Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1992-08-02 – Side 2 – Session 4 – KR.MP3
UUID: ef45fb34-ed81-428e-ae05-7b554e0d3fef
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1992-08-02
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 46 min
Words: 4,387
You can’t find it if you search for you can’t you can’t even find this table when you search for it. That’s not no. Nothing upon analysis is findable. Nothing. This table, this building, you know, is the is the wall the is the wall the building?
Is the wall the room? Is the ceiling the room? Is the floor of the room? Do you think that elephants have labels? No. Think that.
Big elephants have labels. They don’t exist. What’s this table? Exist because if we don’t they exist because if we don’t make an analysis, if we don’t search for them, then they appear to a valid awareness. You, me, this table, if we try to analyze what they are.
What happens when you analyze? What happens when you analyze something? Other than that, you take it apart. What happens to the whole? Can you hold the whole and the parts at the same time in your mind?
So that’s you know, we we can’t do that at the same time. You cannot hold the whole and analyze the parts simultaneously. You have to shift between the two. So when you analyze anything, that which is conceiving of the whole is lost. That’s why it’s unfindable upon analysis.
That’s why it’s dependent upon names and labels. If it weren’t the case, if it wasn’t dependent upon being labeled, on conventional conception, then even though you were analyzing, it should be findable. But the very fact the act of analyzing destroys our — we’re not able to maintain conceiving of it because we’re analyzing it. And not being able to conceive of it, we can’t find it. So we can’t hold the whole and the parts at the same time.
If we’re going to look at the parts, we have we lose the whole. If we’re gonna if we’re not going to look at when we’re holding the whole, we can’t look at the parts. So if we don’t try to sorry? So when we don’t analyze, when we take things on face value superficially, it’s all there. Tables, people, houses.
But once we begin to investigate, that mind which is holding that conception, which is conceiving this object, is lost and we can’t find the object. But they exist simultaneously but not for one mind. When that one mind is analyzing, it can’t find that object. Loses the whole. In space.
Yeah, I thought we’d do that again, but more in detail. Well, okay. The most difficult part and the first step in coming to an understanding of selflessness is to identify, as I mentioned, this word object of negation. Identify our model of the I. Identify what characteristic.
Is it long? Is it short? Is it green? Is it purple? Is it unchanging, changing?
Is it dependent, independent? Try to, as clearly as possible, try to understand, get a clear picture like we’re setting up a target and we’re going to shoot an arrow. Unless that target is clear, then we’re never going to hit the mark. Alright, so not just a name. When you’re saying, I’m so stupid, That I, at that very moment, you’re using a model in your mind.
When you say, I’m so stupid. What does that I look like? What does that I that’s so stupid look like? Does that part? Is it green?
Is it nice? Is it smell? And think of all the possible qualities that I’m so stupid. I’m so stupid. I can’t do anything right.
That I, what does it look like? Try to get as good a feeling, sense, picture, understanding of it as possible. This is the most difficult part because then we’re going to, okay, now I know what I’m looking for. Now I’m gonna look for If you don’t, like if we say there’s a thief in this room, I know there’s a thief in this room, but we have no idea what that thief looks like, we’re never gonna catch him. But once we identify that he’s six foot four tall and has three eyes, it’s, ah, there he is.
So we have to be able to identify because it’s not gonna have any force. Unless we know what we’re looking for, then the non finding of that will have no force in our life. It won’t mean anything. So it’s the I which arises in these extreme emotional experiences. Not that, like there’s an I which is sitting on this cushion.
First, you’re trying to identify. What does it look like? Actually, trick is you’re performing We’re not trying to analyze initially. What you want to do is, I mean, this is why it’s so difficult. You want to induce an emotional state And then a little part of your mind is like a spy, and it’s watching.
It’s trying to see what that I looks like. Now if this spy is too powerful, the emotional experience is lost. If it’s too weak, then there’s no identification. You’re just overwhelmed by the emotion. So some meditators, they would go to an edge of a cliff, for example, and sit at the edge of a cliff and lean over, and this fear would begin to arise.
And then while they were still experiencing that fear, a little part of their mind would try to see what the I looked like. That I that was so very afraid. Or they would sit at the edge of a well or they’d sit at the feet of an elephant, and these are traditional examples. Or they’d go out into a crowd and get them, you know, be jostled around, pushed around so that they would induce some kind of emotional experience. And while that emotional experience is going on, maintaining the ability to be aware, maintaining the awareness where they’re able to watch and observe and identify that I which is undergoing this emotional experience.
I’m so stupid is not enough to actually just think those words to oneself. One has to actually feel the emotion of I’m so stupid. And then what does that I look like which is experiencing that feeling, that model? It looks like you. That I which so what do you see in the mirror?
What do you see in the mirror? A mirror. What do you you see you see form and color in the mirror. You see form and color, don’t you? That form and color is the I?
That’s a — Annie, that’s really stupid of you. How can what? No. You’re thinking you’re thinking about the emotion. What happens when I say what happens if I say what happens when I say you’re stupid?
Does anything do you get any response? So right now, you’re experiencing some kind of emotion. If you could be aware, what is the nature of that eye that’s going through this emotion? How is there some feeling? That eye that I’m so stupid.
That eye. Identifying what that I look like, then we proceed to analyze with in terms of the body and mind to see if we can find it. That’s exactly what we do. Again and again, we look for it. Again and again.
That’s what we’re gonna do Yeah. Let’s see if we can actually find it. If you can, let me know. What do you think? Is it there? We can make it emotionally quite clear otherwise.
So intellectually, I would agree that we can Well, we don’t conceive of ourselves as being independent of the body and mind nor do we. We usually don’t think of ourselves as the body and mind. We usually don’t think about what the I is. We just take it for granted I’m sitting here. We don’t we don’t and then if once you begin to analyze, okay, I’m then you say, well, I can explain the I in terms of the body and mind.
But that’s not the question. That’s not the problem. We act emotionally as if the I were not the body and mind. That there’s something other than the body and mind who we are emotionally. That’s the way we act.
And then we have to actually look to see if in fact that’s the case. When you say, I’m so stupid. There’s no I which corresponds to that. But it is See, what happens when we talk about the, I can have the thought, I’m so stupid, and I am thinking that thought. But the emotional experience of the I which is so stupid.
There is some kind of model that we’re using which we really has a quality of being stupid which we hold to be real. And one of the qualities of this model of an I is that it’s stupid. Sometimes it’s stupid. We hold that that’s who I really am. The guilt is real.
It’s particular state of consciousness. Embarrassment is real. It’s a particular state of Stupidity is real. Yeah. But is there an I which is stupid?
And we have different states that sometimes we act with great wisdom, sometimes we act very stupid. On the average, react a seven and a half out of 10, But we assign ourselves a permanent identity which is unrelated to the fluctuations of our conditions, our peers, our testing program, how we feel that day, and whether we’re sick. We have a permanent unchanging identity which we conceive of as who we are. We’re using that. We’re using that as the basis for generating these emotional experiences.
When I say that you’re really stupid, something’s under threat. Self conception that you have. It’s in the twist. And you’re going to maintain that at all cost. But I think of that as my ego.
The ego that fits in the way of What’s your pride? A pride parlor. So pride pride exists. Pride exists. It can be this I can be felt in it can be it arises in a very positive situation.
You know, I’m the most beautiful thing that happened to Adelaide. Or, you know, I’m the I’m the I’m the how dare you speak to me like that? Don’t you know who I am? Don’t you know who I am? Let’s see what’s the more.
It could be associated with all the various emotions. How does the deeper time become the ego? So, I mean, my definition is that the ego exists. It exists. The I doesn’t, this misconceived I doesn’t exist.
It’s like a snake which is being designated to a striped rope. Yeah. The ego exists. This doesn’t exist. A big difference.
Yeah. So the the ego is this is the is the collection of mind and body which has evolved out of ignorance. That’s what I call ego. That’s what I call ego. Sometimes we identify with the body.
When you stub your toe, you say, I’m hurt. Sometimes we identify with the mind. When your happy thoughts are going through your mind, you say, I’m happy. Sometimes it shifts back and forth between body and mind. Well, I think you would act much more efficiently, skillfully because you wouldn’t be acting defensively out of a sense of threat, out of a sense of pride or whatever.
Can look at the maybe, I don’t know how you would act. Mean, I’m sure, would be much more skillfully than we presently act. And you might think from that person’s side, try to see their point of view. Might react with compassion, understanding. You might be assertive, very skillful.
Yeah, well I think so. I think, I mean, it’s like the, this sense of sense of this false I. I don’t know myself from my own experience, as I’ve been told that as one investigates it more and more, keeps performing this analysis, it’s not quite as solid and concrete as it used to be. It’s like the fading away of a rainbow and it’s hardly noticeable. So it just diminishes and diminishes.
Commensurate with that is that you would be less acting out of threat to one’s. There’ll be less defensiveness. All of these qualities that we associate with having to protect something. You know, when somebody says you’re stupid, you’re ugly. Okay.
You might call me ugly. Or maybe I am. But there’s not the emotional reaction as if something is under threat. So, know what I mean? So, I think there would be this gradual diminishment of all the ways of reacting dependent upon this misconception would slowly diminish and you’d be able to deal with the situation much more efficiently and effectively.
Don’t you think? Because I mean, let’s say that our pride gets in the way, our feelings of hurt get in the way in our communication and dealing with these situations. There’s hidden agendas and what the hell, I need to get going What you what do you mean by that? I better get mine. You you could still get yours, but you because you deserve for people to respect your right.
Just because you have legitimate, it’s legitimate for you to be asked to be treated fairly. So there’s no question about people walking all over you even though you don’t have a myth if you have a misconceived I any longer. We have general rules of fairness that which people should be asked to follow. But it shouldn’t be a basis for hatred and anger and these are the emotional reactions that they usually associate. So it’s a hard subject to him.
What shall we do? The meditation would take about fifteen minutes, I think. So, we could take a break and then come back and do it. Could go to the toilet. So we have a fifteen minute break.
And we’re going to proceed. As I mentioned, the first step is the most difficult. But, you know, we can fake it. Inducing the idea through one’s memory or imaginatively some kind of emotional experience. We’re living in a time when you’re very embarrassed or very upset.
The difficulty is to maintain like a spy. Part of your mind is watching while the emotional experience is continuing. The I which is so upset, which is so embarrassed, which is so angry, whatever the experience might be. What kind of qualities does it have? Trying to see it as clearly as possible.
You’re not analyzing why it’s angry, why it’s embarrassed. That’s not the point. Just who is it that’s angry? And don’t ask yourself, Who is it that’s angry? Just watch.
If the investigation is too coarse, too abrupt, then the emotion will die away and the I will not appear. If you begin to use this, even in a pretend sense, then when you do get upset in everyday life, maybe sometimes you’ll be a little bit aware and you’ll begin to catch an idea, begin to notice what the I appears like when you are in fact upset in everyday life. So the most difficult and the most important is the first step, identifying the object of negation, that is the I, which appears to exist so vividly clearly from its own side. Then we proceed in analysis and we’re going to look, you know, something appears like the snake appears to us. You’re walking along the path and a snake appears.
You get a very clear impression and then you’re going to look for it and analyze to see whether that in fact is a snake or not, whether that I exists or not. In the place that it appears, just as in the case of the snake upon the rope, don’t — if we see the snake over there, we don’t look for it over here. We look where we see it, where we experience it, where we sense it to be, where we sense the I to be here somewhere. We’re not quite sure where. We’ve never really thought about it.
But there’s a general notion that if it exists, it’s probably over here. It’s not in the next room. I’m sitting in this room. And I have a sense that I’m sitting in this room for when I don’t feel like I’m sitting in the next room. So I’m going to look for it here, somewhere on this cushion.
We’re going to proceed through the body and proceed through the mind looking. We want to do it as systematically as possible. We’re going to look at the various elements which constitute the body, the earth, water, fire, air. Roughly speaking, the earth element, all the various dense, solid parts of the body, the organs, the bones, the teeth, the muscles, the tissues, the water element, all the various fluids, the blood, the lymph, the urine, saliva. Then we look at the fire element, the temperature, the heat of the body.
Then we look at the wind energy element, the flow of the breath, the respiration, all the energy moving throughout the body. Then we’re going to look at the space element, all the cavities in the body, the hollow parts. Not within those hollow parts, but are those hollow parts themselves, the cavity themselves? Is that the I? We have a picture of what we’re looking for.
Now we’re going to we’ve taken this photograph. Now we’re looking. Now we’re looking. No, that’s not it. No, that’s not it.
Then we’re going to look finally at the mental element, the consciousness element. And we’re going to look at it in terms of feelings, pleasurable feelings, unpleasurable feelings, feelings of indifference. Looking in terms of perceptions. This is good, this is bad, this is long, this is short. That way of thinking which discriminates or recognizes.
Then in terms of mental constructions, our various emotions, love, hate, jealousy, compassion, is that the I. There’s compassion in the I. We’re not saying does the I have compassion, is the I compassionate? But is compassion itself the I that we’re looking for? Then we go on to look at the various eye, ear, nose, tongue, body consciousnesses.
Consciousness which sees shapes, is that the I? That which hears sounds, is that the I? And then finally the mental consciousness, that which is a simple act of awareness. Is that the I? Is that what we mean?
That’s so angry, that’s so upset. And then you may or may not find it. And we try to Is there any place else to look? And it’s completely gone through, really systematic examination, the body and mind. And there’s a sense of unfindability.
I thought it was there and I couldn’t find it. I know it has to be, you have two boxes and you have something very precious, and you have a sense, you know you put it in one of them. So you look in this one box and it’s not there. Oh, well, sure it’s in there. And then you look in there, God, where did that? It’s not there.
So it’s kind of awe, a sense of loss, a sense of shock, surprise, loss, bewilderment. Bewilderment, that’s a good one. Bewilderment. It has to be there. And if I look, what you thought was there is in fact not there, and to hang on to that feeling of sense of bewilderment, of loss, something that was there but you couldn’t find.
Shall we do that? And then one could extend this meditation to also think, Well, it’s not within the body and mind, it’s something other than the body and mind. So you imaginatively take your arm off and look at it, imaginatively. No, that’s not the arm. Take your leg off.
No, that’s not it. No, not it. Then you take off all the parts and then you take all the parts of the mind. Look at those. There should be something left sitting on your cushion which you can call I.
And you look. It’s not that one. So, the it’s body and mind because you systematically examined it. It’s not other than the body and mind because you systematically looked you took away the body and mind and you sense that the I is sitting on the cushion. You take away the body and mind.
If the I was something other than the body and mind, it should still remain on the cushion. So, it’s not the body and mind. It’s not something other than the body and mind. It has to be one of those two. If it exists, the penny drops.
Yeah. So we’re going to go through it systematically as possible. I agree it’s quite difficult. So we’re going go through the six primary consciousnesses: eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mental consciousnesses. So first we’re going to run through the five physical sense consciousnesses, eye, ear, nose, tongue, and body.
Eye consciousness, that which sees shapes and colors. That which sees shapes and colors, is that the I? Now we’re not saying, Do I see shapes and colors? That very consciousness, is that what we mean? Is that the I that was so upset, that felt so stupid?
That consciousness which sees shapes and colors, is that the I that was upset? Is that what you mean when you say, I’m so stupid? That consciousness which sees shapes and colors, I don’t think you do. But maybe, you know. So we have to be very clear about what we’re looking for.
You know, we have this picture and we’re looking for it. No, that’s not him. Know, Eye, ear, nose, tongue, body. Then we get to the mental consciousness. They’re more difficult.
It’s usually divided up into four aggregates. The aggregate of feelings. Feelings, pleasurable feelings, unpleasurable feelings, feelings of indifference or neutral feelings. Are pleasurable feelings that I? Not that the I has pleasurable feelings or doesn’t have pleasurable feelings, that’s not a question.
But the pleasurable feelings themselves, is that the I which is so stupid? No pleasurable. That’s not what I meant. It’s not feeling. Then we go on to perceptions, sometimes called recognition.
That I, conceives of objects as objects, conceives of doors, conceives as long, as short, conceives of table, etcetera, that which is doing that conceiving perception, that which perceives these objects discriminates this is long, this is short. That way of thinking, that pattern of thought, that style of thinking, is that the I? Then you go on to more elaborate patterns of thought, emotions, faith, love. There are 51 secondary mental consciousnesses, all the various anger, ignorance, long list. Are any of them?
Is love, is that what the I is? Compassion? I’m not saying that the I isn’t compassion or it is compassionate or loving or not anger or not, but is anger itself? Is that the I which is so stupid, which feels hurt, which feels fear of death? Anger.
I don’t think so. Can we apply it to you? All these various emotions. And then the mental consciousness itself. Simple awareness, that which knows.
Is that the I which feels so stupid? The that the very fact of knowing. And then is there anything else that we can find? Either in the mental consciousness or in the body? What do you think?
That sufficient? I mean, it’s one way of breaking up consciousness so we can get a handle on it because consciousness is an unknown territory. We get lost in that quite easily. So it gives us some handle on it. So we’re going to look at feelings, this particular style of thinking we call perception, which organizes tables, which perceives tables, which discriminates or recognizes short, long colors, objects.
Then the various emotions, all the various emotions that we experience, are any of them the I? And then the mental consciousness itself, that which has as its object thoughts. The thinking process itself, we can say. The thinking process itself, process itself, is that the I itself? That says, I’m so afraid of dying.
I’m really worried. Is that thinking process itself? Yeah. So we look. So if you take a firm comfortable posture.
So, we’re going to begin with a few minutes of mindfulness and breathing. So just bringing the mind to the breath. Very gentle, and then allow the mind to flow with the breath. Now we, by means of your imagination and memory, Try to induce some sort of emotional experience. Just try to keep one portion of your mind as a spy, trying to identify what is that I that is undergoing this experience look like.
Try to get a sense of what this I feels like. Try to identify the best you can. So remember either using your memory or your imagination, you induce some personal emotion. This will probably require that you again and again generate some emotional experience. Now we’re going to look for that I.
Try to see if we can find it. We can begin with the body. First, we’re going to look at the earth element within the body. Beginning at the very tip of the top of your head, looking at all the very solid parts, the dense parts of the body working your way down through, all the organs, bone, teeth, muscles, hairs, working your way down through and analyzing. This is the I which appeared during that emotional experience.
All the way down to your toe. We’re going to look at the water element, all the fluids in your body, the blood, the lymph, urine, saliva, everything that flows within your body. So again, your way down from the top of your head to your toes. As you come along to the various fluids. Examining, is this the I itself?
Then we look at the fire element, the warmth of the body. Is that the I? Then the wind energy element, the flow of the breath, the respiration, all the energy is moving throughout the body. And the space element, all the various cavities in the body, the hollow parts, the spaces within the body, the spaces themselves, or any of them, is any of them the I. Now we’re going to look at the mind and first the eye consciousness, that which sees colors and shapes, that which knows colors and shapes.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
- A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.