Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1992-08-02 – Side 2 – Session 3 – KR.MP3
UUID: 4184c4b2-ac73-47f7-8618-0df4010216ea
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1992-08-02
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 46 min
Words: 4,367
So that which determines the quality of the action is the motivation behind the action, whether it’s negative or positive. If someone were to do something to you and you could cultivate tolerance toward that, you could think, well, this is a way I could purify my past negativity by undergoing this experience. On your part, that would be a wonderful thing to do. But the the but whether that action was negative or positive would be dependent on the motivation of this person for doing it. If, you know, I was just presenting a hypothetical case.
Out of maybe compassion, you have very good intentions to help somebody, but you end up making mistakes and you actually bring them more harm than you do good, still that’s a positive action because your motivation was positive even though you made a mistake. So we will we will say the prayer on page 10. Page 10. Then verses eight and nine. Okay.
Yeah. Will you be going into a little bit more about what we started this morning? Mhmm. Yeah. Should we do that?
Some of you, I’ve shown this before quite often. There’s two boys. They’re walking home from school, and this one has just received his examination results back. And he’s looking at his examination results, he’s talking to the second boy. And he says, that new teacher really did a number on me.
In the second box he says, I thought I’d get a B on that test. And he gave me a C. In the third box he says, how did he know I was a C student? So, you know, I mean, we can only pretend so much. He thought he could pull one over on his teacher, but his teacher was too sharp.
Was like kind of a c ness was oozing out of his skin. There was something c ness about him. Yeah? Mean, it’s hard. You can pretend for a little while.
You can fake it. But, I mean, your essential nature, the C-ness is gonna come out sooner or later. And you go on to get a C-grade job and marry a C-grade wife and have C-grade children and lead a C grade life. Something about ourselves, something that isn’t dependent upon our condition, our society, our peers, testing programs, whatever. Something about us is just kind of seeing us about ourselves or whatever.
You might be a C plus or C minus or whatever. We have a sense that we’re independently existent, that we don’t depend upon. Buddhism is not saying that we should believe in ourself or that we don’t have to believe in ourself. Is saying the Buddha made a discovery. He was interested in suffering.
This was his prime interest, the nature of suffering and whether it could be transcended. Whether life was just a bitch and then you die or something can be done. Do we have some kind of alternative available to us? And so he became an expert on suffering. And he began to notice that there was a relationship between a strong sense of I and suffering.
That there was some kind of correlation between the two. So he said, Okay, I’m going to take a look at this I. And he made some discoveries with respect to the nature of the I. This was one of his major contributions to the world. This I that we take for granted that goes by unquestioned.
That we haven’t really examined or even thought whether it needs to be examined or even thought about examining. We don’t have to have an explicitly, clearly formulate I, ideal I or self in order to have one. Here, the I we’re talking about here is not the I which is the empirical I. The I which is sitting here talking to you. I’m talking to you.
You may be listening to me. These eyes exist. The eyes which talk, eat, write notes, things like that. These I’s exist. This is a jumper exists.
This is Americans exist. This is Australians exist. This I is not a problem. The I, it is the misconceived I which is problematic, which we’re trying to understand. Even animals, we don’t have to have a clearly formulated sense of this I in order to have it.
Even animals have this sense of I that they from time to time excuse me, identify themselves with their bodies. They identify themselves with their mind. And are constantly seeking to comfort this I as they try to avoid any discomfort to this I. So, act. If when we investigate in the course of emotional experiences, whether we believe in the I exists or not, whether we have a clear idea of whether the I exists or not, we act as if we are an unchanging, independently existing I.
Is our whether we believe in it or not, whether we have an idea of the I or not, we act as if this type of I existed. It is an unthinking habit that most of us would most likely not question at all. However, our suffering is associated with this preoccupation with this I. All our hopes and fears arise dependent upon this I, identifying with this I as who I am. So, you may argue, I don’t think of my I that way, myself that way.
But that’s to miss the point. The I, the empirical I, going back to that, the I which talks, which walks, which reads, which gets married, has children, whatever. That I is not the problem. We analyze that I quite rationally into its constituent parts. The Buddhist ways of analysis are to analyze the I in terms of the five aggregates.
The aggregates of forms, feelings, perceptions, mental constructions, and consciousness. This is what constitutes the I and we can make that analysis. We analyze the I into the 12 sources or the 18 constituents. There’s all different ways of analyzing the empirically existing I. The question is not whether the self or the I is a complex factor.
The question is not whether the self or the I but a person is a complex composite of changing trains of events conditioned by many complex factors. Any rational analysis shows that this is in fact the case. The question is, why then do we behave emotionally as if we were a single, unchanging, independently existent self? Okay, what I’m saying is can the empirical self can be rationally analyzed And we can come to understand it quite clearly. The conventional self, the self which is talking to you, the I which is talking to you, and from your side, the I which is listening to me.
We can understand that in terms of the five aggregates, in terms of the body, in terms of the mind. There’s some way that we can rationally come to understand it. But the question is, but we act as if there was an I which had nothing to do with the mind and body, had nothing to do with the five aggregates, had nothing to do with the conditioning factors about me, with my society, with my culture, with being given a name I, with being given a name you. That’s the way we act. So there’s a difference between how we can analyze rationally, logically, intellectually the nature of the I and how we respond emotionally.
So, there’s a vast difference. Emotional responses, we act upon an I which is sensed to be unchanging and independently existing. It is independent of the body, independent of the mind. This is the way we emotionally respond even though this is our emotional response as opposed to our intellectual analysis. When we’re looking at the self, for the self, it’s important to remember that it is the emotional response that we are examining.
When we respond to events as if we had a self, for example, when we feel very hurt, when we feel very offended, We should ask ourselves exactly who or what is feeling hurt. Who or what is feeling offended? So if you’re not convinced that you behave emotionally as if you had a singular, unchanging, independent existing self, then it’s important to address yourself to issue. Beginning to question. Think carefully about pain, suffering, and ask yourself, who or what is it that’s suffering?
Who is it that’s afraid of what’s happening or afraid of what’s going to happen in the future? Who feels bad about what happened in the past? To what does death seem such a threat to? You’ll find that your thinking is full of contradictions, full of inconsistencies and paradoxes. This is quite normal.
When a meditator addresses him or herself, to what or who this I is, this self is, it consistently can’t find it. And gradually, very gradually, it dawns on the meditator that the reason he is unable to find it is because it doesn’t exist. There is a tremendous emotional resistance to coming to this understanding, this realization. So it takes a long time to break through. But when it does, there’s a release of tension, a release of stress, of suffering.
The cause has gone. The cause of it was a mental attachment to something which didn’t exist, something which was never there to begin with. So just as in the case, as I was trying to explain this morning, that we, in order to think, thinking is working with symbols, working with models, working with language. And we juxtapose them in our mind. I am going to go to the store.
That has some meaning. I can communicate that to you and it has meaning for you. You can predict what I may actually do. I may not go to the store, but that’s beside the point. And each of these, language corresponds.
When I use the word table, it corresponds something in reality which we both can point to. And that enables us to communicate. When I make this sound, you know what that sound corresponds to something, to this thing over here, whatever. It corresponds to something. And you are able to use that correspondence to understand what it is I’m trying to communicate just by these grunts that I make.
There’s a sense that you understand what I’m about because there’s some kind of correspondence. If there wasn’t this correspondence, then it’s like talking to a Tibetan. He may be, in fact, using the same word like we would what word did we use this afternoon? We used the word yellow. Yellow in Tibetan is serpent.
And he may be saying serpent. He may be saying yellow. And you might as be talking about two completely different things because you do not understand that these two grunts correspond to the same object. That you’re actually talking about the same object, but you don’t know it. Therefore, you aren’t communicating.
So we use models. We use symbols in our thinking. Just because we have a word for something doesn’t mean it exists. And this is, it works the opposite way too, which is quite interesting. But this design, sometimes we don’t have the words for feelings, do we?
And it’s very difficult for us. Did the I mean, this is did the electron exist before the nineteenth century? Did the electron exist before the nineteenth century? Yeah? No.
But electrons didn’t exist, did they? Electrons didn’t exist See, this is interesting. You’re grasping at is something out there which is still an electron, but we haven’t given it the name electron. But that doesn’t mean it’s not there. It hasn’t been discovered.
So, it’s like taking a safari into deepest, darkest Africa like exploration and you’re trying to discover the source of the Nile. It was there before I got there. It wasn’t like I invented it. I sense have it’s the other way around. I think the electron was invented in about the early nineteenth century.
It didn’t exist before. But anyway, that we prescribe reality rather than describe it. Well, maybe electron’s a different kind of example because that’s like quantum physics we’re not sure about anyway. So, that’s a whole another realm. But like source of the Nile, we know the Nile, like there’s the evidence of the Nile that’s coming to us in some way.
So we know that it should have a source. You may not have named where it can be, but we know that there’s a source. Maybe Lake Victoria, but we don’t know. Well, the Nile didn’t have a source, what would that be? What would be the implications of that?
There has to be a source, doesn’t it? Yeah. It has. It wouldn’t fit into our logical world, would it? In order to fit in with our preconception of how the world runs, there must be a source of the Nile.
So let’s invent one. I mean, everything is quite connected. The electron is a hypothesis, which is a model which we can make use of to work in functions. Model, we don’t know quite what’s out there. But let’s use this hypothesis and we can, based upon the hypothesis, we can we can do various types of work.
We can carry out experiments and everything’s okay. What’s out there? I I don’t have any idea. But let’s let’s let’s hypothesize that this is out there. Yeah.
It’s the same way with everything else. Until we get a a real table, let’s use this one for the time being. It serves the function until a real table comes along. Let’s just use this one until we get a real table. Anyhow, the force of gravity.
Know, three hundred years ago, 300 ago, people saw the sun rise in the East and they saw the sun circle overhead and they saw the sun rise in the West, didn’t they? They saw that with their eye, didn’t they? Did they? Oh, the sun they saw the sun rise in the East and they saw it set in the West. Yeah?
That’s what they saw. Is that what they but is that what they really saw? Yeah. I mean, the sun doesn’t rise in in in in the sun doesn’t revolve around the earth. Yeah.
So they saw the sun revolving around the earth, didn’t they? But it doesn’t. They were wrong. We see what we expect to see. We are born into a conventional reality, a body of knowledge.
Everything And that we believe, that we see has to fit in with that body of knowledge or they put us away. Something like that. So, we’re brainwashed. Well, I don’t wanna carry that too far. Everything depends upon language for its existence.
Everything depends upon terms and concepts. Nothing exists in dependence upon terms and concepts. If we don’t have a metaphor for it, it doesn’t exist. There’s no way that we can conceive of it. Nothing exists outside of our conception.
Things do not exist objectively from their own side, waiting to be discovered. It’s a participatory universe that we are co creating the universe from moment to moment. And this is dependent upon language, concept, terms, names. When a child is first born, there’s a mind and a body. And someone calls it, let’s call it Mary.
Mary comes into existence. Before giving that name, Mary didn’t exist or did Mary exist? What’s your call? Let’s call it after your grandmother, Mary. Okay, good.
Mary. And people say, Oh, here comes Mary. As if there’s something Mary about her. They forget there was just a label they put on it at some time or another and it’s if the noise is coming from that side. There’s something oozing out of them like the C grade quality of the student.
There’s some kind of Mary quality. You really act like a Mary. There’s something Mary ish about you. Anyway, there’s something label-ish about this. It’s not as if we had to give it that name.
So, I mean, did did Mary exist before she was given the name Mary? She did exist. Yeah? Then then then the moment somebody saw her, oh, here comes Mary. But a mind body and mind.
But it’s Mary. No. That’s not Mary. That’s not Mary. Yeah?
So Mary is dependent upon being named Mary. Being named. Okay. Likewise. The mind is dependent upon being labeled mind.
Body is dependent upon being labeled body. If we didn’t have those names, when that thing came out, we could say, well, we have a thing. If we didn’t have the name thing, then we’d just watch it. What do I do? There wouldn’t be any way of conceiving it.
It wouldn’t be there. Anyway, what what was Mary when she was born? So human child, that’s another name, isn’t it, label? Yeah. Because somebody yeah.
Sometime or other, somebody invented the word human child. Prior prior to the invention of Yeah. So that’s the conventional reality that we’re born into with all this knowledge and information and which we learn and we make use of these labels and terms. Now, nothing exists from its own side. Are born into a reality which is continually evolving through the forces of our karma.
The world is evolving. The universe is evolving as our perception of it evolves, as progressing through, that we are born not into a pre existing universe, but we are born into a body of knowledge which dependent upon which we create a particular type of universe. And this is constantly evolving. And therefore, our universe is constantly evolving. And we’re born into, we plug into a general way of perceiving, like collective karma.
If you didn’t, you’d be insane. You’re trying to, there’s simply chaos. Let’s say there’s chaos. There’s just a field, undifferentiated. And in order to secure the self in space and time, we have a tendency to solidify.
We give these names. We draw heavy lines around them. Then a big dotted line. This is over there. This, I’m over here.
You’re over there. And this is the way that we are able to secure the self in space and time. And we have conventions that we use which amongst us of what we’re going to call things, of how we’re going to solidify this thing, how we’re going to draw the line around this thing. We have rules that you have not consciously have agreed to but you’ve been habituated, you’ve been born into them. This rule, the rules how we’re going to organize our reality.
Reality doesn’t exist objectively outside of these rules. These rules can change. Therefore, our reality changes, how we’re going to organize it. Like Is someone seeing it’s unusual if someone doesn’t see colors the same way, like color blind. Like conventionally we say, oh yeah, this color is red or this is green.
But some people don’t see red and green. They see, like it’s different, it’s a different thing, but they have to adapt to the idea, hey everybody else is saying that’s red and green so we’ve got to abide by that or else we’re running the red light. So that’s where the insanity lies. Like if we don’t have those kinds of conventions, not grounded in reality or this reality. We see shapes.
We don’t see colors. All that, I mean, in terms of cognitive science, we’re just different frequencies. Different electrical impulses are registered in our mind. And we create out of those simple signals, electrical signals, color, shape, smell, and the world around us. It’s just different frequencies of electric signals arriving at our brain in one respect.
There’s nothing out there. There’s no shapes and colors out there. We don’t know what’s out there. It’s kind of just signals inside our brain, which we interpret along using various specific rules that we have been habituated to. And as these rules change, our reality changes.
So the rules change. That’s why different realities can coexist in the same place. Like one of the traditional examples is a glass of fluid. A celestial being, it appears to be nectar. To a human being, a glass of water.
To a hungry ghost, a glass of pus and blood. Surely, there’s a glass of fluid, but what appears to them is dependent upon their karma, how they’re going to organize that data. And this is dependent upon these predispositions in their mind, the rules in which they’re organizing their reality. I mean, a mosquito would see it as place to lay its eggs, a fish a place to live in. Somebody with hydrophobia or rabies would have great fear of a glass of water.
Somebody who’s very thirsty would have great longing to drink it. I think we got off the subject. So, this idea about the electron, That all we have, we have working hypotheses about. Many of them, they’re functional. They work.
But it’s not to say that there’s not really a table here. If there was really a table here, then when we analyzed it, we should be able to find it. If it was existing from its own side objectively, then upon analysis we should be able to find it. So, that looks pretty real, doesn’t it? Out there, solid.
I mean, you can’t depend upon that kin, what can you depend upon? So, we we said it exists from its own side objectively and therefore should be findable under analysis. If we investigate and look for it, we should be able to find that pen. So we begin an analysis and and we say, is is that the pen? No?
Okay. Let’s say. Is that is that the pen? Alright. Is that the pen?
No. I just wanna just answer the questions, lady. No? Okay. I’m not gonna take this apart any further.
Is is that is that nib? Is that the pen? That nib. Is is this plastic hollow plastic tube? Is the plastic tube the pen?
Is the ink inside the the pen? Is the ink inside the pen a pen? Is there anything left over which is the pen? You sure? So the collection is of the parts, the mere collection of the parts, is that the pen?
Put them together. Is is the mere just a collection of parts? Yeah. Okay. And what happens when as if what happens when I as if by magic, it appears out of nowhere, out of the void, a pin.
So what what happened? What does that tell you about the nature of the pin? It to be put together in a specific way according to certain rules. When certain rules, when certain parts are present and certain rules are following in putting those parts together, then we can apply the label pin to that object. Before that, it’s not a pin, is it?
So, the pin is dependent upon what? Dependent upon its parts? It’s dependent upon causes and conditions, somebody putting it together? It’s also dependent upon being labeled. So the pen is dependent upon causes and conditions.
Plastic, workmen, machinery. It’s dependent upon its parts, the barrel, the nib, the ink, put it together according to certain rules and then it is suitable to be called pin. We then apply, ah, there’s a pin. Before that, the thought, ah, there’s a pin, never rose in my mind. It wasn’t a pin.
Only depends upon its pin that depends upon my thinking, Ah, a pen. Before that, Ah, there’s a pen. There’s no pen. Things are dependent upon that conception being labeled upon their name and for their existence. Everything exists in that same way.
So, likewise with the I, the self. When we talk about the empirical I, the self, I is, you know, there is, I am dependent upon causes and conditions. I am dependent upon parts and I am dependent upon being labeled I. Causes and conditions, you know, the sperm and ovum of my parents, consciousness, all the conditioning factors which make me who I am, my education, my history, all the various shaping which have brought me, which have brought me into existence and maintaining my existence. It depends upon my parts, my consciousness, mainly my consciousness and my body.
Sometimes we can elaborate those parts, we can divide them up further for analysis into the five aggregates. For example, forms, feelings, perceptions, mental constructions, and consciousnesses. But mainly, it’s parts of body and mind. But additionally, it’s dependent upon being named I. You know, if you found some sperm and ovum on your sheets, you you might, you’d go wash the sheets probably.
But over through habituation, we have come to become very familiar with a particular stream of events to the extent that we call it I. We feel very close to this particular stream of events. Yeah? We’ve come to love it. It’s the most important thing in the universe.
That’s only through habituation. We began to refer to it. See, that which evolved out of a sperm and ovum as I and all that that means to us. But it was just we learned that. That to be habitually referred to this as I and then I becomes something tremendously important.
That which evolved out of a sperm and ovum. So, the I depends. The self depends. Depends upon causes and conditions, parts, and labeling being called. We have a sense, so this I exists.
We can analyze it. But we have a sense, an emotional response of an I which doesn’t depend upon anything. Somewhere over here, there’s a concrete solid I which doesn’t depend upon body, which doesn’t depend upon mind, which doesn’t depend upon any condition which is unchanging. And this is the I. This is the problematic I.
This I doesn’t exist but we have a model in our mind that we use. We think it refers to something out there, but nothing, we won’t find anything which corresponds to it. There’s nothing within the, in the whole stream of mental and physical
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.