40 min · 1,866 words · 18 April 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching refutes the view that a sprout is produced from itself by arguing that a sprout and its seed cannot be the same entity or exist at the same time. It argues that production from self would lead to endless, pointless production. The speaker says a sprout exists only as a potential in the seed until moisture activates it, and the seed’s essence disintegrates as the sprout forms.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1991-04-18
Duration: 40 min
UUID: bb1d1da5-d765-4a2e-8529-6356c5bada9e
Words: 1,862
We would say of course there is because by planting the seeds sprouts grow and finally crops grow and from those crops we can gather food. And this has a great purpose, it’s a great point to planting seeds. There’s great benefit to be derived. But if you hold the position of production from self, then the fault would arise that it would be meaningless for something to be newly produced because there would be no point for it to be being produced again and again since it’s already produced. Since the sprout already exists at the time of the seed, what is the use of being produced again?
It’s pointless, it’s meaningless for something to be produced again when it already exists. So we accept that the flower, we accept that the sprout and the seed exists. And we’ve said, we can all see for ourselves that there is benefit and there is purpose in the sprout arising and being produced. But if you said that the sprout existed at the time of the seed then there would be no purpose or benefit in the sprout being produced since it already exists at the time of the seed. And therefore this production would be pointless.
There would be no benefit or purpose in this type of production since it already exists. But we’ve already said that there is benefit and purpose in the production of a sprout. So these two are contradictory. In one sense we say that the production of a sprout is purposeful and beneficial but in this way, in which you’re asserting, it’s of no benefit, it’s of no purpose. So, but if you say that the sprout exists at the time of seed, then you’re saying that what already exists has to be, what already has been produced has to be produced again.
That we both agree that a sprout must be produced, but what purpose, what benefit would there be in having it produced again? There would be endless production. That which has already been produced would have to be again and again produced, and we cannot accept that position. That if the sprout exists at the time of the seed then why go to the trouble of planting seeds in fields since you already have the sprout that you want. It would be purposeless to plant seeds since you already have the sprout.
In our case, that we having been born, we would continually have to be born until we’re dead. We would continually be newly reborn, our births would be inexhaustible. So you’re going to have to accept many self contradictory positions if you try to assert that something is produced from itself. That once it was produced it would have to be produced again and there would be endless production. That in the case of a sprout, even though it’s once produced, it would have to be produced again and again endlessly.
So you’re saying that the sprout exists at the time of the seed and though the sprout has already been produced, it’s necessary that it had to be produced again. That’s what you actually assert. Therefore, when you plant a seed, you’re actually producing the sprout twice. And therefore all things would have to be produced twice just like the sprout. So the seed would be being produced endlessly, that as that it would — [inaudible].
So just as the sprout would again and again be produced, the seed also would again and again be produced. In the first moment, it would be produced and would therefore exist. In the second moment it would be produced and therefore exist. In the third moment it would be produced and therefore exist. And there would be no time when it didn’t exist.
It would be being produced inexhaustibly. If you assert that the seed continually exists, that it is continually remaining in the first moment, the second moment, the third moment, then also since the sprout exists at this time of the seed, then also the sprout is existing at these very same moments. And if the sprout exists at these moments, then how can that which is the result of the sprout ever come to arise, such as the various crops, the various fruit arising from these sprouts, the various leaves, the various grains which grow out of these crops. If what you what you assert would be the case, then the world would never see crops because they would only see sprouts and seeds. But in fact, the sprout and the seed do not exist at the same time.
Their times of existence are mutually incompatible. That when the sprout exists, then the seed has already been extinguished, has come to an end. On the other hand, the seed exists, the sprout has yet to be produced. And since the world in general sees the crops growing, the various leaves, the various stalks of the plants, the various grains which are given up by the plants, then we cannot accept the fact that the sprout and the seed are the same entity. So your assertion cannot be held within the context of the fact that one does see the various effects of seeds such as the plants, the crops and grains which arise at the time when the seed is at the time in which the seed has been disintegrated, has disintegrated.
Therefore the seed and the sprout cannot be of the same entity or the same nature. So you cannot, in view of your previous position, that the seed and the sprout were the same entity cannot be maintained in the light of this refutation, that the seed and the sprout cannot be the same entity. So we can establish that the sprout and the seed are not the same entity because the sprout is produced from the seed — the seed does not exist at the time of the sprout. If the seed does not exist at the time of the sprout then the sprout is not produced from itself because it is produced from the seed which does not exist at the time of the sprout. So from various types of reasons we go on to establish that the sprout does not exist at the time of its cause, that is its seed.
And that the sprout and the seed are not the same entity, do not have the same nature, and therefore we refute the extreme of production from self. So I’ve just used two or three reasons to establish non production from self very roughly, and actually there’s a very profound reasoning set forth to establish this. So these are just a few good reasons to establish non-production from self. So we’ll stop there, but if you have any questions. It doesn’t so the potential of the this potential of the sprout has existed at the time of the seed.
So though potential to produce the sprout does exist at the time of the seed, the potential of the sprout is not a sprout. About seed? Let’s stop the the leaves inside it that have been produced with the seed, that are there. And as the seed breaks, the seed is still there. Those first two leaves that come out are also there.
And they’ve been there, were there So when all the various conditions aggregate, have the seed and the water and some type of fertilizer. Then this activates the seed. And a plant will begin to grow, leaves will begin to form even inside the husk of the seed. But when those leaves actually form then it’s said that the seed, the essence of the seed has already disintegrated and there’s only, though there are leaves, there’s the husk of the seed. The essence of the seed is no longer present.
Husk of the seed is there, but the essence of the seed is no longer present once the sprout is formed, once those leaves have started forming, even inside the shell. You might understand this very well, but I know Harry knows it, apparently the leaves are inside the seed. So he thinks that maybe the seeds must have come in contact with some moisture in order for these leaves to develop inside the seed. I mean, if you you when you look at the ground where a plant is germinated, you would see an initial two leaves. Those two tiny leaves, or there would be one single leaf in the grass seed.
But as far as I understand, those two leaves or that single leaf plus one cotyledon leaf is already within the seed. That is what the seed is. Is there a sprout inside of rice? I mean, you look inside rice, do you see a little leaf and root? He’s never seen a sprout inside of grain rice.
Sprout. But there is there is there is in there. He’s never seen it. So it’s But what but what I mean, then what So prior to the seed coming in contact with moisture, a sprout will never form no matter how many years the seed remains. But upon it coming in contact with moisture, a needle like white sprout forms inside the seed.
And this you know, this is the beginning of the sprout. And this will eventually grow into what we don’t conceive of as a sprout, normally conceive of as a sprout. But until that comes in contact with that moisture, there’s only a potential. And it’s that there’s no actual physical substance which is a sprout. There’s nothing which we can point to as a sprout until it’s come in contact with moisture.
So the position that’s being held is that the sprout exists at the time of the seed. If the sprout didn’t exist at the time of the seed, then the sprout could grow. There has to be something there, there has to be a sprout already for a sprout to grow. If there wasn’t a sprout already at the time of the seed, sprout could never grow. So what takes place is aside from discounting, not counting the husk of the seed, the shell of the seed, that the seed transforms its entity into the sprout.
There’s a transformation of the seed into the entity of the sprout. So, you know, in India we grew a lot of corn. The corn, once the corn was ripened, if there was a lot of rain, then due to that rain the seeds would begin to grow into sprouts. You know, just as you had mentioned that even inside the seeds, if it got very wet, if you open the seed, sprout would be forming inside the seed. So that there are there are many occasions when the when the the corn would get wet and even before it was planted, they would start sprouting.
So, Mingshi thinks at the time it displays these two leaves, it’s become a sprout and is no longer a seed. It’s just the husk of the seed is still there, but inside is a sprout. Yeah. I’ll take your I’ll be okay.