction, say as call in this situation enemies. When we see some people that we don’t like, when we see that they’re enjoying something that’s incredibly fortunate, we’re not so happy about that and we don’t can’t really join in much of a celebration. In fact, it actually annoys us. And when we see them have some trouble or have see them being unable to achieve something they’ve set out to achieve, there is a part of us deep down where we kind of delight in that feeling. And these are the two natural ways that we seem to respond with the people who are near and dear to us and the people who we isolate and say are separate or separate to us.
And what the word that is always used is enemy even if it sounds a little harsh. That’s how we define this distinction between near and dear and enemy. So we tend to delight in all things good happening to our near and dear ones and we delight when bad things happen to our enemies and that seems to be a natural response that we tend to have in the course of our life. Verse 11 reads, for myself and for my friends, I want no suffering, no disrespect, no harsh words, and nothing unpleasant. But for my But for my enemies, it is the opposite.
If we analyze what the causes of happiness are and all happy and pleasant states of mind. If we ask what are the causes of these states of mind? We see that the cause, the cause will always be able to be traced back to virtuous behaviors. What we call virtuous behaviors. And likewise when it comes to suffering, we understand that the states of anger and spite and jealousy, these non virtuous states of mind act as a cause for us to experience suffering.
So we we know, we understand, we can identify what are the causes of happiness and we can see and know, identify what are the causes of suffering. Now if we don’t have the experience of these moments where we are experiencing suffering, If we were to never suffer, we would have no reason to investigate into the nature of causes, into the nature of what causes certain kinds of behaviours and results to occur. But because we’re experiencing suffering, that unpleasantness compels us to want to find out why and to try and find a way that we can stop it from happening. So in fact, these moments of suffering that, these moments of suffering are what give rise within ourselves a feeling of us wanting to separate ourselves once and for all from all the causes of unhappiness, of suffering. So the text reads, the causes of happiness sometime occur, but the causes for suffering are many.
Without suffering there is no renunciation. Therefore mind you should stand firm. So there are certain traditions within the Hindu religion that you may be aware of whereby inflict upon themselves extraordinary pain and hardship. Some of them put knives into themselves, they assume incredibly uncomfortable positions and maintain it for years. And they do all these extraordinarily bizarre behaviours that are incredibly painful.
And they do this because they believe that it’s a way that they’re able to propitiate their God, they’re able to show that they are worthy practitioners within their tradition and they’re able to cultivate patience in order to endure these incredible pain these practices cause them. They endure that pain and they cultivate that patience in order to please their God. Now when we talk about the kinds of sufferings that we’re going through, we’re trying to we have as our goal not only a personal liberation, but the ability to be able to inspire liberation in all other living beings. Now if that is our goal, if that is our aim Mhmm. Then surely when it comes time for us to be able to evoke patience in order to quell negativity and to foster virtue, then surely this is a much more worthy thing to do.
Surely this is something that we should feel incredibly emboldened about that we should have extraordinary determination to cultivate these patients because what we’re hoping to attain by practicing this cultivation is such a profound and noble cause that is our own liberation and ultimately the ability for us to attain the ability to be able to inspire and guide all other beings to towards their own liberation. So verse 13 says, if some ascetics and people of Kunapa endure the pain of cuts and burns for no reason then for the sake of liberation why have I no courage? So we know from the the teachings of the Buddha that it was taught that through the perfection of certain trainings, we’re able to achieve and we’re able to achieve advancement along the Buddhist path and towards our ultimate goal of enlightenment. That we engage in trying to understand the nature of renunciation and cultivating generosity and virtue and persistence and ethics. All of these things that we know that the Buddha has taught about when he first taught the four noble truths that there were all of these a great many things that we needed to devote ourselves to the training and the study of in order to be able to progress along the path.
And that all of these trainings need for us to have endurance and the ability to persist when there are even when it seems that there are no immediate results being achieved. So we have to have through through all those things that were presented in the teachings within the four noble truths of the trainings that we needed to, fulfill and the states of mind we were hoping to achieve, they all require perseverance. They all require commitment. Now when it comes to small inconveniences that we experience in the course of a day, whether it’s hearing some some nagging that we don’t like to hear or any kind of any kind of influence to us that is is just is it’s not really a big thing. It’s not a catastrophic thing.
It’s kind of small, but it’s just so annoying and it’s even more annoying because it is small. And it can drive us, it can drive our mind to distraction. Well, if we are able to habituate ourselves first and foremost to these minor inconveniences, to all these minor inconveniences, the the kinds of things that we really because they’re not catastrophic, because they’re not a major life changing events, They’re just little things that happen in the course of the day. We sometimes we let these things we allow ourselves just to respond to these things without any kind of self awareness. But if these small annoyances is where we’re able to start of practicing of habituating ourselves to be able to have patience, have persistence, to have endurance, to be able to have a sense of a strong sense of commitment to maintaining a clear state of mind no matter what’s occurring to us.
This is where we can start. We start with the little things. We start with all the little minor annoyances and that’s our first steps in training. So that no minor annoyance is too small for us to think that we don’t need to devote our focus and our awareness to it because it is an excellent opportunity to start small. And once we start small, as Geshela said at the beginning, we habituate our mind to those kinds of behaviours and it becomes instinctive for us.
Then later on when bigger problems arise, it’s instinctive within us to have this strength of forbearance to have patience, to have endurance. And so the text reads there is nothing whatsoever that is not made easier through acquaintance. So through becoming acquainted with small harms, I should learn to patiently accept greater harms. So if we think about it, there are a great many experiences that we have in the course of a day, a week, a month in our lives where we’re able to practice, where we’re able to cultivate our practice of patience. Now there are plenty of times where we’re bitten by a mosquito or a bug, we get a bite from a bug or some kind of insect where develop some kind of a rash or some kind of minor ailment to our body or even when we’re feeling terribly thirsty or we’re feeling hunger.
Now all these situations don’t it’s not helpful if we look at all of these situations as inconveniences and immediately seek an external remedy to try and limit these inconveniences to us. Instinctively, if we’re able to cultivate a sense tolerance and forbearance when have these minor minor irritations then once again we are able to set in motion as a habit as an instinct our response to some kind of negative influence as being instinctively what instinctively arises in our mind is the want is the desire to endure patiently and to not react hysterically, to not allow our mind to fall victim to minor irritations. So the text goes on. Who has not seen this to be so with trifling sufferings such as the bites of snakes and insects, feelings of hunger and thirst, and with such minor things as rashes? So we we can continue to analyze all the various little sufferings we experience in the course of the day.
There can be there can be the suffering of of temperature, of being too hot to be being too cold, of the way that the the kind of effects of the weather. We can be cold. We can be hot. There’s the suffering that comes with being sick. There’s the suffering that comes from all kinds of accidents, physical accidents.
If and illnesses. Now if we, again, we are able to cultivate within ourselves an instinct to to make our instinctive response to be that of patience, then we build a tolerance for all of these inconveniences. If however we become very melodramatic at the moment when some kind of affliction occurs to us whether it’s just that it happens to we happen to get wet trying to get to the car or we happen to have some minor experience of inconvenience. If we get annoyed and if we get frustrated and if that if instinctively it arises in us without being having any kind of self awareness whatsoever, we in fact make every situation worse. And so it doesn’t matter how small by nature the external event may be.
If our response to it is to catastrophize it, it will indeed become worse and our suffering will become greater. So verse 16 says, I should not be impatient with heat and cold, wind and rain, sickness bondage and beatings. For if I am, the harm they cause me will increase. So the next verse goes on to use use an example from warfare whereby sometimes out in the course of battle, whether it be, whether we can imagine this example within warfare or, for example, with, the police arriving at a crime, at a violent crime. There are people who when they see the sight of blood and guts in an in an from the effects of someone being shot or severely injured, they become they feel they feel themselves to become, in fact, emboldened by it and feel an an incredible urge to want to put things right and fix everything and control the situation and take charge and look after everyone who’s been injured or damaged or and control the situation.
And yet there are there are other people who might be construct who who when confronted by exactly the same kind of situation feel weak at the knees and find that they are unable to be able to respond in any meaningful or helpful way to what has occurred. And this is an example whereby we can see that there are some personalities, some dispositions where people can be confronted by a catastrophe and inspire them to act, to take control and to put things right. And there are people who when confronted with some kind of catastrophe feel weakened, lose their power, their agency to be able to have any effect to make things better, to improve the situation. So verse 17 says, some when they see their own blood become especially brave and steady, but some when they see the blood of others faint and fall unconscious. So we’re going to the next verse continues by saying, verse 18.
These reactions come from the mind being either steady or timid. Therefore, I should disregard harms caused to me and not be affected by suffering. So when we ourselves find ourselves find when we find ourselves in situations whereby whereby it the the nature of our response to it is going to determine how that how the future unfolds. It is important for us to be aware that what we are trying to accomplish by through Buddhist practice is to accomplish the altruistic mind of enlightenment to be able to attain these states of mind that are ultimately aimed at being beneficial for all living beings. And this is the state of mind that we are hoping to.
This is the solution we’re trying to bring to every problem. And so whereby we see ourselves being distracted by minor sufferings we should instead remind that this is an opportunity for us to be able to cultivate the patience that enables us to have the strength to have the courage to be able to transcend the immediacy of what seemingly is a suffering, is an unhappiness, is an unpleasantness, and use the power of our patience to overcome any negativity and thereby cultivate the virtuous states of mind that will bring about the ultimate benefit. So the next verse, verse 20 reads, verse 19, even when the wise are suffering, their minds remain very lucid and undefiled. For when war is being waged against the disturbing conceptions, much harm is caused at the time of battle. 20, the victorious warriors are those who have disregarded all suffering, vanquished the foes of hatred and so forth.
Common warriors slay only the corpses. So this these what this refers to here is that when it comes to when it comes to our mind being able to overcome enemies, there is no greater enemy to our mind than the non virtuous states of anger and hatred. And the effect that anger and hatred has on our mind and mental states. And when if we are to if if we are to face up to these to the sufferings that we incur in life without responding with anger and hatred and instead are able to apply the antidotes of patience. This is not an easy thing to do.
It is not an easy thing to do. It is something that in fact is very hard to do and it is something that we should regard as being something very noble and something that requires an enormous amount of bravery and courage and conviction to be able to achieve. Now the comparison is made to people who engage in common warfare, experience a battlefield where experience a battlefield where great dangers, where great dangers occur, where there is the threatened life of death and only the courageous are able to survive and shoot their way out of trouble. What the text refers to is that given that everyone is going to die eventually, if we think the greatest battle we’re ever going to engage in is shooting someone who in fact is going to die anyway, then that’s not very much of a not much of a battle that we should be thinking is all that courageous and noble to engage in. Whereas if we’re able to confront to confront the enemy of anger and hatred and are able to protect our minds by applying the antidote of patience, we should see this as a noble battle that involves great courage and great bravery.
So in the process within our own lives where we find ourselves confronted in situations where we feel really pushed into a corner and where we feel completely justified in our anger in our anger arising and being expressed, it takes a lot of courage. It takes a lot of nerve. It takes a lot of conviction to be able to, at that time, recognise who the real enemy is, who the one that is going to be the most danger is, which is of course anger itself. And so this is where the text refers to the kind of bravery and courage that is needed to be able to cultivate patience. So we know that if we go through life where life is very easy and achievements are easy to attain, that it’s very easy to it’s very easy for arrogance to arise and for us to have conceit and arrogance and be indifferent to the welfare of others.
Whereas when we experience sufferings within our life and we as referred to earlier, we feel compelled to find the causes to these sufferings. And we see that how these causes come about these causes come about as a result of the mental states that we create. When we are able to see and experience suffering ourselves, it actually diminishes our arrogance and our conceit. Now when life is very easy and everything seems to come along very easily and we attain great results in things that we do, It’s easy to cultivate arrogance and once arrogance arises, once self conceit arises, then it’s impossible to really have empathy and understanding for other living beings. And yet when it is when we come to experience within our own lives suffering and we analyse why it is that it happens, then we begin to be a little bit more aware of the fact that many other beings are in fact enduring similar sufferings of their own.
And from this point, we’re able to lead ourselves towards a virtuous thinking and virtuous states of mind and develop compassion and understand that by eliminating the causes for unhappiness is the way that we’re able to minimize the suffering that we experience not only ourselves, but that is experienced for the people around us within the world around us. So verse 21 says, furthermore suffering has good qualities Through being disheartened with it, arrogance is dispelled. Compassion arises for those in cyclic existence. Evil is shunned and joy is found in virtue. So when we have these minor difficulties, when we have these minor sufferings, it’s a way for us to implement this practice in cultivation of patients and by implementing and practising the patience we habituate ourselves to that which enables our mind to respond in a similar accord in the future.
So if we come to situations where we’re trying to identify them, if we have some doubt in relation to why it is that patience is able to be of benefit in these varied circumstances to our mind. Shantideva continues by referring to the nature of certain illnesses that can cause us suffering and how that if we become, when we experience a certain kind of illness, don’t in fact get angry at the specific parts that contribute to the illness arising. In fact, we’re being encouraged to do here is to analyse everything that causes us to be in a situation where we’re suffering doesn’t have a singular cause. So when we analyse the conditions, when we analyse what conditions in which certain things arise, We realise that there is never one singular cause and that there is actually a conglomeration of causes and conditions that come together in order for us to be able to experience something. So the example that’s used is when we have an illness and we don’t get angry at the bile that our liver creates when we’re suffering from jaundice.
And we get angry within that. So why should we get angry with an inanimate object and the like when we know that if we analyse it there are a multitude of factors that are happening altogether that are creating that situation. For example all the mental afflictions that our mind is continually under the sway of all work together to be able to create situations whereby we respond in the way that we do. Verses twenty two and twenty three say, as I do not become angry with great sources of suffering such as jaundice, then why be angry with animate creatures? They too are provoked by conditions.
Although they are not wished for, these sicknesses arise and likewise, although they are not wished for, disturbing conceptions forcibly arise. Without thinking the text goes on. Without thinking, I shall be angry. People become angry with no resistance. And without thinking, I shall produce myself.
Likewise, anger itself is produced. This continues on with the talking about the things that go together and the conditions and causes that go together to produce what we are talking about specifically here, which is the mental state of anger. Verse 25 says, all mistakes that are and all the various kinds of evils arise through the force of conditions. They do not govern themselves. So it is wrong for us to think that in a certain situation that a true singular cause and justifiable cause of anger is arising and that it is, not affected by anything else that has come before and that has come after.
Anger itself, we can analyse and say it arises in dependence upon other negative states of mind such as jealousy and possessiveness and attachment and these kinds of mental states. So in this part of the text, Shantideva is compelling us to analyse the way that conditions come together in order for something to occur, that things don’t occur singularly in isolation from everything else. And that we need to understand that the broader broader causes and conditions that all come together in order for a singular moment of something to be experienced. Verse 26 says, these conditions that assemble together have no intention to produce anything and neither does their product have the intention to be produced. Continuing the theme that all of these conditions and causes and conditions join together in such a way that we cannot ever identify that anger is isolated and a cause is isolated and separate from everything else.
That it all arises within moments of complete interdependency both in terms of the object of the anger and the way that anger arises itself within our own mind and the preceding moments of consciousness and other mental, negative mental states of mind, as such as all the mental afflictions like pride and jealousy. Good. Today here, stop. And then are you tired, everybody? Yeah.
I am a little bit difficult. So on Sundays, there have been discussion groups on Sundays that have been discussed. And I have a couple of questions that have come from that discussion group. So I’ll translate those for Geshela during the week and well, Geshela will give answers to those next week. So I’ve got the questions from last week’s study group.
I’ll give them to Geshela after the teachings and we’ll go through them next week. So Geshela is also reminding us about the discussion group on Sundays. And we’ll leave it here for today. We’ll leave it here for today. But if you have questions, remember there’s always an opportunity later to ask those questions.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.